Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0935.002 2022-2024Ashley L. Kiei•kiervicz Council Member District 4 Puna Office: (808) 961-8265 Fax: (808) 961-8912 ashley.kierkiewiez@hawailcounty.gov HAWAI`I COUNTY COUNCIL Hawaii County Building 25 Aupuni Street Hilo, Hawaii 96720 c p MEMORANDUM C= ram( DATE: July 22, 2024 ' `' C, TO: Heather Kimball, Council Chairperson w >'_- And Members of the Hawaii County Council TVv CD FROM: L/1) 'N" Ashley L. Kierkiewicz, Council Member SUBJECT: Presentation for July 23, 2024 Keyser Marston Presentation Please see the attached presentation material entitled "Feasibility Analysis: County of Hawaii Affordable Housing Policy" for the presentation by Keyser Marston and the Office of Housing and Community Development during the Communications, Reports, and Council Oversight Committee of July 23, 2024. Mahalo, AK/kj Serving the Interests of the People of Our Island Hawaii County is an Equal Opportunity Provider and Employer Comm. No 3 S , L Ref. To: D I ow C AL ' Ref. Date� +}c:'; N w 0 N 0 T -0 r D z �D D � n T 0 un ;u r rn O rD x rD rD O rD 3 =3 Ln �' cr -. p n -. r-r Ln rD n r) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0> -h-a = 7v 7v m n D v ;;a O O Q OrD -h� fN D n — rD � O n fD ofDQ _0 O Q �:3 SOCL o � o S S fD n• �q' v Q 0 Q CND rD o N �, w -< �' mN 0 �Q2 0 fD r f�D cn cn• o c i fD v' n C7 rr cn Co fD � O Sara � � Q� �°'aQEL3 �� - N O ��0 • ,rVo� -0 N � �' • �--h � O A -S O r+ fD CD �^ a1 cn �Q -I �, "o�, .••. i•i �q 3 Q , fD 0 S O �p O �, ' 3 N =3 r-+ flQj M CD fD �..� 3 Q fD Q fD fD _0 3 �,� `^ O r+ fD fD M. —.prq r �. fD r+ = � w � f - � �3-%� o N Q QNN O lQ ni O r+( o0-fD � D DD � ��K O Q = � Q o — �o o _0 e -r N =3 fD N N cn N 0 Z) (D _0 - =3 aq 0 O FD N N N N 0 v 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 L Ln W lD W N N O W l0 O G O G E O O O O O O rD O W(D = fD X. S O O S O .01 O LA LA (AO O V �q (DfD S �. O'q � O O ni (D cn � O Q O Q O (D N L N r r cn cn (D �' • � _ 0 fD cn [� Q 0q O'q c rGD rt ��� N� ��� (D� 0 LA z (Iq ED O Q (D O (D rD V N (n r G N (D Q �G 0 Q C N 0- rr (D o o D C: (n O O N N W _ O O � C N O — + (D � � m N r+ O Q � O N �-' G —h v 0-O (D O a, � O .�+ O O Q n) fD rr cn —h O N • O n� • (D a r-f- a ■ ■ ■ iwoZWW M. � :� N N Q (D (D O+ O 0 N m -5 CD Q o- r+ CD cr O � � N N (D (D ■ ■ ■ m — p c) — 0- (D � V)i rr+ f7 r+ fD (D ram+ N N (D fh h 0 (D O -, (D 1 ram+ O Q (D fl�i 0 (D O O e-+ N. (D Uq 0 0 _N (D �• (i 0-0 r+ �3E m rD n rD c m 3 rD 0 o- v m 0- 0 m C m o- n m n n<i Ln 0_ rD (D 0_ :" m 0 D n 0 m m rD v Q rD 0 v 0 CL v 0- rD 0 f-r (D (D N N O N o ((DD O O N � W =. (rl Ln o O0 O Ln 0 + aj =3 cy- rt (D Vf O (D(D O O =3' Q 0-0 N C rD rL =. 7 O rD O r+ ~' O r+ o 3 (D m (D r+ C. (D < 3 ED -0 (D O rt (D O (D 0- Ln Ln 9E P D m 0 O z Ln O m n 0 n n c 0 O rf 3 �1 �• 0-0 O D T �1 V) w rn _� V) O n M- ►-' N IV W W = 0 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 O 1998CL 1999 3 2000CD 7e n 2001 �v 0 CD r"F 2002CD 0 CD O 2003 3 O 2004 � 2005 : r+ 2006 � 2007 XvX=_Orp 2008 (D � N � � (D 2009 Q O N 0 �CD � CD ID D _.. O ' 2010 2011 CD � � 2012 o r C- Z, v CD 2013 C-nCD CD 2014 3 CD CD `° < 3 CD 2015 CD — 2016 3. 2017 2018 CL 2019 2020 2021 2022 0 0 0 0 O M pq n O� fD N n 0- na)m n fD C O w 9 O 3 2 -, o m 3 ID S ro v r* N r�r Q n O cn rt can O rr rt N Q Q O O v cn O n rr v T n O Q c O m �' UU n r r p fD n r* n O r r O G cn 00 S N S S cn S a1 _ m O O ONm r+ 0'q U�l fD O O cn D N, ov T cn rD O_ c�' cn (D -0 Q �' C37 c Ln S O cn 'Ar+ (U O (D (D n r=r O Q (U fD --, (D (—D (n e-+ rD f7 N � O Sv O Q r+ (D n `G N ram+ N O S O. < =3 -- -% �' n = f (i (D r+ e�-F 0- (D G to (n (D Ln O fD Cy- (D (D rD N Ln fl1 N �• (� NJ 0 ram+ N of —• O -, O PQ of -0 N O 3 0 — N O. r+ r+ rD Q 0 �, m N O N O - fD +, r+ r+ O 0- ,< < O v 70 n O r' pCL r+ Cn — `. (D N 3 � o n1 O (rD i � 7 N _0 of UQ r+ (D of C7 r. O n (D O of N Q Q of NO of Q =3 C (D O O ems+ O to on (D. 3 (D CD r+ �n 0) LA c �. p cu C — p p ( C a) aj c O =� n cu N m O 3 r+ O O rr S X O 7 fu V1 R I c� O O v m _ 0 0 o v� _ Q)' o ET ET _ cm w° :;a:;a0 0 0 fD - 3• =5 T cu a) in. (D 3- T N b N O 3 �' LnZ3 = � �_ 0_Uq 0-(D mO fD O Ln �• (D T N �. °- w 3 C fD _ G T w 3 Ul N -I v v�� N Ln W 0 C O O O Ln O O O O O O TI C O O O O O O O O O O r+ 3 rr 4./1• N N W I-, I-� CD WlDNo0�NN0� O O(Jl � 0 O O 0 0 0 0 (DD r•r O CD O CDO O O O O O CDO O O r+ O O O O O O O O M � 4j)- N 4�:- IV Oo N M n• - V) � N � w � ui CY) O N W CY) v m m N N N -I F, ul 0 O O -4 N \ \ O U1 U1 I" 00 0 0 0 T fD O O rr+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 yn 0 O 0 O 0 o O O 0 0 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 o 0 o O 0 0 0 N 0 O • "S •lrlw �• •N. a:•• } a• i+ • s • 111) (1) 41 r-n G) -4 O C) C) CD (D C) C) C) C) C) (D CD (D CD C) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -n C,) a o E w 3 C) Cv p! 0 E 0 QomC) L :7 m E 0 (D 0) 0) 0. -n C,) ;U ?� 0 5- CD 0 3 (n = 0 0 0 (D 0 0 2) 0 (D 0_- -n cn w 3 —.(� 0 (D 0 W phi 3 cQ (D (D 0) -n Cl) D) 5" 36 -n cl) a), D) 5. 3(a W, :;o (D �o m (D X, (D 0 Cn w 0 w w M 0 C-) 0 Q) -r Z =� =3 =]7 0 1 CD 0) (D 0 > M 0 0- (n =r 0 -0 w 0 CCDZ) CD 3 0 =3 cn cn m w CT 0 0 CD 0 =3 3 mfn CD 0 0 CD (n =r --I CD w -r 3 (D CD cn CD CD (n CD 3 =3 (o =3 3 CD w CD CD Q)i (n 77 0 �, M -.,o CDP. o" D N o � rD Vt v Q Z5 7 rD 0 � (D a o s A/)-rD N 0- o � 00 n 0 0 0 C: 0 0 v 2 o v N 0 D w � N D O rD ()0 no O O fD O Q m N 7 O — N 7 0 rD 3 = m ,rt v C, N O O O O O O O O D Ol U•1 � W O W Q1 00 Ln O O O O O O O O 00 Q1 NJ O O O o 0 O0 O0 O O tn• in- {n• tn- N �I N 00 W 0 0 0 0 J (D O (D 6- (D cu Q a O O N fu (D N x cu _0 fD• (D H LL�J V) rD V) O r+ r* O CD CQ' 0' r+ O CD 3 m r+ cn r+ O O w N �D m N cn O v m I 3 O CD CD co CD CS Z O r+ CD r+ O 3 O CD r+ O O CD CD CD r+ O Mm cn 0 CD O r+ CD 0 G N cr .ol I v CD CAD a �G CD C -' CD Cn O 3 CD 3 O CD 3 CD r+ CA <D I CAD CD N v cn 3 O CD CD 1< r+ O Q CD CD LA rf O rD d m uo, m c i C O �* cr m • m O � � n A y Q I-ACA I. o � w 3 (D C 3 r+ N O1 (D O r+ tO V v 3 O 3 D p 3 CL = 3 M y' CL 1"F Q) r • T (D O C O O � 3 C 3 v eD o vi fD 3 3 p � O � — n o N m e A eD H, TI m 3 C a m 3 � O 0 n 3 — O O _ 3 v+ 3 - o :^ SD O (D 3 3 � n '•r OO cu ai O cu (D TI ai 3 W N n O rt = � O C 3 h M O rr-D n (D M N T � _T (D 0 (D 0 7 n 7� 0q N d m ai m O M c n O o V � C 3 � O n D 0 0• c `C O 0- (ND C (D 00, m x y, m (0 O cyn n D Q � 0 3 `C C)• � (�D O a -nO M 0 C R.N a fu O a N (D W N Ln TII II II TI ro V1 N UQ fD O ro _r r n C O 0 O N [D fD O r O N =r-t p) �• ,+ rr 2 Q) • p�j ro 0)� T7 V7 (7Q ro T 3 C= z3 a) V? � 0) - N ro .[ (D � -n(D Q) _ O sv T 3 p (ro/1 n �- O N :3— ro W - W O � a) ro W W O � c/i UQ T v W O � f11 UQ T Q) (D r F — O un a — ro fD — T — — — T T T m — m m n � A lu N V� M Q. fD — T — — — T T T T — T T �• � 0 r•F �) 0 ro N ro C) cn• o v � � O Q � n• ro 3 try r' T Z — T — — — T1 TI -n — m m F" T U'1 D ih O � (D' n r+ Cost per Square Foot in Project m f�s .69 16S 69 6S 69 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O m CD CL nm En ■ O x N U) W Sp l = (0 rh 0 o p m —, vo j, 0 m cn ° v CD (n D CD � CD o 0 Cn v III 00 Z m m 0 O W CD �-CD( CL ■ CD o (n �. C n cD CD C . O �( CD ' O� o v N o - nCD CD 73 �� Z r CD 5 �(D r. CD Cn c� (D 0 cD 1l o nm r CD �. m cD U O CD N O C 0 n (TD (D U'1 4:h W N F, CD CJl A � O D T` ,O.F � M. _ c a) Q = m rt v CD � o O v CD CD o S N CD CD G 3 _0 v m n (D N n CD O o N• m M. 2 c, O rt << -0 O -0CAD % 3 Q � (� N CD O cr N Q < (n lD 0 O N O. :3N. 3 (D CD� CD _3_ CQ n :3 O_ v -n CD w � _— Q (o �' CD CD v CD 3 ZY '� N n � O � M W N n S to CD N r CD < O �, CD <5. CD _0 CD CD < o CD_ CD CD CT C _0v M. :30 co O n (n N v T. 0- 3 v CDCD o- = 0 M 2 Mi n (n CD m v v m v O O N C G - -n N 0 Q O < o rt 0 N CD M FY -0CD CD m_ 3 = 5. CD CCD Q < (n o (Q O v � O a CQ (n O _0 0 �_ < CD O N 3 CD O n O to CD 0 3 � � rt CD z O O � Q N Z) CD Q N O - O `< 3 CD r) O l O n Q O r+ v �G n� (D Ln G (D N D n O Q (D n O v v, (D Q r (D Q h O O N O O U-I i N O N Ln N N cn S O G (D (D Q 2 ;/)- cn O X- 70 (D n (D Q ; 0 m x n (D N N (D Q (D N (D 0 w w Iq 0 2 U.) O O n (D 0- r-r N 06) r+ N r+ _Q OQ 0 2 00 O O n I (D Q N N� N (D Q 3 O N r+ h O 1 (D fV O N O 0 (D C� N O O U1 w rD CL 3 (D r+ 0 r* (D O f. N Ln r+ � O (D � X [� N N (D n X 0- ;;: D, N � '{ O O 3ED (D cr* rm-r � -0 Ln r+ � (D � N N � (D rr �. X � n (D (D 3 N N (D f7 r+ (D N r-r O O r+ (D O (D n r+ r+ r+ n a!5 O h m x n /rD V V) Url o�Qo3 orD rD CD h ��., O O rD Ln cn O O N ON Orq n r0-r Q C O rD rD O D n = F r-r � =3 r+ W rD n r+ Ln C LA rD r+ Ln N I� 0 rD �e-+ N ram+ -0 n O O < r+ � rD rD X r+ UO � n � rD 0 a- - ;: C rD C r-r Ln Ln W N I� -o T c: D D Ln � Cr Q� n N r+ r+ O Ln Q Q Q rD O O 0 --hLn - Q rD W rD rD rD M rD Q c`�n O NO O < S rn+ � � 0 -0 rD rD O O n rD Lncan n N cr C�. < Dq n Ort < we n + rD rD — • r Obi — r�+ rp O r+ �' cam/: O Q O r+ =. rD 3 < = 3 r C 0 m rt O H O O O O r+ -0 N fD rD O :3 N a- (D n rD rD N O fD r+ r+ r+ O N 0 x 3 rL. p o (Aa 3 rt: m T a) (D < r+ C M a0 MO x (D n. r+CL X V% C (D Vf O N 'a H M O m v D m v 00 N O r�D * Fi © rr (DO NJr+ O N O lD (D N o rD O (D o D v v+ O_ 1 r-r O N O - rr S ;G Ex Ul 1� r+ fD C o T fD Q' O (D S ID S O (D (D fD Q Ln 00 v O O � O O O 1rt 00 \ � & O O o O o �, 7 p Q y NO o � o OZ c ,_+ D N (D - o (D 3 r LA 70 T1 N = N l (D I -A r+ D y 0 r) 0 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 �s 00Q 1oo s V� 00, Ooj (D �9 � -10 �. O O c1 011 � `0) -10K, O oV P 1 0 �1y � O 1s — O �'l6 O �1� �7iP O 18 r O 19 ETD O� 1 O 11 —� Q 0�1 10(D (D C� v C Ci O rt (D Ln C2_ (D v C rY N (D 3 `r�-r (D CZ . _ ET 0 n 2 E o. n v cn Q Q � Q Q 7 C7 CD N =3 Z Q Q Cn C CDCD 0 CD Z 3 CL =3 3 CD M CD N 3 CD 3 zs co CD (D C m O n n CD � CS 0 (Q -0 CD CD � Q O o 0 CD o. 0 m m = 3 m Z3 v CL ;r,, CCDD 0 v CD —• CD m � Ca -0 =r O 0 O Q C 8101 h � N O � Q v Q o S= O = 1 O 3 W m 3CD 0 N � Q CD CD 0 Q O m b O O O O O O O O O O o S rD r+ � N O rD -0rr rD � v O0 Ort -h rD `n O � - O O O - ! �, 2 N W p p ( n�i C �_ - i/� v O O +C 4jE rD n O : CD cn n (D O N N (D N '— O O Ul (D N O lko lD 00 v (D N Q 1110 lD O rD O rt O — � FU 0 (D c� e+ h v rD n rD rD rr 0 O :3 � (DD O CD r+ rD � v rD 3 O ram'+ O 3 3 O D lD O �' O Q� � (D r+ ETo- v � =3 N - O rDO D r+ rD m O Z) r... fD � �, N = ,�+ Q Cl) �_ O (D rnr , 70 70 0) 3 r-+ < o Q C 0% Q r+ � NJO - (D �, O Q =3 —� � Co 0- r rD rD (D 00 O O rD O Q (D Ln c� r+ a) v — O 3 �_ O CD � cn Ln O -, O rD D rD rD N o 0 3 � rDLn Q rD c m 0 7 M. d I �• MnR-i r-t O D �• rt V) KO: z a) 0 r rD CIL) A rf O n r N aJ (( <D (DD Lf' O _0O -h 0 C CD n a) n C — r+LA N — Lri O O W 00 + O D 0 N• 3 Q :_w v v N N 0- < fD (D f-+ -11 O OL) N 2 O n = II II � (D !v 0 Q O O � O - Q n a) o LyC: rD Z3 a) m O N O N 2 w 00 0 oa a, m O'Q. a m O n O m ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ m 70 X (D (D Q Q n (D Q Q O D < W (D m O rD' (D N N (D (D � N N O C) T_ (D x (D Q (D (D O 3 rD r-r N r-r D Q Q N N O I� T1 0 (CDD ((DD rD 0) x N � o O (D 3 (D f-+ N 2 —h O =3 O rD -h ` '� LA rD r.+ rF e-+ • < V M rn n `I O co r+ r1) O Ln r^ �. D 0-0 O ET rD f� n r+ <� (/) N� =• UQ O e+ D h O Q QJ cr E Ln �•l ti O 3 Ln 0 �•J . . . -n i M CL U) n 0 0 CL L V) r+ 0 0 s CD n r+ V) rD rD O-Q Q O rD 0- rD CL r+ a) r+ rD CL O On rD X n rD n rD Q r+ V) v rD v V) rD QL O C rD rD v O r+ s rD v r+ rD v r+ rD r+ O v G O Q 0) Q G rD (n ° 3 n r+ r+ O rD cu Ln i m CL m m D O v p vo :E D m vo 0 D � % CL O 0 D n 2) o n rt N O o � � rD = r+ o 3 � E fD O � `� o m 3' rt o -I W r+ rD m rD ( L M a� rD o � S fD CD O a `* cD — _�• CD n' O (A O� O 3 0 O 7f+ O o(D Q a) rIft + �. CL ET r+ = �D O rf 0 -0 < rD� o O La:N _ aj r� 0 '{ n O �. N rD CD rh cn r0+ X 3 0 0, rD p -0N O n Ul) O N 3 3 rr CD :3 -h r+ n � 0.)-h r+ p ram+CL 3 N CD _M �_ H� S r rF N + p -1 rD N O cu rD �' 2 = v X n H Q r f cn X cn cn O r+ rnr i no r+rD rD �< rD x0. r+ rD cn O =5 �+ o rD 0 0 N 3r7 rD rD CD 3 cu � rt N. N o rt r+ O N N Ul W N I" Z Z o �, r+ n Z) O n N� CD 3 3 Q" r O (DD rr O O fD O O O m a O O Q 3 � N " O `< — n T rp fD -nT CD rp lD N t/) GQ �_ N O C Q N a r+ T -L� O if-,- 0 O c N fD O zy O r+ N r+ r- fD O O O N � W n fD .0 fD o ram+ O N In �, W N N N O T fD O 0 fD -arn+ CAD O� p Q . . Z) =. Oro c� O_ v n p O_ D Co O_ D O n fD n rt n r+ fD O 3 a) M fD O E � -0r+ O r+ N m (n p < zp CD r'f fD f� M r+ Q fl fD ram+ fl N_, V1 � — fD O C fD LnN (n 3 Ln 0-r+ — 0- — Q m 0-0 Ln flJ r-F (n V o 3 o fD Q �' Q cn Q N T N r+ O n n O 0 0 r+ N E O r Q E' fD n E' N' O O u 0 2ET rD'* Ln fD fD 3 v r+ fD r+ 3 O Ln r r r+ CD r+ N rD Ln Ln O O ram+ N O r+ fD n fD �+ O (D M cn C N 0 rQ + O O fD LAQ (D C Q -< Q— r+ E. � r+ T� r+ n p + Ln —� N q _n r th O fi QQ� rD •r' vSn Q " fD XLnv D r* r-r rD f D 0- U Ln rC+ Q 3 D fi N C f(D - -0 N O n IV• fD Q Q Q � � � zr fD 0 a) CD'{ — r r < 0 flJ p Q fD n fD Q Q fl) `� Q �' '< r fD n O <, n -% O � Z) v m X zr N O N< al n r+ O— fD N 04 Ln r+ Q _0 N Q )n fD 0- n c fD O Ln rr+ Ln in r+ r+ O rD 0 3 v L. < v '< O O Ort rD � Ln prtj a-Q fD 0-fD Q < N - O � v — fp Di a) r* :=5 r+CD n N m N rD fD r+ O rt I fD N IN �n m • V rD 90- GO) T rn n i iD A CD cn o 0 o D rf m M n E: o o N O rD o(D m 70 O m m M O A �O o' � --0-. m < m CD — Mr+ 3 :3 _ 33 <' r* c �, ,� rf rn fD '{ r r CD C , V O (AM 3 m O CL Q O � m iD m Ul O N m�oCD p Oa fl ArQ ^ ` _ r-r 00 /1 m m oQ m � 00 C rD n p � � < M rF p Z3Ln m (D • �1 cn <' O ^ E� iz rF l • OIQ N rlt `< 0 n m N X N CD Q 0. �• N n m Iv 0 A O N rF UU O x w rtcu m \ a=3 V) _0 rD m O Q �. DO cro N � m rf 0 n QJ 0 I 0 0 IN 3 rf 0 D 0 0 0 rD r z x c,n rD