HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0121.000 2002-2004 ++ax
Harry I{im ~ Lincoln S.T. Ashida
Mayar Girporafion Counsel
" Ferald Takase
oM .w
~ or M~- Ae'.vfrtav Corporation Coimael
ft~aixn#g of ~.ttfutttt
OFFICE OF THF, CORPORATION COUNSEL
101 Aupuni Street, Suite 325 • Hilo, Hawaii 95720-1262 • (808) 961-8251 • FAX (80R) 961-8622
January 28, 2003 '
The Honorable James Arakaki, Chariman
and Members, Hawaii County Council
25 Aupuni Street
Hilo, Hawaii 96720
Dear Chairman and Members:
Re: Second Quarter Report -Claims/Cases
(October -December 2002) FY 2002-03
The following is the quarterly report for the Second Quarter of Fiscal Year 2002-
2003 of claims generally not involving or requiring payments in excess of $1,500:
First, ten (10) general liability claims were disposed, resolved or settled for the
sum of $2,687.31. See Exhibit "A," Closed Cases, General Liability.
Second, two (2) vehicular collisions claims were closed. One claim was settled
for the sum of $9,762.26 (On July 31, 2002, County Council approved settlement on the
claim involving Michael Laimana). The County recovered $6,543.00 on account of
damages to a County vehicle. See Exhibit "B," Closed Cases, County Vehicle/No Fault
Claims Report.
Third, the County had no action for non-vehicular and non-tort claims.
Fourth, the County had no recovery on a collection case.
And last, one litigation case was settled by the County for $1,500.
We further enclose a "Key to Abbreviations" as Exhibit "D."
Comm. No,
File No. CO
Ref. To:
Ref. Date_~~,Q~
Chairman James Arakaki and Council Members
January 28, 2003
Page 2
This report is being submitted pursuant to Section 2-9 of the Hawaii County
Code.
Sincerely,
i
` _ v .
Joseph K.Kamelamela
Deputy Corporation Counsel
Litigation Division Head
JKK:ch
Enclosures
s:claims\2003 rpts\Itr council\1-28-03\JKKch.wpd
A w N #
A
O O N O O ~
~ ~D ~ to Oo N O Ls
A
0 0 0 0 o a~
w ~ w n n~
O~ W ~ N In ~ ~ ~
h ^
w 0 O 0 0 b O~ O to ~
m lD A N
Nao oao oa.o Sao ~
o~~ ~ x~ o u o u
~ ~ ~
R= -fie C
~ ~ ~
~ d
w w
w N
O p p
N O\
O
5 d nr~ ~ 5 9~ sxo`m w C~ v,r< *~r~nG) O
~ ~ w O ~ ~ ~ ~ 5 ~ ~ n o ° ~ .'p ~ ° o ~ H C
~ .'t7 y m w~ b N <0 0 o P. » O" m E O m 2
~ w w w~ c o C A O ~O
opo ~ o O m ~~'a'~D».ti w ~ ~ w `=0 la"H~~[~:7 = [G~
m R,aO`C 'o rn ~ .J~ o o rn an o nm~. v~ ~Ci7
~m ~ v~'7.7 < ~ ~ no w ~ o w c~~~ a~ d p ~Cyrl~iyr.
7
M ~ ~ ~ o o0=dv~
N ~ v ~
~ 3
O
E» w En sz
J ~
~ N H
o° 0 0 0 O '-3 Y
0 0 0 0 ~ o N
0 0 0 o d, o
0 0 0 0 :-n
G1
~ ~ > ~ o
N in ~ b 9 - y
0 0
0 0
a~ t-'N
°o °o ° ~ N
a.
~ a ,o
o;
AT
o. a
C7
w n w .d ~ m t~j" rn d m
~ ~ ~ G. m r'n'
dC1 n:~ an ~ ~ q ~ y,
O, m N O U m~ ~ O~~ ~ b
fC
a 5 0° o rn a a ~ z °a o
00 ~ °o o, o e
3
q ~O Oo J O~ to ~
N
}
A
0 o O o o O ~
~ O O A W W y w
0 0 0 0 0 o a~
N N N N N
b
ti n n A n n w n C7 p n n A n n W
O W O ~p W O rJ W O r w 0
~ Vi VI N l/~ 01 U Va l/i U O ON
~ d 0 pNp P. O ~ a O W a 0 N a O A
O 2[ N O 4i O 3k'-' O 4t O ~ 7t
~ v ~ ~ .N
r
m
Q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
7
0
O N m d
w 00 N O A
o O O ~ O O
N N
Q
r
n,
° O"~ E o E S~T.ot^ c ~t'trJ C~C'CO am^CC !~r'C)
B. n O a' ry ps, U m rn w o~ ~ ~ o O B w° ~ m~~ ° .T,
d "'3 ^3 ~ co ~ ~ <o d G1 ti F w m y '~zz c ~n~, w O
a ~ Ca" ~ ~ a° T x ~ y' aao oao E ~ ~ x ~ ~ a ~ d Z C ~ ~ ~ ~ cn
~ ~ a o' o y . w w~ C C ~ O w p m m
00 ~ c (fin a'~ coo y .ate-,~C) ~q w ~ .w~-n.. ~'~t"~_ fD m ~eT' w
N _
N d o w, a ~G w rv w 'ti ~ o b w~ oho ~ d tn" n w. a m
~ pO,, ~ ^ 0 0 ~ ~ O 0. 0 a 0 VJ o• E ry y~ ~ ~ O O
00
O W a y Q' ry O N Q ~ O a a~ la a P. A. ~ C. C
" ~ ~ R° a ~ °p o
w -n
d d ~ C7 ~ ~e m
a 3
A
vi bs vs va c,s Ea
00 ~
~ ~ ~
N J N O v~ O ~
O O O O O O ry
O O O O O O
O O O O O O
69 69
'ti 3
~ ~ °o o
i.+ ~ o a e
o
~ y
g3
< o
m e
,e
A
a
z z
d o o y
~
~ `0 ~ 'rl a. w ~ w w
a d a. d ~3 0~ '3 a ~3 'o'
d
3
O ik
a
A
no
~ J y m
O R ~
a
0
W J
n
to A
~ ~ _
v W ~ ~
O O #
7 ~
C]
~ dC d
~ G ~
~ V1 w
0
o ~
~ O
i~ r
0
c
C
o zy ~ ~w ox o
F <y ~.b~~~~ z
~ ~
~ C7 w d ~ z t.
.O
~r `~F ~g~y ~
7J O ~ ~ ~ w ~ ~ Y C1
cry =."b,~~to ~
NC7 a~~ 2.~".~ Q~y Ci7 C, '
A n x W ~ 0
~~GC'h7
w ~ ~ ~ o. ~~«.C
x' rn ti Cs7
n
a. ~ ~0~~
`C N ~ .r. ~
G ~e w Z
7 3 0
fA
N ~ ~
O ~ O O
~ ~
O
(D
a ~ W
~ ~ o
a~ C" o
~ N
a
~ ~
n
3 n w
0
a a
A ~ ~
C~
w
~ o y,
a
7 0
~ o
a
z
e
w_
3 _
~ ~ O
N
} N ry A
o a
~e N
x
o w
F~ w ~ ~
to A
N O fD
o~ z
o
N
O
O
N
rt
S ~
O
n N
0
n
a
o y m < c~rr
'b ~ O
O ~ ~ `G y 9 ~ n
°o y o ~ Pi' R. ~ O
N C" A r. < °c
a rv z z
^I
~ ~N0.a~ oyrn
~ ~ N ~ C~ ~ y~~ O
¦ ~ ~ C e ~ ~ ~ ,~`y`ky' O
X N `G ^Y O ~'O~~
o ~ ~ O O y
N ~ Vi
~ ~ Y7
o O ~
~ ~ ~
a
~ 'v y c~ O ~
d ~ w Z y
m
v,
w w ~ o a
~ o
°o o < <
°o °0 7 0
n' w
~
vi ~ ~ ~ o
~ ~ b o
w
n~i n~i a o a n.
i.+ i.~ ^ C7 ,p
~ ~ c
w o,
~ ~ ~ a
" 3
o e
. ~
v, A o
-r
A
a
~u C
d o
~ o
a
~ o
0. e
o
d
no
sd
N
o a
~e N
A
rt
a w ~
N U N
Q W ~ ~
O O A
z
~ o
N
O
O
N
ry W
? ~y
_ V_
n O a
n
0
a
z y ~ Or(']~
o ~ b ~ w ~ Z
o ~ ]'dp
C7
O~ ~ a'w ~ 00
o p ~ Y~ ~ K
a ~ C] ~7
a Vy a < ~ Cyy" 'y!
0 0~°0 ~ ° ~ty~yrytr~7[n"
as ~•~Cy~C
~ ~d
~ ~ ~ tl1 ~ n
ry d N ~ y ~
O
d T N "3 Vl
° z~
o~
n yn
~ v
" @ ~ O
O '77
z
z
o A
o
0
0
a
b3 ~ a
w. °o °
sn c o
<
_7 ~
~ O
49 (A ~ a ~ O
~ ~ A ~ Or
W w m 7 a n.
°Gi w
w 7y C N
N N
n
A
~ ~ 7 ~ O
~ 'r
O ~ 0. O
~ ~
Litigation: October -December 2002
Second Quarter-Payments of $1 500 or Less
Case Name & Nature County Response Paid
Civil No.
Henry Ross v. COH, Civil Rights Case settled prior to trial $1,500
Steven Yamashiro, Wayne (Alleged false (Motor vehicle
Carvalho, Lt. Henry arrest, assault insurance
Hickman, Off. Joseph and battery, carrier paid
Kealoha, Off. Joseph denial of $13,500 for
Lally, Off. Alan Kimura, constitutional alleged injuries
Off. Steve Clark, Jay rights) caused while
Kimura, William Smith being
and Janet Garcia; Civ. No. transported in
97-452 subsidized
police vehicles)
EXHIBIT °`C"
KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS
A. Departments:
DPW - Department of Public Works
DWS - Department of Water Supply
FIN - Finance Department
HPD - Hawaii County Police Department
HSG - Housing
P & R - Department of Parks and Recreation
R & D - Research and Development
B. General Liability:
BI - Bodily Injury
Misc - Miscellaneous
OT - Other Tort
PD - Property Damage
C. Vehicle Self-Insurance:
BI - Bodily Injury
C - Physical Damage (Collision)
COMP/VMM - Comprehensive
PD - Property Damage
PIP - No-fault Benefit (Personal Injury Protection)
S - Subrogation
D. Collections:
C- Collision
PD- Property Damage
EXHIBIT °D "