Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0283.991 2024-2026From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Shaula Elder <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:02 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 7:45ah-, By___CL Date JUL 2 ti'��` To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION Comm. No. 2 �� • ` i I Ref. To:— f� uhOA L Ref. Date ` m 1 _. We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Shaula Elder via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Shaula Elder From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Judy Elich <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:53 AM To: Council Testimony coui�TY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED fff IVED Time f BY To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date ��' IJL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Judy Elich via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Judy Elich at jungleiudyhawaii(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Susan Elizabeth <advocate@ ma il.action button.o rg > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:10 AM r<•.:, ­K To: Council Testimony ;:xit _'r ,iAwAZ z Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED me l l `t 4 (Y1 W s te_ JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Susan Elizabeth via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Susan Elizabeth at elizabeth19660)gmait.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sheila Ellman <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:54 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERKCOUNTY Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED OF HAWAI I I RECEIVED Time By By� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sheila Ellman via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sheila Ellman at sellman32(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lauren Enneking <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:13 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By__CA - Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohan.a BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Lauren Ennekingvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lauren Enneking at laurenenneking3Ca)gmail.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Isabella Esteron <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:12 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTX CJXW COUNTY OF HAWAI I RECEIVED Time i u E py Date JUL 2 2 M I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuteana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR {Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage} programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Isabella Esteron via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Isabella Esteron at esteronisabella(cOgmail com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kathleen Estorpe <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:10 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED ,n Time r Aft BY li Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kathleen Estorpe via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kathleen Estorpe From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Teresa Evangelista <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:44 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF xAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED � Time By="- Date #L 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Teresa Evangelista via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Teresa Evangelista at tevanCcbmailfence.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Melinda Evans <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> COUNTY CLERK Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:08 AM' COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I To: Council Testimony -7 A,� RECEIVED n Q 4SO.W1 Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time 1 B l� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Melinda Evans via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Melinda Evans From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Rebekah Evergreen <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> COUNTY CLERK Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:35 AM COUNTY OF HAVAI' I To: Council Testimony RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time By _ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Rebekah Evergreen via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Rebekah Evergreen at bek_evergreen(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Amber F <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:02 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAII I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time_ iNUM By�_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date J 1 L 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support oui-`©hana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Amber F via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Amber F at achiyo22COgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Tee Faasa <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:19 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time �_ gy__ Date. JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Tee Faasa via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Tee Faasa at teefaasa0751 @gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Elizabeth Fahy <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:53 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I �IVEDP Tim By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Elizabeth Fahy via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Elizabeth Fahy at elizabethfahy(a)hotmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Michael Fakhoury <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:45 AM To: Subject: Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI' I i CEIVED Time Al By�_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date AUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Michael Fakhoury via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Michael Fakhoury at mikeykona23Ccbgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Martin Farmilo <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:44 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED �, RECEIVED Time By Date JUL 2 2 20 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support area[ plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Martin Farmilo via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Martin Farmilo at mfarmilo(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Marianne Fellner <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:08 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY RECEIVED WAI I Time 1=499in By -_CA_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date "d. L 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Marianne Fellner via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Marianne Feltner From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Megan Fellows <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:09 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF RAWAI I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time I*qM t1 By__CA__ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL -2 2 2025 Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE if enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Megan Fellows via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Megan Fellows From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Barbara Fernandez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:28 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI � I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time gy_ ro-_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Barbara Fernandez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Barbara Fernandez at barbf5520@bellsouth.net. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Steve Fernandez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:21 AM COUNTY To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK OF HAWAI II Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED f RECEIVED JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Steve Fernandez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Steve Fernandez at stevefernandez(o)hawaii.rr.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Annie Ferren <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:37 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED �'� C EIVED Time By �p Date JUL. 2 2 2u25 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Annie Ferren via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Annie Ferren at aaferrenPgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Debbie Finton <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:43 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF RAWAI' I EIVED Tim Q S BY— _ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I cation you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained byyears of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Debbie Finton via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Debbie Finton at dsfinton(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Amber Fisher <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:58 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY of HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED--IVED Timelol, By_ Date JUL 2 2 LJZJ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Amber Fisher via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Amber Fisher at Amberfisher620CcOgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Karren Fleuret <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:49 AM To: Council Testimony C'JL'N7'Y CI.?RK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY of HAWAI 2 (zvE---UL1-- Time �l1 By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date- 4 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats the only population -control approach that These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Karren Fleuret via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Karren Fleuret at kalena8205()gmail.com. f From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Brenda Flores <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:53 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time j0l4tft By C. _ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL workingtogether to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Brenda Flores via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Brenda Flores at brendaflores35C80gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Rachel Flores <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: To: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:28 AM Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI T I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time f Oq yn By ryQl Q To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Rachel Flores via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Rachel Flores at rachel floresPgmx.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sam Follese <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:26 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLEAR 'Cows or RAXU -I CtZVSD� Tin* mi Dato JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oha a, BEFbRE,pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost sp'ey/neuter.services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Sam Follese via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sam Follese at follesesamCc)yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Simone Fonseca <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:51 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI I RECEIVED Time ByLQ3_"_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Simone Fonseca via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Simone Fonseca at piteu3615(E�gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Caron Ford <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:39 AM couhTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED � 1�cE2B D Time 4 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date 1111 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our.`ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. our `ohana, our cats, and our island This message was sent by Caron Ford via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Caron Ford at caronfordsassyfordC5byahoo.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Margaret Ford <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:48 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time : 3 Q Q}n B To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date =ut 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support area[ plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Margaret Ford via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Margaret Ford at insteps.sliders9k(o)icloud.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Mimi Forsyth <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:08 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI v I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED Time U4_RECEIVED T By C& Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal -Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Mimi Forsyth via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Mimi Forsyth at leolehiwaCa)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Anthony Foster Sent: To: Subject: <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:00 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED C: _?i.JT'Y CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI' I RECEIVED Time 10, 4 W_By�_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Anthony Foster via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Anthony Foster at trf808 mail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Clayton Foster <advocate@ mail.action butto n.org > Sent: To: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:58 AM Council Testimony C1).,,4:Y COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED IVED Time BI' To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date . JUL 2 2 ' 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Clayton Foster via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Clayton Foster at c1foste1 (o)gmail.com. From: Kelly Foster <kIf0003@tigermail.auburn.edu> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:33 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAV I Subject: bill 51 testimony RECEIVE � Time�SQM_ By Date 'JUL 2 2 2025. To Whom It May Concern: I'm a veterinarian living in Kona. As a veterinarian, euthanasia is both the best and worst service I provide. Now as a veterinarian I am able to provide this merciful service legally, efficiently, and ethically. This bill is none of those things. Pigs and chickens are omnivores and can survive from what the land provides , but cats as obligate carnivores can not. Since the county acknowledges that there are cats currently living on county property this bill is a commendable but misguided attempt to save our native species using depopulation. Now, the term depopulation refers to the rapid destruction of a population of animals in response to urgent circumstances with as much consideration given to the welfare of the animals as practicable. Starvation is not rapid or ethical. It is not an accepted method of depopulation according to guidelines published by the American Veterinary Medical Association. It is also illegal accordingto ourvery own animal cruelty laws. Chapter 711of Hawaii Revised Statutes specifically outlines that to intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly starve ANY animal is a misdemeanor offense of cruelty to animals. Knowing cats are currently living and being fed on county property, and knowingthat cats must eat meat to survive, it therefore appears that Bill 51 is guilty of starvingthe cats. The only way it is not starvation is if the county is expecting the cats to find food on their own, which means preying on the native vulnerable species. This would seem to open the county up to many lawsuits, both for violating our own animal cruelty laws and also for further endangering our native species. Besides the questionable legality of the bill, it also will not work. Yes, some of the cats will suffer a slow death by starvation, but we say cats have 9 lives for a reason, they are experts at survival. I have seen so many cats that cling to life for months to years after they should've died, even without medical intervention. This isn't even just my own professional experience, there are plenty of real world examples of cats surviving the unthinkable. One notable example is the dogs and cats of Chernobyl that were left behind without food or water in a deadly radioactive area and yet still survived. They are at the top of the food chain and adapted to live in a variety of climates all over the world. When these cats start getting hungry enough they will find food, and that food will be some of the same endangered species this bill is trying to protect. Yes, In an ideal world this bill would be fine because we shouldn't feed animals on county property, and there shouldn't even be cats allowed outside on an island with so many endangered prey species. But in the real world the cat is already out of the bag. And trust me, there is not an easy way of getting a cat back into a bag without food. For any effective population control of the cats, food is a must. To effectively reduce the population of cats will require a combination of spaying/neutering, rehoming, and euthanasia. None of these things is possible without using traps and you simply can't trap a cat without food. I would support this bill if it included that certified feeders were allowed or at the very least food for trapping purposes is permitted. Without spaying/neutering, the cats who haven't starved wilt continue to reproduce and the next generation of cats will be even more adept at killing native birds. Without a doubt the long term effects of this bill as it is written will be that the cat population will increase and our endangered native species population wilt decline. So, if you would like to guarantee cats start killing native species in record numbers, break our own animal cruelty laws openingthe county to lawsuits, and further divide the impassioned people on both sides of the debate, then 1 pass this bill as is. If however, you would actually like to save our endangered native species, then you will go back to the drawing board. Kelly Foster DVM COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I 000 �CEIVED From: William Keoni Fox <foxw001 @hawaii.rr.com> Date aL 2 2 2025 Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:00 PM To: Council Testimony Subject: Testimony in Opposition to Bill 51, County Council Meeting, 7/23/2025 Please do not criminalize compassion. Empathy and kindness are pillars of our island culture. The people who feed stray and abandoned animals are the salt of the earth. While feeding of animals on County owned/managed properties may be problematic, the Council should consider an alternative option such as building of a cat sanctuary where feral and stray cats can be relocated. The Lanai Cat Sanctuary is an excellent example of a community based project which has addressed that island's feral cat population. The County has recently been contributing monies to non -profits which address the trapping, spaying and neutering. This program is popular but it takes time for these programs to work. While some may consider cats to be an "invasive species", the problem is actually a reflection of our failure as a society to take care of our pets. Many of these animals are abandoned and dumped. Stopping the feeding may escalate predation on native birds as these strays will have no other food source. Mahalo for your consideration Keoni Fox From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kerry Franciscovich <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:06 AM . To: Council Testimony C,'tAR• KwAl , I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED p Time 1 �J'QMA CR To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date J U L 2 2 2025, I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kerry Franciscovich via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kerry Franciscovich at kfranciscovichP[ive.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ron Franich <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:30 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED 1i CEIVED to±`t Time C By� � Date Jill 2 2 202S To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: ,I,, I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Ron Franich via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ron Franich at lronhoover(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Elijah Frank <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> COUNTY CLERK Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:50 AM COUNTY OF HAWAI , I To: Council Testimony RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time BY Date 202 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and alreadyyielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Elijah Frankvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Elijah Frank at i love avoid38C)msn.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kalualani Frank <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:21 AM E r;; c; ;"Y CLERK To: Council Testimony COLMT-Y o- xAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Timed By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kalualani Frankvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kalualani Frank at kalualaniz1 Ccbgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of John Frei <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:32 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time l� °i By Date UL 2 I 2 202E To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohclha BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wild life We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by John Frei via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to John Frei at i.frei hmsa.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jennifer French <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:22 AM To: Council Testimony GvUhI'Y COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time_ By� — Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal. plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Jennifer French via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jennifer French at jennifer81 CcDoutlook.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Tonia Fritz <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:48 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time RECEIVED Vat BY Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Tonia Fritz via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Tonia Fritz at tscfxo gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Carol Froese <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:15 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI, I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By�_ JUL To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one Led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Carol Froese via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Carol Froese at carolfroeseegmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Doug Froese <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:12 AM To: Council Testimony COUN` L CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I RECEIVED Time %:ySgt By A To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Doug Froese via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Doug Froese From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Mariah Fuentes <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:07 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 1 0 Q !0 ByCA9 Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — white protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Mariah Fuentes via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Mariah Fuentes at mariahmariehawaii(o)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Elisabeth Gallant <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:02 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF KAITAI' I t �J�11I RECEIVTD Time `� .Oaq By� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 202S I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support area[ plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'dhana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Elisabeth Gallant via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Elisabeth Gallant at elisabeth.gallant gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Christopher Garcia <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:07 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED 1 RECEIVED Time f 1 %�iUl�l� By � To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025, call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Christopher Garcia via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Christopher Garcia at film209065)mail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Breanna Garner <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:08 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAYAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 11' BY Date I 2 22025 --AIL To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bitl 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana"BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Breanna Garner via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Breanna Garner at the record2(@zoho.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Maile Gatti <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:18 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY HAFIAI' I IVED RECEIVED Time �l� �S0) By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `:Qhana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or tow -cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Maile Gatti via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Maile Gatti at mag_atti14@yahoo.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Catharine Gauthier <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:09 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: CvutvTi CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I RECEIVED Time n �� By Date JUL 2 2 2U I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support area[ plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Catharine Gauthier via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Catharine Gauthier at cgbookgaaL a)gmail com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Carolina Gaviola <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:06 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time_"V&_ BY JUL 2 2 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Carolina Gaviola via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Carolina Gaviola at cmgaviolaCa)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Christine Georgedes <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:24 AM COUNii CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY of HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED f RECEIVED r, Time, l 0 _ BY To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bitl 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Christine Georgedes via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Christine Georgedes at fyi.gigi a gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Aaron Gibb <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:58 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I i S IVE Time 1AP , • By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: 1 Date b �r�_ 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained byyears of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Aaron Gibb via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Aaron Gibb at aaronfgibb(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Anna Gibson <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:14 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time. 2By 2 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing catfeedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our' ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Anna Gibson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Anna Gibson at anna ibson mail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Brenda Gilday <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:24 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED ,p Time 5u1M BY ��` Date J U L 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Brenda Gilday via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Brenda Gilday at brendagilday@wavecable.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Christopher Gilbert <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:30 AM To: Council Testimonyo� Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED k'LIVED Time (Z' � BY Date �- 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Christopher Gilbertvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Christopher Gilbert at campaign view34()zoho.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Aranda Gillum <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:07 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED TimeQ BY Date jut � � �n�c To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: —�� Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: 2 Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Aranda Gillum via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Aranda Gillum at gillumaCc0hawaii.edu. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Richele Ginther <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:25 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI T I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVEDTime () Date 1 'JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bit[ 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Richele Ginther via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Richele Ginther at 1 richelegCcbgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Dennis Glass <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:31 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I CEIVED Time , BY � To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill. 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Dennis Glass via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Dennis Glass at ieang_lass91 (o-)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Rex Goatcher <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:23 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY of HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED Time IQ-:00 RECEIVED rfj Y Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Rex Goatcher via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Rex Goatcher at rex52rix(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Marla Godfrey <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:46 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I EIVED Time By� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date &L 2 2 `,i4J I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal. plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Marla Godfrey via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Marla Godfrey at mbgodfrey57(q-)9mail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Bomnie Gollero <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:36 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAIrAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED ``��tf`{ RECEIVED V Time G((0 ByCAL Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support ou.r `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Bomnie Gollero via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Bomnie Gollero at b2941605(c-ogmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kevin Gomez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:22 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HATAI' I RECEIVED CK Time to By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohan`a BEFORE pets are surrendered: i .p... Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Kevin Gomez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kevin Gomez at kevin.gomez msn.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Liz Gomez <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:17 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CL119 C Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF H44,t , I RECEIVED TimeJJyyli I` � To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025. I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support ouCohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained byyears of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS wa Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Liz Gomez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Liz Gomez at da xboxqueenC�gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Justin Gonzalez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 2:09 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY of xAwAi I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED I TimeBy VED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date 41UL 2 2 2U6 Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats the only population -control approach that These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Justin Gonzalez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Justin Gonzalez at Boogiegonzalez(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Morgan Gonzalez <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:28 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY of HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED C t�RECEIVED Time By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `o.hana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advo cats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Morgan Gonzalez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Morgan Gonzalez at day.becomeCd)gmx.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Tracy Gonzalez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: To: Subject: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:52 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY COUNTY OF Time S IB CLERK HAWAI' I Y �_ t Date 'JUL 2 2 LULU To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Tracy Gonzalez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Tracy Gonzalez at istandexposure aol.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ann Goody <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:08 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time Date SOL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Ann Goody via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ann Goody From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Beverly Gorospe <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:46 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF xAwAV I REIVED Time ! S By� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats the only population -control approach that These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Beverly Gorospe via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Beverly Gorospe at beverlygorospe(@yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sunny Gorg <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:21 AM Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK TO: y COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED S� RECEIVED Time U" By__CD, To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bit[ 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sunny Gorgvia Action Button, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sunny Gorg at solsitasistaCcbmaiLcom. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Barbara Goss <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:58 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED VED Time , EIBy Date AIL 2 2c3 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Barbara Goss via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Barbara Goss at bgoss333C�yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Erica Gould <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:28 AM COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAMAI I i To: Council Testimony RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time_LLMqM_ By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: 2 Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Erica Gould via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Erica Gould at argue_ fan780Ca)mail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Gail Grabowsky <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent• Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:27 AM CouN2r CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAZ'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECE1VID gY_ Time 2 2 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Gail Grabowsky via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Gail Grabowsky at ggrabows(c-Ochaminade.edu. From: advocate@maii-actionbutton.org on behalf of Madison Graca <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:55 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time I VAI-4S4m By�_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Madison Graca via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Madison Graca at madisonkaplan1 Pgmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Millie Grand <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:34 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF '' c IVED Time T "T� Tfk HPI By W JUG. 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Millie Grand via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Millie Grand at mgrand60CE0gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Michael Graves <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:37 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVE Time -2*Q By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Michael Graves via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Michael Graves at gravesmPhotmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Stephen Gray <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:53 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTX CLERIC Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF Rkl*AI' IRECI•±IVED Time—_ BY—_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date_ JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oha.na BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Stephen Gray via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Stephen Gray at gray86(cbzoho.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lisa Green <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:12 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI'IRECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time By� Date JUL 2 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I Callon you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: -Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Lisa Green via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lisa Green at homesbylgC@gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Cynthia Greenlaw <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:44 AM Lhx To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAV I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED CEIVED Time l ' U l By� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Cynthia Greenlaw via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Cynthia Greenlaw at cynthiagreenlam'09mail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Marcia Greer <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:13 AM COUNTY CISM To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HA►TAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time�111 By CA Date JUL 2 Z To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Marcia Greer via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Marcia Greer From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Amanda Gregory <advocate @mail.action button.org > Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:22 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAqrAI'I TimRECEIVtD e_iI Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes —and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families 4 Support dur "A a,na BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL workingtogetherto roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent byAmanda Gregoryvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Amanda Gregory at amanda.gregory(@hotmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of David Gregory <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:16 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF >�ar � I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVZD Time ��(j4� By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: 2 Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by David Gregory via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to David Gregory at d avid pgregory(ilya hoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Laurel Gregory <advocate@ ma il.action butto n.org > COUNTY CLERK Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:06 AM COUNTY OF HAWAI' I To: Council Testimony RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time 7: 45a4K By Co Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Laurel Gregory via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Laurel Gregory From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kenneth Greiff <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:56 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED ` RECEIVED Time 1 BY Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohariO BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kenneth Greiff via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kenneth Greiff at ken hawaii49Ccbgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Patricia Greiff <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:57 AM To: Council Testimony " Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COW* ir%WAI I i Subject: �'j JED /71 Time UL 2 ` 2 2 ZQ'3 - To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date _ Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: 4, Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Patricia Greiff via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Patricia Greiff at pmg12hawaiiCo)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Cynthia Griffin <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAwAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 0'By___(L�_ Date u u 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Cynthia Griffin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Cynthia Griffin at griffinc aol.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Heather Griffin <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:49 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAVAI'I (Y k `CEIVED ��----- Time 1 L_..� 0� By_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our,'o4,na BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Heather Griffin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Heather Griffin at griffinh mail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lauren Griffin <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:12 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time_4aQBy— JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Lauren Griffin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lauren Griffin at laurenbird1970Patt.net. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Nicholas Griffin <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:42 AM COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK SA*i1I' I To: Council Testimony RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time BY JU Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Nicholas Griffin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Nicholas Griffin at cool_ mind640(E�mail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jennifer Grigsby <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:21 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIvBD Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats the only population -control approach that These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jennifer Grigsby via Action Button, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jennifer Grigsby at.4enngbeventsPgmaiL.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lawrence Grippo <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:42 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAVAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time CM By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support area[ plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Lawrence Grippo via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lawrence Grippo at lawrence grippo(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Judy Guajardo <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:23 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAlfAI , I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time CEIVE Jl By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Judy Guajardo via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Judy Guajardo at iud uajardo yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Grehh Gruwell <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:32 AM Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK TO: y COUNTY OF HAJAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time �� By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `q,I�lpna BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Grehh Gruwellvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Grehh Gruwell at starriderhi@hotmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jacqueline Guerrero <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:12 AM To: Council Testimony cou:� rY ct.rkx Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY of NAMAI � I Subject: RECE IVED Time M gy To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025, I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE.pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jacqueline Guerrero via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jacqueline Guerrero at.*ackie.m.guerrero(a)gmaiL.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Valerie H <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:08 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAV I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By QQ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Valerie H via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Valerie H at valerie h(a)msn.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Katarina Haas <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:50 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAV I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED DIVED Time RY Date JUL 2 2 202 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Katarina Haas via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Katarina Haas at bend bun ny@hotmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Robert Hahn <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:51 AM To: Council Testimony Y CLERK C A IN'l Y OF HATIAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED kECEIVED Time�I r I By 6(7 _4 Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council.: - - - I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oh'ana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Robert Hahn via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Robert Hahn at fire1023(o)vahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Susan Hall <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:01 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF RAWAI'I RECEIVED Time i 5g1MBy._ Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Susan Hatt via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Susan Hall at susansez1 Ca gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Debbie Hallmark <advocate@ mail.action butto n.org > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:46 AM COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAVAI ' I To: Council Testimony RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Debbie Hallmark via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Debbie Hallmark at debbie hallmark1960(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Bert Hamersma <advocate @mail.action button.o rg > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:10 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF RAWAI' I ED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED R�E�C�EI By Time_ ud 4 t — Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Bert Hamersma via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Bert Hamersma at ibhphamer gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Janis Hamersma <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:18 AM C01,INTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED �� Time4S1b By Date .IUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Janis Hamersma via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Janis Hamersma at oceanlady1916 gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Christian Hammond <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:23 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECE "E_ Time To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Christian Hammond via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Christian Hammond at girliehammondPatt.net. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lindsey Hancock <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:48 AM COUNTY CLERKCOUNTY To: Council Testimony OF HA11iAI I 2 Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time �`�RECEIVED 11 e0 G AA BY lA� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Lindsey Hancock via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lindsey Hancock at lindse hancock14(iDgmx.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Michele Hancock <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:52 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED � Time � ( ,C /ahn iWL-CP.— To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Michele Hancock via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Michele Hancock at mnhancock1 (a)aol.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kim Hanes <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:41 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time l EIVED .ry-L `` Date y L� tfy To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kim Hanes via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kim Hanes at kimrocky03agmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kathryn Hansen <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:31 AM COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAFIAI ' I To: Council Testimony t CEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time t�"d t BY Date JU 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goat is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Kathryn Hansen via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kathryn Hansen at khansen26(a)outlook.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Annika Hanson <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> C,:.•Jzd b A CLERK Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:19 AM COUNTY OF HAVAI' I To: Council Testimony RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time ® By Date .i n n I)AIC To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Annika Hanson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Annika Hanson at annikahanson84(cOyahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Grant Harada <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:27 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLYOPPOSED ����(Rj�ECEIVED TimeIc By— C,& ... JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause — not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Grant Harada via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Grant Harada at harada971 Cd)9mail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of M Renee Harwood <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:11 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Timef'RECEIB D y 1 ,,,•, Date .IIII 9 9 9A9C To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bitl 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by M Renee Harwood via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to M Renee Harwood at Sarenarenee(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Alyyso Harrell <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:17 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED -14surn Time By_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Alyyso Harrell via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Alyyso Harrell at kawaipunahele143@yahoo.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jason Harris <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:58 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAMAI' I RECEIVED Time ---� gY l� JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `o;ana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advo cats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Jason Harris via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jason Harris at here science(a)aol.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Edwin Hart <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:20 AM C`)T_'r1_1 Y CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time �:�fit By�_ JUL Z 2 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Edwin Hart via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Edwin Hart at stairlifthawaii(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Maria Hart <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:08 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time E JUL 2 2 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Maria Hart via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Maria Hart at hart kristina17Co)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Christopher Harvey <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:38 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF Hk*AI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Christopher Harvey via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Christopher Harvey at christopher66@outlook.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Melissa Harvey <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:20 AM CO!.TPITY CLERK To: Council Testimony CovNTY of HAWAV I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED CEIVED Time _ BY Date_ JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Melissa Harvey via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Melissa Harvey at myoproinstituteC�gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jean Heaps <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:47 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I CEIVED Time 0AV By02, To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date J11L 2 2 202; I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jean Heaps via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jean Heaps at jeanheapsC�comcast.net. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Marguerite Heart <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:02 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY- OF HAWAI Y I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED �. REp1' IVED Time By—— ') To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the HawaiiDate County Council: UL 2 202S I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill. 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. our'ohana, our cats, and our island This message was sent by Marguerite Heart via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Marguerite Heart at margieheart(cbhotmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Susan Hebel <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:57 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time(� j,� ,R�ECEIVED Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 0 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support oUr"'dhana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services "Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Susan Hebel via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Susan Hebel at susanhebel60)gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Patrice Heller <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:05 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Sub 1 Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF H D I RECEIVED Time (M gy To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date Illt 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets —often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Patrice Heller via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Patrice Heller at fpatriceh()icloud.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Michael Henderson <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:34 AM To: Council Testimony CGUNTY CLERKCOUNTY Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED OF RECEIVED FiAFIAI' I Time ����i By Date JUL 2 2 202-5C�_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Michael Henderson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Michael Henderson at michael henderson(c-Ozoho.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Charles Hendrix <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:29 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HA*A1 ' I R RECEIVED Time By 1 -XIV v Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our`toliana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Charles Hendrix via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Charles Hendrix at charles hendrix()yandex.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Andrea Hennings <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:25 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED REC IVED /� �{ Time (04,.� d By lam ' Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Andrea Hennings via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Andrea Hennings at andih27(a)frontier.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jason Hensley <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:30 AM COUNT)( CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAITl Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED ,�_h Time. iU By l"1��---- JUL 2 2 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL workingtogetherto roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jason Hensley via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jason Hensley at hensLey.-'ason(@msn.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Heather Henson <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:45 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAIFAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Z__j�R_ Time �4 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `of apa BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Heather Henson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Heather Henson at policy store@gmaiLcom. From: advocate@rnail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Joel Hernandez <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:04 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' i Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED C IVED Time io"457 By JUL 2 2 M5 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Joel Hernandez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Joel Hernandez at bluesainto3(c-Oyahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Justin Hernandez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:07 AM C'•")'Tt7"'" CLERIC To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAKAV I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEI XD f � Time By JUL 2 2 2025, To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Justin Hernandez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Justin Hernandez at before lover39CcO live. com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Donna Herr <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:04 AM C,vuNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Timer_ BY-CN,_ JUL 2 2 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Donna Herr via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Donna Herr at hrchoices@netzero.net. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Angie Herron <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:25 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time giaU By_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Angie Herron via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Angie Herron at angieherron24(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Misha Hesse <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:03 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time li(, m By_ fA_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support Qur `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Misha Hesse via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Misha Hesse at mishamagpie gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Brittany Higa <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:51 AM ::LY:ZtiC To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED � E EI By Time To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 1 call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Brittany Higa via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Brittany Higa at lonewolfmama91 C@gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Larry Hill <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:21 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED CUUi J l -x HAWAI' I RECEIVED Time '. By—.r— To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Dat* JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Larry Hill via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Larry Hill at hill larry(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jennifer Hinton <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:09 AM To: Council Testimony �:CUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF X44,TiI Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIV%]D 1111� -11BYL<�2 2 20 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: 23, ' I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goat is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana"BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Jennifer Hinton via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jennifer Hinton at ienniferhinton(o)icloud.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Walter Hodges <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:35 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI T I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED CEIVED Time _�( Date JUL 2 2 20 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Walter Hodges via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Walter Hodges at manoa2000C@hotmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Andrew Hoelscher <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:01 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time l L14C;qM By� JUL 2 2 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oh'ana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: 2 Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Andrew Hoelscher via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Andrew Hoelscher at doomaaaa(@gmail.com. From: Iadvocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Annette Hof <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:43 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAVAI'I RECEIVED Time I JUL Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohanaaBEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Annette Hof via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Annette Hof at annette hof hotmail.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Chris Hoffman <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:15 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I RECEIVED Time 1•�t5 qm gy Date JUL 2 2 2125 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal. plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Chris Hoffman via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Chris Hoffman From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of John Hoffman <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:09 AM COUNTX CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HA%rAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time �Dam ]BY (SZ . Date. JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL workingtogether to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by John Hoffman via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to John Hoffman at john.hoffman39(6)icloud.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Karri Hogan <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:07 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time I0�S RECEIVED Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost 'spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: 0) Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Karri Hogan via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Karri Hogan at kshkona(cOgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kristen Hoffman <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:50 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED ` RECEIVED Time 1 ' 0()M BY—Cg_'__ Date _ `1Llt 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by Local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oharia BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Kristen Hoffman via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kristen Hoffman at kristen.hoffman(@live.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Danielle Holland <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:05 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Tim By� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Danielle Holland via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Danielle Holland at divineprotection111 Ca)Gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Dolly Holland <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:50 AM CO U,vTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED � r�CCEIVED � Time I I �� By �. Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oha"na BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Dolly Holland via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Dolly Holland at whereisthelovebep@yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Linnie Holley <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:02 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI, I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED � Time 1,1 4C,(I h BY__Q�__ Date J U L 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Linnie Holley via Action Button, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Linnie Holley at linnieholley12 gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Susan Holzgrove <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:19 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI � I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED a IVED- Time tgl, To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Susan Holzgrove via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Susan Holzgrove at nalaniholzgrove(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Susan Homer <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:57 AM COUNTY CLERIC To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED CEIVED Time_ L B y Y To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date ,n,, I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Susan Homer via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Susan Homer at suesuechef(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Linda Honsberger <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:51 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAV Z Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED REG$IVED Time .um— — (�tT Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawai'i County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Linda Honsberger via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Linda Honsberger at linda.honsberger(cbgmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Haunani Hopkins <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:42 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Subject: Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF / RECEIVED Time__�� HAWAI' I ByCK Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oha'ria BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Haunani Hopkins via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Haunani Hopkins at alohaapp1 Co)gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Heidi Hoover <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:53 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time Y O�KQ'Qia By Ct Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Heidi Hoover via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Heidi Hoover at heidialohaC0vahoo.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of David Horton <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:00 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI , I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED /�RECEIVED Time I J V (,� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by David Horton via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to David Horton at davidhorton(c-Oouttook.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Carol Hosley <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:01 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVEDTime_ By r� Date im 9 9 2025 '1- To Mayor Kin -to Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Carol Hosley via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Carol Hosley at carol hosleyP9mail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Desiree Hough <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:02 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED o` -RA B D� Tim® Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONGH Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Desiree Hough via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Desiree Hough at desireemunoz76(@gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Douglas Howard <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:56 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED �• i� Time �� By (�( To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025- I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes —and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oF,na BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained byyears of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Douglas Howard via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Douglas Howard at douglas howardCcboutlook.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jenny Hreha <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:54 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED ��q, Time iy � To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2125 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jenny Hreha via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jenny Hreha at jenny.hrehaCd)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jaymie Huihuilono <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:06 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time BY_ CJG_____ Date JUL 2 2 2C25 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Jaymie Huihuilono via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jaymie Huihuilono at mssjavm(c)hotmail.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Brent Humble <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:43 AM Council Testimony `_''`'RK COUN';"� HAWAI' I Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: :.QED Time DateJUL 2 21210,25 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families 0 Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Brent Humble via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Brent Humble at kapihanafilmsCcbhotmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Nalani Hunt <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:40 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED EIVED Time ��p B Y JUL 2 2 -p�L�LJ_, 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes —and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained byyears of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Nalani Hunt via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Nalani Hunt at nalanihunt0413009mail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Trinidad Hunt <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:34 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI,I Time EIVED By �*, To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council.: Date JUL 2 2 2G1b I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Trinidad Hunt via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Trinidad Hunt at trinhuntCOmac.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Michele Idemoto <advocate@ mail.action butto n.org > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:05 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF X#AI ' I RECEIVED_ meJ�_ BY JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `whana BEFORE pets are surrendered: a„,: Free or low-cost"spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law °r.%It Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Michele Idemoto via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Michele Idemoto at midemoto(o)yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Doreen (keno <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:54 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I 4IVEDp Time_ By , To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Doreen Ikeno via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Doreen Ikeno at doreeni@hawaiiantel.ne. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Robert Ikeno <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:50 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED IVED Time- ByBp Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: 1 call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Robert Ikeno via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Robert Ikeno at ikenokona()hawaiiantel.net. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Christina loannou <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:14 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HA*AI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED CEIVED � TimeM By 1. N To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL Z 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohane BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Christina loannou via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Christina loannou at christina.ioannouCcOhotmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Julienne Irwin <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:44 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF EIVED a ff HAWAI'I Time,, By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Julienne Irwin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Julienne Irwin at honualoha9(a)email.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Aziani Ismail <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:44 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTX CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY p,F HANAI , i i 001?ICA IVEA Time V(] To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: 4Nr JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Aziani Ismail via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Aziani Ismail at aziani ismailCcbgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Daniel Isner <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:23 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI'IRECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time By__Q� Date JUL 2 2 202� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Daniel Isner via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Daniel Isner at microvitalsolutions(@gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jeffrey Jackson <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:01 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF RAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time j045gm B,_ Date u N 2 2 2526 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bit[ 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our°tih'ana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: 2 Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Jeffrey Jackson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jeffrey Jackson at jeffyjack19 gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Natasha Jacobson <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:29 AM COUNTY CLERK TO: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED =ED Time Ig ff By_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Natasha Jacobson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Natasha Jacobson at natashaj76 yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Dominique Jacot <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:42 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I EIVED Time B z To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Dominique Jacot via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Dominique Jacot at domjacothawaiiPgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Amanda James <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:15 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERZ Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAVIAI I i RECEIVEDQ Time 1+' j��_ y� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill. 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: M 21 Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Amanda James via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Amanda James at amanda james417C@gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ulli James <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:56 AM TO: COUnCI) Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I �IVE� Time gy To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Ulli James via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ulli James at ulli-ames(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sarah James <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:56 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY RECEIVEDAI I Time 39(1 m By._ 1_ : _ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date ,JIJL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oha i,e�,BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sarah James via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sarah James at siames28(a)zoho.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Norma Jessen <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> COUNTY CLERK Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:08 AM COUNTY OF HAWAI' I To: Subject: Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 1''�A5a^ By CA Date JUG. 2 2 2025- To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes —and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Norma Jessen via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Norma Jessen From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jennifer Jeffries <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:33 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date J U L 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Jennifer Jeffries via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jennifer Jeffries at starr6(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Olivia Jensen <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:48 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAV I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time BY� 19;t 2 Date 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohan°a BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wild life We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Olivia Jensen via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Olivia Jensen at bobcat0125Ccb9mail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sabine Jessel <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:21 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time RECEIVED ��``Rx By� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Atameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wild life We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sabine Jessel via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sabine Jesse[ at kolohe1961 65bgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ashley Van Jetzer <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:46 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAV I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED E RE IVED Time W`45( i; Cg� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill. 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Ashley Van Jetzer via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ashley Van Jetzer at ash ley.vanJetzer gmaiLcom. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ashley Jimenez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:37 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI'IRECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Timeq Q M By Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oh`ana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Ashley Jimenez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ashley Jimenez at ashley jimenez98C0msn.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Paul Johner <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:59 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time QLQQ M_ By_ Date JUL 2 2 2125 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION i We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohdna,BEFORE pets are surrendered: ..:4 _ Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL workingtogether to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Paul Johner via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Paul Johner at iot255 hotmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Martin Johns <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> L CLERIC Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:25 AM of HA*AI RECEIVED ,.I, To: Council Testimony I1'3 uk BY (� Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION i We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Martin Johns via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Martin Johns at martin Johns live.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Brandon Johnson <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:29 AM Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: i �RECEIVED Time' By Date JUL 2 2 ;6Q2S&- I I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Brandon Johnson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Brandon Johnson at bjohnsonCa)hotmail.com. From: Cassidy Johnson <cassidyjohnson9800@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 3:19 PM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY Subject: Testimony in support of Bill 51 RECEIVED* AI I Time %J By Aloha Councilmembers! Date All 2 2 2025 My name is Cassidy Johnson, and I've been living on these islands since birth. The passing of this bill is paramount to ensure the survival of endemic species in Hawai`i's forests. It's already well established that feral cat populations on the islands are invasive at a destructive level. However, for a personal account; I grew up in Hahaione valley on the island of Oahu around the 2010's, and recall a large feral cat population near the town homes I stayed at being wholly sustained by a dedicated individual. Being fed so frequently led the cats to congregate near populated areas, frequently rushing into roads or (most often) causing noise disturbances at late hours of the night. I have also witnessed an accumulation of bird carcasses with the presence of feral cats, and I hope I will never witness a native bird killed in this same manner. Hawaii island is home to many more endemic and important species that are beneficial to the ecosystems they live in —this is a delicate issue that will continue to persist even if we eliminate feral cats as a factor. Such species that are currently the most at risk are the iconic Nene birds and our lovable monk seals. The feeding of feral cats accelerates the loss of the rich, biodiverse life of Hawai'i in the areas they're encouraged to flourish. It also does the cats a disservice; enabling and justifying a culture where people allow their own housepets to roam and be killed on the streets, injured by other cats or animals, or prone to spreadable diseases —such as FIV (Feline Immunodeficiency Virus) which is spread via bite wounds from infected cats. Please consider these issues for the preservation of the beautiful wildlife of Hawai'i, so that generations after us can enjoy it too. Mahalo, Cassidy Johnson From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Emery Johnson <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:51 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By__CA2�_ JUL To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date —? 2125 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Emery Johnson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to EmeryJohnson at emeryleigh94 gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kimberleigh Johnson <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:22 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED TimeI u*q yam By al Date 8UL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kimberleigh Johnson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kimberleigh Johnson at Kimmehjohnson(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Landen Johnsom <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: To: Subject: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:19 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAIII CEIVED Time (0`_(� By� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL. 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Landen Johnsom via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Landen Johnsom at landeniscool12C@gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Laura Johnson <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:18 AM CnUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAMI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED CEIV= Time 10`�. M �—` To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Hate .III z— 7q I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or tow-d6st spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Laura Johnson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Laura Johnson at LKJohn827Ccbgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lori Johnson <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:09 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI , I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time �' q �(11A� By Date .II il: 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: ' I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost'spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: z Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Lori Johnson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lori Johnson at lori@rieicom. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Michael Johnson <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:19 AM COUNTS( CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF RAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time I� Ri�7ED >aatA& JUL2 2025 .�.r4YM I Awl gl..ry y.. To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Michael Johnson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Michael Johnson at painting.detait icloud.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Patty Johnson <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:51 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I ii� (r' E I M Time ry J BY To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date—JUL 22 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Patty Johnson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Patty Johnson at joyfu[path aol com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Robin Johnson <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:10 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED TimelySW By_ -CA- To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Robin Johnson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Robin Johnson From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sandra Johnson < advocate @ ma i I.actio n butto n.o rg > Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:56 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COURM CLERK .COUNTr QT HAMAZ'' x olimo U I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana QEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats the only population -control approach that These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: 2 Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sandra Johnson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sandra Johnson at graamboC��ahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sue Johnson Filley <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:45 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time RECEIVED e By_�_ JUG 2 2 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oFiana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sue Johnson Filley via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sue Johnson Filley at.9ohnsonfitteyCa)comcast.net. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Dina Jones <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:42 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I �CEIVED Time �1�VIM By Date— JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Dina Jones via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Dina Jones at dinajones102(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Joyce Jordan <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:24 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 1 0 MUtA By Date 11 it 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Joyce Jordan via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Joyce Jordan at iiordan8080)gmaiLcom. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Biljana Jovanovic <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:10 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI , I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Tim� e By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support ;oL+r `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Biljana Jovanovic via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Biljana Jovanovic at kat-dawg(a)sbcglobal.net. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Rebecca Jowers <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:33 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED EIVED Time_JAS km By_P JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Rebecca Jowers via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Rebecca Jowers at beckoleei1 C80gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Angela Jozsef <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:52 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I VED — r w BY Time �� S �_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one Led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or Low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Angela Jozsef via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Angela Jozsef at agiozsef b9mail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Victoria Juarez <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:36 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAIVaI' I BECEIVED Time 10 445 041 BY- C To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Victoria Juarez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Victoria Juarez at guess apply52@zoho.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Brandi Juario <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:54 AM CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNT-2 OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time j-' VED Il/il gy Date JUL 2 z 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawai'i County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Brandi Juario via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Brandi Juario at bra ndersmaii(c_yahoo.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: Aloha, tiffany kahoonei <tiffanykahoonei@yahoo.com.au> Tuesday, july 22, 2025 12:05 PM COUNTY CLERK Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Bill 51 - STRONG SUPPORT RECEIVED Times Date_�� 202- wasn't going to submit testimony BUT after going to Liliuokalani Park this weekend I feel it's necessary. Friends and I went to the park to take our kids and ourselves to play and use the bathroom since our husbands were fishing at bay front. We parked by the old sumo ring pavilion and as soon as we got out the car, the smell of cat poop was obvious. On the trek to the bathroom, we spotted several cats just under the tree gathered as there were leaves with cat food in them. We also couldn't help but notice the amount of flies.... It was disgusting, not to mention the many piles of old and new poop we had to watch to make sure we or the kids didn't step in. We were going to stay and take the kids walking and the play but decided to leave right after we used the bathroom as we were just turned off by the amount of feral cats and didn't want our kids to step in poop. I'm sure that's not the only park affected by feral animals, cats especially. I will say... the restroom was especially clean and it was the middle of the day and there was also hand soap in the dispenser! !! I'm actually an animal lover but 11000 percent don't think we should be feeding ANY animals in our County parks or properties, controlled or not, not even by "certified feeders" (what is that anyway; who authorizes these certifications?). I've also seen a feral pig jump on someone's truck while we waited at a stop light. The man jumped out and was clearly upset. Seeing that makes me believe that people are probably feeding from their cars as well. It's a safety issue, it's a sanitation issue, it's a health issue due to the diseases that they carry and fleas and ticks, it's also an environmental issue as well especially since some of the feeding going on is next to our beaches, among many other things... Please continue to support and pass Bill 51. Thank you, Tiffany Sent from my iPhone From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Mary Kamanu <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:44 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF RAWAI' I -' �! I� D MP Time By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Mary Kamanu via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Mary Kamanu at marymia117(agmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Frederique Kandel <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:26 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED 'EI�n Time _(&._ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained byyears of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Frederique Kandel via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Frederique Kandel at zebu lona(cbgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Alexandria Kaneta <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:06 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY of WA*AI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVER ro Time iv 3001h By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oha°na°'BEFORE'Pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Alexandria Kaneta via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Alexandria Kaneta at akaneta07@gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kai'ea Kaua <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: To: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:51 AM Council Testimony COIN LY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED jgWEIVED Time BY To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date UL 2 2 2i125 Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kai'ea Kaua via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kai'ea Kaua at kings7queens5(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lisa Kauffman <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:03 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAV I RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Tine (J2 L Q "-- Date 1111 9 `i ini� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana. BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted', Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Lisa Kauffman via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lisa Kauffman at lisak bestfriends.org. 13 From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Shoshana Kaye <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:06 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time �/ RECEIVED �n : Q� Q#. By �++ll Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Shoshana Kaye via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Shoshana Kaye at shoshana kayeCabgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lorelie Kearns <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:24 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED .RECEIVED Time � ' QM ByC_ Date ii,a2 , 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION Wei nviteyou, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Lorelie Kearns via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lorelie Kearns at Ida limotCcZgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Coleen Keelan <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:28 AM COUNTY CT'E',K To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED IVED Time By_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Coleen Keelan via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Coleen Keelan at cocokeekee(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Stephen Keith <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:38 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY 9F HAWAI' I RECEIVED Time 12BY CV, To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 1 call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Stephen Keith via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Stephen Keith at near.event()aol.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ryan Kekuawela <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:50 AM u,.;_.�.Y CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By--civni- To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 9 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Ryan Kekuawela via Action Button, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ryan Kekuawela at kawikskekC��ahoo.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Deborah Kelly <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: To: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:57 AM Council Testimony COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED -���IVED Time q-, By �p To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 ZUZD I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Deborah Kelly via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Deborah Kelly at dekel42(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Taylor Kelley <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:39 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAKAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 1 ������� By_f& JUL 2 2 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Taylor Kelley via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Taylor Kelley at i love last72(a-)me.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Eric Kennedy <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:17 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Tis®_JL: L,0 BY_ JUL 2 2 2025, , To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana,BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Eric Kennedy via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Eric Kennedy at i love time54Ca)zoho.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Cassidy Kentvierra <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:14 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED (� Time_I.C50 An By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Cassidy Kentvierra via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Cassidy Kentvierra From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Hilary King <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:44 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK F I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEiVICD Time _kqff � LQ 'JUL2 2 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Hilary Kingvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Hilary King at hilaryeckC�Gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Shelley Kirkham <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:49 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I ��IVE- Time By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date i. 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Shelley Kirkham via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Shelley Kirkham at flightmedic9174Pyahoo.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Bonnie Klein <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:35 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED ime RECEIVED 4r m W Cb�_ ate JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Bonnie Klein via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Bonnie Klein at stihlrunning(cbgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lisa Knight <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:29 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HANAI' I ^ RECEIVED Time 230 q' BY N To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Lisa Knightvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lisa Knight at knightl(a)yandex.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Tiffany Koch <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:33 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED '7JUC-2 . RECEIVED Time 1AM By Date 2 2� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Tiffany Koch via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Tiffany Koch at kochtiffan (agmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Wesley Kochan <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:49 AM CUiiN' Y CLie:RK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HA*AI t I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED I Time B,,__cg_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our;.`ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or tow -cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Wesley Kochan via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Wesley Kochan at wkochanC�sbcglobal.net. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Joe Kolons <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:01 AM , ,,; , _ l LERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI F I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED r'�,`,RECEIVED Time_ '�yUM__ BY Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION i We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our-'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Joe Kolons via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Joe Kolons at jkotonsCa)yahoo.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Carla Korrick Korrick <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:46 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time tQq- By� JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Carla Korrick Korrick via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Carla Korrick Korrick at leopardlady ct1 (a_)yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jacqueline Krause <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:10 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CIARK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF MAI(MI I I RECEIVED Tine ��'Ofl By__C&_.. . To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oliafta BEFORE pets are surrendered: "'I Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jacqueline Krause via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jacqueline Krause at house.discover()me.com. From Sent: To: Subject: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Becky Kring <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:16 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I RECEIVED Time � m g Date J U 1. 2 22025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Becky Kring via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Becky Kring From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Candice Kraughto <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:36 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HA*AI'I Time I jf RECEIVE � � (,�!j/, By__ ,- -- Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: . 4. Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Candice Kraughto via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Candice Kraughto at candice.kraughtoCa)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Keith Kraughto <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:37 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED 6��"�CEIBD 1O Time— Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oh6na BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained byyears of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Keith Kraughto via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Keith Kraughto at keith kraughto(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Nick Krotov <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:26 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI'I i , RECEIVED Time 4 ,o El iy To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JR 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana.BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: z Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Nick Krotov via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Nick Krotov at nickskrotov@gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Frederick Kruger <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:36 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERKCOUNTY Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED OF HA*AI I I RECEIVED Time t��� ByLCL Date ''JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `Qhana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Frederick Kruger via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Frederick Kruger at fwkruger yahoo.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Anan Kusyk <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:20 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED TimeRECEIVED ��I _ gy =Ite -JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Anan Kusykvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Anan Kusyk at aniamotoxCc�gmail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jennifer Laaback <advocate@ mail.action button.org > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:53 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I w VED Time toBy To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support area[ plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Jennifer Laabackvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jennifer Laaback at j.laaback(a)att.net. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kelley Lacks <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:03 AM Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I RECEIVED Time BY_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal. plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kelley Lacks via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kelley Lacks at klacks hotmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Susan Lambrecht <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:57 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF EI HAWAI' I Time By By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date -JUL 2 2 z�z6 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes —and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Susan Lambrecht via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Susan Lambrecht at susanlambrechtkonaCuOgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Asia Lamela <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:13 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time %:((�(ry� B To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date—JUL 2 2 2025 Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION i We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Asia Lamela via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Asia Lamela From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Marilyn Lamer <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:34 AM CuuN,rY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time U 4 BY To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Marilyn Lamer via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Marilyn Lamer at marilyn.nii gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ann Lang <advocate@ mail.action button.org > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:59 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF IVED Time - W HAWAI' I gy '�p Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Ann Langvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ann Lang at irisheyes789(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lana Langhauser <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:53 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I 10 J EIVED ,,^- Time_By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date 4UL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Lana Langhauser via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lana Langhauser at langhauserlana(c-Oaol.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Rachel Larson <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:11 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAKAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVND Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Rachel Larson via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Rachel Larson at larson.rachelCa)icloud.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jackie Laswell <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:15 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI , I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time (�= By=— Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kimberly Lauko <advocate @ma il.action button.org > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:48 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY of HAWAI Y I s fIV ED j �n Time By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council• Date �L 22 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification toots Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kimberly Lauko via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kimberly Lauko at sonamaldrolma(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Bernard Lautee <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:38 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAT#AI' I RECEIVED Time �� B To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawai i County Council: Date L 2' 2 2UT- JU I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Bernard Lautee via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Bernard Lautee at bernard@none.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Terri Layton <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:14 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAJfAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 3� BY CL 2 2 2�25`- To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii.,. Date JUL County Council: J I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ghana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats the only population -control approach that These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Terri Layton via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Terri Layton at terrilaytonipadCc�gmail com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Tammi Le <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:46 AM CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Sub'ect: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED �r� J Time g�, l.sr, Date JUL 2 2 20 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Tammi Le via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Tammi Le at tmiiwahC0)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Arlene Leas <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:42 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAMAI' I RECEIVED Tiae--- BY To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE, pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Arlene Leas via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Arlene Leas at iamimah7Ccb9mail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Barbara Leutu <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> C0UNT,, Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:55 AM COUNTY oi' i AWAI' I To: Council Testimony RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time By [ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Barbara Leutu via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Barbara Leutu at babytuamafa(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jamie Leblanc <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:38 AM To: Council Testimony LERKCOUNTY OF HAIiAi � I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED t Time By (%� f. To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date a�_ 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Jamie Leblanc via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jamie Leblanc at leblanc.jamie160)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Marcia Ledford <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:57 AM Cu�cv t �i.r 1ZK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RE y_f-i -_ By Tine_-11� S JUL 2 2 2025 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana'BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats the only population -control approach that These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Marcia Ledford via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Marcia Ledford at Mad remarcia313(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Abigail Lee <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:37 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By_&_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oha'na BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Abigail Lee via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Abigail Lee at abigail lee@inbox.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Bryon Lee <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:58 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED -�. 4[ RECE ED Time By� ;�UL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Bryon Lee via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Bryon Lee at bryonlee808(q-)9mail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jean Lee <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:57 AM To: Council Testimony CUUNTI UC HAVAI T I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time JUQJJA By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohan•a BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jean Lee via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jean Lee at tee.jean()icloud.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Terri Lee <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:10 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY of HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time Tqygm By CA Date JUL 9 2 202 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Terri Lee via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Terri Lee From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Troy Lee <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:49 AM TO: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY O IVED AII MByMP Time i To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and alreadyyielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Troy Lee via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Troy Lee at mauidogs2020 9mail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of William Lee <advocate@ mail.action butto n.org > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:52 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY ci,Ei:x COUNTY OF HAWAI`I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED �ECEIVED Tine._1 2-bQA By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2.2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oharia BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by William Lee via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to William Lee at william_lee@live.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Destiny Leier <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 2:07 AM Coral _.h To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED -�IVED �Jp Time By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Destiny Leier via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Destiny Leier at destinysevertO()gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of David Lema <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:00 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED �n` Time RECEIVED � ElyC Date [ 'JUL 2 2 20 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuteana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by David Lema via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to David Lema at Tema david icloud.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Laura Leonberger <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:21 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI , I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED I CEIBy Time-1 l/�C Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Laura Leonberger via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Laura Leonberger at Lauraofhawai0)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lukas Leier <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 2:07 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED j'VED Time fWIBy�_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Lukas Leier via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lukas Leier at leierlukas(E�icloud.com. From: Jordan Lerma <jordan@nene.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:29 AM To: Council Testimony ce;' .� , c r L'W'Ar I z Subject: Testimony Supporting 51 ECEO,rD Time_ 10 4 Jl By - Date �'? IL 2 2 2025 Aloha e Councilmembers, __----__ It has been a difficult but eye-opening few years working on feral animal issues herein Hawaii County. After Queen's Marketplace banned cat feeding in 2023, our organization became theta rget of intense backlash. We have received death threats. My family has been stalked. Strangers have photographed the inside of our car. And almost every day, my wife asks me why I keep doing this, and if it is even worth it. 1 think back to a year ago. My wife was pregnant with our second child. I was out surveying county parks for Nene as part of our research. She could not come along because many of those parks were overrun by feral cat colonies. I think of other expectant mothers, those avoiding public spaces out of fear, and those who might not even know they have been exposed to Toxoplasma gondii, the parasite spread only through cat feces. For pregnant women, toxoplasmosis can cause miscarriages and long-term damage to a developing fetus. For our kupuna, there are studies linking it to cognitive decline and dementia. People claim the risks are low. But the real question is: are we willing to accept those risks, risks to pregnant women, children, and kupuna, just so a handful of people can continue feeding feral animals on public land? have been following the response to Bill 51, including the coordinated opposition from mainland -based cat organizations. It is easy to oppose a bill when you do not live here. But the outcome affects us, the local families who walk these parks, who breathe this air, who raise their kids in these communities. To those opposing this bill, I ask: think about everyone. Think about the family trying to enjoy a picnic. Think about the mother walking at Lili`uokalani Park to manage her blood pressure. Think about the worker who has to clean up cat feces and trash before opening the gates. After Queen's Marketplace ended feeding, DLNR offered land for a potential cat sanctuary to multiple cat organizations. It was a real opportunity to create a dedicated space off public parklands, but no group stepped forward to pursue it. While the larger organizations declined to act, smaller efforts like the Volcano Cat Sanctuary have tried to be part of the solution. Their public fundraising request was less than half of what Aloha Animal Alliance received from County discretionary funds. This comparison matters. Resources have been made available, and alternatives have been proposed. The failure to follow through is not about a lack of options. It is about a lack of accountability. Now there is a call for amendments to explicitly allow TNRM. We participated in good faith with Aloha Animal Alliance on their pilot project, which was partially funded by County Council. We met with them multiple times and even built colony tracking software to support the effort. Despite that investment, they proceeded to request and receive $20,000 in County discretionary funds. We raised serious concerns about releasing cats in protected areas, including the pilot site at Banyan Drive, and flagged the legal risks of violating the Endangered Species Act, Migratory Bird Treaty Act, and HRS Section 195D. To date, no state or federal permits have been obtained, and yet the project continues. TNR has been tried here before. In a 2011 WestHawai`i Todayarticle, Advocats celebrated sterilizing their 10,OOOth feral cat. Despite that milestone, the issues persist. And in 2008, TNR volunteers were honored by the Mayor on Feral Cat Day. People continue to say the County has not supported TNR, but the record tells a different story. TNR may work in very specific, closed systems with controlled populations and low ecological risk, but those conditions do not exist in Hawaii. We all need to accept that and deal with the problem accordingly. When we came to the Council to request speed mitigation in Keaukaha, we brought solutions and funded all the data collection and analysis ourselves. We worked with Public Works, shared our findings, and developed a plan based on local data. The result is speed tables that have reduced both vehicle speeds and Nene mortality, while also making it safer for pedestrians. That is how problems should be solved in this county, not through baseless promises built on data from somewhere else. We are also offering a solution to support tracking and enforcement. We are migrating all of our cat tracking tools from CatMap into a new data product called FeralMap. It will allow anyone with internet access or a smartphone to report feral animal feeding, damage, and related issues. The entire product, including the analytics side, will be 100 percent free and available to the County. We recently worked with the Game Management Advisory Council on a pig tracker that will also be integrated. This will provide a more comprehensive view of the challenges the County faces and help with enforcement if Bill 51 passes. We are committing to fund and support this tool for the next 10 years at no cost to the County. We are also ready to provide training for County Parks and Animal Control staff to help them be part of the solution. We are also not new to enforcement issues. We have filed multiple police and DOCARE reports involving a Hawaii County Council Clerk who continues to feed cats at locations where she was ordered by the court not to, including Lili`uokalani Park. She has also been seen feeding near food establishments. Community policing, combined with FeralMap, will increase accountability for individuals who endanger County assets and protected species. This is not about hate. It is about accountability. It is about restoring public spaces to be safe, clean, and usable for everyone, not managed under the false assumption that what works on the mainland will work in Hawaii. It has not. And we all know that. Those of us in conservation have been accused of hating animals, even though we are working to protect some of the most endangered species in the world. Please pass Bill 51 as written. Mahalo for your time and leadership. Best, Jordan Lerma Executive Director Nene.org From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Rachel Levy <advocate @mail.action butto n.org > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:18 AM : x To: Council Testimony HAWAI I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED r `'D Tim(_ 2 9 20 5 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Rachel Levy via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Rachel Levy at levyrCcbaol.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Tracy Lewis <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:41 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAUAI'I IVED Time q CEBy(:&-- To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohaha BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Tracy Lewis via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Tracy Lewis at tlewis29Cd)me.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jen Liming <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:55 AM 'xAWAI To: �.x Council Testimony COIR4 ; UP I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time Byl_(&___ ��� 2 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date 2Mg I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent byJen Limingvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jen Liming at buddhijen@)9mail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Noelle Lindenmann <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:01 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED i RBCEIB D Time( Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support area[ plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'oha,ma BE -FORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Noelle Lindenmann via Action Button, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Noelle Lindenmann at tallgir0)uw.edu. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Holly Linder <advocate@ mail.action butto n.org > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:33 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time (� gy To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal. plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Holly Linder via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Holly Linder at hollyscbmainmedia.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Vicki Linter <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:00 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 5GM By C,$ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Vicki Linter via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Vicki Linter at vickilinter(cbgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of James Ljunghammar <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:51 AM To: Council Testimony C0u1,1, i LERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Time I V l71 gyD To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by James Ljunghammarvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to James Ljunghammar atJimflJun@)gmaiI..com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Peggy Lloyd <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:41 AM To: Council Testimony (AAA14TY CLFUM Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY of KAWAI' I RECEIVID Time BY `-✓1 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `bft'na BEFORE pets are surrendered: 5 Y, Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordabieveterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Peggy Lloyd via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Peggy Lloyd at pegg cv hlloyd(q)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ana Lopez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:12 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAV I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED � RECEIVED Time V am W a - Date ' 10L 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `,ahana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR {Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage} programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: 2 Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Ana Lopez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ana Lopez at analopez.al535@gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ariya Lorenz <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:32 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Time ' 1JF'1-WA-- By �� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Ariya Lorenz via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ariya Lorenz at ariyalorenzCd)web.de. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lori Lorenzo <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:17 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED , ' 'CEIB y �uEi� Date JUL 2 2 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Lori Lorenzo via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lori Lorenzo at lori lorenzo(a)ymail.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sonia Ludwick <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:32 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Categories: IMPORTANT CEIVED TimeBy__ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sonia Ludwick via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sonia Ludwick at risquechik68()gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Juthaporn Ludwig <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:09 AM To: Council Testimony cour,�a COUNTY OF °��•��=<x HAWAI I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time MUM BY—CAk_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent byJuthaporn Ludwigvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Juthaporn Ludwig From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sabina Ludwig <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:19 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED_ Time By Date JUL 2 2 2125 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sabina Ludwig via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sabina Ludwig at ljgallagher57 gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Cherrish Lumanlan <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:03 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time �:45 a4-, By�_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wild life We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Cherrish Lumanlan via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Cherrish Lumanlan From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Victoria Lynn <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> C�OiJ,;., CLJA. ?, Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:22 AM CO'UN2Y OF xAWAI ' I To: Council Testimony 6 RECEIVED / Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time .,Icon Byi_�A— Date AL 9 2 204 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Victoria Lynn via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Victoria Lynn atvickyrandy@aol.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Eva Lyons <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:56 AM -nUNTr ' cLE'RK To: Council Testimony COUNTY of HAWAI I r Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED EIVED Time By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawai'i County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Eva Lyons via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Eva Lyons at intrepidkitten (ftahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Suzanne Macadam <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:29 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED EIVED Time By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION Ilk We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Suzanne Macadam via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Suzanne Macadam at.suzannedavy(Ayahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Deborah Macdonald <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:05 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time RECEIVED _ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Deborah Macdonald via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Deborah Macdonald at deborahsmacdonald(s))gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Chris Macres <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:54 AM To: Council Testimony Cu11�i: CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I (' EIVED Tim j By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support area[ plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Chris Macres via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Chris Macres at chrismacres@live.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Shani Madl <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:27 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAwAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED :l� Time 1 1 � BY, M To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Shani Madl via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Shani Madl at shanimadlCa)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sophia Madl <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:28 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 104 By_C�g_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sophia Madl via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sophia Madl at sophiamadl2709(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Glenda Magbual <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:10 AM COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI'I To: Council Testimony RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED f ` Time ( Q �t �C�.l0� _ ByC_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Glenda Magbual via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Glenda Magbual at fhdesign85 9mail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of John Magee <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:05 AM COUNTY COUNTY of CLERK ii*#A6I I To: Council Testimony RECEIVSD Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time By.. Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families . ,4 . Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by John Magee via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to John Magee at rm1273(cbvahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Chevelle Mahi <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:44 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI, I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED EIVED Timeio BY JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Chevelle Mahi via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Chevelle Mahi at ccl.mahiCg)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jennifer Mahone <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:23 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAVAI'I CEIVED TimeIA-A By Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or tow -cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jennifer Mahone via Action Button, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jennifer Mahone at 1-enocean@gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ruby Manantan <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:40 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time Z` VV BY(A To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana�BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Ruby Manantan via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ruby Manantan at mrubynorberte(a)aol.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Tina Mangrum <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:27 AM To: Council Testimony C t�rJ i t �� HAwAI I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 10 By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 1 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Tina Mangrum via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Tina Mangrum at trm1964()comcast.net. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sierra Manker <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:46 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF RAKAI'I RECEIVED Time 1 1' Wqm gy�_ Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `bh'ana BEFORE pets are surrendered: 9 Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sierra Manker via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sierra Manker at sierrabmanker()gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kelly Manning <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:37 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I CEIVED �P Time �� B Y To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kelly Manningvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kelly Manning at kellymanning808 icloud.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Gerdine Markus <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:56 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAII� I I ED B tYY� Time i y To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date jUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Gerdine Markus via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Gerdine Markus at gerdine888(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Janet Marlette <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:43 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED �OF � -��`�v'�IVED ,,n Time By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Janet Marlette via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Janet Marlette at simarletteCcbgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of David Marshall <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:20 AM ;r•.r To: Council Testimony t; t HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time tMa By _ Date 1111 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by David Marshall via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to David Marshall at most6115Pgmx.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Joshua Mack <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:29 AM To: Council Testimony cots«'� c;� htiKAr z C Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time 2CEIVED �� � � By Date JU 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low=cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community ►TiT/=1IF-Al 611oil go] :7-Alto] :/_a:J•_16y�016Y0]goII[*104 Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this— but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Joshua Mackvia ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Joshua Mack at mackj(c-ohotmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jordan Marshall <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:39 AM VL&hK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI T I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED j +'' I RECEIVED�`,� Time I d y� o m gY ____. Datefllll 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jordan Marshall via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jordan Marshall at marshall.jordan icloud.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Charles Martin <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:24 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF R&W' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVID Time 11'' gy JUL 2- __Q- 2 2 uG5 Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `b-Ka'na BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Charles Martin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Charles Martin at various set57C�icloud.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Emily Martin <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:23 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI T I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED TimeRECEIVED Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Emily Martin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Emily Martin at emilymartinCa)me.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kathleen Martin <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:02 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAVAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED p Time 1 I M(1� By Ca JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Kathleen Martin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kathleen Martin at fourmooskmCcbvahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Stacy Martin <advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:40 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Subject: Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF �(j EIVED Time . �K! HAWAI' I By �� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Stacy Martin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Stacy Martin at stacymartin12SPgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Vandy Martin <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:23 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time RECEIVED BY Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Vandy Martin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Vandy Martin at vandymartin(a)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jack Martinez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:20 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAXAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time ei-�ogm By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 � call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support ou.r.`ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wild life We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jack Martinez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jack Martinez at.umartinezPmsn.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kelly Martinez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:30 AM To: Council Testimony CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I RECEIVED Time ByLC� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: 2 Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kelly Martinez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kelly Martinez at kellymartinez(Aouttook.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Mary Martinez <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:37 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HANAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time lU By�i e • Date�UC To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Mary Martinez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Mary Martinez at mmartinez73C-Ozoho.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Naomi Martinez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:39 AM c^' NT'1 CLERK To•• Council Testimony Cou14 i t of xAWA2 I z J Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED �S EIBy Subject: Tim11, By� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Naomi Martinez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Naomi Martinez at naomikeilani12(o)gmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Priscilla Maratta <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:18 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAV I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time u - i W (d By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our�'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Priscilla Maratta via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Priscilla Maratta at prinagao hawaii.rr.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Laura Saint Martin <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:05 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI RECEIVED Time ImsmBy To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support o,ur `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Laura Saint Martin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Laura Saint Martin at two socksPhotmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Mandy Martinez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:29 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED ' p1t AEIVED Time 10'A By _ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 215 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bit[ 51. MayorAtameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Mandy Martinez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Mandy Martinez at professor. have(g)msn com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Mary Martinez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:37 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HA*�I' I RECEIVED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained byyears of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Mary Martinez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Mary Martinez at mmartinez73Ccbzoho.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sam Marzan <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:16 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 1 Ayarn BY Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill. 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sam Marzan via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sam Marzan at marzansCcbyrahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sandra Matoi <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:39 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAVAI'I RECEIVED � ) To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the HawaiiTime County Council.: UL 2 2 gyL Date2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sandra Matoi via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sandra Matoi at Beehere1 CcOgmaiLcom. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Angela Matthews <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:06 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Subject: Council Testimony Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAV I REyEIVED Time IO4S Q I BYCA�,P To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2125 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Angela Matthews via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Angela Matthews at anmatth77Ccogmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Riaan Mattheus <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:43 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HARAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time � B2 JUL 2 202_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wild life We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Riaan Mattheus via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Riaan Mattheus at hawaiibigisland1969(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of John Matthews <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:40 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED ) RECEIVE Time 1 By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by John Matthews via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to John Matthews at matthewsj(cbvahoo.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of N.e. Mattice <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> COUNTY CLERK Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:07 AM COUNTY OF HAWAI'IRECEIVED To: Council Testimony Time 7; Q-�p,m g�, Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION i We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by N.e. Mattice via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to N.e. Mattice From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Lori Mattos <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:25 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED d� RECEIVED Time V� gy Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ofiana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Lori Mattos via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Lori Mattos at dshin95480Ca)aol.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Cindy Massey <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:28 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF tiAUiAI � I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED k�ECEIVED Time_' M By , JUL 2 2 202�— Date To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wild life We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Cindy Massey via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Cindy Massey at factor lover25Ca)zoho.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jennifer Mavilia <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:45 AM Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: r�fEIVED Time �v BY Date JUL 2 2 2 C 2 5 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jennifer Mavilia via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jennifer Mavilia at ileemavilia(a?yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Dana May <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:26 AM To: Council TestimonyCOUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAZ ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED li RECEIVED Time ..� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Dana May via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Dana May at dana(80may808.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Susan Mayberry <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:47 AM covr7TY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI1 I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED IVED Timer BY� JUL ,. r To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Susan Mayberry via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Susan Mayberry at smayberry550 gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Anne Mayeres < advocate @ ma i I.actio n butto n.o rg > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:46 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY cI,rgrj�X Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF V4&Z r Tine t,G� 2 RECICI y' Date- L �— To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: v2 ) 20?5__�Z, , . I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support ourohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter "services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Anne Mayeres via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Anne Mayeres at annekemiekeCEDgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Bri Mayo <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 2:08 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERKCOUNTY Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED OF HAWAI , I fi:UIVED Time By--�+F--- To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: HateUL 2 _2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Bri Mayo via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Bri Mayo at yaamieee(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Matthew Mccoy <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:12 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAYAI I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time Nq'�G0 BY_ Q,, To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our,`.ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Matthew Mccoy via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Matthew Mccoy at matthew mccoy(cbinbox.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kathleen Mcdade <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:05 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CIAIRx Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF Ri1WA.1 , I �� RECEIVED Tian _t3 BY To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem —it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wild life We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kathleen Mcdade via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kathleen Mcdade at wickedwitchmcCo)aol.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kaitlyn Mcdonald <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:30 AM C CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY of HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED Time I � . t RE CEIVED SQP� By Date � ��. ? � 2nx To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: 2`i I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL workingtogether to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Kaitlyn Mcdonald via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kaitlyn Mcdonald at kmcdonald(&hotmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Rosemary Mcdonough <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:04 AM COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I To: Council Testimony RECEIVED Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time If :4J5avA By - Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Rosemary Mcdonough via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Rosemary Mcdonough at rosegardens53(@gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jenny Mcgreevy <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:23 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY cIARK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF X4#j11 I CE I`�D Tiee__l 3_0 By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `oha'h`a BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE L nacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Jenny Mcgreevy via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jenny Mcgreevy at jennymcgreev r�outlook.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Daniel Mckee <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:24 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OFRECEID*AI , I Time G� 0 BY-6-91, To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL ? 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Daniel Mckee via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please replyto Daniel Mckee at trip_ believe47Ccbzoho.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kait Mckee <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:14 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAIVAI'I RECEIVED Time I. ( By--=g-- To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I �� Y I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: . . Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Kait Mckee via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kait Mckee at kaitmarymckeeC�gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sandy Mcleod <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:50 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED IVED Time . S BY �_ °� � ° ` i y25 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date �L �' 2 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sandy Mcleod via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sandy Mcleod at sandyt2u@yahoo.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Robert Mcmillan <advocate@ mail.action button.o rg > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:33 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI'I Time RECEIVED- �=1--�--- �gl � To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date ft II 9 9 0 Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Robert Mcmillan via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Robert Mcmillan at robert.mcmillanCabgmx.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Paige Mcmullin <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:18 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI'I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time & OYU g M Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Paige Mcmullin via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Paige Mcmullin at leilani128CcOhotmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Leslie Meacham <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:46 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I k IVE�h Time By —W To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii; Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Leslie Meacham via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Leslie Meacham at kamakani2013Ccbgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Alexis Mekalonis <advocate@maii.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:06 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time ®° BY Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Alexis Mekalonis via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Alexis Mekalonis at cats1484mCEbgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Donna Mello <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:45 AM C� _`NTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COU14TY OF HAWAi' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RE EIVED Time ,j Date_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Donna Mello via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Donna Mello at muttlee55()yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Gunner Mench <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:53 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK COUNTY I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED EIVEDAI' • Time f BZ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUC2, 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and alreadyyielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Gunner Mench via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Gunner Mench at gunner harborgallery.biz. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Susan Menton <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:09 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED _RECEIVED Time By� Date_ Jilt 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. 1 THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support ou°r `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Susan Menton via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Susan Menton at konamenton(cbgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Mikela Mercier <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:47 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED ii RECEIVED Time I� By_� Date'JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohtffia BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Mikela Mercier via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Mikela Mercier at mikelamercier1 C(Igmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Amber Metcalf <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:47 AM To: Council Testimony Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY COUNTY OF CLERK HAWAI' I EIVED Time By M . To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date '� WUL 2 2 - I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Amber Metcalf via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Amber Metcalf at ambermetcalf(o)msn.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Michelle22@mail.com Shelton <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:21 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED /� Cq Time S (� By t Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or -low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering — for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Michelle22@mail.com Shelton via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Michelle22@mail.com Shelton at vnefna2902ayahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Sara Miki <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:02 AM To: Council Testimony �:uu=• � . _i,hRFC Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI , I t�' -RECEIVED Time 10' S BY -- �)UL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Sara Miki via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Sara Miki at cocokittieee(o)gmail.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Brian Miles <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:32 AM Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HANAI I To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: RECEIVED Time V M By CQ Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill. 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our 'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Brian Miles via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Brian Miles at scene lover11 @zoho.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jenny Miller <advocate@ mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:22 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI' I RECEIVED Time BY!_Cg, To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one Led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Jenny Miller via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jenny Miller at jennymiller14Cclicloud.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Linda Miller <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:01 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVE Time �(C ' By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support oitr `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Linda Miller via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Linda Miller at my1977vetteCc-Ogmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Rebecca Miller <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:54 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY of HAWAI' I r IIED Time J BY *_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 2 202a I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Rebecca Miller via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Rebecca Miller at rebeccamiller559(a)yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Amanda Milliron <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:52 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED Time A 1 CEI�� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Icall on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Amanda Milliron via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Amanda Milliron at Lovinarlee@gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of John Minton <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:19 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED Time �� ( IB D r� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by John Minton via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to John Minton at.ibm into n20030)yahoo.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Maria Miranda Miranda <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:48 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF HAWAI'I /� RECEIVED Time �l� ySa By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date_ JUL 2 2 2025 call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Maria Miranda Miranda via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Maria Miranda Miranda at tatita6365baol.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Ayaka Mitchell <advocate@maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:41 AM COUNTY CLERIC To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAITAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED 'r Time ` S (aA By JUL 2 2 2025— To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feedingwon't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan— one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize.and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Ayaka Mitchell via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Ayaka Mitchell at obraykCcbyahoo co jp. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Shelby Mitchell <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:20 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAwAI1I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date_ _11JL2 9JM I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support oux `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Shelby Mitchell via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Shelby Mitchell at gvatioxjgc4897 gmx.com. From: advocate@maii.actionbutton.org on behalf of Valerie Mitchell <advocate@ mail.action butto n.org > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:41 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAVAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time 1' 0 14fiahl BY� Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes— and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana.BEFORE pets are surrendered: J Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawaii, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Valerie Mitchell via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Valerie Mitchell at lilbitval19830)hotmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Diana Mitzel <advocate@ ma il.action button.o rg > Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:19 AM Cc : "Y ,F>x To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 -STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By Date nu 9 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Diana Mitzel via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Diana Mitzel at shastadawg01 netscape.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Diana Mojica <advocate@ maiLactionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:49 AM To: Council Testimony c'oul" 4, vvA2' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED �CL- ✓ED Time DIY i BY Date JUL To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Diana Mojica via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Diana Mojica at crazyasshen86Cc1hotmail.com. From: Sent: To: Subject: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Carmen Montano <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:04 AM COUNTY CLERK Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawai'i County Council: Time l By _ Date JUL 2 2 2025 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION 1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Carmen Montano via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Carmen Montano at montanocarmen923(cbyahoo com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Jennie Montano <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 12:24 AM x To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED 1s RECEIVED Time By Date JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs and join us in supporting humane, When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance one led by local organizations, volunteers, and PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Jennie Montano via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Jennie Montano at montanojennie(g)gmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Gellen Montes <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 9:56 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By_� JUL 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers — what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned — and we need to fix the broken system behind it. �l�l:Z►Y�l��j1[�l�ilr\�itL�>s�:tili+[t7��7e[��[�7�1 We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Gellen Montes via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Gellen Montes at gmontes8486CcOgmail.com. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Rayna Montez <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:48 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLERK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF A- HAWAI' I BTime Lw_ To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 r zV; 5 I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us— our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Rayna Montez via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Rayna Montez at rayna.montezCcOgmail.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Tisha Montoya <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:09 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI I I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By—� Date jUL 2 9 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, Leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island Less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct— and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or tow -cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results here on our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Tisha Montoya via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Tisha Montoya at mirahloveCa)hotmail.com. From: Ijmoorel @hawaiiantel.net COUNTY CLERIC Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 2:57 PM COUNTY OF HAWAI' I RECEIVED � To: Council Testimony Time Subject: To Whom it May Concern Date 2 I would like to say that I am emphatically opposed to Bill 51. Criminalizing people who feed feral and abandoned cats is not an effective means to control the problem. Managing these animals with a well supported spay and neuter program would humanely control and reduce populations. Starvation only leads to sick and diseased animals that can still breed. There is an untapped resource of concerned citizens out there, myself included, whose expertise and dedication could be utilized by the government. Provide accessible and affordable spay and neuter clinics, and the same people you want to fine would be volunteering to trap and transport. We're already doing it, at our own expense. What we are able to do on our own is a drop in the bucket compared to what could be achieved if the government chose to support us rather than hinder. Change the hostile attitude toward animal feeders, and see what could be accomplished together! Sincerely, Linda Moore From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Nan Morelli -white <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:24 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI ' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED I C 3�RECEIVED Time �" By Date till 2 2 2025 To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct — and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause— not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Nan Morelli -white via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Nan Morelli -white at drnanwCcOearthlink.net. From: advocate@mail.actionbutton.org on behalf of Christopher Morgan <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:21 AM COUNTY CLERK To: Council Testimony COUNTY OF HAWAI' I Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED RECEIVED Time By (J� To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date— � � I call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets — often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support a real plan — one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our'ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordable veterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size over time — while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our'ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawai'i Island. This message was sent by Christopher Morgan via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Christopher Morgan at christopher52COinbox.com. From: advocate@maiI.actionbutton.org on behalf of Kevin Morgan <advocate@mail.actionbutton.org> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 11:17 AM To: Council Testimony COUNTY CLXRK Subject: Bill 51 - STRONGLY OPPOSED COUNTY OF X4A1 , I RECEIVSB Time_ By�. To Mayor Kimo Alameda and the Hawaii County Council: Date JUL 2 _ 2 2025 call on you to REJECT BILL 51 in its current form and instead take action that reflects our island's values of compassion, community, and kuleana. BILL 51 GETS IT WRONG!! Criminalizing cat feeding won't solve the problem — it amplifies it: Starving cats doesn't make them vanish; it drives them into sensitive ecosystems, increases disease, leads to more kittens, and intensifies community conflict. This approach punishes caregivers instead of addressing underlying causes — and it makes our island less humane. We understand the goal is to protect native wildlife. But Bill 51 ignores both the root causes and the real solutions. We urge you, Mayor Alameda, to course -correct —and join us in supporting humane, effective, and proven strategies. THE REALITY ON THE GROUND Families across our island face: Spay/neuter costs they can't afford Veterinary care that's out of reach Pet -averse rentals, forcing people to give up animals Trying To Feed their pets despite rising living costs When families surrender pets— often dumped at transfer stations, parks, or shopping centers —what emerges is labeled "community cats." These cats aren't feral monsters —they're lost, dumped, or abandoned —and we need to fix the broken system behind it. OUR SOLUTION: TWO -PRONGED ACTION We invite you, Mayor Alameda, to support areal plan —one led by local organizations, volunteers, and residents already making progress: PRONG ONE: Keep Cats with Their Families Support our `ohana BEFORE pets are surrendered: Free or low-cost spay/neuter services Affordableveterinary and wellness clinics Protections for renters with pets Emergency pet food assistance PRONG TWO: Effectively Manage Community Cat Populations Deploy proven, humane methods to stabilize and reduce colonies: TNVR (Trap -Neuter -Vaccinate -Return -Manage) programs —the only population -control approach that works. Adoption programs for sociable or friendly cats Certified colony caretakers, with: Monitoring and identification tools Wildlife -safe, posted feeding stations Management and conservation training Strategic relocation from sensitive environments Networks of fosters and sanctuaries to rehome cats These approaches tackle the cause —not just symptoms. They're backed by data, used nationwide, and already yielding results hereon our island. WHY BILL 51 WILL BACKFIRE If enacted, Bill 51 will: Drive compassionate caretakers underground Increase dumping of unwanted pets Undermine trust and momentum gained by years of volunteer efforts Waste County resources enforcing an unenforceable law Ultimately produce more suffering —for cats, wildlife, and our community WE STAND FOR ALOHA -BASED SOLUTIONS Rather than criminalize care, let's uplift the work already underway by the following organizations: AdvoCATS, Aloha Animal Alliance, Advocats Hawaii, Action 4 Animals Hawaii, CatSnip, Feed the Kitty, Good Karma Spay & Neuter, Jungle Cat Ladies Sanctuary, Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana, KARES Hawai'i, Rainbow Friends, Volcano Cat Sanctuary, and others — ALL working together to roll out these humane solutions across the island. SIGN THE PETITION —AND JOIN THE MOVEMENT Together we can: Stop the cycle of abandonment Keep families and pets united Reduce cat colony size overtime —while protecting wildlife We can solve this — but not with Bill 51. Mayor Alameda, we urge you: reject this bill and stand with us — our `ohana, our cats, and our island values. With aloha, Your fellow resident of Hawaii Island. This message was sent by Kevin Morgan via ActionButton, on behalf of Kahu Popoki - Care For Our Cat Ohana. Please reply to Kevin Morgan at kmorgan64Co)msn.com.