Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutFY21-22-MEDUSKY & CO. INC.-48+.- Q7•; W!1 15. 7 Ca= FINANCE MeduskySzCo., Inc. REAL ESTATE CONSULTANTS QUEEN'S COURT, SUITE 405 a 800 BETHEL STREET HONOLULU, HAWAII 96813 PHONE (808) 531.2765 • FAX (808) 599.3736 EMAIL - medusky®meduskyandeo.com Via Email(crystal lene.pacheco@hawaiicounty.gov) Deanna Sako Director of Finance County of Hawai'i 25 Aupuni Street Hilo, Hawaii 96720 Dear Ms. Sako: „_,. JUN 1 4 2021 June 14, 2021 R. Medusky, MAI, CRE Subject: Letter of interest to Provide Professional Real Estate Appraisal Services for (Category No. 40) for Fiscal Year 202112022 In response to your Notice to Providers of Professional Services, Medusky & Co., Inc. (formerly known as Cowell & Co., Inc.) is submitting this letter of interest to provide Real Property Appraisal services (Category No. 40) for the July I, 2021 to .Tune 30, 2022 fiscal year. Our office is located in downtown Honolulu in the Queen's Court building at 800 Bethel Street. Over the past seven years, we have employed an average of two (2) full-time employees and one (1) independent contractor. We have been in the real estate business for 40+ years with assignments covering an extensive variety of properties and clients throughout the Pacific Basin. Services provided include appraisal/valuation studies, arbitration, tax appeals, highest and best use/development studies, acquisitional analysis, disposition analysis and market studies. Property types include commercial, industrial, resort hotel, multi -family residential, subdivision, preservation and agricultural. We have previously completed appraisal assignments for the County of Hawaii and believe that we are well qualified to provide real estate appraisal/consulting services for the County of Hawaii in the future. Please find enclosed herein qualifications of key members of our company (Jan R. Medusky, President and Edward W. Becker, Real Estate Appraiser), the State of Hawaii DCCA Certified General Appraiser licenses for said key members, our Certificate of Vendor Compliance, proof of E&O insurance and our company brochure. Item No. 4 of the "Notice to Providers of Professional Services" requests a list of our projects. Please find enclosed herein a list of several recent projects encompassing many different property types. Per your request, listed on a following page are five client contact names for assignments completed within the past year to be used as references. Real Estate Research a Counseling a Valuation a Feasibility a Investments Deanna Sako June 14, 2021 Page 2 1. Gil J. Farias, Jr. Manager, Trust Real Estate Appraisal Bank of Hawaii P.O. Box 2900 Honolulu, Hawaii 96846 (808)694-4738 2. Trevor A. Brown, Esq. Starn O'Toole Marcus & Fisher 733 Bishop Street, Suite 1900 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 (808) 537-6100 Scott R. Rodie Vice President - Appraisal & Environmental Risk Management Bank of Hawaii Wholesale Credit Administration P.O. Box 2900 Honolulu, Hawaii (808)694-4556 4. Scot J. Voronaeff, MAI, CCIM Senior Review Appraiser NAVFAC Pacific - Asset Management Real Estate Support Branch (AM 12) 258 Makalapa Drive, Suite 100 JBPHH, Hawaii 96860-3134 (808) 473-0566 5. C. Michael Heihre, Esq. Cades Schutte LLP 1000 Bishop Street, Suite 1200 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 (808)521-9200 We provide a timeline for completion when submitting a proposal for an assignment and we and we strive to adhere to that schedule. As such, there have not been any corrective actions or notices of deficiencies for any of our completed assignments. In most cases, cost control is maintained by estimating a fixed fee for an assignment prior to its commencement. However, if the scope of the assignment cannot be determined prior to commencement, a minimum and maximum fee range is established. When required, additional work is completed based on hourly rates. The current hourly rate for Edward Becker, MAI of Medusky & Co., Inc. is $400 per hour and the current hourly rate for Jan R. Medusky, MAI, CRE is $450 per hour. Deanna Sako June 14, 2021 Page 3 If you have any further questions, please feel free to call our office. Thank you for considering Medusky & Co., Inc. for your real estate appraisallconsulting needs. We look forward to working with you again in the future. Sincerely, MEDUSKY A&ACO., INC. Jan R. Medusky, MAI, CRE President Edward W. Becker, MAI Real Estate Appraiser EWB:cpj Enclosures QUALIFICATIONS OF JAN R. MEDUSKY, MAI. CRE President, Medusky & Co.. Inc., Real Estate Consultants Queen's Court, Suite 405, 800 Bethel Street, Honolulu, Hawaii President (1990-1994). Cowell & Co.. Inc. Licensed Real Estate Broker, State of Hawaii (License No. RB -16915) Member. Appraisal Institute (MAI), Hawaii Chapter (Certificate No. 7313) Past President, American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers Honolulu Chapter No. 15 Member. The Counselors of Real Estate (CRE) (Certificate No. 2560) Past Chapter Chair. The Counselors of Real Estate Hawaii Chapter lawaii State Certified General Appraiser (CGA -17) C,DUCATION Curer Militar) Academy. Culver. Indiana Graduated with honors. 1964-1968. Bachelor of Science Degree. U.S. Military Academy, West Point, New York. 1968-1972. University of Fla,%aii. Graduate courses in Business and Economics, 1975-1976. Master of Business Administration Degree, Chaminade I Ini%ersit) of Honolulu. 1980. SPECIAL COURSES Graduate Real Estate Institute, Courses I and 11. Honolulu. 1979. Stapleton School of Real Estate. Sales Licensing Course. Honolulu. 1979. Various Appraisal Institute and American Institute of Real Estate Appraisal Courses. Instructor for various seminars/classes regarding real estate valuation. MILITARY Captain. U.S. Army. 1972-1978. Field %arious positions including Commander. Air Defense Artillery Battery and Special Staff Officer, 251s Infantry Di%-ision General Staff. Schofield Barracks, Hawaii. FXPFRIENCF. Engaged in real estate consultation and valuation throughout the Pacific Basin since 1979. Geographical areas covered include the four counties of the State of Hawaii. the Territory of Guam. the Federated States of Micronesia. Republic of the Marshall Islands. Republic of Palau. Saipan. American Samoa and selected locations on the West Coast of the United States Mainland. Specializes in valuation for litigation purposes. tar appeals, leased fee conversions, arbitrations and rent renegotiations COMMUNITY SERVICE Hawaii Public Radio Board Member (2009 to 2018) ALS Association Golden West Chapter Board Member (2014 to Present) ALS Ohana of Hawaii Past President and Current Secretary (2013 to Present) JAN R MEDUSKY 800 BETHEL ST STE 405 HONOLULU, HI 96813 CGA -17 NOTICE THIS POCKET ID CARD IDENTIFIES YOU TO THE PUBLIC AS BEING CURRENTL Y LICENSED AND SHOULD BE KEPT IN YOUR POSSESSIONAT ALL TIMES. LICENSE NUMBER I EXPIRATION DATE CGA -17 12/31/2021 STATE OF MAVAN DEPARTItENT OF [ ONNERCE ANO CONSONERAFFMRS CERTIFIED GENERAL APPRAISER:� I tE CF k� " �' W9 ,C ❑ 0 � jf6 JAN R MEDUSKY g 800 BETHEL ST STE 40 f HONOLULU, HI 96813 �. k r G� 1 OF LICENSEE QUALIFICATIONS OF EDWARD W. BECKER, MAI Real Estate Appraiser, Medusky & Co., Inc., Real Estate Consultants Queen's Court, Suite 405, 800 Bethel Street, Honolulu, Hawaii EDUCATION Bachelor of Arts Degree University of Hawaii at Manoa, Honolulu, Hawaii Political Science Major SPECIAL COURSES State Certification Courses Appraising the Single Family Residence Foundations of Real Estate Appraisal Real Estate Appraisal Methods Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice Appraisal Institute Courses 550 - Advanced Applications 540 - Report Writing and Valuation Analysis 530 - Advanced Sales Comparison and Cost Approaches 520 Highest & Best Use and Market Analysis 510 Advanced Income Capitalization 430 - Standards of Professional Practice, Part C 420 - Standards of Professional Practice, Part B 410 Standards of Professional Practice, Part A Appraisal Institute Seminars, Programs An Introduction to Valuing Commercial Green Buildings Business Practices and Ethics Eminent Domain and Condemnation Appraising Feasibility, Market Value, Investment Timing: Option Value FHA and the Appraisal Process New Industrial Valuation Review Theory General Site Use and Valuation Analysis Small Hotel.Motel Valuation The Appraiser as an Expert Witness: Preparation and Testimony Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions Valuation of Conservation Easements University of Hawaii at Manoa, Small Business Management Program, Real Estate Licensing Course EXPERIENCE Engaged in real estate consultation and valuation since 1993. Geographic areas covered include the four counties of the State of Hawaii, the Republic of the Marshall Islands, Republic of Korea and American Samoa. Property types include agricultural, industrial, office, preservation, residential, resort, shopping center, subdivision and various other property types. EDWARD W BECKER 370 KUPAUA PL HONOLULU, HI 98821 CGA -581 NOTICE THIS POCKET ID CARD IDENTIFIES YOU TO THE PUBLICAS BEING CURRENTLYLICENSED AND SHOULD BE KEPT IN YOUR POSSESSION AT ALL TIMES. LICENSE NU!n I EV RATION DATE CGA -581 12131/2021 .oR as eww OM rr ar taemece un caesura CERTIFIED GENERAL APPRAISER EDWARD W BECKER 370 KUPAUA PL HONOLULU, HI 98821 , ( f YOrAIUr[ OF L1G[110F! v r0'e.�`.r' i Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs CERTIFICATE OF GOOD STANDING I, the undersigned Director of Commerce and Consumer Affairs of the State of Hawaii, do hereby certify that according to the records of this Department, MEDUSKY & CO., INC. was incorporated under the laws of Hawaii on 08/14/1975 ; and that it is an existing corporation in good standing, and is duly authorized to transact business. AMERCE AV0 v° C0 Z O C. OU, L � D r -r� a � a a O c� TQT� OF ftA`NP IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs, at Honolulu, Hawaii. Dated: May 18, 2021 F� cg� Director of Commerce and Consumer Affairs To check the authenticity of this certificate, please visit: http://hbe.ehawaii.gov/documentsi:authenticate.htm1 Authentication Code: 397388 -COGS PDF -29306D1 1 � LIA Administrators i& Insurance Services APPRAISAL, VALUATION AND PROPERTY SERVICES ASPEN PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY INSURANCE POLICY DECLARATIONS Aspen American Insurance Company ,11cferred to below a., the "Compan) 590 Madison AVCnul', 7th Fluor New York, NY 10022 877-245-3510 Date Issued Policy Number Precious Policy Number 111/28/21124) ;\-111X)7310-06 ,A A [1107 3 1 0-0 5 T[ IN ISA CLAIMS \IAI1 .AND RI:POR-l'1_D POI,ICI'. COV[:R:AGI:IS f.l\[C[1:0'fU 1.11BllJ Y FOR ONLYT IOSIt' CLAIMS THAT :ARI: FIRS"I' MAIN: %GAINS'[' Till: INSURED DURI%G -1-III: POLICY PERIOD ;AND I[II \ RI:PORI[:D TO '1111: (;(l\IP:ANY IN WRITING NO ].ATEA THAN tilt -I'1' (60) DAN'S ;A111=11 [?\P[RATIO\ OR TI:R\IIN ATiON OI' THIS POLICY, OR DURING THF EXTENDED REPORTING PERIOD, IF APPLI(:ABIJ�„ 1�OR A WRONGFUL ACT COLMN1111-1;D ON OR Ah1'1:R Till: RETROACTIVE DATE .AND BI:hOlth. '1'111-' FND OF 11H.' POLICY PERIOD. PLEASE READ TI ll. 11OIJCY ('ARI:I+U1.lN. 1. Customer ID: 135056 Named Insured: \11iDUSK1' & CO, INC. 800 Bethel St., Suite 405 1 lonolulu, 11196813 2. Policy Period:larom: 11/10/2020 To: 11/1012MI 12:01 .A.,\I Standard'I'tmc at the address stated in 1 abov - 3. Deductible: Sli?;10 Each Claim 4. Retroactive Date: 09/09/1995 S. Inception Date: 11/10/2015 6. Limits of Liability: A. $1,000,000 Itach Claim B. 52,000,000 Aggregate Subpoena Response: 55,000 Supplemental Payment Coverage Pre -Claim Assistance: S5,000 Supplemental Payment Coverage Disciplinary Proceeding: 512,500 Supplemental Payment Coverage Loss of Earnings: 5500 per day SUPPICMLnral payment Coverage 7. Covered Professional Services (as defined in the Policy and/or by Endorsement): Real Itistatc ;Appraisal and \'aluanon: AyesX No Residential Property: Yvs X No Commerciall'ropertm': 1'478 X No Bodily Injury and irroperty Damage Caused During :Appraisal Inspecnon (S 100,000 Sub -Limit): Yes X No If "yes", added by endorsement Right of Way Agent and Relocation! Ayes No X \Iaehiner• and Equipment Valuation_ Yea No X Personal Property Appraisal; Yes No X (if "lyes", added by endorsement Real Estate Sales/ Brokerage: Yes No X If "yes", added by endorsement .Aspen .\mcrtcan Insurance (:omPaey 112 e I of 2 1,1. \01)1 {04/ 19) $, Report Claims no: LI A AdminisiratthnL & Ittwnncc tier+uca, SIR) -3114-0652, PO Box 1317, 1600 \nacapa tit, tiann Barbara, California 93101 9. Annual Premium- $2,157.00 10. Forms attached at issue- 1.1.1002 (04/19) MA Hl (05/19} I.I;1013 (05/19)1.1;1018 (05/19)1.1;1164 (05/19)1.1;1165 (05119} This heclarauons Page, together with the completed and signed Pulicv Apphcarion including all anaehmcnn and cshibus ncLrcto, and the Pnlic}, shall con aiture the contract between rhe Named Insured and the Compan) . 10/28/2020 IM Date .luthorizcd kpresclrmslivt lspen American Insurance Compatn Page 2 of 2 [.ax[ ID- 11$1156 1.IAW1 m4/191 Appraisal, Valuation and Property Services Professional Liability Insurance Policy Named Insured: MEDI;SKY & CO., INC. Policy Number: AA1007310-06 Effective Date: 11 10.2020 Customer ID: 135056 THIS ENDORSEMENT CHANGES THE POLICY. PLEASE READ IT CAREFT'LLY. ADDITIONAL COVERED PROFESSIONALS ENDORSEMENT In consideration of the premium charged, it is agreed that Section IV. DEFINITIONS (I) "Insured" is amended to include: "Insured" means: The persons identified below, but only while acting on behalf of the Named Insured: Name Jan R. Medusky Edward Becker Coverage Effective Date 1111012020 11110!2020 All other terms, conditions, and exclusions of this Policy remain unchanged. Aspen American Insurance Company LIA012 (05,19) Page I of 1 MEDUSKY & CO., INC. 800 BETHEL STREET QUEEN'S COURT, SUITE 405 HONOLULU, HAWAII 96813 PAST ASSIGNMENTS I. Property Type: Oceanfront Land Client: Department of Interior TMK: (3) 8-5-7-27 et al. Date of Assignment: 11/24120 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Services Regarding ALKA Ki'ilae Estates, South Kona, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii 2. Property Type: Agriculture Land Client: Agribusiness Development Corporation TMK: (1) 6-4-3-16 et al. Date of Assignment: 01112121 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Services Regarding Fair Market Rent for Pasture Land, Waialua, Oahu, Hawaii 3. Property Type: I'se and Occupancy Agreement Client: Halewaiolu Senior Development, LLC TMK: (1) 1 -7 -Por. 6 Date of Assignment: 12.1"15'20 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Services Regarding Market Value of Two Use and Occupancy Agreements for Electrical and Water Line Purposes, Vineyard Boulevard, Honolulu, Oahu, Hawaii 4. Property Type: Commercial Land Client: Kawa Capital Management TMK: (2) 4 -4 -2 -52 -CPR 1 to 5 Date of Assignment: 10114120 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Services Regarding Medical Facility Property, Lahaina, Maui, Hawaii 5. Property Type: Commercial Improvements Client: Army Corp of Engineers TMK: (1) 2-1-47-1 Date of Assignment: 10+119;120 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Services Regarding Office Space, 711 Kapiolani, Honolulu, Oahu, Hawaii 6. Property Type: Telecommunication Site Client: KIUC/AT&T TMK: (4) 4 -5 -5 -5 -Por. 14 Date of Assignment: 03131/21 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Services Regarding Telecommunication Property, Kapaa, Kauai, Hawaii MEDUSKY & CO., INC. 800 BETHEL STREET QUEEN'S COURT, SUITE 405 HONOLULU, HAWAII 96813 7. Property Type: Commercial Property Acquisition Client: Cindy Brown TMK: N/A Date of Assignment: 05114120 Nature of Assignment: Counseling Regarding Sherwin Williams #8554, Bend, Oregon 8. Property Type: Conservation Land Client: Nature Conservancy TMK: (2) Date of Assignment: 10131119 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Services Regarding Conservation Easement on Residential Land at Kealakekua Ranch, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii 9. Property Type: Industrial Client: S&F Land Co., Inc. TMK: (2) 3 -8 -5 -Por. 3 Date of Assignment: 01/27-21 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Services Regarding Industrial Property, Puunene, Maui, Hawaii 10. Property Type: Multi -Family Client: James A. Cameron TMK: (1) 7-5-27-10-25 et al. Date of Assignment: 05/07/21 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Services Regarding Five Leased Fee Interests, Hidden Valley Estates, Wahiawa, Oahu, Hawaii 11. Property Type: Single -Family Residential Client: Mancini Welch & Geiger TMK: (2) 4-8-3-45 Date of Assignment: 06/01/21 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Services Regarding Residential Property, Olowalu, Maui, Hawaii 12. Property Type: Single -Family Residential (Condo) Client: Case Lombardi & Petit TMK: (1) 2-1-55-41 CPR 387 Date of Assignment: 02/19/20 Nature of Assignment: Appraisal Report Regarding Apt. 4210, The Collection, Honolulu, Oahu, Hawaii MEDUSKY & CO., INC. Real Estate Consultants A professional organization providing real estate consulting services to clients in the Pacific Basin requiring responsible, comprehensive and creative guidance to assist in formulating informed decisions and viable solutions to difficult real estate problems. Mediuky & Co.. Inc. I BACKGROUND AND CONCEPT During recent years, problems with real estate ownership and development have become increasingly complex due to worldwide economic factors, governmental policies and regulations, and the competitive nature of real estate activities. in order to maximize earnings and profits while reducing losses and risks, individuals, corporations and institutions involved in real estate ownership and development often require the services of informed and objective consultants. Recognizing the expanding need for professional real estate consulting services, Medusky & Co., Inc. (previously known as Cowell & Co., Inc.) was established in 1975. The firm's extensive experience in the field allows it to provide its clients with a wide variety of specialized real estate consulting services, including valuation studies, feasibility studies, market studies and market expertise. Such background includes real estate consulting, appraising and brokerage. In addition to the above services, Medusky & Co., Inc also specializes in identifying major real estate investment opportunities in the Pacific Basin for financial institutions, corporations and private and foreign investors. Acting through his brokerage firm (Realty Advisors, Inc.), Mr. Medusky is able to represent clients in major real estate transactions. Mednsk} d Co., Inc. 2 TYPES OF SERVICES PERFORMED APPRAISAL IAL UA TION STUDIES Detailed valuation studies completed for a wide variety of purposes, including mortgage loan financing, rent renegotiation, litigation, disposition, acquisition, asset management, leased fee conversions, etc. ARBITRA TION/LITIGA TION Available for service as an arbitrator, consultant and/or expert witness for disputes involving real estate, including rent renegotiations, valuation and other matters. REAL PROPERTY TAX APPEALS ANALYSIS Review real property tax assessed values and associated real property taxes. Services include valuation analysis for real property tax appeal purposes. HIGHEST AND BEST USE/DEVELOPMENT STUDIES Conduct market investigations, prepare feasibility analyses and counsel clients regarding the most productive utilization for sites proposed for development. Such studies can be incorporated into the planning process to maximize income, profits and potential. ACQUISITIONAL ANALYSIS Conduct land use investigations and market analyses for clients acquiring vacant and/or improved properties. In addition to providing market research and recommendations, specialized services available include acquisition and lease negotiation. Relocation studies are prepared for clients desiring facilities for their own occupancy. DISPOSITIONANALYSIS Analyze corporate real property holdings and conduct market investigations to determine which properties should be sold or retained. Marketing strategies are also formulated in conjunction with disposition recommendations. MARKETING CONSULTANT Establish marketing strategies and prepare marketing brochures for various types of real property. Services include client counseling regarding probable selling price, sale terms and potential buyers. MARKET STUDIES Conduct research regarding office, industrial, hotel, retail and residential development opportunities. Market data is analyzed and utilized to estimate rent levels, price levels, absorption rates, market demand and related factors. The results of the market study can be incorporated into architectural planning for development. Medusky & Co., hne. 3 MAJOR STUDIES AND ASSIGNMENTS CONDUCTED BY MEDUSKY & CO., INC. 1. Valuation of all privately owned property on the Island of Guam, Mariana Islands, for real property tax purposes. This major study, initiated by the Government of Guam and completed over a 2l -month time frame from 1993 through 1995. involved approximately 50,000 properties, including land and improvements. The study covered all types of privately owned real estate ranging from agricultural and residential properties to office buildings, hotels, shopping centers and industrial properties. 2. Counseling and valuation analyses involving all State-owned commercial, industrial and resort land located in Koror State, Republic of Palau. The purpose of this assignment, which was completed for the Koror State Government, was to provide land/lease rent counseling services in order to establish ground rent for various commercial/industrial properties located throughout Koror State in the Republic of Palau. A similar study was also completed for the Palau national government. 3. Leased fee analyses for purposes of converting leasehold residential properties to fee simple status. Over the last 25 years, the firm has been involved in the conversion of over 30 single-family residential tracts and 200 condominium/co -operative apartment projects located throughout the State of Hawaii. This work has been done for lessors, lessees, and lending institutions. 4. Market rent study for 9,404 acres of land comprising of The National Park of American Samoa on the islands of Tutuila, Ta'u, Ofu and Olosega, Territory of American Samoa. This study was completed for the U.S. National Park Service and served as the basis of establishing ground rent for the park payable to landowners in American Samoa. 5. Served as consultant for Hawaii investors involved in 1031 tax deferred exchanges regarding the acquisition of properties on the mainland United States. Such sales involved the acquisition of the First Technology Federal Credit Union Building in Portland, Oregon, for $5 million, as well as other transactions. 6. Consultant to JMB Realty (Chicago, Illinois) for real property valuation matters regarding the merger of Amfac, Inc. with JMB Realty. This major study involved preliminary valuation of all real estate holdings of Amfac, Inc. located throughout the Hawaiian Islands. 7. Broker representing buyers in several transactions involving leased fee interests in land under condominium projects. Recent sales include The Mahana ($11.2 million), Kaanapali Shores ($22.4 million), Luana Kai ($4.5 million), Royal Kahana ($12.0 million) and Pohailani Maui ($5.8 million). Medus4, & Co., Inc. 4 REPRESENTATIVE CLIENT LIST: FinanciaMending Institutions Bank of America Bank of Hawaii Churchill Mortgage Corporation (Los Angeles) City Bank Deutsche Bank Mortgage Capital (New York) First Hawaiian Bank Property Manaement Companies Certified Management Chaney Brooks & Company Property Owners/Developers Alexander & Baldwin, Inc. Aineron HC&D Castle & Cooke, Inc. Hawaiian Electric Industries (HEI, Inc.) Government Agencies State/County County of Kauai Department of Hawaiian Home Lands Department of Land and Natural Resources Federal Department of Agriculture Department of the Interior Department of Justice Pacific Basin Government of American Samoa Government of Guam Attorneys Alston Hunt Floyd & Ing Ashford & Wriston Carlsmith Ball LLP Cades Schutte Fleming & Wright Damon Key Leong Kupchak Hastert Gelber Gelber Ingersoll Klevansky Goodsill Anderson Quinn & Stifel Hawaii National Bank Sanwa Bank (New York) The Long -Term Credit Bank of Japan (Japan) The Mitsui Trust & Banking Co., Ltd. (Japan) TIAA — CREF (New York) Wells Fargo Bank Colliers Monroe & Friedlander Hawaiiana Management MW Group Mauna Kea Properties, Inc. Mitsui Construction Nauru Phosphate Royalties (Honolulu), Inc. Department of Transportation Department of Agriculture State Attorney General's Office Department of the Navy General Services Administration Veteran's Administration Guam Airport Authority Koror State Government, Republic of Palau Kemper & Watts Kuniyuki & Chang McCorriston Miho Miller & Mukai Neeley & Anderson Paul Johnson Park & Niles Reinwald O'Conner Marrack Hoskins & Playdon Rush Moore Craven Sutton Morry & Beh Medurky & Co., hic 5 COMPENSATION Medusky & Co., Inc. is compensated on a fee basis. Typically, a fixed fee is estimated for an assignment before its commencement. However, if the scope of an assignment cannot be determined prior to commencement, a minimum and maximum fee range is established. It is our standard practice to require a retainer fee upon acceptance of our proposal and prior to commencement of the assignment. The balance is due upon completion of the assignment or as may otherwise be arranged. Consulting services are also available on a retainer fee basis. The fee is subject to review and adjustments if the scope of services provided changes substantially from that originally anticipated. Our professional fees are based on the following factors: Complexity of the assignment Professional talents required Time required for assignment completion Personnel involved Urgency of the assignment Magnitude of the assignment Responsibility involved Medusky & Co., Inc. 6 JAN R. MEDUSKY, MAI, CRE Corporate President PROFESSIONAL BACKGROUND Associate of Medusky & Co., Inc. (previously known as Cowell & Co., Inc.) since 1979, initially as Research Analyst and, subsequently as Staff Appraiser, Senior Appraiser, Vice President and President. PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS Member, The Counselors of Real Estate (CRE), Certificate No. 2560. 2003 Chapter Chair, Hawaii Chapter of the Counselors of Real Estate. Member, Appraisal Institute (MAI), Certificate No. 7313. 1990 President, Honolulu Chapter No. IS, American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers. State of Hawaii, Certified General Appraiser (License No. CGA -17). Territory of Guam, Certified General Appraiser (Inactive License No. CA 92-006). Licensed Real Estate Broker, State of Hawaii (License No. RB -16915). Member, Honolulu Board of Realtors. EDUCATION Culver Military Academy, Culver, Indiana; graduated with honors, 1964-1968. Bachelor of Science Degree, U.S. Military Academy, West Point, New York, 1968-1972. University of Hawaii, Graduate courses in Business and Economics, 1975-1976. Master of Business Administration Degree, Chaminade University of Honolulu, 1979-1980. SPECIAL REAL ESTATE COURSES Graduate Real Estate Institute, Courses I and 11, Honolulu, 1979. Stapleton School of Real Estate, Sales Licensing Course, Honolulu ,1979. Stapleton School of Real Estate, Brokers Course, Honolulu, 1996. Various Appraisal Institute courses. MILITARY Captain, U.S. Army, 1972-1978. Held various positions including Commander, Air Defense Artillery Battery and Special Staff Officer, 25`x' Infantry Division General Staff, Schofield Barracks, Hawaii. PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE Engaged in real estate consultation and valuation with Medusky & Co., Inc. (previously known as Cowell & Co., Inc.) since 1979. Geographical areas covered include the four counties of the State of Hawaii, the Territory of Guam, Federated States of Micronesia, Republic of Marshall Islands, Republic of Palau, Saipan, Territory of American Samoa, Republic of Korea and West Coast of the Mainland U.S. Experience includes valuation of commercial, resort hotel, industrial, multi -family residential and agricultural properties. Special assignments include marketing and feasibility studies. Specializes in valuation for litigation purposes including condemnation, real property tax assessment appeals, rent renegotiations and other matters. Qualified as an expert witness on property values in the State Courts of Hawaii. Served as Broker specializing in leased fee conversions for condominium projects. Medusky & Co.. Inc 7 EDWARD W. BECKER, MAI Real Estate Appraiser PROFESSIONAL BACKGROUND Associate of Medusky & Co., Inc. (previously known as Cowell & Co., Inc.) since 1993, initially as Research Analyst and, subsequently as Real Estate Appraiser. PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS Designated Member, Appraisal Institute (MAI) State of Hawaii, Certified General Appraiser (License No. CGA -581). EDUCATION Bachelor of Arts Degree, University of Hawaii at Manoa, Honolulu, Hawaii. SPECIAL REAL ESTATE COURSES AV12raisal Institute Courses 550 — Advanced Applications. 540 — Report Writing and Valuation Analysis. 530 — Advanced Sales Comparison and Cost Approaches. 520 — Highest & Best Use and Market Analysis. 510 —Advanced Income Capitalization. 430 — Standards of Professional Practice, Part C. 420 — Standards of Professional Practice, Part B. 410 — Standards of Professional Practice, Part A. Various other Appraisal Institute courses. PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE Engaged in real estate consultation and valuation with Medusky & Co., Inc. (previously Cowell & Co_, Inc.) since 1993. Geographic areas covered include the four counties of the State of Hawaii, the Republic of the Marshall Islands, American Samoa and Republic of Korea. Experience includes valuation of commercial, resort hotel, industrial, multi -family residential and agricultural properties. Special assignments include marketing and feasibility studies. Medusky d, Co- lire. 8