HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0283.361 2024-2026From: Cheryl Lee
Sent: Monday, July 21, 2025 2:05 PM
To: Council Testimony
Subject: Testimony Opposing Bill 51 - Humane and Effective Feral Animal Management
Needed
Dear Honorable Members of the Hawaii County Council,
I am writing as a concerned community member to oppose Bill51, which proposes prohibiting the
feeding of feral animals —including cats, pigs, goats, and chickens —on County -owned or managed
properties. While I understand the intent to protect public health and native wildlife, this bill raises
serious concerns regarding its effectiveness and compassion. o It7
o_ cQ
Summary of Bill. 51: � zc
--ice
Prohibits feeding of feral animals on County property
• Includes enforcement provisions with potential fines for violations
• Aims to address issues related to overpopulation and nuisance behavior
Key Concerns:
1. Ineffectiveness of Feeding Bans: Simply banning feeding will not reduce feral animal populations.
These animals will continue to forage and breed, often leading to increased suffering, starvation,
and disease.
2. Penalties Discourage Compassionate Care: The threat of fines penalizes residents who
responsibly feed and care for feral animals, many of whom are dedicated volunteers working to
control populations humanely.
3. Lack of Comprehensive Population Control Strategy: Bill 51 does not adequately support or fund
Trap -Neuter -Return (TNR) programs, which are proven humane methods for controlling feral cat
populations. Without accessible spay/neuter services, the cycle of overpopulation continues
unabated.
4. Potential Public Health Risks: Starving animals may become more aggressive or spread disease.
Feeding under controlled TNR programs actually helps monitor and reduce health risks.
5. Environmental Considerations: While protecting native species is important, humane coexistence
strategies can balance ecological concerns with animal welfare.
Recommendations:
• Prioritize and fund TNR programs countywide
• Provide accessible and affordable spay/neuter services
• Educate the public about responsible feral animal management
• Avoid punitive fines that alienate community caretakers
• Develop a holistic plan addressing root causes rather than symptoms yh,
Comm. Igo,
Raf. To: _
1 Ref. Dare WL 2 3 2U
In conclusion, I urge the Council to reconsider Bill 51 in favor of more effective, compassionate, and
scientifically supported measures. Our community deserves policies that respect both public safety and
the dignity of all creatures.
Thankyou foryour time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Cheryl Lee
t,