HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0931.001 1996-1998
Lanny Sinkin
Attorney at Law
58 Furneaux Lane, Suite 5
Hilo, Hawai'i 96720
(808) 969-7768
FAX: (808) 934-9609
E-mail: light@ilhawaii.net
July 27, 1998
Mayor Steve Yamashiro
Members of the County Council
25 Aupuni Street
Hilo, Hawai'i 96720
Dear Mayor Yamashiro and Members of the County Council,
I am writing to you on behalf of Parents Against Irradiation and other organizations
and individuals who gathered the signatures on the certified initiative petition coming before
the County Council on August 5.
The certification of this initiative unquestionably makes the irradiator issue an
electoral issue. Under the circumstances, the United States Constitution and simple fairness
requires that the government itself not use public resources in a partisan fashion to support or
oppose the initiative. I have enclosed an opinion by the Oregon Supreme Court which
contains an extensive and well-developed legal analysis regarding why public resources
should not and cannot be used in a partisan fashion.
This letter is to encourage you to examine the relevant constitutional principles and
then to act in accordance with those principles from this date forward.
Specifically, the use of county employees to write official letters to the editor
promoting irradiation, such as those by Marcia Reynolds, and the use of county funds to
promote an irradiator, such as the continued pro-irradiation presentation on the county's web
site, are both viewed as violations of the constitutional guarantee of a republican form of
government and of the First Amendment rights of those opposed to an irradiator.
The appropriate response to the certification of the initiative is for Mayor Yamashiro
to direct Ms. Reynolds not to engage in partisan political activity while on the job or using
her official position. Similarly, the appropriate response is to remove the pro-irradiation
pages from the County web site. These specific actions should also lead to a general
expression from the Mayor and the Council that representative democracy bars public monies
and non-elected public employees on public time from being used in partisan campaigning.
ooous. No. 93 1. o l
MNo. NcrlaeN
l TO, CO UN C- l L_
se, n....mL 2 71999
Mayor Steve Yamashiro
Members of the County Council
Page Two
July 27, 1998
We would appreciate an immediate directive, resolution, or other appropriate
expression from the Mayor and the Council directing all County employees not to engage in
partisan activities while on the job and in their official capacity and reaffirming that public
funds are not to be used for partisan purposes.
I again urge you to read the enclosed case. The rationale for prohibiting the partisan
use of public funds is compelling.
Aloha,
Lanny pinkin
Enc.: Burt v. Blumenauer, 699 P.2d 168 (Or. 1985) t
c.c. Naomi Cohen, Kathy Dorn, Chaatrles Wurdeman, Media
F41'v~
J
3 S q ti p Q C m ~ ± C E 9 S, O G~ A n 9 C~ F
o, a s 3 ~n o C~ 2 S 3. '~f Ta m n a S " m ~ s w 3 ~4 0 3' 3 ~a 3 F v,
a ° c_ ro m a > a s o rt ~ m" w xw f L r _
w w > c G s i~ w L S ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ M1 o d G 5 a c Aw m ~ r " w n E
e~ 3. tri~~i ESO ~scoB me 3'A .G S.a New Scm`h`-
n i ~ o~ ~ 6 3 ^ ° e ~ "a $ n ~ $'n° w -E ° a ° F G 3 ^ c • ~ ~ a. m i
~ y 3 O w'~+~ 3~ 3 - w e m E `8. c a.c n n 5 rt ^A c= t J`
6~ ~ ? ~°'e ? e a a ~'S'b. m8'~ HFen ~w _<6- d P n .^S
m s C S v- m a m B m. ~ 3 m 3° 5' m q~' c o'a ^
L o Y O Y 'J S G'a ~ C n R C S 0 1- a~ Y Si E C. 'Q o 'S G H A
00 ~ a 8 a , m' ~ ? 3 c ~ S E kkn ~ 44R y `n n 3 ~
G
w s p R 5 w N a y c N N° n> A o C 3 - oa o n , 3 o E z ~ n x 3>_, ~ 3 c- A
gZg ~ 4 w' w y a 'a n ~ o w A 'P o. o o' ] ~ '9n `o~. " o' ro' ~ O a }G n - fi [ o ~ z
^S. C ~m < n r9a g ~ c ¢ a~~ v Tn C xo = E.o ^ o c %na n s a
s ! C.n a n.5 ~ .`.w e^ o.am ~ ~e e' B' =S -.A'~':jd ^a S N Y > p
O V$ 4 w a o v y o ~ ~e n p g n„ 3 c o. 3 c. ~ n o ^1 ~,C
L m c 6 y L Epp ~ L .~Br.Gg r3.N~ L ^ ee a m=i c:s~ o cc A Oq
3 8 ,'3 ~ G p C R A C mG 7 0 0 ~ c u4 ~ e ya ~ L
~ ~ r2: 9yd$G 4 >!n CoGFmw Q ~ cj :$Sw wR-~ ="~'cR
a m e f] `8. f1 0 3 0 3 e a a E^ p o= i m,>. F. `o
c £ e' a rY m m >'B n 3 G L E q c, n ace c c ~ ~
.1 fe (''js 3.< °c,?d m'nc ~ o.=e 'i $q~R~R za 3R ~S~~:o
~m 3w N ~'~3^ac_w a5_.~ofO Ewa o"m~G
03 rrs'~ap 6~£fi o ~~a'e 5~c ~'R3 AS''o.Tw~' m_c
m n ~ 4 rY ii w ? 5 > >
f0 R C m- g O. 5 O. E ONi C C S 6 d C n ~ T, m 6 'w C s P C p A F 9 'G m ui F, C O 75
N S
:P n`~ o e ~i m 5~ ~ G o n P c ~ O w c n~ +c n` = c ,r. ~ o~ A c^T m S n O 'o
8 4 d O G ry? w^ 1 r
e ry q m a ti S. a 6 d N m n ; Np~ S m ^
C d C, ~ ^ C ~i G= 3 C n O e 2 E~ O Y ~ S q p E. R ~ w-
~m? n ° m °-.°`ct ~ 3co ~ 3 ac „ m c$, ~C .^..°c i ^ 3 o aco" c 's 3 -
w _.3 3 a.~ L 5.n a~°e ce P wR ~a~ E ~ w'~ gF ~ .o L.o,E s ~n ~
rnmo as5,5$a Q p9~2m s~RnTa ~'°6'SA;~Y"u 4 Ado ^c w.A.G=.'w ° wa v _
e' n aeo mm°< 3 Cs 9 s G m a e m R °c a, F c R w o n n, a c F ° u
Ycq g~$nw m'3 Pc° g ~ o as ~ ° m
T SR~ 5 5 R a 7. A 'o]. o m `i V E H P q=; e
N. ~ ~'€Ea 5S8<<~- ~M ~ e e^~i: %w„ CR 3 m 5
~,rd ,j Aa p d6 _ ~Ti ad Sw 3 ,o~ cge 8 a~ 5 $ '~o_'.^ ^ ` ` ~ ~°e _
SSg S~w 5'° A $ , 3 e.C.E 4 °e ge R aRR 8 `s'ue Q
° m r m E m e n 04
o c e S.: Q e g m o. m 5 .S d E C. G q °c
N~ r~3~<C4 m =~Je"~ la 5? C^. na°a s u =pie e4 2.4 ~5=9
O X C o v e ~ g . ° o. ~ n $ ua p q ~ .p S ~ a 3 ~ A °u a o. ~ ~ > A ° m ~ a G ~ ^ 3 ` c t31.
G' e O O d O p w m 0 e? o S O R T 4 2
m si- ass aR~amm m $5 Ex.
a s= F5 a=gA e P
a~w
a0 e g G O O 5 a {m~ -'j m _e - m p O A
~c g P d~ a m L97 '~p ~ ~ R o > ~ '3 n ~i
6y la ~ M 6'
.ePyy a 9a~sR Saa~5'0 3 ze rn'~ C ~w $oa fa K' ck~ o z~ ~a
yaa o m 5 d o° o~ y n c a 5 ~ 1c. m
O a n a~q ~ S.$ c y~ w'a $ 'm ..s7 c p c.~5 R $ " n'v o m n m r~ P ~ E o.
a L~S5 ~aa~~ 8 ,~`SSn55 ^{c6$=, P3~~~.. c2@ .°.n $Ew r
a35' 74c e g a a~„, G5. ~o='> ~X a. Sscc
e ~ ji7S'O 3'B 3Fem^~a ~c C~ T°~R ^ g'~ r g^^,ex R
&
r >P4 G• G ? ~ eP 3 ° : n -3 ~,Z 4 °.a ~ r q co
g£ S 'D v m 8 p~ a 3 3~ ,n o S t ,o c o a m m a m
a 1w^o°8 c~ N. ~$~>'=R_~a 6aw'~ ~ c ~ G P 3 a 5 q o-o ~ ~ ~V r. 3.° E~ ~a ~ o
R,3 3g n +T o 3 c ~ m 3 3~ 3 E 3 0 ' n n
Rw R"ZC~S' A~z c o ~ a~ a c n 3mnG YiOr
44yy -3 °o "005' g5 S a a o ce Sc m ~ m m,l'e o o-~ao .o
"~T, ~S ITLT O,°° a ~ 85LK 3RR ag.° cc£°c moO .o ~0'5qq'- nq ~K d~
G'~•2 i=~•oR ~a~i~~~fro3.l A S m~5°pcy^RO+~'`<S•e'S~d•vnm n'^°o~9c c
'84g,j £3': SSS RF( .2 gg0 682. SSS~'wo Fnn .°w.x S, m° .m. •e '-'3 e,°O
.~F( a'AF ~3 ~_.%I~ g~$R ~C.R 6y'i ae ~a c... oa<v ~$m-~~C. S o o
R -5o I. a m o . a :nae o' ..,~m o E ^-.m•°e" m°°~
s3.°R'• 3'
cx ~oRo, a a'- s . n' . 4~ c 6 . ~a a'$.n
',e ^a ~no$n w•<°S
? x' 43R 3'A:y ^ ~lv or'-<'ao 3 ye, sy
~FY'mo3S~a£'m. ooh 4mvn TEO
S 'q~~R' Aj°cQ0 L9i 'c.F°b• m 3
MO aEl i-I 5s~ R~$Rc~ nw5 5rt .eo r 3£° mee °,5~° ~oO
Q$~~ _c .4m^ A33 ~ ~°9~SG-r^,.~oy (e c`°w royn~~ac m$c5 r.9°x
8ufp~'-$'w 6R cod S y.°<o ,.wmc. S.S~~$.m. 5~ i3 ~,~mc$rt^'x i
i p4!^P,Z n"r 3.5 ~~$3 Jan. # .^~Yms-eF~G n'So~ Nn$3 m•ne nP.o.a -m S3•<°?nP
r. A
°pp k y o^ ° R ° e `S. n n66 m i 4G 6 ° ^ A A` ^ m y
m '~'b cC,2~~ 'aq•3 n p6 a Oa ~'G-° 3 Q i ^ °3 ° <'a F
5 g 3~ $a A 5' ~'r 6 Cw ~ns ° 6c w Lyy~i -,3 e'H~ `c'a R N o, E'. ` B' a
a 6'e5',diC
qaa ! q~Y'•. R' m Q~ Ip~f ° ~ u i n . a m meggq ~ o. q r s a G o. ~ e a mm t+f
Gk.i b Sb EE o ql K C.~{ - O1= 6-o.e ~G. E c o'.°. g.R g?a 12.~ ° 3 0' G A
~eE6"tq C- o3 Sp`S iE, a°° ` 5'o aRr•o.°: c. w°° a m $~°s .°7 G a' "i g 6 o, SxQ o L
i SL
C~ K~3 a O0 p~:;3a °,o ° ?c ~ 3 3 £ °c °c O" R my 2 ^ 5.7 c. c w m v:
$ ~6a ~S~ ~ ~ ~'P 1"~Ca j k S- c.~.1 F m ^ r Fang o3A ~ ~ . ~ n S ~5 E n ~ ° ro
' ~ $ C gA' ~ o $mm~3r~3 ~'y`8. e+.y "a'3 min a~7 `~'.mi ,<ayc'~
IL 3'82
aKa4? F~7 R"h'~'?x.`t a amv?~<+.j A ?SwP'SFronm 'B.m Honc
g 'I c if y a r a_ ° a a d n e H Z t*l w s c 3. $ c o 5 3 a r N F 03 orv Pa',°.3 Pn S ,pm
A BE'$o. ~'6•gw mS i°8 ma oCw°,'-m<°c86'~°c fe ? $~o' ~Ms
}:1
- r 9 y . v d5!. s Q - a ~ ,°r m $ E ~ c ~ n ~ e 5 •Z C. ~ m ^a ° ,°c. c '6 C
lze C g ~Sv 3. a ~e d~. m m .3 0 .Sow e
8_ a.a a 3 a 3 ,~m o.o 3 5'm < m
q rma gS -a'- ggmtipE ~;.wo c. °'S. a3 ^8gp ~m
A• Sff~ $ y,d C° C'~. 8 rs0 CC) 3 6 aye 3 e E C nf~ 9
G 8 a ny e~- @. 'gg K- 3 m m 'u p S c..°+ E p< E
ao°ao°w o3m 3n Smon O
yyg 6'j'^e Q}00z ns~ g~Q3'S a m~-HL S naG y..m~2 .~cS
9` a Rq °p 6. r,•:~, p. G m G 9 m 3a neR y^ rs' 3 . a 3 < y ° 0 "3
IV.I 43nI t6i8&3'b& ~~Ga'~, 5'_e ? <°$ma~~. E'°m4
g qq.q -c 6' !1 "3 g> > ~3 . ieSva g,vge a R`!n";o C.s3'? m~"~.a$ 4 z
a! 8R[r 'o o. a,
e a m o. .a o n S ~9. ¢ t' a °e min g. 6'.°~n E. m e o.u .3 w ~ ~ z G
. ~.e Fe"`". a SF- gg i6 S x~y+° e o c. 3 m
~Ss$ s s f 5 E3 m~6'3.°.719.r as z
~~~~,4 ~ ~g'9t •ni~'y `S ~B S3 ewe°+bg C~a,0~~9 ~eP:~~a m~mCs~^'°°~c }
8 ev m~ --ism FdC•.amn
°`°s~p iv o
I. .o
~E ' ~ 6~^qw6'^ a~8 gds Si d'°7 c~ ~R X8$3 a Pi C,<
538•.3 N•~ - no, u. 6. S C 3 y a E 3, 3 C F a o
!g a~~ mgK g gsa~ ;P~SSyes~m:~~C. d
fl5$a3°g'b'aaP<o"
Wig A~_sxsc °4..g?E.w~~S=;: ?o~a:~A~Sd~~?laE
Q b ~ u» A ~ o~~ `Jy. Y w;" F= cy= c d 3= s g E : c~ m,°9. A; w° ~ q m' ° ~ 8 c n n>? z ro
r m U~ 3 h. o R 2 y A •e o~ ~ a~ o R a `o R~ p G a a g g a R
am.mw~x a~ a=3 EapnY~a co=v"8rr ~,8 i v o'o aS 333a S
F :w' C- P ~s 8. 3 s: X A m 'n' o m>; ry^ ^ w? 5 n N= ~6 'u' i i 'D E
'J ° r°w m rl p A rf = s P n _ °'.t R C 'Z R S IX P' = a p A w n
•^Se. a.85'B. S ~?:o as Er~ o~ e.R ~'o S'iG mk 'a. m<~:
~ N Q c ° ter. > v< ] m a 3 S o- E 3 ? w w S o w q m g 'R 3 T ~S ~ sTA c.
6 Gl .e m a ^ g° E w F a a 3, o m a" as ° a w S a c° o o c?
O n a O i e^~ 6 a nn ^ _'gw m < m° q m° a c. 3$ w a m_ '
¢ ^ 3, S o b d 6' C ~ S^ w' sa^ O A ~ m R o% } E. a +a ~ E Z~ iO
~S F>~ $q'c=+o ~ tl S a= iP>• r"~° ~n ~ + F. 3 R m ~ E^,°,•B o ~ SS _ ac:n o ~ _
~.~.Mw 3 5' e.< S S.. S. w G o 9..- S = o^ R o c =
O ee~~p(bp pp pp d = Sc p S S M ~y] F° • a ~f. rS f= P N ^pS pFpJ ~ rS A= J~pO 9 b a~ ^ 'rl- r. ~ n S n
W=a S~s~ ~~MpRRj6~6 yV mw s~BAPG >OmR~C pCF]. =^,G ~~<ymNR~A p. ~
~ ~~~Lfff a rdS a - •rs' ~ ~ MR waa o em F a m ~ S w ~ ~ B ~ S' + 3 c ~ ° e m o o~ °e o n E m ~e ^
yP8F _s p.0 `e<' m SmR S$ c;m .P e^ y8 ~,m c'~mm -=a. ° a.E F
< Fran IS= 3 a. 4 aS Se' ~ ~w 3' A =
O
~'S'SS°+ma~~A~85' -°igS'^m'o'c'~x$v oa^~a°G; cdomSO~'<~$
Q 6' C. n n w a Y.. m T Cs, ^ n qq m S m c c m A r° F e ,<e n u? S *1
mm:S ¢~^zc. ^q 60 6 ~,i ,S ~i3°i 3 m _].^n A
~bSnS,'< mS ~'a^=a K~ e59°F~^=3e~ w^aS ,<o c:R
~a -Sa '~'~F,'Qgp'O 'ti to MeS° .~m'<sm vS yB na°•~ ~»c,~ ~SB~E~ri `n S~8o43^,°?' a
3 p~,e aNB~ ~'L4 nr <'w,r SA as mP1
s+<~S'A4 N^ :^o'~.m ^vnRci cSS°-OOa^
p
^ •ey-°g ^ i~qqi na»A ^S m,a =='gm^_m ~-o'S~g'a'd ..°R' o^= - mw n
r m~'aa -.•~.a eS OG^oo?^~ 5' ~3'o xa R ° a`e ~C' gn EG'ew 3 +b o.`PO
C~a~~Rmpg~$~asc;~r
Sao. a eSg: °m^i`~m~o °'S z$=cS ~m'v a ° a.y rilc oaa~c o.
Sv w ~r+3 oam So+°$
< a R 3•e •q Ma
t~ ~gS~m.a R 3}[,GC1.^c~ -a "tmp Cey R' +c ~.m
9 y FC 6 ~ ~ a IC ~ R tf } 9 ~ ~ T ~ 6 3 'A _b r ^ ; y C ~ N ~ R S S t. ^ 3 9 ^ _ 'F '°j ~ G.
R e / 5 6 n d E~ a 9 P~ g 'PJ R ^ n y y ~~pP ~ t1' P e'. ^ .e tl A^~ m P°< a ri q~ C. ~
' Q a s a e1 ¢ pO a 5 !Gi a P R C F 6 A y 82 $ O. r;z b' w^ + O a p R O° w P^ w' P
RE g! n 4 ~
~y ='N'3.6~'3 w`~=mOC°>a ~ m, a`c'$ s>c 'c c'n <a s=w o$'~ ac~R S o Fn nw
~~iT fn3 Q~~'E~'$""~'"dr'oao$'28 yR ~p $,1o+7~a~m CR me' _~~S^~gE~ r3 m~^
• 9 p p _ ~~yy
x C a . C Y C rJ c a V y^ ~ 'J A dr' > ~°C• `G. a ° b ~S v'
6~ 9 Ll IC O S C i3[ 'pay h' A} O~ A. S .°i. 0 'p A= Q 6 a~ Y a ~J' y 2 wS N< n
R1 O ~ ~ O 'J 'Si n R G G L C A m O i a~ y 6 O S' O N '3 F+ .7 S R C. ~ 3 C m° }e C
= O C ~ F PR ~'u S C R C n m A m E = a R 6,» O~ p 3 S
pr
R' p rs '~~o 6dr'g C ~g3 a ° °'°°e ~.~C3a r u e aG
66 C'O ~°yy n'=q a_~~'a9^C ~m2.^o^n3 Tm'm~ niiC G q0.
Ig a 5 gagE Sv mo• as 6.'•+ R 6u„g w Y n
gg • 5 r S o . p ^ S c m R 5' ~ ° S ~ a o ~ Sep ? p n R
GF~''•~~=0 Fi m'~6~'6 ~_6y5 ,ir'n- ~~~c ~p~~'~a8'Gai 8^5'~ c 3S a
~ro=~~•~~mp R•S S°pm~ _'P ~m~^$aF•,3ox°^~R'.h ~-'g'R Em~6^'n=.
9 > roNa ~g s3
°JS 8 a S°e w 3 ~,3 S G a-d'oc'~rr .S 0 0 3, o, 'y a' m^ ' 0 5 E ^ =o ~5 $
w°~~3~~,~.~~B,Swc FF °+a'8iigg8 c^~~~m
aP S A 6' S F' N n v 6~~ A' 8~ ~ u ~ A
g~`a's Gg. ~$m a7d C
F13~S~'Ren
:R l~6~m~ySe® ¢adn'8~7.x^~r:m~~a~8~~•E ~'~-do^e°y +'e .°.3 ~3 ~°'$a`R=o
C=Sa ~E$ ~j~`Z,',+rd °cR ~>e 6Q _o5a ai `~w'F„3. ~'°;.<S>P ~3w o:.a R.x
S e o o m o y. d p w < .5 ,o n A S 3
P4\~ no $ 1O=~:F r~oEiS 5 G~ oggA
A- $ o. S o
~~~ms-~pa~g~sRrbe'~~93m~aa
Ca S m'_~{{~~ o°o~rm8 d, 'm5 Sa SP'~f.m~a SE'3, 1S1a 3g:d S~,yoZ~aF pe°_+o3
i',°7 a~~rF'OORw a.. eE~,Y6SS E~}'&6¢~v ms
a''6.'~QS'~
yt
. o rm m Pp,c mg< 'm n q a~ E G. m ^q R T
~RBB =~Vi3.0 dr'~8 3 ° m - b ! 5 ~A z° v mn'3 n ~
3 a 3 S % i R G¢. 0 5 .3 y n 8 e. o 'n m S m 3 s yo E. 3 n `=O T w w rt 3 w a
~~SR s.Zmx~ ?.g $c 7a~p q'~myP ^qN 6oP w'~.. rtrse
g~•,en~P oppp e~ Qwo ~ ?3 °_id'ef m 6g E'o' 8 o~7-n 6 ca !l~ a^a S
° S ~ a ..b' 5 g r p • R 3 8 d a. v i a ° S m° 8 m 5 0 ^ e _
F rs _ as ! a n G ~i3. c w ri ° " ° m 5 .r„' ' v •
to
RS'~S Y $~nb~y nF 4G3EE . "S~ "E'gw.a3°o3S m :a<3
$oROy=.s 3~F~. €ce.~,~ G~ny03a<s•^c 9Ea
yy~~ u o. c n~ 6 B a e G
0 eaG T'<"Q fe'~ 7a G 4 B6'4 y. 0.m 3a.7 8.~~'
° CS m ='3 va ~'n S.F $ C S'X =i¢~ ~ c' 8 °9 = q 6 3 3 E •-5 0+ 5.
''g-y]. 6.7 v.~p 0- e' m
G,ee a >Y.'4 ri 'g m~E=ri C 666mG y! °
3 p S w C ? $9R'C pC "_8 A nm mGOt imp 6 _B~ mP~ M QQ yo S~ •.op a. 4' ~ym_ m a
5 p. S ~ ~Z'.y~v! S pp Pp 'r~~ ~ •OO ^~.L °'w y° A y G r• b' N G.O m .O s 3 9
pg }
CA
^a n b'a Arc A "c°c'- S nx•29.3 ~SDa a'46> >
'3 •g F ~ S i 2 ~ C •e W •.r• a A ^ Cn ~ Q q " _ O ~y X_. < b .^i
eee S a a. 3 T w 9 • 3 ri m v t° ~ 1~ y N
. ~ L't. q • . n P .4• y ~ ~ E G ~ y ~ a ~ m L'. ~ G. +1
~.<.PTn C'y E~rd.S,~$, ~>p~~aH mG 8 p'S+o r] °~EC9 ~eBo^~ Z m^c gym SmS n
. •~v R ~'S yo a e 8 Flo o m n c c c E= u° e° ° cA9
S ,`lea ~ 11pppp 6 ~ ~ ,14 .m. ~ 5.3 3 w mo o. !"e
°c ^8 8 8 ~~'B ~ `•l - 6'
O R T'J m A •t A '~C ~ V m~ A O O ~ i
w ne ovwo voero o~3A Va 'em(n 1r, 8ym mna wv E~P-+ ^
_ '~FS°'•@: ^v X e 'R EgGm2. m s' e3o°gZ o5~av ~''°`so ns zn '8'{•m'°~c.a A
>T~{ g. .3g o 6 F+ So E:S. KgeS =.fi n°s A-~r33 ~"FII S„;2 m x m=
3R R @. F _$e^,°, ¢ •^e m.e " 5 c. g e o `-$e o. i
m .'C < 6. g 5 ¢ w n " 3 ri ia5 P^ m e a o' 3_ c 5. wS R v m b' ° y>
~c° a .yT S Q $ SmS~a:c3 ° '2=7 e"o aw °G oc Sm y•q m_m
g• O Z? A g y • C v 5. o. ° n 5: 8 Z 5: P R 5m o S B n ^ a _ o < A
$x gm S=.~ $s ,~rt0A. °.1 .v. o.° w, C."8 •s oo RC 7'~~cm3 _A m
@ ° w3aa ^ Q,°mn aa.5
fl.nFA^Gw Pa lSq m de.°.,
> ° fl.~ GSom '54 Ee X6'5' P'•~S 5c6° m3Qq im n
a 5aag~ °a8a2azygE2^.AF$6 <~~w°cei6~.~g 8~ n~a
QC °p ~3 m S ~ gm ^w H S 33a ~^+f~
'~c>i ~F°gAF~t»n~56°~~5o. 7~'S'na=ag ~e 3m 6~~~°°~.~a. o^c$'~3oa~e
y o 5, G, > 5 S m N y n
drG O n °o.9 a^~S 30 ~+n_. a o nn <m a
>>,g° sr'c~$oC,7 ee art. s`^3an Er
r•mo.~
°3a¢i~~aF'K..~S~g o6 a~ s•`r.'^C•!-y.~~. SS~,j a° 6°°.~
~ "Ri'•S ^wm°»^ a4w S3'~~ S5,6a ~;~SS'$~S C~~ ~m °.7 ma~cS 3 8Co m 3~•°.~O.q
9 n C^ S OC O ]i 9 w w C 9- G. ~ n 9 A
m~ym~~m v-_ 3o S is~ csp cT :gs_`° 8I o. ~'o. o. S ~f R ~.7 po
Y Sri LS ^ a ~ n ~ o' o n _`8,. A m c& m m ^ p A ~ e: A a~~ 1~ n pp< pp 3 c 3~ 8 ~ S
310. o'n Stiff aP g' 3
"5a~y° Sn mo3 ~
a.2p:~sa
F fA 3' no ~m `G
C m 00 A P R A A ' G. m m m `G T '(d P~ J '.j G m
B; EmgSoF. s3,=. =3@@rz°. a 3qy°# ors.-:a' R^ya~!:e
13.
k'3SGa;a r'~ <5 ~385s ^''ca~ 3Ga&'~em'"amr9 C'jomn~m o.
iS e
tl°P RO'.°.e6 $e dr8 m,a•°e~ o •<o.'T '4"v•< •°'n ^p 88.~Gy 39'rnX
a G v. ? 60 5~m C. A r' •o e c Sa ~ 3 ~ 3 'e mP m
y~ ~e o SQS ey an. o~^aw dn.^<'Em s.. :a_ AS P-m Pa
1 beaal gx•S x .tP' 8as Q 5~i' O° $O',O 'de cF oT S n a _oS "e~S5.
5.^~!•~{~S.~Q .S• {KosaFi >lrr~OSo a$3i a a~o~'o°.5-,cy,~o maT
= ?c
na.g < %s'~$ o S 8y~ g'^. m Sy ~S' E°v.'<nln~°SR" ~33g W
'~7 nn65 ' a<
P a ,°<°m 3G 3 8On.
a 'i n 3 V. GP 9 3. g 6 m G O A A 'Oi fS R ID N O R R A O a^ O
q ve c s¢e•,e3 ZSw^ c.m rrljy 3~3~ n ym6-3 ~n3o4 ~o.o ~~.a i3
S 8.< 6 n° R o a e 44 m td X ~yZ n A G 6 y 3 n A °j. ° e a ~ x~ R
1 . a'> r~ em G ° . m a X R'~°r a ^n SBo:•'°. e. ~n ° ~ m5 Q2
+yT c.• R< 1 drto m6s$ a -m . K 5 i n n E3m n'°m 3 ° a > Oc- R°~3~.a! 3 5nR2X ~n°c.~ ~.~OpB ..eym-g_c.SQ >~L. n~Ss _eoO33 ,.m
KKK"' A.°. ~s' < P9 ~S5 8 5 m-.63 ~.ao ° F
n~'c
°o
g w 3 ~g 3S'~S`~e^'O5r'n 5'B,~{~'.gm x•.:83 fag^R. 33 ~ ~-,ow
~~°~g G F <333a F ~o~ ~ ~ •.3^°.^rpva~ S~ R Re go 5'~ 33 Y~
m ~ rr ep Q 6 5'o'•1<'b" ~C " ~^¢n5 y° ~5a y ~ v ^ " w ~0 5 ~ a
m~ gg ¢ e9 g
c C . q p g ' S 3 P 1 °S,+ _'d' 3 3 Cdr. - °C- 3 F nr' a tOS = F' PR.. g c cyn
h. m a a 3 av S de '6 3 n a ° R• ° ? h 6 o. a =1
T•° p n A S Aqq 9<
^ ,QO mFr m° 3 a g vvn - 6• o ? ° yC H.w T n°
w ° w c ^ N. - 'g S_
] o m 5 ^ 7 -o c d '°.nc o'd a ] c ] £ ^ ° n _ o , = ^ °m a
E' 0 0 c e C a gg i0 ^ u S' ,o, 3 m o 3 A c¢°' o„, 3. m o. 6 w F rt- 5' o- g°
@ , Sav 6. o•-' me 3 a 5 a5
RE E ,t'am' 30 336p~~°r~,n3 ri ?.w a a m E ~omA O.S ma
w3RA rs. m
n r~.eo~e $3~d°o-S''>G3 a~Sa'Qre:. a. e'a gym; ~,o^m Poaa o''sn wn F2G
c" e°° tn-.~8»c1.' 5 r> .a c Avg B~' q'~-<'a.~
Re 80 b_SSns'm <aad~o Y,sS '3m~ E$.°.e° $0=$m 5. aoo~aw 3a 3-<' o-w
o, n<^ o • 0 5 E n 5 ^ a o 5 o S fi' 0 5 o w a -99 o~ pyee 3 g ] F 5^ rf o. ti 3°y x 2 m:p S p c g i n P ° o n
o ~¢J+¢ krr d 'N° ^ 3 n u ^ m 3 ° 31. o w 3 3 $ 3
cr^$.~... may°~~ r~ 3~2 sgg ^ac.p $,E<°E SA 3o r.
m b° o . G. ?..m. 'v' r 6] < m 2]
3,~•g Q.°~q m ~g'Sm'. ~C '~-o .v ,°6@. a o_< d 3° ~9 n `o u o :~m ^G FL ^ 'n
O ~~p ~,C^G-Foam °3.d .G2G ao'2,~ p d'1o g"m °c ScR a m' •x.•
C 7 ~ ~ 's: ~ ~ K' 3 ~ y ~ ~ ~ - ~ R P 7 m w i ~ H ~ •S w 5' 3. 5' '1 ' m rtr' a 5' ~
O
q. o 0 0. n rr c o" F c ' ^ 3°. S. 3 rs c. e Ft °o o $ m o A ' ^ o ^ ] C -Al
P s ~ 6 R 3 p N R ] r P, ~ ~ a q+ `V y ~ ^ R ~ ~ ° S Ll P ~ ^ ~ 6 ° $ s n c' ] ~ ^ q s y A '
gy'~ ,~o,s •^wR6.3 ^,~'$EEl
-'4 °^3o gr^G+` a =<^0 ~3.?~.3~aa O.cc a
P ro~^p6 ~3 °~aS5~ G$ 5•,a i y~' ~'.rE'.35~ aggso'o' m o
pC gj p R °
Y L' v~ m » 3 E: E 3 w 4 n H
w e'e'. a z ° e ° ~ g ai S ~ F ~ 5 ~ 3 2 S M ~ c. ] C c. G a a > w $ -a ~C
R S Sq S F$ 3_ 2 6 °c °o S $ E. 6' < id F n d e as E o+
3~'`'S^~+•°+n r^~~•°w°~~~e 8$~ -m b_~'~$~0~~ w 3S3 9~ Bm'a ra e~
5~'~ A e ] qNq 6 G rS ^ ] < < ¢ C ~ - ~ 1 d ^ G ^ O E
~A°o#' 8 ~d 3 .°^fi -o m'R 3 e a •-m','3 ~ HI 5,S 5'g t~~'o o r r ~ mr'v ° ~ ' S
hm o - o. 6 0. w R ] G ~ < •e o ~ ] r 5 E
^rJ5rr5 o e ]o Irvema ^.r.an ri.~^.i 3'°mS
1
'FW3 yw-C3 ^ S % 6.$ o S' a ?.3 °n^d
3' b $ 4$ s G' < 63 E O o A' c. .9
P sS "R o
a
403
C _C 1R '~'Ap. c~-tQ~e, '-Q.~ ~ ~~w•.-Jp~ b'~'NT~~ y~"~Nb-T< i'°~ ds
~ ac' N 3 A ~~.r~ ~~FF, Ago .ear s° ~ao^s~ n
m~'~ -~S°mte °no3$An'~
pA6E a LnS a d.po GO ~Ri~4 G.2 it a °c
_ G38 3 c P 2R 2p S °O Q 3. me m < E zW" A ngN
,i~ia^eS•~~o:~C9E ~~3'4.A 2333Qn~o$g~~.n;>"° nrZ'ao6o oms°p a3.5
yyyyyy ~~RaE~ •Y _ ioe3m p,m >~'n r°<<^,.. fiEem yT<n 0 3n `m
rtA5.3n
FiP~ ; S. 3~_ ~_.m _F° ,d a,^<$u sR ~°'6 RG' 6"...~5ac. .be°4ea e.-A'9~ •~T.'
~e-,~E°R;~' ~JC~ •-y °~`-or ~ 5 ]G`o 0 0 ^ ~w °o ~ 4<C.^ c': n 3 < c
$-2yE ~"may - -S""ca=. ^ ^.w m3 ~$_o
~ 5S2 ~flX ~A9S n..$S37`Q £~~$~mL'@~', G~'ea cw r°-A^R^' _ w
_njam -ffi°,j-. pco-"^a o3om m°~aN ort!on cc~~. °
$ r $4;dZ C`-o~'a". _R ^'Or $ 35 msEsOw_u sa ph'X .m'SF
R6 "°'e;i-T@C3 y?~C pEpQ~]~9:_ •o~ ^"o =tC'° '~^w='.°~°°•`3 c"'~
I~CggSFL~Ii R~h 7 'v 3,Faf~p•E .pj °m Y'Odc C~^ d `m om
.CC P{~. 6 w3 ,so C q~6-~gm°6°xnC c~gn33 w~.. :3 ~.".='4ra=AS aim,
5
° v E ' c o.w -w c o s~ S3
=3 Eg^Z aR ~o. •O> ° ~m mn ^~~7 a m ~C$ ~ o' ~ R1 its 5.'-- '4~,'. -9s~~g ~'6Q na8 ~s "r'<c~~•a E 5:2L^ A ~
a~'F •cCq a~O°~.~,i ae 3'':C B`~.C°'3 c'x ~g~ ~-w' °-.i F
n on
Ro.Q3w23" ° SE >R"ak> E-E_c5. yo 2Ro- • n-}-
ir~ ~zo Oa
p~R~°~ 33 4a2- SE vc- im yynn°~.n sp °~g,o"g3, O }
oS. ~Sy § R •gA S de
^ ST v c sc. w Sc
o. !n° Y~3°~~E CFJP S~O.~a~
~c6••':R~" ~~rr ° E~33E2~skE8 c$.k.d~Po f°wcs
~e ..°d'R aN V°o me ro'$°e $~o Cn o°^°•~~$d Ad^n 3,<°S `~.ao m'ae3m `~o,cw E m.z, cs Fw
q.. ]y+. 7.`~$ r~ g$ o e e p°o. .-m g.°a p ~.E 5~e um^ o.gN n Rn
Sir 3.yna Se o''peymmm l~'~e^1 .'~.-O gw ~,pg4~mm oNGY°a~Sm c~°. ,c'6$~.v
H n ^Sp ^ W K S< d
fj'. q L a O 6 yCy1 N O O^ Q A 7i S 9 p W m A R R.,9
~ 4 n= n ~'~7 gXO ° e° ~^e da =_c N m Ea.~~ ~ 5<~ ^p n 5- S3
p O ~ l P ° .Y 'O C N ~i F' 'Dp- y 3_ o. O < M ii.2 g P Gsp o ~ c_ c n Two S~6 y o S = m
QF CO! 9_NSN PR i p~=.~u POOm` NSC N9 'R 6O. p-~p q'Owerysr
oLto m~ ~ee-~s c5p- ~e m°p co. '"'c, 5'N~ 1-2 E:
wam9-C
37. ~`3y: "~S° Pm°X o 3e$:. AuG''po aE~°y P.pm3
~ ~S a n~~ 'N~OO 6 Q N C a P O, rym S `S ~ N s G P R N a^ Jnl'' n ~C ~ O ~ ~ E to 6 O'm~ A y a
d Ipi S ~ F e. A ~ 0. ~ 6 O ~ n '~j G. ~ p O ~ n j GC O' Y R m _ ~ ~ S `G C ~ ~ f~ q
C e 6= r' $ .T p] q N o. b^ r iS ~ E° m rt = m S y u ^eS ~ ~ W S° r~ O A
,.7 ~ !e + ° we-? oa°y!u c..< X m`< o,a 5'P. S'R --O S ~o = R a m S °,r 'f
' m S p 9 P 9 m X- O F_ S 9
° C C. n N. S A
F'e y E w S c m aS .a m H H s s K 3~ T
n~ ° SnXF ~ o p n~. .p. iO3 ?.36~ F ^c wp=R na sa
5q c 7. o a w 9.S dn~ X,a 9d. ~S ~c m 3 m E S= y]+ o o.R ~ n.~ m A
b ~g o ~y~ S`8. m' 3 s~ X ~ Gav ~ ~ m' S6y'•=.B -la~~o y2L= c°~`~ ^ N
P. °o„$. epCS,°w o E.p So-dn. C, rs eX°< n m n xyZn y nx ~7' _.E^~ r
u* S' mmX3lS S'-~g<" n~ 3c m ''q; oRc' ° TR z
F SP~sa S>c 2! < w c ~c S S 3 we 5 y X i5:q f e',$ 6R. la nPm 5' ° as T
s0.o P?R o w 8 m .C ati^' .o,<°.o o a o f = c° 'r
ff 7. ar.~=„mP'a_.e~'P~s ~'s o=°rt A=oaa°
.
S
z
n F 00 X n d zz ~ B O V G = p ~i R e° S j mn _ O m N S N O' S
w qq ^m
.`.YF G'w P ri0 .a 3 m o '.$7. o'~ O E G fi u S o. ~ n5ri~ S. r9 ~R,m c
H ew g' ° e o n= S v< ~'Z m o it g T ~e S m m n o n m y o a a a R
E O< C d a C ~ G i n rt; S O O X O= n ,OOj _ C _
8 N v n o. ¢ a v 6. ° ? o 3 y g S o y = r m `8. a n= R w E o n> S O
a< 3 o. m,a Semn6 m5'a qqo. 5's<i~n Scf ° an c X38.3 c a v s A^
G'c Cs r°, m._.G SS ~m.~.o. ,yam o.°5'Z~ o; G.~y co'wn '°we
^ A e e w N. S o n 5 e
E fi~ ? m w p ~e m 4° ~ 4 n 4 m m~ i~ n a° G' 7 a m ~ g 5 4 m 4 n' ~ 7
g~ o; m i n c w y~ a m A a `z° m m X R~ 3 z~ S b~ o ~ w v$ q~ S n E a w ~
n^ 2 G 'R m~ c > A ~ S m 7 n .c S 2 a° 3= o. a K n e P K a F i 7. = X ~
P~<°d_~ ni Sn o a w 'S c'~-m'=ncc:~ooG_o p=m'a°ap o= Rp s Y
e o.yc~~.ga t Y ~'S°'S'8pr o'n Xxp° ~s _~°R3 q'mc=.^~ Ko uc
W~ip
$gi XSX~a X~ i K o'~pm poXSmaX~3sR 'T?oz~pd~or.;'G~yAO~.y
o. `eK3 e E m^=. eP4 ~ e o. '2 ~S o'~°e c_..g Cy, 5. a° ~ > 0 3 ' S
y y C m y . ii =66 o n w y y e n p a m°e u> j G A P °y ° 3> d a H m w .O.
%'So~ "3P O ym av'v o ome,g ~ R .q rt~'<nx pn '$3E`
^S a$E Soa g M R oP w>~°$ nmSmA 6tlC:a a Ema A o.°$~
a E 3 a o 'a', a n X m G' n m G' 3 a as u S o x % n a m E m n ~i 0 . S
6 X 7 5 y 7~ P a 5 p ,y _ m e s o n G 3 2° ° y- a 'R N, a o-~ 8. ^ a
p p~ n ~ o. G ,s a r`n 5 S1 c. 3 ~ $ G' G d ~ 3 G aT~ P .
k qq b m 2' ° a
=o a ° .a. n= .7 F _R m ° m m £ n .i q a o ~fyn c Po^ 'e 4
2$ C nR ~.c •
m m' c'~°.m£ c~,3e-a 6y.3 <'8,° c >a ~e SGT 'ua Sn 75 1
%~.:`7 G.<CiO a..<°R m'o•-°. °4G°.R tiFo °.'.°.~c3.°. ,-°i :,grvX NR~RanSa ;9
w-
^°P~ a Co$~7 ~3p¢@ Sa'v an °w'+67n °eS e+'m 5-'~ a~ma °aw 3~63RSC+~n'E y< ~,+ji
~e~„y.,Z `~o d S n ~w m'-e ~ C mo•n X03 R'3'Op S P :n o'~ga ? z
Nay ~ g5'~° ~sm m 5'-~` ~ m X° ~b c i 4n^i o.m S n~ snm-~~e'~ y'~c d,c ~$'OS m a n ~ n,n^ ; A
Selo E<G3X,~"~g- 5:33S~3~d aSSoa Gow. '".°6'a Sm.°.R t
H°G sm oa° :y.,<=mu~c.o ca ~C ~~m..a S.qC} <].'<5'c ~'.a''P"~'$~ H~iz
0= - ~6n S o $.$X v n c. S•'i° $ <~aj ~ S otD i~'$ c. S El p~. N ~3.~y Sna a„ > ac
c~.£3 a E w< 2q''~e<n. 5'.°^.o w d $S ~y °~'e c.m S^ 3 =~~8 w a
& m
N.yp ~9 ' P 'J 5' ; C 6 ~ 3 m O e 6 y°-j Y n~ 5 .°7 e n O X C A n 3 Q~, ~ 3 S n S GY_ S a C n
`m,6~ ~ ~ 3.< o a p?a cv.~~ ~ e < 6o. yE S,le S.-m c.=. p d.R S R >s~~.3 g°.-° S^'~ m S
b G' P~ s •G OJ 7. rt P~ y ~ O A N C 6 re n n _N m R n
O. O 'J m 6 V. _ ST N O Cl C O" p m
~ S. F c S: E ym nS S c r$ y @ m 0 c$ " y p b, a o ° E S'
a ~ ~ ~ ~ m Y ~ P i ~S 5i .°r p wl S ~ ~ Y `G G .t i r7i .3 t/1 iZ AS E. Ei q~ 5~^< b E 'S ~ y T ~ J
r V
d G ~a^ n a o m m ° C, c o_ m a- Tn yT ~a r,
O G~~ d 4a a a~ a f_^If 9 ?Oq• S~ C N C 7 2 R= O P j ? Pi p C In B 2 m O V O^ 5~~ a p
'$a,ao Sro ~~PO.=5,moy Sy ~ "~=b m'°v°cA' ~ ~ d °va"~n'+ o:a,'° 5n~n mag i
0^5 ry .m sdao Cv~`o'm s = ].^o $o.
9 F 5' m R Y • L m < a G O o' n' ^ R 6 fi rJ N' .1 % 90
c m•<m m' ~a n = c ].m °a c. 3' m Cm - O p c..,o °F m u
?Sa $,x 3^ =ySG 3 .c p o'sw 3 2 r "x R v ~qq SSE.='~ m p A o a P
3
~-3~'~gn $c43 gSoaa6'~ xnm = L. %3 ^.S~~m a.°BoRi° A S~>
F'c
~n g.. c n~P v yS< 3 5 oa w m m~ 5 v c. o
° =•e n `c' ° c:o G. E w w $w a EP a9 o"
F [+1 m `RR° a. 'e' $ m. o' p • o c. T ? _ a , n a ° a u " . e m ~n a E m y e
~ v n a 3. S B w °e ~ ~ ° ° n • B 8 m m v F ° ` ~ ~j. m B £ `m .6 -1 5" - ~ - a ~ ° n a
•°C = .O '^J 9 O, E p T o. ea • n O b S, 'O d m n w q o -e n~ 3 A O
a m q P B O S B mV = S • p G O a S^ g a, ° ~ F ] rt ^ f ~
w m S} w° SOo b$ ,7 _ g w o ` 3 m f•° Tw
a _ m y^ o, a °c ^ . ry. m a E ° 3 9 a c- o av c
m d S o. n 3^ o 5 c, s b 3 %t 54
C o w aw .6 cab 3 rn .o to zB 7L
9. n t• n m m c c p 3 c n° O E g o o c
2
t
O
°c~ ~3$'r°,'3;~ 3 wa d O~~c p'° g a S~7'`nmoRaTAA 5 Po lac ^~B c.
QQq u ~j C 3 c v C S 9 w ee o w`o u a 3 - T n 3 s p$ o T w; t
G m a 3$ d 0 5 0 ° .°n. o a w m b a S< T u' ~ry6 n o, n c
BB G 6 m C. °E `~tp O m N= T O' S~ a a s~ P u O d O O P~ Y 6 f] G ~ O 6 p ] n ^
' nnPC.nS %Ym n dm u oG.m - n F m= o$m R== .r°-~.S n^ n o.P r
_ ''QQ 3 Ttl.F ga ^ dab a ¢a° ~ m°m- ?s w'$ ° G m ° .m. ~ ~ c.~'o = °
o r° w w g ~A. s G£ Zt i 6 c d F B i s n° m a 3 ° ^T' TO d= S=
CdY°m~'RGe35'mQ m Ed_'a as=^-:$3~ m- $ovam °o Sm ~a7 ~°m S own s°
3~ o ~e I' n°'g ~ •v 3 m a v S a g c^ p S o a a^ r0 S~ n E °n ~ i0 C m• ° p c
rOa Ev_ag 'S'°', o =3'o'v n ° n ^ o o c. a ~ _ p_Sf' ° o " _ F
q° yy;yy $T wk&
$ b'
c1 0 ~S c n t.-s- M F G m a . 0 3 = s a 3 ] A 3 o m- i
5¢ g cSco,B ~iFv o' o•$c 3 n° ASFw Smo~w .Si 3aa q'S'
~~sb ~N@ S^ rsgn`$n.°..o 3 ' ~ °.,:c c ~ d~<° ~'-'.m-'~c ~'abg m•2o°
B c 3 i p• < c E S ~ 3 arc n G~ 3 `c m a' a ,6 C. o d~ c 3 A
A e~~^~ °e Gn'c.~ S?'`B. S e'A ° ScO 6' .=.•w F i~ ~ C? ~.c
£ b w a n g~~
3 x w _ _
f
~z 3d~,y~, m sg=r^
c° r~.G 'as ~ ~.$~ap w 3B m G v
N M C 3 a T n p rt 6 ~ h.
~ O a ^ m
°•3 0~ gaa w ~ o. ~ _~p~gc pr_
C
3..~ ? o n g S w a` ~ T~ m a 3 f r
3 $o +05~ m ~ "
3'Za E, o-o'd m a n`5a °