Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0163.001 2020-2022 ' /fieRI- GC-itTi-' I '1 L.1. _ -::',, /;;;IC — /1 iii'. i ,H ;' t k 114 ,4 i' 0 W /7 a4 3 f P/b. #b, 1f/21'Z? Aid ,,r.4.. -,mo/ P - _,Y / I Cg® _.------' 0s � p / Co - op:oA •.r ' y_ .1.4. / yi/ P Ili _ : ' �/ Xa rut a to_kili_c__?_&(.6__g_i m A,ea)_t___ ,R T.; 1 " , _ A 7 vlA t • .... ' t .Lzfxr-4._1_1Reszu-Lice_9____A ilillen , -I A } irk r ' ... _ * a _ . ' / A� 1111__' ' '_1_ 06t11--1/14_RA/* af `\/Cb ! �. ' "fir /, , 0 • y 1 4,f.4 1-, r- •0- „if/ik/K(k_a_H-7-1- J . 1r r )10 / i g. .. >l b ) ... Lila . s0 . 'i t y °Oltrlf ' 6' /I r F _ I .P O 44.70 , jh7 f 1O1. D 1 ?...fitic____ we ._. _ A... 41.44 .,iv'oe _ 'fied -71-hrbtjh • ) c Air _ # (_'/1 P / 1 i1' Q/ N 11 _ 1, ' P,. /" I Y ' p 24 V A/F�/ J , _ e '. • / .e.- irI `l, ..r ..i A Si . . a / 40 Ad \ 4, . r,._J I11' Ca-yl /, j /Z s S S Jf • - i < ! r �^ r‘ At `. 4"0 t .. i lJC.� t e . #'/_ '_do!-- A K , (AA( i II _eil /IL- -1 A A....' N.16 Ci4L7-7— ( pa , ) Comm. No. 11073 1 Ref. To: Ref. Date APR 0 7 2021 I (7- !IC73 ) • ..„1. .. • /9,..124Dtd -h7 -9- i ( ....._____ W-977' Q c i , j IT4— 2-I ) - 1-90 • 719Crarn7:77:b 1 piod 561-,--9--/Lleg-?4-1, p . . r "s .-eiritrir070-7-----W % 3 r, I VicZ-' laraiNifid 95 #717/- 1 i (7g7147)10 ,:VW-- 2p----' )Pr' 4 SOCV.°-7 II i de- ___ --Dy r / , 14,-0 / 3 ; , r, ,' "--- ,/ - 1)-- .0, ,: ,ir----r77---4i,-42 „1,..„,,4, „, , „ : -ir.,, '01-0 ,,,,. ,• —? 9 , .., ! il ..lrgeTve-gio fekybi 4-T--t,f- yr-a , 73?-7-k-7---ity ---?7i9—raro, °P"- 1 , "Fir • , eCirnr ,, illiy ryi r: -A - je ir v 1,-; -vS / - 1 , / • 1" .-..v--7-17- j i st iiro vrett4c, .•,- , i ( , 7,Lb / 7)77-=- Z4 L.J S'' -1771-017i :4 Pr r 01 44) f eD-10/1) I s, 1:9 r e #V 0 i 0 ..) e: (i i . "9(d )b Cil c4C(767r7717,) nri- TrVi. c10 cs4-urgura-4- ' /iy-fvuij ) I r;"10-7 --1 ,,o , 4, pw42--df---ald - -f_ai-cy,- -- 5 4 i 'V --ori-P FP 1 i , -r337 " ' b2-1ad 491--V . LLS-a 01/f/ 071 Tn219 2W 4/5' 6' ) 3 DVD 1, '7 j CfVta7-.-- --- 1 * i as , , � .,. _ STATE s. iL 'I 11 . -' •,-; a.89 'ciawzi'i 177 i.9'E; 970 p 2d 4°5 statutes. Const Art. 12. § 7; ERS § 738_ STATE of Hawai`i, Pldintiff-Appellee, 814. . v. 6. Indians a26 "'`''-:-,.. • . Fact that the .claimed native Hawaiian Alapai HA"API, Defendant-Appellant. right Is not spec_icaiiy enumerated iii the No. 1974E Hawai'i Constitution or statutes does riot Supreme Court of Haysai`i. preclude .forth er inqui--'y concerning other. traditional and customary practices that`have 'Nov.ov 't', '199S. - e7,,..fisted: Const, Art, 12, § 7; HRS §§ 1-1, • • Recon fide tior. Denied T'eh. 8, 1999, 1 . - Y i Indians c 26 , . Defendant w+as'con,-' --,in the District -,:.-i-:::„ ..,,,,,,,,,..::„:.,...5�t'iw''-r-egardirra `the common law of Cour Second:Circuit,,�io%yar or;se,onnd'' 4.1e:'-s- ea5atc4-te rPgardu'g tenants use o�land for wh cr lai wy ord las or may obtain degree criminal trespass Defendant.appeal-, ;; aliodial title;:represent the cocccation of tra- • ed. The Supreme Court l 2_ii', J r e_.,d---7-riat _ rational and' custol-nary nztiz*e Hatv:3.iian defendant failed to establis�t' a"ccnstititionai ' .• • rjc ins 'ta i cn' o de the basis far a claim m _ , l✓ protected native Hawaiian right tole On C the su?�ject property . ' a c:oristitution 11.; protected native Hawaiian :s • rights Conal.Ar-. 12. s HRS §§ 1-1; 7- Afflrmed. 1 8. Indians(2•=26 1. Constitutional Law '45 • If property, is deemed fully developed, Assertion of'a constitutionally protected i.e.; lands zoned and used for residential par- right.ureSents a p.irelli legal issue'that must poses vr_th eias:.irg dwellings, impro'ierneots, be determined b'the court. and infrastruct re, it is a"ways inconsistent to permit the practice of traditional and ctla- ? C .nstitutiona: Law c-- ,44.1 tOTnaT4 IlqH V. F ^retia I1 nt9 on sueh:p, ,,,- :. i- t^t,,.v :1rOi.cae,ci , - c n ' ..,..inn ��2„ • ty, the burden is placed on hist or her to. >-__ - show that his or her conduct fell within.- the _ •Defendant'failed to establish cons,tu- prophylactic scone of the Constitution's pro- tionally protected-native-Hawaiian right to be 15ioP_. on the subjec..piop .- :F, as required to de- fenil again i Cnargc_0 Second-degree seco d-deg2 e rriru 3 Indians-«26 • ..npasawer?ae_effered no explr.ador _ . _ h _ _.____— "7-77-77-----'1,-: is the obligation of the person claim- of the history dr orio-in e-his claimed.right to aug the exercise of a native°Hawaii `-ngh. to `sten rresriip� or resroi•at•on and heading of demonstrate than, the right is-pro-thctei_b's__ - lands." Const. -i? ="_: 9--.7HRS;§ 70i•- . ' the Hawaii Constitution, Const. Art. 12, 814(1)(a.). 10. Indians •26 ' - , 4. Criminal Law c303.30(2) To-establishthe e_asteribe of a tradition- _._ The preferred met,od for a defendant to __ or castors rihu-e--Hawa ian practice raise a constitutional -right in a c imihial pros-. there n'1 =no ar adecn:te foundation in the ecution r. b;;.way of a Motion o diim_ss. record co:.neeting t'ri claimed Dight to a Penal Procedure Rule-12(b) __ - fro' - rooted 'ra liii.-a' or Caste :ars native . Hawaiian 'Const. Ar= 3, Trespass c=,84 prac`_:tee. on _. t �°,§•"r. Constitutionally protected native Hawal- 1L Trespass O-8'_ • ia'iv iguts reasonably exercised, qualify as a EyidenrC sustad de E,ndan.:'' - _ t lvj for po.pose` of i:rlm nal trespass titin for ecoid e "Fre cz-irTilnal mespao.s: t ry zt For information.about the genealogy verification process, contact the Office of Hawaiian Affairs (OHA), Kuleana Land Survey Call Center at: (808) 594-1967 Th Section 19-89.5 Kuleana land exemptions. (a) For the purposes of this section, "kuleana land" means those lands granted to native tenants pursuant to L.1850, p. 202, entitled "An Act confirming Certain Resolutions of the King and Privy Council, Passed on the 21st Day of December, A.D. 1849, Granting to the Common People Allodial Titles for Their Own Lands and House Lots, and Certain Other Privileges," as amended.by L. 1851, p. 98, entitled "an Act to Amend An Act Granting to the Common People Allodial Titles for Their Own Lands and House Lots, and Certain Other Privileges" and as further amended by subsequent legislation. (b) Those portions of real property zoned as residential or agricultural, and designated as kuleana land, shall pay the minimum real property tax set forth in subsection 19-90(g) as long as the realproperty is owned in whole or in part by,a lineal descendant of the person(s) that received the original title to the kuleana land. (c) An application for this exemption'shall be filed with the director on forms prescribed by the director. The application shall include documents verifying ownership of the portion of the parcel and that the condition`set forth in subsection (l3) has been satisfied. Verification of the condition set forth in subsection (b) shall be satisfied by either genealogy verification by the Office of Hawaiian Affairs or.by court order stating that the applicant is a lineal descendant of the person(s) that received the original title to the kuleana land. The applicant/landowner shall be responsible for all costs. Ia. ,.� L was made, even though the person _ thea eT� is `� °wed or the tztle to the real estate i • yianted has been ahenated; and all land �i .z.,--4,-4..,‘ y" to the benefit of the heirs and asci Patents so issued shall inure 1$72, c 2I, § 1;RL 1925 568 RL of the-holder of the anal award. [Z, § '100-11; HRS § x72-x1J § , 1935, § I587;-RL 1945, § 4641;$L 1955, No'12t S TO DECISIONS Mabele of 1848 and .andient Hawaiian 'tak + iand,'tenuyes considered and defined eu 'heirs e e hadssectjod to award'in hi, noh� See'Venzis.v Carter 6-Raw. 195, 187'7 Hay, e lifeme royal=for this section -:. . funs 5 (1877) expressly direct-4 tha{xall paEents thereof ti EfT{Effect of patent generally. — Byt issued should "inure,to the bene5.t of the fe to o s based on Iancl`co -legisla- heirs and as-oma'of the holder of the original -',.-'i.: b' have been s inl mmission awards- award.",Siattli-v. Hainakua . . importance to a mere 648, 1904Haw'L 904) Co., I5 Hay. release of the go tegument commutation;but a ]1XI8"60 f190 ). release c go award neve theles t Reservation of mineral rig]�ts.— land • mterpretecl as vthat ita Origin aii� mss b comm -,sion-award,when made mte j Was ""a`de, ,'.,the mineral rights ,'require d b3 stet- afaon of a right to.a patent re P'obin ,. ,ein the:patent bile issued on son,=49 Haw 429, 421. D.24,570; .1966 ute to be`cantamzdm the�ateriE to.be on 1,,Was_ 72 (1966),rehe IIa° 1e co ,sial?;' tnauh the reserratioa was ins 49 acing denied,In re:Rob.- not sef-out m.t1,`P award its 1f In i-e Robinson Haw 520,,421 F2d 570, 1967 Hays,: 49 Haw.,429,4..2,12:11,4,d,570,:;=1966'Raw LEXIS • LEI'S 89,relic;ring denied,TEL re Robinson 49 -�' 72(19-69i;rehearing, ' Ha;,r,574, x.23 P.2d 437,' c . 1967 Haw.LE IS 93, .Haw-.520, 4� p denied'In re Robinson,4, (1967) , 1 Ptd b70; 1967 Haw. 59, R6-yal patents based on awards did not 4eh sans denied'In re .LEXon,49 R w 574, 1 !: ,corifez or con title. Binz r, Smith, 8 �3 P.2d 437,1967 Haff LEXIS 93 (1967). Haw. 783, 1877 Haw,LLS Certificate o award admissible' ('4 aw. 78 pat7nt_was EXTS 24(1877). deuce. — evi- The cert�th it •of an award of-the 1 interest •of. � � quit claim of land commission,' Iia relo, Io HaF e sg ent in•lands. Mist v ve3 are adnuesxb e m evIdence,s �an P�Ymg sur . (189$ , 1898 Haw: 14 X7S 4 _ - },, - • uappear to be genuine,are andwhen they a� 898) eo, of the right of the Prima facie evidence r muusslcn awares held. -good paw in vfhvse favor the against rota] patents 7 anterior date._,... certificate-i, 4Sued. ' 1 Haw-202;185j,Haw., v 859)(de j Bee )ielflakie ,-v Dennis 1'Haw-69.(1851); : under )."' EELS 14 Sulozahn v Gill 1$avr 54; 1852 T�avr LCIS Prior Iaw)- : (decided 852) Adjut�-cat�.on. of land, co (.1852). 852) t6 fo deceased persons This not hP z'PP 7 TP mm1 will ssian. �� ,section does,-not eceased tae 1`r-ahuka, 5 Tia ,' by Ra k 7 aaa v ' issuance -of 04 /885-'''Haw. DK 53 As in the'names bf deceased,persons:Ter �I"88o) After `» atarp of Ham exret Baileyappeal from the land commis" kion to y.Gay 26 Raw.382, the 1922 Hativ:LAS supreme"courE,a contestant could C1s22). AwH d .LEMCS o h(1922) again inof notw begin ., ecourt equity. re �� benefit7,ty In L .�= avrard should inure,rin the case of a deo�xhde Cooke,Ltd., 19 a 47, ewers & - c Haw. 1e08 Haw. 7s -re 2.r Itanoh,iri"who had not alienated his .naht (19i)3) afi'd sub = :?•,;)n28 Lewers ii lam, to h1s hews to those was would have-- g tchei-ly, 222 U S 285 56 L E-2Q2; ,Ltci,v. . 19?1 LI S I.,T'�Lg 1.78 202,32 S. Ct. . § x72 72 Laud P 'tt5 ' ate issued -!'!a-i,„0-,,,'''7'-:-.43,---:;•:6-:' � ..�; � ud -1911) _ -: ,. =settled - and comznutatzon Upon;pre�entaon io the A ceriaficate of a=coninais�lor , dopa �n�"of Nand aid natru al resoi nems of boundarze5 def n,n�' • .0 tiO i _1- 4 the bougdarie, of a pox�lan T • of an Ali upuaa', 1h, or other denominat ou. of and a aPPralse'mez1tto be made of the if :the dPa'tm�Ilt shill Cauae ; II-praYad value'of that © asr1 upon parnent to the d� 1 an,of land, �- partment of she governaelit co p:. iiou~9f ,.and, upon the"appra1semes� e �muE dee rn•that abo . prop ided, the department 12 • 'o, • __ __ __ _m.__r____ _.___ _ -__.___� __ Li Sti �N'kw7" -... _7"- nt_ .�� ;.T-�•4 _- •. ,.. Ybv [t '�. .jam r � Y �- ..,:,:„..;,;.-;:.',:-- 4-2:4 7^7 42 U.S.C. United States Code,2008 Edition Title 42-THE PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE CHAPTER 21 -CIVIL RIGHTS SUBCHAPTER V-FEDERALLY ASSISTED PROGRAMS From the U.S.Government Publishing Office,www.gpo.gov SUBCHAPTER V—FEDERALLY ASSISTED PROGRAMS §2000d. Prohibition against exclusion from participation in, denial of benefits of, and discrimination under federally assisted programs on ground of race, color, or national origin No person in the United States shall, on the ground of race, color, or national origin, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving Federal fmancial assistance. (Pub. L. 88-352, title VI, §601, July 2, 1964, 78 Stat. 252.) COORDINATION OF IMPLEMENTATION AND ENFORCEMENT OF PROVISIONS For provisions relating to the coordination of implementation and enforcement of the provisions of this subchapter by the Attorney General, see section 1--201 of Ex. Ord.No. 12250,Nov. 2, 1980,45 F.R. 72995, set out as a note under section 2000d-1 of this title. Ex.ORD.NO.13160.NONDISCRIMPIATION ON THE BASIS OF RACE,SEX,COLOR,NATIONAL ORIGIN, DISABILITY,RELIGION,AGE,SEXUAL ORIENTATION,AND STATUS AS A PARENT IN FEDERALLY CONDUCTED EDUCATION AND TRAINING PROGRAMS Ex. Ord:No. 13160,June 23,2000, 65 F.R. 39775,provided: By the-authorityvested mwm'e as President bythe-Constitution afrd the laws of the United States of America, uicludirig sections 921=932 of title 20,United States Code; section 2164 of title 10,United States'Code; section 2001 et seT,of title 25,Umted-`StatesCode,-section 7301 of title 5,United States Code; and section 301 of title 3,United=States_Code yard toachieve-eqol=opportunity in eaera y= conducted education and training programs and activities,it is hereby ordered as follows: - Section`1:Statement- 614 on education programs arid activities conducted by executive departments and agencies. 1-101.The Federal Government must hold itself to at least the same principles of nondiscrimination in educational opportunities as it applies to the education programs and'activities"of State andlocal governments and to-private institutions'receiving Federal financial assistance.Existing laws and regulations prohibit certain forms of discrimination in Federally conducted education and training programs-and activities—including-discrimination against people with disabilities,prohibited by the Rehabilitation Act of 1973,29 U.S.C. 701 et seq., as amended,employment discrimination on the basis of race,color,national origin,sex,Or religion,prohibited by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964,42 ._ ...S,.C.n2000e 7�[42 U..S..0 2000e..et.seq],_as-amended,discnmmnationron the,basis-of-race;color-;- national origin, or religion in educational programs receiving Federal assistance,under Title VI of the Civil Rights Acts of 1964,42 U.S.C. 2000d[et seq.],and sex-based discrunination in education programs receiving Federal assistance under Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972,20 U.S.C. 1681 et seq. Through this Executive Order,discrimination on the basis of race, sex,color,national origin,disability, • • . • - -. D a♦ • . SOY ♦ •. e N4 UNITED NATIONS (41 v j HUMAN RIGHTS OFFICE OF THE HIGH COMMISSIONER • Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights Palais des Nations,CH-1211 Geneva 10,Switzerland MEMORANDUM Date: 25 February 2018 From: Dr. Alfred M. deZayas United Nations Independent Expert Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights To: Honorable Gary W. B. Chang, and Honorable Jeannette H. Castagnetti, and Members of the Judiciary for the State of Hawaii Re: The case of Mme Routh Bolomet As a professor of international law, the former Secretary of the UN Human Rights Committee, co-author of book, The United Nations Human Rights Committee Case Law 1977-2008, and currently serving as the UN Independent Expert on the promotion of a democratic and equitable international order, I have come to understand that thelawful political-status of the H-aWaiian_Islands is that of asovereign nation state-in continuity,but a nation state that-is ,under a strange form of occupation-by the United States resultingfrom an:illegal military_' occupationand a fraudulent.annexation. As such,international-1aws (the Hague and7Geneva Conventions)";require"that_governa,ice;and'legal`.,matters within the occupied territory of the_i Hawaiian islands must.be administered by the application of the laws of the occupied state (in this case, the Hawaiian Kingdom), not the domestic laws of the occupier(the.United) States). Based on that understanding, in paragraph 69(n) of my 2013 report(A/68/284)to the United Nations General Assembly I recommended that the people of the Hawaiian Islands—and other peoples and nations in similar situations—be provided access to UN procedures and mechanisms in order to exercise their rights protected under international law. The adjudication of land transactions in the Hawaiian Islands would likewise be a matter of - Hawaiian Kingdom law and international law, not domestic U.S. law. I have reviewed the complaint submitted in 2017 by Mme Routh Bolomet to the United Nations-Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights;pointing-out historical and; ongoing plundering of the Hawaiians' lands,particularly of those heirs and°descendants with land titles that originate from the distributions of lands under the authority of the Hawaiian Kingdom. Pursuant to the U.S. Supreme Court judgment in the Paquete Habana Case (1900), . r • U.S. courts have to take international law and customary international law into account in property disputes. The state of Hawaii courts should not lend themselves to a flagrant violation of the rights of the land title holders and in consequence of pertinent international norms. Therefore, the courts of the State of Hawaii must not enable or collude in the wrongful taking of private lands,bearing in mind that the right to property is recognized not only in U.S. law but also in Article 17 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted under the leadership of Eleanor Roosevelt. Respectfully, r, / - Dr. Alfred M. deZayas United Nations Independent Expert on the promotion of a . democratic and equitable international order Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights • Palais des Nations, CH-1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland :,',.',-=.5.,;§-77-74,077- = ,.77:::=.: - = 'Tr-1'7 =--;= -' '--• ---- ' - - .. - - - :-. .,. . ',.-. . :.,:---:1-,-. -._-: --,: , --.,, ...-... - ' ..: . ,. , , ..., , . • .. . • ,,l Y.o shirribto,`Chalrur3tn and Council Ni0i-rib&. s • . . • • NovembOr 12 20P9 . . . • . - • „ : . . „ . - : • ' . Aitkt;t6 riba.1041ged, it.-iivi,dpaided.by J-11,,e.11.-faigaiiSupregie Crfart In.1-1/ B27'--Z V. Ti .Artifzistii-c' or 3,17420-M.-723 (1877)-11Lizt.the lviliT45tofr vf iliteki0fi',could:lwarfAilly issue ;,,i•4,11.61a A , - Ei ROisTalPilgatiftlr a Land C6.--1.1.4-31ission P...1:1-axe... LI,.iis'.1.14.of 1174,1-1.4.kqpiserse 1F.2 I-law. 71 5 (186A;the its. a.i.'1 Spy- 11O Co held.:1-L.z. it-vitts 2.,.,.c_lt int.... "41 .'1..._,.:ttile.: TI,E,•-'.‘s lauds ,r1 -•end;to 0.• ,--i.m.6f eqe Ka:-..n. g,rr.th .the 1a-:ads slauld c.le.....7.4...-1--.-;-,..ii tO the succisspzs.of the „;.,,--ael1-,. ,..,_,,- iCWg.r uropmly Llaid by,Nameaameha W aid tbia Kani:eli=et.la Tv, _ , who aied wit1.5-7 -it.a will. 6.i .f,'4t7-41 ..rrnii.6=';1 aer--%.- *-3 ipo4th.1_7-g-7,fi.4,21fiik giifi;33,th:7.7:1i-ha ',./' estate as the hil.-a-&-1. .e .i.c -c..).-3,-.-'1,and I'lle 0.}.. ei;cm-half Els dowagef. Ths:8`iip=i,-,,,, . 1.irit held.that the ga.ve41-m-, f...-41c4.7ris w the lart -Ofim..1-idaton!and. - -should i/i-41,7i-i ."- e thpgf....,.a!provy ofr.-'4 1#0..-•de4;''''.1.,•-!.die wereP4sPCo ,.. 4 ,1'74P Landsmt • x. were EtLP.0* , PPOOtY of f'?e•KiPg'h313244-#••04.0014k.': to the hei0.-Othe.'-e-5tat : This cliziE' ..4 status of the K..a ..-ng s lands into CrownandgrocilorriaiiitiitilandS 0424 . FcCogliZat thei parortpr of egt. . . ' 4 The sequd._.,--.7i.of 1437 ,is,Nyhi:gri2,Tedsow.a but..k of the pi**tics iii.vir.a.1.7ar1811,---trzd i-der Lard P — (--_: ;,..,:fiatiti:24-.-L514red f= n-ap,.p-roxinlat.ely 1:g.96. 4:26•These tansidS it.cig., .:2.-140se-1.p.. 105 which are fa-i-hecred..iTiraT&gichszeots tbst real Royal i Patent(i.i..:3i-SH6 =7-'-, 4/e,veic:(iii:61.6 ,ridspeodc.fe,fe.±-proyal&3-,,,,Eit tig-p,..„.2g,,--1:i. bred.th-, Tigh, . ... .,M•b' - ''''''- ' ' . — ---' "- as wen as ti*:,- ..1. .1#1 -tbff",r A It4i-kspi, 11'4n ,.ps_c--i_lt=off117D :F.,5rwail. Isttigls. intheir place,. is the zec4tW;;IMff .."--iit,t,*Atijailit:bisw ai-i.,.iliegi by its-Fresid&it a'Elitb-2.-d B.D6le. higr:-.01ipe4r-,to.bay:::17,--:-.en-forged,youAnu#-014L iy Teiherabeethe rip. n::---.T,-..iwii-61.thlara.wa.:, ci-verthr0: -*A 434-3-&fioty-17;1893- --?-z-----P-Fo -.,4-,--m.'_.a,,,,:_, - r ._. ThoirtW,a fs.3i1 5:-,worp:worie by thegOti eminent hi placeattiietri:ne;the Rripublit.of t1y used the old forms: They dressed out any reference to the _ nienaicl)i-Z--i:.,c1D-:•ii inic-nolcalani. - • - • --)--Friiii---. •,4977,:and forward;it ippeara the Republie1O61d afford tO_Print nOtra grantii and thus frOna 14;97.the new giants were entitled"1.43.047.1Patent-Grantsf:Under-the _ .., , 0,tetfhilt)*,11--_:-.'--:;';'':H4-700't 1.-lairife4-title-tiji all thoti-Ianda-'deaated=aa-,gdliernbaent lands at the .-7-,.2--0t: =irliocin-iyvv. Also seized at i-litiviiritiliretrOiviii-onitg - • -without.06 t Al';;:-4;1;14i.-:t6,ifie-nionaid-- i. . _ ,„_ , . On J h. 7, 1 89_8,. aivai`i ilkiiis anneked by-ilietrikedStates and the lands of the . . _ Republic w:, t. ,. (*ea to the United States. AfiliotighiSeded- ' ,to the United States,the ,+ landsrievir.r 9;4.; 1 I'- the ;"iiiS'S'Wf thethiffiid 8tatest-- 4:411.817ecci'-' Pized a:ill:::a3:-7. : for .ese • :, •: .,-ii r.tm and deein1.---.,-..--- the-ti.e.ic--T---edA of any.sale.of properties Would benefit:the T,-i. tory ofitovai4-i'att..--elitdry-forfther„:4411-0-blta-nt'si'of the Hawaiiaitisiands. . - - , In 1911-Queenif..0`no—kalant brolighttgilft4',Oni—nt the Iktitid gtateiitiiiije t.S. Cort of C . 1, to recover the value of the Crown Lands. In Lifiliokiikiiii v: ntiecl - - . Sta4s 45 Ct. I) 418 ' I ,the colirt,r*itig upon Me earlier IlaN-vaiI•Saprenie Coni "decision in 'ielEstall4 ofKaniehamella 17,suPr4, an'aAthc Ofslanuary 3-180 1 3 • - • - - \ i • )11W CR-0 Wil , Coq t" arid Fiir-+ L,n4s, : J ) , , 1---1 . . . . --i . co MEETINC - 'CE • -, HAWAII COUNTY PUBI ' OPEN SPACE AND ...:1-- ;., -)N COMMISSIO-N -.9 ---f-' .. NATURAL RESOURr- ` • . . .... . ._ - c) - DATE.: Monday, Ma- \*Lk, \ cA,,„- 1 !Cr' . -... \_4•-•?,, :WAX . , \Iv,. • , x...--‘),.. .,..- , -...,, 2-, \ • TIME: ' 10:0P \\, . , ‘ ,\•;:.., N..4\-:/ v„e \ • N Lr • :• ''' ,.._A, . ;'' •!;s ..1.. e.-. • PLACE: \ \ -) _ , \ t (vej Room, 74-5044 •-->.. 1.\ '740 ... ..„..y......- .'. \ ,.`'.\I ‘‘)--.1'\ •••;, _\ • \ .\-X't, ' ?--• \>-. •,,, \ `--_,-__N ‘,4\\;‘ , i-, ••• • ,,-._ 0\.\ • •.' Ci • \ 'N\c" ••W''.-, N '-'3 , sW' . , ;--..-\,... \ i•-•75i c:\••S ,',• .• , x- \_, ,r7,..._ ;---) \ cl:\)•?..,-;..,--1. Li' r\• k\/./i.-• i f\ \\,1\N \•4\‘\\:1 .,_.jp,\;:-\\C(--;1- • 7-.7 D — CD ft, '1 . -,- -_:CD .„„t--."1/41Y X , \ •\i`: - N/t. . 0, - fl -,--71-A -- '-•"'-' I'a -'‘ ___ _. --,-.7:: :-•,--- ±- --7-• _ A -, 'i% ', \;. ''.1/4' 4r."'' .-,.. 1 4 -. \ '‘ \ •- -----4 I . 1 ' 4411,,,. \ __..e . ,.)< ., VI.)• N , %,... ' -,, ", • , • : ?A , \Nc U • k ,• (.\\--: ?.. , SD_ N , .,,.7. ,- N( IA ITEMS ,...m . r APP ,,-k,.. ., e . , RC \5 '7-‘,1\-- • . January 13, 2014; ..„. — Pr — session meeting• s±,0 . . , :\i-,.. ,4 \---v - ,IVNS_'-••' . I• WRITTEN C ,•. 1 ,Corrimunitatim ' [4-001 : Letter dated January 30', 2014 from Janet W. Hara, • .President, KAHI„nc., re: Interested in selling Vacationland Land Trust property to the County of-Hawaii' for park and open space purposes; Lot‘t, Kapoho,.Puna, Hawai`i Tax • .Map Key: (3) 1-4-02:22 _ . , . Communication No. 14-002: Letter dated February 3, 2014 to_Council Chair J _-_- --- Yoshimoto a:nd-Members,-Pf th-e-C-olintSICOUncil-from Mayor-Kenai-re:-Namiriation of -------WrIlia-trip•-fvTeVerS-16-PONit-fortogncil District 3 ,. . ., ----- - _ Communication No. 144)-03. Letter date-d-F-e-bruary-20, 201:4 toCouncilChairl . .. Yoshimoto and Members of the County Council from Mayor Kenpi, re: Transmittal of : ;i-the'2013-.-PONC Ariiii.iaTRepdrt to the Mayor , . • i-, '-il'AIEPARTMENT OF FINANCE REPORT . ':".::•-::4-:;".!'roperty Manager Ken Van Bergen will answer any questions from the commissioners , egarding the Commission's,budget or any other finanCial matters. .- OFFICE OF THE CORPORATION COUNSEL'S REPORT • .,, ._ ._ _D.ep•uty-Gorporation-eourrsetWilllam-BliThante to provide comments and/or information relating to matters of concern to the Commission. • ...• - Hawaii County is an Equal OpportunEmployer and Prbvider /tic e..-0-14441Q,FLGC Er- 7 ' , Pc4-6-ete lop-ecti- A . t • \, . _ Neea Tot icq O vv Na_. - v „ , , • M ri C)0 ALC4,1 A-N P ck, C.._ . - • ,,. 'r , , ---.--,--- ---,- --:- -- - - - --.-------.-7.7------....----7;•7',:m7,44-Tiiik-As.••• ..-=".-4•-.-.'-';.'-----,„s-.,,•-..7. &_.-",--'.*,--,1-"?-er ',C'"'W- . :',"tr'r.T4V-: 71:1_.,:','.2"''' ‘,.'"1:•;*,*'.'4e.:.';10:ittr5V?r 4:4=rffr ,.4- -‘A..:.:•,=y1t"y,,,,,r' ,s ,'.t -, ._-"4'44,,r...go'frF_i.,-; '--,',.),-71,1,41„--:, -.-----,--, !,',,.-,-,!!'",4-:,:ii,..a,--,,,,,,i .....___-4 -..4,,? ',..'ke....S. 3,0:;, ,4,...-....4-,-.+4,-$-.'...',A".,r F""' "'" :- , ..: -" .- —31— F. , - f•--ei-I-p- CT s-VOK? 1C1C(4f'"- T;vt 0 vc-fc0„, . 4-0 itt LI, czpo . 1 . , , . ,.. ILU1110C I 1 7 D (g..5.‘"6. 1.." 1411)11LPR5 IVV .., lAjA) adkaies.,011 Sch. Gr. 5:8 r - [ N L.C,,•-/k. ----- .1 . ; ,--- 10516:1 ---*/ c 1 I .. , L.C.A. 9564-8:1 ( /lab ret-rcz 17 .r..... ,• , 2kii,p010 .)), -----, :1 L.c.A. ,. , Ji 100082 -- - 4--.../.:-iZ---- L.C.A. 9212:lnia(cue_k-o(c) — dn- / L.C.A. I i , i. it , p 9564 .. H nu'a 0 o II ' Fishpond L .. .... A :. A _ 46w , / ,. , . ., _gr . .. tV V. A , i r i., ,'"; L.C.A. ri - , t evil Licv, (Pt°fr-i'( (;"'' •-,,,i , ..,'is-••LAI s..,• .. .,.:- i( ,_. .0. , L - - 0 . \ L.C.A. 9668 :: • .. r :.! • , „ . C —— . 11.•',: ,,,,:.,•-•,..-, : t .. ,, ';.;,..: ..,.,-.:,•.,.,. • . • ,.=--- HOW)!APO BAY • - .0),,0 — lirlAti-0-%r 4 1 1-—• - —I \ .: 6—C— C0g, 494'ir — 1 L.C.A. ,,„-,,,,:---zi„,.•,..:._: . 10323 , _I Wharf „r4i. e4,91'4,4C-A/4 . i f-A-001 4 , Site fgarl :*,:.- ,=„ii Church - F..„--.,-,-.-...,-,-.!.•,.-.. __ _ f.,,,,?.-..„,,-,•.,-„,,,,.... _ 0Y- C/9-41Le__42_ .. . ; ,:_•t.,:- .• • - -' ,, .. 1,-1,-,,,, / ... il7A-a-P4 •V . : r ft' - — . ' - : : VV _._ ' ' ''' ' '' '''' ' :: : - unutt!APO-BAY SHOWING THE FISHPOND ..k.', :-„,-;,_=,;i:'!,,-;',:,'-i • ---,!,-, ' Fig --1.11. -MAP "OF, PORTION OF i,,,!”,.,,- . .. t - (Source• . _ , . ' * '' - .. 'OF THE KLILEA:2=4.AW.DS NARY- . . Akt\D'SOMic.--, . - .1 . _ -.- ,-- 0 „ . . . . -- , --re, i(p.;i-ma, -1S35) - __ T)i*'....11,1.,.,.:-. .- • , L__