HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-01-05 Exhibit 05_Windward Planning Commission October 3, 2024 Minutes INL W; L I'.L; NF\1 ct C: i!V1 iSSii.i
\.111.I«�°1�i1:
OCTc'r F1 � 2C124
r.ri'r1, rilie . I1 1'•i 6: 16 ..I1'1 �' '1 r :ra rr f� i1�ra f•�1i1:I 11
1 ii
� 1 r• 1 1 1 r 1 1'��.�i•ti 0 �r��
I
1 m 1•:7, �� i 1.i i',?;; �.:(f;.: ,l L• ;. �iti7i raj 42r.
NY 1••° , •
r Ir y� y1 I 1 _'.y`tr1Yi r).; L�,L. .1'' ! 1�'LI' •.I1 �� i 1�•L}i }�t�r� i 1; L'L. r rl L .I I�L L I ''.i iI l L. � ,r�i:1 i I��{ ��L�Ir?t� Sf 2. 4�1 L, •g 1 s
'i':.�1�In,,I:,l '�:oi ,�L•.�5. ��� IF,�• �•�1 I•I�� 1I 1•1:01 I111_..,}1' 1%4%11 e :1II'!.111,i'.'',','I'I• I rL rI••,If I:1,I',If1"JJ{•','.1';r.1Iir•
r �,{�.j . r�� n 'y-e�ti i ,.:1 1 �IF� T �m 1 r T1i 1 �1 i e� 1 !, y� r,� %.���1�:, �f i�. 1 ti .gar?,:C
.?L.1 ^".tilti I L 2 I I�®�I L �°L 1 L•' "e1 L L 1:"� III ?'?1 ?_ . �� L�1 1 1 � Lil ."1 1 1 1
_ ti 12:i)i i.i.11"i. C'btiilrm'i1] L'L'rL = L]Jl fI:'icI,. I r..x ss to ' •tt IOC arrl%%A
I� a 17.—eI1[.' minutes.
T � -i.ud',' .:tt d I']'i u i:J r,C111] 7 5 S1c'n r.:cor.v,:mcx.1 rc L1 Ear or. on. Tllurs . '.," C'::_.1;' 'r
1 1
il'.y a 111 III :I I I I I 1[ ' L°I I 1 I,LI II E)cI•.. 25
� �ti � � � 1 1 1 ' � �•�•1 "i Y ������� 1 1 �
r`rrl �I I r� rl l I. 1 1 I 1 I'°�.��� 111 1 I I III I I�i` �k°r 1 I'�;�I11 �,.� 1
I. .i 1r,I I •1 Ids II YiNII:I,.s 1!I I f 111, I I 1 11® ; r)rr.I It: I I I"'i r: 1)e I i 1..ti I. ;I
LJI 1. ���ti..1 L'L]11:= •; +,L_ n•riiL'1a"A.LL1.I
(' ,l 1:5.iO)' ER 4.Ti T AND D i: '.:�_!' r-r. : L'11.�1�ICI F'L'ITII.
AI.�.��a PR I I NI I : 1..21 1].:,_;1rL 171I I pu I a. 1°I I 1
P1 IrIrIrTI!J I ��ti�11'1171L:1"II I L'II�L�I �� a:rl'° �'I'a'•11111°III � �I I'i'3'�'I'�i mid P1HII!I•III"'
L)epartIr etlt staff'.
Two L"1C]I]Lier4 of t c .0 b] 'rr wt 111 t111.1 �11�JL 14't
A cition,rai lykis TTi vi:0 I I °111 ILO IJ'1l.% I I•y'4'I.:I I! I(I ',I1•.:I! II(,I III IT I,1Ij a I IL'
0111 DI7. I LI TJ c E4" :Staff f f'L ftt L u11I 'tj L f5 ti.L=n t'I I L,L I. rh :t}]•ti t�11;]ll]= 1 �J tip•L[1
I'.'ILI 1'.�ri 17 e•e iF L I�I�J{�;: :he I•'2.IIiis Iii•'I:fin. 21 '0:()II 17L1 i_LI I :0I I ]I.III
I ,:r" 1 I 1 IT°;®.,•' I r� I; I� ; '�I�..:I11 r,J
1
C:i I]1°11..L1 r:cLy 111 :3 LIO'?r Ci1 t111,1 (_05 11=1!.LUIlt r: t rti',]L' • ai:] �11 1�'.� ]lltil' .L L .1
t=tL=e Illeet1 ri L. "-SEE ���• ti ' fit" � ��:° �' :t� �I1 I �I i:Ln Dennis s LI JI
thk Lr 1 L,°I1Ti 11 I 1 IrI L'r ic: 4:A1111 11•ITI 1` I WI Iti'I, I�'kti L.'I I11 I�I I.�`Ii:I I b., 1 rl L;I LJ'I I ILs. ti,.T I I I!.TI 11111 11 II
;: s®1L.I1 IL1}• 1•t '7tt d to t a'.= rippiJ(:'7J I I U ]ll rti"til 1 t'1).Ci.1 70(i;iv EKCli. Er: ti••�= ��.!�'
I I 1 1n I.11'I L L I Ii i �_ I':t !! ti I,:iI I s y. 1 h���� 1�rc•°'' ',i, I,.•,11..\' :I:�11)
"
r° I Ail Iv?i::11-k,If II
LL
EXHIBIT 5
it I E
w
.�. •!o 3 I .. L 11= it' 11'111 I L 11.-1 :i11t±7
IL1rl 111 '1'11771'III S.;•II riIEt I ill' . I iI'=
)11,11.S7.4 1.1.1
FRoill I'III': ICI;Il l a l : (1 Ai :F.N I PA I'll:, t s
▪ L '-' item with I I'1 e I I1 pi
_ I�]lrl ti��T�'�'• ClI 1Tl"I'1'11! I.111S .111 }�fl III. 14' �11'Iti�:�t LI��". Itn ,•�,:���1.°'ti'lll:_ �III� I:: ��rL'IIL:°.'� rl�llllll�
C oii ]]1]_ ion U c: 1-5 regarding L!L1rdi 1 ii coorLllt;. L'J. . t I ,;.'1'ti' L -11. °1'7iL'I cc' :Teal till t 3 l]1l'�ti
, .� . tip �, �� .. � . •. q ,
'ii I;Iir ��•FIeII �� ;]i ii I I� ���:�._ IIL '� ilern ,'r�; LAI ed I1.1 ;I LLiI �'�: �. r r�ti '� ' ���' ;:'I��'�,�, .'I,'1r,''
L L
i
'I'IIiI' V.• :Lem
AI1%11N1S'I'R:' 1 I" E .1'1. 'I •1 ER.S ; ' FE 3'1 1Fr® :1
anag C11-.i'.:Z •I[a :ind L3 7
II. LI
ti � �17LL ��lI�'1i1117,� III I�L��I�:I�I]rLIII 1��I��I�1 :I��.I I�I.ti!�II:II'� I��i�,til'll����•11��'� i11 IW i�J�I•II1�1_
Ihe Itilrr lti � I� ,.L'�� lir � 11
'I� r' °,: � o.��, 1I I� �°�• 1 � ti5 1 I�1� I° �'� $r-• 1 �1'�I•� � t
I I h :Lew, m�.w ..�_ rJ 11° II III' 1: 11 m_1� ��. II: 11=� �111•.II_�I�
T.a.e Office of L'I aI I I I I7 a!1'I .ill t l I= b e L ��- I i::ipn1�17 C (.01.1 S Li) :.ta f Delta N]ender_
tiI FI � � '1 'r 1 .ti _, :t i 1 ��°I � S1 I%d I i rl -•� ..I::�.„� . .
1/ :'j I:123.L i.L'L!.51.211:I 1 1;' thic L= CBI L.LI TL.'• s. 1 tL=°°L
'1 i r-r5 I I i I I 1 I i l 11'1 .lie e.)1''S I I'.'1•i • 'III ' �1��'t•�i. '1 :I't• ,1� !�. �. �' i'. �I�.�'
Ifs 5 _ r r
i. L II1F w ���'�.�L:�14'��,I��r r �1'{'.�.y�'.�r�l.l �r: i yn ���r� j — -'i.;i rii L�r� I L:� .'''L'��.lr�w''1� �11 rr r°. ti ti•L �:� ���:
''°�_'•'�1 I °_r ��: �'y�r.�; y ����iu��L'��� ���r;I''L�L� 'L' ��! i� �'� ' ''j I'2 1 1
�� ..1 �—, �
Ptat1rjitli I);p..]11:n YILiff_ Roy L! l'F tit I:' ' 4.LltatL.°n On C urJI..i]atL' ;'211?i.''
i.()F.°Iu'3 Ixf-LN TA' "IT' (SEE •.\ aJ1r 2:m 2:•/ i i 1•L' 1.. I'.i�° '� ri
��•.�rxreo 1 .I.P ���°?'� 1 r:r' °I�•°. ▪i raa'r 'i ri LL'.°•• I� r�i, ® n' r��� �y5'r�i{'.�ti I I, . 1.11'1.;
)c,t w1'tnile '1e, Th.: floor o ...vas t.:ii_i 1. ij:°•1nia.I the C.:2111]II.::iOTJ to z.s.k �]LI•ti l � tti= -.]l�'
1-'1.1r:riil'I LI)C] aiiIliCil. �IaI�J
J Ilia Ii eai i ri i. !tern ended. RL 10:53 a.m.
Chaim:An Lin "_ '_'=4 fit 1 I:f ,' _L'=;. rind -]1t nl't tLT1 1 1_r 1
T,..l 7-STI.M r�.• �▪ �,�
NEW'BUSINESS
APPLICANT: I A«1I .' 117.i I.1. - {PI -s.f1 J •L—'124— I O(I p)
I a-.I I I .fo a Spee i iI l '1:311'a eLTi e]7t Area I® 5e re l';1 I-C' ti® =e a su bd I', I-10TI f'or,
li IwlIre Ls ri . 7 a.c.'e parcel in
°:� •1 °:� 'r I Ail 11n ::11••Ii:.Ir 11
�'1_ 1'I.tr 1. 21'12- Kr IILJt°
the Spec la! rea he silk i =pL''p=^b. 17. I.. ate. on. the de o1:.
•°::11.1 rl.1- 114:Ih L1 ��L.1{1!I_ �I� �,11:_. 11T!�1 14`I -I. 0 I•'' I i'I 71"11 1 4 11! `1'ti'' ' I I ti•i 11 -17
I▪ ,.=J]111-1 ak.. otii Horn c`;tc i1J s. Kair u. P i LLL1_ �I���.tii..i-ia T".• . (;)
1-1-'11:...;:1}1ti
1.41 kern I I 1 '):''
IT1 a ri i I:er: i i die 3.ucl i erlc ;' ,< ��'��''' ',�'r : •_ fir]:1•��1 ,.�1� ; ,�,
1—° y 1 1 1 I '' ti 1 11. ' '•tir ' 1 !, .'� •,' 1 �' r�.• 1 1•J .d r�1 ?.',.i. �' I� I 11° �•.1�,.�1 �.� ��•I�'•;. I I�. ��I � 111� �: I�tiI 1LL t I ;.� a �. . 1 � �1 .�� 7W•}1 _ ;,r y� � ;`4 ti
�I1 e..r1 opened. r. I I. 'c'the to ask ' uesr1 o1 ti i d i e I I a i n i roa L1e n a tr ent
7.1.11.) 1•(;11.i
..\pp lltah c L(ep i e e I7 ca.i,e L5ai' i I .\r'3i._ Land I..5e Nanning 'ULL!ll.l='1L_t i.1 I'Iy:} '��"i tl I `.pp'..i cant
� " 5 '� 11'�'�L'1 I I I�I' I r! I'�'�▪� ' �:�I I Is:���1!� 1'�I�� 1 I"I
▪ ;ISLE 1.11;56/
L. V11 11 14,1 I',I t1LItil!- 'Try!'r i I I Lid 1 �I rl';eti'T!ti. III—11•;'; a1•I11
I_ ▪ (SEE. � t �,r•'� '.� �: {1 ,•. ▪ ,,
2 M iirk 1 • i r z 'a1�.' Mr ;r'��,�`-.'a'��� �� �'.® I.1..�i�'' 2.�1: 0J1/
4. I. _I_ H F }.- .) .11P 3.
L:;;',1'id Skill.i r1 ;� ▪ f •'. 7•' ,i - r 2.. :�...
I _ 1L_tii = 1eGLiire' '�'�' i. '.� '� �' .Z,ti •'�' �• 1� 1 . r��.r.;r;';1
- - •J
I-'i:i 11 Ili ly idualk provided 7.e 711.1- I1v I1Zoom
1 Kell i 111 I� 171�11 11 ;'1 �'r '�� '� '. '�'. �'�'1• �. .�'1��� �. �':;' �i
I ® I r� •
L:_ LA i L Ll. Ken]]�h.p. f i�I` 'ti :in!. .L.L J� 'ti _ 21�1E1 —_ .
1 1 ti 1 • � � 1 L• _ .�Im 1���'���ti �1 ,
1
L,.eui aI aha T.'11F.1 T.111•T' f:9. , 7
1
['IL. I 11 E t1 ti: ':, r!1 i 1 I 1 :I:1[11 E!:•'rM1. I ur I'Itir hied II'. ,lie
.•;� 1111!�I! !i c..I 1 i i k' {1 14' I I 114'I' ;' ?": �' ,' :i ?�.°1•��':. ' :�• ,}_,:�•i. ��}�" 1 {1 I k•I' .'i'!'�1 I I•�1°I' .��tir1 �y
::till=ll tt t 1� Ill �tlfl ti hfti��-I�]Il��� L� h '1�•1� iflI V :.. meet'.i with the rEL[ifi.L:: ,•11 the
I;nit li ciII!IIr': 11 1';,LLr',] 'r ;1i e;i�, tik here !fie!i callf�� .':r;LIi 1u IllIL =-...'r!�W11rW L 7ti1 reilsL+r,:• �IC17°
L J �
1 i fir, L� � ��„:[1 a r..•'ti' w 1. ,
,r�•:_L'I!� I' �r1 i "I�I F.' ti I'1'I •;:L I'i 71 I I':•;:I'I•.. '�k I I I rl rl L'I I I�I I I�:TI:• titi'r1 L' I„�,I I•I I"I! 11:i I 1 rl
ti " 1 .ti 1 �'1 1 1 ti ti t` 1 ti ti.. ti ur
y°rr�7r t'i LtT°]ll 111 .. t�t'J.]��" •ti I i t4e. fLi��:LJ L L'lIT11C r�,:'r1 s ;_muoy�L1)L�•4 �7f1ti 4 ��1 ti:].1 �•= ='�• ci
ti
i '. I' I r; I�I �1 I�:1 I �:•� I I r�.��I' dip... i 1: hear! I I r"I �71. I I"`�11:� rr',;:'rr',erl I ;uA 17 Li l'I I e:•i"Lt 211
IkI �I I L' ��" �1°y•� !''R1 14! I!I I'� 1�.��}11�I '�'�111'1-�I �I ti I;titi• I,�'�1!!1 I I i 1°�11 11,1.%
L epa rtii:.L't had fai led rti ec I1[ac t I1 e r a7. have, ail cl l i a took l_I fe :iori 7.i I. i l i rr for til ai
' .
r 1 ti � 1 1•' 11 1 r' ti , 1".3 1 1
▪ I I'e�1�)1 .eI'IL �. �1�I � �1�1'�L 11� �� _II�� i�.11�. I!���: I �� I�III� 1�r711' L.�' �17L��L_� ti:5�1 i 1&
C tilt-:1]1hIIILty, c oils]d l'r and wcrk t:,'L`.'ards miiv b kiC C'ep= .b l. to
He a n;ellti c:I'I ed Thar_ for the first r..I11 e_ des1:L to [he e i s ti f1 L i e o ni Lr1 e.7dati c.i i be
L: I�1•;'� �!�I �� 1�111 4' II 1�IIl4..'.._ oI°II11 I�,1 r, 1rI ilia" I 1.,111 1'c.% 4'1' L' , 171 .,:I':
r
1:I�.
':� '1 ':1°°• 'r I Ail 11n ::11'' i =lr n
�'1_ 1.1.br
Action: (.I`l ii 1 r11_ .Li Dennis L I J7 I11 c:u c ii ed = r'ti 17 CI 11ue t'LLIJ asice:I the iippl 1 r'ai▪t': representative and
;Fie �I'�11"Il i s�Irl' I, :r kI [rr o11.,.' III I rrl k% r I1 •: �� rl I I 1�I a11�4' 1--��I r� rl °'1•;{{ FLib11 t'nI L]' i i, cI^ I :wTI v 1 I I
� tll�l �•ti p os.sib]L. for - t rcq'1.ti S7> b L. mad L. at '_ ' 4'a[l •t thc. Li▪ t)' to Lucat
tip{II'I �� rti7i 7 ' IJI Iii'inky rtiieniE:' i:. as. I'I iF�IL k�'II.Ii;ALL, feel i11 I IJ IJ� I L I IJ+ I1I�
•Ly. 1I N. 1.:I'1!(l1 '1'111 w I.I I 1 :▪ ,"I I L.''r1 I ', '., 11,4. _.: i _ .7
• 7 LI I-r'I''I:lr{ [) I I rI 15. I in I : tieL i I"7 e° rI''1:LI;1I 1 &i i'I I I 11 I Fir ;J I:v I ea rl 1 ▪Cq LLe.3 I,, ti''I
t •crjt[nIILifCIL Dui _, 7° t _ Lilr ' L1ppLh aL1t ,4 ti• ]I1Cnl.IL°°L]cae tip:• t
1} Ilf1 I I1 A� L'l'2 nI11 c11' will.' updates,. an cl 7.I1 ce fi 1 e 131,i i i I1 I r7 u. L5epL,rtIlJ Ilt L 7. ready tra ['I'eSe°I1 C I L
{4�.�„Ilrll'I1L.11 1�a11 .11 11 rr1 I 1' ....rill 11:j 11} I Itit! ylI! kI.411ilkI. 1--IL I
1.111.1.L. Y() �'� r' 1 r_ir '.2"j t , ti 3.1 1...2�r' The f ti'O r op.m.ed f c r d:[ r l ti]1 �i]ll •II�
17 1°�rti71I•'1i i 17 �I 'Kai rill 17 I ieI dial an ;L1'l=II.:!';ti 1L+.;I Ir1ti'211101 '
i A 11.93)
f I I Lr stir 1�l 11 �l i� �I I I�� � I' I i 1 �r 1 �� °T L' �:i k � I ; '1 mr�. 'r: � 'r'' ', ' :", '�▪ m'1• I
) 1''c Cti 1 Zencic, pfti piz i d r'ti II s I'Ier:I1 a E.-.11.11roral ; 17 I l "si 5
1 and, Lee, I '1': i riii LI I co.1 i ] i i i'I e reel ,'), °..1,r 7:°J 15.
°t e Cbai rill aI7 Ii=•trle _Jn1 e n cl Dennis ▪ cm :lie
1 'r 11.,,it 1 11'1: ,L° ("1• 1'' Iti{11'Itiet I''tir hi �1"Lr �I I4I �I'11 : I11'ti 1i1�`' 11� IliL
� �• . �• � ��, 1°ti� tip. � � y �-� �°• 4
mo,r1LIT 1 L LI. .'LCL'TJJ'4] by C oimunissioncr L.LI LlrLn Fil 1.111 ' a)t:
ro.I I. c211 Taker! I I I.I 1 fn'.I I i':!''1 L': i!J IJ I L e L I I'r'n A I
4.'c1T r I IA ',' i 111 1 14 ' �1k'L i �11"14'I L' 11,11 :ft5._ r ti' 1 .[J � till l[I 1111 La11 1 L :I.I
1 I e rri J� ,�': �' t• .73E •r° .S1T• SIT) 3
tom• a]I-Ll3 n aeL'_n]4 ICS-Ili:al the kict]c'L" tii .','r -I Li motion. to c oati:I-111 c tlic haring until. LIB Litt;
are 111' v_ a die a11.riIim i▪ Del ▪ en1 arid !„ ue•3tiJ7ll cI iof an. A.VS , eted.
.
L~ti�lll
;' �°.�,' - r_° .�'r��''. ? �:'r° •�.101.0 A :kill (-rill • 1' I till' I I 1 11'�'till I,-til{ I•L l
4'01111L111 tii_ DID LnII Lin'1 0I1 C LIlrlI..d K1C_ !Lin. I Imti Luz. tiiL � Lind I1tiiui I_
ari I I'J7 I°. Il L` 1' 1.1•I I I 1 i, i 1 ,I:i I''1S 1.1 h'1 _: 1.
iris I1eaLiJ Lti iteJii ended a[ L2_22•p.Jii_
r,h��ir11 .L t:ILIIJ]E Lill ;:il d .1. L1114'h i cc s Z.7 l :2 p.m. ;SEE 1'0(.' '(. ?L' .1.1T')i_.1.3 }
3_{I:':''•4T,' aLid die recc,iiveneki al I=:5 p m. ;SFr TA'.1.fri
Z PLIC'ANTS: 'AUI VARIETIES Ili\"I=Sri IE N T- INC. :•FORM-.I LY
t_I4.1t ' Si(��L ' rE 1.1 Ill'_/._ .II24 11011lIl: .9,,.Ni ll:\i) l I"_ r L3-l.E( oo 17l
.'i 1)[ti l Lr;i4°rl k111 1 111T1 I' I TI { 'TI to I til I':I I,14117 a.•' i'. I {11'�FI 171 'll I. I 1 '� 1;!11'rr1'. T 1 I
_�{��171 1 to require L'ti I11 I ettoii I U�e I �.I,�_, �.I= ^.I�eTI I1"�I1t ,=ti� �::I°1'. ICI�`�I' I� �I'.~•�1" II������"�-'��. Hw � I prior
▪ '•k 1 I 1 1 I �����J 1 �h1'I�:J'1 �� 1 i J 1'ti
ti
I� I_1 �'�� �1 ��11�'�° L ��-: II � 1"y� ll �� �1
1:r4J L! L1C ' 1▪L'i. 1 I .1. ' .ll j(:I I rcacm,24.1 I from. _ gi is LI[tit rat-
ZC I? I,r`��1 a)TO -fL1111_,:f I a1-l;I � � � Le'T 11.1 Ili:-2 I'•J i_ i! -]c_t ll r J: V ITV is
1.1 'amI ;LI 15-I r K a•I I,:I1c rsoi i 4'...'crI 0.11. 1I
I a ,1'10 .L I I or
i II�) F •v
.'-F..Ii i
K: cT �ILo Homestead Lots, ;: 1_•_.1
1��• Iti,°�L
1 he 4 cIJ'11LT1I!slu I1 =ti▪o up !his ICeI1 E.': I : I.I'_. ',vi=17 �,I 1 �';':III= '° =17I IZeeI! I'111'1 lc 11ia I1".I:Pr in
JRR. ' :'11 ��� r''. ' :�J�,°�'�� _ti: ••_maa:
I'.°.ti
▪ 1 II
1'l.tr 2'12-F-r°•,IU.
r.a .%.; cl lEif -,271 1▪ 1-▪ :,% i
.f ..:11...1.1_111..1.LJ 114 I,ui _4_
jirestii-ii,i.:1;1 f) .0 1 • 1111.•
IIierE ▪ e LH-net:sou 00111 1%."'..1
.%.1.11.3a; ]-( lyy c (led r.I.:21nmi: oiler
Le L L12 :111 at a fa:iv:A:al.:1e be f:Iva nled. tc.. :lie 41'ouritv 41'01.121Ci.I 0,11 Cli ai :2e ''f
Tom., \10 Pf R17.7. 13-0,11;1.11 7 I F i ii Ii PlEniriiiig
1.::1:t()▪I1 ECC 001111C'Llid 1.2;.(...11 I !!_gif 1•(...'7;.2.9..1 A ro:.[ c:41.1 tukc.D.
2111.1 Larrie.4:1 ;h. Ii I L iii N.! e I e h li;111:1:2 ;Ind I liii no
I !.L.II . d1 ()I' 17.110.:.51 4 1.11' .
L i len! I I 1 2 r) rd.
Air : NDi I'S RA L-I(Eit-20 -1_100111.63
A' pr.:K....hi-. !.... d kin Av;i4.:1..11:imil- LI I - M I I'
11%: R. - ,(11)I) (RS- 5 zmiriL: stn ct for 3.25 .....!crc
laiiL1 7.▪ ,IL1...le.L! I.:112111t2(.1 100 le'ei
Lis ii
I 1.421 11.) 1121 IT IL!e sou Iii huLl,
Hawai 1\11.,- a-J-080:1:117
I lie or.iiir2i Up ill i 15; 1['a 1 ▪ I 3 pull!ie jiieiiihes
1.:T! 1.)111 4:1)?i'.4.C!
.1:e-ilu'±r; ' 11. IV , !..9 551
I.1..ep resell ca7.1%,:e lake. c A.pp lic
v1,11A111111 1.1'...11..11.. Ie.11 .11 1.)11 • r :01 ( ci irri ci [ •TI
op.:Al.c.21 for thr:: CLAnmis5ior, to ask Liu csri or.6
..1115i LAP 7; C:)..I: .1 j..1'17 551
I here ▪ e LH-net:sou 00111 Fci EJ-ds
ctiuii C LI Lb M.O.Irl'al 'atilt a 1-.1"Pri IC 171.1 LIE: HI
11 C 0_1 riteI fll 1 II.. I t I C'han,cie rif Zo.rie L.Z.-24.52 4-4,H)r,:h:JIL-3. .7.111.1
Di To.:11..! 1 di,' I...!
zinc] t[:;c: add tti.,..)n of a C whic1.1, relate- t 11111iti 1.1g tbe ill ltab 0±
vi't1 I i in ; ▪ 11 1-11.1 IIi Z.:;17;1 1.'1)1 4..3 3..7....1)
Ny v ▪ . .1,)1.1 -1!.1?...'514 „711ei,74A A I▪ , kill
1..V•te takeil. arid Llie carried yr!' ayes Li i 1_)e Luz. ine7:
I his liearinla ;tern ended ar 1:41 p_im
I Iv? k,If II
lt.Cr ▪.26:2- Kr
I1L•A 1 �„; 11..1 I1 ' .1'1 1 I{. 77 1r rI% 5:17
epul'[J n Spk-t` a1 i - L. 1,u rn :I tkc'n.. I11!Fi Ily I°.Iet 11 1 tE; ii ct1{Ili is s M1�_
1.1131, Lill
Wti- 1:42 I:.r1I., LiJ1 1.1MTILllieed tllIS Iran and Cated :he Special! �ti•L�• � ��IIL 11= ." L' t
I W'I '�"W I •:I 1 i"I!I Ii !I1��17 anti ISS'.i tl. F ':r!!Iir: I Ire.LIIV I;'I' 'he ir[IIE'I IiI:CI :11 i24
,. m, ��,� °ti 1. - .ti ���� T... ., �1 •ti•,1 ti 1 1 ti � ti ,
T,13 L LL , [��� �_Ll-®�.= �_ W tti i '_�L"L nt]_.L�_nt r ���1 ', :.: ll 41 LI..�tL:::n`_ kI ...IJ' 1•ti '_-�� � trt fr m
r �:•111171.77io13.ei' .
- - - ( (E•_' IL_ TS '.11L 1 _ 21:. .c_.1.1
:"IW�r,, pl'I'� 1W°III •I III'.�`�'' •I IIl h�ItiII IIII�W I1°II°"' III I Iti. I 1 I°iI irldn.! 94WI)(1ILJ14id
,\I-1 .L'!°I a i' I_ `t�� I. «:�e t i i'sr'�-1▪ e Special NI eett.I i L u. ti'•1' C i e (ie 17 a 1'a Nan 3n I e''i e�. t�i i'CI I"'I aC
°
• 'Ii r� •`5..J �k• III I I�IW:Ii �'I�I:��I.II':� :1. 1 1 .'1i:I J.II'vm. ti�.II` I'� I '.�I'�I II 4'� stI
,i,_,L; �� i-ti�t-_1=. f L�. I�rti� _•:;lr_• J'�I;�ti.�� l" �l� L��'. Wr ��' � n ;Also m nT]I,L1 L,J J]L1t -ht I'l in.u=n
_fie i rtil' i.1 _ I i. T 1_ p r rc,,7.; c_-e1i -..._ a.I1 11 .evievi. J.4c!1 r a 1.vhieli willti~u rI i rl
W .
I▪ � ��,a��IIr,'I II,..,•ti:l I all�•ti'�II• tit 11�'ti I ri lI"I▪ 'di 0, III•17•ti13 1IIrii 11ii id] iti1.•IIL1. II.Il'I.I
-� �__ -• ._ �� ",. _1 W _ 'ti I T .: II�� :_, ',r� W���� ;- F ,: _ . JOU! '�.l' public
- ���:_' 1 ' �• �,-� �I�� '. sir Lim tL-�.' ����t ��°" �1L ��J ti L_ � �..rt [__ti��" �.l1ll� ��] 1. L_� the
I• I_�L' i7Jrli111,:ILW I3�..Ii"Ii :!_ IiW�I I_l!! :i,lle
I1 JL'lt � lleaniF,JJLl 0I1Ji uLlc.ed than the 4A'iild'v'arcl L'Iaili1„ij1: cri'3 next re:4111;11'
its ng W3tL ill �•�"11- I�'riL . N.c: eIiiI)ei' 1 , 2l 24.
. D.I 7%.'I r .Ei 1 yrT 73E T .1:71S 7:. .4 f4.'49. ,r�,,
Thcre I l.:LI tic l'IJ Lrthcr YW:as L7J aced by Yjc: f l I]ri arJ Lou L L). L ]t J .L=c1 :.i L.-aided by
' r°rtiIII I Ii I1I I.11111211 t3; I'.I!..L' 1.11i9:W iI'or II ':I;11 I1 '1. 11.1"' %.I,•!% ' A:, 12i,.II :Ji7Ll Hitt
,.i ri I ti11 1J rl FJlli 17'1 I°��J l k� "1 I�Ii r"1 I I:III 14'�1 I I I I.I I }ICI j I I I Il I "I IJ�'.� 171�'��L1 rl_ W I 1.1 I I I
i.i!' idcr
"'!WFLbSI
•
1��•�Y u I.r�J 2X1 1C71.1.1.
I.f
I)eiillki LI11v ( II;IIrl11111
1
111 10. TT!I ' W 1171 S 1 S I
L W! II I:":,,,
..'.1' - 1W I °I •
HAWAH COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT AND
SPECIAL MANAGEMENT A PERMITTING
STATE OFFICE OF HI#Wi4II
COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT PRoGiwi
dEBRAi M EN DES SH7CHAd LI
AZT7NG PROURJ4M MANAGER SElYIQR PLAN NER
BEFORE
COUNTY' OF NAB AIF WINDWARD R L,4 N Al1A1G COMMISSIiDH
I[Xlllllll' I
Coastal Zone Management (CZM) Act: Federal and StateTimeline
.i ii.i.•..i..I�la}, �. .� 'i�i i}� ���I i 1.1 ice,!- r,1.11131 e4.I, ;mil it tiir I i i•r 1y4 WxhilP11". 1 i I..rxl u Mi i 'i'.1 I.)5+1'7 1111 -4:1111:4ii L)P,.}I
3L Ili-.v' : a tip Cif the Lai id and watelLrefirrilrecs of the t.al 2uI1i7.,
AV" 1 I4 I L:i-1i lw;I I.i III 1.1 Iia me i:K:I y I--s:l I I'hi h I i'.i;.I ii��:�' •.::..�: I•1���� I I el 1111 I It ei I Ie! I i kfl i'-i I'i
1 1i li I rl{'i'''III i`�1.i. I r i r ..
ti .ir I i{ i i; I�•ri i i i•a,I�i•1�.ii i M �i. li: rl rig�r�i i it i � I i I i,1 1: I�:•i :hi rim i i••i.4I rii 1 1•1 I�•i ti�r•i �a�i•�ii�;1 i�i.i..,.��...,.i il•,,, .ti�Yr'•-ii ri•
Thycdi vi�rti��������.""1 ��W��.JI�1"I���Y f�YI Y' '-��.1'����11�,,1r �'�1.�,��{-. I1.1 ''. '1� _ y
- .�-.�w {�. .BIZ��w.� '11i
1973 177 1" r
I , W'1I i 1151 II - LII.
1 wlt°
: ztil
li
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1: x Y 1 W v 1 1 1 ih M 1 1.MAIMEMI11YY A IMM11 11 11■■'W1'•,.°w ", n••",R x ,
119019 19 72..
ti
1 5 19,./b
I I ill -I X _r 1 � °�
.
•
F1 ,1I 1::•II z K .0 7' F.. .-...n• ....- . µ1
nlir Alin' -
°L l u i r v ... 11.1 1°°I w I Nrial 1 1�.��° 1����Y:. 1 i" w®
r1
'.�J IUJ ii'4WL.w Le tha i"L'ii:.I iI^ ai�„YI°�"..1 I.YI'.1.�r . .I
C m ProgramParticipation
— Voluntary
Federal-State Partnership
_;,... .
.. .
,... .
.....„....• ,....-
•.
. ,
r 1 [s
. .
.....
,,, . .
..... ,
,„1„iic.frip,,J,.., 0 .."
.„..
.
,I7
-
F `
I
II
II ... .
r.
\ :: ::7.: "'.::.- ::::•...
. ,.,..
0••-•-, .--••, .
111C:•,F:.:1 I.S.-I•A
. ,
11"
,
--.
.
4'*
- -:.
.... 01..„.....;:i......:;_...4-
kr,
.1 ..
.. 4
, ,...
A Lc.:1.-':-L;,..:.9.
I, 0,
rkaipirrk Raw-Jon
L.r,it.nirt'ri.:..r:.
•
:•
C U'Lii LLI
ter -
- .,„, ,, •
•- Alm::1
•°: '°
m: I'- --
. 1.-'-I. .L
wir .....
:-L-11;.71:.,77,;'-f
Al! 3c, 1::.111:1il.iid,a. rii_rii,,a i liiritiii3P;, r tri rlt0 Sliai,P.Sz, 1,:iilia ,11Pra ciii ITiiIe,ripH.:2"..1111 irri! ill'i
taCepr-iCir Df AID14.9 . 1:12 icirj1:
Ha wa ii CZM Program
. _ce What is Hawaii CZM
;', a "`
p
�,, ., T� �r�wide fur thetF���ti��� m ana Q�rn��� �e nef cial use,
tl,:. !I . L W 1113" ll�:
V 6
.. CZ114 Ln Hawaii Revised Statutes Chapter 2 0 5 A
Fart I - Coastal Zone Management
� ,,Vf,' .. , .� , Objectives & F icier
l . .. Federal Consistency
"ty ■ Marine and Coastal Zone Advocacy
1'
. W 1 Council
7.112:116.1-1/2 •
itAL '
�1.■,A Fait El - Special Management Arens
Irv+ u, �ta��� 1
5 "' � r .emu r�:� ��� �.,� �,
Fart IIr - Shoreline 5ethack
® Fart IV marine and Coastal Affiir5,
_.- � 1INhHk �
11/2 - .-,_,,,,ar-'. i . , 111.
Part V - Other Provisions
1 Y
Hawaii .CZ1v1 Program Components
�. ; Federal Consistency
3 � Special Management Area (5PA) Permitting
jCg 'IA
Shoreline Setbacks
Hawaii Ocean Resources Management Plan
` ,.P Coastal Hazards.co iru
;+7, Coastal Non-Point Pollution Control Program
0.
Marine and C. s-tal Zone Advocacy COU11C1l
Federal Consistency
Federal actions that have reasonably foreseeable effects on
coastal use or resource must be consistent with the enforceable
poIicie Of the Hawaii CZM Program
Federal Consistency Review Required for
1) Federal agency activities
2) Federal permits, i.e. U S Army Corps of Engineers Permit
3) Federal financial assistance
Direct Federal Funds to the Hawaii CZM Program
- Receives $2 million in federal funds annually
▪ Supports tie Hawaii CZM Program
▪ Funds county administration of the SMA per . it system
Federal funds support 4 to 6 positions in Each of
Neighbor Island Planning Departments
11Z-7 -,-'-='.,_"_
Part - CZM Program Objectives arid Policies ( 5 -
, Recreational ,
Coastal Hazard Resources „,,
s�.
H,Wei i i CZN1 i r
• Historic Managing
r 1
Resources Development „ . 4:-.,;_
,..-..., . 7.,,,, 9,4,.....,,-,,,,,--, .
r _.,---__ ..
{ Scenic and Open - _
Public Participation � ��� �... �� �
Space Resources "E. � ._ �
o ,„;
, ,,,,,,. ', -- - -*, ,
ivy ,„
- .'
'. - .
Coastal , Beach and Coastal ;
Ecosystems i 1 „-
Dune Protection ,. 4,, 2
Economic Uses . Marine Resources
. __
.
Hawaii CZM Program - NeLwork
',khan,Rita!,ArgicabralQrGonacrealljurr
Gruffly Spacial iLIn
C.Z%1 Ereopmahl3 Pc1
Irix11SIalriuii:fi
S Manna Milts
Slam rind Gamily irtpmilomn I:r-I I li
r
1 1 1 1 m I m 7
ul 1 1 IIII 1 e 1 } 1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 11 1 I I W u+ 1 1 1 1 ■W
• e 1.1 1 1 •1 1 1 1 1 1 �.1 1 •1 1 1...
1 ® 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
e l 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
e 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1 1 I "
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
m e I r • a e e I lu e
I . 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 •1 IIIR
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
e 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I�
1 1 '1 1' '1 11
1'1 '1 1' ' ' I,V L Rr 3I
e e e I e e
I m m l 1 1 1 � 1•1 1
1-3111
^ 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 , 1 1 1 1 1 1
• 1 1 1
1 11 1 1 1 Y I 1
e m m e
1
CZN1 Area— Entire
•
u e 1 1 ti
1 _
Fkvoniii °. I n r.
WI• a Is_ ��_ ®fie
CZM Program NetwoNetwork - Regulatory Authorities
Ourthosiiierulatrix
I1.11 N hi'I C CI 312 AHD
A1 r^ MrrI°r} I7IE E HFOIRCE411Lb PEFLICIE1 110 a
•::-• 1 .4Aferi 0 9 ralrnC h.
trcuzz A:id v•Ls - -
11 . a u ..!-....• • .
MJar�L 1, m_. a�i�d .1i��. P : S tato - �u —rt . 1 to ut
rdi r rlc I LJI . - -
.•• -OrC11114n.044-- - i.� u„ Mil I
- � 11•-� . w,u
• . ■ I mp Iern a ItL1t:o ri of the
..°1':�°:11'1iiJ®.1 .•� i 1.. J-iC 1.��1�ti ' J i d ��.1�I C i'?5
.m.Laaa amp
1 l•IF. 111 Eli .,IAa Wel r. ,•r H R 2 U'-1A-1 aid 2DLIA-Ldi
H' maw...IP Wm Ma awL•• L
—1.r-111,1y1,�1 .L-.,1 , ...
11k LLl1 FIP1 1 L • •
■ £iturf Z.. po.ims opp:i ea to
��•�. 1• ,• - °� t { �'m�I :a n s I.st E ra c y
F`1 1 �al. -• .• 1 •-Pal
•UI1•irYlr1lw114, 1 t - ., -1 1r
opSD as the CZM Lead Agency
_
DEvELOPP1 EN 7
IN G& SU STAIN ABLE
OFFICE 0 F'PLAN I'll'
. . ' — (0PS )
..
'"figlit, ' '''' ,,,,t01-11111111
—1— —.....,,,
„.- -, ....,
.,
idd. '
phir111110 Land US
- hr a!Vision
......._ __
,...
.•. •..u,,.
cilsiori
i —
I
CDastl Zonc
Ell...mewl rniiini I
.,
Managarrient„ Ectriew Frov min i IOU PrrkgrA rri
•
..-_.-
prcigr1'n
,
-._
• .
• a " '.'....: ,,,,r''' I'71'41IVIR5.4.!175177P"...- : "ri
i , -.
- --",..
""- .-7„...:'',7,-;a. ' ..;,%.!.
r;ed.4j r du hir Spvcll Flii n9
ill rimmd Lion,
Brom.h..
SrA.Pern?
—
"...- F.N.'.. ..7.,:„, •- '''.., -7: ..". „ .-,'".;"..- .__,-
. ., .
• ..., • i •- —--....,.. ,„,,,
Staicpid
EliJgrMI nabil ILI
. .,
Branch
1„-
0 PSC} - FLavhi all CZ,M Frog tarn Lead ri.re' "
. -• . Atli ,-&"- •.. . . .„,• . . .
.• . ..
q
. . . ,-;.›.- -.....,, ......z:j.: •' -.41. . ._ ....ii, . ....;:,.....;
7•:,""..,..L.• :i...-....', •;:-'''''': .2.4 .
,,:ii.,
OPSD - Lead Agency of the Hawaii CZM Program
§205A-3 Lead agency, including the following roles;
P.eceive, disburse, user expend, anti accowlt for ail Funds. that are made available by the
United States and the state for the coastal zone management program;
El Provide support and assistance :n thiE, acirninistratiol or the coastai zone management
progra fil
11 Rev;eoi federal programs. federal oermits, federal licenses, and federal development
proposals for consistency with the roasta zone management program;
II Conduct a contimiing rf.view it the administration of the coastal zone management
Program and of the compliance of state and county agencies with the ol*ckives and
policies of this chaptel ;
II Advocate agcnry compliance w:th clia.pitef 205A:
Li Phionitor the coastal zone management-related enforcement activities of the state and
county iagendes responsible for the administration of the objectives and poiicies of this
11 Coordinate tie -,mDlementation of the ocean resources management Dian.
Marine and Coastal Zone Advocacy Council ( MACZAC )
i'vl A C Z.h.4:I...X.501i rk;! 1:54Dui.."Lo rielAC74.44 Ac!lvii If
rourLiii.,-.9,r1,1•....1.11.1"-. LAI:-:-.Fm HRS § 205A-3.5 a public advisory' body
"FE i 1FTP•.7 7 01 in Ti....W.-1 •:.J1r• ..;•.CL-%: I...•..A.M.'.:11.1 moo.0. :m.•-
to assit tr.,, lead agency in yvork...:ng tOkile,lird
11,1...•••IT 1-1•J
• • 1.1641.1.
.11'.'AIL.AM- '••''. '' the inipleme1-1t-,o1-) of an integi-ated and
. . .
•••..ir a II i- .J I k•1.•I 1 1.•-
. • .l'r L-V11...••7•J...•••••........I.L.11 Tref...UV. coi-nprehens'ive managenient systeni for
•P••!,......1 rnari(le arid coastai zone resourc.es.
'..•r'...it:-..
a II El Hi..4.Y.•.-....;••-• .ipi-:-:Emi.:11.1
-- ,,,T.-IV—Tel-'.•••I e 1--.V•-,' '
....,.I.J r..-1.1..;....Ito:...E-I!.:4.....1 r... ••p. ...z.('-;,-r xi.i cons7.stent witll the Haolaii CZM objectiVQ5
EN...led-le...r.•n•ir•1 1+::•.• ,x.;r•i.• rrn-
••••.1••• ,• li 0 ,.
•fri sl i •11 n•Iirni and policies.
0..1,0 401.1.111r1Z . . , .
•• •I. . iiii • .
11/2.0.."}AP.±...1r h
I 1 6.,",:-7-:=,- • ...,......•Meg ell
I.'.
I.=. ,
..1.•-=',U 1......om•.... MACZAC, founded .r1 2001, is corni_lrised of
IN...lu nr•rm.rcpu •1.1...r.Ns :111....•...
*I.•.,• ml•N%II s
'fry 0.1•Nr. 111•01r,raci....?rimr f.19 r.rc7..7n.i.0 1 arivi.5ory mmbit9i-s fe...ci-LJited from th e-
OJ'L VX,RJ ire.:L3.:I•A c...........-mi-nJ•JAz-b.
incz=id...1 islands of Kauai Gahur Maui, Molokalr
.PIZ'-Aims.'r: i a• ••Ij•. i•lesmill. ...a•I r
..,...,,ocz,•-..-.. ...1;J.....i...r.1..1,i.,, LAn
..: aii, and Hw aall.
r.1.11.110.1 I T::—n-..f.%•
. •
1.1.1 -LrJ.21 At,vi ri 0 dr...•1 1 R.4...
. .
•:....:.::•- r:,71:.:.IIZA.......• :2: 5
r,r•v y-:......-.•,....li.4.-1.•M. .-A•••
%%I.P.1..1 •'. ...P9 0 Vlii VII ii I N.:! • East Hawaii] Island Rept eseritativE
•.. II r,. •.- . .. •L.E-h•
P-It 11 01 CJ- ••...1 -4 i ...1.111. :!:. •111:,11-Id-a.!....11,1 . West Havoal'i Is;and R.epreser)tat7ye
ler re A..I N•7:II- m i•Trirram.
4...i.- •• • -.- . ..
. I, •
, ..
- ,
o gri FO •' "
ds . • .. . .• „
if,:9.1 I r •-••••1 '0.N.m.C. •mm • •': ,
.,.. L.-,.. .. ,..• !sr••m •r -a •.+or Arr,'.
...,,_ .....„...:..•.:•,,,... _... : , , % ....:,,::-: ,_ ...7 .
Hawaii CZM Program - NeLwork
',khan,Rita!,ArgicabralQrGonacrealljurr
Gruffly Spacial iLIn
C.Z%1 Ereopmahl3 Pc1
Irix11SIalriuii:fi
S Manna Milts
Slam rind Gamily irtpmilomn I:r-I I li
r
1 1 1 1 m I m 7
ul 1 1 IIII 1 e 1 } 1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 11 1 I I W u+ 1 1 1 1 ■W
• e 1.1 1 1 •1 1 1 1 1 1 �.1 1 •1 1 1...
1 ® 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
e l 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
e 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1 1 I "
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
m e I r • a e e I lu e
I . 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 •1 IIIR
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
e 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I�
1 1 '1 1' '1 11
1'1 '1 1' ' ' I,V L Rr 3I
e e e I e e
I m m l 1 1 1 � 1•1 1
1-3111
^ 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 , 1 1 1 1 1 1
• 1 1 1
1 11 1 1 1 Y I 1
e m m e
1
CZN1 Area— Entire
•
u e 1 1 ti
1 _
Fkvoniii °. I n r.
WI• a Is_ ��_ ®fie
Part II. Special ManagernenL Areas (SMA
"
r Hn iii` Ifs! ■iiP
, _um
•
I„„
" �,
„, " s
.•
•. y
I m
° `
•
•o tin r.
•.. i I � a L l
.„ .F .. m ' , . f
di■La �1 N 1 " + i.u ram,
,
+I
iti 1 „ 1. gr 1 SMA - land extending inland
®� � �.� .� - , from the shoreline or any area
e
." subject to salinity intrusion or
_..... Vr i ' tidal influence
_" ' �,.
Designated Special Management Areas ( SMA)
L2IFrI
Nihau
Oahu
IY1010101
MEW
Lliflai
1101%4111
Kauai 19„217 oacire3
Oahu 31,629 ar.N113
Maui 7S;306 arlin
Hawaii 47,556 acres
11111..nre. I Imromi Prriiirhm 2111.4 '14 Irtb volirr,7w
ii
Environmental S ProLection Act Permit
,
.4.41•04
Ni ...,
Purpose P rl tti ®, r®
�Le
in The5HApermitwasestabIishedwith �. ..,
-st
the enactment of Act 176, SLH 19751 • .0. . ..I.dor,
which was called the Environmentzil .
Shoreline Protection Act
. _. ,
- L •
e r
It is necessary to have special controls r ,
•
on developments within an area aIonj '0,, � �,.7 i.11.1- a,. 1 ; -.
the shoreline to . , ,, . .1, . .,,g
:. - . .,ii 4 7—, l'nu
..
L
▪ avoid permanent losses of valuable
resources and the foreclosure of �_ ,...1,11 . .
y
•
management options; an . :
W .,,0., y
▪ ensure that adequate access, by dedication � ....it
or other means, to public owned or used iik. R r %z, • � «
beaches, recreation areas, and natural
reserves, is provided.
- 4
SMA Perrnft - First Permit: for DevelopmeriL
The First Permit for a
Development within the SMA Authorities for SMA permitting
• Does not establish land use policies
for developments • County of Hawaii: Windward,, Leeward
Planning Commi .sion5
- Regulates permissible land uses that • County of Kauai: Kauai Planning
are already allowed by state and Commission
county land use policies
- No development shall be allowed •
within Maui: Maui, Molokai, Lanai
wi#hin the SMA without obtaining aPlanning Commissions
SMA permit 205A-2B)
• City & County of Honolulu: City Council
- No agency is authorized to issue
other permits pertaining to any
development wi thin the SMA unless
2 J)SMA permit is first issued (§ 205A- � -t,.�7
410,
,16
..a
I. .
22 2 22 2. 2 2, 2 2 2
..2, .1 'r ...2 r
CI" NI A PP r-rii 1 Lt.! ng -: '•- .,,:' • . • -.' 9 i."'• •i-
..,..„ ...,........I r ,1.. I
ifc"it,L-
-.....11... ,.,
.•••• •1••• '.1
ii. 1..1.•••:
_,_le.-...r
I I •i,•
......„ J.
•
' ...•
.•-•. ...•\..• .%••. ' ••••
ir
.- -,.. {on...1i.p.ili will.ilv.
...!:,:jc..v..li:utik.Lni'1:...., %,
.-•'''
..-... / '...
.1.J11 l'-,,• rL1 .4, 1? I %...L'!.• / 1.:••••1... '... ••... ...• •'•I A .\
5.-.. i.•:.11 1)-1.111.:Iorl 119 Fe::. .6 -• .....
fs ' J-I illtr-ai rr..07- •"' %-i I. I"I-1
.:-.... .4".. 11 . 1 ic .•
H iim L1.... ..
.• ... _
.0 N ..../
in I.1 rrrri A....:•.e4 A-6.,m I ....•
,
I •::'• % %I. -I
1 I•. ••.,,
-•:•!•:•.. I •7/i'• .•
. ....• .
• '.-%."•.%
• ...I— 1. . .i '•.. • • J.
••• ''•' '.•ii i••-•
—1 1 '
I r I ..... ..,
1..I.I It' .i.e. e•—p
••.% "ii. 1 4 P l• .ii.•%•:.:11.1:
. . ... . '
-..:.1
0 .1 1 a • .• i L. M... -}222
'I 1'2•2 li IOC hill. 11.1 :II' "' "7..“ .11 .•" 1 'I.' '''''
. 17:11, I,)- . . • .:1. .
I .1,11.--... •ii 2:....I.i I
r... .1 :11-..1-.1H-•. ."'.1{.7.—
* 1111161 El iv Irvin m'
•21 •• 1.7.2. 1• .1.1•21.....21. •11 2 2 1•2"...I I'IC 1. ••••• 2 •.•.• • - ••I• 2 2• 21. ••. Y2'2:11.2•111% '11.04 _. _ 212 2 I 2. M. 22 22,121
Development vs. Not Development ( HRS § 205A-22 )
r 111,-. "7 . • 141—: I._
•
...Li..
.: - „ 2, „11,,,, : , • i,u F.. ..wr . , „vir:':.,'„,,„,„,„,,,';,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,„,,,,,,,,,I,attiii,,, P• ti:,,,10,00iiik,„,„0-77.. : ,,„ , ,,,,',„%, :;,..-7.....-z7•
. ....aso•77.16.44,i. „„„„,,,,,,,,,44,,^„,;44=^4!"4,4,4"' it,,,,,,' ,4""" in, , 4'4 4 10,1 „.
.. • " . . ,, i"-5.,..121diz•.!..t.. ' """"':"Aii,,,Eiiiiiiftits"4"°""''''"*4'''4z'4'44'''""''''''' 4,' 44"" ' 41, '4'44- ""
. ' NI'. , ;•.: .• 4 "44170;14;4';44;"44^;"-4 "I•' -1"4 "'„.,-44,,,,_ - , , 44,„„,,,4„,„
4" .' '^4..' .i.7•13100;7'. . .
,„ u -.1"19J,,...,.••• r;oia•L"Al- ' ' _:-14---
• •-•' '•••,,, '"^.• '!'''{ '{,i"
,• -.. 9 . .. '''' "?........ ,...,.':„.•.• .''.., ,
d 11,,, „, " „ , '''' •:_dr71.11.'et",. ,
, • 1
•0',
r.. illi„„
,,
:.• ' 'L':;:r" ,1 ' "' . 'l''
„„''..,.... •1/19- ,„ ,—.,.,.,'''',,,, ',;1;.;',.,,'.,^',,,r-", ',P77;'01111111.06EgFir V't'- ,,Or_iiIr '
IL
Roof Repairs
,1 ...„...
. .
•. .
Single-Family Residence Nai , 411"1ii
(upon its location and 5ize)
idtigliik • — —
11471 ,-,'' • • ' •"
SMA
III ' Il" 1-3'Use I-mit
° �
...„ ., , ,
01. . . 114.,
���n, I • C„
� f� � �� r
®w ,
`fi
1 IV
° ui I 'e" M lw ' „ran
.n1'99Wifw. ft®I i ." Vl',u ��_���� •�, ll'Ji
5 ���a i �1 yy
emu_,,,_ ,�
- ....* .'- al a•- --1k7—"•"110. 1 ' ' iThrr'''' . . z1. -
tli
,.'�.W i .n R�„�„.,° �Yr ,k �, I' 1 Y r �'� I� - 'T ...p��� W���T",��
2'
....J•C.• —.
r. Yr,
{.7.1 ,°' •_.r l_,.... ., m•� .. w ill • w'� ••. tom " �'
, :.I.: ;kJ--itirT i '
, .... ,„,...YL,.:: -,;. .. ,
__
- , 111
J •
_
Iv-4,1ti,
,_, ,,
. .. .
. .
_ .
I.
�a yy� Fun �• w.11 � 9•_ ' •
iriii...,. :" ,, ,'°,c,
.._ , .
_„ . . ,,:,.
. .
, .. , „,
, „.„... ,...._._=, . ,
-i.."1%. • .•
■ Key Factor -- adverse environmental or ecological effect,
taking into account cumulative i m pacts
• Cost threshold -- 500,00 ��oo�t°� �,� , ;"1: :
4
Cumulative Impacts in SMA Assessment
Tefriporal Scope
Spatial' Eni.rurnmell riP
crppriEN-
(ZM Claiwia S.-14 'Mr.4:re,:•• ri.: (.7a y1 ..:7.:11-• r.•::::.y. -:-......w. :wry
Cumulative Impact — IIIIJ' i -.- -..;rr 1A:trirc.
Incremental impact of 1.1.1.iiii.%11,
•.c.:..-i Liii.1--.1.
the proposed action L-.7.r
1
itut„:.b. NI
when added to other
past, present, and .7 Hy.hrl: ii• i•
e.:.-iir rile ...r....r
reasonably
L:1131-t
foreseeable future
F. )nr)!: I
actions regardless of
L .....-.r. ral irJr.,-40
what agency or
1 .-.1.1- li.-17
person undertakes 7
nr-i
„,e...1
other actions (IIAR L ilsiii u --_-L...ic:n•
01.11-213C1.1 )
irixtril•;..-21 IlluJI.1'
;1)1 r»r L. en)
,
Filii i..:171.11.
0:11111\-:1-11-.117irn. r
1.1
'40 4140. ILI*iii il:1s1::; J.; r_i_I-J1..1! Jltait'i L'
hr 1
' 1 I "oo• -.roa
, Guidelines SMA
§
HRS 2'05A- „26
' a
,‘ ,
., 0,
'' 1
00
o.'
-'
Hamiall
vkils
.
,,,, 11,
,,,,,
,,,,,
CZM -1-a- ris
provii° frr
7,"',
,,..,,
N.'.
or
“ ,
' „„ .... . , ,,: •.141. ".7. 7,'
1 FOCI
ii
-.. u,,;,.„• 177'.'u'',,.''..-...1,,.„„'il'„.'..
..i..,
',.
...„:
r , . dip ,ico:2 1:•1' .
SMA Permit Conditions III Include
Provision and maintenance of public beach access
Preservation of archaeological sites
Protection of life and property from coastal hazards
▪ Boundary setbacks and building height restrictions to
preserve coastal views
Drainage improvements to control siltation in coastal
waters
▪ Prohibition of artificial lighting on the shoreline and
ocean waters
0
Enforcement f 5 MA Permit and Shoreline Se
thacks
„of .. ..„. ., '..
e- 11 i 14i.
_ 5
I Ithmr .
f , ' . palL . e • 7......CIP.. .4.
. .
1 _AilliAMIL '5'
. .,,,,,... ..
,. ..
!I • •,
•1 4 ;•• . . -.-.,
..,
. • 1
41.1•,•—.4'41'''''' ..
I • ILI Oa' --'°J,,..--. L
, * ,r.'w ...•z.1 a . ie. is.
, . j......01
eikk:6
It4Itif
11141114''
. .
. 1
II
,m ilutilliffi, -
'
l'Cr;i 'IC
et Vi.
.411 r
.111W;_11111i
3;U 0 CI 12 t CI 5 11:1110E
up±5 '1-1 dal'
' sIarOCEI'eac
11
Part III . Shoreline Setbacks - Land Use Law to CZM Law
H RS Ch. 205 HRS Ch. 205A
Land Use Commission Coastal Zone Management
Act 236, SW 1970 Act 258.. SLH 1986
To be 'ii rr'cir eFf.2ctive mariner core&intent with its intent and 'purp es th priviSkiri of
shoreline setbacks, which was originally set forth by Act 13E5 SLH 1970 under State Land Use
Law H F&S Chapter 205 r ' sre red to Part III of I-I RS CI-1205A by Act 258, SLH 1986.
i'1. i. F^m `O =
Shoreline - Land Use Law to Law
, „
,r„
. „ ,„,,,, ,,���� III 1�. , .. - _, _
��� .w
L
ICI^ �u�MN uuwwu 'l ,, CAI I ww " I I
� � ..:
•
�� — .. : u � , d iy! . r, ; . : .r ,,
il
m
_ ' Pro
.I1 pd ( I I
. "m" I . I r �'. � a
r
r 14 14 w.al
11
�a
w �w M re" _" w 'I I"
VI 10litiliddk VVV, IRS ���� �..�' — � .•����' ���' " :, .���� ��ILL .'� .:: "-4i.. .. a �.. — ' „
.1071
gym.. III—'_
'j 1 „' '' r'' '1' ''''' ''li,'" ''•' .1
": ■ '
wII ., . 4
I �� I� w u �� , � .:. ;>a. gy- rye
litl I
III ,,„ v... o Ortity
",,Nli �
Hew S Structures.res ��_
1 �� MNfl lµ" .,� i
d. �� ' 't i Ih„.74.4- If MI S h Drelin�e. Setback o," . ro
ti""
Alt-.1. I
Existing Structures ' _
.
■r`
op"" i •
u r w
w
41„,,,,,:
•Amendments to FIFA Chapter 205A
•° a n
Act 16, SLH 2020 Relating to CZM
•I Yu. .
'got.
. .
. •
• Amends the list of "development" "not
nod -inn- n
ti
developmentl , specifically for sirs I -fEm l ...
residenc:e P g`..__yam 1"@'E.I — r q: i. " "f d: r"
' %Y
I III{f - '^N•' ;'WP ilwr
• Increases the minimum shoreline setback • _
-1 „_ • „_ _ , °III :°
w • . nn n„ ,, .
„„
from 20 Feet to 40 feet
- -
• Adds sea level rise to the definition of coastal
"" `and o , • -' ., -�"._ s` a,.0 0. ;
hazards, and a definition of beach to enhance
beach protection L�: o �
• Restricts public r prohibits privater li
haideriirig structures at sites with sand ���• -
- _. � � �� �� r
. W a per
beache5 • ,•
• IW "
_ .
Effective Septe...mber 15,,, 2020 • -0
w n
':�" - e
No More Choreline Hardening in front of Beach Areas
PLIrsLIint to Act 16 SLH 2020 shoreline hardening structures in
areas with sand beaches are prohibited from the private property
owners, unless it is clearly in the interest of the general public.
7: i , 1 ,:,
ho„„ , ..
1
The interest of theenema public :a
,ur° m - .mow >,p �a`{,-1�;`s'
� "a
public safety and/or public healthy .i ,
e. protection of public infrastructure in _ _w
response to risk of coastal hazards; ono"-- ®
or
{ heath protection/sand retention for • _ �, '-� -a�:� ® �
■
public use and recreation or coastal -� , '����,� - � _ ;m,,. , . r, .�
ecosystems. ,-., . ,. ,, .w -� , . .. • _ :�,
w r,4 lit ;P 7
Amendments to HRS Cha
Act 229, S 2023 Relating to SMAs
'ts ., aim
„,,,,
, ,,,„
Expands excr r �� I " •
�x�
to
. .
exempt SMA p for the following
T' -
0 .
L.
artiVitieS: '..4. ' ti
.x
a) pedestrian and bicyck Facilities , .. .1xJw .x x�,9 , �_ �„
l trash or invasive vegetation rernov I ���
C) fencing for native habitats on CCriervdtiOn , �, . a�..1/2 r ��� 4: - ���
,gym P4V. ' 11)1Stail.1:.'h•7. -.,E.
land . .:. ....,:......,...,
_• .«�., �`1 IINti°Iw m n -
• ... ) , .. .7'1 •'' 4 •: ....• u. ..1, ilir i' . ,•11 II,
,:b
-.: ,4, .
. r - -ii
„, .r...,-;°. 4•d) feiicinç t I ing public to i WkJ:407ff;
.� I ..
� � ' �� r u� i r � � _ c � $• �. n' .a�n .., lit : mo
racilities
...,
.. _.,„,,.. .
; -,
,,, . ' -7 1
f)
Hawaiian trdi inn I and cu5tomary
,a x
Effective July 6, 2023
P rt I M rin LAffairs
,„
,.
,.,
.„ ‘.
. , ,,,'; .
s 1 ,,,, y �,
0,11,„,„ . , ,,,,,.
„.,,,.,... .....„,
�
.,
�uu uu .a.
PL, , .„,... , , „ il 11. - ' ,,- ,
ng Land
IT-
_ • Presenting OUT
��� �, •��� Ocean Heritage
��� • -�� . z . _ rrriti
ua
�. ��� CoI Iib on nd
it j 4, . ., Stewardship
ti
■� t
rt a�mr„ �. ... � �I■ ..1 � V
r
1101741116°' 4-'
s� . rt
A �
ti .. �' .
� w�.. L• .., 1 u'fr.
Hawaii Ocean Resources Management Plan (ORMID) 2020
D.L.L.12.,arrt 114a—tp—r•-r0 •
I -Am !ma.
itaisam im •lu ari• Id I IIat I 111
I II • I N.,,s IP •me. ri I II.• .
411." """"" •
I aL E. •er • N, 1110•11 Nolapy II•AN,
▪ rim•IN b 1%7 n.r4 •••alb,4 mi I I :-
11411...15—1003 ir hi ,
" I
leg
•roh 111 r N-
at
Mulls Liu 1:1 Fl
",111,"L - 4 •,1
• gr ••• Ine•
—II II.,1.1 11.6 RIF T17,1M1r1.111°,11=1
REIM a
— +6,
- r - 4. I• 4 •
1,N. • It,
&I •
uu !“.1(01'1'1".' F r- p.•••
•••••-•••
L.1.p..1,,wiP
•Pr ra••••P
I• h • ••
I • 1.11• • • 1 all• .
.,„
I• •- •- - •• y •- , •r . I I I 111 • •
1•••,11,1•4•4
5▪ 1. cri.w .T111
IP II I IN • •
▪C4 runt•:••i:•x..iL'Ei.
• • ,
• - , ••4 I I
L 1 I J. - .1 . - • • " ' 11:111
—
911,J r• . •
- • • -/rr• •11 • - ". •• L " .""
Ph •
ORMP inftiatives/Projects & County
Putting Planning to WL'rlc. CooLtOL Lonc g nJLnt 1mpkuichEJt]c'n
Focus Area#1 Coastal Hazards and Development
• •'aptat 'n Strategies Menu, completed July 2323
- Manage Retreat Lega FoI;cy with funding and financing mechanisms,, completed by
12 1/20 2
▪ Etrenc1t mink FesiI ence for DHHL pr o eities through incorporation of CZM, ongoing
▪ F li r� Sharrliiuuii I1drld 'rriErbt InitiEt've„ Phase I completed ted ' D 3 Phase IT Agency
.i u ti-e_xx h and consultation,. completed by 12131/2 24
▪ Act L T . S L H 2021 - Sea Le'e. RsR.-isi=2 Adaptation r r State faciliVes, Ongoing
Focus Area#2 Reduction of land-based pollution
▪ LID Guidance 2006 - Update Sri nro'ress„ competed May 2024
• I e pnr: P ®oi-itizFtion Trio; to inc o 17. Molokai, ongoing
▪ Leveraging rng resources r."".'D H to increase se community rapacity & iniL., ernent identified needs
Focus Area 3 Marine Ecosystems
• Hawaiian EStL,o l2S e'er
▪ Developing cor11rn.in t' I F1'' lit'irirl i protocol partnerships v1th DLrJP-CAR.
Integrated Shoreline Management Strategy
Inoirr6ark1 Ind andLize I ril-r.i InrrRrirmity•r ss!rf..,•alo.14 t:,..lit!ivorellne kirisirrir;64..1191m
w
'.1' ''-17.1 1 ird FRIthilk;ECIIIN-Itzarde Dr 3 iubri-ma Ilie.ver r (ditiYi. 19 Ird7..1111[0.1
., r.
' A!' ... vv;', ' ' •. :.' _. 'fil • -.lip. i ume2eariti.te,!Lail Ii!!tleivviCIIIit11;11;2 fr...1"1,Mkt{t...1111.L.V401PalluiLtIOIL LiP 1 a_.,.t li pr LI
1,,,,, • . . 7: ..". ,,T.,-.-- 11 • ion.1/2,01."1.4' , Lr,Ficisilinulin 1 Ls*
ir t liff'ili i Im
.
• ' ,..' IIII'' it....
. .
•N,. ,,,11.' ;::::-.'-4:-"',...'ii • , '"''''.411 '-1111-4:11i.c. :"46 .1 1 ii6rbr9 x!.blilc eimagr,ttlile L.AI.;C... ::PlieLtlilik olaillto 0.111111111.i 61..Cri,i EDt,..1.11
• -"- v
IV 1 Il',v• , tvIv 1 Lii,',',7-' IC,' t'""•&-,• o
„LY 7,7, 1:i i - DiELirgek&Ai Ai,-Id1 1-.:.:+.1.-1.1 ilre.^.bid• ,,5[Tt'Al I u h Afid 3ct Lg.a I r pi.lio.,.. Jiti..11.E.-.•.
, I ,' '711 • ' '''. °. 5,,,..,0,,,, i' , -4- , , vvLiri.;3 IA r 1;th GM
v.v
""'ufirin iriNXTII rev:I:Glum midOtall 1.:..rr,'.IL ,,a•la EpainlirttIllei.Ar I.))1EICI;hc.....1-illIrEht- I- --; ;- a_LL.,13 ri,..,I I.
..zj: 111..dir!ij I 1,9Lrittikfilti;C-111.Wile L I ' . ' ...irilk.Lzili!.1 ILl ie.h EU L,-.1;lar611..'"';31. in.
• ' W.(, 4 .... ., .,.
r 111:,NIL E:.,.1:1"IF I g NJ lidliii.•-1:11t..1 A..7"1"lo'btiV Liih Ilympl I;hgh-gurgy ihaire!ix
., ..
. .1!
- LPi lillithitiL ... 1 I I: IL LI kill II
IIILALI LW mi..;L.ill .o.1 Ira. vv,, .;•;,..21...Liar..lin I ii.i,.mil ur i'er.himlniiii.41 1.1114111.1.10114",...ekh
.., ,
di EAU:1.011F fa Lim_lulu I ::.;.1.0,,,tir-1.I r;".% .•..vv,:l.1 LII.JII pLill III 11.iall•Ilr.11101,Ur,did ki'l
4 p La I la h;1-pel•1 ruri i Lip Ira.
.s vv,
..v .. 1 livvzr-zr;rurn I mrnigni rorF-nrk nr iiFIE IEL.:-L•ricicki:ii inilim I in al q:Eirr....inor..prtck.q.ilmilA3 E,
kolic:PL ELY..10!.LI IILL.."13 l'Ci '.1.:..',-,J,Jr3L1.-.11.L.1:11tCip.1.•.;I 0 a I Li ili.:-LI ii i J.',5 !III LIY F idoilitsi iti"
mr ;
I r. ;:r1;; 4-rn Leo.;ri iii!o;,ZIPS'0001 ii V 1,-irrp.j;ri• •bin in fript,5 r....iiii1.716.1.1 IR.FAL 1 I 1 i cnr-rrin
'ill'
'''"'7II vI II •IvIv•- e ivI".A.
Questions? . .
• ..,, •
' , ." I i• ' ,
1 .1..!. • " ! ': •1 '''"I " i ' " ' 4,111.igi_ii. ,- =rp ;0
_.
State of Hawaii Office of Planning
_0
P.O. Box 2359 i
''„,,0
A., A
Honolulu ilawaii 96804
(SOB) t-187-2846 . •
,.,,.. _„,,, %-,,,,, , .... • .„... •,•
•,
•,,,_,ow
r'll'ili ' :A •;,", & • .
_ .., ....
- ,'
'' '
i A i
•
•• ,.
• •
, 11•
. ..•r .1, .1, 1.. _
.
_.06.1"- 7....°6.1C-,. _.- .8 ,„,, .- -..k.a6_
04,71. • , ,-L.2..- • . . ii.' - —' .0. . L 1111-iii,0,,,...,, ' ,,,,,,., .-,:- - • - --c, ,e,, , , . .
CrvILIATIVE EFFECTS/D1PACTS ASSESSMENT GUID_A_NCE:
IN SPECIAL rti..A.NACEMENI: AREA PER_VIIIT
] [Erwaii 'Coastal Zone Manaenient Program
State of Hawaii Offic• of Pl.a.annig !..3usrainiible 1:1:21..tqc.13menT
St}8 -587-2 :46
00\
April 2022
EXHIBIT 2.
"u ulatit;e'rfi I 'Trri1iaci:s Asesisfnitiull. Guidance
in Special Nlu ngt'incLlT A, 1; .P er 'w
I_ ]'pose/Background
SpeLl! ;_ ii.inki m4ur_ r Li I�_• : 1 p•ti d i"mit i a o[tr.r
.i'..i l •▪n-Li �' ti]1L}_ bid,.: to I t.• 1,1 Lt= kippr!v. _ r.2]].4 L. 'tl.L11
!.lJII'IILI�lLi� III:iI I 1°1 '1A qui red Ilk, .Iie ( ..- s.41
-
\'1 MITI�I �u1T1 I�I I I ;i•-:��"i�' I ,�tir�° r 1N;ti Lei kl I,° 1I 4°5°I����� �'�I�111.�'� �� �. I I kIpLo. 20-
�A P1,I1'�I I;S°17 t ;..)
F 1 61''1®,'L-2__ iii C d i_te rIi'r I IIllI fIl dl i 111 i ti" have n 511k7.5•= .11ti 3] acIverse
ell' I'I'Ir1111 111:71 itil' a '�•'ll_ I_.i eI I±i_i 2111i. 1IIe1'e ii ii L require a LA, I .1zi 1r:11,1
i.:C' lJTJt putcnt]ki] :_"1fl of Ltv Fur°rh•ti1_ tlic
:ullt " au lii: :t riLld5 that aI'_'r exc."tided.use. ope t=.�11 J11a " IIave t cuo7iuL.:i •'e
•rl I�I =4�, �`r LI �1�1,i' 'S•ITI I •y:14 1:I rl I l ' ri, I:1� �titi�' �I I I...1 ti�I �1I 4�1ti I kin I I
cip•tiTat]ooLl Sh 11 lJ'7 'i 1nt(j k. .1 .•'d 7,llt permi.T:ng_ Fir
plc. it, N I 1 t 11 L'IJIr'�IJ .ILi. . e1 I Ls�L_ ��II` I ;LPL'°ti, I ideit1eti. I lilt!'k '..
ti �111 QI• TL BSI L 11L;;. .11 S•I I�•nL Q r1v. 1:11.1 rl.; •
L �'k� i gIFFl�•.II, ti111
n11 5cl]trIL' [mini Etl-ati r:111 S I T{lA' t=lificc for C
. '1 Li11 L1L an P17 L: a 7. I I [1e"I fII i c aI 17 L ii'IJ L]L'tL 12 e'"i1 IuL1tL I I 1 ch_perf.,,I'I'Ii.. L is:e.fit'
I Im�4'I'rl I I ;S I,1�11 1 1 ti'�°i i �°I•'S I Ira 1 .";:'r14' ;Li1 I I' F
�'•ti:�:r�l LTJ ��� h� re
"��":r��''��'���r� .•���' rig � ®i�1r1' r;� rl�; �l�r ).111:' 1 ti 'tiI ti. �• i I l
ti ti
I.'w �I�L �I.�:I�.�1� ;7i7L1 �.:� 1J71 L �7�.17�1'� 1r. the
▪ 1.10..17 1:::1.a11'L,i li t,I,. Ii;'s:L'I L11 r1•,'I S;'1'111 11 L: ,'1.11111;11.j 11 °ic! 111'u11,°:.L 1T1
:II El 71 1,1▪cial JIiLil1i1Llil11EI1c ea l'!er I'i1 t[111 1 L'iir.s5. and 1:,; 11„ I'll11nit-. L"IIrll 'ic"5 Lire LI115Cr^zei"
'rJIIL� III I r.c I'Ie J L!L •Ja:lc' '•kM °11 IILi. be ▪ 17l2ItiI @°ILk 1.1IL=I II.1n ,
I
n 1'espti I7_e tit ('•i •]' C:a Cit .2.11 t i 11(I 111_; and c ei'ti 111 171 en it i .. 11 s, the State of
C)111i,:i.: awl1 P1kwrm:11vMITI41 iC. S1 ), 1I{Iti', �Iii
PFJ`L'L11]1_ lLl h ' 'Ult1til tllI 1_'Lllnr.y [I]inning t'L kiII'J] TltL -r_4, `.Tl,l J'• I.rl 1 711 LI I ti ]k•
Il°l;: lil �7 � IL'I r!1� �11 IS�11.�1 � i l�'17:- I I1 I▪ '1: 1 �1 Ill II'il•.L. Ill L•1 ! IIrLc; 1I°Ie.
til l l r �1'I'Ltiy.�: I I I'4�� 11•� �;.tirl ,I�'L I.1%i it; 0.1(1y
I°l I:. III CLi.l111L_:!:I',t '_'i.liti211i c
ft-ODI t mJ LiT _ n% I._ P" Lind Hai& 'Env Lr'tuL •ti Ll,tLl
L':I i c'' :1..et
�•"� 4. 1 I.I 1. 1 l. �J I I LrI r 4'1 L'1' :1' 'L' 1'or
:1o;1Sr'°ak 111aLl iLtm4'nT progr!.Ln4 ti°tip' tht I t:7I :taTC!
T C Ill i•C 1--11C •i ''_. �- 1:1'1T I r.0'.';°'ti C11;!17 ol 4:iti1 S11.ti 11;1'.:1= Dtve%.117'11C11".
1=T.Htra _.', Act ;'1'.v.r 1 i -°I 202.
1
Reiertrell I hie r i/IA A 01 I'Su i Val T 'i.l' alttire)IfI
IT ti " 'rr1 f T1 Yr I.1 ' I' r i L.I�rn
...° 1 i�1 i L'C n Ent 140 t o rrL n
i 11. L.LItiiLLI° i ' irr I i � Lri tiI1 iri 1-iticEAI ° i�rr�i i ° 11m"1tI•1 1Fl L ur 11
pkinrini.g fiLT-Raltuvaitii for thLir i put
L KEconirne.rid. che pttra ne•eIr°s..ait'l°triter°i a f: utrnuh ti a isapact a es simll+erin.t cr
' iA T .. rlaiiLin1
I ake 0.1-1"8 I 3 tzf
I_ t)I)T1 F.l4'':P161'11 rm 14 ]'i�411 a1 s x 'I r;L:11 i]1 •� I i
(} :•ILr1711i:'II' eSiec Ill[I IL1 -
Principles LII't LI :"imi1L1+S Ni!4 C.!L ' nt
°
Spatial arid to I11 p L°° p a rai1 e•_e of e. :s.i 111 pact:
T 4e1rr1°i1.li�1
&L iteria in cumulative ulative effectsiinapact5. assesssnent IQ LJIPL a=is
() ,iL',IIi I ie.L.r;.2.e 01%cIllr'mIJI; Live i'1� �1 :'rl����:��L_�ti '117L IIIi eIi ':.kIi i,
I1 ].:ur•pc se dii5 prid'iile and aria rIeIlel=a=i017 I tC a FiSC the
ey)LLri lie:; ' Ise ,e1 !hell ,I 1. .permitting.ng. ,IhLs not riiaL. .T ttil'y_ LEI]dunce nut 1.—Jav t±
aid e fe aii'l s h=.o I supersede stat ti�l° �uIit' tip s a rI d rule= re I ati]"I 1 I [111
' .. ,i�•;, Ixti'� I"I�; "� til � .gy N � � ! 1
I• •I l l y I I I•ti I'I " I �F I m L 11 ti Ili 11�•I I° 'rrl l r •}�i�l i tii l �� 4 II I I.I I!,I 11"' I
4"'`_ '�•:° �I ��ti�•.'��: ;�I _ �' p '1'11=1 nu IIg
2.
_':_ t '_
▪Ile,I t-11.1 I°I'ml: III
I�m:1'•:'I m I i. I I}I III;�'}1�;i •�� }III }Im y I m I m I .ti r��yw11 �Iti kl .1;T I I.I- r r�. I I l•I: '� }I��.I�1,��7 •ti.
�" I' W =•� ll r u1 ie of what o 1• Ts I!' slid! otliei
° L
I4' 'I'1,. If.i) • 'API I III%, 1�� 1 m1.:I 'L': ti i �IJ' 1 I°:� I°i�ti'�' 111I�� I I]„ztii:111119. I.i°IC
ti I_m� 7tL�'1]= Lti t:_r�+ L'm.:� •:f �' _']:� EU 1111174 In Th.? first - 1 rrd LIli
▪ I c.e_°i I e,1 I repealee, arld an
}I � �ti°'t .'I" i" --l'•� 'm•i! Im 4.I°' .ti l.I m��„ ;,!Itil ,i�•III •" I I (. . •oi:R !) Ti..; I
• 1 mw;• tip ..•� :�a�� '� ' 1 t � tiyiy " 1 � ' � •� ",y - ti �
i m.�� �.W�� ,.., �����'�r�•r II'.�`�I7: _iI!I"., .'. I I"� I.I lil�Ir �17 IIu.I:!!l!uII° I: iI' �� I:1°_1 h1.::; e
.:�a ''TI mti•7' I m'r I!�1 1 4•� I '.�1 c1''. 1 .;,.gym.I �i m: .. �r' •� 'I i }I�1 '•tii m I I°�a•�`I� tirl�I i ti �
proposed opo action yes_ III I I_I� I I �_+ tl F�.� � �t °�'•__�
11'+r11 I•FI 1•I '••Il A_L ilid%
.F. =:rti III"1I1 I.IC1'F ▪ :! I1 "lir. .ii 1 .°uI1' ;re I I I1..r1C1]ti. ;'I.:t.IF `.,C! i I AAAr A i`r i{tr;:t1 ti t 11
u;'1tirzT ! I;I I
Ilu !is Iir1TT u°u 'I NF.7A IX',-.:?'m:under(I -1'1:"11 1 IIfi. i Il_Il
l i1 Iy a 2:1 2'; I-••I u t 7LI' :IS I14I 1'I1 t'= F 61.171 r .p1{-er 'c r.11u_r - .2'.'I!. IC"FLti' fur li E u _ "u I 1▪ '.'1ST
:1 5:'I I I.III I hv ▪ Ii I1IiiI r r11' 'I'1 II I;'w=t titi:IYm tic I' x
-11fi ri•"-in
N
ii•,Ie !•I' �I I7: I rise ;:�!ICI II' II 1iie 1.81'111c: ed illµci.is,Lanc.err t1' iFi'e
r 1.i11;ti;�.,��,i ;:4�I.!;.'r� 4�r :• I��.:�r ri::i I:m �� ; ���4a "1 R I . 11.
I I 1-.I.Il 1 ilIiLLI i I Ii III Ism .• III 'h:.I[y. f
,1 _ I , 11m 1'°LIti5 rLT1Lir:Lrntr1t 'tind J4IL1 s
:11 I11 Li I LLCI "E Impact 1 i -die Cdie c:1 I =':a eu1'ti'i rii...fil E 1i['Ii at resu=t5. from the i.ncfeinental
i::I'I I1 �I y:I I �I I ti®.114'TI II III!�'II 1 r fi i.. i °1':1 1. For i.'i.:1,1 I, m;I rI LJ 1'.!ti1 :tiii:i 1.:I :I ti;i:-j_i.:11 1 11.' 11,1 i_IT
. •tim-' ,•� m-• m m.� . r r - •m� mom" .� 1 ti._ I. m l E_ . • I , 'Lip•m!oT1 5 rt��'�_� 4.�� tti� �m �ti� ��tiJl� �tiL"� ���:•II I LY �.���:4 �- t r �.�t7�� '▪ m � �s.: 1L
1a I IIts` L.IIiiI III IA IItiiI i;.i '' ilti IC' ItiJ JI I�"'aI' I he I®
he ''I.r j IJ a I m.c m uik on ?).iy. 4.1227.1]
J. r .4 I. 1 19971. :lie Ii L 1�1'I I 1 i I [imp'
I}. !:•I i i ii I I!.:�"I�. i 1��!:•I •111'I r}��� I'pi� m
�in�ll�• L i ;' �t�'r11�J L� - .t m� r 'fi,.14 ti ] J..Li r L .ti m ti m Lm m mx m titi
J��m mJ1�,� I i.J..L� •• t1��I r''� 4�� �� tJl' L.°�1�'�•t]11 _L"!,t�J 4��Jl.� r�IJ t.���_
of a P rcipc ed a L t1 c u I III die context text of ti 1 111111 I ati e et 'e i:'a t.p re I l r and
d
�1 :11�111 I".rri i I I::;:I' '4' � �I I I m l 1 ti11 l .4' 4'I •;:4:1 •°I I I'�r ;!4 IraLik.TICrILL IlLiw ti,' I I I
C11.I.ruL1 m cUTtiil 1 Li I..I n rt lci. ant -LiiIT' k.' such.h. Li 3 rc I I Ltiircr •
ti I I i i i I I I J I F1 1.'t IJ i I1;Ll I"4' I':-}I Iir}r,v s
1..CFQ 1in!'
1 In'± 0.Ii LIi. &ii , II.:11711i ii.:
ti�
= t i .:: ti� ®a t � ' •:tt �'t of
I 3frace effect . f.pariiil deiiFI ' on the err...-,.r 111iient:
'I .: - I�•'i i I I;W 1 — I:1's'4'� m �'L �Jll�I I` ;I"', kI_m' i'uFI I I I i L L;:41;c e:
z� m r ti, , �'�', .i.. m, r m , � tir m ti ,
. I t'°�'�7�Ll=� L�t�1tL n— , :.. = .L rin.ga 1LI J. TJ ..tiipL, pai-.r rLl
13.1 '''Ili '' iliiLllii_ ire:2I ii
m 'I iiI Iim tig I mmI I I — m�'I'mI 'I ml I m '1�ti ':I•LJ
r � �a a ���'Lti �•� m may' � �•� m
ti m- ti•• tiT ti.m m� ti
i tLl� r L'= c'� i.-= 1c� I, E —'i±::t t= 4 fi. m_�' �?� �7 L=�:ti°. �7',�, �!ti� ] ]t •r 1'�. �I L �1 r1 .
3, I`riIItiIlIi:. 1iti'iiriiiiIiiiy'e V.iSrII{1iI
Curnu =i ti'e erj''c.-.3:'iJii '3 t: i5 LIiLII1'11_iI1__ becavise o1'tile d t IICu:tv .-:
i]��':I•II 7 i h _ .-1. 1.a1:Iii'. I{•['kill LI:I rJi1d Ii 117C �I�Iii I�ti ��1®I ���IJII�.�7_� I �: IIIL I�u i''' iiiLi! i{
k1,1 1113]t for r k:tcLu inin .L1 •.Iyprcil:n kitt' and C 1r.L17, Of tii L UI Lt'1I Dirt
H ciWc"C L'.. a t!a!t'�r ��I r• � �`'�f r:,', ti' ▪ ,.ti .�J �� •fi r"r��� :����I i
_�.1 — m I I i I I I°�y._ I"' 11 I .'i 1 I�. ti� ��'4 m 1 �' mtiti .� I••�I
1.I f:i.1I I1iI: ;mi',.. L'I Iti . 1I''. �I �•r�' �11�' �ti I1:1 :., Tti� �:;.rl m �11i.1 :L':.:,111;
t :e .rIct1J.1IL'I auctL.L-...115.
21 : C .. 1E Ili,":, &I ed i•e'I.iiiii Ir!�'Ii' t11 LslI �.:L_ III
OLin:I . t L LIE.y.-•ti Lei_ Ling h LIlt U]. Corrimunity of all.
who has the 'leCi I1 _
m
I 11711 ;';I L I 1):m ti ..ti ti :: iti.1.111 ;-1I 1r1'! Iti rII' % ▪ ti '▪';I II��' Ti.' 'fi"nG m
• �' I•stern. kI]]IJ IlLIJl1a1.1 m _ iffcct d
II. I' 11 ' I •1L_II� �I 1��i � �.1rJ1 � moln ti ti IIiI'II• I y - "I%mhL.•_.'; Or Ali m11 lie um ti':2I';ei �°II•II
II•. 'i I ':I L ii".'i;.rII11���' ill �.'L I li.I!�°I ���Iti ': :II I l ti':' i:!I drt® I: ii '• �114'i'111Fi I iI
3
.IIrow..:'.':1.•
I:I',i iii.I r]1l I•' ;;i i:I
. � I •I •�• �•� L �1 I_� � �I�1 1 . _ .�:�1 I �
I101.1ridiirie t'.' et'_su a:I of e L _
Iii r. Ihe.
7 ou_ '1]Ii!r i t 4':T4'Lr1 .
° CUMLi_�tI ° �7 ~-' - 9 � T-T- r - •1- -I
i^ 'I'e et!e. -_3 IItai• _a'_for IIIaii . •eta °,.., iid 11e LFe tip- = ie acis�11 _11pit
'�I 1®1I I I1i� 4°I'I'4�'q•1
ti
E ith �.tt�_�°t�IrJ °�4 v,1.1 - • �•�• '_LJ± Ling LIST b•ti titLLLily LU J Er:
ie.:Iv'ti •1 '= E'I��L;1c I.'. •!i i': i'II iii''''.J.:-" e f't ':., I'' I:L] '''Ii :Il I'Ititr! !Mit lull
'•
•� � �ell;LIr*1 A R 1-2()(J I-I •ti,�Cull) l%.:Y Ar! rlrl
LI 1 LigElt i[I'd[1 trOntti.d•1S It Single LIB 7J 0 tiL:ht
r . I ] t1 ; ' I u �'L'I prowail I
2.: An In Ivtt hI k7't]01.1 J ni:c:c5skiriyti Jkirga
Ir LI 111 I rej.9.6.6rws rI L' IIi']iilrr trLI I::: I r I' _LII'r L1-
1
41 Thij k1 •I i .tiT1 1l L 4.1 i:Li•' I i c-91 �: � •;:1111�i I k i t ti'11�l .�11 cI rI Ll r r I yr i l
arJeL1uat ly ti.he I JI1po.Ct.L of each i i i'I i' i dll,i l ti=1 r'Iu a n i2s1' uI! 1::f
AL"I.i }I S ;1 Ir iti l e_.
I lie 1I 1 ,I' i,jiiII 11:. v j W.: °IL , ._t 1,„. IL•r� 1.1 1 I-- I e' I11J71aii s :J5 when
•'f� 1 11� I - ti 1 1 1 1 , ¢ I,����.1•I I 1»I� •�. 11 1 1 I 1�• 1 1 I �6° 1 1
��1•�1'°I�'ti, �, T 5�. 1 i� ;I�'T'11 11�:��I tt;��, i,, F1�.11 I. I,� i tir l l �l 1�I 1 �ti 1�ti 1 1 I' '�I;I h l 1 I ;!I 1��1°•� ' I u
_u• i _n
• v
S cII.1 .'.°°J.1 ti'r TLC' SUM Of C 1:11:f ti t't. OE tile 1J 1.1;1�iT.1: of t i4' _'�I'� 1'�1 iu m �J`. �o
1_ n � - �®
I I I IJ C I E ' r I I I'a:11) I tI I }
4 ti.'l l'•� 1:�1:��l°1, �ti�l I I. ` :Il 14.FI I 1'I_,!L:1 I 1.6 1�I I�•:,:I ��[.':I r;:, � _ I�7 tii__ l I 1'1'y' 1 f l I I I I I I:i I i 1 r;jS;: I. (.1i I 1 Itil
LIny;TI It mUI]r on =lk'il' t 1J t i rn1]ut'1 To have c ftCT.111 T T.%
]1 ivr ▪ I iJ u t:!.:1'•,• h!:S r I LLti:. I I 1 :!i •'I I e 1': e
L'I !4' , 1 Ijti�11"1 t 1 L'ri',.i I'I�II'I 114'I i I„ °:°Ir .rI k I k L' �.I'I"111 I I I!l i,'1I I 'I. 1 I'°r! T :i'';l'•1°I I • I r •,�:�ri rr1 iI '
�ti l ti l' eptbc tanks _.L' cith e i ai i I I I a r: or ac e o r,. :tli.icTu.resiuse7. to a reF I iher ce tiiic nh 1'.e
ti 'ti 13- r IS1 � I.y1
.7�IIl. i� 1� III : I1�n �� IIi {'! �:�I'' ti �1'�°,���I�7�17I iIS
L _
r�,_~�:•i'•j I I L ti• Ste;i';I!-•''L'iI,';' L•r??'.1c1;.°i i.I r L. i� °i Iti' SCc•r L.'7!ti'
i' .1 r 5' 'u (II::▪ ' .I° • r c a r i l'. a.� 1 r• 1.1.T i a:.C: , �„'l . ,
v��,rl'rrr�rly r � �Ititi�•,r r r� . .��1 ti ,.a�I� ,'_�®�; ;f � ' 'r �'�.' ; ' T rti ti 1�1.' _r �.ti_
t 1L'th ]&.L •• of ti.L=t.'.'L71t T t= J.:L L1! ti�IJ'_]I�;:� '_� �); ± I.]+�'�.�'i�J � 11•ti _
E.�1 "�.•'I�S I i• ,1ti, 1 1 i1. • 1� 1�,..'�i �� I �' ��'� ,.I�' ;v11 li 1 16; I I II 111; �,��1,� TI.;•ti.
J'i°LJIr_a!'I .:�iIiI i1111 Irti� I��'I11� :�=i ~te,J
I �..i`I lILL�,t,I i iI 3�•�'. I II I�r�1.1J1'1� Lk• •I.�II®®, 'II�.I.tiI I•. � II Li11,:lii + `r�I' I — 'ii Illilt'I.JI�Ii ,
3:: '-ti!�I I� �:°�; t.- 11 �L�L Litt t11 I1L1.4T_ ,IN: '}CJl.
foresee.ahle fuat!'e t.'_i.r.ns
4'1 17.{,:,:11 11�;'4 I�.'�I '. 'I_l' '4' ;'.4:Ititi�k• 1'•:I'i �111,i III•I1litiirl �m:W Il'.I`II II1II,', I'IIIi I i�•;' ,IrI�II�� 4'.h I�i
t4'Ill t° _t k° I :1ACJ ' T4.7. LIU t 4."•nlMO .7_ rwl�. '�m:t'.�:°iL`I 1 : 1,_ti. ''�J�1, %;1 ._,t 1! ti]]l'` tli 1
4. i Lti 1I7 i iir: I IpArsiiiiur!Le.rs w 1 IWI]e f 1 : li IFreslmi 214Li iiiin s it I S'111.
permitting
In..c t cal am:c L'• t[j th •J cf LL1]t] .'Li 'eumalkitiVe Irnpact pr ti•]ou !v detinc.ci 311 4=E 's rule
in HA.R I '01) I_ and d the ce a rc Ii .n the i I1 I :' C ISs Office
I� iII ' I'l1 II ('I wI Nil ▪ � E �I:ial..I I C'�i ti•I I��I Ii I���•i'I}I �� � •� � ��•� 1:�4 � � � � ,. � � f7 L"[ � rti����I I'•�
LIrC two cr tic:ill 7LI op,: past, prc=: Lit, ;And. rea .:mably fore iJuur.'
iit need to i e tai eri into aL courit I"'i L urrm aci e i r pac assessments_ h J.:'Ip.:? ,7• spatial
. � :'L ; 1
�ITI� Ivlrl 1 '1"" '� '"T ti4 'rrl �rl•• ' '� I•'°I� ill �ti� �T iy��� ti 1IyI� •tIK IyI
y . g rts.:'LI1'ccs and for dnk•'Lrtti11Lftnt., Each •.f±LL'ttd"I c.c.o.s '`:t4'lt _
lie term..., or mit.i 'T
4 ;-tiI! i �������i I '��I� ' ITI I � ;� IJ I ,r� � r•��.1,, � 1:1 i �I I I L I L:1T1 I ic i;A
currmlacive effecrr•i—pact fisse s]I]eiir! i.�uLd he expanded to the at which a specific
ti 1 I rtit 1'.. I nil I''r, Si'ri I iiriI Ls are io..1
tI affected c p.m-tics. L'r1'ev Lr,.L. t - •rLzLTJ L and 4 t4.nnit1]ll e g''og ap..]; •.Lld ten ttil'ni
s:co..pe ni 'u riuuazi e etTecmiimplizts ill,the •1:'I i' ii r`I [i rc.ces- can dh -e ri
the ti.l 14I;:.0 li I•:;'I I i IL; ;r 0i rI �•����rI� ;II L,I�, I I I��4 ;LI��I T •�I r�•� � I�� li�;� I�i�ti�l
fii.ct5. Giv tt that exi.stin elfe; tslimi ets Linc]lVsi pA icl an,.a. from
'_ .i ri I i I',I' 15 Hill I Lti'v.l k'I L'L ip the 'o17 I I or Ilse SMA,
r.
r1 ITTI" �Trl "TI �I14�,111. I Is __ ' A :;0. � MJ1'I'I yxy: 0011VTI
. )aE 61 Pilld s open:of the iwuui-ti'.e io eiirip i c a L.ssii)ents..
V.th reEpeet tc' ; ti. seL ,setting:-t eueousit e•.L'at1 li Lit an L L'•tLL' L Ln ▪ gun
a.:1 t h e S 3r•1:1. hnundary I n wt h e cu Lr p...r juEisd.iction. re dttvela rica LTAi rI i INt
�I������iIIP�.�ai ��®I � tiI. �I a�• ��:�11:i�' � � ����.' � �w�l�� ' � � �• k��:� 1i HI
i ire iIi I �� in ]� �I ] I i L �▪r 1I
i �ht 1 1r d ._ find t t n��L t L 1 Lth _ . _
ti .. • ,�' r�L•�•.�. �1°J.1�1��� InL � w •
.I LL F 2 zialirilLN tidal I Lti• h. ' ,„ ii'I ▪� ti�� � Ah ,:illTIL. d 1•.
ti 'LIri �i,r :. LIT LIMITI, L4I r I ' 20 ri. ] .F11.'l Aoath oxIii 6IwI1
shown 011 311Ch !naps filed v. th the tint„Iut.e ' ,. Co 11" rrni'
die iI i•I� II"1 I�� �I iii ;•iiii ii.'I1 II 24 '5:1177'`ii 4, ;iiid L L1111 ICII'Ci.1177LIIii11'i
e ti c•`_impact HE L S41t •:_Lit= LLL Slik•L' 1' nl;1 LTJ L. 11 H pIar :pr' .T• and
=I]e "•1r; ['nun dLliy as a spacial tarii]reccL =t no cuidical iL 3,llks on Iti a.s_IL I' urcc$ or
4TItiiritiIIirI4'1°i {i 4' TkIIbe.C.1 °_�•�.�II�I �I°I S'e1A Tilt: 1. !Jrki[Iii��4: i'{i iiI' iJij
7.0 t.h " 'l. in]and bounui.il-y: troll] the .11or i1L1c his the minimum 5patial. scope e TC. kiSSC 5 ; at
17LI rti'1e17I;)I Ii°t Iii I 0 1 1iI'oEic., ei° JuIt" II 'iii Lti l:' ti Iw II L � �L ;°°' •�II°I I' r�. Iw III' 17L:
l I: :I c ri}Ili Iy
!1iI.11I'°ieI' LI°iie1 Ei it;1iie1.er iII:e 1:2 "
fllt�lr�� l.i:uon; tc' ;.1.4 4 S t if (' .1Ln p ic1 rc SI.L t!"nL from a prop.;cii
..L'Leason3b Iv foreseeable- ac ri c n ale ti c. e :liar_are Likely to razh er than those. [ha:.
�Ir�' rrl��•T 1.I.ti. iti � 'i l,l tip. f i•„• i 'I I uI i�til �'Lai l II! it E � ��ir• }`III I• r 'i 111 ty
�• LI ���� I . fir.��.I ti � . � � • �'ti 4'��..I ��' L I LI �� I�� � ; �4!
that 'c o Lrti.a[ to ovalap rerriporallv 'ail a pr pc c 1 project, Ii
I'�!:•���J i I it L.a I se Perm = I rp[c LseI.' T1_ lt�'it � F.r. i rCirWirmz n it(=To'ity ( ..TTral 1u; : r i i 1 nti1 ;I; ...i�.irr�•ir m ?ro yr;i if
itiir -'lc C..7'.!-Ti cii;ictti hi- 4.Cr I 52I H 2 J21
tip'i 11i I7 I'1'..-1111 1 i I LLB;L Lt i ti'• --i'.I7 [1.2.1eni.ial I,I 11'1 e Li i i . ; IJ 117
i]1c LI L rTI. II. 4 I.:f I''.',:; C!A:i.I 1 1:1 I. I I L' ;:I ilk' I I 1 r1 L' E]1,4, �,ti•:: y' •:I l l,�l'm ti11 �'����
action: the 0 13S L) m i n i rmarn ti fF 5 e .i 11.1 L' I.-J, ci r` :lie
a 1ILr I'IlI L I a I'�'r I I 1 :�1� iI "��• 2.; �ti ��ti,,. .. ..
� I�� ��L1 � �1 I�I"Yk��x •ti � ��'� r � ;I� �rti7���II��� par'�I II�l�1' I��'•rti�_I'Y�I� �I�J�I r�t�ll��'17�
within tii 5 •L. ▪ for Thc purpose 'if ]Jl
perm i t.6I1!_
L'
_ w 11 .. Y �• 1�_ Y 1 1 ti 1 iT 7 f ��� 1
TER: t:_Lti=a"ti .1T.•'°_ o til L=� L ". ' 1' •iL, ,!.id I ti�'�' t_' u w 1 ® �.:n L®�i 1a �i�°I a J W :.r Y..:u!T�.LI L 1,•
I11�"lit 1.1. Ih: LI.k 1'Ic-L.ILL �I 1'� I ;��1 ''I".:� �II'I'��'�'�� ALL j,I'''�'I 1. `�"r1W 1L11 r-�'�' 1 i i•', ti'�'•IJIk1 ! IIII I�W°ill
II.1 ,: l 1"l:Ii..I1:!: _ •,'. ti!:I k' I HI.I'I I'. :1.",I�L1-���-:, '' '•I
et,ec wIJIl :att•a- I .���
r �__• f� r. - Hi �� 1���I ��•� �'1 ti'_ Ole� ���`J���� L'�'c opJ IL=er..,1.:: a::
ti y 1
I L1r! :et �y ti I,I
LrL 1� AIL III� ��L.I r ti 1 17 1 7L ��1 1� I��Y.17J�1 Ilr:= I�Y��'�11_:�.ti fl� �.111�� tirr��1111 "II_ I'1'•I�•
• L• L
cl.u's or I]1 rti .jL practicable from 31W]'_c L7tL:u of . ,pp:.I'o..'!J° 1ar 1 r-1_'t LI ti L i::
and up co the l i feFpa n of a scru.ctu.re or the operiitl ti I7.:1 I I i_-e Y.if a pp.pled i..1 ti F I e _ as the
11ti;Ji r11�L111
5. 5'rLt criteria in cumulative a efe'tsrirpads assessment
bl 1c111 l 1 mid '.1111 111.1 F W',',1 Ve ti:17;�4 1 111���I 1 }I 4' 1T14'TI 1 1T1 I"I L�r�
perm I I t[LLI I1 process Iuiu::L he coaducted wider t 7 of t 1 e K^wa i i Law 1 1
anti L'':is ' es ill :he ('7. '1 i;j ... provide Lp,irr1I' 'I 1 i r! L_'I L,;I:L1Ic'' I.'' !he i
1'
Yi L LLTJlstra7io J t�T. - c' SM.A. permit° y tc m. The I i4 ti pL.I.icics
I !:•I'L��"I 117{�. 1'esk IJ rLe
- I I I:ti1"l 4 LEI r 4 � I '� ��I;:. I rl �•;�L I. I::°rr 1"Y;:�1
- c,nic and — I'LI is .part c p itim
L ,••, Beach and e t I (Julie
I, Fi Il C!:•I.I or!
- r�: :I I I�l 11 I r. �I 4'
®r':l iIii I 'I AM ;Il7Lt Iiit ;J1'I;LIII;JIi;i ;17 I
L ti
. apply tr..) the S LL, lit LI_T tial] be
c'to:ed :rim the of mLiV p"-Toped.' -i"'th..1I :he 1 A r'�11111II1111
,
'�y,:•I 114' ▪ ®;1114 k� I rl 4' I r"I 1,1 I ��' J ' W I;:�;'t 1;' ,:I'W: 11 r1 i31 I I•;:ll l l 1 I.�::J11 .:1111 I'I tip`' �.
1 e1'.e1Y:-:re IF ')F I -17;LI 1.11e G.: 111r:I1t., :And s]7
ti, 11 '1 1 °: I I F ,! 1;1 I'y"' '� •W I I Iti• 11 1 T;1,l L I' Y. L' I I r1 1 I Y. ti I 11 r1 I Il W 11 4 Y• 111 11r11..I ;ti l' °!
i_. LL1lit;LIM '5 n+.c•'ir or LJiU7 d: pl''7C cfir='= t111,1 ',13p1;:iaiti 011 p'7.t
L crlcll:
F Y?'..10 Li1 1.".,' 1�IIT;:`ill_ t 'i:t'7 iZtIA:111 belch d Inz,'ticliri l 1alto1.
'arid v..1:al"' I.1'1fiI tAr,.51`rniFliV t{'t It Niii IIL I CZN,1 r'L ci a Sul m_}Asti i11,1 I LII ]
Ffac cr111;1 . 1 ice'fun-frier
''�I "1"I„�'I 1 ,� 111~r:10r_I0F iT1'.T tll'l11 Il.1ri'1'e C rttCF:IT1 paL"c :isstcc111erlr
1!
•��' I '1ir: as ]iI;ii Lickibig I1' rl'i the' ;i:[ ii21.7i.i1i. J11J4l1.1]1 10 IIJe
' }a :
d L:Ieici'1°I
h.Ltt I1 l I f J i to SF' 3.. a ..ti _L'L1P 11 I L ra.ditt3 til iL I I Je other Iiti=I ifi 3
;5 Ex I en i ci n I Ie F Ilirl'J I he SM Lai°LEI'IJ ay; 1112 CI:rii1,11 I• �i I I i i.. I IL 17 t ��1�"�.
1 _
is Effects on omtstd1 '.'n':cr Th.:. C )I objccti'':s Ling i''1 urU ]iTJ I
I_• 'i i!.! .Fi�' rr!IT1'rr!I I1 I I bl.:ci i i;1! um! I i' I!i.ii:.I';'1 •:::11 ti' I::L Ii ri I �I! ��'.� �•1_® I�11 i�l :�,J1T14'TI 1,
].].i. tvuip;:cil Iii.']..LI scz.tc.s fGr
'rI I.:2.24 1 1 e F uij ec:: n.] i i'_ i I: ;Ir I II IN : !Aril.i I ir;iF,
.'I'�I. fall, �J i::,��tir�• ''I :tii IL'. P I I.:;1 in 1;; N i..i.Jiiiil ;:,I 'ic' 'iii j!m.`..1. .;•. '
envitromileiiral L' e n l n I c al ttemt Oil _7_ti C';.: •::i i .1.1.17 Fay MCe FT ft 1i1 i .I IF:
= L1�1ir i _1111' NINA Pi') III .205. -22.
ti
• _t �: 11� I:L ��1 I .i ri I 1 I i rii to r.Na _ 1 • : �+�I'lt I 'ti�_11J1�1 �=I�'� ��=�~='.11111��'' �- �� '`' � � � IIL�1"at°�II1
11 L' I J I I III 1,E : I„ ti, 1 1.' �
; r �:� � � I ti . � y'',1�I I r1 rl t •y.� I I� 1 �.1 I�!�.1'I.• �111� � �IJ I � 1 rl���. .4•�'���I 1 r1�,1�14:1
•"°T 1 ti ti 7 ti 1 , 7 �' 7 , 7 1 �' ti. 1 1 , 1 1
t��t11'1 nun kl t tir :�J 1�1�..L't Li tl_'�. tii'4 ri rnLtt 11 .1L71t_ �t . �'�i J.t �:.r�1! rut t�. tli4 I�- i!Act
1
ill IeIJ L �.
LJ1
1
1
t ail li; J_ ( cif 'i�JJ���I i l� F:1L�'�� �S 1L1 r `� As.s.itiss,Jit :1a1°I h,\LA.
-r. J1 :,.
I):1tiLIuI
e .
.. I E of In. .0.5r ffprli:'
- J71:I I I ram, - ini rjo e5 5
' •I .'r i I i.r iv! 1!:I 'W'_'�. I'4 ,��i=t'� I �'1' -ti.�L'�t _IL' LMJ I�� k1z�
1 r° IL LIJ�1 cll..'
a= ac=1'ri [....La.::i able fi':'oi _11? FrupiPs d
lip
ti ��1T1 d i r'ti• from m 71].t to tLtc
..Li]JI:•;JLIi iii IFS ��1';:'I'(.
re ciiite:
H S;.=ric
I
Stiei1I and
•
r I-.I•i1': IrIiL
7 fi ;:L:II�I.IIIriL�
1...rotecri'I1
6
b1w. e ruaL ".
11i71i1:1
rL' ::. "mouth.,
ICI �1 '°Ti
rill:11V
.0LIUI,
l�a
��.�ricttiti l
JJ
IJ2'. ..71 Ir111i1
I C.'1 1 I'iti1 1 I')I1'w 1 I 1= % pt:c 114 tip•a i TT'S 1-1 -' '�� : '_•I.. �I I �1�1 I I ti -- �f I .' _�•:;• ti=a ti7 i°ILr17II:I1
p:1s_ II
!._-L 1 r "L•'� ':ti�:•1'.1 I I ..1'a'I'r�:�' -r' tii�I i,.I I�.I IE _�:•T 11'.� 1ti �,'�'iv 01x1 '`1 I.Ji Ii:r :I:Its.�'ti'I r 1�I ����r•�1' For
L •
.I 11,:•T:I I�JI w.ti}I I 1 IT .IL I°j lresi:I A ril IiJ I:I I II i' n I I0I i% I-'111111 i I 111 111 '••1L 111.1 p :-Icc 1ID I I°m
I lie r�: }mot I:��' �ti}ILI I :"•1r�11111:1 ii I:'r:•I I I��rl°_ '�r l 11'.�J'�;�I 1,J�1�'�i L ;Jo 1,J 1J.ti i 11%.:: ��l lei �I ti iI:•Ii° 1'Lti_���_�.:I'3k 1'11.IJ_
I ii.'i i Il lrsri 'x 1 I,J 1 ril!1i L I: Irt kind 1LJ !Lie � 1�1°.:I IL'�:E r::•�JJ1:"11�.I::•1
e-iTiLL1" iiidiL(„74 fil ii I 511.i ve
tt[7.01.1.41 110:defined iinctel c'haprei •- 4r.ificanc effect' 311C1 C.11111111
[111.1111i:1- 1.{&11, Ili& I 1 I .11! iTiiii'll. 111;11 I Iii[lAC1 ,111 IMSf '11P.V1e1
13.. Lind HA.R lit,pacT aE
.„ii
▪ rh L I LI i11L1 U iiL curtail Jac
16.07.%.:. I he vizi.iniiierrird
1:iiri. kir ;lit;
e. e. coniniuniry and. S[are I. 11.Z.S .:.J4_ -2j
1:i ▪ • th;it ti I tE thiz
cuf 1!a5:: 1.-.1e7:eni.. and. „realcn.31111,.
• !!.. 1111111."1(e110."-;
1 iL:fiT: 1.!...!I b LIT C:01.[Lic:TIVid.:11-1
ITLI;22 • ••:.! • 11!)it 1 I N. Su I I-2C.H.J.I -21
I 111'. '11▪ 1 ▪ 11.1 - ! hi..1 iled .ficance C1iEria. Inc I Lidi.nia
A 5.i L.1ii
I co'!Wei'
;Ai; ::! :_•I- . II I I I% I II ri:Iiirriviik,
- C kir :;
ea ▪111%!,.: nti al Jd-....er5e effecl Eke e...:Cifif.)111i re_ ..71.
- EL.Ve ,,...'1"fc:ct on 1)..0:Ilic
advene SeiZO.Tidar: iiiacts. 511Cl1 I ation cIirie %IA effeiz[s cli rllilli K
— L111:15,1aLl.T.ii.1.1 0.0 LI] C.1.1.F.L:OD111C11.7 .]
".."A C11111111ilt.a.':eE'!," lia.ve ad, effect
1)%r
- i I. ;I 1..;i1 • IA] 4,'.1141misiiiv,ii.3 Ht.-.
I I i il r I I Li 2:5.e
- [ lull II III I L II L I ii 12• I....! I I k
II! .1 F 1 I I I 11 I flood
▪ IV
— 0!.1 ...1.1.10 icA1,p]ar.1-.:.s,
;I:
I iii: •.11, 111111iiiri.%. .Aiio.1 r..it !11110.11.
i11.1-21.62:21:11,1 117 2.2.421, '17-21-A1 ri 1:1711.17ity .111.71
j
'.1'r:r;iiI:i'_�I I:ti �''i:t :!".l:i�' II_�i ::.e IeI111:III-ii: i�1i•L I'I'.LII
1 1 _
Irvin ._ _ i. .1��T�I I I�TI. �I 17 1 I ;�•�1 rl
i:Iecet'Lr1 I fi ar_1 on I:eL'11;I:7: i I1 i I1 or lie r111 and , ,l; perm 1'111 I r exe 114ltir1 L; u
ir LI 1. 1 m [i I'iI II. 1`:.:•! I -�Iil d ii' _ aJ;o I�r� I�ill _ .I'IC I�r•I il�:.l17��
Critt riLI hi_i'l]cJ Lii coustrz.i.o..:4.1 Ti_ I'il iL iL. kind SNI.A. g LI iil.=i..1..Li.. .
l I I• 1�11i�1 Fa 'IiitiI: I Yr 5.'I- �,..1:L.ril�i:: ri, eti:l' 1i"1 y°I;ti�ti�'ii.li! 1i:11
rum it, ii11-ltiitii�L� ��f: 1= rh°I1'7 ,:•li I bi. 4r1I:9at to . OTfl4' Tiarm. o
'r'I��' iii' iil. 1.'� iIII���• `.I�.11 ®III ]lI'I'��•i�: ��L .ILI!!:li 111!, Ili) 2.1
�'ti:�iliti`iL:;l.l 1'I :4`I_ I�altill!�r 111 Iiti .l!:�'i.'�,llli iI:_,i.TI i�11 i�:l•Ili 1�1!:i�lk�� ,:1.1.;A:11 'ill ti] 'r•° _'�illlll
spec i k vi.e 7.v :I1:l assessment p i:.°i.:'. u I ti r3 e i i;:,:urae.eJ 11pu.i i ri a =ta 1,i!aL thze d
Iii�II and reI:LI 1inL! Ii:o.ct s
I`f'.I L r,i :311 r i,:.0 171uLa=1;r' i:: rR. .0 ice �I 1"a I ti 11 I I'1
"' I'�'•I 'tirl�11�1 1 I1 '' �}1:1 I I" ti1 I''�:I I L' rri I ig;!I i c'"1 I I '®I•. I I°_': i I I I I=' :1 til I I I 1 I I"I:� I I ]���_ ���I CI'"1
DJ71 SC. i fl_tlLl m-iin Z.L1.4i'iir ;:,L1 I I k; F .. ptopiu.Ecd i]Ill l i II]cnt-e i
Eli 1'uiiieiiIrJI Fyn' eI!I[i17iaiiI Iri I'e Fio17 '
L _
� I �
' I `�:1•�:°��I I�I°r�°,: �1 I•�'-����,��I I` I i 1,1 {I I 1 i,�i• "il I iti1;L��11,.71�
ill SP ]:\ pertriitun to ac.hiece W:t11 The ar_d 'iI L°'9
cl1i� II17 � 1112 . I17i1�.iu.Ie
and. 11_•^_17[en auii: iuieac e5'.
Y�I'�;�It III I r��il�!:•I.I�iri I wLI'C 1;.Ii II iii{tip I �� 'I. ....unit:. and u:illiu i i7�11 1ti Ili u u
L
1%11"1 i°I t MITI L] pr opii..W I.° I'1',.rrl �ti�l 1.�11 r{i. ;;7(1 ,1 LI1% i i 17•,.(I 1 i I I I .S I, 11;i I 1 1u1'
Lii is coon of head' and ':. ,istaI d1Ir�e
1 � 1
..i i!:•L1 i ir ':i L i r �1�• ���'I:1 i �l "�'1 '�ti
e
—
D1'!]1 r1:i!!'"4: I I�11,ti:° I�' °'I 714'rl L tti Gi_Trr,ri_) :I:I.'11 I I I I!I L:(!;:ti�I i ',•Y;!;':„���ti
L'IT:.111:1,'1Iti 11 ► f'a.'If1l_1LIl I LIIre I 7• :hiiireiiPc and ocean.
—
Lr ;IT 4';1I111 11vi1Lioi ',, :lriL] ,F1 1171 ��'�.�I�'ti:lriL.Tii. Ii) i' I ;ii:
3tLi1cn1re 711tih .a aHiLi=2Ie- I11iI " re !dei1 e. o1: a sliorepiI.e1l3L'ceL
rluluh11hit•Jk.41 •ffutsiimpkicts a44cssiiicnt has been r.q11i:A:4J Li'r' :CEP A. kind HEI',L Ii
several.. decades_ I I1 accordance wj I1 b.O's new uu I L iieJ in: 2020 and L'e al't J1
�lil T•. �,r r 1 I i ti'ti;'i,' y:r i I r i1;.trill Hr..P. I I r P.A ;He 414.1 i l I� ' 111'tip 11
l�rt�k• LL' Ll] yin!' i to how ;I4't ni]ilti.:tuu11J Latr 4't 4'�' �`ul�► .�'r •.I�•'_� 411��ti LLt. t�' 11Ct t 11L
I L[i I11'e®1iiF ii. I lie Laci.. [I JIE:11 ni5.1 ieniporal IIli:7L
i.lii,i.lh,111 4' `:II�: .LL:�"'1171 ti . ;' IT�'Trl �1 11'1i 1 '111'.1!_ 1101 Li i1' i11 'l▪ .u, lll'I;i1'�° f}ril }11�i II
evaluii.ri11t!. bAs and hJS- Ifi lC,f!..IISCtri01 • %L e' aurti..-..ii. The 01.11::;ID lia7conducted
i'ir! :! I 1':1i;11 1 r/ .A:I I 1 I 03 12u_iI 1 I)'i. r17 2010 1i) A[il„iL (1.12C.1 Ihi4 2,11; r�
cases_ t Jes.YF].u.kil i `
and hI speiL.fically discussed or applied spat and [e1npi '3I I1=ra11le,...e supe the
111,i ti L LEI S�I I�° ail �11'' 4����1 I u. LJa kirk' :] .L1 i tii:! 1°ri L:i.I rri iJ :1 1. h'4' •' I��'�,.I:1171 r �l '� "•, L: 1714,'1 i L:ti
I�°Rr�� ]J1~• ti•ti 1. (ic:.0 of Fini.il E.A 4 u1T1cI E!5= simply I.f rrcd to tJ141 definition
•:I �'Llutill�lt L
14
I iii]7 t 1 rJ l l i,l well iii ad• SL.i. 'i ii t 171 ill'17�ti r7 ti t'I`° t i:•�1177�1111 11' 'wy�4 t` ''•�:'�.I I I I��I t I{ Fill I I���I
]11';ti[ti�1 L,d I.11' �I!.. I▪ •
1 ILr"L� s •; IIL I ..11.2.10.11,.I� Ihl'''rrid:;e aJitiI III.,II ill ell ;I '''IN11111L �i:LI �1� 4 L �IIti"Il�r�ti i
with Thy ;:L T.1.cm. Ti an EA. •'r EIS 4 t e UppordEg 'i OC I.J[jL n. f..r `1 SM
use, pei the L)J"'L that Elie 1'tlh"IFct h.1 iet i iLLII ' iLrude
L'I ,1 L16.1111 I till '▪ , L' I i1 L'=11 .:"rI I 1 L.:ti}J , 1.17 :rl°1''W :I'I r P.:7;
_ uL�1tt�...•rl 1� Eirr.1 [111 gkifiLL.II I L_ec ti.u_LIl'4 ..,2oTJ�tL ucT']LPL'_. "y.l.o..„
L'a.I. Pr!ir :ri...1„.=Ill]:..JC.I, 1 •I C110I i i. i it
(II•.k 4'I�i JJ I I I.. it..
7..
keeon ri]en da ii 'r.
▪ f r TO p t.t 1;1' C L I L I I. f r o L7j �I
ti
I i r°`.p'i � ti I ',rl "1 �=W_ I'l l L�� or l i l �." J7 C ra t t Ja t as def.I1 ed.
Ti' .'II'II L. 'rl.i.]I. rHl';IT' L'I'5.',;.'",ti'ei111p(R:I : •li I\f. T1L''1pn1'I,1'1I' ,
-ht 1JI'SI) ra a u L n: L.4]5 t[,tiiT tii S IA ti15°5'm'..'nr pi ci.,'i'11.1
11,71. ,:I :''. III I 11'I.T L.rrl l.. l, ▪ ''I ti}1,51 H
r esu r i ii from a l rop.2.7:e [.i 17 e r the criteria s recl in I able
are.
1L71�' iILL rJtLIt L.n p Lis tiiui:1 too] :'rIr;ht r tLin'J LiriJ zi: +1ffcL't4.i1tp..cts
assesstrient in
w_ A. Ioc itst.0 mnp al p.as. pLI:•:_ L.. .in ;: V.E.cj3.I']y LInit.= kiL'ti.."n4 rh .-ha%
heel' wider ; 1:1:i i. I:I•ia;. 3IitL e arid ..erripciral I iil�'.Itiltltl'� Isar"
1� e,.. I 1 I I I�.'. L. '. .r1 111 I.I A 1',I ti•L'
t4'].]].p_..l'Li„i„, sc._l:1.1 the '._.];{T7 C LI Map .h .'t11(..i aisCH 1:11.11;.::_:',1 i��i�.`.'..r'ti ."I-.•l
L' 10 S s° 0.1 7 1"I i i rti erI1, i`) 1k1(:,clur .J
I(eferenct s
� •1 ,r1 1 e�•rf I�r r,11e , 1 1771 ' r11 el" � i r r r e.� 11' a er� r1 ,�W7 a 'e'
I 1 1� J'ILI 'Y 1 1 1 1�1�i 1�.� 1 1 1��1�•�,. , +'1,'' I1. �• 1'{.� 1 1 I11 1 u'1 � ,''�.�i'1• rY �} !.1 '1 1 ,1.1
r L.
r l' 1^'r rr�l'�`i<.r��I" r�r�� t�� •I i �.'2.tll 11•i. L i ii ii. 11..7°1711 '1=tLi LLLI=t . I-11=31 J31 e. I-t ei=_
• .7, 1 , L' !_ 10 1II II ' I'�•Wrl'�.,
It wJil 1.4 'L. .e.•..L•.. .'•• :ni'I_k '.k ur .L nt:P-- . -_ I- 17-1 I Ia ;`2 I I..-1- ,9. f
L W 1 1 _L �L
i i1 ��'_'� �.'I I '�:ri i'L rW�'•t} �': }t��.y ;91;L•1 1 11.It} �'r L i t}fat r Ir:I u l' �'t � t' � �'` ��r�� �'• ' r° :L Ii Liz 'I I I I i
1-Tr. I't�rl l�l�'1 i i ��J'I;�y I",'�_ , }j i i rp�1 i•1R. ti 4
ff^� 1 ,r 1r W � 1 7 1 1 � ., 1 e; 1 1 7 1 y
a I J: L.'LiL ii? ?I�1 i 1 , , 4:7, L.r•'.' (I 1 Fie''I ,i ti 1 , ,' I .1IL iL I •!1.1iu 111.";e4V :•1,1��'-f!4i 1,t;. L7 IL r i i L I i
e
�I"I`' 11' Illtiltl'i .iI IrJIJr.J�'�IJl ll�a '�'rti 1. di M1.•1'''irr I)i=I':°II e1611�11• �r''� 'I 1'.IIi;I W1 IWW�i11�'�11
I.C•..LI+ .Ill,_ June .I! I5
'�- , fr IT � 1 1 4}}� 1 ,, ""e 1 1 Ill r 7�~�f f11 �1 �-n ,f1 1 �1 1 r 1q 1 f ,•��•f1T
J�o.pci .I ._ti. " '▪ 1 1 1 I. j r.�. L r�� 1 L L�1 1�:ti f�.r"1 1 e 1 L1 �'. 1�LPL 1�1 1 L�ti�1. . L r.� I I?I 1 1 2.1..,l I F • ,!_,)L L 1.h'
LIWa I 1'r.F i I IIti r '▪ �:I I 1 ���1�l 'I 7L1�1 °• �°'1TI�1 •LTFI I'1
2'ti I] i
�'�I I tir�°, • I' i'� ����t�e'� I �I�'��L�°," I. ..�i'I:L , �1 7���� L.1 L� ti1 li e ;'I% I I A yL l t i°I 'I I 1 1,L.",'..I•
rl k m 1':II 1111 Ell I.I 'I 1,2 I I.I1 I I:I: ,•Lc] I LV1•
111
Curoul.ti risi ! r'ip ttS and file Special Management Area
County of Hawaii PlanningD p rri riL {20 )
Rule 9::
11 1 I 1E' i AI 1 ,111 11 1 1 it y. 1'1"� II '��1 I11 1 �•. �•�.�, L L •t. ,•1.� 1.:1 r�t.I,r r 11.'.�., LI.L•• L1.'� ���r�'i�.Li r,_ti: ���_. 4J�'�.r m�fr L1. ��:'_�LI ti ti 1 1 LI •�'r"�� LI �'�.r�`aiiiC r.4"i.
Vol:f.a1'at odifEvse L ri L!III Nil neater?rrterr or ectillogiirehi effect rflr 1:F1�� •"�a'r'It�! �' ;'t�I LI I 'I ' � .1�'t'I I u'i'I 1.1c.
f,r. ,.� 1�� 'r ���' 1 1 ,�, 1•,t,�y'I' tim ��. rlt.'�rl t1'� L�1 t.''F' ''��''rr'�:�' 'rl�' L1L.11L'I�L�1'I L; *L' 'fir 1•'.}.r�,W°_'�1.
3 f E �•1 , r 1 E'� _,i i.
'"'�'�.'�'I I�f"�i�Y i�tl����1� � 1 •� �����.�f° '��"I'I'�;•I I 1 �� �'I� �i�'�'�i '" the Ei.'ITiaL cur e 1-.rr e nt,
'r 1?i��ti'���1� 1�# RZ•!I!�"� ti 1''i Ili 1''� �'.i 1'� a r' 5nr.1: 'l riff,'fI which ich 11075 C 1''TIJ..11griv inpict. or 13 5 can ti ti`
oofver5e.en piroininrre r or sc 4-1logicrr effect t .= . F oiri•r'1.' 1��1.1 mo1;1a 'i ^°t �IIru1��JM
' 1:1'
ri II !1�1 I 11i.i0.9 1 1 titi r ' :i ,• I '{ •. .,� � '�ti. ��• ,• ti } ati ••_•,� 1 �,•E'1 r,1,1r till':71 1 1 Iti• .ti 1• F1,ti ti .+ Iti
�.������ ����'�.J � � 1 � �' �1 �' r�� ����1� ���� ��i �� � � � �YV•1�I.�•�I ti•. � �1� 1 til L �.�: ��ti 1•'1 I�'1�.�9�• 1 1 ti. 1
GI':'�•.".'!t:t' t �' • J �a �� Oa.;or lithich may Piave. ( Ca: ifigatjva il] Ciit Di 0 I tQ.1l L~hJ1, c' 1e. ne.
t 1 Liiifro °ae1'r "fi1.Q 1 logical'.'f 'C 01: 1' g l gcri;eir..i Arc tl
1
The pr rt1Ci OSSESS L..'se5., Is m_`I V!ti . Gp C r•r C ois proposed ,r E, OaLI•ilI 1F yyTTL1 rti � 111 1i[ •I
.V a_ .10 i/r ';.17 L'i' Cr0OilFtirl t ...11170.7e prt"'QcLe �?_ ', G t"C;vi l`y or op ero Iti!r1 YC
E.CEE .5UCr.f. ,in L•'a.IL:'cfi,"',° r:•.r b: hove. 1:111p6Ct, or o giigirrifietrrq i3 r eTivi n r?tLVr c
O CEr EjfECIL on (".tlE _pEc'c I'itib"G'g'E.1°r'C11'L t,1:1 13 co:-' thE o izEzs."1e i t p1'ora.J..,Yt's n10.1i .511
'•,'°O,1.1E.1, 310 [1'72 opQ1,''iG'1 it 0"2th iL1CI the 1L h11 1 111 1_5,:'1 i fOr u � ��'YL 1 I i Li I i:1�F:"��11 all'„It ,rE.1 !:1_ Pef i j 1'[
Ou'rfLiVillt Ca sE i gr1 7-1 1.
1
tc'iL1''i „Q'rGL:,r C'sE d LEE G c ti' I ty c' erof'ari rtOt ;in e.xeNsCif$5 a 000 i!"I
't;w11:61 rig s CUrr [.riltrfr'v 1:rinpoet., Or Cr SCrbAtant rii odvgyige.i t ori rh Spe ;of 1'rici riogein=1r''t.-1(EC I.,
C G'+r2 r rE view by C 1-.,E i L.��L"', L l•'o r, _ 'L i r.t"t ".r c r m.."! c'i ce f'I.'t ' 2 7„cfo�}c forTh.cf t h E a.recilzir
r1.'1!i ,!=LI'.. (u SA4.6 r.'i.'1 tr"'.r i E r 1'"'1•'2.
1 _L'�I'�'I
�7.11 1i'.'(rti ti'. .'i.: .1 63c:ore thcG't Li SpEc1'G'' I'r'�tir1'1i '_-11 i ,- reG' USE ' e,'1'n't '� ��'•� ��''�1 .+ 'T_ 1'5 fci.'Ir'd that i i he
proposed 4.15e0 activity' air"'operation 11195 ci V411I1Y`eii1f? in iF e'Ec Cif$500,000 Of May hove Cr .0 5 1:rr'rf rcrl
Ii v . COI Thi- _ p P•rjr.i 1 111.4 . ,,'PiJ
9-1 1)�F1 1:
1
Oh'&ICI 5,1Lir7 clef-rare ,' op!."";r6:q ' er pi i''rm: I, 'rfir.'+!:i.'1..1
do I,.i tr,1arrl 'i f,: j ri i L fIL L f'_' proitiosaq !i l I' 1 r' rip? £.'I i L"_i ury does oJor
rP V re ctiabuiative impart.,rt. Of o strbstantichi adiersoci.:iirdroimlerilehl tie a r Lat'JJ? tr ri W1 i t' z E•ri tiW
e2i1 CO. 11F'e 'rIoy I,rill:ion' cL4wr LEI r1 LL'
L': 111 L 1 1' 3
1".5121•a EVTITiL r'i p''tiJpci.cFI PJ r}rr 1_I ��� Ifl�� i'I' sera F!I�' }1 i :��•�1�.� ,'!P' LiT ,cLil tit°rVI+in! i.7011,19rEP thr
_ F�i!!Thi i ir'11?irjIJ'.PIrr�r..'1C rI''.Pi?.
9-101'11r
runt i.1 rif!'F'I r I j r I I
I I o.i r 'I ,� ''r�i 1'1.y ti I r .''I.�r'I�'I , r ti+°•�i 1 ' !ti y'�' y } .m � i ••y I'�, �e� + 1 : '
1 I .1 I I ��.1I � g I r I ri�i I ti�. 1 r� ��.t� •.�'� Ir°'•�'t®, 1u;Fl� D c or �1�1 I ti �ti �'ti!� rl�w 5 10l A Of
° ,_ �'!i"t'L 2;I d1L 'M`E'r 5.2111. 1��'t i f1 d���i LI i�ti'� '; .'171.-1 I r t:!I nI!ET:: di rl.i 51110111 Pvciquote the. overall ono
Crr, rhlatrL?effects of the action.
A 'sda'bstoit Ia i GJ dJ Liar;. ��t d•C i toIrr::'1 1 i 'd 1 i i ' •J'ptL_g d" d".'rcLJ 1 istri 1 i•d-2ss I I ie, I'G•'p.1 i'd or
0.0_ Otid.'l® OIR1e .1':111:rg °r e t .r 0 L". r,90_r�1 1101r_ •r 1I = til"I1 �1 �' ��r_12 Elj.:EdC Lm t.ne e17 rl.r0'1:716(7
t 'E L ',t C0( r3 I1C1i1 r° ^ id'I• ever. O Ld12 Lr!0 prOOOsretir1 tir ct1 r•�!"1 0:70 expertr'o LO'is2q!e,71"erJ• •1 L.h.r" on r11ti:1,r•f
1�� .ti aa�l�:'�•���J''Ir• 1��' rhr c[.rr'nri'lliiiLie weir a5 the 5hor1 1 r icihcj-rim eftcr al the proposal'. i.1 I'I.'Pi i`ti!T
in '1•mi I,'!i' riot ^10 ti r i'1 i ir'1ti r}.-, r,hr 0 1i,1 1•v'I•q .ir1i'(. If iT oori I rent i I^1 1.-o rr'
MG p constitfile u sGbstantfrir J dyer. e effect OR the en vrrirrerpt w i!tie) !i ii''i ri,
;fir (}r 'ri'or,:
(1) I p.1...e 4't•.ti1 t'7'C1 i L7 ?' C cif ;1.'�'1 L�rr�'1 {� II?tip LI! dh'1 Ls":.'L•L 1,•1:" 'J,' ir.)1.'r is [.1.rr ti I 1:r C-in Is r Li' r,..a lit t' '
,1 :IN: 'r, , r: ;.:_; •', J . n I , I J �� � � �'i=•�: ��i 1 1 •E1 f w �� •'! r 1 �r
'. ti�,1I1° � �fir, �!�.'+� �1`�.11 da !�:! �I::ti� t .!I.d ti'•��!d.1 !rl�:�' L.'!•�"�!t� {�!al �� t_ I.1 �.t ��+_I����� .ti2l. dr® ��_I7�.
1
(2) ! 1 IrIQi IS f!'11' ,ro,'iq ����;o r'1 ' r r , I-. r r.�.•'r '�1 4 t 1 1 d.l L•J�J � �1��• R. �.�.''1� �ri 1
CelltilktA With t!a fon° L?r,]i LrrftiriftrorI i pifm1;t161 Of guilts of U1 E 3erl.Perri) Sri Pr Dr ttre.Sr tilt
Plan,
i:e21 L j rt.i r.11 r 1 ! m r'1.1•C., ,rs'ti.' L'•�r.•'r! �' 1�1�:a •.�1.+1 L''�t��.ti i 1 �: 07.rr..17711.:ri (..012 rr 1)
(5) I rl 013!'F L5 'f 1;ti.,'.Io1II,et!r !• e.@'7 1
j 9(I 11 ti I;.y5a
1
i rl.175.1:16`11IGS rti0 S!,:�1��•�'�T�'!�i�'�°��•!''=�• :'a't•�'��bur citn�thlate ,'�has consh eioDire adverse e tect tbpa]
the env.'marn.2It c r i rI I.dr•1'1rt di ! !I 'I 1.rri r','.'L.I da r o ff.!I rl ti,a
11,1 : €'ti L di rr L,'d;'1, tiJl 't'j �� �ti1��'. hr CO f': liEldr I ld01 1dr'.rt 1i 1�,��'t'' '� 1Chriirl7Cill L.1 ,'' . i'I
Ir i d n t.: 1/ •i t.j o 1 r c•1' war rl Cie r o'r Lo r i W 110 i S
�r T - I i r 7—I- III : i'— re L• CO =J:' I i• I - '�
I_ �'�r� � l'l 1� I Ia �� �� � 1�•.l�1 SE'l��'C.�� � d�. LJ�. 1�_�r dr CO''��� 'l� � I'l1��'Tl� ��� la .P rei J#i{trl- 1'O;i 0 er r ,
qE.j.11 Gg lti11 l).. hg2ordou's 10^I :, 25 C!Ior a f'rCsi Note,-0 C005 I.:11 L 'O fee';.r
I'i a:0 MP- ti'�!a 1 r}ti r,1,5.7 .:J'10 ir'7..I,I I P.c +hs P10 17,rr 1 ':' 176 d
SpP!.1 i .. rera GLI.I. Ii 11,ac I ; : rip ter 20 a.,,, HI?S.
PC RULE 8
11 ti!ti �ti� �.. .ti ti! } , ti � � ,. �tip., t.� r� � �ti �ti } t � r ti' � �ti �
ti�rti,i,Fir �'ri�.�mli�ti� '�� i� (... r ircociic. of m�i 5 I I � i ti i ti G�•1.1VOS. ti;t e r �i i �F•i {,ti 17r.rrl aril)l 6 6 5 r�,i, ��•1.1VOS. !•C
i. �ti � ti I ti :y�,r.'fir} Oi tip• ': i ! :r,m' I rt._ 1..!i 1I��5 C � {�� f ti ti" N i is I ti��'5a 9 5�i '; I 1 1111 •F1CI
ri r m ��� � � i i i r � r � � r' vi i
'. . L'R iQ.C i?I I• "r'.e!iu[I :.ri !i ri;I �1�� t�t"f����'a ��:I�. f� L f��' Fti'• ti�rl m L fly' ":�'��• � ,V.h.'i.rm ':c'_
�•1 . L.� _.J m " �F•i" t: r•'.J mr L(i r : - rid•'.�L.' .i L"a,'.1 i .. ,ti . r ti r,', r 1 m' 1 1
�a�"�"�' ®r m m,w�� �� .� .1 .�� t�ritm � � �i �_ m_�_ �rl ti?�'t'�.�ti�.��� I�1r.�rl ��� r�.e�.
». 2 3-. ••... C.r L'i'ier...)',®e oe r7a0 i n sec E'om' HP5 ,
L.-l 1 .I —.lc variance bE g rsr;:e d J I a : a p p r=priate c n±iti or. a-e i ii po d 33 3 3 3 I•=3b12':a
}�I I�'I•I"ml rll iT� •.ti< c' aciver5R irli ad 5 or. hE, •-h
1.9)— Imo•I":i m i'P 3civer.E innip?c(5 oI". pL LEI•c: rh,R s M r3
Eval etc p.ote i,i ,II ;.ic�' ;11r Ir: !�' �i r� '�!ry ri irlri;tir'r�
PD
Ji-3(i1 r i 11P 1143 FY r9?:hP.7 c)#i:'1 ri i ll:ai• (7171I'�
1?I{1.I rid( UIj!!'17(ti Ili ti {I }1› I I E ▪ VC ! Cif E I ii IIiii(lOV6iIiI 41.� � ti!5 ilk II I•i °r.1
r
� 1 +1 •ti !ti r ti � +T. '. + ti ,.,r , ti.i 7• � 1 Ilti r+ til 1 1 1 Jt +� , 1
.� n. � ��• r T Ib. ��•t:,.I ,II'0 row.h;a n.I ti iI ti �;�,�I 11 r .I :j is i_.t1. , 1 ti f i, .by r,ti '.ti 1' r °'J "�,7 F'L'�,I 1. •,1 &°°1
', •n� " "•e, W ! •, , •1• k � � 1 �9 !" "i. , " �! , ,•, •r,,•1 i ,," f f , 1 � 1 v r_ � 1 I
':.':• _ •. _ {° ��.,, r,=. �,.�I 1 LrE=, .'rlli_`, i1Li. ��tl• t_� _,I,�•� °I L.1� Ll�t,rL Isl ,_,2I,t� Eritl I ti�Lirti
11 r 1 r•° 1�1 r 1 ' 1' r1.1.1.25.
.��ti'Lj1 L'e.I .rI r��'t',_rti� ,!�'�' :f•'�L I I ,;5
11-4(0 I i i a 1 Ia17(71 r1g, L'eac1-1 111, Play _.Err,1'1=1..,1 I171^ ,e u'1,2rt',E r't , ' CLi"SES 111.11LE' El ii6E1'.2 rl u j v
�'�'��1�'�, �I' 1..�!"�L1��L�"1 �.~.I•I�:'�t�'�, c1. =.....i,'"'-1_ ti'l'"1cEs .3I' 1_01',d ,ZI, 3 W, E.e 2t IZ_ 'activity
O(0.0 o,csE,1 C't 0 Lo17 5'oE .:i ,1.2 5Ebb 1LP i b ecoszievotivPIK, but retgeoubilv
es+tab,ri5 7e0. 10 : .9 rd.'bi.' i C r: niS .'iti i I i.:1 J rl pi.c,r:o!
▪ 1~1'Iti;i 1:?
11.'( } T ti , tii ,.r 1 ' ':.:, ny' 1','1 !$ " •} :"• r-'r' ,-y ,�+1 .' ,tif ti ,ti• ••_•,o 1'n
7+ �c 1�1 1r1 e1 1 cm ��1 Wll�� ti�� ��1��. �•ti�:. J �r�'Ig��n �, tip�� !1 ��1��1 1�1 � 1��ti•I��•f °'L�Ia �I til�1�1 � ti.L�� 1 1 I' e1•�1 1 r.1r'
I�'10 5 1r} T,lu,'I,rri 5,,Fi q r 11.0!? �� r°• ��,ti y •� f. r ,; 0.90 I ! I y 0 �;:p,
°�•,.1 �1 ti�,, ,1', ti�:�•ti� ti �F�•I ��� . ti i
LJ_'RIai ,d, rI i I rI,rlf L ".ILO I L' `tir ..'hie."I',•' Or "1: :i I r1 II &Lid! t' .110f-_111 I®E'
.etbcrcIc varrd°rrL-E the If Iif1!^g De 71.1'I`11.a^2. 312tei n•-.1 rl i 1 i.3 1 ri•at u r���i bE 'A,nn:E E_ •a.
O 1_`I r•C;01.1 thE _I r r.11''1E o17d 11r0!I Id not I r'EE r1-a,-� 'a'V�''�1 i ��.,"�1!L til.IL a_s r Ipulbli,C 11102.,'S � o'"Li •f1!QRii thE
5.1:10,EI.I',E_ 17,. w 11:L m °E 'u rr l_.17-I•i_ I TI�'v '..__ I . E 3S: " = .._•a_ _ ,, F._.: .:1 ° .'1 °;1
Cumiulative Impact trri rao ;
US EPA:
1 ' 1:n J.,I ,`, '' , r;l,. .,,, a, !, i' ,,, i „• I, i,,, ,• 'FIr' �r 'n ' I t�I r'n ti
L. 4I_, ,_r L1„I0_ _a_1•..�1 t.2 1 -5�_Lla"1 . -•..�•�l0_1�1 1�_ Lti! I ._fit'! 1.�II•�. _�I®_t°L_„N
2 I ti II':L',' L�i-'w ropo1ct' r1c rifL.7 i I I'1II,.It"r 0,2 Iu rI_ II7 0.1E •,t[f r1!' ;:i L't'gF ti�•�f1!� arE'G':
GI.11.'1'..I..! !Ii the OFEi S.11,1I0r ffELts Oli thE rESiQLJrCE
j'°,�,1 L�I i '+ 'E,� 1 i � I-t ayE been i 17:StanCa l:I'_Igr..if I,'I ,rQ( re=I Dice; a"d
(51 . .
L°'1i '� ,Ens L t.I'1al'.�,�!� �•' � ^ �ii rrt'G love!dE!�t, ,EJ���rl CL.i11 LJ'IatiI'E' E,t'crs do^cE,ra
§ 15011.7 Ctirn uI at ie i mpart
L:•.:i i I r 1,5 II;ti pact oe r !, .1) I.E1 it I )(' i ri!77.5 ;'11 a! 1 rh
i i i'fix' r� 'r�riI I, I�� :�'J J I� i.,I �•�T °°'' p(J:t, II I::.r 'rl�, •'��ti�! l i.'ti�;gym �,l'� �� I •� I''llrrr?'.'I II)I'' !1a�!J11 41��1ti�. :Ji'I I,ti �! I Lori Iir
�`, !•,, ' n, ,- , , �I 1 7 i, ,rn l °r r , .ICI n - , I - ,5 , ! 7' � , 1�1 1 n, !� i !. , ! :•I, ,.. ,I _ „ ,
t.,t_�.i_: 1 r�•�t�tl1 •.i, I, i-_ c.•),; L: a�1���. •�I, e.r_tilC�l 1��1, .11 1
W , M T ' „• ;n� �- °i W•! , i, 1'1 111 , • ,,.°r r Il
,� wl '.'•'W,l..m:,! a ,!", ,�. , ,!, 1�i„I°�ILe!.N,, i� �.'�,'4' r s �,6,..,�..i� LJ1�., 1,, ..L,�'�" Ld�dEi�Li �.ti.�L�J � _Ir1iC.
Typo of Nroi-21: C urn.'ii la iv
Effeei
NalLire 1:11fIr'ucIRea5Driabr:.
Effect In iib1& Foreseeabke:
Prodiciablo Probable Pub au
f Pf0Fet 1 Plittoff".. 'Di fida Dieect
EffE-id. hid r e_I
tteici5, and EftR :ts
or Oklier Aclivities
TinYina cif At Son) Fullulf6 Al Ti i r Prci.
Effeti Congrudon DireiG1 CLAFILArtuAlbilIll n
ilmplEmentatIon EFit thE
.acrialr,g) Al thg. Proti1 Viiirl!hin F-i= Within
Etirxi Loc.-0143in ci-f SyMion115 cISy5tern5
Affected by the Affected by the
Proied Pfojecl
can LI•FL.Co uri L•9 .1•12.4ui-er-iuril.la• uprierv_Lu udu a'CL:irruta Ulm Jr•ripat•LAriAv5..;
11..11L. Cour!Ly cicirw •arri ,Lin I IOW Li] ii Luri dLiv'. Irripact•s' A II IFiL
environrr ent
Proposed
Piujed
Imp;E
a.riu
Paw H Impact Dil
act 44- oct
Amlons Irrir Individual Acdcris -
Rt)source
oco r 3 liii f:Dror_ior)ciD
ncludies Inc'rect act on:;
paLl.
Other
Prosent
Actions
I. Pr: cPL1Project iinpa•ntF.— npFicririp
Iinnarts tin rp.r.ource, o' within RE ogi iphic F —re i
07hE r C —en7 pncts TO '10 I gerop,'Aphic. n'ea
P3.(15-011 ;:r:tic.r.. .1-1(.1 -hey 71-,,e tleoeTa:).1 c:
Define..
d
I:.Li-1'1_11d vc hiped Ara piL