HomeMy WebLinkAboutSugg. 25-01 Revised 12-08-2024
r'
COUINi TY OF HAW I„III Reservedfor office use:
Preservation Commission
Public access„ err ace„ and l�latuirall Resource Prese
SUGGESTION FORS +�g . 25 urw
For Lands,and/or IProperty Entitlements for Acquisition Rec'd vna emaK k 1/28/25 5:3 p
The IPubllic Access,, Open Space, and IlNatural Resources, Preseir ation Commission (PO,NC) is accepting suiggestilonis
for sines or projects to Improve upon Ipublic access, open spaice, and natural resources preservation, pursuant to
Chapter 2, Article 42, of the Ha ai'ii County Code. Please use this form to tell the Commission about a property
that your waroulld like to see protected.The Commission welcomes re-suibirmlissioin of previously sl uibirmittedl properties,
pleaise use one form per suggestion and limit totail application size to,less than 10 l B(megabytes)or 20 pages rmaix-
innurm (including photos, maps, and figures. If adjacent or nearby areas are protected and,/or publlic areas, include
regional maps as swell). Additional) public testimony may be submitted to exceed the 20 page rma irmium. The
Commission's ranking of the suggestion is (based on the information provided in this suggestion form and Ihiovw,it meets
the PO,NC scoiriing,criteria and not sollelly on the e pressiolin of public support or opposition.
Nllarme of Site or Project; W k hii1'Wa I 'uriaL Site 19 114 & A riio uItura lComplex: Site 191013
Ahupua'a,Council l District,and Location Within: Wa i k lh iiii'i u l , County C 'Itl"Y I] D14
Tau Map ge'' (TIW K),Niiurmber(s): �"w+K:I 3-1- - ` ; 14 TM' K.- 3-1 mm,5mm 3-, i4 Land Area(Acreage): T �. ,217
Property Owner I nforrmation-
TIMI 042 Aind irsorkiz araa wd Was,And d son,Jackie Fa AndaPrr poi nj y Fk)yr,,i, f 042:
Niarme s);IMI 043:Giant 11ropeurwm,„s LLL Email: TMK 041
.INK fr 2: Anderson,Hu abeth Was.4,1044 Ae Nines Way o Manslde 4�A 92056 TMK 0+ :
Address. TMIK 04.1 Giant Pn opeirties LLC iPo n,ox r 0215,HH Hr sa-721 521 Phiolrwe. TM. 0 ' :
To your knowledge, is the property owner a^wwraire of this nomination? ElYes OINlo D Uns--ure
Suggested)Purchase Method: EIConservatiom ILasernent 91Fee Simple Mother
Nominators,Contact information:
i o'eau oao_r 'itirien
Iarne(s)a Leah Couker Lmnalli:
No`maC 1 No'ea
ddress: V r9 air: ME" Phio,irne. Lrtr, .
(Reason for nomination of property(please check aill(bones that apply)
El Public outdoor recreation and::education, inclludIng access to beaches and mountains
El Preservation of historic or culturally important land areas and sites
17-3 Protection of natural resources, significant habitat or ecosystems, including buffer zones
0 P'rese�rvation of forests,including beaches, coastal areas, inatura�ll beauty, and agricultural lands
D Protection of wvatershed lands to preserve water quality and water supply
Hawai'ii C'ountV is an Equal Opportunity P'roviideir and ILrmplloyeir
Page I of
ADDITIONAL REQUIRED INFORMATION
Please provide the information requested below. The information shall be attached to this form and appropriately labeled
with the name of the identifying attachment.
➢ Attachment A: Provide a Tax Map Key Plat map and a property map with the property boundaries and/or proposed
access outlined or highlighted. Confirm the council district by contacting the County Clerk's Office at: (808)961-8277
or visit https://www.elections.hawaiicounty.gov/resources/maps.
➢ Attachment 6: Provide a clear statement detailing how public acquisition would fulfill one or more of the above
resource values. Explain the intent, long-term vision, and/or strategy of this proposed acquisition or project.
➢ Attachment C: If available, provide community letters of support or endorsements for this proposed acquisition o r
project.
➢ Attachment D: Identify and provide contact information of community organizations, land trusts, or individuals will-
ing to be part of this property's long-term management/maintenance.
➢ Attachment E: Please answer the following ten points by providing summaries and/or abstracts (rather than full re-
ports). Include, if necessary, citations or links to reference the documentation related to the suggested site or project.
Do not send original documents or pictures as they will not be returned.
1) How would this proposed acquisition or project benefit the general public?
2) Describe any significant historic, cultural, or natural resources on the property. Please be as specific as possible
and include only a summary of documentation (i.e., archaeological reports,flora/fauna surveys, etc.).
3) Describe (and include maps if available) any significant relationship to larger historical, cultural, and/or natural
landscape (i.e., corridors, complexes, agricultural field systems, conservation strategies etc.)
4) Describe the level of urgency (i.e.,the property is currently on the open market or for sale and if so, for how
long,there are current development plans,the property has an active filed application for re-zoning/subdivi-
sion, is an area of high public use, etc.).
5) Describe any special opportunities for acquisition that presently exist (special funding available, etc.).
6) Have partnerships with other government agencies or private or nonprofit entities been identified to leverage
resources(funding,grants, managing partnerships)?El Yes ❑ No El Unknown. If yes, please describe.
7) Is/Are the property(s) or property easement(s) available for acquisition? ❑Yes ❑No ❑Unknown.
If yes, please describe.
8) Are there any covenants, encumbrances, restrictions (i.e., association or maintenance), or easements on the
property? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Unknown If yes, please describe.
9) Describe any known hazards on the property(i.e.,flood zone, lava hazard zone, mudslides, pollution, etc.).
Hawai'i County is an Equal Opportunity Provider and Employer
Page 2 of 3
SUBMISSION INSTRUCTIONS
The Suggestion form and attachments may be submitted via email to PONC@hawaiicounty.gov, or you may mail (USPS,
Fed Ex, UPS, etc.) it to:
County of Hawai'i
Property Management-PONC
25 Aupuni Street,Suite 1101
Hilo, Hawaii 96720-4252
All nominations must be received by 4:30 p.m. on January 31, 2025, as evidenced by the County of Hawaii
time clock, PST.The Commission will not review any submissions received after the deadline.
We are not responsible for forms lost in the mail.
For further information,contact Property Management Division at (808)961-8069 or PONCOhawaiicounty.gov
Hawai'i County is an Equal Opportunity Provider and Employer
Page 3 of 3
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment A
I la w aii County 4 ou m A Dnwm°ucr 4
_ ... ._ ... .. _. Y ,•�f n9. 1 'If' � {..4%YIPT Li 5"rY U,E
1
PONC Application- Waiakahi'ula- Attachment A
1)20g25,9:28 AM qPLJb11(,'-R0-Hawdo'i Courity,W Rvpoi 1�150630420�000
Parcel Information
Parcel Nirmbcr 15062CN820000
Lotaflon Address KAHAKAI&.VD
Proj"t NaMe N o,,ivolon P.wkM Stjlrdivi,,iori
Property Cl— PF yIDLNI IAt
ProoeolY CMSS refers to Tax Classl cation ONLY.
`D'
Nem!oborlvood Code C44A I I
'"' Informatiori 10F A 9414 5F RiLK63PPr,'dT HAWN PARM,5M
1—d A—(acres) 0,21 75
dared A—(.pp,.A..t,.sq fitl 9,474
\,6 i,yid M,;p
1",1""t Cf N ,,'8 M
Owner Information
0—,Na.,.a MMH�g Addeer
ANDER$411NTLIZASETRPo01-As rN owfwrjoin T,namv AND[R5ON,EUZAsr,m BLAS
A�NDE�,R.5014, " FIX -Q-w� 4 JAIE � 044 Al DUA WAY
ANDE b0N,,AyFj()yj) mvner eat TAN$Wt(;A V201,6
Assessment Information
Market A--.d A--d Total
Land LMd Duikfing TaxaMe
yeaq Property Class VA.,. M
ai.. V.11- valuo.
2024 RESDENI(AL $1,3(xt V) $
Land information
Property Clji�a Square Footage Amago Ago iculluo al Use hidicatot
RPADENTRAI VA I't a 21 I'll
Building Division Permit&inspections Information
fwp, I,"Hyl, (i,I 1k, rY Apj,,, vff,o! N in
Sales Information
Sale Date Salve A mot Date ROorded Bookipa9c Conveyance Tmm
00 s 04102/2000 04/2V2002
2 $2$ODD 031"IVi989 77"""11,16el 1J.110
oafI51198
CluVrLtit Tax Bill Information
Origir.1 T T- NO
'Tax ------- ............ A—!7T...........C, Tax—Peltalty
...........
per"O'd Real Properly Tax 08/20/202 $0,00 SO-00 Sjoor�Uo $10-00 $5.50 $0,00 $11$-50
2,024.1 Rc;al Propmy Too, 4_ $0.6rj S0.00 _$100.00 $0 IM w(y,y vwa $10ow
21)74 2 Tin.001 with I rterovt emput0 tthrourh OV3112025 OV20120d SOX % 520U.N) $10-00 $$.50 SO-00 $21550
Pay T�I ffim i rl,,1,ix, rwa�I
00 K,,e PAY4,re,1 t Op 1 i w, ".1m k,L Vrk
Historical Tax Information
pay—rt: Am-1,
$0.00 $200DO
52100r= $0 00
-$ $0 00
$2W.00 ($200 0M $0 00
$ox),00 W0000 $om
$200,00 (S200,0% $0jD0
$2 00.00 06
%210J)a $000
51w.aa 3100 ft $000
$=60 (5106 66" $6 60
................... $=60----------------- ------------------------ ------------------- -�(j 06------
104M1-,1y&10 236180M?Olypp1O 4&Pagc.0 110
P,I
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment A
1p20g25,9:28 AM a PLJk 11(,'- 0-H;awa i County,M➢ Rvpoi 1-150630420�000
Paynte s Amount
Yea Tmw� and CrPdR, D7
.. sgKat oo Isttatolarar., scalrra
,.,.,.,.,.,,.,——I n w
witch .. sAdxa¢raft ali Lek i6W
.:: „a1: ......... ......... $Ilr 7aDlb ......... ......... ......... ......... ......... woo 00) ......... ......... $0�J .... .........
SOOD
l„ �Sf%7 iVfP ......... ......... ......... ......... ......... ( 1a.. ......... ......... SOS......... .........
�s f ids cbfr I'll�di`7 e45y sp tad
..,, .... .... s100.00 .... .... .... .... .._ ls1fM'bl+'��_ ..... ..... s006 .... __
�1si
510UO riIarr iv $0 VIG7
is K'„ ip� ua
AW
if
51OW)o 31WOM so OD
�w I .. .... ... ....., .....525:00. ... „...... ... ... ......, ... ... ...,... ... ........Tv s!mN.e,
Matt
IUI"i
Recent.Sales In Area
Salle date range:
Frrrna G.YI N)/2f122 Trot 0t f20l 2r)2P.i
..w-----------------------------------------
No
dan3 ayalbbk for the following mnodmlds:Cwdoi Piniavn,/Apartmont Urk la forni6ora Ap,yk uh�ural Arc„srnerra P.ebO64,ndiad Irn,rowwwrruona Imforri Worn,
C'.ImQUMua.Oal firowo,tment11 P(ua41'tWMB US1,Sltie4Q;w1 .Offier DWuldiow va,W Yard mor"eme,6K Pariniq IMora aCuor,
; sc�rr�IcaEFz
t,1,r u v I��>f�cw 1 1 f,f>ri�.0 w l,tlr4r
A
htwgvr.JJ �tl9auur,�e,�lrem i�0��rr,araar�)n�p glia,trnm.rgx A��tCa=�al¢C]nP$ L,yor1a 236180?Olyµwa*1O UM ag.0 20
3
PONC Application- Waiakahi'ula- Attachment A
I/2Of25,9 32 AM qPLJbIICJI0t-I'lawail Cwrq,HI Report 15G630430000
Parcel Information
Parcel Nuimbcr 150620,430000
Lotaflon Address T -2745 PUNA PARKWAY
Ptoj"t Naftle 0WAHAN PARKS SUHT)V15ION
Pmiperty Class PF SIDENI A!,
ProoenV Class refers 10 Tax Class cation ONLY.
`D'
Nei!oborlvood Code I C44A I I
'"a Information 110 1 39'P?51 F P e,9 I lAWAHAN PARKS.5,(D
1—d A—(acres) 0,21 76
La.d A—f.pp—dan.te. q� fty 9,479
W M,;p
1",1""t Cf 0' i," M
Owner Information
O"n.,Naan,.s Mafllag Adde.
GIANT PROPERTIESLLC
�-c)HOX 102 1
ULQ 11196 1 2 1
Assessment Information
A flk�h
Market ftseSSCAI AswS14 Total
land L-,d (ludding Taxable
YearPmperty Class SS8,4M Val" V�!ue....................................$58,600............................... ... ............................ Y�I�e
2024 RE SI DE N I RAL $0 .........................558,600...........
Land Information
Property Glass Square Footage Atmage Agvk ul turA Use Indleator
RE50ENTlAi 1,479 02176
Building Division Permit&Inspections Information
Sales Information
sale Date 5.1.A—unt Date R—ded 13-1,1P.Re C.n-y..,..Ta.
06/13`201 $4 3=0 08/07f2019 0
9 S1000 02128/2002 3.(X�
02/2"V701) $0 1008/1989 Z�776/124
His&WAFTax Information
9
payments Amount
Year Tax .and Credits Due
5515.04
$447 33 ($44 7331 $wx)
$157.42 53 5{.44 $0.1
S14188 3:14 1 W Sow
g 2oow r$2(nm) $aqm
M/ S20O.N) 3200.00) $0.w
W0.00 3266.06) k W
$10aw 310000) $0.00
sloom 3 Ibobo) $0.00
sjao o r$vywo) $0 n
$100.00 3160X0 V)b()
. . . . . . . . ..... . . . . . . . . 5100,00) . . . . . . . .
$TIN)00 r$100,001 $ODD
$lw w r$ICOXJO WICK)
$100 ay I IMMI $0.0D
Sim 00 f5100.001 *10.00
SIN.)00 w 0M $0M
5100.00 I$10=yl
1100.00) S0.00
2,i61UPap0yIp0A0 40nep.113 9878&Kr,,VV„IVufl. 1 110
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment A
I/20P25,9 32 AM gPUbliC'let-I'lawai'i CQurA3,HI-Report 15fl630430000
Payments Amount
Yea A" Tax and Ct,dl tx ICluar
41C}('!rL'rCY ,,r#nsxc009. aafixr
-----
,——_ „———— ,—w,,,,, ,.,,,. ,,,„.,,.,,._ ,..,,.,,.,,.,,. ,.,,.,,.,,.,,
Ill', .. $1GPJ IYJ .. .. .. P'$5C9k9 CYC1,Y k(J GCY
'41 C7(7 M1}G P Po G{P.Y,FCr) t6(.75
... „el�� ......... ......... ......... ......... ......... ......... ......... ......... ......... ... ....._.
�25.iff 4E:2 i..t7CV;i $(7!Cw ....
Y, '42.r.d7 "E25.00,1 't7 CCb—
Map
I�
"fJClr� 4
tVf M I
i�
IJQ 4
I t
1.
Recent Sales in Area
Sale mate range:.
F'rmm. 01.i 20,IP1;2 Tw 01,./20/ 202'."-
No dal a avalNablle for Ow following morluulos: Ufrn lu fof raarouro.AWruurlfural Av,..n arut lrlfo n atio,ResWurlial lnlpsuuva, >urYa,Ic16uar r,Yudr ru,
Clurnme,f 6rl hT'j "VCMLmt Informa4 pm,slkoeprc.,276I Cr Ru.Yiilul'rulp,ind Yard lmpruwarrno tls F+.rlrvgh.Infurmat ear Cwvr nt Tow SHP lnfep n tlioro_
SCHNIEICYC.k
I1,=vl Y Yr/17�Y fry 1a114^iv. rrir,:e•
I,-Ylisrr Ir,l,,f r;' r ;r,.,1 �rfYAkr7.�
hY91+„'Fpt;pxLuhilr,;GMfinrniyWryurnrpro eouwrlaA g,Ile:wuirtan,as m+n 15�I) a.C]ra A l.a3rvrt 1's=2,i6INMrR;,"EPf°f grl7mOB]=���a1 w�rpa�s¢] 9gi':F R I4ro lrgtuuue=]6fa6.fD✓,p:1'4',Y(ACItl'a 20
5
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment B
Attachment B: Provide a clear statement detailing how public acquisition would fulfill
one or more of the above resource values. Explain the intent, long-term vision, and/or
strategy of this proposed acquisition or project.
In 1974, the Bishop Museum conducted an archaeological survey of multiple
areas within the Puna district, including the traditional fishing village of the
Waiakahi`ula ahupua`a. This survey identified significant features, including a canoe
shed, several agricultural sites, and a burial platform. The canoe shed and other
associated features were located within County property and are part of the
Waiakahi`ula Beach Park today. However, just across the street, the burial platform
and its adjacent agricultural complex were found to be on private land and remain so
to this day.
In 1998, a follow-up site inspection was conducted, as detailed in the document
Site lnsoection and Limited Subsurface Testing at Two Parcels(TMK.-3->-5-63.-42,43)
Hawaiian Beaches Estates. This inspection confirmed the presence of the burial
platform (Site 19014) and its agricultural complex (Site 19013), assigning them site
numbers and issuing recommendations for their preservation (See Fig 1). Specifically,
Site 19013 was deemed significant under Criterion D. Site 19014 was classified under
Criteria C, D, and E, emphasizing the need for its preservation due to the presence of
Native Hawaiian skeletal remains.
As stated in the 1998 report:
"This burial platform is significant for a variety of reasons. Paramount among
these is the presence of Native Hawaiian skeletal remains. According to
Hawaii State Statutes Chapter 6E, all such remains are considered
significant. Additionally, this site meets significance criteria due to its vaulted
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
1
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment B
chamber construction (Criterion C), its research potential (Criterion D), and
the traditional cultural value inherent in such a location and feature (Criterion
E). Further research may reveal additional significance under Criteria A and
B."
In 2013, an Archaeological Inventory Survey (AIS) was conducted for Site 19014,
further reinforcing the need to protect these important sites. The AIS included specific
recommendations, including the creation of a Burial Treatment Plan for Site 19014. In
response, Escott prepared a comprehensive Burial Treatment Plan in May 2013, which
outlined long-term protective measures, (see Fig 2) including the establishment of a
permanent preservation buffer and the requirement for fencing during any development
activities near the site.
In 2024, both Sites 19014 and 19013 were desecrated by Giant Properties LLC
during an attempted development project. This act of desecration occurred just weeks
after a public ceremony celebrating the return of the traditional place name Waiahahi`u/a
to the beach park. Within 24 hours, representatives from the Hawaii Police Department
(HPD), Hawaii Burial Council, Division of Conservation and Resources Enforcement
(DOCARE), and the State Historic Preservation Division (SHPD) were on site to collect
evidence for their respective investigations and reports.
This event has since triggered several actions in regards to the perpetual
protection and preservation of sites 19014 & 19013. One of which includes this
application, in which our overall goal is to have this land acquired by Pub/icAccess,
Open Space, al7o'Natura/Resource Preservation Commission(PONC) to preserve the
integrity of the overall village complex that extends into the County park, as well as
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
2
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment B
afford these sites the protection and stewardship that accompanies PONC designation.
A non-profit 501(c)3 is in the process of being developed with the mission of stewarding
all cultural and historical sites within the ahupua`a of Waiakahi`ula.
Both properties are currently overgrown with invasive plants and are in dire need
of maintenance. One of our long-term projects is to partner with groups such as the
Friends of The Park as well as the `Aha Lamaku `Oia`i`o to remove the invasives and
instead implement the preservation measures that were prescribed in the 2013 Burial
Treatment Plan. This includes establishing a 20 ft buffer of shallow-rooted native
vegetation around the burial site.
We would also like to work with Mala La`au Hawaii, who has been helping to
bring more native Hawaii plants to Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, to do more of the same for
these adjacent properties. We would also work with them for invasive species
eradication.
Lastly it is essential that a long-term preservation plan is developed for all the
cultural sites on the properties and adjacent beach park.
Figure 1:
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
3
I C Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment B
m
00
CPO
i
y
u
,
�a
E & a goo do � m� C.
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
5
4
PONC Application- WailakahliVall-, Attachment B
FIgure 2:
Site 19013 is significant under criterion "D" as it is likely to yield infortnation
important to history. However,during the current AI S study, it was determined based on
feature type and constniction method, that the four features are agricultural plianfing
depressions wild agricultural terraces.'The lack of artifacts recovered lix)m excavations at
Site 19lO 13 supports the cAmclusion that the area was used for agriculture. The opihi shell
ftagmcnts recovered fro mTU4 were likely food waste discarded while working in,the
garden area. Information recorded at Site 19013 during the curl study bas adequately
ascertained the dining and function of die site and documentation contained in this report
is sufficient to warrant no further work,
Site 19014 is a traditional Hawaiian burial platform and is significant under
criteria"C", "'Dl" and "E". It is recommended that a burial treatment plan be prepared by
the landowner,, Mr. Timothy Eden,, to protect the portion ofth c burial within Ws property.
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
5
PONC Application- Waiakahi'ula- Attachment C
Attachment C: If available, provide community letters of support or endorsements for this proposed
acquisftion or Iproject.
Letters of Support:
We received over 60 letters of support of this acquiisition. They are complied iin,a Googlle Drive file
labeled here:
Petition.
An online petition was created on,Tuesday,January 21, 2025, Within the first w� eek,the petition
received nearly 250 verified siignatures. The petition can be found here: Priotect Hawaivan Cuftu4�
Sites of Waiakahi'uIa IPuna, Hawali'i
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment D
Attachment D: Identify and provide contact information of community organizations, land
trusts, or individuals willing to be part of this property's long-term
management/maintenance.
The following groups have committed themselves to the care of the cultural sites of
Waiakahi'ula, Puna, Hawai'i.
Na Hoa `Aina o Waiakahi'ula: No'eau Woo-O'Brien, a Native Hawaiian cultural
practitioner and life-long resident of Waiakahi'ula, is currently in a Friends of The Park
agreement with the County to steward the cultural sites that exist within Waiakahi'ula
Beach Park.
During the kipaepae in July 2024, in which the park was renamed Waiakahi'ula Beach
Park, No'eau also was given the title of kahu. The title of kahu comes with a
commitment to the well-being of both the land and the people of Waiakahi'ula. Since the
kipaepae, No'eau has collaborated with numerous groups such as the 'Aha Lamaku
Oia`i`o of Pahoa High School, Mala L5'au Hawai'i of Pahoa, Ka Pouhana of UH Hilo and
many others all for the sake of caring for the beach park
No'eau has also created numerous online videos to educate the public about the history
of Waiakahi'ula, many of which have attracted a large number of views, & have also
been featured in various educational presentations across Hawai'i.
Kawai'ula is a cultural protocols and community engagement group that is located
within the ahupua'a of Waiakahi'ula. This group is led by No'eau Woo-O'Brien and
Kumu Hula, Taupouri Tangaro of Hawai'i Community College. Kawai'ula is dedicated to
the development of Hawaiian cultural protocols and training for the ahupua'a of
Waiakahi'ula and the Puna community at large.
The group currently consists of various Puna residents, who have taken on the kuleana
of being trained in ceremony, so that they will eventually be able to lead kipaepae
protocols at Waiakahi'ula Beach Park. Kawai'ula recognizes that Waiakahi'ula once
supported a thriving community rooted in Hawai'i life-ways and practices. With that
being said, this group aims to bring those life-ways & practices back to Waiakahi'ula.
`Aha Lamaku `Oia`i`o (ALO) is a leadership program for Native Hawaiian and other
youth of Pahoa High School, which also rests in the ahupua'a of Waiakahi'ula. Led by
Pahoa High School instructor, Leah Gouker, ALO offers after school programs, camping
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
1
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment D
retreats, and a summer program. ALO partners with multiple community organizations
and leaders to provide `aina-based service learning and culturally-relevant leadership
training,
One of the ALO project areas is called Aloha Waiakahi`ula. Students were to work with
cultural practitioner and Hawaii scholar No`eau Woo-O'Brien and Friends of
Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, Hawaii County government officials, local archaeologists and
cultural practitioners to preserve, protect, and perpetuate cultural and historical sites
and mo`olelo of the ahupua`a of Waiakahi`ula, where PHIS and Pahoa town are located.
ALO haumana played a large role in the renaming of the park, as the students of this
group submitted testimony to the County Council, which resulted in the passing of Bill
132-24. ALO also participated in the kipaepae and renaming ceremony for the park in
July 2024, in which the students were trained in hula, chant, and protocol.
Recently ALO have participated in planting and cleaning sessions at the park & have
also committed themselves for future kipaepae & ceremonies in Waiakahi`ula. Beyond
the park, ALO has continued their efforts by educating their peers at Pahoa High & Inter
about Waiakahi`ula`s history, function, mele, and oli.
For a brief overview of ALO's works in Waiakahi`ula, please see the following:
Aloha Waiakahi`ula
In late November 2023, a new ALO project area began. Waiakahi`ula is the name of the
ahupua`a in which Pahoa town (including PHIS) is located, and "Aloha Waiakahi`ula"is
dedicated to preserving and protecting the cultural heritage and identity of this
ahupua`a. The fishing village of Waiakahi`ula was located in the area near the Hawaiian
Beaches cliffs, and a 1974 archaeological survey revealed that there were a number of
historically significant archaeological sites located in the County park near the cliffs.
The sites include a large double-stall auha, a hale site, an ali`i burial (located just
outside the park on the County easement/right of way), and agricultural sites. ALO
students began working with Kumu No`eau Woo O'Brien, a life-long Waiakahi`ula
resident and Hawai`iCC Instructor to visit the park and locate the sites referenced in the
survey. After some coordination, the students were able to meet with County
Councilmember Ashley Kierkiewicz, the County Parks Planner, and a retired SHPD
archaeologist at the park to communicate their goals and vision for protecting and
honoring the sites. The students collectively submitted testimony to officially rename
the park to Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, which was unanimously approved by the County
Council.
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
2
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment D
The Kauwela 24 program culminated with a cultural family, community, and civic
engagement event on July 3, 2024. The students worked with Kumu No`eau during
Kauwela 2024 to design five 3'x 2'cultural/historical educational signs that were
unveiled at the official Waiakahi`ula Beach Park re-naming ceremony on July 3, 2024.
The students participated in a KTpaepae protocol under the guidance of 1 Ola Ha/oa
(HawCC). The renaming ceremony was their ho`ike and La `Ohana, as it was the final
day of the summer program. They served approximately 200 people lunch that was
primarily prepared by the students and the Men of PA`A with their Imu Mea`ai program.
The ALO program was also officially recognized by the Hawaii State Legislature for their
outstanding community work and efforts, and presented with an award from Vice
Speaker and Puna Representative Greggor Illagan. Other dignitaries, including Hawaii
County Mayor Mitch Roth, County Council District 4 representatives, KKP
administrators, PHIS administration and ALPSS program students, KS Kaiaulu
personnel, the OHA land agent for Wao Kele O Puna, Men of PA`A, and the students'
`ohana, many other community members, and stakeholders observed the KTpaepae and
participated in the celebration.
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
3
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment E
Attachment E: Please answer the following ten points by providing summaries and/or
abstracts. Include citations or links to reference documentation related to the suggested
site or project. Avoid sending original documents or pictures as they will not be returned.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
1. How would this proposed acquisition or project benefit the general
public?
The acquisition of TMK would offer significant benefits:
1. Preservation of Cultural and Historical Heritage: These sites are integral to
the Waiakahi`ula ahupua`a, a traditional Hawaiian fishing village with deep
cultural significance. Public access to these areas will promote education and
appreciation of Hawaiian heritage.
2. Permanent Protection: PONC designation ensures long-term safeguards
against desecration or development, preserving the sites for future generations.
3. Community Engagement: Designation under the PONC program would support
public programs, fostering community stewardship and cultural pride.
4. Educational Opportunities: Proper management of these sites could enhance
educational initiatives, teaching visitors about traditional practices and history.
5. Legal and Cultural Protections: Acquisition ensures adherence to state laws
regarding Native Hawaiian burial sites and honors cultural practices.
Summary: This acquisition would safeguard cultural and historical resources while
providing educational, ecological, and community benefits for future generations.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
1
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment E
2. Describe any significant historic, cultural, or natural resources on the
property.
Location: Sites 19013 and 19014 are situated on TMK 3-1-5-63.042 and TMK
3-1-5-63.043.
Historic Resources:
• Site 50-10-45-19013:
o Agricultural features, including stone-rimmed depressions and terraces,
constructed with pahoehoe cobbles and boulders.
• Site 50-10-45-19014:
o Pentagonal burial platform made of pahoehoe cobbles, containing human
skeletal remains in a traditional Hawaiian burial.
Cultural Resources:
• Reflect traditional Hawaiian agricultural techniques and burial practices.
• High cultural value under State Historic Preservation criteria.
Natural Resources:
• Flora: Mix of guava, albizia trees, and native plants like `awapuhi (wild ginger)
and ki (ti plants).
• Geological Features: Uneven pahoehoe lava bedrock typical of Puna's natural
landscape.
Documented Investigations:
• iso useu 1 4 Survey
• 1998 Site Inspection
• 2013 Archaeolo ical Inventory urve I 1 an oriel Treat ent Plan
T
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
2
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment E
3. Describe any significant relationship to larger historical, cultural, and/or
natural landscapes.
Site 19013: Agricultural Features
• Cultural Landscape: Stone depressions and terraces align with sustainable
Hawaiian agricultural practices.
• Ecological Integration: Use of local materials emphasizes malama `aina (care
for the land).
Site 19014: Burial Platform
• Cultural Practices: Reflects Hawaiian burial traditions tied to the land and sea.
• Geographical Context: Proximity to the coastline symbolizes life's cyclical
nature.
Maps:
1. Figure 2: Depicts the broader Waiakahi`ula region and site locations.
2. Figure 3: Shows spatial relationships between Sites 19013 and 19014.
Significance: Integration with traditional practices demonstrates the intimate
connection between people, land, and tradition, highlighting the need for preservation.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
3
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment E
4. Describe the level of urgency.
• 2024Desecration: On July 28, 2024, Site 19014 was partially destroyed due to
a violation of the Burial Treatment Plan. HPD, DOCARE, filed reports on that
day, within 24 hours of the incident SHPD & Burial Council officials were on site.
The preservation measures for the BTP (created in 2013) have not been
implemented.
• Development Threats: The property owner of TMK 3-1-5-63.043 has stated that
development of a vacation rental will proceed in April 2025 if the property is not
procured by another entity.
• Hi_ h TrafficArea: Parking occurs on burial sites, violating a 30-foot preservation
buffer specified in the burial treatment plan.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
4
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment E
5. Describe any special opportunities for acquisition.
N/A.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
5
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment E
6. Have partnerships been identified to leverage resources?
Yes.
• Friends of The Park: Stewardship agreement with No`eau Woo-O'Brien for
cultural sites.
• Kawai`ula: A cultural protocols and community engagement group led by No`eau
Woo-O'Brien and Taupouri Tangaro in Waiakahi`ula, Puna, Hawaii.
• ALO CAha Lamaku `Oia`i`o): Youth leadership program of Pahoa High School,
providing `aina-based learning opportunities.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
6
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment E
7. Is the property available for acquisition?
Yes. Owners of TMK 3-1-5-63.042 and TMK 3-1-5-63.043 are willing to sell.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
7
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment E
8. Are there covenants, encumbrances, or restrictions on the property?
Yes.
• Zoning and Designation:
o County: Agricultural (A-1 a).
o State: Urban.
o LUPAG: Low Density Urban.
• Special Management Area (SMA): Partial location within SMA.
• Burial Treatment Plan (2013):
o Interim preservation buffers: 30 feet during construction.
o Long-term preservation measures: 20-foot buffer with native vegetation.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
8
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment E
9. Describe any known hazards on the property.
• Lava Hazard Zone: Located in Zone 2.
• Tsunami Evacuation Zone: Property lies within this area.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
9
PONC Application- Waiakahi`ula- Attachment E
10. Additional Notes
These sites provide a unique opportunity to preserve and protect Hawaiian cultural,
historical, and natural resources for future generations. Immediate action is required to
prevent further desecration and irreversible damage.
Woo-O'Brien & Gouker
2025
10
Aloha mai kakou e ka Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission,
I hope this brief letter finds you all and your 'ohana healthy, connected, and joyous!
As a historian who holds a doctorate in Hawaiian History with an emphasis on
Hawaiian Language resources and Historiography in Hawaii, I have spent the past
twenty+ years researching, teaching, and speaking about the critical importance of
preserving and highlighting the people and places of the past so that we might benefit
from the experience of a more than millenia presence in these Islands. From cultural
precepts that help ground us all—Kanaka 'Oiwi and Non-Kanka—to pragmatic
understandings of weather, farming, fishing, and many more, "I Ka Wa Mamua, I ka
Wa Mahope (The Future is in the Past).
Preserving a site like is not merely a "cultural win' for Kanaka 'Oiwi—although that
could be argued as reason enough—bur rather preservation of this important site
allows for the continued presence of spiritual, physical, and educational 'ike
(knowledge) that can help all in Hawaii navigate the future.
In times like these, the physical and spiritual resources that can buoy us with hope,
education, and spirit seem to be disappearing at a record pace. This site, and its future
can and will make a difference.
I offer my strong support for the acquisition and preservation of TMK 3-1-5-063:42,43
and I mahalo you for your time and consideration.
Dr. Ronald Williams Jr.
Rmi,,faa1 W.flh,,. ns 4, PhD
�onv as<,a (Aivhpvaa�), %,.Jh mis Rahap aha . up tui� O a<,a Mohf 15�a '),a II'awgyp`p (I I'aw a
/ avhp map
VO (;oochless hake, a coy ,),)�,ntul4y lka,my o
p p: w"J a
1/26/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations
Living in Hawaiian beaches, and seeing that waikahiula beach park as one of the last vestiges
of native habitat that hold deep cultural and spiritual value to the Hawaiian people, the same
people that the subdivision is named for, the Hawaiian people, over the years we've seen
people move here or invest their money into rental properties and to buy homes here, and we've
seen people willfully cut down our precious coastline endemic species (lauhala), purely for their
view and to profit off our investments and make better curb appeal for their properties, these
things done without any forethought to cultural significance of these places and spaces;
although our coastline is under special management without proper advocacy and education,
these places are still at risk from inconsiderate impact from people not of place. People are
leaving California enmass and buying up the last remaining undeveloped land in east Hawai'i,
and many are fleeing their climate prone cities and neighborhoods because it has become
increasingly apparent that these very harmful mindsets have placed aina under aggressive
dominion that has led lands of America to become overdeveloped and nature has been buckling
under unchecked development, and now their homelands are experiencing climate crisis and
are now fire prone, and if unchecked and no mechanisms in place to educate people, we will
inevitably recreate these problems in Hawaii.
Western culture is not one of that teaches stewardship, but rather a utilitarian way of
commodifying nature and land, and because of that we're seeing massive amounts of people
moving here with little connection to place, or understanding of the impact their actions have on
aina and people, waikahiula beach park and adjacent properties would be a boon for cultural
practice, and serve as an important community resource to teach and promote cultural values of
Hawaii, as well be a beacon for stewardship and aloha aina, that are the values born of this very
land, and I a resident of this place support these places to be preserved as culturally significant
wahipana, my family asks that you consider these properties for a ponc land purchase and
support Noeau in protecting iwi kupuna and advocating for our aina.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou require further
i
ormation or ersonal testimony, please feel free to contact me at i" or
Me ke aloha,
Benjamin Rodrigues
Charlotte Cheek
am
January 22, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by Giant Property LLC's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula. Protecting these areas and educating the public is vital to the well being
of our community and `aina.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou require further
i
ormation or ersonal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha,
V
o � 41
o
� q
Charlotte Cheek
N
Gre
rmm
01/22/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located just mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park. These parcels are of immense and rich historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the current community at large and
future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi'ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded and preserved against further harm, such as the recent
destruction of an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition
of these properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the
County's guidance and carried out the community.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula which in turn enhances the communities perception and behavior to and
at the place. Having places like this throughout the island only fosters better community
engagement and pride.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at [your phone number] or
[your email address].
Me ke aloha,
ti.
Makani Gregg
Hau`oli Louis Viritua
31 W. Kawili Street
oil"
January 22, 2025
Aloha e County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Aloha `aina `o is `i`o,
Hau`oli Louis Viritua
YunaInoue
1/28/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou re uire further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at
Me ke aloha,
YunaInoue
Y40tje2, 40,e4be,
Ka`imi Galima-Elvena
15-675 Puni Mauka Loop N.
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located ma uka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha,
Ka`imi Galima-Elvena
Kalena K. Blakemore
1/23/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-o63:42
and TMK 3-1-5-o63:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC) program.These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent
destruction of an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The
acquisition of these properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper
stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites,the
acquisition would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper
connection to the history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-o63:42 and TMK 3-1-5-o63:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared
for in perpetuity.These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage
that hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require
further information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha,
Kalena K. Blakemore
Antoinette Kauilani Almeida
January 24, 2025
Native Hawaiian pursuant to Hawaiian Homes Act 1020, amended 21
Advocate, Protector and Beneficiary Consultant under 43 CFR 47&48
Eo to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC), Aloha.
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's PONC program. These parcels, located mauka of
Wakahi'ula Beach Park are of immense historical, cultural and ecological significance and
deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As a Federal Beneficiary Consultant, the land that houses the Waiakahi'ula Village complex are
legally protected because of its kapu aupuni, therefore there should be no doubt that it be
protected and heavily secured, as there have been witnessed incidences of malice by one of
TMK's current neighbor landowner harming the wall structure using improper repair methods
to cover up his mistake as many others have done and continues the practice of harming our
sacred sites and iwi kupuna, thinking that no one is watching. *PONC purchase of the two TMKs
should mitigate any more future harmful incidents to the Complex.
In protection of the Complex, I am confident in the Burial Council laws provided, but by no
means did I expect for it to stay in place forever and ever amen, rather we are demanding that
meaningful, regular evaluations of these laws be a major instrument in justifying the word
"PRESERVATION." Our lands are always evolving and so should the laws.
In comparing before and after pictures of Waiakahi'ula Village complex, I strongly support the
acquisition by PONC of TMK: 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43, because your program's
mission ensures legal stewardship and protection of Hawaii's unique cultural and natural
resources.
Mahalo to all community members engaged in turning these bushes into shagri-la,
IMUA KAKOU I KE ALOHA AINA, HU!
Ka-dant IMWtC&
Kauilani Almeida
Victor Shawn, Seiler
M
m�
01/27/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawai'j Put)lic Access, Open Space, and NatUral Resource Preservation ColmnlissiOn
(PONC),
I arn writing to express niy strong support N-the M.1,11lisition of the parceis TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-
063:43 under the COLUltyS PUblic Access, Open Space, and Nawral, Resource Preservation Conirnission (PONC)
program, These parcels, located aiaUka of WaJz'ikahi'ula M'.wh Park, are of irnmense historical, cultural, and
eWogical significance an(] deserve to be Preserved for the benefit of the comrnun�ty and fUnlrc.' generations.
A,s Part of the historically significant Wflakahi'ulaa village comptex,, these, lands,are horne to sacred and legally
protected sites, including the burial eat`as high-ranking, individual. It is imperative that these sites, are safeguarded
against further harrn, such as the recent destruction of an ancient walli by they current landowners unauthorized
activities. The acquisition of these,properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship
Under the Clountyr's guidance.
Preserving d'iese lands aligns with the PONC pro grarn's mission to I)Y-(,.)tect IlawaiTS UlliqLR` cultura]i and natural
resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant site;, the acquis,ition would also foster opportunities for
education, culturai practices, and as deeper connection to the [iistory,of Waiakahi'uta.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3,-1-5-063:42 and'rMK 3-1-5-06:3!43 to prevent
further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in lie pewhy. "I'llese lands are
not just spaces; the..,y Eire vi ta:ll pielces, of our shared hedtage that hold stories, mana, and [essorls for all who call.
Hawai'i home,
Malial,o nui four YCAH"i'Attention and for considering this critical Matter. Should you require further infO11TWO(Al Or
personal testimony, please feel free to contact nie at Vn
Me ke alotia,
Victor Shawn Seiler
Susan Kazama
January 20, 2025
To the 2025 PONC Commission,
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition and preservation of two parcels
(TMK 3-1-5-063:043 "Giant Properties", owner David Chun and adjacent site TMK
3-1-5-063:042, owner Anderson) located near to Waiakahi`ula beach Park, because of the
cultural and historical integrity of the sacred burial site of the Native Hawaiian high ranking
individual located there. The significance of this site cannot be overstated, both in terms of its
historical importance and its deep spiritual value to the Hawaiian people. It would be a grave
injustice—and indeed, sacrilegious—to allow this sacred land to be desecrated for the
construction of a vacation home. One owner David Chun, has already violated the Burial
Treatment plan for that land, by destroying the ancient wall of the burial site.
This site is not merely a piece of land but a living connection to the rich history and heritage of
Hawaii. The burial site represents a deeply spiritual and cultural landmark for the people of
Hawaii, and its sanctity must be honored and protected. Allowing construction on this sacred
ground would not only disrupt the historical landscape but also deeply disrespect the traditions
and beliefs that have sustained the Hawaiian people for generations.
Our collective responsibility is to protect these irreplaceable cultural treasures for future
generations. The preservation and protection is needed, to ensure that the legacy of Hawaii's
history, its royal lineage, and its rich cultural heritage is respected and maintained. We must
remember that the land is a sacred trust that links us to the past, our ancestors, and future
generations. To choose to preserve this site is to affirm the values of respect, reverence, and
stewardship.
I respectfully urge the PONC to acquire this land as soon as possible, and consider the
long-term impact of allowing development on this sacred land. The right thing to do is to protect,
preserve, and honor the memory of those who came before us, ensuring that this sacred space
remains intact for the generations yet to come.
Thank you for your attention to this critical matter. I hope that we can all stand together in
support of preserving the rich history and culture of Hawaii.
Sincerely,
Susan Kazama
January 23, 2025
Aloha Members of the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission(PONC),
My name is Leila Kealoha and I am a lineal descendant of Puna and the Executive Director of P6haku
Pelemaka 501(c) 3 nonprofit. Our mission is to protect,perpetuate,and enhance: the intrinsic qualities of
the lower Puna area,Native Hawaiian wellbeing, and the transmission of intergenerational knowledge and
practices in partnership with `ohana(family), county, state,government,public and private sectors.
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK
3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission(PONC)program. These parcels,located mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of
immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the
community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex,these lands are home to sacred and
legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is imperative that these sites
are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of an ancient wall by the current
landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these properties would ensure their protection and
allow for proper stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique cultural and
natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites,the acquisition would also foster
opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 to
prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in perpetuity.
These lands are not just spaces;they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold stories,mana, and
lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should on require further
information or ersonal testimony,please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha pumehana,
Leila Kealoha,Executive Director
P6haku Pelemaka 501 c(3)
Cynthia Lahilahi Verschuur
W=
January 24, 2025
Aloha mai kakou, Members of the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and
Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my heartfelt support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's PONC program. These parcels, located mauka of
Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are not just land—they are sacred and historically significant.
Preserving them is essential for the well-being of our community and the generations to come.
These lands are part of the Waiakahi`ula village complex, a place of deep cultural, historical,
and spiritual significance. They house sacred sites, including the burial of a high-ranking
individual, which are legally protected. Sadly, these areas have already been subjected to
damage, most recently when an ancient wall was destroyed due to the unauthorized activities of
the current landowner. This further highlights the urgent need for the County's protection.
I have witnessed firsthand the profound impact that the reclamation of the name and history of
Waiakahi`ula has had on the local community, particularly Native Hawaiians in the area. It has
reinvigorated a sense of pride, connection, and stewardship, fostering a deep respect for the
land and its cultural significance. Adding these parcels to the public trust would further this
movement and ensure that the positive tide continues to flow.
However, if we allow a profit-motivated colonizer to build a vacation rental next to a sacred
burial site, we are sending a dangerous message: that it's acceptable to commercialize native
lands, to misappropriate the mana of our wahi pana for short-term gain. This is not just an issue
of land—it's a matter of respect, of recognizing the value of our shared heritage and our
responsibility to protect it.
Acquiring these parcels would not only safeguard these sacred sites but also align with the
PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique cultural and natural resources. This land is
part of the living history of Waiakahi`ula, and preserving it is an investment in the future,
ensuring that this sacred place remains intact for generations to come. Once raw lands are
developed, it is nearly impossible to restore them to open spaces. This area of the ahupua`a
already has too many American-style fancy homes that don't fit the landscape.
I respectfully urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK
3-1-5-063:43. These lands are irreplaceable, and the opportunity to preserve them for future
generations is now. Let's continue to nurture and protect this special place, not just for the
benefit of the people of Hawaii, but for all who recognize the profound significance of our wahi
pana.
Mahalo nui for your attention to this important matter. If you require additional information or
would like to hear more from me, please don't hesitate to contact me at or
Me ka `o is `io,
Lahilahi Verschuur
Noel K. Ta ab-Cruz
1/24/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
PONC has a kuleana (responsibility)to maintain and preserve Waiakahi`ula and other Native
Hawaiian cultural and historic spaces and places. The Waiakahi`ula village complex includes
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands is in direct alignment with the PONC program's mission to protect
Hawai`i's unique cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant
sites, the acquisition would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a
deeper connection to the history of Waiakahi`ula.
I strongly urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-
5-063:43 to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana (celebrated places) are
preserved and cared for in perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our
shared heritage that hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou re uire further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at
Me ka ha`aha`a,
Noel K. Tagab-Cruz
Sheena Lo es
January 22, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located ma uka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou re uire further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at
Me ke aloha,
Sheena Lopes
January 22, 2025
TO: County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC)
FR: Kulia Kauhi Tolentino-Potter
RE: Strong support for Acquisition of Parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
(PONC)program.
Aloha mai kakou,
I am writing this letter in strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and
TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program.
The 2 parcels listed above are located mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park and are of immense
historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the
community and future generations.
The `aina la`a listed above are home to sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of
a high-ranking individual. In this time and space, it is the kuleana of this generation to step
forward and be the leo to protect the area from further harm. Too many sites have been
overlooked and history of our people have been destroyed. In this situation, the current
landowner has done recent destruction of an ancient wall. The acquisition of these properties
would ensure the protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou re uire further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at
Me ke aloha,
Kulia K. Tolentino-Potter
Nicolas Michael Storie
January 27,2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha,
Nicolas Michael Storie
Nai'ali'i Valera
lip=
22 January 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou require further
i
ormation or ersonal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha,
Nai'ali'i Valera
January 20, 2025
MEMORANDUM FOR 2025 Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)
FROM: Bryce Lynn Knape
SUBJECT: Urgent Support Request for Acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and :43 in
Waiakahi`ula Village
Aloha mai kakou,
I am writing to request for the County's approval and action to acquire TMK
3-1-5-063:42 and :43 through the Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC) program. These properties are integral to the
preservation of Waiakahi`ula village, a culturally and historically significant area that
must be protected for current and future generations.
These parcels contain two identified, legally protected sites, including the burial
of a high-ranking individual. The location's significance is reinforced by its proximity
to Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, a newly renamed area already under the stewardship of
dedicated local advocates.' These advocates, including myself, have dedicated hours
(others, years) to malama this wahi pana, recognizing its importance not only as a
historical treasure but also as a symbol of our kuleana to protect and honor Hawai`i's
cultural heritage.
The urgency of this matter cannot be overstated. The current landowner of TMK
3-1-5-063:043 has already violated the Burial Treatment Plan, damaging an ancient
wall with a skid steer. This reckless disregard for the site's sacredness highlights the
critical need for County acquisition. Without intervention, the owner's stated intent to
construct a vacation rental risks further desecration and erasure of these irreplaceable
resources. Hawai'i as a whole has seen enough erasure and desecration. Waiakahi`ula
specifically, has also faced these challenges throughout its own history.
-Con't on Page 2
From my personal observations, the properties in question are located extremely
close to the road and lack sufficient parking or infrastructure to handle increased
activity. This makes them ill-suited for private development and further underscores
their value as protected open spaces. Their proximity to the existing County park also
provides a seamless opportunity for stewardship under a unified preservation plan,
ensuring the integrity of the entire village complex.
Acquiring these properties under the PONC program will not only safeguard the
sites but also honor the spirit of Waiakahi`ula as a whole. It will allow for the
continued stewardship of these lands by those who deeply understand and respect their
significance, ensuring they are preserved for cultural education, quiet reflection, and
connection to our shared history.
I urge the PONC commissioners to take swift and decisive action to protect
TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and :43 before irreversible damage occurs. By acquiring these
lands, the County will affirm its commitment to preserving Hawai`i's unique cultural
and historical legacy.
Mahalo nui for your time and consideration. Please do not hesitate to contact me
for additional information or to discuss this matter further.
1. (County Officials Join Community in Waiakahi`ula Beach Park Blessing:
https://www.kwsx.com/2024/07/04/county-officials join-community-in-waiakahi%CA%BBula-beach park-blessing/)
2. (Summary ofpast cultural erasure attempts of Waiakahi'ula:https://www.youtube.com/watch?vV4kgOHsKOHY)
Me ke aloha,
Bryce L. Knape, TSgt (Ret)
United States Air Force
Co-Owner, Meme's Treasures
Pa� e 2 ()f.2
Karen Cain
15-690 Kahakai Blvd
lop=
1/25/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou require further
i
ormation or ersonal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha,
Karen Cain
",Ty Op
Uraivc���i ry�l HAwti+rs L°i.�, Office of the Vice Chancellor for Academic Affairs
Rkwm'i
COMMUNITY" COLLEGE
Kimberley P. Collins
Vice Chancellor of Academic Affairs
Hawaii Community College
1175 Manono St
Hilo, HI 96720
January 22, 2025
PONC Commission
Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
25 Aupuni Street, Suite 1101
Hilo, Hawaii 96720
ponctestimonyghawaiicountygov
Dear Members of the PONC Commission,
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the properties located at TMK 1-
5-063:42 and TMK 1-5-063:43 by the Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC). As a community member deeply invested in the cultural and
historical preservation of our lands, I believe it is imperative that these properties are acquired
and protected to ensure the continued stewardship of the significant wahi pana(cultural sites)
located in the Waiakahi`ula village area.
As a member of the University of Hawaii system and the Hawaii Community College
administration, I am committed to our strategic plan. Our first commitment is Ka`ika`i Kuleana
Fulfill kuleana to Native Hawaiians and Hawai`i Island.
The sites on these parcels, including a burial site of a high-ranking individual, are invaluable to
the history and heritage of our community. They are legally protected but remain vulnerable to
destruction and development, as evidenced by the recent destruction of a portion of the ancient
wall by the landowner of TMK 1-5-063:043. Any development poses an imminent threat to these
historically significant sites, and it is crucial that action is taken to preserve them.
The PONC program provides the necessary protection and stewardship for such lands, ensuring
that culturally significant sites like these are safeguarded for future generations. The acquisition
of these parcels will help to preserve the integrity of the larger Waiakahi`ula village complex,
which extends into the county park, and will prevent further damage or destruction from private
development.
1175 Manono Street
Hilo,Hawai'i 96720-5096
Telephone:(808)934-2512
www.hawcc,hawaii.edu
An Equal Opportunity/Affinuative Action Institution
I urge the Commission to act swiftly in acquiring these properties, as this issue is time-sensitive.
It is our collective responsibility to ensure the preservation of these important cultural and
historical sites.
Please consider this letter as my formal support for the acquisition of TMK 1-5-063:42 and TMK
1-5-063:43 under the PONC program. I am hopeful that the Commission will take the necessary
steps to protect these important sites and honor the wishes of our community.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter. Should you require any further
information or clarification,please feel free to contact me.
Mahalo,
Kvo.� (O—Ut ✓'z
Kimberley P. Collins
Vice Chancellor of Academic Affairs
Hawaii Community College
i
ssa A real Kay
M&
January 22, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Aryssa Apreal Oliveros Kay
J f;l
i
ri ah Brown
om
O1/22/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Azariyah Brown
Elizabeth Motoki 1/23/25
1190
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK
3-1-5-063.42 and TMK 3-1-5-063.43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and
Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC) program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future
generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent
destruction of an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The
acquisition of these properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper
stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's
unique cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites,
the acquisition would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a
deeper connection to the history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063.42 and TMK
3-1-5-063.43 to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are
preserved and cared for in perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital
pieces of our shared heritage that hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii
home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and consideration of this critical matter. Should you require
further information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at
or
Me ke,aloha,
Elizabeth Motoki
i
ol n Rose Koto Fukushima
January 22, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Carolyn Rose Koto Fukushima
Camila Lu uin-Heid
22 January, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Camila Luquin-Heid
Cassel n-Mae Acosta
January 22, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Casselyn-Mae Acosta
<,'( d (,, ,j
a-�
imend Morante-Rodrigues
O1/22/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Dymend Morante-Rodrigues
VY�"
i
Caleb Bartolome Morales
O1/22/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Elijah C.B. Morales
Elaine N u en
O1/22/25
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Elaine Nguyen
Maluhia Alana Kaiwi
January 23, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Maluhia Alana Kaiwi
Ghency Vine Pasion
January 22, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Ghency Vine Pasion
�I
f
Ha den Quihano
22 January, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Hayden Quihano
cl,
Jhe den Haili
O1/22/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Jheyden Haili
Krizza Venice Marcelo
January 22, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Krizza Venice Marcelo
u�
1/24/25,9:52AM Gmail-(no subject)
m, No`eau Woo-O'Brien
(no subject)
Ryl AlvareMoo
Thu, Jan 23, 2025 at 8:11 PM
To: No`eauWnen
01/23/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
(PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-
1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
(PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical,
cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future
generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to sacred and
legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is imperative that these sites are
safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of an ancient wall by the current landowner's
unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper
stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique cultural and
natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition would also foster
opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 to prevent
further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in perpetuity. These lands
are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who
call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further information
or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at
Me ke aloha,
Kailiena Panaewa
Kailiena Panaewa
https://mail.google.con/mail/u/O/?ik=0917318b8f&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f.1822109568028845485&simpl=msg-f:1822109568028845485 1/1
1/24/25,9:52AM Gmail-(no subject)
m, No`eau Woo-O'Brien >
(no subject)
Ryl Alvarez > Thu, Jan 23, 2025 at 8:11 PM
To: No`eau Woo- nen >
01/23/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
(PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-
1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
(PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical,
cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future
generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to sacred and
legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is imperative that these sites are
safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of an ancient wall by the current landowner's
unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper
stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique cultural and
natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition would also foster
opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 to prevent
further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in perpetuity. These lands
are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who
call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further information
or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at
Me ke aloha,
Kailiena Panaewa
Kailiena Panaewa
https://mail.google.con/mail/u/O/?ik=0917318b8f&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f.1822109568028845485&simpl=msg-f:1822109568028845485 1/1
Lehua Norris
January 23, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at [your phone number] or
[your email address].
Me ke aloha,
Lehua Norris
-a- 42.—,
Lehua Norris
January 23, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at [your phone number] or
[your email address].
Me ke aloha,
Lehua Norris
-a- 42.—,
Michelle L. Carrillo
(808)896-4462
January 23, 2025
Aloha County of Hawai'I Public Acces, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC).
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi'ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi'ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further disturbance, such as the recent
destruction of an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition
of these properties would ensure their protection and allow for the proper stewardship under the
County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC programs mission to protect Hawaii's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi'ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further destruction and to ensure that these sacred lands are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity.
Thank you for your attention and consideration of this important matter. If you have any
questions for me, please contact me at or
Best,
Michelle Carrillo
Meidor Hu
1/22/25
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou require further
i
ormation or ersonal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha,
Meidor Hu
Michael W K ser Jr
January 22nd 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou re uire further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at
Me ke aloha,
Michael W Kyser Jr
Hope Pualani McKeen
MM
01/23/2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. These sites
must be safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of an ancient wall by the
current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these properties would ensure
their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home. No`eau and Leah have proven their
loyalty to malama in this area so that we preserve our spaces for generations to come. As a
Kumu Kula (classroom teacher) their work is so valuable to the learning of my students and
building connection to place.
Mahalo nui, thank you for your attention and consideration of this critical matter. Should you
require further information or personal testimony, please contact me at� or
Na`u n6,
Hope Pualani McKeen
i
Hale ah Mari Ganot
January 22, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Ros Haleyah Mari Ganot
[Your Full Name] Rylee-Anne Andres Dalmacio
[City, State, ZIP Code]
[Email Address]
[Date] January 2W
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC) program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
[Your Full Name] Rylee-Anne Andres Dalmacio
[Signature] /
1/24/25,9:43 AM Gmail-Letter of support
m, No`eau Woo-O'Brien >
Letter of support
Sue Alana > Thu, Jan 23, 2025 at 6:06 PM
To:
Sue M.Alana
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
(PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-
1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
(PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical,
cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future
generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to sacred and
legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is imperative that these sites are
safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of an ancient wall by the current landowner's
unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper
stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique cultural and
natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition would also foster
opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 to prevent
further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in perpetuity. These lands
are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who
call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further information
or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at [your phone number] or [your email address].
Me ke aloha,
Sue M. Alana
https://mail.google.con/mail/u/O/?ik=0917318b8f&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f.1822101702509014561&simpl=msg-f:1822101702509014561 1/1
Theresa K. Donham
Historic Preservation Consultant
January 23,2025
County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
25 Aupuni Street, Suite 1101
Hilo,HI 96720
Subject TMK Parcels 3-1-5-063:42 and 43,Waiakahi`ula Ahupua`a,Puna District,Hawaii
Aloha PONC Commissioners. I am writing to ask that you please acquire the subject parcels,
located along Papio Street adjacent to Waiakahi`ula County Park.Two significant historic
properties were identified on these parcels in 1973(Ewart&Luscomb 1974),and later
assigned S1HP site numbers 50-10-45-19013 and-19014. One of the identified historic
properties(19014)was verified to contain a human burial in 1998 (Rechtmen and Henry 1998),
and a Burial Treatment Plan was prepared for the site. Site 19014 is located within both of the
subject parcels, and is also within the County-owned easement for Papio Street.This has
created a situation whereby no individual owner has full responsibility for care and
maintenance of the burial site.The owner of parcel 43 has violated the terms of the Burial
Treatment Plan for Site 19014 during ground clearing, and also impacted features within SIHP
Site 19013,which consists of numerous agricultural and habitation features. Clearly,any
development of either parcel will result in the further destruction of Site 19013 as well as
cause indirect impacts to Site 19014.These sites are among the few remaining cultural traces
of Waiakahi`ula Village,a once thriving Hawaiian community; and they have inspired the local
community members to take action for continued preservation.
The Friends of Waiakahi`ula Park have been involved in the preservation of these sites, as well
as the sites within the park, and will continue to provide stewardship care of these parcels.If
these lots could remain open,it would provide a meaningful addition to the open space in the
relatively dense subdivision,and more importantly, ensure the continued preservation of the
historic properties that are integral to the history and cultural value of Waiakahi`ula.
Mahalo for your consideration of this acquisition.It will only become more important as time
passes and this area is further developed.If you would like more details on the information
shared herein,please contact me at the above email address.
Me ke loha,
Theresa K.Donham
Debra A. Preston
January 22,2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
1 am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission(PONC) program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex,these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual_ It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites,the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories,mana,and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or at
Me ke aloha,
Debra Ann Preston
ia. ".7
January 20, 2025,
Dear Members of the Hawaii County Council and the Public Access, Open Space, and Natural
Resource Preservation Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of two properties located just
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Park. Preserving these parcels is of critical importance to maintaining the
integrity of the historical and cultural sites that form part of the larger Waiakahi`ula village
complex.
The Waiakahi`ula area holds profound cultural and historical significance, serving as a tangible
connection to the rich heritage of Hawaii. The properties in question are home to features and
landmarks that embody the spirit and traditions of the community, including archaeological sites,
cultural landscapes, and remnants of structures that reflect the daily lives and practices of those
who lived in the area centuries ago. By protecting these lands, we can ensure that future
generations have the opportunity to learn from and appreciate this unique cultural legacy.
Acquiring these properties aligns with the mission of PONC to safeguard spaces of historical,
cultural, and environmental value. It also supports the County's commitment to preserving open
spaces and protecting sites of cultural importance from potential threats of development or
neglect. By incorporating these lands into the public trust, we can provide greater opportunities
for education, cultural practices, and respectful stewardship.
Community members and cultural practitioners have long recognized the importance of these
properties in preserving the broader Waiakahi`ula village complex. Their acquisition would not
only honor the ancestral connections to the land but also ensure that these sacred and
historically significant sites remain accessible and intact for generations to come.
I urge the County and PONC to prioritize the acquisition of these properties and to take the
necessary steps to integrate them into the broader preservation efforts for Waiakahi`ula. By
doing so, you will demonstrate a profound commitment to honoring Hawaii's cultural heritage
and ensuring that its stories and traditions are preserved for all.
Thank you for your consideration of this important matter. I am confident that, with your
leadership, we can secure the future of these invaluable lands and their contributions to our
shared history.
Mahalo nui Ioa for your dedication and service to our community.
Sincerely,
Iwalani Harris
Ann Kobsa
January25, 2025
Aloha PONC Commissioners,
I am writing to urge expedited PONC acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43.These
parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and
ecological significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future
generations.They are currently threatened with development!
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to sacred
and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is imperative that
these sites are safeguarded against further harm, following the recent destruction of an ancient
wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities.The acquisition of these properties would
ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique cultural
and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites,the acquisition would
also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the history
of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 to
prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity.These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at
Me ke aloha,
Ann Kobsa
1/24/25,12:27 PM Gmail-Waiakahi'ula-Letter of Support
m, No`eau Woo-O'Brien >
Waiakahi'ula - Letter of Support
Makamaii A. > Fri, Jan 24, 2025 at 12:00 PM
To:
Andielyn Makamae Kapule
lauary 5
Aloha to the County of Hawai'i Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC) program.
These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi'ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance
and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi'ula village complex, these lands are home to sacred and legally protected
sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further
harm, such as the recent destruction of an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition
of these properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique cultural and natural
resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition would also foster opportunities for education,
cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the history of Waiakahi'ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 to prevent further
desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in perpetuity. These lands are not just
spaces;they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further information or personal
testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha,
Andielyn "Makamae" Kapule
r ..
�d
https://mail.google.con/mail/u/O/?ik=0917318b8f&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f.1822169399083618835&simpl=msg-f:1822169399083618835 1/1
Barbara G. Garcia
1-26-2025
Aloha to the County of Hawai'i Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC) program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi'ula Beach
Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi'ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction
of an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai'i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the
acquisition would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper
connection to the history of Waiakahi'ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for
in perpetuity.These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that
hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawai'i home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should you require further
information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha,
Barbara G. Garcia
Chiemi Sasaki
January 23rd, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42
and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter. Should ou require further
i
ormation or ersonal testimony, please feel free to contact me at or
Me ke aloha,
Chiemi Sasaki
1/24/25,9:46 AM Gmail-URGENT:Waiakahi`ula PONC application-TESTIMONY NEEDED!
m, i Leah Gouker >
URGENT: Waiakahi`ula PONC application- TESTIMONY NEEDED!
Cory Tue, Jan 21, 2025 at 11:23 AM
To: Lea ou cer >
Cc: No'eau Woo- nen
Mahalo you guys for doing this!
To whom it may concern,
I, Cory Edging, support the purchase of TMK 1-5-063:043 and TMK 1-5-063:042 by Public Access, Open Space, and
Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC). Too many historic cultural sites have been, disrespected, destroyed,
built on, demolished, never to be seen again. Much of this has unfortunately already happened in Waiakahi'ula, but that
doesn't mean it is ok for it to continue. Any cultural site of significance that still exists today should be preserved and
protected.This is a perfect chance for the county of Hawaii to do just that. Mahalo for your consideration.
Aloha
Cory Edging
[Quoted text hidden]
https://mail.google.con/mail/u/O/?ik=993269c82f&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f.1821895195303968951&simpl=msg-f:1821895195303968951 1/1
Lu Ann Iwalani O'Brien
IIFr
January 24, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and
TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, locatedin the mauka of Waiakahi`ula
Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be
preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. These sites
must be safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of an ancient wall by the
current landowner's unauthorized activities. Acquiring these properties would ensure their
protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui, thank you for your attention and consideration of this critical matter. Should you
re uire further information or personal testimony, please contact me at or at
Me ke aloha,
Lu Ann Iwalani O'Brien
Ifelifieffil Jerelniah
,W nualry'22" 2WS
Molia to fl',te CluMy of Hawai'i 1"uh1u;Aoxvss, Spacc., wind,Nattiral Rv'scnlrva Pre-scl vwion
(K),W),
I mu W ng W cspr(, o; my wong support P the acqWsakm ordw pmrds TMK T 046142
and TMK, 3-1-5-lain 3A,3 un!der 1he County"s PubHe Awn, (Van Spcq and Nawml Rvwamt,,�
Proservaikin C(,,�uunrmion (F10NC,) prog'ratrt. 1"hese pat-ccls, localed wwlhctnattka of
MUSK Rawh flaxk,arc of Worical, cuhuml,and ecological QUAcence wnd
41eserve w be J"arv's"'Crved Whe bemalli t,)4 ifte co m m u rs i tna�w and ru t ture, gwnv ral i o r1s,
As pan orMe MricAly signikent 1A1'kx4d�"Uhi"(t'h1 VAlq6'(":''C"0MPjCx" these to
Sacred ar0 1C9td1',y PmMewd shes, includbl;the buria,fl ofa, 6,0vWtud, It is
Spen6ve tha"hese wakes are safo.'�gtt,�,,uded against as,the recent desoructk',-aw,
(J'r an 4,',,o't6cn( waIJ by Ow cturtrent laada%vef s Tura aultiorize(I a6vilics, The acxjuirrifjon of these
pro[wwfies would arid aHow,for
jQdwwc,
Prvserylnj',,�thcu lands ahgas,w4th (ho K)NC pirograt"n's ni,Jssion to pr(")tect' 1"I"awaiTs uniqw
cukuml and nahmal resouric-,es, Bqmmd he physmal pniection WWWant she% the aujukWon
woWd sho Amur opponunkies CUHUwl pralkes,an(J a to dw,
I WIC Me COMMismon 10 prwritivc" 11'te' of"I"NIK 3-1 5-10,634,2 artdT'MK 3-l-5-0(,5343
to prevent Rulher desecrnfim and to ensure that these mn,,j,Jfi ,,,rxana wre,prcscrvcd atid cared tbr in
perpetuay 'rhese lands are ootj1051 aJraaw a,an the'y Air vital pie'zes ofowit,shwre(:f he6vq,,'i,,e (hat ttold
*wNt nMnK and lwrr nrraw f'or a'k who'w"'M Ha"wo'j"i how,
Kihl 'lwn rlui fbryotor atw'ntion and fivir r,,',w,Dsidoring Ohs WWI maUer. Mould ou re We
rurtbcr, inflorrittvionar personal toohmaq.phmse'k,0 fi- e lo,conitio rille,as t"HI
Me ke Whil,
1
/
//
/
/
/00
//
/
// r/
r
/
r
,rr rr,r rr i r _� rrrr r
� r
//
/
r
/
/
rr /
/rrrr /
, r.
/
/ o
/
i
i
/ r
/
r
r ,
r /
f / /
/
/
/
//
/
/
///
i
/
/
r/
r/
/
1 /
/
/
/
r /
/
r i ,rrr„
/ / /
/ r
I
I /
/1 � o
/
I I �
I
I �
/
�,�o;oiol IIIIIIIIIII���, ,
i
f
I
I
I
/
, � II
I
I I I�
Y Ililll �li i f r
,
,,
/
I /
/
r
i
)
l
Y
/ r
I
i
it l /
I
1
/
/
/
,
/
i I
j
I
/
I
1
I
/
r
r
/
//
1/24/25,10:29 AM Gmail-Testimony-PONC Application for Waiakahi'ula
m, Leah Gouker< >
Testimony - PONC Application for Waiakahi'ula
1 message
Wed, Jan 22, 2025 at 5:16 PM
o: ea ou er
Ku'ulei Kealoha Cooper. Trustee
James & Miulan P.Y. Kealoha Estate
January 21, 2025
Aloha County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
(PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-
1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission
(PONC)program. These parcels, located mauka of Waiakahi'ula Beach Park, are of immense historical,
cultural, and ecological significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future
generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi'ula village complex, these lands are home to sacred and
legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is imperative that these sites are
safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of an ancient wall by the current landowner's
unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper
stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique cultural and
natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition would also foster
opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the history of Waiakahi'ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 to prevent
further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in perpetuity. These lands
are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who
call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for your kind consideration. Should you require further information or
have any questions, feel free to contact me.
Warmest aloha,
Ku'ulei Kealoha Cooper
Mffllw���
https://mail.google.con/mail/u/O/?ik=993269c82f&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f.1 82200793 93 8423 1725&simpl=msg-f:1822007939384231725 1/2
1/24/25,10:29 AM Gmail-Testimony-PONC Application for Waiakahi'ula
https://mail.google.con/mail/u/0/?ik=993269c82f&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f.1 82200793 93 8423 1725&simpl=msg-f:1822007939384231725 2/2
Elizabeth Motoki 1/23/25
1190
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource
Preservation Commission (PONC),
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the parcels TMK
3-1-5-063.42 and TMK 3-1-5-063.43 under the County's Public Access, Open Space, and
Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC) program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future
generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent
destruction of an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The
acquisition of these properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper
stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's
unique cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites,
the acquisition would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a
deeper connection to the history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063.42 and TMK
3-1-5-063.43 to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are
preserved and cared for in perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital
pieces of our shared heritage that hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii
home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and consideration of this critical matter. Should you require
further information or personal testimony, please feel free to contact me at
or
Me ke,aloha,
Elizabeth Motoki
Ghency Vine Pasion
January 22, 2025
Aloha to the County of Hawaii Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Commission (PONC),
I am a student at Pahoa High School writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of
the parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's Public Access, Open
Space, and Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC)program. These parcels, located
mauka of Waiakahi`ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and ecological
significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of the community and future generations.
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi`ula village complex, these lands are home to
sacred and legally protected sites, including the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is
imperative that these sites are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction of
an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities. The acquisition of these
properties would ensure their protection and allow for proper stewardship under the County's
guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to protect Hawai`i's unique
cultural and natural resources. Beyond the physical protection of significant sites, the acquisition
would also foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper connection to the
history of Waiakahi`ula.
I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43
to prevent further desecration and to ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in
perpetuity. These lands are not just spaces; they are vital pieces of our shared heritage that hold
stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawaii home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Me ke aloha,
Ghency Vine Pasion
�I
f
II 1116 � "" IIIIIIIV�
42h. a
f'
���� IIIIIIU,
Executive Board SUBJECT: SUPPORT
Lisa Lehua Kaulukukui Aloha to the County of Hawai'i Public Access, Open Space, and
President Natural Resource Preservation Commission (PONC),
James Kimo Sanborn
I am writing to express my strong support for the acquisition of the
Vice President parcels TMK 3-1-5-063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 under the County's
Clarence Kalimahana Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resource Preservation
Young Commission (PONC) program. These parcels, located mauka of
Secretary Waiakahi'ula Beach Park, are of immense historical, cultural, and
Kelli Bond ecological significance and deserve to be preserved for the benefit of
the community and future generations.
Interim Treasurer
As part of the historically significant Waiakahi'ula village complex,
Directors these lands are home to sacred and legally protected sites, including
Erin Henderson-Lacerdo the burial of a high-ranking individual. It is imperative that these sites
are safeguarded against further harm, such as the recent destruction
James Kaulukukui,Jr. of an ancient wall by the current landowner's unauthorized activities.
Stephanie McVitty The acquisition of these properties would ensure their protection and
Michelle Keli'ipio-Lee allow for proper stewardship under the County's guidance.
Preserving these lands aligns with the PONC program's mission to
Kupuna Advisors protect HawaiTs unique cultural and natural resources. Beyond the
Lilinoe Keli'ipio Young physical protection of significant sites,the acquisition would also
foster opportunities for education, cultural practices, and a deeper
M. Kau'i Keli'ipio connection to the history of Waiakahi'ula.
Michael Warsh
Anthony Keli'ipio I urge the Commission to prioritize the acquisition of TMK 3-1-5-
Sue Wilcox Keli'ipio 063:42 and TMK 3-1-5-063:43 to prevent further desecration and to
ensure that these wahi pana are preserved and cared for in perpetuity.
These lands are not just spaces;they are vital pieces of our shared
heritage that hold stories, mana, and lessons for all who call Hawai'i
home.
Mahalo nui for your attention and for considering this critical matter.
Should you require further information or personal testimony, please
feel free to contact me at kananilehua@kuamoofoundation.org
Me ke aloha,
Lehua Kaulukukui,
President