HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0406.004 2010-2012 07 ''
3
1 ��� �, (2 , 6L4c-ve5 \- - ye ° ,• • -'fi,si' / 4 . PIFC
Itinut(\h't ii)C\ +0SPC 0(1-,( CSC WN-4.9c094, .(k‘4 :7 P.A Ri CO
,,,i ) cS( .44%,1414.
SCI (� �s �
C;) 3 ✓ I F 7,34
= tilAkC_)_cr- ci-6 -A . -. _ t\i\ic\i "ni-KAN11.011ce
, a , -,-,
tie ciowtf-q. (7 (i(Okn a V\.■c (--) c-4-e 1 u-vee ‘ c) 6-c cr.z), ,....
, \ , se ), (-)V. °c,
�t1� l YC � � �=,....
tit a tv)c\c2).• e i l Cap , (3,,h5c 6, , ... =„).Li
i\c) , v__ L ,r__. 1.--. -- (.:_ \4-- , c A\
p 7\T Xcl 6 ce tininis
' -'• )A-t 'd- )e:--ir-±_ .
, I \ I ,fri< J L
-- cy'll1,.(.) Oil ( 1.0 - ( 1
..--- -e-
4 , , 0,clocced (:)00, c,'_t Y-1(((20(43)
\ e47e
) --0/ - . ‘ '
cs- ,), _:, ,.,,..-- (0 _. --(--QR 4 CIA° i
5 6 co-, ,
Vi. , v\, Q11- wee
(0 , cerkec.
'\,-e(C. ' 2_q'O 0
rxect:3) , ) ,_ =c) (IA cm vo -vy ,
. +04, .6-t 09 4e ' -ut/A, --ilie\ca-- PiAre .o o
LCV c/1,,\, . °:'°'
+inezn c_ ----ttti (fteuuts 0\ 011 . 'r ,1 217\>t iii*) 4 i-o"
.U`4i1 g■, S' YY\l'i (iVt9-VC LetNciCk VW-16 \111 1)14' A d 1
qA 6W )\IV\ 0* 1 rar,S gY1, RA, u 4 4
:A in --t L
')-eCK'IC-5 C\-) . Va0601 OLEAVA) Ut\tre9- )t \--, e.e-jrc2A,
SUBMITTED BY:
MARK McNEIT
R-\ticx u A () ,,,5--\--\_A Wb y\vt,q- Cr(Gz :1/4/147-4.
) W:- - - (
(A ( ,,.
an c) ,,cA0-'1 Tvo e.u,,, , __,„,„, „,
1 1 j ' tep ,/.■,0.& .
G&Q.tt. ),1 neVAr
c(1,0 cio
i • ) ,,,, - , 'Q
0._017.) --, ,- c4o- vrctiA-- cov(7,1-kfri etc. .
Va.„c\ c-i- Tn, -Lc-i -f-ici.-,QG\ufivi:17cL-c* C
J 1 C-...■■•
C\ WO-- (Neopt-e i, ---( 0/* cc\wItpiN,cr\y\
I
( 0 C) Qc& ik'Vec*acih 'Ce 01,57 -6 baiCe
PC.'\ C 1 C \ck-, (-' SX9j (ff VY-filice C, 0_0) '6 IA.
o- -Q_ RI' r• -,
, 1
t /
ar,Qc:.__ic c c€01641-- , i■ ott(tk \i .tge
6) csf\ -c cc Pciu-/-7-17 69--1/1, -A 'Agr ‘3(ilhcilet(1) -
c
--Q_,--4,:o„ •L'''\,0--VrQ1ViokiVe_c or) fi,,Q, ,,t . Tfit?pt< cor,), ,,tin---
Scl-_ ; ),n , ci--c(cr GcYd-ti) C, A\c'k3-1-2-1/6-h) c --il,OtiTo\
cc tpl. \Ma4 t , ,,ec.F--e'V\ OyCiNie\CAr -u-VI:di )
U ,:f ,,.-Va,(f1,64-41 ,I ciA\tcs.-Latv6V\
„.,n1A,
COUNTY OF HAWAII .STATE OF HAWAII
��,II J c Z 1 BILL NO. 78
POSTED _ 51M Draft 3
Dom: (9-'I � o
ORDINANCE NO. 05 85 v -�
— >rn
w =
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 2 OF THE HAWAII COUNTY CODE, AS
AMENDED, RELATING TO PUBLIC ACCESS, OPEN SPACE, AND NATURAL
RESOURCES PRESERVATION FUND.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE COUNTY OF HAWAII:
SECTION 1. The purpose of this ordinance is to: 1) provide a permanent funding source to be
used for acquiring lands or property entitlements for: land protection; public outdoor recreation
and education, including access to beaches and mountains; preservation of historical or culturally
important land areas and sites; protection of natural resources, including buffer zones;
preservation of forests, beaches, coastal areas and agricultural lands; and protection of watershed
lands to preserve water quality and water supply; and public access to, and enjoyment of public
lands and open space; 2) to establish the Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resources
Preservation Commission, and the Commission's duties; and, 3) to establish the protocol
necessary to carry out the requirements of this ordinance.
SECTION 2. The Hawai'i County Code, Chapter 2, is hereby amended by adding a new
article to read as follows:
Article 4L Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resources Preservation Fund
Section 2-225 Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resources Preservation Fund.
(a) A Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resources Preservation Fund is hereby
established. This special fund shall be administered and managed by the finance
department.
(b) The fund shall consist of monies from:
(1) The proceeds from the sale of any general obligation bonds, authorized and issued
for the purposes of this article;
(2) Council appropriations for the purposes of this article;
(3) Any source of revenue dedicated by the Hawaii County Charter or the Hawai'i
County Code for the purposes of this article; and
(4) Grants and private contributions intended for the purposes of this article.
•
(c) In adopting each fiscal year's operating budget, the council shall appropriate a minimum
of$250,000 to the Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resources Preservation Fund.
(1) When the unencumbered balance in the fund (exclusive of bond proceeds) equals or
exceeds $5,000,000, no further co, `q.tions shall be made until the balance
falls below$5,000,000.
(2) Nothing in this section shall prevent the Council from appropriating amounts in
excess of the above minimum amounts to this fund.
(d) The fund shall be used for acquiring lands or property entitlements in the county of
Hawai`i for the following purposes:
(1) Public outdoor recreation and education, including access to beaches and
mountains.
(2) Preservation of historic or culturally important land areas and sites.
(3) Protection of natural resources, including buffer zones.
(4) Preservation of forests, beaches, coastal areas, natural beauty and agricultural
lands.
(5) Protection of watershed lands to preserve water quality and water supply.
(e) There is established a Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resources Preservation
Commission. There shall be nine members on this commission, appointed by the Mayor
and confirmed by the Council. One member shall reside in each county council district.
Staff support shall be provided by the Finance Department. The duties and
responsibilities of this commission are:
(1) To develop an initial island-wide prioritized list of qualifying lands worthy of
preservation and submit it to the mayor. Priorities shall be listed on an island-
wide rather than district basis. The list shall include the significance of each
parcel or entitlement identified, the reason for its priority, and its anticipated use
after acquisition;
(2) To update this list at any time, but at least annually by December 31 of each
year; and
(3) To explore methods of funding land acquisition and make recommendations to
the Mayor.
(4) The commission shall give emphasis to land acquisitions where the county's
contribution can be leveraged to obtain state, federal, and/or private funds.
{f) The prioritized list developed by the commission shall be submitted to the Mayor for
comments and recommendation. Within 60 days after receipt, the Mayor will submit the
list to the council with comments and recommendations. The Council shall, by
resolution, select the land or lands to be preserved. Under no circumstances shall the
purchase price paid for a property exceed the appraised value as prepared by an
independent appraiser engaged by the county. Where there are multiple lands under
consideration at any one time, priority shall be given to coastal lands and lands where
matching funding is available to leverage the county contribution.
2
(g) Negotiations for acquisition of lands to be preserved shall occur between the County and
the seller or its commissioned agent, or a licensed broker only. The Commission shall
have no role in the negotiations other than in its advisory capacity.
(h) Appraisals, title reports, surveying and other costs incidental to the acquisition of land
shall be permitted uses of this fund. These costs shall be allocated equally between the
seller and the buyer.
(i) Adequate staff to carry out the provisions of this article and to manage the land acquired
shall be provided in the Department of Finance to maximize the use of available funds by
minimizing the payment of commission to outside agents to put together funding plans
and to ensure that the county is a good steward of any land that comes under its control
through this article.
SECTION 3. For initial members of the Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resources
Preservation Commission, the terms shall range in length from one to five years. Initial
members of this commission shall be appointed by the Mayor no later than August 31, 2005.
Within six months of appointment of the commission, an island-wide prioritized list of
qualifying lands worthy of preservation shall be developed by the commission.
SECTION 4. If any provision of this ordinance or the application thereof is held invalid, such
invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications of the ordinance which can he given
effect without the invalid provision or application, and to this end, the provisions of this
ordinance are declared to be severable.
SECTION 5. This ordinance shall take effect upon its approval.
INTRODUCED BY:
. iGi! =�
COUNCIL ti'n ER, COUNTY OF HAWAII
Hilo, Hawaii
Date of Introduction: May 4 , 2005
Date of 151 Reading: May 4, 2005
Date of 2nd Reading: June 1, 200 5
Effective Date: June 13, 2005
REFERENCE: COMM. 208.121
3
(g) Negotiations for acquisition of lands to be preserved shall occur between the County and
the seller or its commissioned agent, or a licensed broker only. The Commission shall
have no role in the negotiations other than in its advisory capacity.
(h) Appraisals, title reports, surveying and other costs incidental to the acquisition of land
shall be permitted uses of this fund. These costs shall be allocated equally between the
seller and the buyer.
(i) Adequate staff to carry out the provisions of this article and to manage the land acquired
shall be provided in the Department of Finance to maximize the use of available funds by
minimizing the payment of commission to outside agents to put together funding plans
and to ensure that the county is a good steward of any land that comes under its control
through this article.
SECTION 3. For initial members of the Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resources
Preservation Commission, the terms shall range in length from one to five years. Initial
members of this commission shall be appointed by the Mayor no later than August 31, 2005.
Within six months of appointment of the commission, an island-wide prioritized list of
qualifying lands worthy of preservation shall be developed by the commission.
SECTION 4. If any provision of this ordinance or the application thereof is held invalid, such
invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications of the ordinance which can he given
effect without the invalid provision or application, and to this end, the provisions of this
ordinance are declared to be severable.
SECTION 5. This ordinance shall take effect upon its approval.
INTRODUCED BY:
COUNCIL 'DER, COUNTY OF HAWAII
Hilo, Hawai`i
Date of Introduction: May 4 , 2005
Date of 1'' Reading: May 4, 2005
Date of 2nd Reading: June 1, 2005
Effective Date: June 13, 2005
REFERENCE: COMM. 208.121
3
Tr C/S-CotAC/t•CC
Tribune `�� �J•1>R 111
Herald. ,,,, ,.,
;Sunday,November Sr 2006 Proudlyfi Anil lit '.ndthi Sip itiairtdiriii"1923 rv„. . ._ " - i • •11
_.. }}//,qqyy�� NATION -,. - 1
90'0 Woman named leader Man aims to preserve _. l j Hawaii rolls past
of Episcopal Church quiet in nation's parks �' Utah State,63-1t
/ -A s •\ -z-+}�.;�.; Pa a A2 —. Page C1 1 V.,ga-Ltt kir:
pH/ Fa h.....
e in ui• id tea
Some area residents becoming homeowners thanks to self-help projec
By JASON ARMSTRONG houlcsle:ulcr w'a,%s,Irkiny 19 play to Ihu Ihrn Ihlov• WWII.I%a,ihu,rn NIIII hhank),II l 11,1111.)oil.` ,hr - t.t.h',Mt, h,aw-,
tribune Herold stall writer , build her very in%n tittelline. in lease one ill-III Tots the 1)11111. said of eelliuy Io!caw a lol ha 4U "I heir•.I Ion of it ILIr.:.
Ig91i,Ihlo%','_S vrar stmt n, "I wailed tin lit long.I tie ei has barb till.' ;hie`,in Milo 'I hr pr:11 at$1 :I cr:u lit t mt I.t nl,tu,n t
hrillnlr e Iuour,niner IN ahotll 11101112 III I fins nnutL Ill Eel S„ule- t'.Ill.11'tt.l kr,utt.ut Loh.l ail It,is like roam,d het nest urlchh,n. 1 I li/\i I I l. t
Paver.and she auuldn't hr bap- thinly.aculdll■•••said I'ilu■,whin'% Ioi.11eJ Ilcllind Ihinsr K111uo I'I:va. Noy knew bolt al.nit h hurl I hint ill
pier. ,pent till her lilt tin a.tale Depart- - a1 I'uuulakt 11ri•cl anal I<:nlnled )et utluntrin•tl 1.11 a sell help p1,I1 nIII.I- it sill.11, :
u,
\\'i/II Paint on her Eire Mid swell !rill ul II:1 :Man Molar Lands' r\scour. CO dial III, Ihrs I-I hrmla•,leatl tutu
on her shirt.the Natiie 11:maii:in %%aunty list lot a Iesidential I0,l,c. `all m) elr,h.I like Isaldl."thank lies the t e..11.-Il:♦fMIL III kohl See HOME:
Alter several years in the DAff: L Java bring
Y
makinli 1-lo>nualxo in Ka`u y out Crowd
is dedicated as a park`.- ` ''` Holu;llod Vill.l l C
'e _e tl`` C "fit'•tI' ,•t-n.. - Art [1011 .IIII,I�I lIt.:,
•J '�•'S`rgt• ••-.':' • By HAQLEY CATAt ANC)
y E W P LAC �� � . : I
•x 'p.•. - II 1111"11 I Ih I I ,...,. .
"
,ntllhnr II I I 11.1. I�1,r1.
J.n w Ihdo,Lla+JI t 51
PLAY l I:,:ILI.Ilnll I 'I' .. ...
T null, I t. .. .
G y ton L.I Ill I !I li I
Iaet t lilt, .ut., V(,,,,I .
.■(Alt,I utul.11!■ _I
By PETER SUR -\1r 11,.1 h:.,: li ;., I=
tribune Herald stall writer ,:atl I lolo d.,.. i. ,,I•,I' I .1.
II u,u, . l•I.,I. :
0111\I I) 11,1‘)All .. I h I - C
l n!I% t m ,I Pal 1•
i lull I) dl I a, run 4} ,,.`.e,e--.,.,r � svp•„,, .4,.. . -r. l ,( I !I I�_i
flak.t I ill n ha•nta n pal lit slit's .-� - I ll- a iIt
pn,:ni mars I„k 1 penal sties rs t+`y,a,•iti7. '-s0,r • - I I I,o, I 1 r...4
coastline bee hum _ Ir,.r:w
dr%rin nu•nl 1
l
'.., :-• Il an ill.. V
lhresi,lIt , az „' ., Ill, ,I 11 I I�c)
_.5 air sal l:uLl 11 .:„ - . :.?r _ It,mud w l Ii..l
null usin II ,'I �
Iutn•un I I,nt II ul., r.,' .. haul,Mk It • lh
Ulan I,t II,I.•„wq . AT-
.t1r,lnUt 1 1n.J - ., ": -- - ''" Ire, — •G itJ
Iv ka'n It ''''.",l' i. �)1 , • GPq
e h il. \ 1 REPLOGLE rryye� ti ;�``-•Iw �r .>,.'.',�,� N lair II ..yL ;
I d , lo, I .I r'""�st %'''d''w xs.+•`•�...^' "�,. I II !II'I ,/
,1111111%I`I,III .. ` 9 ^ -. + .., . 4"Em4,► '.:. ,•In,lr;.I.,L,Ir. 4 s2 'a' F>;-� 'a°Ft.' it�r,+- '-.
Ii drrtll.and _ �.i.,v'446''''.1,41o., '„si°°,s,;.: „�..;;
couilly hinds • it ii mil nt,u.. till 1„
•rA ,,,,,,, F4 ,. _ j1„ 5 shine,till,illlit I
„,„....... 111)!etl rz l6',IXet, i'1� r ,—,. Y N tK, ,,,,.�i t, .. 1 ....r
• .^ null unnw. dlt .I,n•,.
io,,,htl IIt n).%%1111 : '- : i,i” r 1 it "yy. + a ..;.-•
I $.1X111111 in Pn,Ile ,••,t..r ,r ° -f s .i ' die.0 ns,:IL n„ul.
gt �
�•p L� y� y [ ., .,y':. Ili,• uall,•,I ,Irc,l 11 1.0. tun
_ i don;nu,n, ht bu■ STANBRO 'Ib'•''r e t •sY'�• V .;rx a 1.e•. L ..
thl•:tu•rl ,n Ill,
the Plupeit\. . ,„.,.rI�.._,' . le 111111111y.I I„Inl. t„ rI ..
()ne III the rinri it ale,III the 'vy a .. .:• �' s. 1”"I' 1 1
puith,lsa••.Irlho I<cployle,IN Plt•'i c Ip
1 dt•ua III Ka I Ihmla(I I lunuepu,a 'i. S' ...• Fall:is,1 poll ill,a I.•, 1
y
1 loll b,1111 L•,.IIIl4•I 11 t ....
gong,it' nla•J mound the dc,nr Ill pia,flit .d..1::••1:. Ill.•1,,.t.! I
' keep Ihr I Iouu.Ipo i,lu:V}Clean and k
1 bee hull di,elupn•n1. ■' -
"Ipli%ulbelrl!rmuetlb,
1 I Ihr I1,,Iu.lb,.l\nI.∎, 1,...
,t%II II 1rt'IC Photos by PErEX SUN/Irltunr IfrrrlA
i
I lop photo:A panorama view of I lonuapo is;ern',awnlay.Above:Sb•Ihntl,Moll ut Sluunl.un I 1
♦k t tl:. -I
See PARK Vage Alt Vu•ty prepare;to eine,the oi can aIII I i Ii on Saloulay to yo,peal h;hl fly
u ,
.list.vn.�LUUr
iSee(OF ill
II•k-t!)' s;iid ,Ill' Nab icall■ millllen 111 ledct;Il money. the `dtld. ./,i,,,l;t,,,nninlleee011h'!rift he'd tl ll,
II 11)1 CSse,I that wtmlrtl put ten project's inl r;tslr uclurr was Lessee I)erek K:Ilai said ieu„ISIMI1 h(11011rnibune he•eeiJ,cel,n. al
SI
PAR K irant front page •
••■\•t• lt'uld cow down and •
nimp lick. :I. kids.Our parents
t,auld drop) us off and seas and
' 1 \\ant n to he here filrfuttnr
generations” Replogle slid. d
There was a problem, ho
4' ll
• e,et the kraal around the estu- .«, 1.� 04 ,, : • h
;u\ \\a\ t�wnrd by I.antl('o. a a
l;h((((int. real et,tatl,'ctllllany, ' A' ' A /.r \ n .__. .
• atNl \I:Iletilal'ds'wt'IaI)I11eIlt• 1 ►` ♦ :+.ter .■
\\t.' Ill\I ',laded' 11111 at Itrsl, -•...tam ` w. nn � " .: ,'a +" ,•'e` .• n
• 4 Y
coming, to see ,what we could s..,�`'�-'"�M1. ,, ` •Y
•
(It, to noted IIII\ !1l c but + ^� .. ... y .•we didn't knoV'-alnything -- a ,� .c 1,_ ,Art, '0..� + f...,. : `e _LL' '" b•
Replaglc •old. �" �.'"" ,rte-•-.-_ , . 4�;,; ''r;. i- n
I Hier lash Stanblo, a project tav" . y .,.r,L r+p," " ,. 1 ,:,:: AS �■
• iti: )■1 k.•I h,I the nt,ti!)rl)lit•.IYust V',
tar l'ubll. Land, who shepherd- ,
ed the I don W!h) *lull!)thro I..h y 0 �'" ' ,, fl-the steps needed to acquire die • x , 4 ,, ,,1'2,' t - • . �•, , ,,.
• land. n a, X:G+. d. W0.'r ..M t 'e , t ,1 f, ;
..II took on a 111e of its oVn,' .+ ttt.. w �.. 4,;',.:, �i '' • 'EM! 1�1Y.�\ N
• Replogle said. 4 .1�"' z.. •4-',.'.
Ka'u ('uuneillnan Bob ,;,`., ,.K�n+:i., - .• a
.facolium introduced a ;rte*' K';n; t
5500 00(I;tl)f)Ittl)I lalion Co buy T :� x .. _ 1
, the'land bum l:and('o: Slue ;.'4• ' ,,.1 ,a- . „" ". "",- `�"'' $ I)
.w„ 4� ii
KC!). B01)'I lerkes and Sett: • ..: . i;1∎iiont4 'y:.- ' , v,_.t..=-Z..,-k .env.. -----
—
Russell Kukubun got the state . WILLIAM ING/Tribune-Herald
fl
II)INIn\ up$1 million toW rd A group of people fish from the rocks Saturday at the Honaupo park. d
the pin,!lase, and Ilawaii', • rt
cangressitmnaldeleg,tics v---- Sen.. which is to preserve this site in • tnuinent of silence for Bernard get rolling;' Replogle said..
I4anii•I Inouye and Rep.Ed perpetuity;'said Patty Belcher, Keiiikoa and.Ka'u Prescrva- • Then the hand, led by Kurt ' I'
Case ; added $1,5 million . a member of the'Trust for Pub- .lion President Keola Iianoa, be la Cruz, kicked off the cel- '-
hont the federal Estuary Pro- lie Land, as she looked out over who died in March. 1Ianoa's ebration,which lasted until It
, teetion I;Und. the estuary. widower,Earl Louis, is now., - 3:30 p.m.
'I,and('u. iar its part. Among the officials rec- the Ka'u Preservation vice Councilman Jacobson felt an • n
Liitcked $I((1,II0t)oil its$3.4 'ogniied at the dedication ' president. • "inexpressible happiness that
Million asking price and agreed were('use, I lerkes, Kokuhun, "We went to the County ' this was being done„
to keep the property.off the Jacobson, ('ouncilmau) K. Council. We talked about say- Ile also said that the efforts
market until "I•I'I.could acquire Angel Pilagu. Department of ing this area;' he said. of the late Jerry Rothstein, • r
enough funds to buy it. Land and Natural Res(murces' . "I'm happy the way it turned president of Public Access
The deal closed I)ee. 24, Chairman l'ai'r Young, Hawaii '..out. It's nice to he here and see, Shoreline Hawaii,were"criti-
?O05:after which the land Volcanoes National Park Super- the energy," Lester said. cal".in acquiring the land. c.
was Owned by the state, which intendant Cindy Orlando and • The effort to raise money Ka Ohana O Honuupo was d
hammed iiaver to Hawaii. Mark Lester, the president of was sue successful that even recently granted nonprofit sta- tl
('aunts. • I.andCo. after enough was received to tus,and will next establish a I
Saturday's dedication ser- Alter introducing them, acquire the parcel,an addition- Memorandum of understanding o
vices,,lere held at nearby Whit- Stanhro turned to the assent- al $75,000came in, • with the county Department of II
Iington IieacIi.11ark.. Pualani bled crowd and told them "this "This money will he a good Parks and Recreation over the . n,
.Kanakaole Kanahele rave a same group-of people can work seed money for us to hopefully stewardshij Of the site. _ d
blessimt' in I Iawaiinn, and her ' together again somewhere else sock away and use it as a base On the Internet: http://n'n•1v. if
I!Alan O Kckuhi performed a • in your district to make this for doing other thi)igs at Honu- .hotttrrtpupctrk:org - st
hula La)iiho. • thing happen:' apo when we have our agree- Peter.Sur can be reached at al
"\1v hope is being realized,. The ceremony included a 1ient with the county, and we p rur(a)hmtaiirribune_herrdd.com.
pI
COFFEE.From front page``'.
ill
tit
in
V to the ,erne was the around." -- Hundreds I)
Male O Kona, a barbershop- The company's sample ,' of tourists' of
•..,stw!e. four•part ac Ipella group table was set up in front of *i • and locals
tchrl pertornled up and down the gallery of Shelly Matm V sley. �''14, - packed the ;It
the.street.The singers.who are White, a close friend of the "" street of t)'
part of )Veet Adeline; Inter- Bolton family. : .- Holualoa th
m16011,11. pleased. t h e'coffee For Kona Art Gallery owner - ' ' , ' . Village for S.
taVd ''"..1111 I law:Man songs Elizabeth 'I'heriault, the day the$th
•
4
letters @hawaiitribune-heratd.com J- n_'•un Hie` "2,
y
.
�� Notable
115 �t �,,.: 1 quotes
- .* / clooc, n EWS, / ���,,.._ • `The press can hold its
y glass up to our
44 I .' CilwsY1� , , magnifying g P
problems.Or they can use
3UDGrE Mu t, that magnifying glass to light
` ' QW UTO 1 •y; ;'r.) ants on fire. .:.The press is
�, our immune system. If they
• . PQS'f. • "'"1 overreact to everything, we get
•he _ ��.::, �'' sicker."
z ,�c \-vm, - Comedy Centrnl's Jon
y i 'l a .
r' n �/� i 1 r Stewart, lambasting cable TV
'. , 1111.1��;,. 1�lsl�� ri//�f�.ii mill �, news for amplifying outra-
i�� " =,ly�. _ m_---,/..-', l - genus statements, stoking fear
'� -r.�'Y.� ���/ , v= and seeking confrontation.
•"I know that we're in the '
•
n l days of a campaign. So
f _ snot surprising that we're - '
• ) 5 seeing this heated rhetoric. ...
:"•
P F But when the ballots are cast•
• and the voting is dow,we •eed
`;: ` fr' ' I But
re lei11 ` i , i
riot io address Satttx'day. --C—.I
g an 1 ' v c'' -< •
ar, 2.-. - n
• {
arm a Tribune - Herald en or
are
ild
The Tribune-Herald makes • Our 'View er. Besides proposing some
of the following endorsements awful legislation (the"tent
• for candidates, charter amend- - bill," among others),she seems
ments and state initiatives STATE SENATOR,2nd Dis- es Marlene Hapai (R). unwilling to question Mayor
appearing on the Nov.2 ballot: trict Billy Kenoi's spending,propos-
The Tribune-Herald endors- STATE REPRESENTATIVE,5th als, and she voted for his hefty
ina, U.S.SENATOR,Hawaii es Russell Kokubun (D). District property tax increases.
No endorsement. The Tribune-Herald endors- Fred Bias has had trouble
,e STATE REPRESENTATIVE,1st es Robert Herkes (D). articulating where he stands
U.S.REPRESENTATIVE,2nd District on certain issues, but his
in Congressional District No endorsement. STATE REPRESENTATIVE,6th grass-roots approach is
has No endorsement. District refreshing.He deserves a
lip- STATE REPRESENTATIVE, No endorsement. chance to show us what he can
;h GOVERNOR/LIEUTENANT 2nd District do on the council.
has GOVERNOR No endorsement. STATE REPRESENTATIVE,7th The Tribune-Herald endors
e. Former U.S. Rep. Neil District es Bias.
ped Abercrombie (D) is experi- STATE REPRESENTATIVE,3rd No endorsement.
ii- enced and feisty,but we fear District COUNTY COUNCIL 6th Dis-
his left-leaning nature will The Tribune-Herald endors- COUNTY COUNCIL 5th Dis- trict
result in more taxes, fewer es Clift Tsuji (D). trict Incumbent Guy Enriques
le jobs and bigger government. Incumbent Emily Naeole- has been a disappointment.
th Duke Aiona (R) is far STATE REPRESENTATIVE,4th Beason's heart is in the right We believe he is out of touch
it" more conservative than Linda District place, but she has worn out her with many of the people in his
Lingle—and that worries us The Tribune-Herald endors- welcome as a county lawmak- district, and his lack of humil-
hat —but he can be trusted to ity has been troubling.
08, fight the Democrat-con- .�,'�";`,q�";�L ' r .Zk , h Enriques voted in favor of ,
trolled Legislature's inevi- �' 4±` v '' Kenoi's property tax hikes,
table attempts to squeeze "b'' 4' «& i and he seems unwilling ,
a- more money out of busi" r ,4,',..0 ' `,1,„ .• to scrutinize the mayor's
ably nesses and taxpayers. �' ,,V4 X ';"t 44 ` budget requests—includ-
so, More than anything, 1, '.-,:t �' a: . ',`U. ,`.; t, k 4 f.,,` 1., ing his recent proposal to
nal though. the choice boils ""'�`t -{""` borrow $56 million.
;o, More than anything, 4' <. .� , '.'c. `, ing his recent proposal to
al though, the choice boils y` '' n {' ' t ."' borrow$56 million.
. down to this: Hawaii � ,, ,, Brittany Smart is
simply cannot afford to AR►-/ .,0 4110 ,4„,::„., .0- °,,," young and inexperienced,
return to the days when ,'', • .,"i n �y � ). but she's also bright and
one political party con- ',, f�'' (1:4'-'' ti ' �1 ','�' thoughtful.We think she'll
trots both the executive .,:.y ' ,AK.'", e f •_ - '. '' ' a work hard to represent the
and legislative branches. - , 0 ,� �. „',t,; , •rA diverse needs of the 6th•
One-party rule is bad for � " . '-"" °•)* 1�0.� . .: District.
Hawaii —especially dur- :9 .11„;-.,,,-'• :- 4sit.0114 ,� .. The Tribune-Herald
;e ing these troubling eco- i ,,� �'ri. � w%:�f.;,'�a.`-: i endorses Smart. •
nomic times. 1/ . , .. 4•, „,, ii!,.-.,-11 t
. The Tribune-Herald ' BOARD OF EDUCATION
endorses Aiona for gov- No endorsement.
ernor and Lynn Finnegan `o - -
he (R) for lieutenant gover- I%I OA Dlf.R HERE,the L'>;As1 'roucAN Do IS G'E OFF OHA TRUSTEE
nor. YOUR CO(KN AND&O VOTt.' No endorsement.
AS
Our recommendations on ballot measures
lees
STATE time and money. Vote NO. Charter Proposal 9 — Relat- Charter Proposal 14 — Relat-
Constitutional Amendment No. ing to Data Systems: This ing to terms of merit appeals
l —Relating to the Board of Charter Proposal 4 — Re/at- amendment would rename the board membership: This
Education: Electing members ing to civil service laws: This Data Systems Department and amendment would bring the
-nd of the BOE has been a failure. amendment would delete from move it to a different article of appeals board in compliance
It's time to try something new. the charter references to civil the charter. It has no signifi- with the charter has no signifi-
' We like the idea of making service laws, which are the cant impact. Vote YES. cant impact.Vote YES.
Is
i the governor responsible for jurisdiction of the state. Vote
appointing members of the YES. Charter Proposal 10— Relat- Charter Proposal 15 — Relat-
es
hoard. Vote YES. ing to the Fire Department: ing to removal of directors
Char ter l'ruposal5—Relating This would move the depart- serving under commissions:
. Constitutional Amendment No. to.the reapportionment cam- ment to a different article of We think this proposal is too
2—Relatinsg to tax refunds: mission: We like the part of the charter. It has no signifi- cumbersome and overly com-
The Legislature is often reek- this amendment that requires cant impact. Vote YES. plicated, and will result in
less and irresponsible with the commission to create a wasted time and money. Vote
tax revenue. We urge voters report detailing the reasons for Charter Proposal 11 —Relat- NO.
ho to reject this attempt by state its redistricting plans. Unfortu- ing to the dudes of the direc-
iti- lawmakers to create more nately, the rest of the proposal
tor of Environmental Manage- Charter Proposal 16 —Relat-
ways to spend our money. is too cumbersome. Vote NO. meet: This would allow the ing to appointment of charter
Vote NO. commission members: Char-
n d
_ Charter Proposal 6 — Relat- mayor to assign the director ter commissioners don't need
of the Department of Environ-
._ • COUNTY ing to preservation of natural more time to complete their
mental Management duties in
1e Charter Proposal 1 Relating and cultural resources: This work. Vote NO.
to the establishment of an open amendment was modeled after addition to the charter-man-
�o- space fund: We think this puts an article in the state Consti- dated role of managing solid Charter Proposal 17—Relat-
unnecessary restrictions on the tution, but it's overly vague Waste, wastewater and recy- ing to membership on hoards
executive branch and the coun- and potentially more restrictive cling. We see no reason for and commissions:We think the
this change. Vote NO.
ty budget process, especially —especially when it comes to current system for compensat-
during tough econorriic times. the rights of landowners. Vote ing members of boards and
-- Vote NO. NO. Charter Proposal 12 Relat- commissions is fine. Vote NO..
ing to, the qualifications of .
l Charter Proposal 2—Relating Charter Proposal 7 --7 Relat the director of environmen- Charter Proposed 18—Relat
to recall: There's no valid rea- ing to grammar, spelling and tat management: We think ing to electronic posting of
son to soften the requirements formatting of the charter: It's its smart to require that the special meeting notices: This
for recalling elected officials. hard to believe voters are being director has an engineering or is a reasonable attempt to give
The best remedy for replacing asked to bother with an amend- related degree. Vote YES. the public more ways to learn
politicians who don't perform ment to fix typos and punc- when a special meeting will
adequately is simply to vote tuation. That said, there's no Charter Proposal 13—Relat- occur. Vote YES. ,
them out of bffice. Vote NO. ' reason to oppose this non-con- ing to the duties,of the pros-
troversiat proposal.Vote YES. ecuting attorney:This amend- Charter Proposal 19 Relat-
- Charter Proposal 3 — Relat- ment, which would expand ing to publication of notices
ing .to charter amendment Charter Proposal 8 — Relat- some of the duties of the via an electronic medium:The•
petitions: There are 19 char- ing to the Department of Water county prosecutor, looks good current system is fine. Public
ter amendments on the Nov. 2 Supply:This amendment would on paper, but we're concerned notices are already published at
c ballot. Do you really want to change the titles of two county it's overly broad and open to no additional charge via elec-
6 make it easier to create more of officials. It has no significant interpretation — and abuse. tronic media, such as newspa-
them?Bad idea,and a waste of impact. Vote YES. Vote NO. per websites. Vote NO. .:
(I
G
V ideN 4..6, 14 6_,c 1 Ks
D iok5IJi
C UN Y QF ERK
p OSTIED HAWAII
201! OCT 17 AN II: 57
LI a .-• ,= fit (.1..4 -1 T O •I CI"
; '' � -
. r - `Z ? L.: s^ - ^�`
..
n 7-1. - ?
r - . C C ! - ...0 a b."a "�• •
rw
*3343,33 3
_ .
i ' 'r .. — Z !.
.= J -. re', +r ^ -.-+ . -. .-� I _ �- A
.fie f y � .
-
:� " .. -- r r, s < r. H•..J - 1, •— . :7 J .J n.. .J.• — ^ c-sd�
it
4. ,^ --••• y _ .+
^ f ... / aa, ! °tip•
r. 1
_ ^ •'' ^ -'• -- - '` ..._ r " ( /- ^" l
r --. _ ~ r P` .5 .. ^ ... ^ d.
_ v 1 ^
ofts
/5- ..-. ^ �. 4.-,-. I o� i. Om
.. 7: - f ! J r� 1'�
r -- .- _+- f J _ gt
^ n om. r �� .-.4 1
.1.
- y
r -
I .. _
r + _ ✓
-
•
__` ..
eN r
/ - • 'It is l_l 111 I h I hu}c p1 I•.:1 \\:n uu.v-
k' %%/////� ���I/I , %r• I l of 1 I,C I it I i lire 111,1.I pt II,01111.1.11i:1
� ` ,
Iti x1��l,7?!r"/�I'+l/// i I d.:1,,l I I j 1 - -
w. ,� IYoI u( r Hrnuurr r,rococo aunn•r Jw du'1. �.. //oucohdlr 1ilrn elll,rr.cols qtr,111 rl.Ulnr ls]net
, , ; 11 cot- llrrrls.1)ri ll r nnrl w Inc turn lLurAv air roan• .
/' nF.l'i�Q i !�/d'�A.l•': /r tutu r rr lU/crud Nrnld IGu I!rnmur rir in
:- ,�� .w P QT "�� !`: '! `jam•' "1+. �,_• y Iluuuii.. . .
•"." .•.r - _r ,�,v • .-am�,S��•� ter- jS/yi ` \lC ••Vs' .tic 111e11:11 111?'lu�i•Irbr:dc luluun.,,i it•. / �, j ' r ' —__ lrlan ,_ ht 1 /\11:d Ilaul.11i .I„Iwr„lullu Uu1,111 .•
1. j•. ;4.4 , 7/:', — "�"- V �a ' _ �i1.'.• �� ,n, It•aln,l tiadd:wl I lu,,.•iu null,corn ulh
,. _ •I••ti�,`,..l�lf / .. .„ �,i l.`-. � - - -E .-�",�= - u. iu,ctl rrl.rui oliup huudlcads.+I.Idaho coat
-x^C' — . ,$ (�"` j" �-j.. --- _ '_ ' `� ko 4\ etiildreis•flrllur111L,I,I11C Il,lle;1111,Iiis!killing I•IK.
(e it ArY ry,�(ol f ardllAw/vt 7( IruplF_!1 a mar T _ \ •
•
Our View ,
election recommendations
. ,
The Tribune-Herald ' s
hr I Ilhunr I Irr,ld Inge,suppun lot ''LVI I•.Itha'Nlal•.,\'I rVI'll'I':-I)islrirl .Senate ronlirinatiuu.This amendment would special l,ulpu,c revenue bonds and use the
T
ow Glllowing candidates and Ircow Uinurrf,t('hli'I-wji vv.Kcpuhht;llt erode power that should reutait wills Ills proceeds IioI i die bonds to assist al:ricuhhr.
ni nd;niun,on initiatives in I'ucsd:w', 1:lhiau'1'o'ih,o Nu cndorsen)elli. . .executive branch. at enh•rprisr,arrving inqunlam.II euhur:d
lauds'!
canal election(our picks are listed
Ill bald. "denote,incumbent): 1I A 1.F.Itha'ItICtiI:N II l\'I?-District 4 "2.Shall the Constitution he amended to Our view:1'1•:S Agriculture is an
D.•mm.1m 1 aye I lanulunm vs.Republican provide for a salary commission n'review important part of I Iaw,u1\economy.and it
I'.S.SENA'IOlt Brian)ullla11,.. I iheil,nIan Aalrnl Airlcl- and reeu111111e111 saL•u«'%din ft1Surc, fodl•t. dust.e,ltii„m1' 'I „h,Ihr]•Ic,cnue
'it'll I gill Ak,lka has x•ncd I l:nyaii well. still.NO eod11i•seuleul. Slane IegiSktuls hit gU,CInUl.the heuleu bond,That is i uouul]mowed by utilities
Ina thin didn't slop us from endorsing Rep. and glrvcrnor,the administrative thwelul.ill - ulaoHlacn11 101,oper.uhuu,,heaths,ale Rauh
lies.government housing project,;md 1,111
1.11 t';nr ill Ow primary \Vc argued Ihen,:Ind ti 1 Al I.Ith.l'Itl•Sh:N'fA'I'1\'I:-District S ,Ise slate,slate ilep:uvnint head,col Cxrca I
,lilt Mlles.•.Ihai ii lime for new leadership I hum...tIt Itohell I lerkes'vs.Repuldican live ollicers or the executive ik iililw,lit, ens.
ill the Setime.,whvrr Hawaii Asks a,uddeh .1'11,11 ir,I lu,ley Ni,elidlll•se111C11(. 'and the(hinnies or assistants to d.paitols•lll A111•:NI)111:N'I"fO'hlll•:
lo„of se1111nily if Akaka anti/1,r Sen.1)an - heads of the executive departments,esclud I IA1I.: I('OI T.1.'COD:•:
inynr:II uuul+lr 11,lini,h their terms.We STMT.It l•:I'Ithal•:N'I 1;1'I\'1•:-District 7 mg the superintendent of educiniou and Ihr Ballot qui,lion I:Should the I I:oyoii
also le direr \k;lka',rvornu•liberal vimng "C""""I('indvdivans ,s.Itrpuhhre]II prcsilenl of the l.lnisrl:,lIi or IloWa11' County Cade be:1,I li.ii 11,r:rucuk I
Irrn111 1,nod in,k•p viilh Ihr average Il.nvali N illi:con Sant SIII Ni,endursem.iii ()or view•:NO This would dint..uuritcI percent Lrl real properly Su ItI I I:I\u•crnurs anuu
rd•,idrnl.\Vlulr oipouent(1'nlhia'I'hielen.. unnecessary level 111 guvernmeol ;dly 1L1 Me I'uhlii Access.Open Spat.1511
,I Rrp11h1n,u'•i,uupuwtn con the Inllilnal OFFI('I•.01.11ANVAIIA\,\FPAIRti
_. NaI111,d 1:s N11111 r,Pit 1,am,',Ivnd.'
a,r}'..we Ihu1k II,11'1,l''h'replace the 1.t'_. Call u,cold I;I,hitiurll,bud ss•drrlim•t„ i.Shall the mandatary retueinuu agt col Ow ,irvv:NO I'hi,i,au osiily li.,l tit
air old Akak;1. rudul,c:my 011A r:unlidah•,bei:wx we /11 din all stale court justices 1111(1 judges be
I I lac nuualoc 111111 15 1111111 tic ow ell∎ ie l
feel this race is hest lift 10 Illy I I:og11u111 repeated'!
inllllllllllll\'111,1111 VIII. county 1.'1 wt'11lllll'151 11111 111;1 I..Ill■l'JI, lit
1'.1.its:1'Ith:51:N'i)1'I'IYI: Our view':NO Thews is nu cu11q'clho. Suucrpl col nruul.tuly,dying,IuI.Iptu.
Cungrc,siunal Dislricl 2 Il.utin 11,L1rtllgcille nlaulkduly JrIiItlIltIll ,pate i,.'plr.aliu;',bud this inlbemsc wrulJ
\\r.ouhlnl III.'1'1111 1111conscience.SCSI 5 • • COI'1l'1'COI i\('11.111:.\181:12 prevision,which L'IISIIICS Illn11"e1 col judge` du Ilnllr II:uIII thou gaud
I Irnn,rl,ll\lark 1 111 II 1 lino veins ago when District
(rain'Salo il.' vs Nudity Naeole.Ni, and:rvoids wnle of the problems associated
dlt LuI,..dual I.iuda Linpic,and we caning with lifetime judicial appointments • A;\II.vllll,\IS It) 1111•.
,11doni hid nova.She had a:l undistinguished eudurscnn•o(_ - __ ' II;U\'All COVN'I'Y CIRIt1'RR •
•...obi as lieutenant gu,rnml in the Carela- !.Sh;dl the('un,tiluuu❑of Ih.11.uc o1 1pH',Inu] I and!bulb dial wish uaul.
nn al11ui Iii lI 11111 ,old,he has heel]virtu ally (Ot,Nll.('OsI1('11,111(11111•:8
District 7 Ilesvali be amended I()'amide that ill tut ]lunges lot various departments in,outly
la i111.‘111:.d col 111 oon ill Ihr fun'al Ic since her lillllnll,sexual Ussaldl et Ones against'moots government texample-.changing the Hank.
laded 'ubrnleIhIII Intl.Is Mal Iradcrshil,•' 1'urini;l slxll' v,.ISlrnda Ivld Ni, -
i',11111.11.,',Ilhh t,nl Bob ill"Ilt•would he'1 rtdursemenl.
younger llgCi'111:111 I.1)'eat,rd ape,Ifni Lt'l!1,1:1 col the-tile drpal'I ll ll'lll"In"1101\air Fite
\\
I k lure may define: Depart lni i.-
-mimic,choice Ion I Imvaii. I I 1\V'Iu helms col cun,ululc,a cunluw Uur,irw \\C h;1]c 111,npiuiun as In
1\1111)\II NIS IO'1IIF.
ti I VI 1.:(o t I Ii t'I IO\ IIr course of conduct and whether the names col the departments
• 1111(NR\(llt , constitutes
,ii,.-I easy.1;o, Linda Lingle I Shull the g cost our be required 11,select l_I\Vha1 ron,uurts Ihr jury unanimity should be changed.Amore nur11•,ung vacs
l.r,l o11I.•Ildtil,l•III1911 weirs b.luli,and' 110.101 0l repents candidates 1111111 a pool of that is requued tier a el'IlS WIII,li.' lion IS Du Ihr vied,col lilt lair 1,1:11111 cult
r`�1,• ..,ImiJ n again for her tin•Ir„ III] l' llualiIirll raudldalt•s Sirciutll and proposed Our view:VI'S.pri,ecmul,and kiss livid 11,hi hollered with thus''We'd like 11,
•1..!'rl II l5III lei:tiled in the Ii'hl direction 1'y.o Candid:lle ad]is111y&mutcil for the enforcement officials staliwidi suppou 11115 see a dilitrenl process by which department
l hoard of lel:eIu,of the University of Ilawaii amendment,which would make II casiCr It, manes Call he Changed,without haying to get
lard v„Ii•.ii 1111,nation.Particular' admit, n pn,cidcd by has+:' put six of behind bars and make II einhlll diem vutcrs and clog up the ballot
bl I h:r,burn irr push hI dr elmalin•Ihr bro. Our view:NO. l ht current system works harder for Ihemt Ill r free on a let'lllliiality
kit bloated Department or ktIticalion.She g1.
hoc 'Hie go]enun should he allowed to Question I,could allow adonis who Ill
has 110.-11,I,maul,elletov headed Idespile a .hoo,i 11,,1,r irr awn c:uulidalis,suhjrel 11, 5.Shall the slate he unlhuri/Cd dual„tic a vac:ukty and Se]IC less Ib,w Iwo
1 i;'.1,1.1111m 11141 I•nG1111s s.1 sl I ,coat shun' a rill 11;I 11 1111111] build 1,1 rti111
orhl,Ill,.11111 h 111,rocs a,c.uud 1e1 111 �- ' _... A/,1.,Ivs,l i,1;i',"i+••• m1„11 I1 he rh isle fur momma-
' J lino I 1'It'll-I Ind,11rud •n svhu
1 Ih I 1 f\.\\I ('O\ lI 151,11 l` aunt.1 Full lieu may he reap
\1 II I V 1 I nwnl',sn coal:Ilig shwd Iles )� pointed,but replacement nItnlheis
nl,li.o bIa a lunplhn'choice In the rase lot. • J.r I, .51„... pointed,• uuuut.Our view:1'I?S
Iii nl 11 lit 1.0%t'l 1101.11111 iurw11hi111.1: s i .. ) ' I •
Ihkfl :\Iona lea,lid I,UI In he a}null VOTE.-
l
1,11 mil I.,i Go, I.un;alt The two nn.Ike.u] { -__ — I I.. ( nabs 1I1111i I plcnucl led htr.lie
no
ell 1, ir.11u and Aiona's criminal IIlllV _L_ _ __ �� /+ ` • O,'t I all 51111 tat 111nenl I.r111nIIr loot
Il.. h- I ern;m,sect III list admit- - i5 IIC�.CIC!'l_'t Q� P ..
I,1,au1 n'\\'llv onus V.•nh xkrtes,'!Krrp Iii 1.F�T -11M-1-Ti :,liUdslinger B I - '`•'S ''\ ( , '{ r 1,,n h 1.'t 1.h uuI rui luuuhru 11001
.too 111m.1:1 1 1 1 1 giant Aluna a second team r - 1 qualified Sol r. 1 1,1 1 1 1 1 I ,Ih,uu
- i O lCF SBYV! ray ,O varr I ter,.. ` ?pun rn]col registered wlrls 111
- •S
�8�. C1 - .-If *** . 1 I °x.+A'Yr••'r•• 'r Iii I/1 1 1 pcner t election.\VIM,.
Ian I Ill tih:\11'1 11'1•:-1)hilis ll 2 O VOit v) I ti's ro 1 con able 11,;rl:uc 11111 ks
rd Icily('h m v,.It coil. li:l0 * ,,a''AA•��•('�•,��77 Nast _i lull Ill] ,at think chtoging the
lhalon\'aonen,I.Nu endoru'rnenl. -7_ �O� NWLIpIVCIs M \.tAA.t I,._ nunthtn 11, peicenl col rcgrdtacJ
_. ... `` -- �A GNER ,a I ,, t t• I valets Is Urdi hlgh amt would ats.
F`. t 0 D Ern TE gi'- j G I' it r I, recall churls unreasonably dint
,I ribune Herald j * , F11"� L--- _-_ rata.V01c N(1.
S in� .r
wrk ✓” Out nun 5 would Femme the
Trd Dixon.k islI hlr I r 1 1 ('1M
David Bock I.o1..I f I•'' `.' - -- •( u�JJIM .._ 4 rilluu nut dial 1 tell tic.urily•
jorar'css t unhu,he!MINIMS'h] people_
Alice SleAge,A Iv rt 1,,q Uneaten I im333:1-. J.-.--. ��(�IAI i/R) T , - --- , it 1 petition,I I i i 1
' .yJ ��tt\�, _- align Ie,ptl o n na cols.
BM CrawlurA.Cnu feu n DntUUr. r.�r a 1._1 ( l' ndlnn, 11111 r I
} t t e ndnntnn
' Kathy higakl Utbte Mutant.' 1,„,.:.........,. I I - cot
gTI�EI, N \3 °'l
Arlan Vierra l4.IJucuarn Sywea•,Manager • eau AtN.1k w..”' . ) / coI Illlpeai llitielnt el lures.That's a
{ �/ gaud change,but Ih.same 11111101
ij 3 r {f { i 1 \ (11/� tuncnd11W11f Idsu would retuwe
k
rr o Wilton r�nr Ind f . .,,,,�H.H 1
�3 �r•.� /4 "' -k- ,r• <!� " ' '' .1:. y1% Ile requirement that inanity
n I In.,.._rr o v >> , _ }' s 1.r' :uldlis,he rovided by -Wm_Who'
,r tiled) M a nt4'- .-` I (-Idyll_ J' "'. r / 1
1_�' .j am \i • ` sign petitions for recall of elected
rr r .rllr fall. ;� '_ L. ulliik;ls IA•r;wSi of that flaw,we
'ti, a`. �" mgr a NO vote.
•
1v '' , _ C®lJ '
DIc7
i.
Candidate 0 - Page 1
Printed on 11108/2006 at 12.3923 am
Y y
;, '. r`• Hawaii Department of Civil Service Name
3 - *$,_ T :, r f Changes 71 of 71
�Y,
is �� YES 22.028 45.4`;:
ors - NO 21.902208714455°:247;o:
20 45.2%
F, Blank Votes 4.538 9.4%
- --_-- Over Votes 15 0.0%
GREENWELL, KELLY HECHT, DEBBIE Hawaii'Fire Department Name Change
71 of 71
CANDIDATE Age:69 Age:59 YES 33,150 68.3%
Occupation:Landscape contrac- Occupation: NO 2.320 24 8%
BIOGRAPHY pation:Retired real estate
tor;nurseryman broker/investor/developer/ Blank Voles 3,310 0 0%
Residence:Keahole property manager Over Voles: 15 0.0%
Education:Four years of col- Residence:Kailua-Kona Hawaii Terms of Board or Commission
lege(Arizona State,University of Education:Bachelor's degree Members 71 of 71
Hawaii) in education
Fun fact:(left blank) Fun fact:I am an avid tennis YES 24,424 50 4%
player,love to garden,snorkel, - NO 19.153 39 5%
hike,body surf,read and write. Blank Voles: 4,909 10.1%
Over Votes: 15 0.0%
Hawaii:Impeachment Petitions
1.Why Because I was born in Kona,I I can do the job!Being a small- 71 of 71
should can appreciate the changes that business owner,real estate YES 27,521 56.7%
people vote have occurred,both cultural and broker/investor for 3"0-plus years NO 15.900 32.6%
physical.I have a better under- will help me to be an effective Blank Votes 5.056 10.4%
for you? standing of how it all happened, council member.I enjoy work- Over Votes 24 0.0%
what to avoid in the future,and ing with community groups,
what may have been lost.I also problem-solving,negotiating Hawaii:Petitions for Initiative,Referendum,
see that which has been real- and seeking win-win agree- Recall:or Charter Amendment Revision 71 0171
ized,what has been found,and ments.I worked as a council leg- YES 28.938 59 7%
what makes this a wonderful islative aide reviewing budgets, NO 15 058 31 0%
place worth keeping. researching issues and writing Blank Voles 4.483 9.2%
legislation.I was the lead writer Over Votes 22 0.0%
for the League of Women Voters Hawaii.Public Access.Open Space.and
for Initiative and Referendum Fund Resources Preservation Fd 71 or 71
(approved 2008).I submitted
amendments to the Charter FOR 27.566 56.8%
Commission and argued points AGAINST 16.135 33.3%
on recall,impeachment,land Blank Votes 4.780 9.9%
fund,filling vacancies and - Over Votes 20 0.0%
appointments to boards and
commissions.In 2006,I ran the REGISTRATION AND TURNOUT
campaign to set aside 2 percent GENERAL
of property taxes to acquire
open space,approved 63 per- TOTAL REGISTRATION 91.596
cent 2006.I would be honored TOTAL TURNOUT 48.684 53 2%
to continue my work in an
expanded capacity in Kona. PRECINCT TURNOUT 32.132 35.1%
ABSENTEE TURNOUT 16.552 18 1% ,
Z. In OVERSEAS BALLOTS CAST
your Y The No.1 problem facing Kona is Jobs and infrastructure.For OVERSEAS TURNOUT
district, that we are not often able to rec- 0 o.o%
ognize problems for the oppor- Job opportunities,encourage 1ST CONGRESSIONAL 0
What is 9 P PP these industries:1)eco=tourism-
the biggest tunities that they really are.We based national parks:Kaloko- 2ND CONGRESSIONAL 0
e have a closed landfill that could Honokohau,Pu'ukohola Heiau,
problem, be processed into composted Pu'uhonua 0 Honaunau,Hawaii
and dirt to build parks and play- Volcanoes National Park,and
how would grounds.We have effluent water linked by 175-mile national his- COUNTY OF HAWAII
you files it? being pumped into a hole which toric trail,Ala Kahakai Trail,with CARD TURNOUT
could be upgraded and used a parallel trail for hiking and bik-
to irrigate these parks and we ing;2)communications jobs link-
TYPE TURNOUT
could eliminate toxic seepage TYPE 1 29.368 32.1%
ing the mainland with the Pacific TYPE 2 29.354 32.0%
onto our reefs by doing so. Rim,supported by expanded
These opportunities,because alternative energy industries;3) ABSENTEE TURNOUT
of their environmental impact, expanded ag industry to help TYPE 1 13.554 14.8%
qualify for federal assistance.My feed Hawaii's people;4)Universi- TYPE 2 13.385 14.6%
biggest job is to get public sup- ty of Hawaii West Hawaii campus
port in acquiring recognition of for skilled labor.Use strategies to
this opportunity and get it fund- help developers achieve respon-
ed.This may not only eliminate a sible growth,to help ensure
To threat to our natural systems,it subdivisions t are comp
To leted,
expands employment opportu- reduce the r enegotiation of
infra-
y 2 nities,and it affirms the vision of structure and reduce the number
Kona as having a leading role in of development bankruptcies.
= the green revolution. Subdivision infrastructure should
4 be built before new residents
i-' move in,so existing residents are
not impacted by crowded streets IRi REPUBLICAN
F and schools and diminished
= services.
Haw Tribune-Hera,''. Haw
luesday,November V.2006 • . .,t ._...
COMMUNITY l the Tote F'O R
O
I.1 I '.; 'Frog.'.,}•
���� ' ■ 2 .0 Open �
_ ¢t';! 1 i � y Y ` ',�`'°C(f v .
.1'
t 3r _ _ .; �k'-r�•nE�,<!'-a: t' lq� I reel
.: . 1y1, Space Fund and
h 1 ail ' YY tau
r t '1v.,t ' h eih
, ,
•
��., �t.- , '' r.0 - Vote FOR County Ballot Question #1 pro
I f; opt
5`` 41:* "The very LAST trestion on your Ballot!" Wt"
_--.� ' ��� °, fMQ,\1(, •� p�,'f�'�,T - Y Q Y I5.
vZd ICI J A .N1 � `, :••J/ .1 , het•
bas!'-: ' - 'a',. 4,,,, „n-`".Lr - `^•.,.•
.lye Center of Hilt.Social Service staffers preparing to provide memory checks are,from left: -- i- -. - - t. •+• ,
ugawi,Lee Guillermo(assistant director of social services),and Faamanu Timoleo arrang "^yA+x '•
he displays on Alrheimer's Disease and"Taking Care of Your Brain.”Life Care Center of Hilo Re
R.one of the national sites for"Memory Screens'on Nov.14 sponsored by the Alzheimer's F.,..
Jalion of Americt:. L 5
dhi•
of 10 minutes? Tim e to get a .- _ k
w - ~- s =
ri14 a e11 '' a&s a)g ;�:
1'11.1
et' memory check on Nov. 14 `�
.. ''F ;lint
1 III minute, sisis 1,l questions:mil tasks to Asa follow-up to a Screen „._. Ilan
111,11 ,111111 11111 11111 I r assess memory a d is admin. ing, comprehensive medical 1'' ".h ,. Ilav
1,a can lint nil whether nunil by a health-care proles- exams may reveal that dlt r1'i .S) I - �._. bile
11,111 keys of InILLtIIIIf .tams A screening could sods- person Is sidled ng Iron] a y.1; Y ■5+1 aT y is 1" i a disf
mauves R ,i nredl cute whrlhei,inleone slundd reversible condition such i I I'' min
t,blens that nee h In be Itllow up with a complete vitamin rlicie I y 1 r my t id {' 4Y,4'Iq�3 y1 (1 ty.?
1 out Further.^ medical exam problem.or Irmo In 1,t n .. '1/,)�.7' r 7 Dili
n idu,11NC11n r1lied 1160111 II I, 1114 used m diagnose title disorder like ALhei min's a ` 'd') •.'":,ti.rsi f .
aYIr t,ml:keadwtu,tage ally illness;old dia•s rm',PIA', di,,,,,, which k Ill e,g1,1h '*' r Ili the
confidential l%ercenings um.1111 min with a qu•ddicd leading cane ,l death ill the l it
r sd.,r. sloe 1.1, T, part prof i n II lire AFY\"id. U.S k.'"�sg', 1:117:.wt;tie. T ', 1`r.•,
nuol Meno'v ti1,Cening Chris Ni Ilev, inn•cloI or -More uheu. people walk ;4'L .,Jy 4 1,''l e" ✓.
I l 4•� Y l a)� Ilh.•
l. im l event presented Social sea ices at Life C',ve, ; val fl nl these screening, 1 ) 4 .fir r 7' .. 'fi. liti I,
��� 1aj' r s r
\lihe nn tb Ivnmdatinn encolrages Ihr-over 55 years with a log sigh 111'relief."l hcv �is),Jiyr' I1' Iy G.�}" qE .1, 1 r f;' '3 =F,y�.gr 7,` Prot l.nevi(M.:\1 to promote old" community members to lied out they're okay,phis they / • f .�,�y;I1 �t .�" $.. °r
tattoo 111 AlzIn imer's take advantage antis tree inn receive inhumation about hove . _�!, iSj�g �t 1 r � r a\'.'' -,g� t 'k. yIC „h',
. :11111 1 I n I ill It.a1, nuuulV nuc o1i;m .uund n1'atv vlu ucldly;',,IiJ I n� y+�Z�j,%l g9trf,,... 1 i
,,,,o in ides \vnh Im.k hokum'''.111,1,1,112,1 a J. Hall,AI i\s chief executive ;if`.4 1 h z.• j f' ;•p'a•w�l Ii ii 3 J," •+ 0,, y. i4 7" soli,
I:d ,\bbl nnet s I)tu'aee release Iwnl sit that results can officer. .n r t ;..-; °�&p.- d 1 r qty 14.1y"s •F M 4.,k` the.
,s:shank be stint to their personal physi National Memo y Screening ) e •o., ,'f S reifies It a yr.r Y t}'� 'gii*q'�d 1 f;. 135
11i('are ('enter 1,l Ihlu clan Results 1,4 the 11,1 will Day's premier sponsor is 1•ur �EYyy :7101'; it1 a},-�r l 1;_ rsIl i l t I odd memo yl s':nen- nut ht Eisen to puuitip3nt. -_ sl Ph imaceulical. Ina and ' i7x 'I i, sif;} 1} TI{ .1 �r T '.[i li''..;N',..*iifirtrtnint.grh S�•{ Pa•
Ills.cente.IL1J;WLSL_\aid 12 itIley. .. 11le event'\-oesenlin L-, III I l.ml M. twin 3-( p.m. AI•A initiated National is Orihu-McNeil N ur logic.. e • ''+ ,t(: qr C.�'' � � a�,:
,nr inhumation and an Memory Screening 1)ay lime Inc. .. • WHAT I7 WIL DO: .•. ) ,,''.:,r,.I '%fr Sir
nm•Ill.Vali('ht is:rime). .yea's ago In mist' awareness ,\d4\ is n New 1'nrklutsetI Sol asule 2'Y,11l.skiing,I nl jIll iy :.,l fy,
'1151 nl AI/Itehlltl',disease and the nnllpluliI Inettniollinl, that last',gal II VI•dr ill Ill'I'''111111.0 inking 15'.5151 tillahty, At
minimal nd5 new e fur impnn;ace of catty detection, locust,tin care for hulk idu w,dershtn is,cudsh,l access,heat Iles,and important ndliv5 Idaw.liian tan I
.11 Memory Selrentng Proper medical treallnenl and als with ,\Lheimcr's disease I'Ill k,
trues, I)ciihe FIJI is community slpplrl, and'elated illnesses,and their Iiillliral sill's,
.mine pl•nple II' 'Ow This year,hundreds nr silos Iaufies.It mews hundieds 01 at 11•
II It.'a scleCnin,. will be participating in neatly member urgali/alinns act°SS • 2 a Au
E i participating > BROAD SUI'1 ORT Nnr.
'mole loss is a (lard •ll 50 states:screening sites are Math America that provide
people to squall- listed at the Welt site: www. hand,-m1'support services.Al "The Land Fund will...help strengthen our year
titbit's-ida1 very tel lrui....national lilen11ry'.Ct ceiling.nry. a national level.AFA's Berrie. _ ...vote for the 2°�, " um iI
.maeIive and to!taut 1101 The AI'A suggests Ill,,any- ,s include a toll-free hotline, . local economy Land Fund. . has lt'
I HI'It' hieing.(felling a one concerned tbInl changes educational materials, a free Kung-Kohala Chamber of Commerce nlaku
,deeming ism lil,t',le, in ml'nury�III ulhel imillecIual inagavinc lip' eategivt'rs out lags•,.
sI.",.`5 ledl'L';mil V p.innl •1111111 ions should gel stn•1ned. Itiliuillr Fur hcahh-aloe p1111.5- At
...:1111 cant•. II east make Signs that Mete might be it ,fonds. 2%dedicated land hind endorsed by 2004 .rnpir
.61leie ore tor tim,ilics, problem include liugelhdness Ras more information, cull I• a dui
ill.best knusrn,1,"Its, ghoul mashes and event,,ask- 11nlldreel %tn.AFA-%-1%4 la Hawaii County Democratic Party resolution. - aainti
I.' 1'.v lens" on Days or Mg repetitive questions. loss 51511 55 ww alifiln.org.Fur litea1 ex dw
Ives Kills lather had 01 verbal or wriuen skills, C1111111t't Ind iuh,rmaliun, call • rrfrCTIVI:;I)01icaling 2'll1 of the laws we already pa),lit the I'uhlil 1
..,.cs di,Iast•. ' eunrrsion, and etmlic mood Ridley al Life('lye(:'enter ill 11r Cll.
At css,(Jima Slate I unll\viii NOl'raise taxes.Maui and Kauai )d„Ir:1
ugnr inusivt'kit ton- swings. 1MO at 959-9 151. • l 1
citizens vol,d owl wIli ln,ingly lit creak,similar land funds in 200 ioreth
zai'dous waste.collections • December rli(ir i)r gmny lases hive not incre.lsed and their services have note in
lrlla'I:lg
diminished,and nv,r 10(1 acres of coastal land.ind access have dndut
list of.iten)p to be accepted Dec. 2 in Hilo .Dec. 9 in Kona • already been protected! sic Ir
t) 1 ... hot he.
ATTRACT QI IT51Dr.ruNf)iNG,I)edicatod funds attract matching
goy uflicial,announce' types of batteries, merctn'V anions waste disposal frmll stale and 1(41(1,11 illlilhlli;hl our Island:I or 1'Calllilie,the I d.i 111iiliun
oe dates tar "blouse thermometers,oil-based paints businesses, as well as 1'1 11e1
LI/Malnl,1V11s1e CONC. Lod 5111111v, 11 151e garden sup. disposal of other 113/arlhm5 I lonu'a(,n t.isl01 arca was saved with only$500,000 in County
.'II limb sides or tat.Big plies,poison,,11111(5.11 III 11111- 1105.1,1,,iv 1n'nila111e by coin funding.Now that's leverage! I
dated medications and 1111 5 I- Iacling Gregg I'crry with I(nri
- • SMALl.I ER(f-.NT,If1C_IMi'ACT,A 2.%0 Set aside for alt,(limn llI1t l
eulleuiuns will.lake L•uteonv huu.ehul t pl11aucn r1,Sets i a 1%U%)%39-7v"' '
to S.nadal, Dec 2,Hi "Nil aou•pleu are cull County Public lit 1511111 would IIaVll dedicated$2.6 million 1:151 year 111 1)'1111'11 our 1,111,1,. ICE'
I,'Ii❑mlet Staten owl-.-lrotled_sub leilcv,, hin11rest,__Derailment_officials. . .. . We can't Mimi(to weal any lunged. ..:
,v.Dec.9,al the Keal wnstt explosives flares,HO- -issued a !embitter that Y • 1'leise vote
FQR.Ihe road,vole_IQR Co inlyQuestion#1,Any -
IIsailmt Kmn)11,msfer 'logical and infectious waste, C gv 't ' _
l'115l I I,Gp 51oa1 I 1.111,C1 IuE ( u m11u1 111, was w 1 11,IIy !await 1 x..
oat. The hours al Lnllec• compressed its Cylinders,let haunter lotions and t!e is contusion or(10(1 ions that you mile in the ballot Ianguag(with nil
a1 60111 sires wilt II:1111111. extinguishers and non-havard- lundti lbs 11 ill again lbw dosed 1 bangle Its'efli•llivt•ness of the I un1.lh•Sao(Our I awl(-iIi7en'e
1,i II,,.2'to p.111. : 1111s Illaleru lbs.',aid 111 1161115, . .1111.Illankvgiving Day.('111151-. ('onmtIDI'I'has 7 51(111121 I l'I1dU 1Nn11l'1,15 foil,Count it nr•IIIho•rs and
Iceottenn can doll off More I nI I Ion nn bass• tons f,ny wail Now Veto's I)ny' 1 andid.u•s as well as a wrillen r till u lilt Will Iran,Mayor Kim lit 1
I 1evdennal ha/John,
1e,that may have accmnu- ■*E1 i 7,1443 ..ilAR I C1C*111 Cf**1311'Al3l:3*EE 1 rt:2•49 I. reinstate the'impost.clause to prole(I public access to heat-lips mill
1,sore the last 15.111,"said /r' , . ..nmunl,iins,cuiliH,ll sites,natural resources,forests,I sastdl drt•a5,and
1
„hn.mn `�r' —walersh,d woo()bat salve Our wate quality. Its(O Oddity I:timid!
\III 1, h dai+�•tnrS m hrL-- ------ '(/ACU FLO . -il • ••• members and candidates who have Cr OMMfrI Fria tIl hiring o the int,111
iosal 11111 be 1111' nnhloW- 1111 IYUILTIN CENTNYL VACUUM SYSTEMS• ffi
mein>: aumnuui)'e IhriJs' Are you really cleaning... or just. �'k ,-.0f nearly 1(1,11(11)Big I51dnd t.ili,ens who signed Its,i,quunn and
oiling used 11101111 1111 111111 Ed 9 f1 suigaltl the fund's purpose Claus,are:Brenda lord,I'ele Ilufftnan,Bob
ills 1 amdrt'e t inn moving dust around.
VACUFL0W-central vactalm s95lefns`are dust""• - '-iaci)bsun,Carly NSt ore,Angel I'ilago,Gary Safarik,and Dominic Yagong.
Zap l� DI Nee They vent to the outside of your •' J '• house like a clothes dryer. •
Put your . :! Your home stay fresh and dean! `' l VOTE FOR it 1
Company Name I r l ,Y :, �_ • -
or [C � '�V NATURAL I 'cu AN f'
Company Logo r oQ { l SAND WAtrll
in this spot! R El �.'' ` Is VOTE FOR
v:
Cal Our Display 5 , ` COUNTY QUESTION #1 I
Advertisimr 3 Home Convenience Center- F,3:
- - g Lie.q C-9854
Department [ - \. www.bomeconvenlencecenteacom J �� THE 2% OPEN SPACE FUND
' 'Kona-Comic;01 Kulwl and Lubin Snouts . ��'I 7+
DUI'dl ta11, dr. F9 I vest I hl ;:paid for by Save Our.Land Cilfien a Committee„ FµL
a. , _:__Lotelod.In.Up Old Industrial Null_.._.._.....��
t. .. 29.9956 ., I f Y,, y ��t.?:
935-6621 5' C�1 Box'414D Kailuit-Kona.Questions?Call 989.3222 anytime to get answers r
, .Hilo-corner.of Kanoeluhun A LOniknula
1'1 • . Located in the Osaka sumo° LI • about this critical step to protect our quality of life. 4
Imlay! : 6 a 951-2555 Oa— 11 www.leKacylands:org
71r rnrmir7t n r.:7.14/1•1=4.41!• C.> 31 wi t- 1 Ecwwtl Net K1;°"3'k'1.sv'"[3 •''' ' � —
ill111111111111111111111•1111111111M■
- -
-• 'LI In E`... '‘.6.n*C... ''. '''' Z.' °°*".- E ...• tc'-'3' ,.. I. I.
0 0 a e .8 1 °
s' -:-,7: < _4..... ,- E .Q . '2 -...- - .-. . ... -z •-6' -- ' 5 . -7c ismos
§ kit w wzr..._..8...
E. cn
..12_ > ao 511 =
7. 7i a_ c,) cz, as c.,-;_ ,...-• .•;. ,-- a -t3 '..- -- tc„-c3 , 0 f_:,) .s014 0 cx. =0.1I
. -E. )... .4 (:■ L.) po tu - E .;-•°' a ,'",,' '44 2 R -,. °, = ca.,..1 Z 4›.)", m =INN=
C) CC ..'Z' 0 .. a': ,--' .a.. (-) c o a .1:: o ° .3 41 .-
LU Ca•I ...e • •"-* •-• .-- ,, • 8
V", t..) -i• ''' c.)---,,,, s.,._Q o ,,t .-: 0 -1
3 t.., r-: 1 _ Lc.1 •-• ',L. c., Z.,) ',2 2. z z ,.... v. 4, i.--
._. •
. .= CA id) cie E.... 0 ...1 Ls 0 'E•0-.5. tad L. •..... , .ft), ,•••• •-qd ,.1:3 .t4
• >, < cra
-''''' . cz.-44 'iu- -4. "'• tL) C:3 -.ad
t C gc, ,,, ° "'.) to °.'
•
(n .2 0 ...5.'''' .''-- -S.. '-'.5 ''''.E... a t .....-z1-z .'''' zt
L.. cd a
L.44.., C1 ''''° lit .4.' L: '..-5 t.) .-.z.'-13 E.:I C".11 CC....9" en• . .-...., :-.0. -a : citut ..5
"58 - c..., -... ,...)
„, ,„ ..... .... , a, •-■.) a tu L .- a) •-• 03 c
vs CC S..,..) E t:s ,... E ...g. R .., ,_ , L. •,,, ... s = u..g 0.= vl i I.
'..) r.1
• '..) ."', ‘;',.30 Qs C:L. ty, • • Cu '''') ? ....„•• CU ..a 4) •=1 C.) 0
i = L.L.1 .--- ,.... ......, , 0, ,,3 0) c.:, •z...; (-1 0 0 , ,),,i) -g 21.." 0 = c.) I CL
... 0 0..0 L. 5--= 0 co
• -1 -5 ILI -a 52 ---• 1.Z.....--. our, .... ..2"'A' Q. CQ z 0 "'' v., 0, fml
''FfS c3., 0) I.. a = -NA 1- (10 = ...ro
...9 o. 3 '-'
i ti) CC=,... •••■ .Z.,,4 1/.... t..) en U •••Z 8 ,,, ,..,, tt,:, ,0 ,.. . fm. 0 = 4,
- s
11+
t.).. '5. .0 •- ft: ..5 alt. u eu u 4)
.
..... 4...., (Z) _ .....
la r.1 00
••••■ c., ,y, 130 to t 0 ." 0'-0 '1,),., ,, 2L g•"4
r" 7.•••• Is .E -a --. a a 74 a a) a 2 •-• 2 4)
.ot ar,..1,„....., eri c),) Z ,::: .7 ..S " Ce7•....
U•1 ..' ....3 "--' C. t.) 1.. L 0./ I.. CS ... L ,.,o: I...
.= . ,.
G - ...-
:-"D--L. -.).r , .--.. ,... z3 ,,e to ,-, to - (., ••••• 1,51).Cat. r.) 1-4 t''''§ .. .
at•:-.":) . C‹ (... .'- '- '' .z.. o. a .1 ..•' .... CS
•--,.. CS ISI 'SO '/ CS „ e ..-- ,.., -
= ..a ..,
,-4tw
-......
...-.
1':) = tr. ,e) 'S 0 .... TS."". < = •
L. 0 -0 ..,.., .1..,z. •••.--., 5-= a g 03 c.) c•'72' a 5 41 la b < .'"u3
.tu..,.... i. 0 13 7.6:, ..582 ),..9 :-...6' '!.',:III: ;
.Z.i: . •:.,. , , '') 0 c'' au• c..., -Z
CI 0
'i"•:: ,,,
' - CID .c . C
I.
..,
4 CI9 ''/O ..
*--E.., c;.., P.',, 0 0`•1-.,„ m ...-. .... E ,„.° cc.:
b
O. ....-, ,..) - 0 ••••• cql =- 0 o 75 iu - ci-. - ' •• is
'-
',•C t.L.1 cL. c.1 u, i...) tj vs .. o
' ''' C) L.) E a3:-.. a) ..', 1-•"c) ao t.... 0 4"cl a 6).,=•s T., E 0 : - .
,..,„ cc ,z404 t ,,,... ..,,I, ....,,,,.. ,,.9 .....acc-<,,:, : ..).,.9 ,At I.;.1 s. <0 e ,„
,
Q. tn . a). ,,, - -z 11. w .c.,-, - . ,.s -° = (.,-g .s = 8
4.)cz-Q, ,, ,::: , 0.z 0 i,-), ,-• . 8)0-c 'W T B 2 4
r CC '') ::- 2 `e. "r-s-/'S. °El >. ' 0 _d' eu r"' -1-^-, 41. 0 = •-•
V.
‘,4,7 Q-. cg4.1 .c..1 -...'-' ti .-E-3 ••••il .k.' '.3, cn '...' .5 --ea lei. tt g B1 ..,,, C6 IZ:l .4 U (.9 (1) ll i '
- •`l "CI 't,'
It: = 0 CL) col •••••, g =•,-. •••••• 03 t..)- Z
,--..c !....) Ca,"..i. ...4 0.1 ,9 E , .' ea =: (L) 0 4".••
f'' = ...._(b ''F'), 't./4. C) @ 8 ,4 ,4. E00E ,
i,,,,--. ....1 Z. a a •N o o ,,-• .
tn
t,L '; 1/4.....1 '' C 0 cl.) ci)"'''',)), to § „.,1 0 V '
0)• 0.) ,... 0) t.) = , 5 = .... c.)
•
- .-.1C.) .z • "-.F3' 2*•, O31 ,„:g f4o2cia:*0-c415 ,4) t"
'...0
E ,c, 4-. § ,
_ ,• z 4- • , 41.) cc; cn 0 2 ,- ,:,' ti) 0 = ›..
i ..v'l) ' ,...z E t
..-.),,)•
- § i
UL
czE '.'--'z 1 I • aw'a.:^-- •'' °' I -7:3• U =t2
Cl -co a •- t:s a •° : cla L
( C' t..) •L '-..1 tO P•• CI.O.; 0, "t C) 0 e „,.,0 ,..,r'l a/
A 4.1
-„..
,....E Z',.,,,.'-i. :,....,..i--- ........---,,,,„•,r..-.. ,oz ....s :C.', ..,.a.,, 2....,,, 01-'.4.1 a,) 2..„:-:a t-,; a.
CL
-
), r,„ ...,... 4-".,--.,..., .._,,, 7....,.. tz r,'''' .6--) ..Z./ .'"E 4^.,,„, t..j''''' E lt?7,t3 (4".1c)..zk, •i i. 0 C14 i.. 0 on .
Z."•C';'''C\I's--'C'' Lk' tr) ''''.1,_,t"'' Pt) .9. 0 %) ' ..,..lisi
WI wl
*S 40= la' •I'l F:',.5 -ci '' c.ri:'
....
cu C 4 „B
a) = = vs
w'l 0.•E as 0
.". ...1■10mals
--- re Do E t:s ..... 744 o L is. z •-• ,,s ..., -..
'." a "5 1:s ° a * • ;;,--1-
g=1
,, 0 f:11-....'•,t-s,,:.' 0 clo... ki a, ... t.,- ..... .,... to .....
44 ,,, tx, cs t .3-E. .rz■ -.. a.) tx) E E ..', ,,,, a) 0 U rr 41 .,,.,t.
g
;),„ ) = ••• L. C343 u A, . , L. izi. L.
,.., - L ,- Q czic, .,'. URI,-cu al••-• t.
Fara
,,,,,*--..;, •-• ,a3 c." c4...c) .- a ---, ,..) t.) .... a 0 o
4.1 _ lid ,-)..Q •- tu - 4-1 •-
11 - tu ),.. ' E 0_n 0 .5 a)
'''' ',',,, ' C.-) t •Z E-'`I L t'5 .qJ E 0 '.--.- %) .• ..- 122 (' •Z U 4)
IONS ' .-:;;Z,Kr,' 1 E•■, tl) ti Co Z4. 'R.-:-- Q -- -,.... . 3 ' 1-,s.
... •- , ,„, Q. c:, , Q. z3 „.„ 1-... ,Q, _,_,i ?..... 8 F.., GJ = N
Z tj
CZ) '''::;li 14 --- E E Q --Y tu .. to
10 --• 0 .... •r4 cel E...-• 4,
frifil * - g E-c,5.. --,,,,-, •E ziL t.,-. 8 8-1' Z °-,,, 2-z3' :Fr: 'E 4 g .v, 7.=, E 0 E -f.
or 0 ...c, ,,.., „ ,., z 00. ..., ... , 0) 5
-5- -LI • ("):::: UN-, 63) 1 >CL) 8 c`*=
C 3
Ciao
c.:1 E.-Z.,. .•.1;3 ....'■:' cz.... z z..4 Z‹"Z:3" -
-1) .. ... 8,c3 .'(7-) "2 t5 -,7?,
...- („,,i,
, c) 0 •-• --• -0 -.r. ,:z3`..--, tzt - L. (^,1 0:1-0 WI••0
0 - ' ''44 E •Q U 'u E Q•.`. '4, '4 Z ^'' tl = = <L) ..-. ...... =,.... ttl
gale -----
-2t E -.. .-z a ..2 -x EI E L. -B u .... ae
•
I., �. C
a0 • c • r, a, O tiu. "p p - p c� a -A u Ou °, Z .o O� o) L •
G
O v' '-o a) a) > •p c a O a w, ..+ cd c� O t� 4) a. o
a� �' ed..) o U ,U v ' cu cab Ou = " U .a) .❑ 5 'N [—. = t
a, .a 3 yT, O :a o
,,., ?.0 x a at? "C, .0 4.+ CO '� �''' p C 6 p =. >-,`4;:!, :' -. O 1-- =» p�
:v p 0a) � 3aS `a au � >, OrC ° � � �' Q, acoz
a C O.=� U 'J "t7 .v' CUi Cl '� O P. ct, •� N 3
aa�� > .b ,.. c..., a ,, V) ti.,, a .a) 'b a) a) E•.., R p) -O p 7.. :.O
a) a) -4-. a '� a) a) .a) p u 'U O v' a.' O r �,; Cs
'� : .. bn wbn `�'b u = > u a 0 " '� › b- >, y to O O%) '' p w
� .0 ° .u .E: ban'> a' ;. o 'E = E ci. °n 3 E .E � E .E c., 4-, --. -z cil= � . - •2 .. ( O 4 t c�1 = 0 'O b C 0 a) 'd 0 • .
.�' y 4i 0 .4. ctiO0 o �, a 45 CU a -v a •N � -0 a . (1) c� a a, a�•V u v 5 °
cn aOOa .o --.6: u ^ .2...) a boy . N0 .� A. uaaaa �, >, b
pa a,..., ,n a) u E ' O w u A '�• 'c� O .,-, cis
a- . w : 0 a) -d .bo = > Vic, oao �0 .� aa) � � a' E a ) 1.)
• . , cox bnaai � .o � -a+ .C .a ° U 0 , . p, o � o .c) 0 �, 0 u
o � � ' 4.4 'a a`3oo. O > �,o � � o� UWa) .a � a"w ,tiU .� �
4- E = a- a. >, as a) a-.
C a) 'C ..., a, >, E �a, >,'� a a)b c�.
E •0 .0 v' u bn 4., a. h1 -fl
Lt: E 0 'C .n �, > a, bn � U a'�. r c� � .� �
TIM p c;.) 0 a a) • a act ti)>, cts i- O Ln C C a
.� a) • � O 'G � q >.„ a) •C c4-4 •p a) 0 ,L 4 O v c > > . O a • U
O a > U 3 a
c 0
u-0 O a) a -„ • t1, a O a cn a.a
cc = e D 0 '9. u o ' = I ` °' ' U 0 0 G.n " 0 to ) °= am'- a _ Q `n a n ►- .r. 'c } c. aN . r. a a, N � p b IL,4. O .a . O U ^ a A a 04) a cA '- E ,.. 40 J O bn O N c (-NI ,-•. n
a va ) a C ,. a - U Q a5 0 a) p O E a) ° o
13. t au 'a U U � ' N a ct C c0 c c . u O+-+ `n U a) p ca „ c >.'X a u o a ;° ' a 0 w, > 4. o . d 0." [ . - . ..; p a .� - > 4 a) u a)a ° •�O Ly d p �� V u v a °a) > ' c y vi C ,„ t a, (
.-� O . ; „ , -4-' -•a' � c ` ° .. � E a O u = - J 0 a a a ) • a -. ca e. v y cy C c U U bo }.. s- E.o Z7 a a) H a E C .Ly a d U cs 0 7 4-. O 5 0 > 0 ,
.a u a o a,E s ca ° i— ,p U a,Z a. a (8....r,_ � > c W u —
` u 3 U u a) u :�
Cl. e) c a) o. a) b a) -0 c� ° c a.,p 3 ..':b bCn cs - •v' .U E C
cvi > • -v "a) s5 N . .c a a > ° 0 0 p a) a �, . a) .c a a)
ti:','� .� p .L 'p Q, al 1.. 'v' •C •.a •t, a a 'C . o E o a c
�/��/ 0 a U- a _ c a) 0 . a,.•_ a,^ .ti 0 , a) E .E -' -� o u
iii a 0 t 0 a) c_ au E . •E - p a c° U u a) u Q.
L ■ a) a >, �. l•” �.. U 0.4, b0 Cry w 1-= > b a y N 7:5 cu
Imo 3 a s a) c3 .c'2,.d 5 O a a tA Ou .• 0 a) cS c O p bn p u C a-
O tt U I u >, - as ‘e. -2 a `o a ~O t . u -E �, ?- ' E
� . N `� = . c.., 0F3 c � � cEcA uaJ -r� ; � 3bA^ � ° ' = � ° � �'
_ S� ... .›.,I. cs a) - u .773.. = - ►.. - � " O ►..■
:--
v = p.. 'U 4- .u a.) C' `*-• .4.-.C >,
� ? -O ° a•° oa � > ¢ c `' ° >; EHc?saO0 �> ak
tt
, ; o c
'c ° •L = cciU -5" s cE � Z o F= v EU c , ,,, .
E