HomeMy WebLinkAboutComm No 0043.37 - Testimony - CA-26 - Qualifications for the Director DPWFrom: Nimr Tamimi <nimr.tamimi@epinc.pro>
Sent: Thursday, June 6, 2019 11:48 AM
To: Charter Commission
Subject: CA 26 written testimony
Aloha Charter Commission Members:
I oppose CA -26, the proposal to amend Section 6-2.2 relating to Qualifications for the Director of the Department of
Public Works. It is vital that the Director's qualifications continue to include the requirement to be a "registered
professional engineer", more accurately, a "licensed professional engineer (P.E.)" because:
1. The Director frequently makes engineering decisions as part of their duties and responsibilities, in fact has the
power to over -rule engineering decisions made by his or her subordinates; many of these decisions potentially
affect the safety, health, and well-being of the public;
2. The adverse risks of an unlicensed engineer, or a non -engineer, over -ruling the engineering judgement of local
DPW engineering staffs, have been well-documented by the National Society of Professional Engineers (NSPE),
and is an unacceptable risk for Hawaii County;
3. Licensed P.E.'s are bound by the NSPE Code of Ethics for Engineers, which first cannon states that "Engineers, in
the fulfillment of their fundamental duties, shall hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public".
The very concept of engineering licensure was developed over a century ago after a series of engineering disasters
causing much damage and fatalities occurred, due to inexperienced persons making critical engineering decisions.
Degrading the nationwide system of licensed engineers in responsible charge of matters of vital engineering decisions
goes against the need to "hold paramount" the safety of the public."
If you are not able to stop this, we would like to ask you to postpone your vote and to include discussion with the local
engineering community to help craft and amendment that would make sense for the County of Hawaii and for the
Engineering Community.
NimrY.Tamimi, P.E.
1
Comm. No. 43.37