PC Proposed FOF, COL, and D&O Tieli Wang (PL-SMA-2024-000058)

Home

14. On September 5, 2024, Commissioner Kusch amended the motion to include the request by the State Historic Preservation Division for an archaeological field inspection. 15. On September 5, 2024, the motion by Commissioner Kusch to approve the Special Management Area Use Permit failed as no other Commissioner seconded his motion. 16. On September 5, 2024, Windward Planning Commission Vice Chair Daniele then moved that the application for Special Management Area Use Permit Docket No. PL-SMA- 2024-000058 be denied based on the following reasons: 1) septic issues associated with the development; 2) the importance of tidepools; 3) the fragility of anchialine pools in the area; and 4) limited access via the private road to the subject property and traffic considerations for neighboring properties. Commissioner De Luz seconded the motion. 17. The Windward Planning Commission voted unanimously, 5 — 0, to approve the motion to deny the application. B. PROPOSED PROJECT 18. The applicant requested a Special Management Area Use Permit to construct three (3), three-story single family dwellings and related improvements on each of the three subject parcels. For Parcel 44, the Applicant proposed a three-story single-family dwelling to include five(5)bedrooms, and twelve (12)bathrooms with a total living area of 6,008 square feet(sf), with 352-square feet for the balcony, and 3,004 square feet for parking. Per the applicant, the space in this dwelling will be reserved for the owner's family use and may also include short- and long-term rental units. For parcels 45 and 46, the applicant proposed the same design for each parcel with the intention of using both parcels for short or long-term rental units. The design for these parcels involved building a three-story dwelling on each parcel with the first floor set aside for parking (2,280 square feet for parking), and the second and third floor to be 4