Laserfiche WebLink
TABLE OF CONTENTS <br /> TABLE OF AUTHORITIES..............................................................................................ii <br /> I. STATEMENT OF THE CASE........................................................................................... 1 <br /> IL STATEMENT OF QUESTIONS PRESENTED FOR DECISION................................... 6 <br /> III. STANDARD OF REVIEW.............................................................................................6-8 <br /> IV. ARGUEMENT ..............................................................................................................8-28 <br /> A. THE APPEAL IS BARRED BY WAIVER AND RES JUDICATA................8-17 <br /> 1. Summary of Judgment................................................................................ 8 <br /> 2. ADC Waived Its Rights to Appeal Imposition of Condition No. 7............ 8 <br /> 3. Res Judicata Applies to Administrative Adjudications ....................... 11-12 <br /> 4. ADC's Request for Amendment of Conditions Cannot <br /> Revive Barred Claims.......................................................................... 13-15 <br /> 5. ADC's Constitutional Claims Are Waived and Barred By <br /> ResJudicata ......................................................................................... 15-17 <br /> B. APPELLANT ADC FAILED TO CARRY ITS BURDEN OF <br /> PROOF; THE COMMISSION'S FINDINGS ARE NOT CLEARLY <br /> ERRONEOUS.................................................................................................. 17-25 <br /> C. THE"ROUGH PROPORTIONALITY" TEST DOES NOT <br /> APPLY TO NON-DEDICATORY CONDITIONS........................................25-28 <br /> V. CONCLUSION................................................................................................................. 28 <br /> APPENDIX"1" Letter from Sidney Fuke & Associates to Mr. Norman Hayashi, <br /> Director Planning Department, dated July 24, 1002; letter from <br /> Sidney Fuke & Associates to Mr. Norman Hayashi, Director Planning <br /> Department dated September 4, 1992; and Summary of Planning <br /> Department Public Input& Information Meeting for the Ainaloa Golf <br /> Course, September 1, 1992 <br /> APPENDIX"2" Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order dated <br /> November 15, 2004 <br /> APPENDIX"3" Hawaii County Code Sections 25-2-44 and 25-2-65 <br /> i <br />