HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0684.003 2002-2004 RK.:EIVGr '
8
i~gyMy Coundl / '
Waste Reduction Technology RFI Worksheet :Response Summary
-
rl rl ARROW BARLOW BRIGHTSTAR CANADA EAC t=NTECH ENVIRONMENTAL
Technology Anaerobic Incinerator Thermal Gas Anaerobic Incinerator Thermal Gas Mixed Waste
- -
Preprocessing Large material None Trammel None None _None None
Shredding Wet shredder 'None _None None Yes-oversize None Double
Dirty MRF If recycle paper None None Necessary Not needed Not stated Advised
Capacity
-
Minimum 2-110 tpd 40 tpd 100 tpd 68 tpd 140 tpd 1 tpd 16-48 tpd
Maximum 220 tpd _200 tpd 200 tpd _548 tpd 500 tpd 500 tpd "unlimited"
- -
BOOT Will Will Will Will Will No (leased) Will
Sort StationlEarl_y Startup Build/operate Own design Own/County Can include Can include Won't supply/operate Build/operate
SPRB Desirable $30-40 Million Not desirable Desirable Good idea Not stated Not needed
Life Years 20 + 25-30 years Indefinite 20 years 30 years No estimate 25 years
Cost (Tip Fees) $10-14/ton $55-60 None provided $75/ton None provided No estimate $70/ton
Diversion Rate None stated 90% 87.50°/° 84% Not stated 100% 99.7.0%
Off-Line Time None 2-4 weeks/year Not stated None 10-14 days/5year Every 7-years None
-
4mW/200 tpd
2.2mW/220 tpd
Energy Export (273kwh/ton) 5mW/200 tpd (480kwh/ton) 200 kWh/ton 600kWh/ton No estimate None
- - -
U.S. Facilities 0 _ 3 0 0 3 0 _ 0
Other Facilities Israel -2003 0 1 Pilot in Australia 26 foreign 0 foreign gasifiers None _
Operating Experience None Good Limited Fair Excellent ,Not stated Poor
Permit Issues Poor Good Poor Poor Excellent Poor Very poor
Pilot Plant Not feasible Not needed Welcome Amenable Not needed _Offered Can provide
Product Methane Electric energy Flake Compost Electric energy Electric energy Bldg Mat'I
End User Identified None none None None None None None
PermiUConstruction:Time Not stated 42 months 12 months 45 months 48 months 24 months 6 months
(Submitted by Barbara Bell, Director of Environmental Management at the
July 22, 2004 PEMC Meeting)
Comm. No.
Ref. To: Presented ~E
7/22/0410:36 AMRFI_SPREADSHEET.xIs
Ref. Uate
Waste Reduction Technology RFI Worksheet :Response Summary
Criteria HERHOF JDIIGEOPIASMA NORTON SSFM TVD(UKI WASTE MANAGEMENT WASTE RECOVERY-
Technology Aerobic Compost Plasma-Arc -Mixed Waste Incinerator Thermal Gas Bioreactor Anaerobic
Preprocessing Organics None None - None Sorting Yes
Shredding None Some Unclear None ',Required No indication
Dirty MRF Not discussed None advised Included None Implied - If no separation
Capacity _ _ _
_ Minimum 8 metric tpd 25 tpd 300 tpd 105 tpd 25 tpd 100 tPd
Maximum __219 metric tpd 500 tpd 800 tpd 200 tpd Unlimited 850 tpd
BOOT Proprietary Will Will Will Not willing Willing
- - - - -
Sort Station/Early Startup Proprietary _ Provide/operate Can provide Not indicated Not needed Build/operate
SPRB Proprietary Necessary $15-19 Million Desirable No indication Would consider
-
Life Years Proprietary 30 years 30 years Not specified No indication 20 years
Cost (Tip Fees) Proprietary $100/ton None given None given $80-85/ton $45-50/ton
Diversion Rate -Proprietary 100% 40-50% 90% 88% 65%
Off-Line Time None 15% (time) None No landfilling required None required None
- 9 mW%500 tpd -
Energy Export None (432kWh/ton) -None 384 kWh/ton 836 kWh/ton 124 kWh/ton
- - - -
U.S. Facilities 0 0 2 (50-550 tpd) 0 0 0
- _
Other Facilities 48 (6 on MSW) 3 Japan 0 0 0 13 (Europe)
Operating Experience None Not stated _ Fair to poor Fair None Fair to Poor
Permit Issues Permit in place Fair Poor Good Poor Poor
Pilot Plant Not recommended Not recommended Medina County Not recommended Recommended Not indicated
Product -Compost Electric energy Compost Electric energy Electric energy Gas and compost
End User Identified None None A~fl~nths excluding- None None None
PermiUConstruction:Time 24 months 36 months permits 30 months 39 months Incomplete
7/22/0410:36 AMRFI SPREADSHEET.xIs
V
r:~ W 'o vv r z C1 m'.v oIC) 3 A x,T'~U! ?i
m m o o.d~m m'o m'~~ m.~ o o'
°a W o m ,"y n G),.c'.1'~0 0 k.'~ 313 al,~ II,y ~
o ~ n,T y o d'o 0..7 c'a x.13• ~,ooi 5'i ~
~ ° ~ 3'r: ~ y'~ a m ~ ~ 313'ylvp m m
m m
°oO 3''aon m m~^' ! m s
~ o o .00. 1'< W r'O y'.o x 3: '1~~0 ~i_ B ~1 I
~ ~ c o all p, f'd m x,o S x o
=~G~o H 7 N w .mss N N''. ~
(n 7 C I O w~ ID W I
m ryI w'' 3'w 11
m N 3, dim
"
m
T Z N fA ' Z N' N W
~ ~ 0,0 0 0 0 0 O° 0 0 0.~ c~
3 3 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'm m ~ 'm Io ~ m a N.
d A' ~ ~ O N
m'm m m Im m J T +,J -o o'
~ d
o o o O o 'lo ~ v'w'm
T T T T T T '1 j I
'O~AA AiA'~A ! c
i I' W
000vv oOO~ o cNi,~'~o',oo Ow ~
mm'm m m m °F' °F' ~ o w'u'~ o.,D J. I~ ° ~
3 ~3 3 3 ~ n 'nom °1~D nln m. n oA N
m d
J J J J J J N O I F N ~ C
N (D N N (D (D 7 ~ t/`1 t0 ~
ZI .Z1 .'i1 A .Z1 .-0 ~ ~ 3
T T T T T T
O O O O 0 v 0~0 T A j Z~1Z N~ Z'~ O Zi 3
(D N N '(D N N JP JP ~p O '.n O O °'O O O 1 O
d d p O ry 7 O' O J
m m m m m m ~ m w m'O n. O
~ 3 !3 '0 2. ~ ',d n'o- to N ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ `°'o Q ~ DID ~
0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ 1~', m 1~ m ~t
n
1 ~
I 1 N
v O~'v D O v0 O~m 'A N'Enz'. cnrn 11Z Nnp 'S
m m m m m m'd v m °o w'~ ~ ~ ~
m m m m m m ~ v i o ~ 1
3 3 3 3 3 3~~ n '.m ~ m ~'~a n11~ n IQ
m m m m m m J ~ L2 J n III N
0 0 to jo 0 0 j ~ m d
A AA'A A A ~ O
T T T T T T ~ ' 7
I~
v v OO O v10 OI,m m w z ~Z O~G~ C
m m m m m m x x~ o °'OO o'o ~ o
~ 10 A J J.°' 1.
3 3 3 ~ ~ ~
m'd.a a~a n'1~ o'o:~
9' > > > 'm T.~ ~'o m 'a c m ~'7
m m m m m m J < N I la a m~ <D
0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ 1 o m '1 I H
A A A A A A i n m I~ 1 I
T T T T T T' 1 I m
T T A T T T
o v v v v v 0 O'm ~'z z m cn ~ Z o Z Z
m m m m m m x- ~ 0 0 0< 0 0 0 0
m m m m m m ~ ~ ~ ° ~ ~ ,Z ° n ~ ~
3 3 ~ ~ ~O m J'c n+
~ n a
m m m m m m m
O O O O O O ~ N N ~O
~ N
Tl A T~ T A N~
T ~ T T ~ A ~
v v v v v 0 0 0 z z N 6e Z ~ D Z W Z
N N N N N N Jc ~c O O~ O J O~ n 0 5 O
N N N I N N N 1 `O< `O< N C N N ~ C' ' N n J
3 ~'3 3 3 n~ 3, a!i~ p m
m m m m m m N a ~ m
0 0 0' 0 0 0 ~ n
J m
A A A A A A n
T T T T T T J
A A A A A A ~
N m~~ v r Z O m o o n 3~ x T w r
N A ~ „ d O p d N A O' d N d C O
o ~ 3'In v c °<'~7 m l,y N c a'x'' 1D y y
w a ~''3 <ro ~ G1 f''q ~ O'9 3'.3.~'D.m_ m
+n ~ 01 F ' n - o
D u, m 3 ~ 31m ~'m m ° m ~ 3'3'3'0 2
r:
T °00'3ooa~~3m m^I'd' ~'~~''p~'
N w 7 'X S'« 0 '.di ~ O ~I
i- a < m r m d a v v to v O ~ I
m ~c d a''.~ 0 1D o y''m
m 3 V$ c d~ 'n ~ o' I v c ly
cn c o' m ml m.
m 'p' n m 3 d
m H 3 N m '
K '
f%1
D O o 0 o O O O z ~ v~ z ao z A'~ ~
m m m m m 'm ~ 'm o o I~ 013 ° °Jlo 0
m m m Im'm 'm m 3',v a 9 ~m n rn~ ~
3 3 ~ I m'm v, o'm co
m m m m m m g .z ,Z ' o '6 N~~ ~
0 0 0 0 0 0 I, ~ a n'a ~
T T T T T T
B O O O ~ ~'~O O A (O T W EA ~Ut NIZ ~'Z
N N (D N (D N JC Jc N e d i0 ~'O ~ N
N N fD N N N ~ `dG F ~ ~ ~ O 'O ' ~ < ' (Op
cn N ~ ~.Ia ~~a w ~ ~oyi
'm 'm'm 'm m m ''S°o o ~v~~2
0 0 0 0 0 0'~, ~ Q = ''a'a ~i
;D ~7 Zl ,17 ;U A N 7 m ' C
T T T T T T c
I I A
O O O O O O10 O~Z ~~w,z Zw wll3 OII~~
m m m m,m m'~c ~c ~o o ° o o', °o °o n d,~l' I~
m~~I~m,mlm m'i~ ~ 'm ° m 'm m' ~ ' ~ 6
3 ~ ~ ~i~ 3' d ~ a nlm ~ ~ ~
m m m m m m m ~ d
0 0 0 0 0 0' ~ _ 'O m om'
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O
7
O
O O O O O O O.O W ~O Z Z Z N -`Z !Z D
m m m m m m x,x ~ ~o o.0 0 0 °~o o m O
A O OI
m ~ a o- a' alv'.
N N N N N N ? ~ O~ d i d ~~T
0 0 0'0 0 0 ~ ma ~ ~ °
T T T T T T
n S
fD
C O O O O O O O' ~ Z~ Z C N Z Z
(D N N (D N N vc' F~ O O ~ O ~ O O
m m m m m m~~ ~ ~ ~ ~'m 3,1a m ~ n N
3.3 3 3 3 3 ~
m m m m m m S m~ c, o.
0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ > > 'm ° ~ 7
a _
.Zl .Z7 T T T A i~ I O
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
I C
O.
<D
3
lD
N
O O O O C I C O'~O' T'N to Z m~ w~ W-~
fD N N (D N N A O° (A71 I~ 0 0 0 W C O
m ~m m Im m 'm ~ '.m v,I~ o m n c
~3 3'~ 3 ~ d ~a n m c o a
> > > > > ~ ? o d v° m o '
m m m m m m S ~ m d~
0 0 0 0 0 o c m ~ a
~ ~ ~ ~ Tl ~ o m
T T T T T T
~ T ~ ~ ~ ~