HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0118.005 2002-2004 rfI Os ry
tAL KON[SHI bi,cQ,
CONSI~ANCE k. KIRIU
(~nuwl}' (~[erk LrpCslnlire , iudilor
,IAY MI:NDL ~~..~'Y'.
t 0l M~
Depuir ('omnr (~lerk
County of Hawai `e
Offrce of the County Clerk
.l upuni Sirrr7
lTdn. llauzn 'i 9C'20
Telrphonr IR08i 9(7-8786 hiiaimile. iNO,Y/ 9n/-.4i-,
April 24, 2003
i0: Aaron S.Y. Chung, Chair
Committee on Finance
FROM: Constance K. Kiriu~ ~ ~
Legislative .Auditor
RF: Finance Department Response to Committee Discussion on Bill No. 49
Agricultural Propert} 'I~ax Program
After the Finance Committee's workshop held on February 18. 2003. about Bill No. 49, relating
to the Agricultural Propem Tax Program, our office attempted to summarize and categorize the
issues discussed by council members and members of the public.
The issues were transmitted to Finance Director William Takaba for comments.
Attached is Mr. Takaba's response to those issues.
Att.
Carom. No.
Ref. Toy
Ref. Date
Mtv or yu
Harry Kim William Takaba
Mnyor Director
~ Nancy E. Crawford
~
~i~h,o.,N'yP Deputy Otrectar
O
County of Hawaii m
a G~ ~
Finance Department ~ ~ T~
25 Aupuni S[reet, Room I18 • Hilo, Hawaii 96720 _ -
(A08) 961-8234 Faz (808) 961-8248 Crl
i
~A
C ifl
Memorandum w
To: Constance R. Kiriu
Legislative Auditor
Rodney Oshiro
Legislative Assistant
From: William Takaba '
Director of Finance
Date: April 14, 2003
Re: Bill No. 49
Agricultural Property Tax Program
Enclosed, please find my comments or recommended action to the issues brought up at
the Finance Committee workshop on February 18, 2003 and presented in your
worksheet. Should you have any questions or concerns, please call me. Thank you.
wt
Enclosure
E E o m m d
N O N L ~0 0 ~ O~ 01 . N
C U d L O L N 3 N iY ~ N d ~ N C~ Q1 C O M
Z (a N O Y O~ lO F- fa ~ _ N O C_ N O ~ 9 r 3 > ~ 'y L M O O
Q C O n C O ` N N L p, ~ ? 3 0 L N O O O~ J N O) ~ O ~
F LL~ U C N f0 C O N O a~~ J c j d N N N N d« N L~ U
Q O N S N r N ~ N E O C N O N N L S O C~ y L t«x0 ~ U~ C Y N N y ~
O f0 J N y U CO > O d U E 3 .L. ~ > Y O C~ IO N= N 01 n J X 0~ N
w n c n p N m o p E o ~ o m m _m c J w ~E o c y ~ c
p N 3° o ~ d ~ m y= aci J E 3 0~ a v m m o o N O o
Z c x~ n m 3 vi ° °c ai m o a m a o D c~> >Lp. m~ a"i a ai d E a
W o- ;g m o o c N c c N o c- c t a ~ ~ d ° d~~ ~ v aEi
g~ > ° o o N m o n u o m _ a E E N ~ a x o o v c x
~ 3 m~~ m o n y N ° o 'o m ~ aYi ~ E o o ~ m o E o o ~ y ° o y
~dcm3LEcm~a:.NU ?o'yoyd oo Exec np~N mp
K~ _o c i ~ E m _o E d o m m~ a1Oi w° a o o v v~ 3 0, w~ = c
R' a"i ° m d U ° z: N m~ E L ° y c 3 d E~ ~ J a .o N m~ w > o N
Ev o£ymEmcENCE3Eo m~E 3 m`a ddLEm .may
Z L N d O N 'C t N r m a O V N~ >
L> N N N«~ N N~ L n F .U ~ Q1 d~ ~ ~
W O N~ N O~ d .L. N O d d (0 L O> j~ N N 0« to O O n Z' J N? S
f N 2 m m m o d°~ a ~ o F- $ E o~ 'o E d d o c N ~ w°~ U U m
m _
i ~ m c o m ~ c g m m~ J of c 'y d r 3 y Li cYO ~ ° m .5 m aoi p rn
H y~ v 9 w-- m~ a°i ° 3 c J~ m r a 2` m J d ~ c n
o m E x o o° v n~ E d em a aoi ~ t rn~ ~ n ~ o a o
f d r ~x a~i m«~ api n aoi d t
a~c~dL3aQ ov~°aSoc~o-t-m5a o5 nw C) ~F ~~£mo~m ~ U
a
0
i.
2
c ~
N T
y L pF p
a
'V~J m ~ O O
~ ~ ~
a~ ~ o a a
a O C N !J N N d N N
S O 'n J J N L NL, j J
(n 0 N N O N T ~N ~N 'y O N
O Y
3 W J~ x x x
wzmQ m ~o `m
U w ~ y E E E
Q ~ m J ~ °o ~ > > >
Z F LL ~ L L L ~ ~ ~
LL U Q~ ? ~ E E a q v
C C C ry C
-a. E ~ m a u16i °c c c ~ o
~ = o. ~m ~m i y i y i y p E
a ¢ a ~ o J J y
Q Q Q Q Q Q O i ~ i w w
0
~ T ~
N ~
N {C~
OI ~ U N
~ C_ C J
_ N y C p~
~ ; 3 ~ ~ ~3
d ~
O ~ N m
N N U
~ ~ C ~ U ~
n m c
m o ~ y E n E ~
E .n o x y m m cg F
0
c ~ a c E a c E d c
7 N ~ ~ Y ~ ~ o m a` 3 p`~ a
d o ~ E ~ L O N o~ ~
t ° N d 3 m m m J~ a
~ J~ 41 d ~ N ~ ~ ~ > L N
N m d O p ~O~ F p m p ~ ~
~ O T = ~ N ~O 9 C O= O O.
H L` L N d O C U N J
~ 3~ V n ~ p o o a E E
m
o. o a ~i v o 3 0 3 v c
~ m m~ m y o O1 3 ran « d `c ~
c x= N L o m o m m d
m N L c
d ~ 5 3 o d a a.. o a
U
O U a m c > ~ 3 a m w i. Z U
N M C ~O (O I~ O W O
N C C N O C 01 "O
« O N E Ol .r C ~ 0 0 O > J
0 0° E o ~ O o N c :4 ~ o~ m ~ ~ r M
C ~ U O 0 0~ ~ ~ ~ C N ~ C N ~ O
m° E a E~ m E ~ 'o O n Jo y o` m w v
N L_L-. ~ O N d O) T W N 4 L N n C p X ~ O C ~ N
d d 'O ~
N 3 N M a~ C 0~ N N V 3 N ~ N d .m. f0 C .T O L N
E ~ w o 0 0° d `o ° v m Q ~ m ~ m O J T
L C C N« C- n - N D- y .O C T 1] L d
N N L N~ C a .L. « N > O U N N~ N ~ O N U ~ m N y J
N N N d N N N~ C p y O J O O O y E ~ N U O
C~ O O N N d~ a N y T ~ N d JO w m N O y N C O N U C N
c E N S m U o m d c v m n- c o c ~ o d
an d ° aEi ~ L b ~ J r o~ N ~ d m o Q E= a c ~ ~ a
u°i Q d ~ 3 ~ n~ c c~~`~ E` c x N m m _
y Y N C m O N~ d y N j U ?N? m N m C E C 3
N ~ O m E~ O D p N« ~ n y 3 C C 6 d E. a C H 0~ 0 Q C 3 ~
~ J m C~ C` N N C m N p 'O N N E 41 O ~ f0 N N n « N
m «O v O~ j« N N m N C« O N O y O N N d~ t0 O U> N d N
N O N N E- U N- t0 ~ C p O N C n ~ W d Y d E N` m~ -y0 L N d y
~ °~L°. v ~ 3 N o " v a~i = Jo ° o ~ E N ~ d > ayi d °c d ~ m ai d
3 a 3~ o v c m ~ ~ y n a m a L E E c o rn y c o m~~ m m d a >
d o o 'O m m ° ~ `o v m m m E .-p' 3 E c a 3 J o n oo a w 'o m ~ ~ d
L L>> C N N N C O N C L J 3 0 0 0 J d 9 ~O X W~ L >O N N L
U F' T T L y 0 'r 9 N n F- C N L U d C C l0 d m n~ (n a C > ~
-9
L m
~ D L j
E `6 w v~
x J~
Q N ° = o
L L m y -9p O~ CO
N N - ~ ~ L l0
a~ o aO,J o m N b UW ~
W M 0 Y N Y O) ~ m Y C
= 1 o S r d m ~ d m d > > > £ ~ m c
K a ~ O d' H vl ~ F N F U N U J N N m
Of
0 J ~
Y
W R' m = N
R'
Q ~ m m y
z F w E n
W J LL d A N N N N N N N Q
U o 'p a a a n a a a n
E E E E E E E E ~
a N N
E of N U U U U U U U v °U1 °U1
Q X U d O O O O O O O O O O
W ~ J d a a a a a a a a a
41
OI U Z
m B 3 3
UI J t - O
J d m t ~ N
y U
m
- C N
A U K N K ~ U 6
d
N L U~ _S ~ C ~ m
p m y O ry L
N m L a
m° ~ o t E .3 3
N O p_ O ~ W N N N
C V ~ _ C 9 ~ ~
E O y ea ai c y C_ c a
N ` a ~ d O m rTj j 0 m
'g-~ °~T a°'i ~i a v n ~ m 5 o f m o
° N ~ ppc 3 y ~ t c~ m m
N ~ U m - O.N O m O 3 0 ~ N m
0 0 ~ ~ ~ z m ~ ; ~ `o d ~ ~ E ~ ~
~ C E N N C N d T C N Y L J
~ v E ~ y co N m m E; m e '3 m
T o m 'c m ~ ~a - m m 'r o m ~i o a m
ma m e E m m u; d E ~ ~ N m~ n r
w EE om ~ m'-8- ox m m y~ d m
J ~ m t d m yD 3- ~ 'a n c3 N ~ m
N m w Z ~ `m Z 3 t a n 'u m 'O a ~
O O N~ ~ C T C U C p J O OI ~ p U
C N L d C m O m J p S O C m n L -
~ fA N J J d U N ~ E ~ a` a c~ ~ w J m 3
N M V' ~ t0 I~ W Ol O N M
N N N N