HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0315.045 2020-2022 •
J
it THE
:TRUST
7 ,. POB I�
e PUBLIC
` a LAND
August 3, 2021
Sent via email
Hawai`i County Council
counciltestimony@hawaiicounty.gov
Re: Testimony in Support of Res. 161-21
AUTHORIZES THE DIRECTOR OF FINANCE TO ENTER INTO NEGOTIATIONS
FOR THE ACQUISITION OF LANDS AND/OR CONSERVATION EASEMENTS FOR
ALL OR A PORTION OF THE PROPERTIES IDENTIFIED AS TAX MAP KEYS 9-4-
001: 008, 009, 016, 017, AND 023, SITUATED IN THE AHUPUA'A OF KIOLAKA'A
AND WAI'OMA'O, DISTRICT OF KA'U,UTILIZING THE PUBLIC ACCESS, OPEN
SPACE,AND NATURAL RESOURCES PRESERVATION FUND
Aloha Chair David and Councilmembers,
The Trust for Public Land is a non-profit land conservation organization and our mission
is to protect land for people, ensuring healthy, livable communities for generations to come. For
over 42 years we've worked to protect over 57,000 acres and 43 special places throughout Hawai`i.
Our Aloha `Aina Program protects lands that are culturally and historically important to Native
Hawaiian communities and returns these lands to Native Hawaiian organizations for community
and cultural stewardship. Our Sustainable Hawaii Program conserves lands that support local food
production,our forests and their native species,and clean water sources with the goal of improving
Hawai`i's self-sufficiency and food security.
The Trust for Public Land("TPL")has been working with Ka`u community organizations,
residents, lineal descendants, and the Ala Kahakai Trail Association("the Association")to protect
and acquire Kiolaka`a for community stewardship. The Ka`u community has been working for
years to permanently preserve its beloved 80 mile coast to honor Ka`u's ancestors and allow all
current and future generations to be nourished by these coastal lands. Kiolaka`a is part of this
landscape level effort to protect the Ka`u coast. We helped to protect Waikapuna in 2019 with
County and State funds and Kawala and Manaka`a which are permanently restricted to agriculture
and cultural preservation through privately funded conservation easements. We are currently
working to conserve Kaunamano with State and County funding. Combined,these projects protect
a 6,600 acre cultural and natural landscape, connected by over 6 miles of the Ala Kahakai Trail.
Kiolaka`a is an undeveloped 1,841 acre property home to treasured natural and cultural
resources including portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement,the Lua Nunu cave system and
the most extensive refuge cave on Hawaii Island, heiau,habitation sites, an intact native dryland
forest,an extensive trail network,miles of dry stack rock walls,native coastal plants,the Kapenako
fresh water spring,a complex of six anchialine ponds teeming with two varieties of`opae 'lila,and
the eastern shoreline of Ka'alu`alu Bay, a popular spot for fishing, diving, surfing, and camping.
In the 1800s, the area was used for ranching starting with Ka'alu'alu Ranch owned by Princess
Ruth Keelikolani. Today,a portion of the property is licensed to Triple LLL Ranch and MJ Ranch
for cattle grazing. Protecting these historic ranch lands would help Ka`u perpetuate its paniolo
1 Comm. No.
Ref. To: f UUn(.
Ref. Date UG 4 011
history and continue ranching livelihoods and jobs.
In September 2020, the County PONC Commission ranked Kiolaka`a number 2 priority
for funding. Each year, an extremely competitive pool of worthy and inspiring conservation
projects vie for the limited funds. The PONC Commission's high ranking of Kiolaka'a speaks to
the breadth of its rare and precious natural and cultural resources not found anywhere else in
Hawaii.
In September 2019, the State Legacy Land Conservation Commission ranked Kiolaka`a
number 2 for fiscal year 2021 funding. On April 23, 2021, the Board of Land and Natural
Resources (BLNR) approved State Legacy Land funding for Kiolaka`a. This is the only PONC
project this year that has secured matching State funding.
Ala Kahakai Trail Association has conducted extensive and inclusive community
engagement and outreach to gain community support and address questions and concerns. The
Association scheduled dozens of phone, zoom and in-person meetings with community members
and hosted two well attended community meetings. The Association presented three times to the
Hawaiian Civic Club of Ka`u;presented at the Hawai`i Island Burial Council meeting; presented
at the Na Ala Hele Advisory Council meeting; met with members of the Aha Moku Council of
Ka`u;presented at the Wiliwili Tree Festival; and set up a regular booth to talk story and engage
with community members at the local Farmer's Market in Na`alehu.
Through this community engagement effort, the Ala Kahakai Trail Association and The
Trust for Public Land confirmed overwhelming community support to protect the Ka`u coastline
(including iwi kupuna,cultural sites,and sensitive ecosystems)from development,including broad
support of the Association's efforts to protect and acquire Kiolaka`a. The Association and TPL
found that, while there may be varying opinions about issues such as the extent, type and details
of managed public access(pedestrian vs vehicular,cultural vs recreational,etc.),the need to secure
public funding to protect the land from development now is the community's priority and
outweighs future management issues, which can and will be resolved through a community
management planning process. The community also expressed that, if the Association is
successful in protecting Kiolaka`a,they want to be included as an integral part of the Association's
community management planning and stewardship efforts.
The Ala Kahakai Trail Association's previous land protection efforts demonstrate their
commitment to community-driven management and stewardship. For example, after closing
Waikapuna, the Association formed a Ka`u Stewardship Committee of eight Ka`u residents and
descendants to lead community management planning and stewardship (Shalan Crysdale,
Nohealani Ka`awa, Michelle Galimba, Ka`ohi Mokuhali`i, Jodie Rosam, Megan Lamson,
Pelehonuamea Harman and Leilani Rodrigues). Interim management of Waikapuna is guided by
this Ka`u-based Stewardship Committee. To plan for the long-term management of Waikapuna,
the County is in the process of hiring a professional planning consultant, to develop a
comprehensive and inclusive community management plan in consultation with the broader
community where everyone can participate and have a voice.
With the County as the proposed owner of a Conservation Easement over Kiolaka`a and
2
the Ala Kahakai Trail Association as the proposed future owner and steward,there is new potential
for community-based management. Local communities with relationships to place are in the best
position to vision for the future management and stewardship of their waters, lands, and cultural
and natural resources,and protect them for future generations. Protecting Kiolaka'a cannot happen
without active participation and stewardship by the entire Ka`u community.
We have attached 34 letters of support and testimony from organizations and community
members who support the protection of Kiolaka'a including: Ka `Ohana 0 Honu`apo, Ho'omalu
Ka`u, The Nature Conservancy, Hawai`i Wildlife Fund, The Mary Kawena Puku`i Cultural
Preservation Society, Makahanaloa Fishing Association, Sierra Club, Hui Aloha Kiholo, E Mau
Na Ala Hele, Huliauapa`a, `Ohana Keohokalole,The Cave Conservancy,MJ Ranch, Tripple LLL
Ranch, Kuahiwi Ranch, and the Office of Hawaiian Affairs among others.
Kiolaka'a continues to face acute threats of development as this pandemic has ushered in
new waves of investors and developers hungry to acquire property in Hawai`i. If the County passes
Resolution 161-21, the County will be able to acquire a Conservation Easement over the property
protecting it from development forever and enabling the County to monitor the property annually
to ensure its resources are protected in perpetuity. Once the Resolution is passed, Kiolaka'a will
have secured both State and County funding, and we will be in a strong position to negotiate an
option agreement with the landowner to acquire the property for conservation.
The County Council has a tremendous opportunity to protect and preserve Kiolaka'a where
natural and cultural resources will be stewarded by the Ka`u community. The PONC Program not
only conserves precious cultural and natural resources,but plays a critical role in diversifying our
economy,supporting jobs in conservation and agriculture and enhancing our food security,making
Hawaii Island more resilient in future economic downturns.
So many kupuna in Ka`u have fought for decades to protect this coastline for future
generations. The Ka`u community is so close to realizing its vision. With your help we can secure
the future of this coastline forever. Please pass Resolution 161-21 to authorize the Director of
Finance to enter into negotiations to acquire a Conservation Easement over Kiolaka'a using PONC
funds,to protect Kiolaka'a for community stewardship. Mahalo for your support.
Sincerely,
r rk t 1 t ' (ff c'
Reyna Ramolete Hayashi
Aloha Aina Project Manager
The Trust for Public Land.
Enclosed:
• 34 Letters & Testimony in Support
3
IFWU
14 1. Ka `Ghana 0 Honu'apo 18. 'Aina Akamu
2. Ho`omalu Ka`u 19. Fred Meinecke
3. The Nature Conservancy 20. Kalaho`ohie Mossman
4. Hawai`i Wildlife Fund 21. Jodie Rosam
5. The Mary Kawena Puku`i Cultural 22. Cone Yanger & Andrew Christie
Preservation Society 23. Patrick Conant
6. Makahanaloa Fishing Association 24. Gary &Deborah Johnson
7. Sierra Club 25. Selah Levine
8. Hui Aloha Kiholo 26. Cherie Felzer
9. E Mau Na Ala Hele 27. John P. Kalua'u
10. Huliauapa'a 28. Angela Guidi & Soli Coleman
11. `Ohana Keohokalole 29. Kady Foster
12. The Cave Conservancy 30. Alex Wang
13. MJ Ranch 31. Kevin OConnor, Bee Boys LLC
14. Tripple LLL Ranch 32. Ryan Williamson, Bee Boys LLC
15. Kuahiwi Ranch 33. Caitlin Kryss & Taz Rosam
16. Office of Hawaiian Affairs 34. Janice Glennie
17. Former Representative Richard Creagan
4
Ka ` Nana 0 honu`apo
0 v), Post Office Box 903
Na`alehu, HI 96772
Ica ghanahonuapapark.org
21 April 2021
Re: 4/23/21 BLNR Meeting (re Kiolaka'a)
Aloha members of the Board of Land and Natural Resources,
Mahalo for this opportunity to share our support for agenda item C2B about Kiolaka'a, Ka'u.
Ka 'Ohana 0 Honu'apo is a community-based, non-profit organization whose mission is to:
"To restore, care for and protect the natural and cultural resources within the Honu'apo area.
Utilizing the values of malama 'aina (care for the land), kupono (honesty and integrity), and
kuleana (duty and responsibility), we will work in community partnerships to preserve this area
for future generations."
Ka 'Ohana has been actively working with the county, state, and community partners since our
foundation in 2005 to help manage and improve the 230 acres now known as Honu'apo Park. In
2019, we applied for and secured a tier 1 permit to restore the estuary at Honu'apo and we
began hosting community workdays to rebuild the loko i'a earlier this year. We understand that
Ka'alu'alu Bay was also once a flourishing fishpond that provided sustenance for local residents.
It is critical for places like this one to be protected from development and providing resources
for our local community, as we have here at Honu'apo over 15 years ago.
We, the undersigned Board members of Ka 'Ohana, support the protection and acquisition of
Kiolaka'a, Tax Map Keys: (3) 9-4-01:008:009, (3) 9-4-01:008:016, (3) 9-4-01:008:017, and (3)
9-4-01:008:023, by the Ala Kahakai Trail Association (ATA), to protect and preserve the 'aina
for future generations, and return these lands to our Ka'u community through community-
based management and stewardship.
Protecting these'lands would help fulfill the Ka'u community's long standing goal of protecting
our beloved 80 mile coast. It's because of our kupuna who fought long and hard for this vision
that we are here today, with this incredible opportunity to secure another 1,840 acres along
this special shoreline.
www.konuapopark.org
Ka `Ohana 0 Honu'apo supports the Trust for Public Lands and ATA efforts to protect and
preserve the watershed, lands and forests that feed the Kali coastline and our coastal
ecosystems. We sincerely appreciate your time, consideration and commitment to protecting
Hawai'i's wahi pana for future generations, to perpetuating cultural practices, and to providing
healthy ecosystems for native wildlife.
Our community is sustained by the natural resources that surround us, and we support this land
acquisition at Kiolaka'a in order to preserve Ka`u's natural and cultural resources for future
generations and protect this region from development and land fragmentation.
Me ka mahalo (with gratitude) for your time and consideration,
From all the current Ka `Ghana 0 Honu'apo Board members:
- Kaldho'ohie Mossman (President)
- Nohealani Ka'awa (Vice President)
- Kenneth Sugai (Treasurer)
- Megan Lamson Leatherman (Secretary)
- Daniel Dierking (Director)
- Jodie Ray Rosam (Director)
www.honuapopark.org
0,44,4
'�;44,,,00 "44,40,1„i
� � i
astir Yr ::r YID f y'. \ t
, Iiiµ' " y1' C) O � u a Li a 501(c)3 non-profit corporation
�',@ } lily",� p A 'q , ��
Oro fe � ,.'� y ''' August 29, 2019
'
Ohi'a Lehr�a The Trust for Public Land
do Reyna Ramolete Hayashi
1003 Bishop St., Suite 740
DIRECTORS Honolulu, HI 96813
WENDY SCOTT-VANCE Re: Letter in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public
PRESIDENT Land's Efforts
to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a, TMKs: (3) 9-4-001:008; (3) 9-4-
CHARMAINE IiEANU 001:009;
VICE PRESIDENT
(3) 9-4-001:017.
IcEONI FOX
SECRETARY/TREASURER
To whom it may concern,
BLOSSOM DE SILVA
DIRECTOR Ho'omalu Ka'u is a community based 501(c)3 based in Na'alehu, Ka'u, Hawaii
WILLIAM IAUPEA Island. Our mission is to "perpetuate, protect and conserve the land, culture,
DIRECTOR knowledge and history of Ka'u and its people." We are committed to protecting
LEH ITA LOPEZ-MAU the archeological, cultural, and historical treasures of the Ka'u District as well as
DIRECTOR the pristine, undeveloped environmental ecosystems in Ka'u's 922 square miles.
The Ka'u Community Development Plan makes it clear that this community
supports the preservation of the 80 undeveloped miles of Ka'u coastline.
Ho'omalu Ka'u strongly supports Ala Kahakai Trail Association's efforts to pur-
chase and protect Kiolaka`a.
Kiolaka`a is a 1,836-acre property south of Waiohinu Town that includes intact
native dryland forest, the eastern shoreline of Ka`alu`alu Bay, and portions of the
ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave system. The cave system
features a fortress with an elevated defensive wall and 102 sleeping platforms,
built during the wars with Kamehameha. Other cultural sites include heiau, habi-
tation sites, petroglyphs, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National Historic
Trail. A network of trails lead to Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine
pond teeming with two varieties of`opae 'lila. The mauka pasture lands are
leased for cattle grazing, perpetuating Ka`ti's paniolo traditions.
The cultural and spiritual connections to places throughout Kiolaka`a are still
important to Native Hawaiian and local families. This connection of nature and
culture is inseparable, he pilina wehena 'ole, and serves to link us to wahi pana
(storied places) and Hawai'i's past.
The Ka'u district retains the natural resources that supported thousands of people
POST OFFICE BOX 384• NA'ALEHU,HI 96772
for millennia, and it is still the land and sea bank that can sustain generations to come. Be-
cause this area has the seeds for future sustainability(agriculture, food, medicine, tools, build-
ing materials and spiritual connection) the preservation of this land and shoreline is vital.
We sometimes forget the value of unspoiled beauty, wildlife, solitude and spiritual renewal.
Kiolaka`a offer us all of these things. Its protection in perpetuity, is important for the people
and the future of Hawai'i nei.
Mahalo nui,
Wendy Scott-Vance,
President, Ho'omalu Ka'u
The •
1 � Ll�e "' The Nature Conservancy, Hawaii Program Tel (808) 537-4508
` 923 Nu'uanu Avenue Fax (808 545-2019
Conservancy :, F Honolulu,HI 96817 nature.org/hawaii
Hawaii
August 29, 2019
The Trust for Public Land
c/o Reyna Ramolete Hayashi
1003 Bishop St., Suite 740
Honolulu, HI 96813
Re: Letter in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's Efforts
to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a, TMKs: (3) 9-4-001:008; (3) 9-4-001:009;
(3) 9-4-001:017.
The Nature Conservancy supports Ala Kahakai Trail Association's efforts to purchase and protect
Kiolaka`a in Ka`u, Hawai`i Island. Ala Kahakai Trail Association's mission is to support and guide
a community-managed trail that honors those who came before and perpetuates for those to follow—
with protocols and respect for Hawai`i's past, present and future.
The property is below the village of Wai`ohinu, and native seasonal mesic and dryland forest
remnants found in the rough lava lands support stands of lama, wiliwili, alahee, hao,ulei,naio, and
the listed endangered kauila. Along the shoreline at Ka'alu'alu Bay a network of trails lead to
Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond teeming with two varieties of`opae `ula, and
thickets of naupaka, milo, and `auhuhu at the water's edge. The adjacent Kamilo section of the Ka`u
Forest Reserve in Wai`ohinu contains the most diverse native coastal strand vegetation remaining
on Hawai'i Island.
Founded in 1951, The Nature Conservancy(TNC) is a leading conservation organization working
around the world to protect ecologically important lands and waters for nature and people. Our
mission is to conserve the lands and waters on which all life depends. TNC's Hawai`i Program has
helped to protect nearly 200,000 acres of natural lands in Hawai`i. We manage 40,000 acres in 13
preserves and work in 30 coastal communities to help protect the near-shore reefs and waters of the
main Hawaiian islands.
TNC's Ka`u Forest Preserve is part of the largest and most intact expanse of native forest in the
state and featuring closed-canopy koa and `ohi'a sheltering a lush understory of native uluhe and
halm'u tree ferns, rare plants and endangered forest birds. Also, our coastal Kamehame Beach
Preserve is a critically important nesting site for the endangered hawksbill turtle and a refuge for the
threatened green sea turtle whose survival depends upon undisturbed nesting sites and healthy coral
reefs primarily on Hawai`i island.
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
Mark E.Agne Duke E.Ah Moo Paul D.Alston Dr.C.Tana Burkert Richard A.Cooke III Ka`iulani de Silva Brian J.Doyle
Robert J.Dzielak Dr.Alan M.Friedlander James J.C.Haynes III Sean A Hehir Brett MacNaughton Kathy M. Matsui
'Janet Montag Alicia Moy James C.Polk Dustin E.Sellers Nathan E.Smith(Chair) Peter K Tomozawa Richard N.Zwern
/hupaniAdvisory Council:ChristopherJ.Benjamin Kenton T.Eldridge Eiichiro Kuwana Duncan MacNaughton Jean E.Rolles Crystal K Rose
Founders:Samuel A Cooke Herbert C.Cornuelle
The Nature Conservancy, Hawai'i Program
August 29,2019
Page 2
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka`u community's long standing goal of protecting our
beloved 80 mile coast to perpetuate our rural lifestyle and Hawaiian culture. Access to the coastline
is important for our community which still relies on subsistence fishing, farming,•and gathering.
Conserving this landscape will perpetuate cultural access for descendants and recreational access
for travelers along the ancient trail allowing all to walk in the footsteps of Ka`u's ancestors.
Mahalo,
Shalan Crysdale
Director, Hawai'i Island Forest Program
The Nature Conservancy
(808) 443 5413 scrysdale@tnc.org
�
t,
• a
hawai`i Wildlife runc!
fort CYJ'!cc 50x JO • volcano,/ Yl•9678,5
Celebrating 23 years of protecting f hawai'i s native
wildlife through research,education and conservation.
The Trust for Public Land
c/o Reyna Ramolete Hayashi
1003 Bishop St., Suite 740
Honolulu, HI 96813
5 September 2019
Re: Letter in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's Efforts
to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka'a, TMKs: (3) 9-4-001:008; (3) 9-4-001:009;
(3) 9-4-001:017.
To Whom It May Concern:
Hawaii Wildlife Fund supports Ala Kahakai Trail Association's efforts to purchase and protect
Kiolaka'a in Ka'u, Hawaii Island. Ala Kahakai Trail Association (AKTA)'s mission is to support and
guide a community-managed trail that honors those who came before and perpetuates for those to
follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai'i's past, present and future.
Kiolaka'a is a 1,836-acre property south of Wai ohinu Town that includes intact native dryland forest,
the eastern shoreline of Ka'alu'alu Bay, and portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua
Nunu cave system. The cave system features a fortress with an elevated defensive wall and 102
sleeping platforms, built during the wars with Kamehameha. Other cultural sites include heiau,
habitation sites, petroglyphs, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. A network of
�"' www.wiIc/Iia wail.or,
trails lead to Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond teeming with two varieties of'Opae
'ula. The mauka pasture lands are leased for cattle grazing, perpetuating Ka'u's paniolo traditions.
Hawaii Wildlife Fund (HWF) is a small nonprofit organization that has been working to conserve
native species in Hawaii since 1996. During'that time, we have been involved in research,
education, restoration and advocacy projects related to marine debris, Hawaiian sea turtles,
community-based management, environmental education, anchialine pool restoration, and more.
During this time, we have also recovered over 300 tons (600,000 lbs.) of marine debris from the
coastlines of Hawaii Island, Maui and Midway with the help of thousands of volunteers, and can'
attest first-hand to the growing problem of plastic pollution in and around the Hawaiian islands and
the threat this poses to our native flora and fauna. We hope that this purchase by the Ala Kahakai
Trails Association will both'help protect native plant and animal species, and the archeological
history (and continued cultural use) of the area now and into the future. We look forward to
working more with the AKTA to expand the capacity of our coastal conservation organization (and
other partners like The Nature Conservancy), with support from the Hawai'i Department of Land and
Natural Resources and the County of Hawai'i's Public Access, Open Space and Natural Resources
Commission) to conserve the remote southern shores of Hawai'i Island.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka'u community's long standing goal of protecting our
beloved 80 mile coast to perpetuate our rural lifestyle and Hawaiian culture. Access to the coastline
is important for our community which still relies on subsistence fishing, farming, and gathering.
Conserving this landscape will perpetuate cultural access for descendants and recreational access for
travelers along the ancient trail allowing all to walk in the footsteps of Ka`u's ancestors.
Please let us know if you have any additional questions about this letter of support.
Sincerely,
Megan R. Lamson, M.S.
President& Program Director
HWF - Hawai`i Island Program Director
megan@wildhawaii.org
(808) 217-5777
www.wild/7a wail.org
The Mary Kawena Puku`i Cultural Preservation Society
A Unique and Invaluable Educational Resource
March 31, 2021
Aloha kakou,
My name is La'akea Suganuma, president of the Mary Kawena Puku'i Cultural
Preservation Society and Mrs. Puku`i`s eldest grandson. She was born on April 20, 1895
in Haniumalu, above Na'alehu and raised by her granddmoter, Nali`ipo`aimoku a kahuna
la'au lapa'au, a medicinal expert and a kahuna pale keiki, a trained midwife. Kawena
was chosen to learn from her grandmother and grew up with no children her own age to
play with. She was always with her grandmother, who was born about 1830, so those
she was always around, listened to and learned from were elders. After her
grandmother passed away, her instruction continued, led by her mother, Pa'ahana and
her aunts and uncles.
For those of you who aren't familiar with Kawena Puku`i, she was a true child o Ka`u
who was determined to preserve the culture, language, dances, chants, songs, wisdom,
history, legends, beliefs and traditions of her people. Duringher lifetime, she authored
9 � p P
or co-auuthored over fifty books and scholarly papers and over a hundred songs and
chants beginning with `Hawaiian Stories and Wise Sayings," in 1923 to 'Olelo No`eau in
1983. I shold clarify that it was her last work while she was alive. She passed away in
1986, but other works of hers have been published after that. Among her publications
were the Hawaiian Dictionary in 1957, the Polynesian Family System of Ka`u, Native
Planters, Songs (metes) of Old Ka`u. In addition, she translated the works of Kamakau,
John Papa I`i, Kepelino and Malo. Her songs include "Ka`u Nui" and 'Ke Ala A Ka Jeep"
written at Uncle Willie Meinecke's home in Waiohinu after a day of sharing her homeland
with Eddie and Myrna Kamae. Songs composed with Maddy Lam, Irmgard Aluli,
Kahauanu Lake are considered classics that will be favorites as long as Hawaiian music
existsl. With all these accomplishments, my grandmothe was soft-spoken and humble,
never pursuing recognition, awards or financial gain. She lived by all the Hawaiian
values we admire and talk about today. In fact, I can hear her now, telling me, "Lawa
kela! - That's enough about me.".
Her grandmother, Nali`ipo`aimoku was the first of her generation to receive a Christian
burial. The many generations of our family before her were deposited in Kilauea, after
midnight, their bones wrapped in red and black kapa accompanied by the proper
prayers. Many, many generations, back into the dim mists of time, followed this
procedure of those who considered Pele, an aumakua, an ancestral guardian, The Fire
Clan of Ka`u
Raised by her from infancy, she instilled in me her love for the sands of her birth, that
deep aloha that I have passed on to my children and them to theirs. Genealogy'has
always been very important to Hawaiians. While growing up and introducing
835Ahuwale St., Honolulu, Hawai`i 96821 *ph.(808)377-5611 *fx.(808)377-5612
mar pkawenapukui1d inail.coin *marykawenapukui.coin
schoolmates to her, she could talk about their family and where they were from. Some-
times I recall her saying, "Oh, your family is from Ka`u and we are related." I was
surprised to hear someone at the last BLNR meeting speaking unkindly of genealogy.
I`m sure their kupuna were saddened to hear such talk. Speaking of talk, I was taught
that in the word is life, in the word is death. One must choose his words carefully,
because once said, words take on life. You cannot retrieve them and there may be
consquencers for what one says.
One of the things my grandmother told me repeatedly while growing-up was, "Of one
`ohana, one family, are the people of Ka`u." She said that to the western man, they go
back one or two generations and that's all. To Hawaiians, `ohana is `ohana, no matter
where they are and extends back to the beginning of time.
There's something different about those whose ancestry traces back to Ka`u, something
I'd like to try to explain. It`s a strong bond of aloha and respect because of our ancestry.
Like Kenneth Makuakane, the pastor at Kawaiaha`o Church. When we see each other,
no matter how long it's been, It`s always a greeting of, "Aloha cuz" with a hug. The
same with Sky Ishibashi, direct descendent of Kalaniopu`u, or Cy Bridges, noted kumu
hula and genealogist in Hau'ula whose ancestry.includes Kuluwaimaka famous chanter
from Ka`u, cousin of Nali`ipo`aimoku, both of whom traveled as part of Queen Emma's
court when summoned. We are also related through the chief of Kama'oa, Lilikalani or
Haililani and other ways. Always a "Howzit Cuz?" Or an old schoolmate, Ted Mokiao,
who I might not see for twenty years or more, but when our paths cross, it's a warm,
"Aloha cousin" that's exchanged. Or something I`ve experienced with a couple of friends
I`ve known for many years. Like Umi Kai who started training in lua back im 1994 with
me and who recently told me his grandparents were from Waiohinu or respected Kumu
Hula and Hawaiian language teacher, Kimo Keaulana, now at Punahou School who also
recently told me of his Ka`u ancestry. They are no longer friends. They are now family.
I`ve met many, many people throughout my life, whose ancestry goes back to Ka`u.
There is a different feeling of respect and aloha, unlike any other place in Hawaii.
Our family lived in every part of Ka`u. I previously submitted the English translation of
an old chant to the BLNR, composed in the early 1800`s, Ka-lawai`a-holona-i-ke-kai-a-
Manaka`a. It`s about my grandmother's grandfather, Keli`ikanaka`oleoHaililani, his
brother Kekipi and cousin Kawelu, three men from Waikapuna fishing 'at Manaka'a, one
of the areas included in this acquisition. Not long after this chant was composed,
Kawelu's wife, Huli-o-ka-manomano, gave birth to baby girl. Years later, after she had
grown up and married, she gave birth to a stillborn child. Kanaka'ole took the child,
placed her in a large calabash and held it up to catch the warmth of the Waikapuna sun
and prayed that she would live. The baby stirred and cried, and Kanaka`ole named her
Hanau-maka-o-kalani (Kalani_who was born from his mother's eye), for an 'aumakua
who lived in the sea. This infant who was brought back to life, was the great grand aunt
of Keoni Fox of the Alakahakai Trail Association.
page 2
In 1960, my grandmother brought me with her on a field trip to Hawaii Island, while
with the Bishop Museum to record elders who spoke about their lives, memories and
experiences. In Ka`u, we stayed at Uncle Willie Meinecke's house in Waiohinu and
visited with 74 year-old Uncle George Kawaha, who lived a few houses away. He told
me stories about his father, Luhi, and his maternal grandfather, Kaho`omana who was a
lua man. On the 17th and 18th of August we went to Na'alehu school where Ku'umi Kin
in and Kalama Kahape`a were recorded. Ku'umi's wife invited us for dinner after the
second day and I remember Ku'umi being so happy that electric lights were installed and
turned on in his new house just before we arrived. The next day we went to Ka'alu'alu
to record a famous fisherman of Ka`u, Kawelauokekapu Kua'ana,the gtanduncle of
Kawehi Ryder who I photographed with an old Brownie Hawkeye camera I borrowed
from my mother. They are, as far as I know, the only pictures of him in existence. Two
days ago, Kawehi was in Honolulu to meet with 91 year-old Riley Fujikawa who, in his
youth, stayed with Kapu at Ka'alu'alu. He tells the story of going out in Kapu`s canoe to
deep water, when Kapu grabbed a big stone in the canoe and his spear. Holding the stone to his
chest, he sunk down to the bottom quickly and started poking his spear into a hole. Riley said he
came up with a big he`e (octopus) and when Kapu carried it ashore over his shoulder, the head was
by his waist and the tentacles dragged on the sand behind him.
There is an old story about a Ka`u chief who got greedy, taking more than his share of fish, leaving
the families without fish. One day, the fishermen convinced the chief to go fishing with them because
only he could insure a good catch. They paddled far from land, into the deep sea. As they caught
fish, they loaded them all in the chief's canoe. His paddlers jumped out so more fish could be thrown
in his canoe. As the canoe started to take on water, the chief protested but was told, "Oh no great
one, you deserve all we can catch." The fishermen then turned their canoes toward home and
paddled full speed. They landed at Ka'alu'alu and never looked back. The greedy chief was seen no
more. Ka'alu'alu is part of this Ka`u acquisition.
All these places and people have special meaning to our `ohana. If the many generations of our
family were standing here and were given the choices of development or preservation for the
generations to come, I can say to this commission, without hesitation and with the prevailing belief of
aloha `aina, that we fully support the effort of the Alakahakai Trail Association and the Trust for Public
Lands to preserve and protect these lands of Ka`u Nui....Ka`u kua makaani. Majestic Ka`u, Ka`u of
the windblown back.
Mahalo for your kind attention and consideration.
Page 3
William Keoni Fox
From: Makahanaloa Fishing Association <makahanaloafishing@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, February 05, 2021 12:36 PM
To: blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov; reyna.ramolete@tpl.org;fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Subject: Testimony in Support Conservation of Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a FishingVillage
Follow Up Flag: Follow up
Flag Status: Completed
February, 4th, 2021
State of Hawai`i Board of Land and Natural Resources
The Trust for Public Land
Ala Kahakai Trail Association
Re: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's Efforts to
Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village in Ka'u, Hawaii
The Makahanaloa Fishing Association strongly supports Ala Kahakai Trail Association and The Trust for
Public Land's efforts to help the Ka`u community purchase and protect, in perpetuity, Kiolaka`a and Manaka'a
Fishing Village(the makai lands of Kawala).
Makahanaloa Fishing Association represents over one hundred and twenty `ohana from Pepe`ekeo, Papa`ikou,
and Honomu. Our access to traditional fishing areas has been threatened since the sugar plantations slow
demise, ending in the 1990s. The Association is by every means seeking to grow and to protect our fishing
community's rights to provide food for their families and maintain the generational bond with our treasured
shoreline areas. Many of our Association members travel to Ka`u to fish and gather and are grateful to the
community of Ka`u for working to maintain and preserve these important shoreline sites.
Kiolaka`a is makai of Waiohinu Town and includes intact native dryland forest, the eastern shoreline of
Ka'alu'alu Bay, portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave system, and a segment of
the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. A network of trails lead to Kapenako, a fresh water spring and
anchialine pond teeming with `opae
Manaka`a Fishing Village stands on the sea cliffs overlooking Waikapuna Bay, along with 22 precious cultural
sites including heiau, burial caves, lava tube habitation sites,water collection caves with underground springs,
and ancient habitation complexes. Over one mile of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail runs through the
property and two ancient mauka-makai trails connect Na'alehu with the coastline.
Personally, I have been fortunate to visit most of these precious and storied places with my ohana. I spent time
restoring Kapenako, camping at Ka'alu'alu, throwing net at Waikapuna, and standing in awe at the caves, lava
tubes, and heiau that foim the piko of this `aina. My heart breaks when I think of this area developed for people
who would likely not have the appropriate respect for the history and abundance of this area.
1
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka`u community's long standing goal of protecting an irreplacable and
unique 80 mile coastline. Access to this coastline is important for our whole island community which still relies
on subsistence fishing and gathering. Remember he i`a kokekoke ka ka lawai`a, a fisherman always finds fish
nearby, but we must ensure that our fundamental rights to gather from and malama these special places is
preserved for all time.
Mahalo me ka ha`a,
Blake McNaughton
Vice President
Makahanaloa Fishing Association
M akahanalo afi shing@gmai 1.corn
808-756-1054
Makahanaloa Fishing Association
27-1049 Old Mamalahoa Hwy Pepe`ekeo 96783
Ua ola no o kai i kai - Fishers live by their own efforts
'Olelo No`eau(2838)
2
IuRRAp
0 � mHAWAII ISLAND GROUP
March 30, 2021
Aloha, Legacy Land Commissioners,
Subject: Support Grant funds for Kiolaka`a
My name is----Deborah Ward, and as Chair of the Hawaii Island Group of Sierra Club, my
testimony represents the support of over 800 members, some of whom are Native Hawaiian
practitioners, hikers, scientists, recreational users and conservation activists. One of many services our
club offers is hikes that are led by certified leaders to wild lands at no cost to the public. I am writing
today to ask you to protect Kiokaka'a, coastal property in Ka'u. Many of us have known and loved this
area for many years. We feel very strongly that it is a resource that is too precious to lose to
development. I have recently been appointed and confirmed as representative to the Hawaii County
Public Access, Open Space and Natural Resources Preservation Commission (PONC)for District 5, and
have had the opportunity to review the files on this proposal.
BLNR will be considering a recommendation by the State Legacy Land Conservation Commission
to grant an award for the preservation of Kiolaka'a at Ka'alu'alu Bay by the Ala Kahakai Trail Association
(ATA) in April. An application was submitted to the State Legacy Land Commission in 2019 and out of
twelve applications across the State, this two Ka'u property was ranked#2. Sierra Club members and
hundreds of others worked hard to protect the lands that include "Road to the Sea", prized by local
fishers in Kahuku, and we believe this would be a significant and valuable addition to the protected
natural landscape.
Protection of the Ka`u coastline has been a long-standing goal of our community.With only a
handful of privately owned properties at risk of development,this vision of protecting the entire Ka'u
coastline can be achieved.A preservation purchase would protect this beautiful stretch of coastline
which has been threatened by development interests for many years. This and other properties have
been targeted for large scale subdivisions. These developments would impact numerous cultural sites
throughout the landscape as well as sensitive native plant habitat, open space and public access. As
part of Sierra Club's commitment to community-based stewardship and management,we are willing to
work with the community to create a management plan for the land. The management plan will address
elements such as public access, education and resource protection. This property is currently listed for
sale and it is possible that either the existing owner or new owners could continue with development
plans if we are unable to raise the funds.
Recently we took part in a virtual community discussion (2.16.21)to be sure that our community
does have consensus about the high priority protection of our critical lands.John Replogle led off the
discussion, reminiscing about kupuna Pele Hanoa, who pledged to protect this land in perpetuity. Brent
Kakasako and Bog Agres facilitated the discussion.
The following is a list (but is not comprehensive) of Ka'u residents and supporters who took part in the
community meeting: Leah Lani Rothbaum.Angelica Peneran, Reyna Ramolete Hayashi, Kaleo Paik, Fred
Kanali Meinecke, Leilani Rodrigues,Jodie, Rosam, Annie Bosited, Pelehonuamea Suganuma, Keoni Fox,
La'akea, Suganuma, Flora Krivak-Tetely, Scott Mahoney, Nanea Bekeart, Richard Taylor, Leivalyn Kaupu,
Sierra Club Hawai`i Island Group I sierraclubhig.org
Michelle Galimba, Pua Yang, Ethan Souza, Kala Keahealani Wright, Otis Salmo, Lea Hong, Angelica
Penaran, Pua Yang, Mel Yokyama, Brown Leiokeko'olani, Lynn Hamilton,Julia Neal, Carol Fong, Luana
Fox, Leimana Damate, Melanie Seyler, Nohealani Ka'awa, Bob Martin, Aina Akamu, Kaimi Kaupiko,
Wendy Vance,Jackson Bauer,Jon Oshima, Kaohi Mokuhali'i, Rae, Donna Ambrose, Monte McComber,
Katie Graham.
The outcome of the meeting was a consensus that the purchase of the land is of the highest
importance, and that the specifics of management, pedestrian and vehicular access, kupuna access, and
maintenance are all aspects of care that can and will be addressed in meetings with community
members to follow. We agreed that if this land were to be developed for private holdings, significant
cultural, archaeological and natural resources could be lost forever.
For this reason we believe that the Legacy Land grant is in the best interest of the Ka'u
community,the Hawaii Island Community, and the state as a whole.
Thank you for considering this testimony in support.
Deborah Ward, Chair, Hawaii Island Group, Sierra Club
Opti Vh010
Our mission is to protect,perpetuate and preserve the cultural and natural landscape of the
Kiholo Bay area through collaborative management and active community stewardship.
February 9th,2021
State of Hawaii The Trust for Public Land Ala Kahakai Trail Association
Board of Land and Natural Resources reyna.ramolete@tpl.org fox@alakahakaitrail.org
bin r.testi mony@hawa i i.g ov
Re: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's Efforts to Protect
and Acquire Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a Fishing Village in Ka'u, Hawai'i
Aloha mai kakou,
Hui Aloha Kiholo strongly supports Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and The Trust for Public Land's efforts to
help the Ka'u community purchase and forever protect Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a Fishing Village (the makai
lands of Kawala).
Hui Aloha Kiholo is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization whose missions is to preserve, protect, and enhance
the cultural and natural landscape of the Kiholo bay area through collaborative management and active
community stewardship. Our stewardship of Kiholo bay, North Kona, Hawaii Island,through a Curatorship
agreement with Hawaii Division of State Parks has resulted in over a decade of care of over 2,000 acres of
coastline at a level far beyond what the State could have done on its own.The benefits to Kiholo's cultural
and natural resources, lineal descendants,families, community,visitors, and partners have been immense,
and we gladly anticipate similar fruits of this upcoming ATA-TPL collaboration.
The following highlights the main reasons Hui Aloha Kiholo supports a conservation purchase and
permanent protection of the makai lands of Kawala:
• Enables the active stewardship of ancestral homelands by people of place and the continuation of a
rich living Hawaiian culture.ATA's Ka'u Stewardship Committee is comprised entirely of Ka'u
residents to guide the stewardship Ka'u lands through the development of a Community
Management Plan in partnership with broader stakeholders within 18 months of taking ownership.
• Connects public lands to its north and south, protecting important natural landscapes and
oceanscapes which will only become more valuable and vulnerable into the future.
• Protects native dryland forest,the eastern shoreline of Ka'alu'alu Bay, portions of the ancient
Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave system, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National
Historic Trail.
• Protects a rich cultural complex, including heiau, burial caves, lava tube habitation sites,water
collection caves with underground springs, and ancient habitation complexes.
• Maintains access to the coastline,which is important for the Ka'u community,which still relies
heavily on subsistence fishing and gathering, as well as for the public, allowing all to walk in the
footsteps of Ka'u's ancestors.
It is fortunate, indeed,for our Hawaii nei to see the intersection of dedicated community and stewardship
organizations, committed to pairing their strengths and carrying the kuleana (responsibility) of stewarding
the lands and people of Kawala makai. Hui Aloha Kiholo urges you to support the successful completion of
this land acquisition and protection.
Mahalo nui loa,
Nahaku Kalei
Executive Director, Hui Aloha Kiholo
P.O. Box 1868 I Kamuela, HI 96743 I www.huialohakiholo.org
�~ I RELE
P.O.13OX 6384 KAMUELA,HAWAII 087434384
To Preserve and Protect the Ancient and Historic Trails of Hawai'i—
.,; 7----- incutdingtheir Natural and Cultural surroundings
February 21, 2021
State of Hawai`i
Board of Land and Natural Resources
blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov
The Trust for Public Land
reyna.ramolete@tpl.org
Ala Kahakai Trail Association
fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Re: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's
Efforts to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village in Ka`u,
Hawai'i
E Mau Na Ala Hele, a non-profit organization established in 1979 and dedicated to preserving the
ancient and historic trails of Hawai`i strongly supports the Ala Kahakai Trail Association (ATA)
and The Trust for Public Land's (TPL) efforts to help with the acquisition of a 1,841.3-acre parcel
in Kiolaka`a Ahupua'a and a 348-acre parcel in Kawala Ahupua'a (also known as the Manaka'a
Fishing Village). Both areas are known for their rich cultural and natural resources that need long-
term stewardship and protection.
Kiolaka`a is makai of Waiohinu Town and includes intact native dryland forest, the eastern
shoreline of Ka'alu'alu Bay, portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement, the Lua Nunu cave
system, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. A network of trails lead to
Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond teeming with `opae `ula. The mauka pasture
lands are leased for cattle grazing, which perpetuates Ka`u's long-standing paniolo traditions.
Manaka`a Fishing Village is on the sea cliffs overlooking Waikapuna Bay, and includes twenty-
two known cultural sites including heiau,burial caves, lava tube habitation sites, water collection
caves with underground springs, and ancient habitation complexes. Over one mile of the Ala
Kahakai National Historic Trail runs through the property and two ancient mauka-makai trails
connect Na`alehu with the coastline.
ATA's mission is to support and guide a community-managed trail that honors those who came
before and perpetuates for those to follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai`i's past,present
E A . . NA A LA EL
^� P.O.BOX 63U KAMUELA,HAWAII 981434384
To Preserve and Protect the Ancient and Historic Trails of Naw✓ai'i—
Inculding their Natural and Cultural Surroundings
and future. ATA has a Ka`u Stewardship Committee which is comprised entirely of Ka`u residents
to guide the stewardship and management of its Ka`u lands. If ATA is successful in protecting
these properties, it has committed to developing a Community Management Plan in partnership
with Ka`u community groups, descendants, and stakeholders. ATA is committed to community-
based management of these lands and their natural and cultural resources.
As a Hawai`i Island-based trails advocacy group, E Mau Na Ala Hele is certain that ATA with the
support of TPL and the Ka`u Stewardship Committee are well equipped and committed to the
long-term protection and stewardship of these lands. Supporting the efforts of these groups will
help ensure that these places,which are steeped in history and valued natural and cultural resources
are properly cared for and protected.
Protection of these treasuredplaces will helpensure the residents of Kau and the people of'
p p
Hawai`i can continue to interact with these places in a more sustainable manner. Sustainable
stewardship is vital to maintain the natural beauty of Ka`u so that this place may be enjoyed by
current and more importantly future generations.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka`u community's long standing goal of protecting their
beloved 80 mile coast to perpetuate their rural lifestyle and cultural traditions and practices.Access
to the coastline is important for their community which still relies on subsistence fishing and
gathering. Conserving this landscape will enable community based management of Ka`u's lands
and resources, and perpetuate cultural and subsistence access to the coast for descendants,
community members, and the public, allowing all to walk in the footsteps of Ka`u's ancestors.
Mahalo,
Kamuela Plunkett
President
On behalf of the Board of E Mau Na Ala Hale:
Lokelani Brandt Adele Salzman
Karen Clarkson Barbara Schaeffer
Marcie Davis Suze Shannon
Linda Gallano Johnathan Tadross
AmpniNo
' ►2 t VILILIAUAPAA
August 29, 2019
The Trust for Public Land
c/o Reyna Ramolete Hayashi
1003 Bishop St., Suite 740
Honolulu, HI 96813
Re: Letter in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public
Land's Efforts to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a, TMKs: (3) 9-4-001:008; (3) 9-4-
001:009; (3) 9-4-001:017.
Huliauapa'a strongly supports Ala Kahakai Trail Association and The Trust for
Public Land's efforts to help the Ka`u community purchase and forever protect
Kiolaka`a. Ala Kahakai Trail Association's mission is to support and guide a
community-managed trail that honors those who came before and perpetuates for
those to follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai`i's past, present and future.
Protection of the Ka`u coastline has been a long standing goal of the community.
Kiolaka`a is a 1,836-acre property south of Waiohinu Town that includes intact
native dryland forest, the eastern shoreline of Ka'alu'alu Bay, and portions of the
ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave system. The cave system
features a fortress with an elevated defensive wall and 102 sleeping platforms,built
during the wars with Kamehameha. Other cultural sites include heiau, habitation
sites, petroglyphs, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. A
network of trails lead to Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond
teeming with two varieties of`opae 'lila. The mauka pasture lands are leased for
cattle grazing, perpetuating Ka`u's paniolo traditions.
Protecting Kiolaka`a from development would ensure continued access to this
coastline for subsistence fishing and cattle ranching, cultural access for
descendants, and recreational access for travelers along the ancient ala loa (Ala
Kahakai Trail) so future generations can walk in the footsteps of their ancestors.
Huliauapa'a's vision is wahi kupuna thriving through Hawaiian self-
determination. Our mission is to grow Hawai`i's communities through culturally
based dimensions of innovative learning, leadership development and
collaborative networking in wahi kupuna stewardship. We are a Native Hawaiian
non-profit organization which seeks to educate haumana and communities on the
appropriate stewardship of wahi kupuna. Huliauapa'a members, including
resource managers, researchers, educators, cultural practitioners, and students,
share a unifying commitment and belief: to protect, preserve, and perpetuate
Hawai'i's cultural and natural resources through educational opportunities,
community outreach, and advocacy. Our organization is intent on transforming
Cultural Resource Management (CRM)\ in Hawaii, by integrating `Oiwi'
perspectives into our every-day operations and activities and striving to give
Hawaiians and kama`aina a voice and a meaningful role in managing our own
resources.
4,74070
'40t 1-4ULIAIJAPA'A
Huliauapa'a provides educational programs, such as the Wahi Kupuna Internship
Program (WKIP),which is a summer internship for undergraduate students in the
fields of Anthropology, Archaeology, Hawaiian Studies, and related fields. The
program targets Native Hawaiian and kama`aina students to increase their
representation in Hawai`i's Cultural Resource Management (CRM) field by
providing them cultural and scientific mentoring, professional development,
education, and applied field experiences. The program aims to develop and
support the next generation of cultural resource managers in Hawaii by offering a
learningenvironment that bridges the worldviews of culture and science and
by
encouraging the interns to respect, appreciate, and utilize their cultural values,
beliefs, and practices while conducting archaeological research. Kiolaka`a, Ka`u
would serve to be an ideal learning environment and the perfect educational
grounds for training our youth and communities in the tools of cultural resource
management and provide a perfect setting to further connect our people to our
`aina and wahi pana.
Huliauapa'a ran our annual Wahi Kupuna Internship Program in Ka`u in 2014 and
we were able to visit the Ka`u coast with Keoni Fox and his ohana, and it was an
inspirational experience for our students and staff.To see first hand that there are
still intact cultural landscapes in our islands that provide a direct connection to our
kupuna was something that many of us have not experienced before. These types
of settings are extremely important to preserve to teach our keiki and lahui how
our kupuna were able to utilize the natural, cultural, and marine resources to live
sustainably in these islands. There are many lessons that we can learn today from
how our ancestors understood and utilized our unique environments, and
Kiolaka'a is one of those cultural landscapes that should be preserved and
protected for these special opportunities in the future.
Mahalo for your support,
0 jAkideord—
Kelley L. Uyeoka
Executive Director
Huliauapa`a
kell ey@ huliauapaa.org
www.huliauapaa.org
February 16, 2021
Board of Land and Natural Resources
Hawaii State Government
Re: Testimony in support of the Ala Kahakai Trail Association (ATA)
& Trust for Public Lands (TPL) efforts to protect and
acquire Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village in Ka`u, Hawaii
Aloha mai kdkou:
Our organization, `Ghana Keohokdlole, is in full support of the efforts of the
Ala Kahakai Trail Association (ATA) and the Trust for Public Lands (TPL)
to help the Ka`u community acquire, manage and steward the lands named
above as well as all other unprotected Ka`u lands into perpetuity. The
missions of the aforementioned organizations have been well documented in
the Board's own records, and our `Ohana, without reservation, applauds and
respects their continuing work to protect these precious lands of Ka`u for
present and future generations.
`Ohana Keohokdlole is a federally-recognized Native Hawaiian
Organization (NHO), and, as one of its main missions, was established in
1999 in response to ongoing issues of disturbance of iwi kupuna (Native
Hawaiian ancestral remains) to make room for housing developments,
building of new and refurbishing of outdated hotels in Waikiki and updating
aging infrastructure in Honolulu proper. We have been recognized as both
cultural and lineal claimants by the burial councils on Oahu, Hawaii Island,
and Maui. As a testament to the commitment of our organization together
with several of our claimant families of Waikiki, we designed and built a
burial repository that sits on the corner of Kapahulu and Kaldkaua Avenues
in Waikiki. This repository now houses the remains of kupuna that have
been unearthed in Waikiki and other places around the moku, and still has
space for future disturbances.
A second mission of our organization, is that of Hawaiian education by
providing opportunities for our ldhui to study and learn the Hawaiian
language, research and explore family connections by tracing one's roots,
leading field excursions to cultural sites, participating in and offering
training to kupuna and students to further their knowledge of the Hawaiian
heritage. We have provided seed money for development of curriculum
development, scholarships for student and kupuna travel for cultural
exchange in Hawai`i, the mainland, and overseas.
Given these introductions about us, mo ok7 auhau is very important when
our family speaks of Ka`u. Our Ka`u connections go back to High Chief
Keawe-a-Heulu, ruler of Ka`u after 1791, born at Paiaha'a Bay. His heiau,
Panee, which he built is located in Wai`ohinu. Our familial ties to High
Chiefess Ane Keohokalole, granddaughter of High Chief Keawe-a-Heulu
and mother of our last King and Queen, underscores our ties to Ka`u as she
was owner of many parcels of land which eventually became the sugar
plantations. Also, our kupuna kane, Keohokalole and his brother Manunu,
owned 106 acres of land at Kiolaka`a where they lived before the
catastrophic earthquake of 1868. Many Hawaiians perished and were
displaced from their lands because of this disaster.
The benefits of preservation of the Kiolaka`a and Mandka`a lands are many.
Our organization believes the greatest benefits that can be derived from a
unified, concerted community effort such as this one is 1) the assurance of
access to the fishing areas as well as gathering rights along the coast; 2) the
planting of food crops in the uplands to provide food security; and, 3) the
educational opportunities for our ldhui and descendants to help manage,
protect, and learn about the stewardship of all the cultural resources that are
inherent in the landscape left by our kupuna. We want our descendants to
appreciate their inheritance.
A final comment. For us, the basic mark of our identity and connection to
Kali is the `dina. We are tied to Kali through our kupuna's existence on
their `dina when they occupied their lands. The metaphor of the mo `o in the
word mo oku auhau as defined by the kupuna is that of a continuing
succession of family—pedigree. No pronouncement of"outsidership" in
any way removes our claims to Ka`u which we, `Ohana Keohokalole, make
on the basis of our kupuna who lived in Ka`u.
All of you who are privileged to live in Ka`u at this time cannot nor should
P g
you ignore the claims and comments of the descendants of those who
occupied these lands before your arrival. No single organization "owns"
Ka`u. All of us are members of the Ka`u family and community, regardless
of where our families now reside. We are all obligated to and have the
urgent responsibility of protecting this `aina. Remember that our kupuna are
watching and listening and they expect us to hana like (work together). We
must do it with Aloha and respect each other in this entire endeavor.
May Ke Akua give us wisdom to move forward me ke ku `ikahi (with unity).
Mary Kawena Puku`i in `Olelo No`eau 1620, "Ka`u lepo `ula`ula"
"Ka`u of the red earth" said of the natives of old Ka`u, who were one vast
family..." We are one vast family!
If you have questions or require clarification on any of the above, feel free to
contact us at eek4@hawaii.edu.
`Ohana Keohokalole, NHO Emma Emalia Keohokalole
Family Representative
POBox565
Kaneohe, Hawaii 96744
(808) 371-3398
e-m: eek4@hawaii.edu
iFVo ^wrMrM**ZY,w.�hy+- 'NAM1 nu r1b .
' ia" CAVE CONSERVANCY OF HAWAII
3y «> 1 47. P.O. Box 7083
l OCEAN VIEW, HI 96737
10 MARCH, 2021
'M+yrNN _ :'WWMMv MdM NF✓xlfia'wW IA•o �.d
State of Hawaii
Board of Land and Natural Resources
blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov
Re: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's Grant
Application to Acquire and Protect Kiolaka`a (Item C1 B) and
Manaka`a Fishing Village (Item C1C) in Ka'u, Hawaii
Aloha Madam Chair Suzanne Case and Board Members
My name is Tomislav Gracanin. As President of the Cave Conservancy of Hawaii (CCH), I
represent a Ka'u based conservation organization whose members respect and cherish the lava
tube caves of Hawaii. We recognize that caves and all associated above ground properties
should be protected and conserved for their geological, biological, archaeological, and cultural
significance. Our members are cavers, hikers, scientists, and conservation activists.
BLNR is considering a recommendation by the State Legacy Land Conservation Commission to
award a grant to the Ala Kahakai Trail Association (ATA)for the preservation of Kiolaka`a at
Ka'alu'alu Bay and Manaka`a Fishing Village. An application was submitted to the State Legacy
Land Commission in 2019 and out of twelve applications across the State, these two Ka'u
properties ranked in the top three.
I sent a letter of support to the Legacy Land Conservation Commission for consideration at its
meeting of September 4 - 6, 2019, in which the CCH advocated for the preservation of the
immensely important and significant archeological cave known as Lua Nun O Kamakalepo. At
that time, we attached a detailed archeological report by the eminent archeologist, Prof. William
J. Bonk. written in 1953: He stated the Lua Nunu o Kamakalepo is unique in many ways among
caves of refuge, having two walls, one in each segment of the tube. He found that the cave
dated from 1500 to 1800 AD, based on the fishhooks found. He explains that this period is
correlated with "a cultural period that includes an increased population, the development of a
more elaborate or complex political organization, a formalized pattern of warfare, and in general,
a higher level of sociocultural integration."
In addition to protecting this most important lava tube and refuge cave, we support ATA's vision
of protecting the entire Ka`u coastline. The ATA is a non-profit land conservation organization
and as such meets the LLCP's requirements for being awarded conservation grants. In
addition, the Association has a track record of acquiring and conserving properties of note. The
ATA has received three grant awards from the LLCP's fund, namely:
34.6 acres in N. Kohala in 2012
2,317 acres at Waikapuna in 2017
1,363 acres Kaunamano in 2020.
1
In all cases the conservation easement is (or will be) held by other organizations. We have
every confidence in the ability of the ATA to execute all the required steps and follow through
with the acquisition of Kiolaka'a and to secure matching funding from PONC.
The properties are currently privately owned and are slated for subdivision and sale by the
current owners. This is of great concern to us as the only protection for the Lua Nunu o
Kamakalepo cave is that fact that its location is not generally known, and also that there are no
good roads to it. We understand that the plans of the the owner, Mr. Ernest Moody, to
subdivide Kiolaka'a are well advanced. He has already acquired a road variance and a water
variance and an exemption from a historical survey from the State Historical Preservation Dept.
It seems obvious to us that if the ATA is not able to acquire this land, it will be subdivided into 20
lots, each one about 80 acres in extent. Those lots will be zoned 20A so each one can be
further subdivided into 20-acre lots. Once roads have been built and fences installed, the Lua
Nunu o Kamakalepo will be easily accessible and will, in all likelihood, be looted, vandalized and
essentially destroyed. The loss of this refuge cave will be incalculable.
__ We have read and heard some of the testimony of local Ka'u residents and are moved by their
concerns. We understand that deeply rooted generational families have strong ties to the Aina;
however, that alone will be insufficient to protect these parcels from being subdivided and sold
by the current owners. We understand that ATA intends to collaborate with Ka'u families in the
interests of long term stewardship of lands purchased.
As we see it, the best way to protect both the community's interests and the future of the land
would be to award a grant to the ATA so that it can, with a grant from PONC, purchase the
parcels and give the County a conservation easement. The County of Hawai'i has agreed to
pay for a management plan to be drawn up by a Townscape. If that plan is based on input from'
members of the public, including generational families, then, we feel, the needs of the
community and the public will be equitably balanced.
A preservation purchase would protect these spectacular lands, some of the most remote in
Hawaii. The alternative - subdivision development—would assure this land will never again be
enjoyed by present or future generations but would instead by crisscrossed with roads and
fences and inhabited by hundreds without any connection to the Aina.
In short, as a Ka'u based conservation organization, CCH supports ATA's efforts and we believe
that with a grant from the LLCP, the land will be conserved for posterity and the community's
voices will be heard. It will be a win-win.
Our considered conclusion is that both Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a Fishing Village are too rich in
Hawaiian heritage to remain in private ownership.
Mahalo for allowing me to testify on behalf of the CCH,
., ......
TOMISLAV GRACANIN
PRESIDENT OF THE CAVE CONSERVANCY OF HAWAI'l
April 01, 2020
The Trust for Public Land
c/o Reyna Ramolete Hayashi
1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740
Honolulu, HI 96813
Re: Conservation Purchase of Kiolaka'a, KaO, Hawaii Island
TMKs: (3) 9-4-001:008; (3) 9-4-001:009 ; (3) 9-4-001:017
Aloha Reyna,
I, Walter Andrade, and MU Ranch support Ala Kahakai Trail Association and the Trust
for Public Land's efforts to help our community purchase, protect, and steward the lands
of Kiolaka'a
Our family ranch has sub-licensed a mauka portion of this property, 316 acres, where
we graze about 75 head of cattle, and we have also camped at Ka'alu'ald Bay over the
years. KaTis agricultural lands should be protected to support our local agricultural
economy and self sufficiency.
We look forward to working in partnership with Ala Kahakai Trail Association to ensure
that our cattle ranching license continues and is complimentary to the goal of preserving
the cultural and natural resources on the property_ Protecting these lands would ensure
that KaVs rural character and paniolo traditions are preserved for future generations,
Thank you for your consideration of this request to preserve Kiolaka'a.
Mahal;
Walter D. Andrade
MJ Ranch
PO Box 74
Na'alehu, Hawaii 96722
' .
Roy A Loando
Triple LLL Ranch
pD. Box 674G
Kamuela Hawaii 96743
To whom t may concern,
I, Roy A Loando,support Ala Kahakal Trail purchase of the Kiolakaa parcel. I am a rancher
in Kau and presently lease a parcel in Kau for that purpose. I would like to see as much of the large arid
parcels in Kau preserved and protected and not be developed. If the Association is successful in
receiving the funds to purchase the parcel,it will be the last piece to connect Ka Lae to Honoapu for the
benefit of the people of Kau. I ask the Land Board to please vote in favor of the Ala Kahakai Trail
Association's funding request.
Sincerely,
e?' Ar4'‘-'67
Roy A Loando
January 21, 2021
State of Hawaii
Board of Land and Natural Resources
blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov
Re: Testimony in Support of BLNR Agenda Item C(1)(B) & C(1)(C):
Legacy Land Grant Award to Ala Kahakai Trail Association: $1,475,000, for the
acquisition of approximately 1,841.3 acres at Ka'u, Hawai'i (Kiolaka'a) & $875,000, for
the acquisition of approximately 348 acres at Ka'u, Hawai'i (Manaka'a Fishing Village)
Aloha Chair Case and BLNR Members,
I would like to express my enthusiastic support for the Legacy Land Grant Award to Ala Kahakai
Trail Association to purchase and protect Kiolaka'a & Manaka'a Fishing Village.
The protection of these lands is in our community's interest because it is one of the last
remaining pieces in securing the undeveloped coastline that is so highly valued by our
community, as expressed in-theKa`u Community Development Plan (CPD). I was a member of
the Ka`u CPD Steering Committee and protecting Kiolaka'a & Manaka'a advances the vision
and goals our community articulated:
"The Kai) CDP should honor Ka`u's unique rural lifestyle, its connection between people
and place, and its distinctive Hawaiian cultural heritage. It must plan for the future in
ways that: increase economic opportunities through a diverse, resilient, and sustainable
economy; and protect and provide reasonable access to natural and recreational
resources including the mauka forests, the coastline, open spaces, and park facilities
and programs."
"Objective 2: Preserve prime and other viable agricultural lands and preserve and
enhance viewscapes that exemplify Ka`u's rural character."
"Objective 10: Encourage and enhance agriculture, ranching, and related economic
infrastructure."
Keeping these lands in agriculture will support the rural economy in Ka'u and provide the land
base for agricultural production that supports the County and State of Hawaii. My family owns
and operates Kuahiwi Ranch and we currently graze approximately 200 head of beef cattle on
the Manaka'a parcel. We have been ranching on this parcel for the last five years and its
protection would allow our lease to continue.
Kuahiwi Ranch specializes in local, free-range, grass-fed beef which contributes to our local
food security and self-sufficiency, which have become so critically important during this health
crisis. We market about 450,000 lbs of meat annually to grocery stores and restaurants
throughout Hawaii including: Whole Foods, Foodland, and Foodland Farms,Alan Wong's, Town,
and Honolulu Burger Co. We also provide secure jobs to eleven employees and our work also
supports other food system jobs that enables our beef to get from ranch to table.
We strongly believe in the agricultural, open space, and cultural value of these lands. We are
committed to working together as close partners with the Ala Kahakai Trail Association and the •
broader community so that our ranching operations can co-exist and compliment the
preservation of both the cultural and natural resources on the property. Kiolaka'a & Manaka'a,
as part of the Ka'u coastline, should be preserved for the people of the State and County of
Hawaii. The pristine Ka'u coastline is a treasure that we can steward and a gift that we can
pass on to future generations.
Mahalo,
M%che(I.e 4al,i,wi.ba
Michelle Galimba, VP
Kuahiwi Ranch
PO Box 24
Na'alehu HI 96772
(808)430-4927
PHONE(808)594-1888 FAX(808)594-1938
fy V"k
*.1},)
STATE OF HAWAII
OFFICE OF HAWAIIAN AFFAIRS
560 N. NIMITZ HWY.,SUITE 200
HONOLULU, HAWAII 96817
HRD19-8931
June 17, 2019
Reyna Ram olete Hayashi
Aloha 'Aina Project Manager
The Trust for Public Land
1003 Bishop Street
Panahi Tower, Suite 740
Honolulu, Hawai`i 96813
Re: Letter of Support for the Acquisition and Protection of Kaunamano and Maniika`a Fishing
Village of the Ka`ti Coast
Kaunamano Ahupua'a, Ka'a Mokn, Hawai'i Mokupuni
Tax Map Keys: (3) 9-5-012:001; and, 9-5-011:001, 004, 005. 006
Aloha e Ms. Hayashi:
The Administration of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs (01-IA) is writing in support of the
Trust for Public Land's (TPL) efforts to acquire agricultural and conservation lands along the Kati
coast for the purposes of preservation and restoration. OHA understands that TPL is currently seeking
funding for these acquisitions from the County of Hawaii. Public Access, Open Space and Natural
Resources (PONC) Fund, the State of Hawaii Legacy Land Conservation Fund, and the Land and
Water Conservation Fund. Thus, TPL will meet with the PONC Commission on July 8, as well as
submit an application to the Legacy Land Conservation fund in July. OHA further understands that
TPL is closely partnered with the Ala Kahakai Trail Association (ATA)) who will primarily
implement long-term stewardship of the area if acquisition is successful. OHA has previously
provided support for similar TP1_, acquisitions in other areas along the Ka'ti coast. The current
proposed acquisitions are aligned with a greater Ka'rt community effort to protect the entire 80 mile
Ka'a coast.
OHA is the constitutionally recognized body responsible for protecting and promoting the
rights of Native Hawaiians. As such, OHA's mission is to improve the well-being of Native
Hawaiians by focusing our efforts on six strategic priorities: ãina (land and water), mo'omeheu
(culture), ho okahuawaiwai (economic self-sufficiency), ho`ona'auao (education), ea (governance),
and mauli ola (health). By maintaining a connection to the past through the preservation of %Ma, it
is OHA's hope that Native Hawaiians will participate in and benefit from responsible_ lina
Ala Kahakai Trail Association (ATA) is a descendant led non-profit organization that provides community assistance
for trail management and planning. The ATA helps ensure that the Ala Kahakai Trail is well-connected to the community
and that Hawaiian values and principles are in place and practiced.
Reyna Ramolete Hayashi.
June 17, 2019
Page 2
stewardship. Previously, OHA has supported many efforts throughout the state that promote.the
preservation of agricultural and conservation lands threatened by rezoning and unnecessary
development. OHA values the protection of such prime lands as a potential vehicle for food self-
sufficiency and a means for reconnecting people with the 'aina through responsible stewardship.
The lands of Kaundmano and Mandka'a contain innumerable cultural resources important to
the preservation and perpetuation of Hawaiian culture. This area of the Ka45 coast contains many
still-intact fishing villages, historic trails, pristine cultural sites, natural. springs, burial sites,
petroglyphs, lava tubes, and caves that together maintain a strong cultural landscape. • Native
Hawaiians today continue to use this area for traditional cultural practices and educational purposes.
Mo`olelo of this area describe, thriving fishing villages and the practice of lua (traditional Hawaiian
martial art). Additionally, it is believed that the caves and underground lava tubes served as strategic
spots to defend the area and conceal armies in times of war.
The Kali coast is also home to a variety of endangered Hawaiian flora and fauna. 80% to
90% of the honteea (hawksbill sea turtle) nest along the Ka'ti coast. The honu (green sea turtles),
Ilioholoikauaua (Hawaiian monk seals), and.kohold (humpback whales) depend on the clean waters
off Kaundmano. Native coastal plants blanket the shoreline, while pueo (Hawaiian short-eared owl),
migratory birds, and native sea and shorebirds live along Kaundmano's rocky shorelines .
OHA understands and. supports TPL's and ATA's efforts to protect the natural and cultural
resources of Keil for present and future generations. As both TPL and ATA aim to protect existing
cultural resources and seek to reconnect people to the Iiina through responsible stewardship. OHA
views their overall efforts as being in concert with our own mission and strategic plan. OHA notes
that the preservation of the parcels in question are further aligned with the October 2017 Ka.''[i
Community Development Plan which seeks to protect and enhance natural resources. 'FPL's and
ATA's efforts to acquire these lands would effectively eliminate potential undesired development of
the Keit coast and help the Ka`ii community achieve their dream of one clay protecting all of the.Ka'ti
coast.
Accordingly, OHA supports TPL's and ATA's efforts to acquire these lands and thereby
enable our beneficiaries and the, Ka'ti community to preserve, practice, and perpetuate Native
Hawaiian culture; malama Kele s resources and sites; and, contribute to the future security and self-
sufficiency of our islands. Should you have any questions, please contact OHA's Lead Compliance
Specialist, Kamakana C. Ferreira, at (808) 594-0227, or by email at kamakanaf@oha.org.
'0 wau iho no me ka `oia
Kamana`opono M. Crabbe, Ph.D.
Ka Pouhana, Chief Executive Officer
KC:kf
•
PHONE(808)594-1888 FAX(808)594-1938
OW,,/
STATE OF HAWAII
OFFICE OF HAWAIIAN AFFAIRS
560 N.NIMITZ HWY.,SUITE 200
HONOLULU, HAWAII 96817
HRD19-893IB
June 27, 2019
Reyna Ramolete Hayashi
Aloha 'Aina Project Manager
The Trust for Public Land
1003 Bishop Street
Paualii Tower, Suite 740
Honolulu, Hawaii 96813
Re: Addendum to Letter of Support for the Acquisition and Protection of Kaanamano and
Marffika`a Fishing Village of the Keil Coast
Kaunamano Ahupua'a, Moku, Hawai`i Mokupuni
Tax Map Keys: (3)9-5-012:001; 9-5-011:001, 004,005, 006; and, 9-4-001: 008, 009, 017
Aloha e Ms. Hayashi:
The Administration of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs (OHA) offers this addendum to its letter
of June 17, 2019 in support of the Trust for Public Land's (TPL) efforts to acquire agricultural and
conservation lands along the Keil coast for the purposes of preservation and restoration. This
addendum is to clarify the applicability of the June 17 letter of support. to include the contemplated
acquisition of lands in Kialaka'a, as part of the storied cultural landscape of Keil: described in the
previous letter, and whose protection from development and undesirable land uses would enable
present and future generations of our beneficiaries to preserve, practice, and perpetuate Native
Hawaiian culture; malama Ka`ii's resources and sites; and, contribute to the future security and self-
sufficiency of our islands.
Should you have any questions, please contact our Lead Compliance Specialist, Kamakana C.
Ferreira, at(808)594-0227, or by email at kamakanaf@oha.org.
'0 wau ill()r5 me ka `oia
C. 4a—t-ert.
Kamana`opono I Crabber Ph.D.
Ka Pouhana, Chief Executive Officer
KC:kf
•
\k$417r
•
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
STATE OF HAWAII
STATE CAPITOL
HONOLULU, HAWAII 96813
October 14. 2019
MEMORANDUM
To: Speaker of the House Scott K. Saiki
From: Representative Richard P. Creagan.
Chair, House Committee on Agricultu e •
RE: Letter in Support of Legacy Land Conservation Funding to Protect and Acquire
Kaunamano, Kiolaka'a, and Manaka'a in Ka'a. Hawai'i
I am writing to express my strong support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for
Public Land's efforts to purchase and protect Kaunamano. Kiolaka'a, and Manaka'a in Ka'a.
Hawaii Island. Ala Kahakai Trail Association's mission is to support and guide a community-
managed trail that honors those who came before and perpetuates for those to follow— with
protocols and respect for Hawaii's past, present and future.
Kaunamano's ancient fishing village of Pa'ula includes the famous rock paved anchialine pool of
Puhi'ula cave. The property includes over four miles of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail
and 444 archaeological sites including heiau, refuge caves and lava tubes with petroglyphs and
pictographs, a lua training area, house sites, and burials. Kaun.amano provides extensive coastal
habitat for native plants, seabirds and marine life including humpback whales and hawksbill and
green sea turtles. The lush mauka pasture lands are leased by Kuahiwi Ranch,for raising local,
grass fed beef, supporting the local, agricultural economy.
Kiolaka'a is a 1,836-acre property south of Waiohinu Town that includes intact native dryland
forest, the eastern shoreline of Ka'altealu Bay, and portions of the ancient Kamakalepo
settlement and Lua Nunu cave system. The cave system features a fortress with an elevated
defensive wall, built during the wars with Katnehameha. Other cultural sites.include heiau,
habitation sites, petroglyphs, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail.
Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond teems with 'opae. 'ula. The mauka lands arc
leased for cattle grazing, perpetuating Ka'il's paniolo traditions.
Manaka'a's breathtaking Maniania Pali rises over 200 feet providing protection for nesting sea
birds and native coastal plants. Cultural resources include 22 documented sites such as heiau,
burials, lava tube habitation sites, underground springs, over one mile of the Ala Kahakai
District 5—Na'alehu,Ocean View,Captain Cook,Kealakekua,Kailua-Kona(Island of Hawaii)
Chair of Agriculture
State Capitol Building, Room 427,Honolulu,Hawaii 96813
Phone(808)586-9605, Email:rapereaganecaktol.hawaiLgov
National Historic Trail. two mauka-makai trails, and the remains of Manaka'a Fishing Village.
These lands provide some of the best cattle grazing lands in Ka0. leased by Kuahiwi Ranch.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Kali community's long standing goal of protecting their
beloved 80 mile coast to perpetuate their rural lifestyle and,Hawaiian culture. Access to the
coastline is important for their community which still relies on subsistence fishing, farming, and
gathering. Conserving this landscape will perpetuate cultural access for descendants and
recreational access for travelers along the ancient trail allowing all to walk in the footsteps of
Ka'a's ancestors.
I wholeheartedly support the Legacy Land Conservation Commission's recommendations to
provide land acquisition funding for the conservation of Kaunamano, Kiola.ka`a, and Manaka'a.
yv
4,11LO
./0
•
District 5 Na'alehu,Ocean View,Captain Cook, Kealakekua,Kailua-Kona(Island of Hawaii)
Chair of Agriculture
State Capitol Building,Room 427,Honolulu, Hawaii 96813
Phone(808)586-9605, Email:reperea_on(a„capitol hawak.gov
1
April 22, 2021
State of Hawai`i
Board of Land and Natural Resources
binr.testimony_@hawaii. roovv
Re: SUPPORT for Agenda Item C2(B): ALA KAHAKAI TRAIL ASSOCIATION, $1,475,000, FOR THE
ACQUISITION OF APPROXIMATELY 1,841.3 ACRES AT KA'U, HAWAII (KIOLAKA'A), TAX MAP
KEY NUMBERS: (3) 9-4-01:008:009, :016, :017,AND :023
Aloha Chair Case and Members of the Board,
My name is 'Aina Akamu and I was born and raised in Ka'u. My mo'oku'auhau traces back to
Kekuhaupi'o and Pine, and my 'ohana has lived in Ka'u for 67 generations. My dad was a truck driver and
electrician for Ka'u Sugar, an alumni of Na'alehu Elementary and Ka'u High School. My mom is pure Hawaiian
from Kapa'au,North Kohala, born to parents who met, married and lived at the Hansen's Disease settlement at
Kalaupapa; and worked at the Punalu'u Black Sands Restaurant and Pick and Pay at Na'alehu Shopping Center.
I was primarily raised by my paternal grandmother, Mae Kalilinoeokalani Macomber Kapika Akamu, who
spoke to me in Hawaiian, was part of the first group of Hawaiian Studies kupuna teaching in the Ka'u schools in
1978, and passed on to me many Hawaiian traditions such as la'au lapa'au, mea kanu, mea kaua, kapa,
waiho'olu'u, hula, mele, lei making and other hana no'eau and sacred kuleana that I continue in my `ohana until
today.
After attending Na'alehu Elementary school through grade 6, I attended boarding school and graduated
from Kamehameha-Kapalama with an Honors Diploma, graduated Cum Laude with a B.A. in Linguistics and
Theater from Dartmouth College with a focus on Hawaiian Grammar and Dialectology, a M.A. in Teaching
from the University of Southern California with an emphasis on bilingual and social studies education, and a
Teaching Certificate from the University of Hawai'i in Career &Technical Education with a specialization in
Industrial Engineering Technology, Building & Construction, and Design and Drafting.
I currently teach Engineering, Construction, Culinary Arts,Agriculture, and Entrepreneurship, and I am
the new Ag Program Director at Ka'u High School. I am also a faculty member in the Hawaiian Studies
Department at Hawai'i Community College in Hilo, where I Hawaiian Studies classes through the Early College
program for Ka'u High School students. I also chair the Education Committee and serve as Kakau'Olelo
(secretary &webmaster) for the Hawaiian Civic Club of Ka'u, am a member of Kauaha'ao Congregational
Church which was built by my kupuna and where they rest today, and a community volunteer and land steward
doing what I can to ensure the conservation and protection of our natural, cultural, and historical resources for
the next 67 generations of my `ohana - in the same way my `ohana has preserved Ka'u for me.
It is very uncomfortable for me to share all of this with you because I was raised to pa'a ka waha (shut
the mouth), nand ka maka(watch with the eyes),ho'olohe ka pepeiao (listen with the ears) and then hana ka
lima(work the hands) because ma ka hana ka `ike (in the doing is the knowledge). I am not one to talk or write
a lot, or get involved loudly with various community issues, but you can rest assured that at 5am when it is time
to E 'ala e, I will be there, with my gloves and boots, ready to work. I am someone who is more comfortable
being quiet and unnoticed, but always there for others to listen with an open heart, to observe with a sense of
makawalu (eight eyes), and then to do what I can to help.
2
I feel compelled to share this with you today because the issue of Kiolaka'a (and Waikapuna)has really
taken a toll on members of our community. There has been a loss of trust, communication, and it feels like so
many are fighting against each other although we all want the same thing -to preserve our precious wahi pana
of Ka'u. I honestly do not know what to do sometimes, because it feels like supporting the Ala Kahakai Trail
Association means taking sides against my own family and members of my community. I honestly just want
the land to be left alone, to be saved from any future development, and to be protected from the harm that
humans do intentionally or not.
As a lineal and ancestral descendant of Kahula Kekuhaupi'o, who received from Kauikeaouli the Royal
Patent for the kuleana of 349 acres of Palauhulu, who passed on that kuleana title to Kahula Macomber, who
passed that kuleana title on to Mae Macomber Akamu, who passed that kuleana title on to me, I stand with them
today and every day. Of the hundreds of great-great-great grandchildren in my `ohana, I am the one who holds
the palapala that Kahula once held, and was directly given the sacred kauoha and kuleana of protecting the iwi
kupuna of my `ohana. I live on my ancestral lands in Ka'u - and I look out over the Kiolaka'a property every
day. My kuleana lands extend down to Ka'alu'alu road and borders the Kiolaka'a property. The current
"landowner" of a portion of my own kuleana lands is preparing for future development, which is another fight I
am preparing for in a spiritual manner. In my own `ohana, I know that my ancestors support any efforts to save
these lands from any development.
As a member of the Hawaiian Civic Club of Ka'u, I have done my best to bring forward any information
to our club members and have shared all the relevant information on our website. Our club is currently 52 years
old, we have monthly meetings, and our membership is open to all. We are a transparent Hawaiian
community-based organization that has endured for many years and, through the pandemic, has managed the
transition to Zoom meetings for our club. There are members of our club who oppose acquisition of Kiolaka'a
by ATA, but still want these lands saved. We also have members who support ATA's acquisition, and are
willing to work with ATA and serve on their Stewardship committees, attend their meetings, and be a conduit of
information to our community. It is challenging to stay neutral, but in the end, for me, it is not about a person or
a group, but about saving these lands from future development.
Personally, I came to support ATA's acquisition when I asked if they would return these lands to the
Hawaiian Kingdom once it was reestablished and the military occupation of Hawai'i ends. I was assured that if
any Ka'u non-profit could take over, they would gladly transfer the deed to another group's care.Additionally, if
the Hawaiian Kingdom was returned prior to that happening, the lands would be returned to the Hawaiian
Kingdom and the Ka'u representatives or konohiki would then take on that responsibility. To me, this gives me
enough trust that I have worked with ATA, have attended their meetings, and as of yet, do not have any
concerns about ATA developing the lands, or restricting any traditional and cultural uses of these lands.
I know there are still concerns. I will continue to do what I canto help bring information to my
community, and to uphold the kuleana given to me by my kupunahine. I was raised to know that it is not my
place to claim my rights t6 something, but rather that I have responsibility to uphold and to ensure that the
rights of the lands are held in highest esteem.
He ali`i ka `aina, he kauwa ke kanaka.
Aloha, a koe no na pua.
'Aina Akamu
William Keoni Fox
From: Fred Meinecke <fineineck@hawaii.edu>
Sent: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 1:05 AM
To: fox@alakahakaitrail.org; reyna.ramolete@tpl.org; laakeal @hawaiiantel.net; Emma
Keohokalole; Samuel Plunkett Jr; Lani Lapilio; Fred Meinecke; Brian Richardson
Subject: MALAMA Kiolaka'a me Waikapuna a me ke Ala Kahakai ma Ka'u
Follow Up Flag: Follow up
Flag Status: Flagged
Ae, ho'i! Aloha mai kakou pakahi a pau!
Eia neia, 'o wau 'o Fred Kalani Meinecke a no Wai`ohinu mai makou.
A no ka pono o kenei papahana, e kakau aku ana au i na 'olelo 'elua, 'o
ka mua no ka pono o na kupuna o kakou, a no ka lua no ka maopopo
is lakou o ka 'Melo ho'okahi wale!
This rendering is from Fred Kalani Meinecke and we are from Wai'ohinu.
And for the propriety of this testimony, I will convey bilingually; first for our
kupuna who cannot be here, and secondly for those confined to a single
language!
'0 ko`u 'i'ini no e kakau iho nei 'o is no e kako`o i ka 'oukou hana nui,
lokihi a pa`upa`u i mea e malama i ka `aina o na kupuna o kakou. He mahalo
nui is 'oukou no ka 'oukou ho`omanawanui i keia hana ko'iko`i! Maopopo
loa no ho'i ia'u! No ka mea aia wau ma Kona me Herb Kawainui Kane ma
i na makahiki 1975-79 e ho'a'o nui e ho'opakele is "Ka Lae o ka Moa"
ma Holualoa Kai mai ke kukulu hokele hou me hale hou! A i ka hopena,
ua pomaika'i i ka ke Kia'aina Ariyoshi i ku`ai mai i kela 'apana no ka
Moku`aina `o Hawai'i e malama ail No laila, hiki wale no ka hopena
lanakila i ka hakaka e malama `aina!
My intent in writing this is to convey support of your long, difficult and
exhausting task of protecting our ancestral lands! I very much know what
it's like and what it takes! For I was there in Kona with good friend Herb
Kawainui Kane and others in the mid-70's to struggle to save the sacred
religious complex, "Ka Lae o ka Moa," The Headland of the Warriors,"
from replacement by a Holiday Inn and housing development! And in the end,
it was fortunate that then Governor Ariyoshi agreed to purchase the 15-acre site
for the State to protect! So victorious outcomes can happen in land contention!
A ua poina wale ia`u e hag mai i ke 'ano kukaulani o Ka Lae o ka Moa no ka mea
ua ho`ike 'ia mai `o Keolonahihi, ke kaikamahine a ke Kahuna Nui Paoa (= Pa'ao),
1
me kana kane na mea kuhikuhi i kela kahua heiau i ke kenekulia 'umikumaha!
And I've overlooked mentioning that the very sacredness of the religious
site complex (five heiau, court of law, virgin ali'i women's sanctity, warriors'
training ground, sacred cadaver preparation site (incl. the imu for Kamehameha's
body to be defleshed) dates back to the founding in the 14th century by one
Keolonahihi, daughter of the High Priest, Paoa ( a.k.a. Pa-1°a) and her husband.
No Ka'u, he po'okela kona 'ano kahiko loa a kapu loa no na hanauna ali'i
me na hanauna kahuna. A he nui loa no na mea kuhohonu, mala, palapala 'ole,
a 'ike 'ole ano! '0 is kahi kumu he pa'akiki ke ho'ike laula ano ke lilo loa na kupuna!
He aha e hana aku ai? -
In regard to Ka'u, its antiquity and sanctity is foremost because of generations
of paramount rulers and high priests. And yet much is deeply hidden, secretive,
undocumented and not known today. It's one of the reasons it's difficult to
widely inform today when so many (all?) of the kupuna are gone forever!
What are we to do?
-- Fred Kalani Meinecke
fmeineck@hawaii.edu
(808) 371-4233
2
February 28, 2021
Kalaho`ohie Mossman
P.O. Box 43
Na'alehu, Hi 96772
Reyna Ramolete Hayashi
The Trust for Public Land
1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740
Honolulu,.Hawaii 96813
Re: Support for Ala Kahakai Trail Association and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to
Purchase and Protect Manaka`a in Kawala Ka`u and lands in Kiolaka`a, Ka`u.
Aloha,
Aloha, my name is Kalaho`ohie Mosman and I am a resident of Wai`ohinu,Kali. I support The
Trust for Public Land and ATA`s efforts to protect and purchase the Manaka`a and Kiolaka'a
properties in Ka`u, Hawai`i. Protecting these lands would provide impactful community
benefits: preserving beloved cultural and historic resources and an outdoor classroom for
students to learn about the area and the Hawaiian traditions.
I had expressed concern at the last meeting considering this purchase because I felt there was not
sufficient community engagement. Since that time ATA and the Trust for Public Lands have
reached out and have held a community zoom meeting as well as spoke to individuals in our
community directly. I am satisfied with this effort and feel that the community will be a part of
the ongoing management of these lands in the future.
If these properties were to be sold to a private buyer it would mean the loss of significant cultural
resources along the coastline. It could also have serious impacts on our coastal and marine
resources. A resource that our community depends on to survive.
I invision this area being protected restored, and stewarded by the community for `aina-based
education, Hawaiian cultural practices and creating a space where one can establish a connection
to the environment.
Mahalo,
Kalaho`ohie Mossman
Ka`u Resident
P.O. Box 43
Na'alehu, Hi 96772
September 4, 2019
The Trust for Public Land
c/o Reyna Ramolete Hayashi
1003 Bishop St., Suite 740
Honolulu, HI 96813
Re: Letter in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's Efforts
to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a, TMKs: (3) 9-4-001:008; (3) 9-4-001:009;
(3) 9-4-001:017.
Jodie Rosam and family are in support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's efforts to purchase
and protect Kiolaka`a in Ka`u, Hawai`i Island. Ala Kahakai Trail Association's mission is to
support and guide a community-managed trail that honors those who came before and
perpetuates for those to follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai`i's past, present and
future.
Kiolaka`a is a 1,836-acre property south of Waiohinu Town that includes intact native dryland
forest, the eastern shoreline of Ka`alu`alu Bay, and portions of the ancient Kamakalepo
settlement and Lua Nunu cave system. The cave system features a fortress with an elevated
defensive wall and 102 sleeping platforms, built during the wars with Kamehameha. Other
cultural sites include heiau,habitation sites, petroglyphs, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai
National Historic Trail. A network of trails lead to Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine
pond teeming with two varieties of`opae 'lila. The mauka pasture lands are leased for cattle
grazing,perpetuating Ka`u's paniolo traditions.
Our family owns nearly 50 acres in Kiolaka'a,just mauka of the property to which this letter is
directed. We also own several parcels in the Green Sands subdivision, also in Kiolaka'a. Our
family has been here for over 30 years, and we care deeply for these lands. As a restoration
ecologist, conservationist, and teacher, I see the uniqueness of this land. Not only does it contain
rare plant species, but it contains history. From battleground cave systems to ancient agricultural
sites to veins of rare plants, this place is rich with significance.
As a mother of two young children, and an active member in our community and our keiki, I see
the potential of this land for our future. Our family has a vision to restore old agricultural
systems on our property and bring students from local schools to educate them on ancient
agricultural techniques. We also plan to collect seeds from rare species and give seedlings to our
community to restore these unique plant species. If this property were to become developed, a
major source of dryland forest seeds would be lost. It is without question that ancient agricultural
sites, burial sites, and cave systems would be destroyed as well. This land is special. It is sacred.
And we fully support protection of Kiolaka'a.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka`u community's long standing goal of protecting our
beloved 80 mile coast to perpetuate our rural lifestyle and Hawaiian culture. Access to the
coastline is important for our community which still relies on subsistence fishing, farming, and
gathering. Conserving this landscape will perpetuate cultural access for descendants and
recreational access for travelers alongthe ancient trail allowingall to walk in the footsteps of
p
Ka`u's ancestors.
Mahalo,
Jodie Rosam
Rosas, Ambrose, and Rosam Ohana
jodie.rosam@gmail.com
808-987-8681
February 16, 2021
State of Hawai`i
Board of Land and Natural Resources
binr.testimony@hawaii.gov
The Trust for Public Land
reyna.ramolete@tpl.org
Ala Kahakai Trail Association
fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Re: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's
Efforts to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village in Ka`u, Hawai`i
Our family strongly supports Ala Kahakai Trail Association and The Trust for Public Land's
efforts to help the Ka`u community purchase and forever protect Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a
Fishing Village (the makai lands of Kawala). Ala Kahakai Trail Association's mission is to
support and guide a community-managed trail that honors those who came before and
perpetuates for those to follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai`i's past, present and
future. ATA has a Ka`u Stewardship Committee which is comprised entirely of Kau residents to
guide the stewardship and management of its Ka`u lands. If ATA is successful in protecting
these properties, it has committed to developing a Community Management Plan in partnership
with Ka`u community groups, descendants, and stakeholders within 18 months of taking
ownership. ATA is committed to community-based management of these lands and their natural
and cultural resources.
Kiolaka`a is makai of Waiohinu Town and includes intact native dryland forest, the eastern
shoreline of Ka`alu`alu Bay, portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave
system, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. A network of trails lead to
Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond teeming with 'Opae 'ula. The mauka pasture
lands are leased for cattle grazing,perpetuating Ka`u's paniolo traditions.
Manaka`a Fishing Village stands on the sea cliffs overlooking Waikapuna Bay, along with 22
precious cultural sites including heiau, burial caves, lava tube habitation sites,water collection
caves with underground springs, and ancient habitation complexes. Over one mile of the Ala
Kahakai National Historic Trail runs through the property and two ancient mauka-makai trails
connect Na`alehu with the coastline.
Our family has lived near the boundary of Ka`u and Puna for almost 20 years and we have
committed our lives to protecting and restoring natural resources particularly in Ka`u, mainly as
employees working directly for the National Park Service or otherwise within Hawai`i
Volcanoes National Park. Through our work,we have assisted The Nature Conservancy and
various local groups in the district as well. Outside of work, we have surfed, played, fished, and
contributed to malama `aina efforts in the area for nearly two decades. We have been fortunate to
have camped along the coast, learned about cultural features at the nearby site Puhi`ula and
celebrated weddings of friends and family at Kiolaka`a and Honu'apo. Many of our `ohana have
these ahupua'a whether through ancestral lineage or current land ownership.
important ties top g
We have seen how development can change the shape of the land and the connection to place.
Protecting the Ka`u coastline is important to us, to our family and friends who call it home, and
to our children's future. For the past few years,we have participated in a stewardship training
called Halau `Ohi`a, and we have learned from training and from huaka`i about just a few of the
numerous natural and cultural treasures held within Ka`u. Our family's mission is to raise our
keiki to have a deep relationship with the places and people of where they live-not just their
house and their neighborhood, but to know their moku, to enjoy and appreciate the coast, plants,
and stories of place, old and new. Safeguarding and caring for the Ka`u coastline allows
everyone-including visitors, but especially the families who call Ka`u and Hawai`i Island home -
the potential for deepening relationships to place, maintaining a critical perspective of seeing
themselves in the landscape, and perpetuating a strong sense of aloha for this island and her
sources.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka`u community's long standing goal of protecting our
beloved 80 mile coast to perpetuate our rural lifestyle and Hawaiian culture. Access to the
coastline is important for our community which still relies on subsistence fishing and gathering.
Conserving this landscape will enable community based management of Ka`u's lands and
resources, and perpetuate cultural and subsistence access to the coast for descendants,
community members, and the public, allowing all to walk in the footsteps of Ka`u's ancestors.
Mahalo,
Corie Yanger& Andrew Christie
808-430-0913/808-430-9363 and cmyanger@hawaii.edu/a_duncan_c@hotmail.com
February 10, 2021
State of Hawai`i
Board of Land and Natural Resources
blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov
The Trust for Public Land
reyna.ramolete@tpl.org
Ala Kahakai Trail Association
fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Re: . Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's
Efforts to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village in Ka'u, Hawai'i
My name is Patrick Conant and I am familiar with the areas in which Kiloka'a and Manaka'a
fishing villages occur. For at least a few years I have been assisting with volunteer native strand
vegetation restoration efforts with the Hawaii Wildlife Fund under a permit from DOFAW. I
believe that the area from Ka'alu'alu to about Ki'i might be the most intact native strand
vegetation in the State and it deserves better protection. We have been pulling up fountain
grass, sandbur and other weeds along the Waiohinu coast,between those two sites for several
years now. We are attempting to contain those 2 grasses, along with other weeds so the area does
not burn, nor would native plants be outcompeted.
Also, I am a former State of Hawaii Entomologist and I recall that Entomologist Dr. Karl
Magnacca has found Hylaeussp. native bees in the area, and those should be studied more
thoroughly there so protection can be implemented as necessary.
I cannot speak to the cultural aspects of these two fishing villages, but I do know the area is rich
in what appear to be ancient trails throughout the pahoehoe and even a'a lava flats. Petroglyphs
seem relatively common and there are many of what must be temporary inclimate weather
shelters under rock overhangs.
In closing, I very much support the effort of The Trust for Public Lands and Ala Kahakai Trail
Association assisting the Ka'u Community acquire and protect these two ancient fishing villages
and the surrounding cultural landscape and native plant communities. Both could be easily
damaged without some form of protection, and to some extent, the plants already are. Neglect
alone is damaging. But, I am optimistic this effort will succeed, with the terrestrial plant and
cultural sitesand the shoreline best protected by access continuing to be limited to the existing
trails rather than building roads.
Patrick Conant,
Volcano, HI
From: gary johnson <gpjohns on2951@gmail.com>
Date: Sun, Mar 21, 2021 at 9:58 PM
Subject: Re: Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Preservation Update
To: Jodie Rosam<jodie.rosam@gmail.com>
To the BLNR,
This testimony is in regard to the acquisition of Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a lands by the Ala
Kahakai Trail Association.
I am a resident of Naalehu and I have supported a number of acquisitions of land for the
preservation of the Ka'u coastline.
In particular, I volunteer regularly at Kawa Bay, which is part of the County's holdings in Ka'u
(acquired about five years ago.)
What I experience in the course of a day at Kawa Bay, represents the potential that Kiolaka'a and
Manaka'a have to preserve the history, the ecology, and the spirit of shared community(aina) in
Ka'u.
I work with Dwayne Pua and two other Hawaiians who have dedicated themselves to conserving
and maintaining the land that for them has ancestral ties. I have helped to reintroduce native
species. I have cleared the site of an ancient hale (as have Hawaiian families at a number of other
sites.) I have worked to eliminate invasive species and opened up glades for larger species, such
as acacia and Java plum. I have seen Dwayne rebuild the stonework channels for the freshwater
springs that once supported Hawaiian villages, and more recently he and his crew are developing
plots for traditional foods.
He is also working with the County, conservation groups and NOAA to create a long-term plan
for the lagoons, tide pools and fish ponds.
Most importantly, his efforts have made Kawa Bay accessible in a way that has preserved its
native flora, its history and its spirit.
This is the bay where all the locals learned to surf and it still draws surfers almost every day.
Families come to the bay to fish and camp. My wife and I have hiked sections of the King's Trail
that runs north along the coastline(it is being reestablished by local groups.)
Why does this matter? It matters because Ka'u is unique. Large corporations have tried on
numerous occasions to "develop" sections of the coastline, and each time have failed. But the
people of this community(Hawaiians, Asians and haoles)have remained. Together they respect
the land, and they work to insure that the land and the waters will continue to enrich the lives of
all who live here.
Lastly, in preserving coastlines like Kawa Bay, Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a, Ka'u is linking
together a number of already conserved lands,not just a token site. Where else is it possible to
conserve large ecological areas and critical ocean habitat, within the boundaries of an engaged
and committed community? Where else is it possible to conserve land that represents generations
of people who respect and value that heritage?
Thank you for the opportunity to speak of the necessity to keep these lands in the public domain.
Sincerely,
Gary and Deborah Johnson
P.O. Box 777
94-6557 Lewa Lani St.
Naalehu, HI
96772
William Keoni Fox
From: selah levine <selahbit@gmail.com>
Sent: Saturday, February 13, 2021 9:34 AM
To: blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov; Reyna.Ramolete@tpl.org;fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Subject: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's
Efforts to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a Fishing Village in Ka'u, Hawaii
Follow Up Flag: Follow up
Flag Status: Flagged
My name is Selah Levine and I support Ala Kahakai Trail Association and The Trust for Public Land's efforts to help the
Ka'u community purchase and forever protect Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a Fishing Village (the makai lands of Kawala). Ala
Kahakai Trail Association's mission is to support and guide a community-managed trail that honors those who came
before and perpetuates for those to follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai'i's past, present and future.ATA has a
Ka'u Stewardship Committee which is comprised entirely of Ka'u residents to guide the stewardship and management of
its Kati] lands. If ATA is successful in protecting these properties, it has committed to developing a Community
Management Plan in partnership with Ka'u community groups, descendants, and stakeholders within 18 months of
taking ownership. ATA is committed to community-based management of these lands and their natural and cultural
resources.
Kiolaka'a is makai of Waiohinu Town and includes intact native dryland forest,the eastern shoreline of Ka'alu'alu Bay,
portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave system, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National
Historic Trail. A network of trails lead to Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond teeming with 'opae 'ula.
The mauka pasture lands are leased for cattle grazing, perpetuating Ka'u's paniolo traditions.
Manaka'a Fishing Village stands on the sea cliffs overlooking Waikapuna Bay, along with 22 precious cultural sites
including heiau, burial caves, lava tube habitation sites, water collection caves with underground springs, and ancient
habitation complexes. Over one mile of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail runs through the property and two
ancient mauka-makai trails connect Na'alehu with the coastline.
My family and neighbors enjoy this area for subsistence fishing. After the lava took the Pohoiki boat ramp we have no
way to safely enter the ocean for fishing in Puna and now go to the this area of coastline to fish. I am sure that we are
not the only family in Puna that frequent this area and due to increased pressure on this coastline it is even more
important to protect it.
Without the protection this fragile coastline it will not sustain the needs of families who benefit from the natural and
cultural resources of this land now, and for future generations.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Kali community's long standing goal of protecting our beloved 80 mile coast to
perpetuate our rural lifestyle and Hawaiian culture. Access to the coastline is important for our community which still
relies on subsistence fishing and gathering. Conserving this landscape will enable community based management of
Ka'u's lands and resources, and perpetuate cultural and subsistence access to the coast for descendants, community
members, and the public, allowing all to walk in the footsteps of Ka'u's ancestors.
Mahalo,
Selah Levine
808-769-1173, selahbit@gmail.com
1
February 5, 2021
State of Hawaii
Board of Land and Natural Resources
blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov
The Trust for Public Land
reyna.ramolete@tpl.org
Ala Kahakai Trail Association
fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Re: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's
Efforts to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village in Ka'u, Hawaii
I, Cherie Felzer strongly support Ala Kahakai Trail Association and The Trust for Public Land's
efforts to help the Ka`u community purchase and forever protect Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a
Fishing Village (the makai lands of Kawala). Ala Kahakai Trail Association's mission is to
support and guide a community-managed trail that honors those who came before and
perpetuates for those to follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai`i's past, present and
future. ATA has a Ka`u Stewardship Committee which is comprised entirely of Ka`u residents to
guide the stewardship and management of its Ka`u lands. If ATA is successful in protecting
these properties, it has committed to developing a Community Management Plan in partnership
with Ka`u community groups, descendants, and stakeholders within 18 months of taking
ownership. ATA is committed to community-based management of these lands and their natural
and cultural resources.
Kiolaka`a is makai of Waiohinu Town and includes intact native dryland forest, the eastern
shoreline of Ka'alu`alu Bay, portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave
system, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. A network of trails lead to
Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond teeming with opae 'lila. The mauka pasture
landsare leased for cattle grazing, perpetuating Ka`u's paniolo traditions.
Manaka`a Fishing Village stands on the sea cliffs overlooking Waikapuna Bay, along with 22
precious cultural sites including heiau, burial caves, lava tube habitation sites, water collection
caves with underground springs, and ancient habitation complexes. Over one mile of the Ala
Kahakai National Historic Trail runs through the property and two ancient mauka-makai trails
connect Na`alehu with the coastline.
I am a mental health counselor, committed to caring for ourselves, each other, and the earth,
these lands that we live on and breathe on. Part of my work is working with children, supporting
them to learn how to be in right relation with themselves, each other and the land around them.
Our children become so alive with the natural around them to teach them, rather than the screens
that are becoming so pervasive. I first came to Ka'u in 2003, and was immediately touched by
the connection I felt to a different time. There was a very special part of Hawai'i that still felt
alive here. I felt very privileged to be here, and as I came to know the community, understood
that their connection to and protection of the land and the ways of life were part of what made it
so special. Seeing clear to the ocean,unencumbered, with spaciousness, allowing plants and
animals to flourish, brings wellbeing and connection to the people who live here, something that,
as a mental health counselor, I see as imperative, as so many are struggling right now.
It is so important, not only to protect the land, and the Ka'u coastline, but the cultural richness
that exists throughout this landscape, including the native plant habitat and ancient sites, so that
we can continue to flourish here as human beings, feeling connected to something greater, in a
challenging time, bringing up our children and teaching them about the plants and the animals
and the history of Hawai'i, of Ka'u, of who they are.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka`u community's long standing goal of protecting our
beloved 80 mile coast to perpetuate our rural lifestyle and Hawaiian culture. Access to the
coastline is important for our community which still relies on subsistence fishing and gathering.
Conserving this landscape will enable community based management of Ka`u's lands and
resources, and perpetuate cultural and subsistence access to the coast for descendants,
community members, and the public, allowing all to walk in the footsteps of Ka`u's ancestors.
Mahalo,
Cherie Felzer
Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist
Weaving Pathways
510-545-2709
weavingpathways@grnail.corn
I, John P. Kalua'u, support Ala Kahakai Trail Association's purchase of the Kiolakaa parcel. I am a
rancher in Kau and presently lease a parcel in Kau for that purpose. I would like to see as much
of the large lands parcels in Kau preserved and protected and not be developed. If the
Association is successful in receiving the funds to purchase the parcel, it will be the last piece to
connect Ka Lae to Honoapo for the benefit of the people of Kau. I ask the Land Board to please
vote in favor of the Ala Kahakai Trail Association's funding request.
Feb. 15, 2021
State of Hawai`i
Board of Land and Natural Resources
blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov
The Trust for Public Land
reyna.ramolete@tpl.org
Ala Kahakai Trail Association
fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Re: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's Efforts to
Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village in Ka'u, Hawai'i
Aloha, and mahalo for giving us the opportunity to voice our opinion and concern regarding Kiolaka'a
and Manaka'a._Our Ka'u community is lucky to have the vigilance of Ala Kahakai Trail Association and
the efforts of The Trust for Public Lands to help protect our precious treasures. Let's agree, land is a
limited resource. Once open space and access are developed or compromised; it's gone. Kiolaka`a and
Manaka`a Fishing Village are priceless,needing protection and stewardship to honor the history of our
ancestors and preserve the land for future generations.
It's estimated humans have modified more than 50% of Earth's land surface. At the current rate of
growth, it is unsustainable.* Much of Hawaii's natural landscape is threatened by development,invasive
species and global climate change. We've seen the loss of access on every island. It's in all of our best
interests to protect the open spaces that haven't succumbed.Not only for their rich cultural significance
and sensitive ecosystem, but for the bonding role they play in our community. It's an amazing experience
to spend a day at Ka'alu'alu Bay: playing on the shore, surfing, or hiking the coast—you can't see one
building. Please, let's keep it that way; for all future generations to experience taking their keiki to this
place to experience just being there. It's so important,and once its gone,we won't have another chance.
Mahalo,
Angela Guidi and Soli Coleman
PO Box 41
Na'alehu, HI 96772
spareroom@mac.com
* (cited from an Article in GSA Today by scholars Roger LeB. Hooke (School of Earth and Climate
Sciences and Climate Change Institute,University of Maine) and José F. Martin-Duque(Dept. of
Geodynamics and Geosciences Institute, Complutense University, Madrid, Spain)
February 23rd, 2021
State of Hawai`i
Board of Land and Natural Resources
blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov
The Trust for Public Land
reyna.ramolete@tpl.org
Ala Kahakai Trail Association
fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Re: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's
Efforts to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village in Ka'u, Hawaii
Foster Hair Design LLC strongly supports Ala Kahakai Trail Association and The Trust for
Public Land's efforts to help the Ka`u community purchase and forever protect Kiolaka`a and
Manaka`a Fishing Village (the makai lands of Kawala). Ala Kahakai Trail Association's mission
is to support and guide a community-managed trail that honors those who came before and
perpetuates for those to follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai`i's past, present and
future. ATA has a Ka`u Stewardship Committee which is comprised entirely of Ka`u residents to
guide the stewardship and management of its Ka`u lands. If ATA is successful in protecting
these properties, it has committed to developing a Community Management Plan in partnership
with Ka`u community groups, descendants, and stakeholders within 18 months of taking
ownership. ATA is committed to community-based management of these lands and their natural
and cultural resources.
Kiolaka`a is makai of Waiohinu Town and includes intact native dryland forest, the eastern
shoreline of Ka'alu'alu Bay, portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave
system, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. A network of trails lead to
Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond teeming with opae 'lila. The mauka pasture
lands are leased for cattle grazing, perpetuating Ka`u's paniolo traditions.
Manaka`a Fishing Village stands on the sea cliffs overlooking Waikapuna Bay, along with 22
precious cultural sites including heiau, burial caves, lava tube habitation sites, water collection
caves with underground springs, and ancient habitation complexes. Over one mile of the Ala
Kahakai National Historic Trail runs through the property and two ancient mauka-makai trails
connect Na`alehu with the coastline.
I (Kady Foster) and my husband (Drew Foster) own Foster Hair Design. We are a
hairdresser/barber team with a salon in Na`alehu. We as a family believe in supporting the
people of Ka`u and giving what we can to our communities. We strive to care and provide our
services in this community for all who need it.
My daughter was born here in Ka`u and is growing up here. I feel unbelievably fortunate that
she gets to live and learn in a community that is as diverse and resilient as Ka`u.
We live here because of the nature.In my belief system we understand that we are nature not
just a part of it,but it. We need nature equally as we need water or oxygen. It is the birth place of
both. Our families special connection to this area is the deeply profound connection that it is our
honest home, the planet that provides life for us, and it is disappearing all around us. Most people
on this planet would feel a sense of connection to this coastline. It is raw and true. It is the spirit
that is each of us. Every sacrosanct piece of earth that is left needs to be saved and protected.
It is important to our family to protect the Ka'u coastline because we believe the people of
today have to start leaving the land in better condition then when we found it or soon enough our
children will be deprived of natural resources.
To our family this is not a singular issue. Plenty of academic studies along with day to day
truth shows us the rate of which humans are becoming depressed, anxious, overwhelmed,
unhappy, etc. Yes, this is for a lot of complex reasons but these emotions are signals. This
epidemic of suicide, depression, and anxiety disorders are screaming to us that we are not living
a life that is aligned with being happy,joyful, or fulfilled in the way we know we could.
The raw land as it is, the Ka`u, is our true and honest home. Just by looking at it alone we are
gifted with a calmness, lightness, and largeness which is breathtaking and to significant for
words. We are not meant to wipe away its beauty which took hundreds of thousands of years to
create and we know it is irreplaceable. Like all beautiful and resourceful nature that has been
remade by humans can never be undone. The state of Hawaii has been a victim to this for
decades. Please consider that our future generations do not live without wildlife for we are made
from it,we are it, without it there will be nothing left to support our human lives and the children
that follow.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka`u community's long standing goal of protecting our
beloved 80 mile coast to perpetuate our rural lifestyle and Hawaiian culture. Access to the
coastline is important for our community which still relies on subsistence fishing and gathering.
Conserving this landscape will enable community based management of Ka`u's lands and
resources, and perpetuate cultural and subsistence access to the coast for descendants,
community members, and the public, allowing all to walk in the footsteps of Ka`u's ancestors.
Mahalo,
Kady Foster
Foster Hair Design LLC
808-895-2151
book@fosterhair.com
March, 11, 2021
State of Hawai`i
Board of Land and Natural Resources
blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov
The Trust for Public Land
reyna.ramolete@tpl.org
Ala Kahakai Trail Association
fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Re: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's
Efforts to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village in Ka'u, Hawai'i
I, Alex Wang, strongly support Ala Kahakai Trail Association and The Trust for Public Land's
efforts to help the Ka`u community purchase and forever protect Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a
Fishing Village (the makai lands of Kawala). Ala Kahakai Trail Association's mission is to
support and guide a community-managed trail that honors those who came before and
perpetuates for those to follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai`i's past, present and
future. ATA has a Ka`u Stewardship Committee which is comprised entirely of Ka`u residents to
guide the stewardship and management of its Ka`u lands. If ATA is successful in protecting
these properties, it has committed to developing a Community Management Plan in partnership
with Ka`u community groups, descendants, and stakeholders within 18 months of taking
ownership. ATA is committed to community-based management of these lands and their natural
and cultural resources.
Kiolaka`a is makai of Waiohinu Town and includes intact native dryland forest, the eastern
shoreline of Ka'alu'alu Bay, portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave
system, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. A network of trails lead to
Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond teeming with opae 'lila. The mauka pasture
lands are leased for cattle grazing,perpetuating Ka`u's paniolo traditions.
Manaka`a Fishing Village stands on the sea cliffs overlooking Waikapuna Bay, along with 22
precious cultural sites including heiau, burial caves, lava tube habitation sites,water collection
caves with underground springs, and ancient habitation complexes. Over one mile of the Ala
Kahakai National Historic Trail runs through the property and two ancient mauka-makai trails
connect Na`alehu with the coastline.
Ka'alu'alu Bay is a special birding location for our native shorebirds such as the Kolea (Pluvialis
ficlva), the `Ulili (Tringa incana) and the Huna kai (Calidris alba). Especially in fall and winter,
this serves as a gathering place of these shorebirds and concentrates them in numbers far
exceeding nearly anywhere else on the Big Island. I have seen well over 200 kolea in this bay at
one time! The kolea use the bay to rest in between tides when they can no longer feed on the
exposed shoreline at low tide. Nearby development would be harmful for these birds and likely
would drastically reduce the effectiveness of this stop over point as a resting area for the kolea.
Additionally, I think there are those among us in the community at large that like to visit
Ka'alu'alu for recreational bird watching. I have friends from Hilo, HPP, Volcano and even
Oahu that have visited Ka'alu'alu for the express purpose of seeing the birds in this area. This is
a very passive activity that has very little negative impact on the land or its resources. I think
that building development adjacent to the bay would greatly diminish the scenic beauty and
natural value of this location for birds and bird watchers alike.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka`u community's long standing goal of protecting our
beloved 80 mile coast to perpetuate our rural lifestyle and Hawaiian culture. Access to the
coastline is important for our community which still relies on subsistence fishing and gathering.
Conserving this landscape will enable community based management of Ka`u's lands and
resources, and perpetuate cultural and subsistence access to the coast for descendants,
community members, and the public, allowing all to walk in the footsteps of Ka`u's ancestors.
Mahalo,
Alex Wang
Biologist and avid Bird Watcher
(808)937-7924, axwang12@gmail.com.
William Keoni Fox
From: kevin beeboys.org <kevin@beeboys.org>
Sent: Monday, February 08, 2021 11:20 AM
To: blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov; reyna.ramolete@tpl.org;fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Subject: Testimony in SUPPORT of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's
Efforts to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a Fishing Village in Ka'u, Hawaii
February, 8, 2021
To whom it may concern,
I very strongly supports Ala Kahakai Trail Association and The Trust for Public Land's efforts to help the Ka`u
community purchase and forever protect Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village (the makai lands of Kawala).
Ala Kahakai Trail Association's mission is to support and guide a community-managed trail that honors those
who came before and perpetuates for those to follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai`i's past, present
and future. ATA has a Ka`u Stewardship Committee which is comprised entirely of Ka`u residents to guide the
stewardship and management of its Keil lands. If ATA is successful in protecting these properties, it has
committed to developing a Community Management Plan in partnership with Ka`u community groups,
descendants, and stakeholders within 18 months of taking ownership. ATA is committed to community-based
management of these lands and their natural and cultural resources.
Kiolaka`a is makai of Waiohinu Town and includes intact native dryland forest, the eastern shoreline of
Ka'alu'alu Bay, portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave system, and a segment of
the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. A network of trails lead to Kapenako, a fresh water spring and
anchialine pond teeming with `opae `ula. The mauka pasture lands are leased for cattle grazing, perpetuating
Ka`u's paniolo traditions.
Manaka`a Fishing Village stands on the sea cliffs overlooking Waikapuna Bay, along with 22 precious cultural
sites including heiau, burial caves, lava tube habitation sites, water collection caves with underground springs,
and ancient habitation complexes. Over one mile of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail runs through the
property and two ancient mauka-makai trails connect Na`alehu with the coastline.
I grew up in an area that had thousands of acres of open space,many farms and beautiful meadows and pastures
were the fabric of the landscape in suburban Philadelphia. In the late 80's and early 90's many farmers died
and their children who inherited these farms and meadows didn't have the same connection to the land, it was
no longer viewed as an essential aspect of their life and many sold their beautiful land to the highest bidder who
happened to be developers. These developers wished to extract the most value out of the land in the quickest
most financially lucrative way,which was to subdivide the open space and build roads and homes. Once land
has been sub-divided and developed there is no going back, no flocks of migratory geese to honk their way
north in the spring and south in the autumn. This development has created many unforeseen
consequences. Roads that once were easy to walk or bike on became too busy and filled with traffic it became
dangerous to continue. The lack of foresight has also created flash flooding events in the area streams eroding
their banks dropping trees and silting up the waterways, displacing freshwater mollusks and filling in swimming
holes and fishing spots. This short-sighted rush to create jobs and wealth for a few has ruined the land for the
many.
I left that space because the momentum was too great to stop and broke the balance between development and
nature. People who seek quick short term monetary gains are drunk with greed. Progress is necessary in the
direction of resilience and regeneration. These costal lands are an asset to Ka'u and need to be preserved so that
our future generations have the opportunity to experience life in it's wild foitii.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka`u community's long standing goal of protecting our beloved 80 mile
coast to perpetuate our rural lifestyle and Hawaiian culture. Access to the coastline is important for our
community which still relies on subsistence fishing and gathering. Conserving this landscape will enable
community based management of Ka`u's lands and resources, and perpetuate cultural and subsistence access to
the coast for descendants, community members, and the public, allowing all to walk in the footsteps of Ka`u's
ancestors.
Mahalo,
kevin oconnor
Kevin@beeboys.org
808-987-7416
Beeboys.org
Sent from Mail for Windows 10
2
February 6, 2021
State of Hawai`i
Board of Land and Natural Resources
blnr.testimony@hawaii.gov
The Trust for Public Land
reyna.ramolete@tpl.org
Ala Kahakai Trail Association
fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Re: Testimony in Support of Ala Kahakai Trail Association's and Trust for Public Land's
Efforts to Protect and Acquire Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a Fishing Village in Ka'u, Hawai'i
BEE BOYS LLC strongly supports Ala Kahakai Trail Association and The Trust for Public
Land's efforts to help the Ka`u community purchase and forever protect Kiolaka`a and Manaka`a
Fishing Village (the makai lands of Kawala). Ala Kahakai Trail Association's mission is to
support and guide a community-managed trail that honors those who came before and
perpetuates for those to follow—with protocols and respect for Hawai`i's past, present and
future. ATA has a Ka`u Stewardship Committee which is comprised entirely of Keil residents to
guide the stewardship and management of its Keil" lands. If ATA is successful in protecting
these properties, it has committed to developing a Community Management Plan in partnership
with Keit community groups, descendants, and stakeholders within 18 months of taking
ownership. ATA is committed to community-based management of these lands and their natural
and cultural resources.
Kiolaka`a is makai of Waiohinu Town and includes intact native dryland forest, the eastern
shoreline of Ka`alu`alu Bay,portions of the ancient Kamakalepo settlement and Lua Nunu cave
system, and a segment of the Ala Kahakai National Historic Trail. A network of trails lead to
Kapenako, a fresh water spring and anchialine pond teeming with `opae `ula. The mauka pasture
lands are leased for cattle grazing, perpetuating Ka`u's paniolo traditions.
Manaka`a Fishing Village stands on the sea cliffs overlooking Waikapuna Bay, along with 22
precious cultural sites including heiau,burial caves, lava tube habitation sites, water collection
caves with underground springs, and ancient habitation complexes. Over one mile of the Ala
Kahakai National Historic Trail runs through the property and two ancient mauka-makai trails
connect Na`alehu with the coastline.
We are regenerative beekeepers, manufacturing food products and skin care products with our
honeybee colonies. Our product quality and certification relies on natural beekeeping methods
and pristine environmental conditions- including access to forage for our honeybees. The Ka'u
coast is unique, free from commercial agriculture, golf courses and developments that threaten
bees and contaminate their honey and products. We've built a business, dependent on the rare &
rich open space below our apiary,where our bees forage. We supply some of Hawaii's best
hotels, grocers and boutiques with our coastal honey and products.
Protecting the coast protects the value of my company, the vitality of our bees, and the
sustainability of our community. We chose coastal Ka'u to start our business, because the
undeveloped lands offers us a rare and unparalleled product, that can't be found anywhere else
on the planet.
Protecting these lands would fulfill the Ka`u community's long standing goal of protecting our
beloved 80 mile coast to perpetuate our rural lifestyle and Hawaiian culture. Access to the
coastline is important for our community which still relies on subsistence fishing and gathering.
Conserving this landscape will enable community based management of Ka`u's lands and
resources, and perpetuate cultural and subsistence access to the coast for descendants,
community members, and the public, allowing all to walk in the footsteps of Ka`u's ancestors.
Mahalo,
Ryan Williamson
Director/ Owner Bee Boys LLC
ryyannbeeboys.org
808-333-6895
Beeboys.org
From: Caitlin Kryss &Taz Rosam
P.O. Box 711687
Mountain View, HI. 96771
To: Hawaii BLNR
Kalanimoku Building
1151 Punchbowl St.
Honolulu, HI 96813
RE: Support Item C1B and C1C Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a
Dear Members of the Board of Land and Natural Resources,
I am writing in support of the protection of Ka'u's Kiolaka'a and Manaka'a lands. These
lands provide critical habitat for numerous native plant and animal species, many of which are
threatened or endangered. These lands also represent the cultural heritage of the people of
Ka'u, and deserve to be protected for future generations. These lands are connected with a
multitude of cultural stories, sustainable use practices, indigenous knowledge, archeological
significance, scientific study, critically important habitats for native species. Losing these lands
to development and destruction would be absolutely devastating. Our family is born and raised
in Ka'u, and the health of these lands is a piece of our identity.
At a time when human impact on the natural world has resulted in mass extinction of
many species, and the destruction of indigenous lands has disconnected people from their
heritage, we are presented with this unique and powerful opportunity to conserve something
so precious. These lands are so much more to so many people, and if they are preserved and
protected, they will remain a resource for our children and their children. If these lands are lost
to development, we can never reclaim them, and they will be relegated to the list of lost
opportunities of gifting the next generations with something intact, healthy, natural and
culturally important. I urge you to please choose to protect them.
I also want to extend my deep mahalo to the many dedicated people who are committed to
protecting our special, unique, and precious island home.
He Ali'i Ka 'Aina; He Kauwa ke Kanaka
The land is chief; man is its servant
Mahalo nui,
Caitlin Kryss &Taz Rosam
From: Janice Glennie <palmtree7@hawaiiantel.net>
Sent: Monday, April 19, 2021 12:56 PM
To:fox@alakahakaitrail.org
Subject: Protect Kiolaka'a for conservation, ag and cultural preservation
Aloha,
I'm writing in strong support for the protection of Kiolaka'a for conservation, agriculture, and
cultural preservation.That's why I strongly support the vision of Ala Kahakai Trail Association
which is: to support and guide a community-managed trail that honors those who came before
and perpetuates for those to follow–with protocols and respect for Hawai'i past, present and
future. ATA's vision is community-based management of the trail and its surrounding natural
and cultural landscape.
I've worked with this group in the past and have huge respect for the work they do. And
though I'm not a Ka'u dweller, I'm also familiar with other groups and individuals who are and
who have spent hundreds, if not thousands of hours working for decades to protect this land
and its nearshore resources from environmental and cultural degradation.The far too few
times I've visited the area (and all over 20 years ago), I found it to be amazing, wild and
wonderful in indescribable ways— unique in the world. and that's not counting the cultural
resources which are ancient and living at the same time.
I hope that this crucial layer of protection and management will be given to Kiolaka'a.
Mahalo and sincerely,
Janice Palma-Glennie
r.o.box 4849
Kailua-Kona, hawai'i 96745
Tel#8 08-5 24-009 3
Cell#8o8-989-3549