PD RECOMMENDATION REPORT (PL-SMA-2023-000034)

Home

The proposed development of an Ulu farm, residential structures and related improvements is consistent with the objectives and policies of the Coastal Zone Management Program (Chapter 205A, Hawaii Revised Statutes)including: Recreational Resources: No development will be within or near the shoreline setback area and will be approximately 160 feet from the top of the Pali to minimize future impacts related to coastal erosion. Where the property abuts the Pacific Ocean and Hakalau Bay, the vertical slope of the shoreline Pali and steep slope of the Hakalau Gulch Pali as it transitions to the side of the gulch makes any past shoreline access highly improbable. Hakalau Park, lying on the other side of Hakalau Bay, provides shoreline access and a recreation area for the public. Historic Resources: Based on the history of development and use, the area of development proposed shows no evidence of historic properties other than what was noted by SHPD relating to sugarcane cultivation. The subject property is not used for gathering, ceremonial, or other cultural purposes by Native Hawaiians therefore there appears to be no potential for cultural impact to culturally valued resources or cultural practices. The three (3) concrete walls that formed a structure used to stage sugar cane being loaded on to the flume is an old mill related structure that was considered historic. The use of this structure to support the Agricultural Storage facility is consistent with its previous use and was supported by the State Historic Preservation Division. Other than this structure, we do not believe there are any historic structures at the site. Scenic and Open Space Resources: The subject parcel is located near the Hakalau Bay Park, which is across the gulch from the project area. No impact on the open space resources will occur from the proposed project on access to the park. Additionally, the project site is blocked via landforms and vegetation such that no views from the highway exist or will be impacted by the proposed project. -5-