2024-03-04 PL-SMA-2023-000046 Alex Williamson Opposition Testimony

Home

Dear County of Hawai'i, As a resident and humble guest on this beautiful land, as well as a student of the University of Hawai'i, I write to bring to your attention something of great importance. I take this opportunity to voice my concerns about the contemplated development of Punalu'u and the coastline of Ka`u. I strongly urge my fellow residents and authorities to consider the sustainable management assessments (SMAs)that are being proposed to Punalu'u. This matter is one that, I believe, steps beyond the bounds of real estate and urban planning, reaching into realms of historical preservation, cultural conservation and, ultimately, respect for those who have long since called this place home. Firstly, there looms a key concern about indigenous burial grounds. To say that these grounds are an integral part of the spiritual fabric of the Native people is an understatement. Regrettably, they have not been properly surveyed. Building on this land is an indelicate imposition to the indigenous residents and marks an unfortunate echo of colonial endeavors that disrespected indigenous ways of life worldwide. The beautiful creatures that depend on the shores of Punalu'u, the turtles, form another cornerstone to the argument against the proposed development. These majestic beings have long been revered as a symbol of good luck and endurance, integral not only to the ecosystem but also to the cultural significance of this land. Consider Na`alehu - a town once situated closer to the shore, upended and ultimately relocated due to the devastation wrought by a tsunami. Would it not be prudent to learn from past experiences and avoid risking both lives and property in such a hazardous location? Embarking on a similar course of action repeats the same cycle, wherein we pay more in terms of cost and human life in the face of foreseeable natural disasters. The call for a shoreline certification is imperative, especially when taking into account the proposed Beach Club Cafe's nearness to the beach. Considerations of respect and care come into play when dealing with potential discoveries of human remains, which may present a possibility given the close proximity to native burial grounds. The nature of the Archaeological Resources Protection Act permit adds weight to the importance of comprehensive project planning, encapsulating a prompt and effective consultation process for unexpected findings. Therefore, moving forward without a shoreline certification could result in hasty consultations, legal challenges, and possibly substantial penalties. In conclusion, it's non-negotiable: a shoreline certification is obligatory for the safe and legally compliant progression of this project. Let us not impair the harmony of our Hawai'i landscape or violate the resting places of our community's ancestors. Let's make sure the demands and rights of the Ka'u residents are upheld.