Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0500.000 2024-2026HEATHER L. KIMBALL COUNCIL DISTRICT I (North Hilo, Hamdkua, and portion of Waimea) Phone: (808) 961-8828 (808) 961-8912 Email. heather. kimba_110hawaiicountugov HAWAI`I COUNTY COUNCIL COUNTY OF HAWAI`I 25 Aupuni Street, Ste. 1402, Hilo, Hawaii 96720 --s W �t-- DATE: September 5, 2025 TO: Dr. Holeka Goro Inaba, Council Chair z r and Hawaii County Council Members FROM: Heather Kimball, Council District 1 SUBJECT: Presentation by Hunden Partners and Dept. of Research and Development: County of Hawaii Economic Impact Study on Short -Term Vacation Rentals I respectfully request at least 40 minutes of time on September 16, 2025, during the Communications, Reports, and Council Oversight Committee, for a 20-minute presentation by Hunden Partners and the Department of Research and Development, with the remainder of time for a question -and -answer period. Attached please find the presentation material entitled "County of Hawaii Economic Impact Study on Short Term Vacation Rentals". Hunden Partners would be presenting via Zoom from the Midwest, and therefore I would like to request that said presentation be held at an early morning timeframe to accommodate their efforts. Should you have any questions regarding this request, please do not hesitate to contact me. Thank you. HLK:dbk Att. Hawaii County is an Equal Opportunity Provider and Employer Comm. No. � 00 Ref. To: Ref. Rafe SEP — 5 2025 n r+0 0 0 c l\j (-n CL M z r+ 0 0 0 0 � ' n ...... .... C <� :::T �� Q 0 (D TD O D 1 0 �< 0 v CD Q a' aqa) Ln < O FD n O CL CD O v U') O — Ga O z o CD �D N J D°FD J 0 N rt Q� J WE I Q_QQ7C) < < < CD M���� O -0 O -0 O _0 cn rr ::3)3D�� m m m C'D OQ_ -<CD (D�� CD-O < (D CD O � rn a—' 3_ (D O L n O v � =. — a) � (D cn cn O 1 C J J < i(D N rn(. 0r o� r C 00 CD O o o� �. �C�o n CD 0 C/1 V O �• r J rt (J) O CD 0 < b _� L D b (D CD DO r-t- cn CO --h (D r--5- t E Cn CD (D < CD- —, —, < C)7 CD Dou (D 77- ::E Sr 0 / m \'w = \ § a) 0 7 / = < 2.-•0 L 0 m o J= o 0 oƒ /'� A g o 0 a < 0 o _ 7 J § ° J n _ g J / z = J E'f * U « / �e n 2 a = .5 = '� o (D 0 \ ƒ / \ $ � R ( ° } 2 0® e 2.o c 2/ J/ § 5 » \ 7 � 0 / �CL � V) = ` 2 3 � o ? J n o � Ln ƒ § CD \ I § � o k o / ƒ k n Ln n L 7 e / // ) o m 3= / f L� U ® o f\ �k �\ o °7\�/ J 2 e /(Dd << / Z- /7§ U _ •a j o �_ K 7 m ® $ ƒ/ / < �_ � $ _ � ƒ 9 § L /§- 3 o\ 3 o oƒ ./ / = g ƒR?(Dƒ 7$ ƒ/CT/� CD � 2 ~ z / < ° ` § \ i � \ / GO' _ _ a w O m O• 7 TI N D U) CD V) N C- (D CD U) TJ C (-r N n O C Q (D v n v CT CD n O C CD CAD CD- 0 0 D OQ m M OJ N ■: m A O m O 3 A• n 0 r+ 6 O N v N C O_ CD n r-r v O_ Q. CD n rt n O 6 0 C O_ Z7 N r-r O ZY (D n O C LP - CD n O O O C M0c�< p<3o� a.w 0 -a ' 3 0 � ,< ai v Q� � _. 7 � CD D CD- -< < O CD O n O O -D `2 rt Ci �* N (D 7D � � -O cn r+ !� 3 _ O Q _ rt - O m N CD n -< OC O 3 O N• rr O (D v v C x n • O (D + -: OQ M O „ v O G O Q N Q O r r O CD v C rr 3 S O r r n N CCDD CD CC _• rt OQ 0D p OO a) 0`�r< (D vQN. CD N CD 96) o�� v �<<•� m3 (D — c ao M CAD Z rt O�< X n a O CD p C CC, (Dr-t �. �o�= CDaD�N Q fN1 wO �D cn M r* K v N <. O v CD CD Q N �_ a.) (Drt W -0 UI -, O CD � T (D QQ (D O � 6 D) Ln :p) — n n v n O <= CD C N O t N Q� v n O c O< =3O C O X 0 h Q 0)rt O G. Z 0-* r, U) rr CD < CD O A N 0-� CD r r rt CD O H• �. O CD n o) Z O co C f�D fD 0o a) CD pt� = CD (D< m n CD zT rt O O C C n (�D O O OC °J 3 O A a� =3 0- O O (D O _ O O rt j.(n � � � (A p n< n �0. Cl o O mo n „ C C c: CDO Oq C 06) ,-r � -" n(D ZT M O O N N (D r r CD �-r n fD rt (Dan O = :7 — a CD OJ OCrQ � r* � O C ° C!Q CD n N Q O mQ O n O rr O NO 0 W C.N n Q rt p rV)r On-r �_ H O P (D OOi rt f1 CD n a' V 0� U) CD O 4,1} A O o Q CAD CD r�—r Q. o rt NCD N o an•n :D O < lD O U) (D N r+ _ 3 < �. p C n _ -„ n p 7 K O 'O rD =T C . -p M;n CD O < -~, O n m � 7� � 3 n N CD CD n (D N rt (D O fD O'Q m r+ n v w O OX CD O Q N= O'Q V N 0 3 O 0 a) C p N CIQ � D G n A a ,rt °J �CD D�-� m v n N (D OQ fD a� n NC n_ 11 O rr CD A CD 77 = U' C7-r D (D O Q < 3 O cn � O p -� v O cn cn 0- rr C v n� O G = (D U) (DC CD rr O ID O O O C: CD � < O n. V)N � N M<. C ° v N m C X N CCD N (D Ul Ul N Ln V) K cD 0 a 0 0 00 J 0 w N Lai B B MC a-H O O (IQ a N fD p G) o O Z < < O Vf to V1 � m m = = o O O R ; � 'C Efi 3 O m Ln fD oo O ry N = Nf O N O {� �I N 0 W W 0 N N O (DD m � 0 p0 < W 0 NJmn .o -� c CD ai (p 00 O fD p 00 O n m m _° LAC CD D < ER rr m Ol rNr = 01+ O of . lD W m D v N o to J .. Ln Ln O m r— W m 0 < 0 3 �� (D M v r+ o n �'wl v C7 S rt 0 o` O '_* N un CD D °' ago. N .. W m CD Co C rvr CD rt o p O CD vFT O CD :D _0 O CD N rt 3 o CD CD rt v n fr O C � N v CD -0 CD Q O cn Q m o CD O C 0-0 5. ov O n v aly CD O < E CD N CD 3 o n CD rt N C rt rt CD v cn O � n U � O _ r-r CD my Dv N. v Q N � 3 o rt C'D v� CD v n Co �. N o v n CD T L3 D � N z< D 70 v N D CD Q n O o C N D ( O � C O- n O CD N J eP a m p 0 3 0 H N IV .3_r ol m a ;u Z 3°: �� 0zC �O c 3 mC o N 0 M 0C H < C O C co O '" 3 70� v0+� d� ca+r. m QQ N� o 0 C 3 (D z 3 S U) v m m O c o d N oa �, O O 7 M G °v a o od °^ c. O X -« _« .. m R °a N D < -p N v CD D N rr • � C fl CrQ 0- CTCD CD < _ a) (DC Q CD- 0 O CD v v n V) D N N � � C O CD u) Q V) CD O N C C Q rt C. (DN N =3 N 0 Q N 0 Q D C v O O- h O CD m N � � n 0-0 o �. � O n CD CD � rt v C O CCD O Or-r � CD CD N -0 C n n -< cD Ln- O O n � O N D O CD �• v O O. a � v v v � CD- CD- _0 . -0 o n Ln 0 ul C mn d 7 �* (D ,n o U, 3 o < � v V) ;;a COD v _ 0- CD Q CD O n p rn-r r O :30 3 CAD (D v — � < -O O CD (D n (n n (D (D G C<D cn N 77 (D O O 0 O -0 CD _ CD 0 C v O 7C) G CIQ : CT N <� CD r+ < Q CT N O CD c _ O CD (D Q rt O O O -0 � C O rvr (DD Q ::T CD CD - CD rt = O n CD < CD CD p N n N rF Z v O --h n 77 rD 0 CD 70 CD 0- O N C v � N D D v C CAD N Q _0p O (-r rt O V O CD v fi n < 3 3 v O CD fD OO °< pCT � N o v O rt 0- 0 y C O O �. O CD rr CD CD v r-t- v :3 (D Q v O 00 v CCD O O_ v N (D � CD O n o II O O CD - Oro. = 0Q (-r O N (D D Q 5' 0Q O to N (D N 0 c Q v OC1 (D O I� W C- 3 o' D r-1- O N O O' N n• O N CD CD CD N Q CAD o < O C v (D v v C ri � O .G O VG N CD C v CVD O 4-4 CA) W Ln 3 O o .bfi In I� I� 3 O O CD oa O (D 2 <v n O c v N CD' D r+ D n n O E3 O Q v r=-r O Ln N v X n D U) c (D (D N C ul O v N CD n (D D O_ Ln C CD 0 C Q D O flJ < CD 0 v 0 N v Q r-r 0 Q 00 00 O O O CD CD C v v v CT (D 0 Co CD =5 Un < Cn O- 70 O °J n N 70 D CD o CT � Z D rr 0- D n CD O Q n cn v O. OID Q O CD- (D N O _r rt O C =7' O CCDD O O Q - r-h 0 q Q7 =T (D M CD -(Of, �. �n v CD - CD ((DD rt � my O 7' (D CDN. CAD -0 CnD - (D p CD U) Ln 0 O O =3 3 � Q � v r+ v N 00 (D- (D OQ r�r m CD CD p Q C Q O N � n CD- p (D 3 o CD-Q fi < O {4 F� v Ln W CAD � N _ Ln I Iv W o O N � rt v O' O p zT �. (D N• _ v � n n O 0,0 0 (D Q (D v Q V) F* CD c (D N (D n (D O U (- - O N N C < (D (D CD- V) v (D Q =' V) N Cv v• FIT v Q �) (D rr v (D Q v r-h v O x v r-h (D N O 3. n 0 3 v v (D 0 O v ZT O O O O 0Q' iD CD m A 3 V >y A e-h O N N O 2 !y N O N OQ 0 C Q. w fi !y 7C' fD rt m (A m A fy a On � N �,� Ortm I cn O OU O X (n -h crtn O v O m v O < O rD o N X c (D rr fi 0+ 0 0 (D st r•r 0 p�j Q < O =3 Cp (D N CD ci CD 3 (n 0- of (DD N CD OIt- rt� .n� dq O N CD v rNr O 0 v O O rD O G �Q 3 Ln 0 N 0� O c CAD -1 fr O CD _0 -O N o = 70 O v 3 v (DD °J_ n rr � GQ D o c N 1 10 O (D-,Iv Go Ln Ln � r-r 0 -b4 O Ln -0 LM Ln Q rt O 0 rD 3 O n O v O v c _ rD rr rDCD- m �' Q n O < n c r�D 3 O :3 (D N D wrt r-h v ao GQ D n m Ln N (D� (n O C O 0 Q O 0. a N. O 0 G fi c n rn 'cr rn 3 rr+ o�> � rt O O Q rD n n, rD Ln N C O CD h v N n O N _ CD cn v O i G N (D O rt v O D U0 v X d 3 rD v r, 71z- rt r) O O r� 0 c v c 0- r) O v' r) rD 2 v n 0 un O ;G rD CD c v rn-r O Ln ("1 n c Q W N rN-r v 3ibo3 Q- n 3 Ln0 0O O O V mOOo0) =—IOO v O 0 c c < D cn ArD CD G rD M N r+ � O rD 3 `n N CD Q CAD rt ro c O rr � v 5 m °' x v n 0 v v X a CD C) v 3 m C r<D rl O Oc o O rnr O v rt to N rD Ln N (D c v rt Ln rD cn cn m mo c O r+ c r0+ O Z N 0 3 v rD N (D D 3'0 w o D 5 x � 3 N O � N c � rr-r DD O N O O rn-F• Q m 3' 00 N y (D c 00 rNr rD Ln 3 Ln rD O O c O c �Z '0 O c 3 � O fD � n 0 v r-r r. c ao o=3v c rr o w 0 N 3 4-4 O N c N � 3 C N r c f<D —Di C -1 lD O 3 3• v c � V1 y O O a -a O r � n c ro n O m� fD rn Q c rD Q v � v ��'� OID Q O C c c � O O rt r=r rt � N � Lnm CD 0- o D�CD n Q o 3 c 00 O 0- Ln O N -I N rD 3 v < X n— O D— 7J � (D • O rt v � � CD D CD 3 O'Q• rr In r-h r-r 5. Q 3 0 n rD CD N N. � N r* O N (D CA) O c r Q �G C N• rD O rc_r rt � n � O � N =3 -0 rt O 3 X rD C —(D v � 3 co o u, O O O O rt O r& r1 L•J -oh 0 O O E Ji ew a itl n a = W u) (n N (D v r�r ('D O 6 fD � o 00 N O rt— O D- � p (D C Co O- -A, 0 v n< Oh rDD u rr- 00.) O� O- N o C O rD 10 r in�. n (D C R v_. o <. rD C: _D n N(" r�rOcr (n 7�n "fD (D Zr O N N 6 N =" Q (D O (DN N o O W rDD C a Q 0 n, n 00 < (D (D rtrD3 fD lD '-r O o O O fD (D '0 V) pOq O 3 o � ni Q (D Q = o0 0 < a N N °T a c O`D O 70 N n(D (D N 0_ N < Q (D 0.) Cl)cn (In(D � N o o C 3 lD (D N Ort n rt 0_ o rt v W � rr 7 7 f� C r=r O (D p C� rr Q rr (D O (n (n O (D Q p C Q N �- O (D M. 3 O (D Cr n � C o C Q C mn v 3 (D 'C rt O_ rt < (D � 1 p (D i aq- rt (D O� CD Q M O O r r Q v N (D m (D a) CD rt rr <' O N (nD W C w y for (D fD G (D 'r O O =, Ort N (D -ti (OD (n 0< C _ rt 6 O C p 0 N 3 _ _ °' _� firC -_ y3'0 O�r r Q O (DCD D n D_NCD rD (D(DvnD rr D M r7trt (n (D O (Da � O CD Ln N0Oo0 C pp 0CD C Nr rSrtr O Cv oO ort 00 :3 (D n (n O 'd �onp Orr SO pQ Q. aj --� (rDr v (D v <O0 oD v:3 O m O 3 Q D—p '0Nrr_rr AO p D PC CD v =n °O"p n NO o Qo_N n (D o- Qj�C�p C ND -t-W D Q D (D CD O N (D Q �_ fir (D (D "O Q d (n p- rD � 3 -o_,,, �, Q � ao - M n -a N v o 3 v a w� o o —h'D —I (D rt 3-< v O p N OL� t /) -0 0 r r O(D O O- Q cn 0 0 fD n fi 7 (1 p N v rt N 5' O — (D O pp O n0 3 m Ort v r < �. r�r a ((DD 3 M O (ODD Ln 0- 3 CD Q CD O3 4C rt N (� °' N 0- MS CD r+ rt CD O0 C QQ N O C O `G O -, G (n (D (D Q N N C' O (1 0 < C m w � O D- O� o �' =3 'p (n (D O p_ d a n O 0Q rD n' CD (Oii Z) n O r�•r p n n C -p -, O _G .'o �� � orn< C:� crC O rt O-•Qcn O (D ::3 O (D C O _ rt d O 00 O NaM_(D On fD <' -I m_ O � CD 0 < (D O' Q M(D (D , O �I r r n' (D n < v O ni O 5. (�D (ND -p (D ( OQ :3 O (n r+ � O < o� o-o o no N (DN O ram+ :D � o zT v Nr N c w C CD N v' v o O O" (D p�q (D O N N F-+ t� o L N O O(D Q Q N ° 5' (D � o v o M v CD ° ACD O� N = CD rt rt CD 2 CO 2 n v-, n Cn O rt° N v Q rr -* 3 O-h rt O• p O'o 77 v< v (Dp N. p) N D � — < (nX O rt � �' CD Ln CD (D Oq' D �' 00 < m oa�No rt ° v z (� � c D o o ram- CD CD Q O rOr N CD O d rO-r O h Q (D N N. v v -h O- n m e ) N n o n) O� (D O c n rt 3 c (D C E< O 70 O O p) rt CD - (D (D ccn O n CD r_r cn < CD rt �' QO Q v (D 7 �, COD N O rt cm c Q CD ry N c p v= v CDCD- O CD N n CD CD n O Oc O -hpj O Q Q CD N n N (D �. r-r Q = D o --h p Q ■ . -I N � � Cn N N 0 j (D Q j O r=r 70 N 70 OO O Q O O O O �' LA N n O c CD CD �- CD CD rt CD Q 6 O < < :3 CD N n _0 p (D O 6 C N CA) (D N CD ° r2 O W O' v �• (n1 rt O Ln � n O O �. 00 ° C O c rt O ti, -_ - (D rt N CD r* rr rt O 3 N 7J CD N rt N _rt �' O 7 � N C rt rt rt CD G �O O O N O Q=� < -s O CT O C C G Q 00 N � v mO O z (D N N � < Q N < O N _ (gyp fl- 0-CD W S O OQ cn -. c N rOr N v Q `� Q O (D O -I D CrQ (gyp CD c rt O CND O m -jNQo r-S+ CD N QQ N p� rr CAD Ln CD rt (D N rr C O CD O c � n o- � < -1 O ° O n rt L N r� �0 N N N W � M V) CD 70 n Z v n O r N C OQ N O O v � � Q Q CD QQ n0 � CD 0 O .Qv n C CD Q rt CD r , CT O � � ut rt C v Q CD C(D . rt O v CD O 0 C :3rt (D CD - CD cD CD 0- n0 CD C v 3 = c n' O N CT rt CD n 73 v O L -t- o 0 CD O x CD CD x N Ln CD ]J C � � n Q v n � C O rNr CD C x CD n O o. cOn 0CQ C v G v_ v LD. C � o- W V) 9J C C C CD- Q Z5 C CD C- O O O Q O W (n O Q H � rT n �• fOD fr+D fD Oq O CC G A CC N Q UQ m O M ry+ O � O o� 2 S N (IQ A N O = M < < O C C D'Q to � fD = D) o (A OIQ M= C A fD •C L O m vi N " x O f01 (D• O fD S rr m. < m S < fD fD •p .O O fD N �• a. 5 M O O O m O N* to fD <• B• O m n fD am w aQ3 W (Ao r+m n -a O �. N fD o =r ofu 7 rt r O x O N .O `< V r+ C e-r H 0 2. o CL 7 H r+ N M 'a =r D) rt OQ m O :3� (AU• r+ QO O — N CD W C O rt O (P ff) CD �' v 0 CD C O CD v3 rr v) 3 CD-O O '< CD rt� Z3 N CD- CD C OJ CD- cn CD CD iD n Q N q2. CD- C O CD Cj — v Q p CD N rt G D v (D CD N Q O O- C�D CnD O ) Q < O C CD r* CD n Q C N rt pp <=T cn O D D n N rt N N CD CN. CD-O C 7 rt v O 3< V1 ort v L7.. N flJ V 9Q CAD n G Q C CD rt n C CD N N 6 C O OC p v rCr -d C C Qq CD O v G a O CD- -0 CD v 3 n rt _�, F' o�Q ON Or1 O v n� C r N O rCr pp v O, N n CD C v CD CD OG O O CCDD C rt � rt O p O CD CCDD O o CD (/) n: 3 C v C E C n QQ Q F < � _� < O0 � N N v c O C Q v CD O c v) O- O Co Q N CD O CD N v v CD v CD V) C n CD Q v 0 Q 0 v oQ v Q N O — CD C C C CD OJ v rt C Q -� Q �° v CD ' CD - CT x n cn v n O c rt C CT n 0 O'Q v 3 N Cr 0, C O < C N Q U-) F. O CD CD c D CT 0 fV C rt N CD (T O � n vN g�CD CD v, O °+ CD CD- c vo °Q N C v O (D O CD C Ln CD C 6 OQ CD N rt