HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOM 0710.120 2010-2012 Pa e 1 of 3
P ICOUNaa.
Murashige,Laura A�4 ') I; I
From: Paul Kuykendall[bigislandpaul @gmail.com] N� I I ll
Sent: Monday,July 30,2012 9:33 PM
To: counciltestimony @co.hawaii.hi.us
Subject: Testimony for the Hawaii County Council regarding Bills 256 and 257
Attachments:signatures_596 july 30 2012.pdf;commentsJuly 30.pdf
Aloha,
My name is Paul Kuykendall.I am a resident of Pahoa and live within one mile of the
PGV plant.I am testifying regarding Bills 256 and 257.
I'd like to begin by thanking the Hawaii County Council for listening to our concerns
regarding the geothermal plant and trying to do something about them.
To voice our concerns and join with our neighbors to support the Hawaii County
Council,my partner Suzanne and I wrote a petition on July 16.Since then it has been
signed by 596 people(as of Monday night,July 30)427 of which are citizens of
Hawaii.For my testimony,I would like submit this petition.There are links and
references after the stated facts for your information,though I know many of you are
well-acquainted with them. I've also attached for your reference a list of the names of
the signers,sorted by state and city and a list of comments made by the signers. The
comments give a good indication of the broad nature of the support for overriding the
mayor's vetoes.
v -
Petition for the Health and Safety of the " " 1
People and Aina of Hawaii County
, J
We,an alliance of people of Hawaii,taking inspiration from our kapuna and our --
keiki,hold these truths to be self-evident.That all men and women on the Big Island
are created equal and their safety and health are inalienable rights.These rights take
precedent over the rights of corporations and governments to make profits at the
expense of the people.
To protect the health and safety of the people of Hawaii and,the Aina,it is the duty of O
the people to take peaceful and democratic action,and to elect leaders who will take
steps to protect us.
The history of geothermal plants in Hawaii have been a long train of abuses and
usurpations.To prove this,let these facts be submitted to a candid world:
When the first geothermal plant in Puna,HGP-A,was drilled in 1976,the project was
presented as a strictly experimental,two year demonstration project and not a
production well.In 1982,despite commitments to the public,a three-megawatt power
plant went on line.No community meetings were held explaining the change.The
geothermal power plant continued for eight years and was shut down in 1989.HGP-A
dumped the toxic geothermal brine into unlined ponds that fouled the air,land and
water.Federal regulatory agencies deemed their effluent abatement systems
unacceptable.(From Harry Kim's testimony to the Hawaii Environmental
Council,http://www.higislandchronicle.com/20 I 2/06/04ipolitics-harry-k ims-testimonv-to-state-
wai i-environmental-co und I-may-17/1
There has already been a major accident at PGV in 1991,when PGV had a well blow
out that vented more than 2,200 pounds of hydrogen sulfide over a 31 hour period,
killing animals and forcing the evacuation of at least 75 Puna Residents.(LA Times,
June 15, 1991 http://articles.Iatimcs.com/1991-06-I5/ncws/mo-503 I Puna-:4cothcrmal-
venture]
Based on a detailed review of emergency response capabilities at PGV in 1996,the
EPA made numerous safety recommendations,including the development of a site
specific evacuation plan.Sixteen years later,these recommendations have not been
implemented and we still do not have an evacuation plan for the local community,
even though our records show 18 declared civil defense emergencies at PGV between
1991 and 1999.We have not been able to obtain the records after that.We believe
there have been many more releases.
(http://www.epa,aoviregion9/waste/punaiemerfi nal.pdf
Since then,PGV's parent company Ormat has gone to great lengths to insulate /O•themselves from financial liability in the event of a catastrophic accident.If you look Cc, - r1. �i . t
up Puna Geothermal Venture in the state of Hawaii's business registration website, p// _ _
Ref. To: [ I Wt.t.vt(if
Ref. Date AUG 0 1 ZUTZ
7/31/2012
Page 2 of 3
you see the stated owners for Puna Geothermal are two entities named"Omi8 LLC and OrPuna LLC."It is clear they are designed to protect Ormat's
assets from liability.
PGV does not own the power plant that they are operating in Puna.Ormat's 2011 10K report states that,"Pursuant to a 31-year head lease,PGV leased its
geothermal power plant to an unrelated company in return for prepaid lease payments in the total amount of$83.0 million.The unrelated company
simultaneously leased back the Puna Power Plant to PGV under a 23-year lease."This means in the event of a catastrophic accident or liability for toxic
releases,PGV would have no assets to garner,and Ormat is protected by LLC's.
There has been continuous drilling,despite statements made in 2002-2003 that due to PGV being the hottest well in the world,future drilling might not be
necessary.No further communications to the public on why drilling continues to this day.(From Harry Kim's testimony to the Hawaii Environmental
Council)
PGV calls their system"closed loop",but they often release hydrogen sulfide into the air when they have problems at the plant.As recently as November
7,2011 PGV was affected by a lightning strike which tripped the plant offline and caused hydrogen sulfide gas to be vented.
(http://www.hawai i247.com/2011/I I/08/pgv-plant-goes-offl ine-vents-hydrogen-sulfide-gas!)
PGV uses 60,000 gallons of highly flammable,toxic pentane as part of what they call a"closed loop"process.They lose an average of 40-100 gallons of
Pentane a day into the environment in this so called"closed loop"process.(From PGV testimony Hawaii County Council Meeting,July 2,2012,also
Environmental Administrative Decisions p.274 hnp://books.google.com/books7id=8SO5oa-
wxw0C&pg°PA274&lpg—PA274&dq pentane+pgv&source=bl&ots-CmlfueY.10W&Sig-19FgydV72vWNvbh8nHHoisoGU3s&hl en&sa_X&ei k!4D1J1'6o1 Obo2AXT2pi'
20pgv&f—false)
PGV is pumping 3,000 gallons per minute of toxic brine back into injection wells.If a pentane explosion,lava flow,earthquake or hurricane breaks their
pipes,it would take minutes for the air,land and water to be irrevocably fouled.
The geothermal brine contains hydrogen sulfide,lead,nickel,chromium,and mercury.They call their system"closed loop",but they also accumulate
geothermal scale in steam/brine separators.This scale is removed during scheduled plant outages.(Goddard and Goddard,engineering and environmental
studies, 1991.hnp://punapono.com/does/Goddard91.pdfalso,letter from Ormat,July 13,2012)
DOH has cited PGV for uncontrolled steam releases.The Hawaii Department of Health reported on April 12,2006—that PGV was cited for exceeding its
one-hour average of 25 parts per billion of H2S on August 25,2005.During a cleanout process,station B recorded a one-hour average of 789 parts per
billion.(DOH news release dated April 12,2006,Harry Kim's testimony)
With the passage of ACT 097 this year,the counties have been stripped of their land use control over geothermal development.The county no longer has
authority over the granting of the Geothermal Resource Permit which requires emergency plan development by PGV and to address noise levels and H2S
emissions.(From Harry Kim's testimony to the Hawaii Environmental Council)
Also with Act 097,Geothermal subzones were eliminated.This means geothermal exploratory drilling and a power plant could be built almost anywhere
in this state.This includes agricultural and rural districts.Note that 50%of the people on the Hawaiian Island reside in or about agricultural and rural
zoned areas.(From Harry Kim's testimony to the Hawaii Environmental Council)
Helco is preparing an RFP for 50 MW of additional Geothermal power on the Big Island in 2012.They say in a January 6,2012 press release,"HELCO
will undertake technical studies...(which)include the need for more transmission lines if the geothermal power is all from the east side of the
island."(Helco press release January 6,2012 htto:/www.heco.com%vcmcontcnt/StaticFiles/pdfi20120106-GcothcrmalRFP.pdf)
Although Puna produces 20 percent of Big Island electricity requirements at PGV and another 10 percent at Shipman steam power plant in Kea'au,
totaling 30 percent of Big Island power,Puna residents only use 6 percent of total power,in part because many Puna residents are off-grid,conserve and
produce their own power.Any additional power will not be used in Puna.hup://www.heco.com/vcmcontent'FileScan iPDFConvcrt/PowerFacts.pdf
Advocates say geothermal power will lower rates,but the Big Island has 20 percent geothermal power now and has higher rates than Maui and Oahu
which have no geothermal power.(Helco website
http:/!www.hcco.com/portal/site/hcco/menuitem.508576178baa14340b4c0610c5IObIca/vgnextoid 692c5c658c0I c0l0VgnVCM1000008119fca9RCRD&vgnextchannel--I 06
During 2011,a total of$1.8 million in geothermal royalties was received from PGV by the state of Hawaii.They in turn distributed 30 percent to the
County of Hawaii,totaling$568,000.Additionally,20 percent,$378,000 was distributed to the Office of Hawaiian Affairs.If you follow the money trail,
the geothermal supporters all have two things in common:they live more than 10 miles from the plant and they are making money from geothermal
plants.
In response to recent discussion about expansion of geothermal power,USGS Hawai'i Volcano Observatory highlighted the hazards involved in
geothermal power plants in high risk zones,stating,"The effect of an eruption within a geothermal power development could be severe,and the site could
be deeply buried by lava."http://hvo.wr.usns.gov/volcanowatch/view.php'lid--130
Given these facts,we petition the Mayor to reconsider his vetoes which disregard the health and safety of the people.If that does not happen,we petition
the Hawaii County Council to override the veto of these bills.We also petition for long overdue environmental monitoring,health studies and an
evacuation plan that will give people immediate notice and egress in the event of another catastrophic accident at PGV.
We petition the Council to stop any further geothermal development that will put the people and Aina in harms way.We ask you to look into your hearts
and make the right decisions,knowing that if you disregard our petition,you will be risking our lives for the sake of profits and political careers.We ask
you to protect us,our keiki and kapuna,from having to suffer and possibly die for geothermal power and dollars.
Mahalo for your consideration and support.
Please note I have printed below a list of the signers.
7/31/2012
Sheetl
f1.11 1 Name City State Zip Code Country
Alan D Ackerman Mobile Alabama 36608 United States
Cathy Sagerser Soldotna Alaska 99669 United States
Robert Drury Casa Grande Arizona 85122 United States
Angela Brentano Casa Grande Arizona 85122 United States
terry hedgecock prescott Arizona 86305 United States
Mary Crecco Scottsdale Arizona 85255 United States
Alyssa Romano Tempe Arizona 85284 United States
Thomas Ah Yee Tolleson Arizona 85353 United States
Paul Davis Jasper Arkansas 72641 United States
Catherine Ridder altadena California 91001 United States
maitreya silver bolinas California 94924 United States
Daphneleah Schneider Canoga Park California 91305 United States
Kristin Ohman Claremont California 91711 United States
marsha lange Covina California 91723 United States
Jan Minter Desert Hot Springs California 92241 United States
Osha Breez Encinitas California 92024 United States
Ellen Bryant Eureka California 95503 United States
Kim Chamberlain Fortuna California 95540 United States
Leon Galico Fresno California 93726 United States
Susan Park Fullerton California 92833 United States
stephanie landa granada hills California 91344 United States
carrie reinagel Hermosa Beach California 90254 United States
Tracie Jones LA California 90064 United States
Linda Nansen la honda California 94020 United States
Megan Gruber LANCASTER California 93535 United States
Tiphareth hallock Los Angeles California 90046 United States
Scott Chambliss Los Angeles California 90039 United States
Jaymie Homan Los Angeles California 90066 United States
Nicki Harris Los Angeles California 90066 United States
Maria Taylor Mission Viejo California 92692 United States
Cora Bird Myers Flat California 95554 United States
Leta Gibney Nevada City California 95959 United States
Chelsea Madison oakland California 94619 United States
Sandra Vaughn Oakland California 94605 United States
nancy barker occidental California 95465 United States
Michael Matheson Occidental California 95465 United States
Zoe Matheson Occidental California 95465 United States
Jeremy Clear orange California 92865 United States
Colinda Lynch Palmdale California 93551 United States
Ben Loewy Palo Alto California 94306 United States
Laurie Masters Petaluma California 94952 United States
Chris Costello Petaluma California 94954 United States
David Domingo Pleasanton California 94566 United States
Aimee Popovich Rancho Palos Verdes California 90275 United States
Kathleen Hendrix Richmond California 94807 United States
joy cash San Diego California 92103 United States
Noemi Wallace San Diego California 92123 United States
Howard Moore San Diego California 92115 United States
Angus Whyte San Francisco California 94117 United States
Karl Mauzey San Francisco California 94110 United States
Katey Chikasuye San Francisco California 94115 United States
Barbara Raymond San Francisco California 94110 United States
Page 1
Sheet1
Victor S. San Jose California 95128 United States
thea altman santa barbara California 93105 United States
Dori Kuehn Santa Cruz California 95063 United States
pamela porter santa rosa California 95404 United States
Douglas Hay Simi Valley California 93063 United States
Caterina Nelli Studio City California 91604-3036 United States
Katalin Urszuly Tarzana California 91356 United States
Carolyn Correnti Torrance California 90501 United States
Bridget Webb Trabuco Canyon California 92679 United States
kirsten johnsen Ukiah California 95482 United States
Shawna McClure Ventura California 93001 United States
Sara Macalusos Woodland Hills California 91367 United States
Erika Boyer Fort Lupton Colorado 80621 United States
Ryan Zeller glenwood Colorado 80163 United States
Beth Best Lilttleton Colorado 80123 United States
hillary english littleton Colorado 80128 United States
don perrin Wiggins Colorado 80654 United States
Barbara Felt Northfield Connecticut 6778 United States
Mary Marvin Porter Waterbury Connecticut 6749 United States
Carlton Bryan Bonita Springs Florida 34135 United States
Maggie McClellan Fort Lauderdale Florida 33312 United States
DAVE PAGADUAN JACKSONVILLE Florida 32246 United States
Marian A Atlanta Georgia 30032 United States
Adam Bregman Atlanta Georgia 30312 United States
Kathryn Andren Capt Cook Hawaii 96704 United States
Susan Gierman Captain Cook Hawaii 96704 United States
celeste eaton captain cook Hawaii 96704 United States
Gerri Mahon Captain Cook Hawaii 96704-8233 United States
Rachael Mooter Captain Cook Hawaii 96778 United States
Pamela Greenaway Captain Cook Hawaii 96704 United States
Yvonne Conner Haiku Hawaii 96708 United States
cleo wilson haiku Hawaii 96708 United States
Paul Solomon Haiku Hawaii 96708 United States
Edward Schroeder Hakalau Hawaii 96710 United States
Denise Reghetti Hakalua Hawaii 96710 United States
alan sitt haleiwa Hawaii 96712 United States
Patty Irons Hanalei Hawaii 96714 United States
Jessi A. Hanalei Hawaii 96714 United States
Ike Pono-Payne Hawaiian Beaches Hawaii 96778 United States
Lew Whitney Hawi Hawaii 96719 United States
Hard Truth PAC Hilo Hawaii 96721 United States
Kerri Marks Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Leo W Pexa Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Charles Tuttle Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Sky Doherty Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Ashli Quevedo Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Jennifer Walters Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Christopher Lawinski Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Odette Rickert Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Gerdine Markus Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Ronald Fujiyoshi Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
NICHOLAS ACKERMAN Hilo Hawaii 96721 United States
Bryan Brey Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Page 2
Sheet1
Elisha Sevareid Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Ronald Fujiyoshi Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Joan Wibberley Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Gene Tamashiro Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
tj simms hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Sylvester Anthony Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Allene Kaplan Hilo Hawaii 96721 United States
adam jonath hilo Hawaii 96721 United States
Stephanie Whitehorse Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Megan Magdalene Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Andrea Tischler Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Demetra Adams-Kane Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
michael donenfeld hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Arlene Mullen Hilo ' Hawaii 96720 United States
Cynthia massa Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Wehi Kanewa Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Kay Howe Hilo Hawaii 96720 United States
Georgia Pinsky Hilo Hawaii 96721 United States
Roberta Goodman Holualoa Hawaii 96725 United States
Kaleopono Norris Holualoa Hawaii 96725 United States
Shannon Rudolph Holualoa Hawaii 96725 United States
Geoff Shaw Honoka'a Hawaii 96727 United States
Teresa Sugg Honokaa Hawaii 96727 United States
Puaen Ahn Honokaa Hawaii 96727 United States
Malulani Orton Honolulu Hawaii 96815 United States
Jamie Oshiro Honolulu Hawaii 96816 United States
dangelo mcintyre Honolulu Hawaii 96816 United States
Rick Morse Honolulu Hawaii 96815 United States
damion rosbrugh kaaawa Hawaii 96730 United States
Kristine Mooney kahului Hawaii 96732 United States
Michael McMullen Kahului Hawaii 96733 United States
aikue napoleon-ahn kailua Hawaii 96734 United States
Josephine Keliipio Kailua Kona Hawaii 96740 United States
Benjamin Marantz Kailua Kona Hawaii 96740 United States
Dana day Kailua Kona Hawaii 96740 United States
Michael Dinmore Kailua Kona Hawaii 96740 United States
Alexandra Barber Kailua Kona Hawaii 96740 United States
Reuben Lelah Kailua Kona Hawaii 96740 United States
Melissa Frommer Kailua Kona Hawaii 96740 United States
Elsbeth Brand Kailua Kona Hawaii 96740 United States
Lee Messenger Kailua Kona Hawaii 96740 United States
Deborah Sevy Kailua-Kona Hawaii 96740 United States
A H Kailua-Kona Hawaii 96745 United States
Pamela Russell Kailua-Kona Hawaii 96745 United States
Laura Mallery-Sayre Kailua-Kona Hawaii 96745 United States
cheryl atalig kamuela Hawaii 96743 United States
Daphne Gray Kamuela Hawaii 96743 United States
alice thigpen kamuela Hawaii 96743 United States
Michael Herrick kapaa Hawaii 96746 United States
Marianne Hooker Kapaa Hawaii 96746 United States
Sandra Gray Kapaau Hawaii 96755 United States
Melanie Harper Kapaau Hawaii 96755 United States
James Macey Kapolei Hawaii 96707 United States
Page 3
Sheet1
Sherri Thal Kea'au Hawaii 96749 United States
Robin Worley Kea'au Hawaii 96749 United States
juliann collins Kea'au Hawaii 96749 United States
Rosemarie Patronette Kea'au Hawaii 96749 United States
Janice Dauw Kea'au Hawaii 96749 United States
Gloria Pondela Kea'au Hawaii 96749 United States
Cynthia Warner Kea'au Hawaii 96749 United States
James Clear Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Barbara Fahs Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Richard Coleman Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
John Schinnerer Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Bryn Berg Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Kim LeCates Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Rasha Blais Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Lucretia Hatfield Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
John Erickson Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
David B Maloney Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Jonathan Mather Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
eddie rincon keaau Hawaii 96778 United States
River Rpgers Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Manuel Mercado Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
helga costello keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Mary DeVincent Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
william collins keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Danny Li Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Paul Deeter Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Harvey Huihui Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
vincent callagher Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Kalikolehua Kanaele Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Ann Szaur Keaau Hawaii 96749-8155 United States
Chi Amaral Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Larry Bergner Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Scott Stoddard Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Martie Buchanan Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
jim costello keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Vicki Vierra Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Keith Whitaker Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
susie hawkes Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Debra Luiz Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
Mary Kohman Keaau Hawaii 96749 United States
zachary nathan Kealekekua Hawaii 96750 United States
Sharon Willeford keauhou Hawaii 96739 United States
stave scott keauu Hawaii 96772 United States
myrica morningstar kilauea Hawaii 96754 United States
Brian Woolsey Kilauea Hawaii 96754 United States
Candice Richardson Kilauea Hawaii 96754 United States
Nancy Ravelo Kualapuu Hawaii 96757 United States
Keith Ranney Kula Hawaii 96790 United States
Jim Albertini Kurtistown Hawaii 96760 United States
Cynthia Bettencourt Kurtistown Hawaii 96760 United States
Leah Carrero Kurtistown Hawaii 96760 United States
Margaret Balej Kurtistown Hawaii 96760 United States
Page 4
Sheet1
fred &eva hofer kurtistown Hawaii 96760 United States
Leslie von Arnswaldt Kurtistown Hawaii 96760 United States
Rev. Nancy Harris Kurtistown Hawaii 96760 United States
hanalei Fergerstrom kurtistown, Olaa, Hawaii 96760 United States
Elizabeth Schusser Lahaina Hawaii 96761 United States
Jean-Marc Offergeld Lahaina Hawaii 96761 United States
devon mastrich lahaina Hawaii 96761 United States
Amenala Neahru Lahaina Hawaii 96761 United States
Jim Hague Lawai Hawaii 96765 United States
conrad martel Leilani Estates Hawaii 96778 United States
Jesse Kalishakti Makawao Hawaii 96768 United States
melissa ebeling Makawao Hawaii 96768 United States
angie hofmann Makawao Hawaii 96768 United States
Jenna Chikasuye Mountain View Hawaii 96771 United States
stephen settanni Mountain View Hawaii 96771 United States
Patricia Chikasuye Mountain View Hawaii 96771 United States
Clesson William Chikasuye Mountain View Hawaii 96771 United States
Jennifer Ruggles Mt. view Hawaii 96771 United States
Blake Watson Mt. View Hawaii 96771 United States
Joseph Demoruelle Na'alehu Hawaii 96772 United States
gary cole Naalehu Hawaii 96772 United States
Jamie Kawauchi Naalehu Hawaii 96772 United States
gypsie gwarek naalehu Hawaii 96772 United States
Tina Floyd Ocean View Hawaii 96737 United States
Cabbot Sanders Ocean View Hawaii 96737 United States
Sierra Spruce Ocean View Hawaii 96737 United States
Roy Lozano P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Barb Cuttance P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
richard rimer P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Richard Bidleman P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Terry J Walker P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Gemma Lila P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Lyn Howe P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Tamara Dorman P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Edward Miner P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Bett Bidleman P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Addie Berliner P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Nadia Ranne P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
cindy dupuis P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Sandra Alstrand P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
John Evans P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Ian Gimple P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Steven Quirk P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Randolph McCreight P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Adele Wynne P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Margaret Martin P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
stephanie Kleiman P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
William P.Appleton P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Steven Heselton P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Caroline Delano P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
rulin xiu P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Alexandra Briggs P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Page 5
Sheet1
Stephen Grillo P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
rena wingert P--whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Graham Ellis P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Damian Garramone P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Alex Reif P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Helena Brandfors P--whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Carrie Branovan P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
William Brater P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Kari Anderson P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Lara Johnson P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Charles Harter P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Geri Tolchin P—whoa Hawaii 96778-0894 United States
Trayce Pjirrou P—whoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Suzanne Wakelin Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
robert petricci Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Lance Duncan Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
John Begg Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Richard Denholm Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Geoffrey Kern Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Kaika (Debra)Welch Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Dwayne Tarletz Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jasmine Steiner Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
christopher gonsalves pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jozsef Szuromi Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Valeria Nagy Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Dennis Davis Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Julie Paul Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Geoffrey Last Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Wendy Swoboda Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Fredy Morse Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
sean king pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Valarie Matinjussi Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Emily Low Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Thomas Travis Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Carol Simmons Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Laura Travis Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
chris kaiser pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jack Adam Weber Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Ellen Levine Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
sheri joy pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jeffrey Luther Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Bo Lozoff Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
jessica fueger pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Irina Savery Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Andrew Leo Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Mark Caudill Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Hillary Wilt Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Maurie Ortaleza Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Lee Eisenstein Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
bernadette sabath pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Douglas Orton Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Christy Ceraso Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Page 6
Sheet1
Michelle Schindler Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Maria Arroyo Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Ashley Campbell Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Marsha Nytes Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Sheryl Palmer Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
David Shapiro Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Bob Bogle Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Natasha Alter Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Barbara Ryan Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Kalil Dupuis Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jim Hedgecock Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
ann kobsa Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Satya Anubhuti Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
LEANNE BUDLONG PAHOA Hawaii 96778 United States
Yeshuah Kauhane Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
james grazzini Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
debbie kelly pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Lauren Herskowitz Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Robert Savery Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Kieba Blacklidge pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Ninu-Alexandri Quirk, MD Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Sasha San Malo Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
David Webb Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
michelle carrillo pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
John Arany Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Adam Ranne Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Marilyn Begg Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Rachel Nack Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Daina Cockrell Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Christina Bryan Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
athena peanut Pahoa Hawaii 96778-9710 United States
Aurora Martinovich Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Edith Hall Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Alec Karp Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jahnava Baldassarre pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Mimi Karp Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Katarina Culina pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
annie Ernst Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Karla Tobey Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
John Tobey Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Daniel Moe Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Clive Cheetham Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Eric Berger Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Ryan Hendrickson Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
john olson pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Reverend Mark Johnson Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Debra Preston Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Sarah Milcarek Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Waymer Strahm Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Kim Marzetta Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Debra Smith Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Luella Crutcher Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Page 7
Sheet1
Dianna Wilcox Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Dena Smith Givens Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jennifer Jackson Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Dea Rackley Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
peter Altomare Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Michael Helms Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Melissa Cardwell Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Emma Neilsen Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Julia Conner Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Chris Berry Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Dean Cail Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jenna Way Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
keli mutscheller pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Adrienne Cutten Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Holit Bat-Edit pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Harold Stevens Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Paris Latka Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Steve Hill Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
JOSEPH GARRAMONE PAHOA Hawaii 96778 United States
Noah Moore Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Dale Day Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
brady metcalf pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Lorn Douglas Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Elizabeth McCormick Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Daina Fawn Cockrell Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
sara steiner pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Sienna Aki Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Wade Bauer Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Alexis Lww Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Deanna Evenrud Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Melissa Plotkin Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Nancy Range Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Therese Mulroy Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
terra blackford pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Robert Taylor Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Suzette Ridolfi Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Ryan Jones Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Portia Ownbey Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Steven Jacquier Pahoa Hawaii 96778-1256 United States
hans xiu Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Doran Vaughan Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Hailey Johnson Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Lee Mertins Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
dominique pajot pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Gerald Sarvas Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Tracy Matfin Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Rachel Rose Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Gary Kaupp Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
greg self Pahoa Hawaii 96670 United States
Moses Thrasher Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Hannique Ruder pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Shelley Addison Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Page 8
Sheet1
Sevyn Galambos Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Beverly Frederick Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
LEONARD SUSSMAN Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Paul Crawford Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Leslie Wingate Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Dorian Carter Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
john hayes pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
thorn gagne Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jillian Hurne Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jenni Bearden Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
thomas grexa phillips Pahoa Hawaii 96678 United States
Anne Nuttall Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Richard Koob Pahoa Hawaii 96778-8019 United States
Albert Bicknell Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Janet Taylor Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Wai'ala Ahn Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Michon Olson Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
aliina champion pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
barrie saccomanno pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Gene Thomas Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Jonathan Hensley Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Craig Boening Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
John Calvert Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Share e St.Cyr Pahoa Hawaii 96768 United States
timothy lloyd Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Nicki Conti Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Patricia Spinoza Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
suzanne stjern pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Michael Hyson Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Christopher Biltoft Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Delia Montgomery Pahoa Hawaii 96778-7777 United States
William Craine Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
C Conda Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Erika Satynda Pahoa Hawaii 96749 United States
Dustin Paulsen Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Robert Carrere Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Brad Sorte Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Nancy Davis Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Kim Marzetta Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
John Lemes Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
scott middlekauff pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Mary Fleming Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
robert matinjussi pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Marie Fontana Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Rich Givens Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Pualani Lindsey Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Garry Hoffeld Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Gisele Evans Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Duane Evans Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Anna Sanner Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Joyce Folena Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Charles Traylor Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Dennis Letvin Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Page 9
Sheet1
C
Vicki raine Pahoa
Eric rainra Hawaii 96778 United States
Pahoa Hawaii
96778 United States
Sarah Joy Pahoa
Jim Larsen Hawaii 96778 United States
Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Sahara Lawrence Pahoa Hawaii
david hoffeld pahoa 96778 United States
Joey ere a Meta eta Pahoa Hawaii 967778 United States
� Hawaii 96778 United States
agnes tavres pahoa
Brent Davy Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Da David Kazmierczak Hawaii 96778 United States
pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
David Kazmierczak Pahoa Hawaii
Steve Dailey Pahoa 96778 United States
David Sands Hawaii 96778 United States
Pahoa Hawaii 96778 United States
Glen Swartwout Pahoa Hawaii
Michele David Pahoa (Seaview) Hawaii 96778 United States
Reza Morin-Dayani Pahoa, HI 96778 96778 United States
bruce oatway Paia Hawaii 96778 United States
lames boyle Paia Hawaii 96779 United States
James Tolley Paia Hawaii 96779 United States
Mitsuko Tolley a Pearl City Hawaii 96779 United States
Donald en Harvey Peepeekeo Hawaii 96782 United States
Donal Wessels p Hawaii 96783 United States
Pepeekeo Hawaii 96783 United States
Saturnine Doctor Pepeekeo Hawaii
Joy Gardner Pe 96783 United States
eekeo
p Hawaii 96783 United States
Agnes Repasihi Volcano Hawaii
Terence Spencer Volcano 96785 United States
Hawaii 96785 United States
David Contreras
Volcano Hawaii
Justin 96785 United States
Jn tripp Waikoloa usti Hawaii 96738 United States
vincent mina
Wailuku Hawaii 96793 United States
Connie rios wailuku Hawaii
Amy Nicole Wyant Wailuku 96793 United States
George Medeiros Wailuku Hawaii 96793 United States
Chris Wurtz Hawaii 96793 United States
Chicago Illinois 60630 United States
Susan Havenga Evanston Illinois
Scott Bo Domino Cher Berne Indiana 60202 United States
June Domino ana 46711 United States
Portland Indiana 47371 United States
Jim Oxyer Louisville Kentuck
ryan y 40203 United States broussard Louisiana 70518 United States Ste man Leesville
Louisiana 71446 United States
Erica Conner Germantown Maryland
Paul Newton Irelan Lee Massachusetts United States
Karen Boenin assachusetts 1238 United States
9 Grand Rapids, mi Michigan 49546 United States
kyle Johnson Jackson
Ruby Leal Michigan 49202 United States
Paw Paw Michigan 49079 United States
Kim Hansen Browns Valley Minnesota
Patrick a Chouinard Sparks 56219 United States
p Nevada 89436 United States
Christine Chouinard Pahoa New Ham shire
Betty Ann Welsh Cologne p 96778 United States
il
Edward Quirk Hamilton Township New Jersey 8213 United States
Rena ntos al irk Jerse Cit p New Jersey 8619 United States
R Quirk Middletown Twp New Jersey 7306 United States
Shawn uirk orf Ocean p New Jersey 7748 United States
Amelia Ra mend New Jersey 7712 United States
y Arroyo Hondo New Mexico
87514 United States
Page 10
Sheet1
riki stevens santa fe New Mexico 87594 United States
Andrea Nicklas Albany New York 12208 United States
Desiree Mwalimu Brooklyn New York 11233 United States
Denise Callihan New York New York 10101 United States
Cher Mauro Oceanside New York 11572 United States
Christy Smith Syracuse New York 13210 United States
Douglas Goetsch New York 10014 United States
David Anderson Asheville North Carolina 28805 United States
Lisa DeGirolamo Asheville North Carolina 28805 United States
James V. Jones Akron Ohio 44310 United States
Marcia Loebick Cleveland Ohio 44135 United States
Brenda Kaup Fort Recovery Ohio 45846 United States
Aaron Haslam Ashland Oregon 97520 United States
Anna-Liese Amundson Portland Oregon 97217 United States
DANA rOSE Rogue River Oregon 97537 United States
Juliette Hedgecock Williams Oregon 97544 United States
Nadya Vdov Lewistown Pennsylvania 17044 United States
ellen schomer charlestown Rhode Island 2813 United States
Chris Randall Madison South Dakota 57042 United States
Thomas Van Dyke jackson Tennessee 38305 United States
Glenn Herrick Salt Lake City Utah 84158 United States
Joni Weiss Salt Lake City Utah 84105 United States
Jeni Rodrigues Salt Lake City Utah 84107 United States
paul bromm La Center Washington 98629 United States
Julie Day Olympia Washington 98501 United States
Eric Johnson Seattle Washington 98122-3027 United States
Guy Goodness Tonasket Washington 98855 United States
Danielle Halversen Vancouver Washington 98661-1670 United States
Ruth Barrett Hollandale Wisconsin 53544 United States
Simone Gloser 75175 75175 Germany
Lamoine Maryniak Edmonton T5E 1 H3 Canada
Abby Barrios Ensenada 22890 Mexico
Vikki Peters Mission, British Columbia V2V 105 Canada
Dawn Brookes Neath Sa112LD United Kingdom
Moana Flowers Opotiki 3199 New Zealand
Fred Kwint Utrecht 3523RX Netherlands
Lois Joudrie Vancouver V6E 1Z4 Canada
Kat Norris Vancouver v51 1w5 Canada
Sophia Tara Wellington 6242 New Zealand
Paul Kuykendall
Malina Lobel-Karimi
Jane Whitefield
Dylan Johnson
Nancy Paul
Kathryn Craine
Isis Albright
Darla Cash
Hutt Bush
Dana Rose
jio rose
Steve Bohlert
Henry Klein
Kimo Auwae
Page 11
Sheet1
Bruce Cohen
Katalin Koda
Amara Karuna
Diane Brucato-Thomas
Theodore Banta
Kristen O'Guin
Olena Adams
Brent Magstadt
grant davis
Debbie Hawryliak
Raphael Rayfinder
Kristine Kotecki
Dianna DeRosa
Ken Pierce
Anah Laudenslager
Romy Boyce
Vonnie Bryan
Gayle Chavez
Terra Barsby
Page 12
Sheet1
Name City State Zip Country SignedOn
Lance Duncan Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-16
Jane Whitefield Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-16
James Clear Keaau HI 96749 United States 2012-07-16
Julie Paul Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-16
Richard Bidleman Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-16
Jack Adam Weber Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-16
Ellen Levine Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-16
Keith Ranney Kula HI 96790 United States 2012-07-16
Tina Floyd Ocean View HI 96737 United States 2012-07-16
Irina Savery Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Richard Coleman Kula HI 96790 United States 2012-07-17
Tamara Dorman P--whoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
John Schinnerer Kea'au HI 96749 United States 2012-07-17
Bett Bidleman Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
christy ceraso Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Steve Bohlert United States 2012-07-17
Nadia Ranne P—Uhoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
cindy dupuis Pahao HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Robert Bogle Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Sandra Alstrand P—whoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
ann kobsa Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
John Evans P—whoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Noemi Wallace San Diego CA 92123 United States 2012-07-17
Letisha Boyle Kula HI 96790 United States 2012-07-17
Ninu Quirk, MD Deal NJ 7723 United States 2012-07-17
Henry Klein Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
David Webb Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Michelle Carrillo pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Jesse Kalishakti Makawao HI 96768 United States 2012-07-17
Randolph McCreight Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Aurora Martinovich Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Barbara Wynne Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Edith Hall Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Christopher Lawinski Hilo HI 96720 United States 2012-07-17
Kimo Auwae United States 2012-07-17
Willy Banta Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
Page 1
Sheet1
Kim LeCates Keaau HI 96749 United States 2012-07-17
Kristen O'Guin Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-17
ellen schomer charlestown RI 2813 United States 2012-07-17
Angus Whyte San Francisco CA 94117 United States 2012-07-17
Brent Magstadt Pahoa HI 96749 United States 2012-07-18
conrad martel Leilani Estates HI 96778 United States 2012-07-18
Debra Preston Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-18
Luella Crutcher Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-18
Kaleopono Norris Holualoa HI 96725 United States 2012-07-18
Reza Morin-Dayani Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-18
keli mutscheller pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-18
Jenna Chikasuye Mountain View HI 96771 United States 2012-07-18
Harold Stevens Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-18
Nadya Vdov Lewistown PA 17044 United States 2012-07-18
Ellen Bryant Eureka CA 95503 United States 2012-07-18
Wade Bauer Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-18
June Domino Portland IN 47371 United States 2012-07-18
Robert Taylor Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-18
Candice Richardson Kilauea HI 96754 United States 2012-07-18
River Rogers keaau HI 96749 United States 2012-07-19
Robert Drury Los Angeles CA 90064 United States 2012-07-19
Angela Brentano Casa Grande AZ 85122 United States 2012-07-19
Cabbot Sanders Ocean View HI 96737 United States 2012-07-19
Paul Davis Jasper AR 72641 United States 2012-07-19
Clesson William Chikasuye Mountain View HI 96771 United States 2012-07-19
Rachel Rose Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-20
David Domingo Pleasanton CA 94566 United States 2012-07-20
Page 2
Sheet1
helga costello kea'au HI 96749 United States 2012-07-20
Moses Thrasher Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-21
Paul Crawford Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-22
Dorian Carter Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-22
vincent callagher Keaau HI 96749 United States 2012-07-22
thorn gagne Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-22
Guy Goodness Tonasket WA 98855 United States 2012-07-22
Jillian Hurne Rochester MN 55902 United States 2012-07-22
Richard Koob Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-22
Betty Welsh Cologne NJ 8213 United States 2012-07-22
Barbara Raymond San Francisco CA 94110 United States 2012-07-24
Karen Boening Greenville MI 48838 United States 2012-07-24
Scott Stoddard Keaau HI 96749 United States 2012-07-24
Christopher Biltoft Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-24
catherine ridder altadena CA 91001 United States 2012-07-25
Jim Costello Kea'au HI 96749 United States 2012-07-25
Susan Havenga Evanston IL 60202 United States 2012-07-25
Cindy Conda Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-25
Dustin Paulsen Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-25
Andrea Tischler Hilo HI 96720 United States 2012-07-25
Page 3
Sheet1
Vicki Vierra Keaau HI 96749 United States 2012-07-27
Pualani Lindsey Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-27
nancy barker occidental CA 95465 United States 2012-07-27
Bridget Webb Trabuco Canyon CA 92679 United States 2012-07-28
Michele Denise Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-29
Kat Norris Vancouver v5I 1w5 Canada 2012-07-29
Sahara Lawrence Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-29
Ike Pono-Payne Hawaiian Beaches HI 96778 United States 2012-07-29
Maria Taylor Mission Viejo CA 92692 United States 2012-07-29
agnes tavares pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-29
cynthia massa Hilo HI 96720 United States 2012-07-29
Moana Flowers Opotiki 3199 New Zealand 2012-07-29
Steve Dailey Pahoa HI 96778 United States 2012-07-30
Page 4
Sheet1
Comment
PGV, Department of Health, State of Hawaii care little to nothing for the health of our citizens here on Hawaii island, and as a
Here is the article that shines some light on this issue.
<a href="http://news.yahoo.com/changing-cities-ending-hawaiis-oil-addiction-103101000—abc-news-tech.html" rel="nofollow"=
I live near PGV, &want to keep on living
so something must be done!
This is a residental area, please go to an uninhabited area.
I don't want geothermal wells next door to my house or in my community.
We need health studies and practice evacuation plan.
I have lived here for ten years now in lower puna, near four corners. I have built a haven on my land, turing solid rock to a bur
I, like many here, have a deeply soulful connection to the land and all we have done to make this place more sustainably pros
Let's put the money into solar and wind power and continue to preserve this beautiful place.
Mahalo, Jack
I think that huge solar arrays in North Kona on the big lava desert there would be far more effective, and less dangerous. and
I stand with the people of Puna.
Geothermal in Puna is INSANITY. Why do they keep calling it'green'and 'renewable'?
I protect my home
STOP! JUST STOP THE POISONING OF OURAINAAND PEOPLE. mayor WE DO NOT WANT THIS HERE
Because I believe that instead of putting more energy into geothermal, the county should put its efforts into generating more e
Puna will not be a"sacrifice zone"to serve the wasteful power usage of Honolulu or other islands' mega-resorts. Let them ger
This petition clearly states the safety and health concerns in lower Puna regarding geothermal development. We should not t
I live in Puna with two sons. Despite a very healthy diet and lots of love, they both have had endless problems with sinus and
Because I am appalled by the mayor's disrespect of the people of Puna by vetoing the geothermal bills we worked hard to pa
This is critical to the health and safety of residents as well as the environment. There are much better alternatives to consider
Geothermal should not be considered an alternative form of energy because it is not clean or safe. There are many options fa
Because I believe the Geothermal Power Project can be successful when done using safer and more modern techniques. I w
I see more negative aspects of this plant than positives. I want my pets and my husband, my neighbors and friends to be safe
I love this place and do not want to see it violated, such as by having massive machines boring holes in it or tearing into it. Hi
PGV is way too close to a residential subdivision. Which is illegal. PGV is so noisy that you can't even hear yourself think, alsr
I have family in Puna district, owning 4 properties. I remember the first plant while attending Pahoa HS 1976-1977, when it WE
Environmental disaster, threat to human lives , enough said !
Puna is a pristine agricultural area, one of the few unspoiled areas left in Hawaii. Having dozens of power plants will turn Pur
I've lived in Puna for 33 years. I don't want to see it taken over by development, especially not power plants that can explode
There is no good reason for geothermal, except for a few people who would make a lot of money from it while the rest of us si
It is imperative that we protect the people and the soil on the Island of Hawaii. Do it right, right now.
That oart of the Big Island is SO BEAUTIFUL. Why wreck it with industrial development. Keep Hawaii green! Just look what
Although I like the idea of geothermal reducing our island's dependence on fossil fuel, the placement to drill sites and plants
Dangers of ruining the water table are very real.
Geothermal gass H2S consumes oxygen!
Our family had to leave our home of 26 years because PGV would gasses while we sleep !
PGV gotta go !
To protect our health and future
I am signing because research shows that it is not a good thing for the Earth.
do not compromise the health and safety of your community!
For safety of the community
Geothermal energy is too dangerous.
Page 5
Sheet1
I am signing this because it is the pono thing to do.Anyone who would vote for this cares nothing for their constituency or the
I care about the quality of our'aina, air, ocean, and our quality of life in Puna. That's why I'm signing.
i am aformer resident returning
There is already sufficient NATURAL geothermal activity on the Puna coast. It seems unconscionable to add further UN-NATO
It's time for local governments to listen to the residential community, instead of their constituents waving dollars.
We.
The.
People.
I do not want to see these operations continue so close to residents homes. Too undependable, and vibrations etc have been
I live in Lielani Estates and want to stay healthy.
It is not safe! Its not only the Hydrogen Sulfate, but other toxic substances including the huge amount of Pentane being store
Please we need help to stop a project that puts material comfort before peoples safety.
Lance Duncan wrote"for the 16 billion cost of the cable, we could provide rooftop solar, hot water, and micro wind on every he
Solar is a better alternative. PGV is a source of constant source of noise and environmental pollution. I work with children k-•
i believe the health of my children and me is being compromised and that the current safety measures for the development of
I am signing because I feel extremely concerned about the health ramifications of geothermal on the populace (both human a
I intend on rallying with other youth who have had devastating health ramifications from geothermal and take PGV on! We an
The health risks FAR outweigh the benefits. With only one road (Highway 130) out of the Puna area the residents would be u
MUCH SAFER alternatives to geothermal power, including solar and ocean wave power exist and must be explored and utiliz
I visit the Puna district yearly. It is a beautiful space of natural beauty. If measures aren't taken to protect it the world will lose c
Mahalo
My Grandson and Great Grandchildren live in Hawaii, all of my ohana is there. I'm also concerned about Gov't Weather Modif
I am a land owner in Kapoho, the prososed plants would be very close and dangerous. What if the plants were going to be nE
we spend about 2-3 months per year visiting family in this area of the Big Island. We want them to stay healthy &ourselves .
County must spearhead a mission to address the health and safety issues that are being swept aside by our mayor. We don'
Threat to our farm!
I have asthma and suffer from visiting geothermal areas
Health, Safety, Clear Landscapes, Right to control and benefit from local industrial activities.
My intention is to aid in the well-being of others.
because the energy technology that I am not yet ready to introduce to this island is 1000 times more effective than rippin' up t
I'm sorry, besides the environmental impacts of geothermal, the Hawaiian people consider this as drilling into the heart of their
This area needs to be kept geothermal free.
Have we become so desperate for energy that we value corporations more than human beings?
As a resident of Pahoa, as a person who prioritizes my physical health including the need for clean air, and as a physician wh
I'm concerned for the health and safety of families near the plants.
Page 6
Sheet1
i guess our"representatives"where not interested and never took notice.
None of our"leaders"seem to bother either to see how other countries are dealing with energy generation.
For instance,
In Israel it became law-in 1957 ! -solar water heaters must go on every newly constructed home.
I visited Sagres in Portugal in September of 1987-solar water heaters on roof tops on many buildings including on the 3-stop
I visited northern Germany(lower Saxony)this May 2012, observing many wind generators and large solar voltaic collectors
mostly in the farm villages there.
Note the northern location of Germany compared to Hawaii.
Hawaii-and many other states like Utah,
Arizona, New Mexico-are s0000000000
behind in what's going on big in the rest of the world when it comes to alternative energy generation.
And then there was Tesla- his discoveries conveniently forgotten.
Stop centralized energy cartels adding more poisons to an already toxic world !!!
THIS IS THE HEALING ISLAND !
Build on THAT !
It is wrong to risk the health of residents in favor of corporate profits and political favors.At least hold off on new development
With over 100 miles of rift zone to choose from. Why on earth choose the greenest, most beautiful, and most inhabited place
I am 74 and have been dealing with congestion in the lungs for seven months. Drs say I am in extremely excellent health. I ar
Solar is the best option for the financial and over all health of the Island. It is clean and cost effective. Also the least invasive
The standard around the world for geo-thermal is 10 miles away from people- 10 mile buffer zone-this is standard. Here in F
I am a Native Hawaiian and have already seen what This type of extracting energy has done to the surrounding areas ..The s
We live next door to Geo Thermal and do not believe that there can be a price put on human health. I am expecting and shou
Go with a safer, non-polluting method: Empower our island livelihood by furthering sustainable solar technology throughout H;
I have family on the Big Island. I am shocked that the Mayor and the State of Hawaii has allowed something like this to happy
Although I don't live full-time in Puna, I own a house there where my son and grandson live. I am shocked to learn there is al
Am planning a move there shortly and it needs to be kept a safe area for all and we have the right to preserve the land and p
The county owes the people a 1 mile buffer around PGV. (Feds say it should be 10 miles.)That is your kuleana. Find a way tc
Although PGV has been in operation for several decades, there has yet to be a program that seriously addresses health conc
I own 5 acres on Pohoiki rd. 13-382, and I have just built an eco-green home that is a place of retreat and sanctuary! Off the
common sense
Everyone involved in this (or any power plant, mine, industrial farming project) either pro or con, needs to ask themselves why
The planning safety document hasn't been enforced. It isn't safe.
There are so many safer options, I don't understand. Why this cement well on an active volcano.
The people don't want it. Why does the Mayor and Governer?
I stay off grid on east side da big island for grow da best kine foods, breath fresh airs enjoy peace an quiet, fo provide my oha
Question : What are health benefits of living next to all kine big geothermal power plants?
I can't think of any!!
So please no build over here!!!!
MALAMA KA [-UINA
mahalos,ONE LOVE
I am concerned for the health and safety of those that live near the geothermal plant.
Page 7
Sheeti
They never should have put the geothermal plant in the middle of a subdivision.
In support of the Geothermal health &welfare initive.
i m a property owner and plan on retiring in a safe place to live
I was born in Honolulu. I would like to see my birth-lands remain prestine, beautiful and healthy. Please do not strip and explo
The Petition Letter is clear and I believe and stand by the reasons presented. Personally, I do not feel that a power plant shou
As an Indigenous person, we are all one, working together, to protect what is left of our earth, flora and fauna. Our waters are
Use the sun! Stop fucking up the earth &ALL of us!!!
its time for the people of puna and the world to stand up and tell everyone that its not right. i am you and you are he and we a
Sacred grouds are being raped by the illegally occupied (and greedy) State and businessmen.
i don't need more pollution.
Property in this area that I am unsure about living on with the impact to my health.
Big corporations are making a lot of money at the expense of the health and well being of many lives. When will you big busii
To expand Geothermal without more purposed assessment and evaluation of the health and environmental impact is irrespon
Page 8
Sheet1
itary to ensure big energy projects such as geothermal, big wind, and intrisland cable are done to sup
ails-oil-addiction-103101000--abc-news-tech.html</a>
ctricity, everything by hand and hand tool. It has taken me years of intene and joyful work to do this.
ollute the land where I have made my home, day in and day out, in ways that readier beyond simple
is the WAY TO GO!! Please consider this for the health and safety of all fhe island residents, animals,
have some ill side effects, placing the lives of our community in danger from Qses and other heave m
needing so much.
are asking for. However, if government fails to protect its citizens, the only Cher legal recourse we ha
Duting factors, I now consider the possibility of toxic exposure from the nealny plant as a culprit. I mov,
cal communities. Furthermore this prospect is extremely unsustainable. People in-iawaii need to cons
;, including human safety and life.
f life, without destroying the earth, our home, our self.
operty, and threatens the livelihoods of farmers, and residents. It is by air, the most irresponsible geoth
on the safety of the surrounding communities.
Des not seem wise to me. Geothermal energy is a good idea, but the poweiplant should be far up the
we now already gives off toxins and an unpleasant vibrational hum. We dn't want more of that. Puna
(pant. The Puna side of the Big Island is one of the last great places in Hawaii. Hui could you even ti
gricultural area. Further, inspections--REAL inspections, by the DOH are necessary, and the results mt.
Page 9
Sheet1
ironment. I have owned a house in Kaimu-Kalapana for almost ten years and heartily oppoe this con(
ire plants going in in this area.
interested in helping Oahu and could less about those of us that live in Paa. There should be a 10 n
drillers forevermore."The Mayor and the Hawaii County Council ought to feel olligated to INSIST that
1 mile away. Many geothermal plants around the world are located many milesfrom human habitatior
1 very affected by geothermal: I have been sick my whole life, having been raisedn Mountain View sin
victims of environmental classism with complete disregard for the land, native species, keiki, human he
substantial number of Puna residents who do not own vehicles and survive on rideshang and hitchhiki
)i, County Council members and all related government officials accountable for their ations, (or lack c
is respect the delicate balances in nature and put selfish interets aside. Protect the sacredness and b
people's health. Don't allow these plants, or make them pay to have a 10 mile radis relocated.
related to the actual emisions from PGV into the community's air and aquifer. Tla county's emergen(
icient.
I the peoples right to say no to this.
la! plants, I implore the State of Hawaii to do what is right for its resideits by not allowing futher geoth(
Page 10
Sheet1
en at night
inated.
i for clean air is measured no less.
reed from the mainland in January and continues today. Having had a full mediciitesting program by I
in Hawaii, the Mayor and Puna City Council member Blas are"in the pocket"of tits big business intere
Ca and look at the pine tree next to the site! Pau!
th nor the health of any children or adults in our home. We are also very attachedo our house/land ar
hydrogen fuel for vehicles and pm power.
tural enviromnent.
tment here, making money for themselves for electricity for a city on a differeit island. The people of II
s of a maximum credible event. Such willful neglect is not tolerable. Funds receivel by the County from
', all for green reasons and integrity to the land and the planet! Please prokct this special place" All
sere. The local community doesn't need it or want it. So it comes down to theGREED of a very few pec
Page 11
Sheet1
)ing used by local people. I also worry about the health risks for me and my en and puppy. It is most it
wasteland, and clear-cutting and government and corporate greed, the majoculprits in the destruction
, the health and safety of the public is very important along with a well-ead easily understandable eva
? White might is a cowards plight! Power to the people!
g the population already living near the existing plant reveals there is no threat-apanding into popula
Page 12
Sheet1
)port the military's destruction of our preciou
purchase of land and investment. I have pu.
sea creatures, ground-water, pollution-savi)
etals. I want more solar and less geothermE
ve is a lawsuit. It is only a matter of time be
ed to Hawaii to raise my children in a safe a
ider what is truly sustainable in terms of disl
ermal project I've ever seen in my life and h
mountain in areas where no one lives, work
is one of the last peaceful farm communitiE
-link about destroying it?
1st be made public. This island has a history
Page 13
Sheet1
;ept.
Wile buffer zone and I am not sure if that is b
the State Legislature undertake a thorough
1, and for good reason.
ce I was born in the early 80's, and only dis
,alth, and oceans.
ng would also be unable to evacuate. Rest
)f action), in relation to allowing geothermal
Ireathtaking beauty of the islands.
evacuation plan does nothing to address
=rmal development near residential areas.A
Page 14
Sheet1
May, I was considered to be in excellent hez
,st and will not protect the very people that K
id do not want to give it up!
ie U.S. want clean energy, not this dangero
i PGV operations must be used to address
the creatures, the homes and the families t
)ple. The Puna district of Hawaii is a unique
Page 15
Sheet1
nportant to protect people and the environrr
for'progress' and infrastructure.... and? lar
icuation plan that is geared towards the peo
ted areas is even more irresponsible! With
Page 16