HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0067.019 2010-2012 comments on Comm. 67, Bill 18 re. redistricting
by Cory Harden,PO Box 10265,Hilo, Occupied Hawai'i 96721 mh @interpac.net 808- 968 -8965
for Hawaii County Council. 9 AM Wednesday, February 16, 2011, Hilo
i support changes in how we do redistricting. since the last effort was so contentious, but we need to act
with care.
The redistricting manual Ms. Ford used says "after the 1990 census 20 states had suits in state courts
concerning redistricting plans; 28 states had suits in federal court. Eleven states had suits in both state
and federal courts on the same plan. New York had cases in four different federal courts and three
different state courts." [1, p. 33] We need to act with care to protect the County from costly, time -
consuming, contentious lawsuits.
Mr. Yoshimoto was concerned because Ms. Ford didn't read original court decisions when writing this bill,
but used interpretations of court decisions from the manual. But t think that's okay, because it takes a
legal background to understand court decisions; the author of the manual has excellent credentials as
Senate Counsel for Minnesota; and I assume Corporation Counsel will review this bill.
Two sections may need to be clarified.
The first section, in definitions (p. 2) says
"Permanent resident... No person shall be deemed to have gained or lost a residence simply
because of a person's presence or absence in compliance with military or naval orders of the
United States, or while engaged in aviation or navigation, or while a student in any institution of
learning."
The meaning of "you don `t gain or lose because of presence or absence" is difficult to
understand.
The second section, p. 3 item (2) says
"Nonresident military personnel, nonresident military dependents, nonresident students... shall be
excluded from the permanent, resident population base..."
This may contradict the first section.
Mahalo for your work on this important bill.
[1] "How to Draw Redistricting Plans That Will Stand Up in Court. " by Peter S Wattson, Senate Counsel,
Minnesota
Comm. No. (0 �• 1 y
Ref. To:
Ref. Dope F F R 1 6? n t ,
comments on Comm. 67, Bill 18 re. redistricting
by Cory Harden,PO Box 10265,Hilo, Occupied Hawaii 96721 mh @interpac.net 808 -968 -8965
for Hawai'i County Council, 9 AM Wednesday, February 16, 2011, Hilo
1 support changes in how we do redistricting, since the last effort was so contentious, but we need to act
with care.
The redistricting manual Ms. Ford used says "After the 1990 census 20 states had suits in state courts
concerning redistricting plans; 28 states had suits in federal court. Eleven states had suits in both state
and federal courts on the same plan. New York had cases in four different federal courts and three
different state courts." [1, p. 33] We need to act with care to protect the County from costly, time -
consuming, contentious lawsuits.
Mr. Yoshimoto was concerned because Ms. Ford didn't read original court decisions when writing this bill,
but used interpretations of court decisions from the manual. But 1 think that's okay, because it takes a
legal background to understand court decisions; the author of the manual has excellent credentials as
Senate Counsel for Minnesota; and 1 assume Corporation Counsel will review this bill.
Two sections may need to be clarified.
The first section in definitions (p. 2) says
"Permanent resident... No person shall be deemed to have gained or lost a residence simply
because of a person's presence or absence in compliance with military or naval orders of the
United States, or while engaged in aviation or navigation, or while a student in any institution of
learning."
The meaning of `you don't gain or lose because of presence or absence" is difficult to
understand.
The second section, p. 3 item (2) says
"Nonresident military personnel, nonresident military dependents, nonresident students... shall be
excluded from the permanent, resident population base..."
This may contradict the first section.
Mahalo for your work on this important bill.
[1] "How to Draw Redistricting Plans That Will Stand Up in Court, "by Peter S Wattson, Senate Counsel,
Minnesota
4
Ce
Slide � l,� WA
Plastic Planet I�ti
e h .
"Wale Ta W 'Iy John NCawr
Slide 2
f
Slide 3
Slide
Slide ,»
</. � � .
} ���
��/��
Slide
_. \
Slide 7z _
Slide 8
Jw, k
Slide 9
t�
r
Slide 10
Slide 11
Slide 12
Slide 16
ut r
Slide 17
r
f
M
4
Slide 18
� ,
,
Slide 13
Slide 14
4
Slide 15
^ �a
I
Slide 22
Slide 23
r
Slide 24
`'
Slide 19
Slide 20
Slide 21
G '
Slide 28
Slide 29
Slide 25
Slide 26
Slide 27