HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0286.051 2024-2026From: Jennifer
o
0
Sent: Saturday, November 8, 2025 8:16 PM
—
o
c__«
To: Council Testimony
-fig
Subject: Bill 52 Testimony for Back yard chickens and henneries
W
Aloha,
I am writing to express my strong opposition to Bill52, which proposes restrictions on
backyard chickens
and the sale of free-range eggs in Hawai'i County.
Asa lifelong fisherman and farmer in the Kona community, I believe this bill undermines our
island's food sovereignty and self-sufficiency. The Big Island is not a big city— it is a rural, agricultural
community where raising chickens is away of life for many of us. While I understand concerns in densely
populated neighborhoods, applying a blanket restriction across the entire island is not appropriate.
Those of us with larger lots should not be penalized for responsibly raising chickens.
I am particularly concerned about Regulation 4, which prohibits the sale of hens and eggs. This is a clear
example of government overreach. When hens reach about three years old and their egg production
slows, it is common practice to sell them to others who may want them for low production or for food.
This not only supports sustainability but also ensures the birds go to good homes. While not everyone
sells their eggs, I believe it's unfair to restrict others from doing so, especially during times of egg
shortages when local supply is crucial.
Additionally, Regulation 1 is problematic. It fails to consider the realities of raising chickens in Hawai'i's
hot and humid climate. Traditional enclosed coops can be harmful to the birds. Many of us use open-air
coops or runs with proper fencing and ventilation, which are healthier for the chickens and reduce noise.
Chickens are natural foragers— confining them to small spaces is not only inhumane but also leads to
health issues like mites and disease.
Another big concern is about the proposed rule limiting chicken ownership to two hens per 3,000 square
feet of land. While I understand the intent may be to maintain neighborhood standards and a big
nuisance, this restriction feels unnecessarily strict and out of step with the realities of responsible
backyard hen keeping. I live in an Agricultural 5 zone, but our neighborhood includes lots ranging from
20,000 square feet to as small as 8,000 square feet. Nearly all of us have chickens. We responsibly
house them in shelters at night and allow them to free-range in enclosed yards during the day. They do
not leave our properties or cause issues.
Lastly, regarding the health concerns about selling eggs: I've raised chickens my entire life. If an egg
looks or smells off, we don't eat it— it's that simple. Local eggs are often fresher and healthier than
store-bought ones, with vibrant yolks and better taste. We know how to test them, and we take pride in
sharing or trading our eggs with neighbors. Responsible chicken owners should not be penalized by
overly restrictive blanket rules.
Comm. S
Ref. To:
Ref. Dafe NOV
In conclusion, I urge you to reject Bill52. Let the Big Island remain the Big Island —a place where
sustainable living, community sharing, and food independence are valued. We have far more pressing
issues to address than regulating backyard chickens.
Mahalo for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Jennifer Nobrega