Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2022-07-27 Minutes TAXBOARDOFREVIEW MEETINGMINUTES AppealHearings Wednesday,July27,2022 AupuniCenterConferenceRoom 101PauahiSt.,Hilo,Hawaii CALLTOORDER CharipersonNelsonHaranocalledthemeetingtoorderat9:00a.m. Present:BoardMembersNelsonHarano,DianeBlancett-Maddock,MichaelOkumotoandDale Tokuuke;DeputyCorporationCounselSinclairSalas-Ferguson,DeputyCorporationCounsel SylviaWan;RealPropertyTaxAsst.AdministratorKeitaJo,RealPropertyTaxAppraisal SupervisorDionneCostaandRealPropertyInterimAppealsBoardClerkTyoanyTavares. STATEMENTSFROMTHEPUBLIC Therewerenostatementsfromthepublic. TAXAPPEALCASEHEARINGS Note:Priortothestartofthecasehearings,DeputyCorporationCounselSinclairSalas- Fergusondidnotannouncethegeneralproceduresoftheappealhearingastherewereno appellantsormembersfromthepublicpresent. Foreachappealcase,theappraisersubmittedapacketofinformationtotheBoard,unless therehadbeenapriorsettlementwiththeAppellantorwithdrawal.IftheAppellantwasnot present,anyinformationsentinbytheAppellantwaspresentedtotheBoardalongwiththe appraisers’packet. CASE#45120–PHILLIPS,MARY TMK1-2-006-013-0000 Theappellant,MaryPhillips,wasnotpresent.PresentforthecountywasAppraiser,Dori Ho’ohuli. TheparcelisvacantlandlocatedoffofUpperPunaRoadwhichisinthePunaDistrictatthe16- milemarker. Thelandvalueisunderappeal. Countypresentedtheircaseandrecommendedsustainingvalueat$280,400. Acallforquestionswasmade. Ms.Blancett-MaddockmovedtosustaintheCounty’srecommendationofvalues.Mr. Okumotoseconded.Acallfordiscussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof4:0. CASE#44504–CALIBOSO,BENJAMINYAGO TMK2-7-026-010-0000 Appellantwasnotpresent.PresentfortheCountywasAppraisalSupervisorDionneCosta. CountypresentedtotheBoardtheappellants’executedsettlementwithabuildingvalueof $161,000andlandvalueof$138,100.Acopyofthesettlementdocumentareattachedhereto asExhibitA. Acallforquestionswasmade. Mr.Tokuukemovedtoacceptthesettlementaspresented.Ms.Blancett-Maddock seconded.Acallfordiscussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof4:0. CASE#44505–CALIBOSO,BENJAMINYAGO TMK2-7-026-015-0000 Appellantwasnotpresent.PresentfortheCountywasAppraisalSupervisorDionneCosta. CountypresentedtotheBoardtheappellants’executedsettlementwithabuildingvalueof $141,500andlandvalueof$137,000.Acopyofthesettlementdocumentareattachedhereto asExhibitB. Acallforquestionswasmade. Mr.Okumotomovedtoacceptthesettlementaspresented.Mr.Tokuukeseconded.Acall fordiscussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof4:0. CASE#44501–CALIBOSO,BENJAMINYAGO TMK2-7-026-035-0000 Appellantwasnotpresent.PresentfortheCountywasAppraisalSupervisorDionneCosta. CountypresentedtotheBoardtheappellants’executedsettlementwithabuildingvalueof $68,500andlandvalueof$136,300.Acopyofthesettlementdocumentareattachedheretoas ExhibitC. Acallforquestionswasmade. Ms.Blancett-Maddockmovedtoacceptthesettlementaspresented.Mr.Okumoto seconded.Acallfordiscussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof4:0. CASE#44502–CALIBOSO,BENJAMINYAGO TMK2-7-026-066-0000 Appellantwasnotpresent.PresentfortheCountywasAppraisalSupervisorDionneCosta. CountypresentedtotheBoardtheappellants’executedsettlementwithabuildingvalueof $170,200andlandvalueof$142,700.Acopyofthesettlementdocumentareattachedhereto asExhibitD. Acallforquestionswasmade. Mr.Tokuukemovedtoacceptthesettlementaspresented.Ms.Blancett-Maddock seconded.Acallfordiscussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof4:0. CASE#44503–CALIBOSO,BENJAMINYAGO TMK2-7-033-002-0000 Appellantwasnotpresent.PresentfortheCountywasAppraisalSupervisorDionneCosta. CountypresentedtotheBoardtheappellants’executedsettlementwithabuildingvalueof $21,000andlandvalueof$152,900.Acopyofthesettlementdocumentareattachedheretoas ExhibitE. Acallforquestionswasmade. Mr.Tokuukemovedtoacceptthesettlementaspresented.Ms.Blancett-Maddock seconded.Acallfordiscussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof4:0. WITHDRAWNCASES–9:00AMAPPEALSAGENDA CountypresentedtotheBoardappellants’requeststowithdrawtheirappealsforthefollowing cases: CASENO.TAXMAPKEYAPPELLANT 110340870000 44994AKAZAWA,KENKIYOSHI 120060230000 45009WEBER,JACKADAM 230090040000 44357CHONG,WALLACEFJRTRST Acallforquestionswasmade. Mr.Tokuukemovedtoacceptthewithdrawals.SecondedbyMs.Blancett-Maddock.A callfordiscussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof4:0. Recessed:9:39a.m. Reconvened:9:42a.m. Note:Boardmember,DaleTokuukerecusedhimselffromthiscase. SETTLEMENTS–9:00AMAPPEALSAGENDAS CountypresentedtotheBoarda1-pageAppealsAgendacontaininginformationon1casethat hadreachedasettlementagreementbetweentheCountyandtherespectiveappellant.Acopy oftheagendaisattachedheretoasExhibitF. CorrectionreadintorecordbyAppraisalSupervisorDionneCosta,buildingvalueof$1,317,100 andlandvalueof$828,400. Acallforquestionswasmade. Ms.Blancett-Maddockmovedtoacceptthesettlementaspresented.SecondedbyMr. Okumoto.Acallfordiscussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof3:0. Ms.Blancett-Maddockmovedtoamendtheagendatomovetheafternoonsessiontothe morningsession.SecondedbyMr.Okumoto.Acallfordiscussionwasmade.Motion passedbyavoteof4:0. CASE#45038–JRDINVESTMENTSLLC TMK9-2-083-012-0000 Appellantwasnotpresent.PresentfortheCountywasAppraisalSupervisorDionneCosta. CountypresentedtotheBoardtheappellants’requesttowithdrawtheirappeal.Acopyofthe withdrawaldocumentareattachedheretoasExhibitG. Acallforquestionswasmade. Ms.Blancett-Maddockmotiontoaccepttheappellants’withdrawalofappeal.Mr. Okumotoseconded.Acallfordiscussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof4:0. WITHDRAWNCASES–1:30PMAPPEALSAGENDA CountypresentedtotheBoardappellants’requeststowithdrawtheirappealsforthefollowing cases: CASENO.TAXMAPKEYAPPELLANT 940060980000 44356CARDWELL,JONATHANHARRIS Acallforquestionswasmade. Mr.Tokuukemovedtoacceptthewithdrawals.SecondedbyMr.Okumoto.Acallfor discussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof4:0 SETTLEMENTS–1:30PMAPPEALSAGENDA CountypresentedtotheBoarda1-pageAppealsAgendacontaininginformationon4cases thathavereachedsettlementagreementsbetweentheCountyandtherespectiveappellants.A copyoftheagendasareattachedheretoasExhibitH. Mr.HaranoquestionedthevaluesforCaseNo.44702.AppraiserRaynetteMaranswered. Ms.Blancett-MaddockquestionedthevaluesforCaseNo.44530.AppraiserDoriHo’ohuli answered. Acallforquestionswasmade. Mr.Tokuukemovedtoacceptthesettlementsaspresented.SecondedbyMs.Blancett- Maddock.Acallfordiscussionwasmade.Motionpassedbyavoteof4:0 ANNOUNCEMENTS ThenextmeetingoftheCountyofHawaiiBoardofReviewisscheduledforTuesday,August9, 2022,at9:00a.m.attheWestHawai’iCivicCenterconferenceroomB2,formerLiquorBoard conferenceroom. ADJOURNMENT Meetingwasadjournedat9:58a.m. Respectfullysubmitted, TyoanyTavares RealPropertyBoardClerk EXHIBITA EXHIBITA EXHIBITB EXHIBITB EXHIBITC EXHIBITC EXHIBITD EXHIBITD EXHIBITE EXHIBITE F EXHIBIT F EXHIBIT EXHIBITG EXHIBITG H EXHIBIT