2006-11-01 tnakamura - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

GRAHAM:We are in discussion period. WATANABE:I -. GRAHAM:Commissioner Watanabe. WATANABE:Thank you. Personally I dont see that much of an issue with this. Initially I thought maybe there should be a limit on the size that was possibly larger than the half acre, but then I think thats also covered already in one of the conditions that the Director had placed, which is Condition D referring to restrictive covenants in the deeds of the proposed lots within the subject parcel. And I would also point out that this is directly adjacent to an area that the residents, as Brian testified, initiated a zoning change to Urban; and actually, that right apparently was upheld in Court relative to his testimony. So I dont see where its that big a deal, especially since I think general knowledge is that the area is not really conducive to agriculture. GRAHAM:Thank you. Other Commissioners have anything to offer? Commissioner Siracusa. SIRACUSA:For one thing, you know, when they say whether its rocky or whatever and not conducive to agriculture, theres all sorts of agriculture. You can do a lot of agriculture in raised beds, you can do it on tables. For example, potted plants for export or orchid, you know, growth doesnt require any kind of soil at all, really. So, to me, thats not an argument. The point is also that there is nothing legally that would keep them back from holding it in common and passing it on to heirs even if they kept it as one parcel. And perhaps one of the attorneys in the room would care to comment on the possibility. But it seems to me that the reasoning to just, you know, to be able to pass it on to heirs, turning them down would not preclude that. GRAHAM:I understand. Any other Commissioners? WATANABE:Follow-up. GRAHAM:Commissioner Watanabe. WATANABE: I think we have to recognize that its very difficult to get people to agree even if they are family. I think wed like to think of a family unit as one really cohesive unit, and Im not implying that the applicants family is not a cohesive unit. On the other hand, it is much simpler when you can make your decisions on your own rather than relying on other people to sway you in whichever direction. Its, I think, a reasonable request. GRAHAM:Commissioner Iwashita? IWASHITA:Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just for the record, I want to incorporate all of my prior concerns about the lack of a community development plan implemented in this area, and that, as you all know, it is my opinion that that should be the process that should be on-going before we consider any rezonings such as this. In particular, as to this application, as a body and as a Commissioner I view my role as looking at the big picture; and that is to say what is this area going to, you know, look like 20, 30, 40 years down the road and what impact is the request going to have on that. And, you know, as I mentioned, in passing earlier, you know, my uncle andmyaunt,mycousins,theyfarmedaparcelinthisarea.Itsnoteasywork.Theyworked many,manyyears.Itsstillproductive,theirfarmingoperation.Itsnotreallybeingworkedat muchnowbut,youknow,thatsnottosayitcantbedone;andthefactthatits,anyfarmerwill 7EXHIBIT A