HomeMy WebLinkAbout2020-07-02 Arborist Advisory Committee Minutes
Arborist Committee Minutes
July 2, 2020
Page 1 of 3
ARBORIST ADVISORY COMMITTEE
JULY 2, 2020 MEETING MINUTES
OFFICE OF AGING, TRAINING ROOM – HILO
1055 KINOOLE STREET, SUITE 101, HILO, HAWAII
ATTENDANCE
Committee Members Present: Leonard Bisel, Chairperson
James Boyd Friday
Jonathan Sudler, Vice-Chairperson
Carol Wyban
Maurice Messina (Executive Assistant to the Mayor)
Committee Members Absent: Bobby Camara
GUEST Bill Brilhante, Human Resources Director
CALL TO ORDER
The meeting was called to order by Chair Bisel at 10:07 a.m.
STATEMENT FROM THE PUBLIC
None
APPROVAL OF MARCH 6, 2020 COMMITTEE MINUTES
Vice Chair Sudler wanted to make 2 corrections to the minutes.
Change the number of approximately 11000 trees to 1100 listed in the State registry
County of Hawaii only has approximately 31 and should have the largest inventory
Committee member Wyban wanted to make 1 correction to the minutes.
To remove the paragraph about suggesting to publicize to submit exceptional tree
nomination.
th
Motion was moved by Sudler and seconded by Wyban to accept the amended March 6
minutes.
The Committee voted 5-0 to approve the minutes.
COUNTY HUMAN RESOURCES REP. TO ATTEND MEETING TO DISCUSS NEW ARBORIST
POSITION
Arborist Committee Minutes
July 2, 2020
Page 2 of 3
Human Resources Director, Bill Brilhante presented at the meeting. He explained to the
Committee that the Arborist position was funded by the County Council in 2017 and 2018.
However, the position was not filled because no allocation packet was submitted by the
department head from the previous administration. Brilhante also mentioned that in addition
to the allocation packet, a request to fill form would also need to be submitted by the
department to the Managing Director. He informed the Committee that the Mayor has the
ability to transfer a position from one department to another. Chair Bisel suggested that the
Committee should start by talking with the Mayor’s office. EA Messina mentioned that both
Parks and Rec and Public Works are open to having the position transferred over.
EXCEPTIONAL TREE DISCOVERY
Vice Chair Sudler discovered a notice in the newspaper from June 10, 1991 which described an
upcoming public hearing to discuss the nomination of the banyan trees on Banyan Drive for
Exceptional Tree status. According to Sudler the Outdoor Circle book Majesty, included these
banyan trees. Sudler noted that the trees would not have been included in this book if they
were not exceptional. He requested to recertify that the grove of banyan trees is exceptional
because it would provide benefits for the County, and hotel owners.
EA Messina mentioned that since this is a public notice of a public to adopt exceptional trees,
and there should be a publication of how this meeting came out.
Chair Bisel, noted that this was a public notice to discuss the nomination. The notice does not
include the outcome of the meeting. Further, the final step in the nomination process would
include consideration of, and adoption by, the County Council. There should be some records
from the County Council or the Planning Dept.
EA Messina will email the Director of Planning to see what documentation they have from this
meeting and what the vote was.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
DISCUSSION OF DRAFT COUNTY PLAN OF ACTION TO ADVISE THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT
AND THE MAYOR’S OFFICE TO PURSUE ADMINISTRATIVE AND LEGISLATIVE CHANGES TO
ESTABLISH A TREE MAINTENANCE CREW THROUGH A REORGANIZATION WITH THE
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
Chair Bisel mentioned that this is something that was brought up by Roy Takemoto and will be
kept on the agenda.
Arborist Committee Minutes
July 2, 2020
Page 3 of 3
STATUS ON COMMITTEE MEMBER EXCEPTIONAL TREE NOMINATIONS
J Sudler mentioned an orchid tree that was by Kalakaua Park. He was informed that this tree
was originally planted as a commemorative statement. The 22 year old tree was cut down by
County but then was replanted. Sudler wanted the Committees input whether or not this
would make it an exceptional tree.
C Wyban had a question about the Survey123 app.
JB explained to Carol how to use the app and that Asia Wasser maintains the database system.
STATUS OF RETRIEVAL OF COUNTY ORDINANCES RELATING TO EXISTING EXCEPTIONAL TREES
Chair Bisel explained that at the last meeting they broke up the list of exceptional trees
Committee was given the task of going out and verifying their condition and documenting this.
JB used the app and located several trees.
ANNOUNCEMENTS
J Sudler announced that Outdoor Circle was able to facilitate a meeting with Parks and Rec
regarding the monkey pod trees at Panaewa Zoo. It was concluded that Mike Kraus will be
taking care of the trees in the equestrian center but also the 2 trees in the parking lot as well.
JB also had an announcement regarding the Kaulunani State Program and Smart Trees Pacific
was working with Cal Poly on developing an urban tree selection database.
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned by Chair Bisel at 11:18 a.m.