HomeMy WebLinkAboutChapter 18 Provisions 230920 Redlined CHAPTER 18
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
Article 1. Common Carriers.
Division 1.General Provisions.
Section 18-1. Definitions.
Section 18-2. Safety glass required.
Division 2.County Transportation Commission.
Section 18-3. Membership.
Section 18-4. Mass transit administrator as chief administrator.
Section 18-5. Commission's powers and duties.
Division 3.Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity.
Section 18-6. Required;hearing;issuance.
Section 18-7. Issuance in two or more names.
Section 18-8. Revocation;causes.
Section 18-9. Rates,routes,safety standards,and insurance set by commission.
Section 18-10. Rules;procedure and evidence.
Section 18-11. Notice of hearing.
Section 18-12. Penalty;injunction.
Section 18-13. Appeals.
Section 18-14. Applicability of other laws.
Division 4.Passenger Capacity.
Section 18-15. Determination of carrier capacity.
Section 18-16. Children excepted from consideration.
Section 18-17. Seating capacity determined by examiner of chauffeurs.
Section 18-18. Vehicle to bear notice of seating capacity.
Section 18-19. Rated capacity limit.
Section 18-20. Penalty.
Division 5.Bus Terminals and Parking.
Section 18-21. Bus terminal location 441E,� buses Sri. H i o.
Section 18-22. Bus terminal location;country buses.
Section 18-23. Rules and regulations.
Section 18-24. Parking fee.
i
Article 2.Taxicabs.
Division 1.General Provisions.
Section 18-31. Purpose;scope;definitions.
Section 18-32. Certificate of public convenience and necessity.
Section 18-33. Hearing;factors considered;revocation.
Section 18-34. Personal use by driver.
Section 18-35. Cruising.
Section 18-36. Unauthorized possession of taxicab paraphernalia.
Section 18-37. Penalties.
Section 18-37.1. Taxicab license.
Section 18-37.2. Establishment of road taxi stands.
Section 18-37.3. Prohibited acts.
Section 18-37.4. Fraudulent call and nonpayment.
Section 18-37.5. Notice required.
Section 18-37.6. Bulky items.
Section 18-37.7. Disorderly persons.
Section 18-37.8. Soiling of taxicab.
Section 18-37.9. Condition of taxicabs.
Section 18-37.10. Taxi sign.
Section 18-37.11. Taxicab control numbers.
Section 18-37.12. Trip route.
Section 18-37.13. Evidence of financial responsibility.
Section 18-37.14. Rulemaking powers.
Section 18-37.15. Appeals.
Section 18-37.16. Trade names and markings.
Section 18-37.17. Shared-ride taxi service.
Division 2.Driver's Permit.
Section 18-38. Permit required;content.
Section 18-39. Issuance requirements;exception.
Section 18-40. Expiration;renewal;waiver of examination.
Section 18-41. Permit fee.
Section 18-42. Permit revocation or suspension.
Section 18-43. Appeal to circuit court.
Division 3.Taximeters and Fares.
Section 18-44. Installation requirements.
Section 18-45. Operation during taxi use.
Section 18-46. Registration and inspection required.
Section 18-47. Inspection fees.
ii
Section 18-48. Repair and testing of defective meter.
Section 18-49. Schedule of fares.
Section 18-50. Waiting time stipulation.
Section 18-51. Computation of distance for fares.
Section 18-52. Baggage charge.
Section 18-53. Rate charges.
Section 18-54. Multiple loading.
Section 18-55. Posting of rates of fare.
Article 3. School Buses.
Division 1.General Provisions.
Section 18-56. Definitions.
Section 18-57. Penalty.
Division 2.Specifications and Equipment.
Section 18-58. School bus construction;inspections.
Section 18-59. Fuel tank location;diesel exception.
Section 18-60. Exhaust pipe requirements.
Section 18-61. Door specifications.
Section 18-62. Emergency exits.
Section 18-63. Aisles and ceilings.
Section 18-64. Seat location.
Section 18-65. Seat specifications.
Section 18-66. Required safety equipment.
Section 18-67. Sanitary condition required.
Section 18-68. Metal screening required;exception.
Section 18-69. Identification markings.
Division 3.Drivers and Bus Operations.
Section 18-70. Liquor prohibited.
Section 18-71. Smoking restricted.
Section 18-72. Driver hours limited.
Section 18-73. Talking with driver unnecessarily prohibited.
Section 18-74. Inspection before operating vehicles.
Section 18-75. Unsafe vehicle;alternative transportation.
Section 18-76. Repair of deficient vehicle;certification required.
Section 18-77. Conduct of passengers;driver's responsibility.
Section 18-78. Discharging p, E ui in a safe manner required.
Section 18-79. Driving violations to be reported to police.
Section 18-80. Manner of operation.
iii
Section 18-81. Bus operation.
Section 18-82. Dangerous loading prohibited.
Section 18-83. Doors closed while vehicle in motion.
Section 18-84. Manner of stopping vehicle outsiderEyd,lale,.
Section 18-85. Manner of backing vehicle.
Section 18-86. Use of clutch.
Section 18-87. Pulling trailer or transporting freight prohibited.
Division 4.Inspections.
Section 18-88. Inspection of vehicles;issuance of certificate.
Section 18-89. Monthly inspection required;certificate of inspection.
Article 4.Public Transit System.
Division 1.Island-Wide Fare Structure.
Section 18-90. Fares.
Section 18-91. 4rl ff+ E±1. ,u.
Section 18-92. Fare schedules.
Division 2.Paratransit Service.
Section 18-93. Establishment of paratransit service.
Section 18-94. Definitions.
Section 18-95. Eligibility.
Section 18-96. Suspension of service.
Section 18-97. Appeals.
Ill➢vision 3 I�i�:ed Roi.,ke Se:rr,vioca
............................................................................................................................................................................................
se+t irrur.l8 95 ,,,...... d_ouuii W I'nu,s �W t e llnL,, - Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.35",Line spacing: single,... ..
-Section ➢8-97.:: d r uitll trt _fern Ljp. ri Aiorri aurj(l d o rrjty➢yu _ysfeni Tab stops: 1.85",Left
Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.35",Tab stops: 1.85",Left
11a::v:,A.sA.anri 6&a„ Taxicab. grid„" rr�avispna rr a Aan;1.Netwa.rk 6 anu 1p.5ar �o�^�...Subsia�;;es
Se+t irrrt 18-99.14.44 Auf➢tali r ft orj,,, - Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.35",Line spacing: single,
...
Tab stops: 1.85",Left+Not at 1.01"
Division 5 Use of➢1,�sa�ri ak;�d. Irr an;1.,sA Facilities
„i irzur„18-99.24r44 ➢ e e (;crii u e r(;,c3e r, ura;b;i e c3 1 ll „;ui; ri (u fif ie ;,
Division, 6a, Activities P.rohibited,..While....�7sari�➢�aab➢io �;`r axis@ian;rrk akaanrl,
irzur,1;8-99.3 hr i ivLt;:ie priirzW,;r;➢yri e d ort i ll „ri fit;.➢yu e rid f'm fif ie ::.
Seci irrra.18-99.4. Reserved,
uhred
Secfirrri,1;8-99.6. . Heniov�j or c3ef;f
ni iort J 8-99.7. f rru; tll aui (e i�;6;uir e rr[, ,u Lr a,;,,,,a ujd ide;,!r;,.i i(r+ A iort r aird Ile ri JfL,,,,
e+;t irrui ➢8-99.8. 9 ELF Ire ui a11W [rrii r rr�a,uit e ii le ri ui rrii a 7rui ,r rruuIt e ii le rt t¢rllce ui ,r,°eruprrrui ,...!rii tprprirrve Q3 Formatted:Font color:Auto
SUPP.1 (1-2017) iv
cab rrds
.................................
j tcf iort 18-99 9 ,. I't ui ali;v �Formatted:Font:Not Bold
E+,t irru!...,1£3-99 10 ....:. �u.`.7.:II�E ui r,rr.1, .1 C��vtr�C'.:
„t iorrl:...18-99.11.44r4-9 Is
.h..II:P:ll:.L'pb.I:`=.:.
a Formatted:Font:11 pt,Bold
1wisianr Ia�a Av�^rr'k� �r Formatted:Body Text,Indent:Left: 0.11 ,Line spacing:
Exactly 12.3 pt,Tab stops: 1.01 ,Left
,. +Oiorrt 18-9912 Adv,erfi rrri�.irri rd p uir3 out i.( d ,rurrj. ill aui f buses,.:,,
t cf irrui 18-99 1 4 r3vE iit i aiui ,erui d",,�uuity Oyu,. ��t es � �Formatted:Font:Not Bold
.. ..
Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.11 ,Space Before: 0 pt,Line
:Ps4 4 Pam: sp.ac..ng.:...sing..I.e...................................................................................................................................................................
Formatted:Font:Not Bold
Formatted:Font:Not Bold
..:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
[Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.11",Line spacing: single,
Tab stops: 1.01.",Left
Formatted-Centered Indent:Left: 0.11" Line spacing:
Exactly 12.2 pt
SUPP.1 (1-2017) p
18-6
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION § 18-90 Commented[WK1]:Sorry,did not have a chance to
review changes to Division 1 or 2 yet.
Commented[AJ2R1] I made no changes there right
now. We will address later. .,
(Article 4.Public Transit System.)
Commented[WK3]:May need to define"fixed route
Division 1.Island-Wide Fare Structure. mass transit service".
Commented jJU 3]:Not sure that is needed It
Section 18-90. Fares. explains it all-fixed route.
{l ..Unless otherwise provided for in this section every person using the oX r9.,-. Commented[WKSR3]:If there's a difference
1CtlVg1'ro_or flex rocjte,mass transit service owned, or between fixed or flex route then there should be a
operated by the County shall be charged a$2+7 aru$ a iy�twrcr lrcroau;fare pa uir3. definition that defines as such.
lh11111 be ellassiifled as tllar Gen Ir al(' I'aire i rte,g¢u]rY.. Commented[AJ6R3] Seedefintons
[ ..... ] y .....
--„Discounted fares for�seniors�a t a +,,person with a disability,Wtrut,t V]t 4��c tll t r tll° . Commented WK7:How does a fare by hour work.
fir 1 E II �E i E II aui and students.,.The following persons shall be charged a$1 1r I noticed that the other counties/city in HI do not
wa-Y'I.wr hour fare,on.OtE f[xedroui;e➢rria t7 a rt _ervrc auk ftallb rla rhwl a the have fares on a per-hour basis. If someone's
... ....... ........ ...... ....... ......... ......... ........ ........
1.)]is oll nV I'a➢C r fl e' t]l v. commute takes 2.5 hours,they need to pre purchase
tickets for that timeframe. What if they don't know
(1) (Senior a a#a a rr -age sixty and older after providing proof of age from a valid how long the bus ride will be?
state ID card, County of Hawaii senior ID card, driver's license,birth r�
certificate,�uLii eu f ransfi W t w rn df d a Vint f l¢1u;)9 br passport; Commented[AJ8R7]:Since the fare boxes are U
(2) A person with a disability with a valid, "Person With Disability Identification Commented[WK9R7]:Not sure what RTCSNV
Card" issued by the County of I lawaii4j �vd III II_ r a�yrlrty )r all��ct is prl ar arCQ3 Commented[AJ10R7]:RTC of Southern Nevada
roni„the Cormty of Hawar r llf lc rrui n iui „uat)Ir u t o uua9dt SwStr qpr dfs ou nt 11,,,,,
Commented[WK11]•Note if deleting"citizen",wil
r aur3 illYfiClll+ Dui Wri1i]Cpr a.yrlri E hrt �..... )prul�l atu aui ii r aura�;,F uc�r.�y,,,i1i ..... .... ... .... .... :.�
d rrUutty of 11 rva"ull II o otptr a f u tSaf y teni 4fr r t urrtI IIl caai�.;and Commented[AJ12R11] Noted.See next attachment
.. .... ..... ....
(')......,,,,,,Students kthrough college)with a valid school identification card. Commented[WK13]:What does"other transit
....
(ft) fcroatlr,aa E fiveai1ulrru,!.,,ktseventeen yE�Wrs old w)te.. urriaWui¢ri,-)tavE avalaQ3 r)t{r(rl ��Commented[A114R13]:Any discount ID issued by�
.... .......
3euii r(]r,pat irrur.r�palr d..
dpYcrVa9w�o�swrilt a i�4lvand V)t4ficwIt r ar(l,, Commented[WK15R13]:Wouldrecommendaddn
u)O,)m_� Eton„ )i a valrQ ,uii �Commented[AJ16R13]:Done.
.... ..... .....
(r) Commented[WK1 7]:Take a look at the definition ...
oaru pr au g w of 9 8➢d➢�t a g�oa D�uag>'o di o)off fo antra tlrw o�wib � ... ...
f 1)...... l 112 to IM10 fVw rs,�b d L11 oaruu ,ir IH b i-djarvr„r9 p,,a cruuw n�;,1ay t u� ��Commented[AJ18R17]:Noted.
(i'),,,,,,, l 1Yw IYV1„ t o aui,Suf k.,I.YY! °�IYlry a.„y a;,y w of w i_tw V"V V VPf w Pf w VV of VCJ,YV P A:: f,C,V k V"'�CJY�i-,r9 u d CrVAnfi Gf Commented[WK19]:May need to modify the
d Fareprepayment discounts Commented[AJ20R19]:Noted.See attached.
I atw of 9 Ve➢8➢d➢
Commented[WK21]:Alternatively,you could def
LL)......- t4 uiE hail>fl )irr�all pu a E„ hall av arl a„ lE fern �,,o Q1Q1 auiQ,3;,,E xpurllE J fl hours, a(Ier
... (
v alrr3 A 4f ))W 111t f all C box [Commented[AJ22R21]:Rather keep them separat�
... .... ...
(i)....... ))a r rruuit 2 1 ow pr a )t afl,,,-fit av as,,))lt full s a0 arri C x)Dallt....24 hour's � Commented[WK23]:I th nk th s would also need
(I or v„lalr(.aIE�,,,,1)W fh fare ox All �lr rriuuii pra_F uses, hall how a�rpruq,; prat ,,, �{
Commented[AJ24R23]:Not sure it is needed,as itU
If) rui.,g iI r3E u i r,,,,ui rlrZ ii cart i;h utti a .._tu aui ri �s ll vl e,;,,,
tAEuiEual r r3 v ua E hallb u�varla lefrru � t.Q1Q1 aui� exY111C afiEll u c of
Commented[WK25]:Are people supposed to kno
( )........ ll .... - u U. ...............
seven uir3rvrduu d i init_,,,Wii1uur. trait WE ,II II rwl WIfh C�,r h 4f av �C ru. [Commented[AJ26R25]•https://www.va.gov/record
v ali(3„t t 4f rrui i;..;it I)Us fii71 i i 1leruI �t II)¢r3 There )t al r7,¢ r.rr ll t fia,rir3 .]1..... Commented[WK27]:Not sure what this means.
xr1ia �;,, t i( all r .. aW_ ,allt uteri ;Used
L)........ Dt r ourjI 6 4f ay L a t E i all ))c,,,pav arl a..bj full {y) Q1Q1 aui,�:-t xprr t,�,(t t II a e of'„ Commented[AJ28R27]:No.flex routes can meet
vt]f.,,,,;tfi.frvrr3u,�ltllltti 3,.-Wrtlurt, rruit `veal) prtllr¢2(.J,Wltlttiir)t(., 1 tu; Commented[WK29]:I need overall clarification of
v alr(3 bt t 4f rrui i.fit I)Us fer71 a 24 1lerull )Dt II i¢r3 There Il,' )t alf r7,� uirr II t f`.a...r3 .]l:-. Commented[AJ30R29]:Explain what you need?
..... ...
xr t au7, t r a.,. A 4 aW wre nof.........................................Used 4 Commented WK31R29:Don't know what you me
(r) tAtuitllu�I 'I rIayaira t -....,`piall �ye...avarla�at fern dy�.) Q1Q1 aui. ,.tx�irrut..�(itu '.1.... [ ] y
r rrui tCUt M r3�. Wrt.1 e u)t d„y))t rrri vualrr3 At d.rrui 11tt bus full �24 Roar Commented
[AJ32R29]:De�nated Fixed Route
... .... ......... ........ ..........
p II r¢ l,..There II t shall be YN¢ II t f u.n o t xcft aui .t .... Commented[WK33] I need overall clar ficat on of
)tr a rota,it ') r3y )r a t,7, pi all av arl ilt full dyQ1 Q1Q1 a n t x)Dr]1 ,,,,a(i t II '.-- ��Commented[AJ34R33]:Discounts offered off the
18-7
ive E.JLh e�wh(L�.y!�L,.,j y��H(hAed ort fhe bus, f'or�� 24 hour
............. .............................................. .......... ...............................................................................................................................................................................
praao,r
...........T.........h.....e......]...1..0..........Sh....�...d.......l.......b......e.........n.o..... r..ef..,..u.......n..d.........o......r...................rfiaui......................... ..............
1r4.4 f4 tp�*Vel cmyt 4 lweFFf-y 4w)11wipoent
(4 f4e "(4K44A441(�M 4 fwre 4y. 4 IeFF 44+4, 1'(w 1 k4 4Wjr
4wet W44 da4)(�44,ia 1f4d4,
x ,1,4.H.+ R+4+Y' 4
4a�+4,Xf)4iraW,44 4,4� da, i4'Wir
p44�I44-w, P,',H4 4 fF44w+- k,+un -E4 i iawaii'i Ho4w+ir I P
4rw whir.'..H WIF-I
A V,444 i n44iy 4i 4wet-4k,,i+4A+4 A
iich 44(� W,iich a
wit-fr Pi�H44 4 y kley)4 6�4+ir44 F+ A 4)Y-4R"04�+iy)4 v 41 lawa*4.
84+idey)4w(4++�++ ana4�egg++� v 4i 4-("4-4 r�f en 44+4 Pw pep
4444 W,iich Pk+e,a,*inc&4-w4�7 W,iich a�,aiid a+e,h-aWAk
h4+"Y)4 at of i..,^4aa=43:,:
A i4+4q+4+4y 4+1� f4ir+j�4iin IR+�iy 1'+, � +i:w4 4*40-fro
4h'i 4 43'e, ,,�A 14 4R"li44- F 4+i�L
qwn4W iinil 441eir- Wi,�
4 4+Vn a kr,444 4*s�4i�4ir4, (44+ung�...€4444waii'..ii s<h4w+r-P.)i°414,
(+r-f)4W,�ff4, -M++R 4 1�f)4WS(H�+haI4 ix krall W
f4+jro-H-g,I+f4:w 14,4t(��*Ieyf4aF di*y 4 ea-P74 m4rFFtl+W44 no-gpa-pw]I WJPH44:,
R+4+Y' p4q"�
4-4 4+ir iffa l4v�*W,4 iri4i+ a+R a14 W44 a vall*4, �2oirF+rfa
4K-4F4 44, y,
18-8
§ 18-90 HAWAI`I COUNTY CODE Commented[WK35]:Not sure what this is.
Commented[AJ36R35]:Where people are trained to
use fixed route public transit whom may be disabled
f r; d:k4�n4 s(t-�h+�ha^,a.�:�,,� 4 r 4 4 t,[ � �4� E �.....#nt *44t4- WA s siH .-. or a first time user of public transit.
4�' re4f-pat � i 4 E a f*4 4P-w t_inIk+R4+,4 Ihh-4-, r+n�i,[- F- k ,-aif'-+°pp s�4H)g,i ,, I+I4 Commented[WK37]:I have concerns that this
k+44�--iF] Ott41-h i44a4f wP, ]+14 M44f-4➢4`11h�44-,4',41,+1�1 kF- Ia44-➢k-M-a 1+44K 14�4 would lend appearances of conflict of interests and/or
1eutdii favortism. What groups of entities are intended to
benefit here?
�. ..... ➢ "➢e�i ➢�..D , aa..u:rt4 .-tit+ a x filrl ilr r, a�i4➢ �i:y l ll w ,�pa mt.....i�a sr ....... ........
4 �...:P� p >➢ k�h�4]�I�P+ �y 11k4 W- E 3 F Ew tfi� 4 , t,y fi ,4t ; .. Commented[A138R37]:Surveyors,people do ng
business for the County,vendors doing transit
(E) ➢ilE,e f➢are.,.,
related work.Administrative rules can be developed
if needed.
➢ a;,c fi all....p)c w a[v,�,c3 frill tl;c [olj Pw1P1.:.:.
C ���Y
,„hildren under the age of five;,- Commented[WK39R37]:I would advise this section
(J�,)
( ,�COnnty of Hawai r ePllrr7i l¢rWE c -`�^��^"^`^ti^ -' `_who show t v thQ3,,,,( rzunt:W, be removed due to fair treatment.
ipl¢rW C C identification card oral l21h c Commented[AJ40R37]:I disagree. We need to be
(4) F—tnj.�h.L t of..any of the followin + ronf ll tr t;o s who currently have active and able to trust the judgement of our directors.
... .... .....
unexpired contracts with the mass transit agency and that provide thefollowing services Commented[WK41]:This seems to conflict with(g),
+..E . Paratransit service fares.
to the County .... .toI>eratx>nal CIIvlrC E+u..itW E11v�+.°,E toavwx tuaouuoua .
contractors C fj Ip)�LtL services rill ric aui�ui r ill aui �t vC fur fC S rill p)U 6fLt fit II All Commented[AJ42R41]:Defined as fixed and flex
p
shall have z^the +1 t 'g r u ;, a v a 1la,.identification card route services
.. ..... ... ....
oY LtAs c i ut QI.. t ftt urrt tuts.. is t utr W Commented[WK43R41]:I thought in order to be
(4 fern't,➢le eligible to use the paratransit services,paratransit
mass t u a uasbt at e_ 1oy➢Yy lY v�a Vt. I1, a .11.(I➢D, th rn a : t;,a V1 at a 't rle passengers had to show that they're not able to use
W g_W _ _
�(5)cVup,u➢a➢w �uua1u4Yt utpu 4cuzp,wa Il4➢:rig,fo)akd and f➢wxroii .tl ans: t wuvu¢w.and the fixed route buses?So if they're using the fixed
route service then they're not eligible paratransit
g w rseruzaV¢;aaw,attw,n�aurt�g w tfy a gaaratu aua4gt w,Vo o➢ao gty➢fl¢,ar4➢ o ggIRA ➢)y t➢rt mass passengers by definition?
of a wx ac Y
r_ r i,,.,, FF,.,,,,.,I Commented[AJ44R41]:Because when you travel
train a paratransit client,they can use fixed route
(� �.Yy�rutt.. seekin a _t auir C t➢Lll'erU ,ft t fad N ai r¢pg7,.a1 '1 ar C frll'g:r�ll tllttt,if transit to reduce costs.Also some paratransit clients
the("ounty of Hawar i is currently participating in such program•- are conditional meaning they can use paratransit for
44 I'wres foF t-ll pawe4 4 4t;:4*%�n t 3ft4 t-ftE ige 4 4ve wpakvc d part of the time and fixed route for part of the time.
(ff f rL uV f w..r A See the ADA Part 37 for more details.
lf)..............f'a c,n, C II ft ,11 ft avcunlhnrr li-ed t ll msfers b iwt t n bus w�i fu,tri i he t init fll auul�,rrf� Commented[WK45]:Police officers are employees of
ftt fan°4 rill pia_, prullrft ,FtQf An wftllt.kfttff (e DUllrfta7t4fwhertIh fill°errll Dt_ the County,so this would be covered
underCOH
........ ......II ......
ft a t xlrll t Qf (Commented[AJ46R45]:Deleted.
(i),,,,,,, ➢nere`�fialI be..-uirr t ll ans,feI b0c ...........weert fiXed l rrWe,,auiQ3 1 � 1 pull atll;aui �t u.uplE fib,-.
Commented[WK47]:I think this needs to be
pia CII fia_ )CCPI ll uitEQ3 arua4➢otoeruza9waVoroI)Ht ➢aasq.aderurt➢r�acro bwo asatfoot➢rby. r�
➢Yw,anaggtuauasata w,Vzcya,ind YtafA[blwfurftllE�,,gU�IlE�apa,illaui ftlCt¢riftt �xtQfllrrutt� Commented[AJ48R47]:Passesasnotedabove,2 U
W i c lln7.l'`tea +„TkfYw I a w V,w r siY a s➢Y(r,w-his or her a�u V at u a asut Commented[WK49]:Do you mean"granted'?
identification4-4( and tot➢r w f o)ak 4➢or f ll X u eroat w,,,,l)II o.v u�� � � "Commented[AJSOR49]:yes
�.
Commented[WK51]:This may also need to be
(Commented[AJ52R51]:That is def ned m the
(})(,,,g).Paratransit service fares. Commented[AJ53R51]:httns://dredf.ore/ADAte/e11
Under the,-'+,-mira4�n-��ea-r am�t-f-r��^�➢rt- e 'y++at--(ADA},the fare for a trip charged to an
't
ADA paratransit eligible ;4 a a cur E II of the complementary paratransit service Commented[WK54]:What happens if they don
shall not exceed twice the fare that would be charged to a ILa �p E ui ,car�uiui43w� 1Commented[AJSSR54]:They would nde free on tl�
paying full fare(i.e.,without regard to discounts)for a trip of similar length, at a Commented[WK56]:I actually don't think this is
similar time of day,onthe+-raa4 4 as raV... _fixed route system: Coommented[AJ57R56]:Should we leave so there
(1) A one-way paratransit-u o a p�a;� Ep,uj,,,,Ear fare shall be twice the fare of the
current full fare 4 ,; without any discounts on the,C,'),aa,r t 's fixed-route Commented[WK58R56]:It's redundant but OK.
system; (Commented[AJ59R56]:Deleted.
(2) The fares for 1f-lr4i� �1 gal nrruttt, -O,ui,l¢,pgp:.=--accompanying ADA paratransit eligible Formatted:Normal, No bullets or numbering
SUPP.1 (1-2017) 18 9 .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
12.E ui ,E; ,who are provided service under section 37.123(f)of
the ADA,shall be the same as for the ADA paratransit eligible-444v4ui*�ls--
l�+yurb;5 e ut ,ertg i-;icW;,are accompanying;and
(3) A personal care attendant shall not be charged for complementary paratransit
service.
Shared-ride fares.
Shared-ride program L ail e s._sh all br.....r ub r(fize¢3 A i,h Lollo v�ut ii A r�7....
- awa t aiF+iL�-a-��.�:1....:1ry tl ...:{ aP lam,1-L`r;r�-r¢-a"r,lH*e era, a�i t ui� �inil�t'::,....
¢rya.fit in accordance with the following schedule:
°:..:;oHpa)di+..:O PWeSgbs dN RMe
➢a.aat:;e ...
..........................
a s-y r R u: ..::Pr N{ ' I:. .,: w,¢ y -r
P+a4Ha44-y-aaq+4�-M 4 IJ:K.,:
>hi uld 1 Lip.-F Ub aIY...i{ Ae b -exr E E¢3E:d'1 h �a�,� E ui ,car s Li...a....1.l r:¢rv....E ii i h mhfit aorri�l-.
C;osf Pmsed out i he f�ri e schedule pas'defIPted ln sent kat. 18 19 foir i paXrcd➢b a oir�s
...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
¢]k Jiin ¢]Iu „d;ir ro pz¢z;ir;d rd iion ua;k� w¢oirl °2;z opz r aii;k, oir ➢ 4 �4rH=-4 w+W-�z-w..-E ipi+v-a 1....
lru 143-i;a Ord url-u�r� i-h ased °ram �,�, n�.-th Laws.,,..-14�
, ..�.¢aI4r'W'::l..¢ 1p.A ..u:r..-a"4e4-a4u+4
(4)(z.)Promotional,.,fares.
The purpose of this subsection is to provide lower u_ w Ljuva u n a h 'bus fares Commented[WK60]:When you say`eliminate',do
when a new route or service is provided or to boost ridership on established you mean that some fares may be wiped out
routes papa d f rr7.e¢I b the.➢rrms 7 f n wart d lnirru sf rrpA orr. permanently,or does this mean suspend fares for
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... certain routes temporarily? If so,then how is this
section different from the next subsection,where the
administrator has the ability to suspend fares?
Commented[AJ61R60]:Remove fares for
promotional opportunities. Be based on 1
administrative rules created.
SUPP.1 (1-2017) 18-10
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION § 18-90 Commented[WK62]:See comment above re:
difference between this paragraph and the one
immediately precedeing.
(1-),(j)..,The n t transit administrator may establish o :ua pw uu(9 Mares on a [.above.
Commented[AJ63R62]:It is a subsection to the
..... ....... ....... 1
temporary basis for a period not to exceed one hundred and eighty
calendar days for bus routes and services. Commented[WK64]:How is this subsection
(1986,ord 86-15,sec 2;am 1990,ord 90-37,sec 7;ord 90-91,sec 1;am 2004,ord 04-141, different from the Discount Fare Category?
sec 1;am 2005,ord 05-151,sec 1;am 2007,ord 07-141,sec 2; am 2009,ord 09-160,sec 2; Commented[AJ65R64]:A program where these
am 2011,ord 11-62,sec 2;am 2012,ord 12-36,sec 1;am 2013,ord 13-32,sec 1;ord 13- ! educational systems would contribute funding to the
76,see 2;ord 13-109,see 1;am 2016,ord 16-95,see 2.) Mass Transit Agency to allow all of their students to
ride Hele-On for free.
(y) Lu'yq w,¢Va d fa a es.l Commented[WK66]:This paragraph(1)appears to
LL)........ mass t u ul�r ut u�,w Vl¢y yw t ubV u,q�Y u g u cr,�,y uu tt fou,,,,,t aYw u -9a.uu)c w of aYw S't b of conflict with the provision above where students who
awraL°I [lw�g)artumtt nt of b:(9wgAa on "IIMI�;' cru'coHkw n�and wicvwwsuty stuu fi,nt, faeulty, can produce a valid school ID get to ride for free
9 stall bud p..0 w lu7d ay p '.�w utin4Y. bw u u. d to tua(9w uut ___ha d ua V t y uuu(9 t u S 1 y Commented[AJ67R66]:No,Discount fare category
Il(fb:,ou acarVdwgw,cru uatt)gvw,ugutyau)(9vrulll)w gu71)pwettotw,u' gto[Dt�agVw,wtdV.ag)on 1)wA, ¢.wn ride at half fare-notfree.
u10Yw u' DOE or Ow coH1 tw or and 10Yw ttn,js to uin'gl ug,w 4)ey "rtoaa9t�tttttg, Commented[AJ68R66]:Subsection(e)of18.90
fuaoaVty, uu)(9 t fftovwDr utt oaa�r..pu w �.uw o ua.g9 DruVVp.�,yt0 fauw mw utoahw(drat0rwu explains whondesfree.
.. ... ..
t0rau) �f uu w w tabbs0rw�d oatt)(9w�u Sw etoaru) 143-;1d➢.
Commented[WK69]:This paragraph(2) doesn't
(?). �lOYw� mass tuan ut aw:ncy gOYalV crffwtu' ku boas g)a�g�g K)u'ou'a➢ fall' uu)(bvubuaaVs V¢bcr�gwt seem to fit under the umbrella title of"special fares"
DYouast�lYcr�4� ulYteormV , IYVwwl, 11Ywt dm)artIrmw nt ofil rV.isur andu7u'[Dan dt tV .tn1, but is rather an option for the MTA to have.
g;luldelL'Yes IOT° ]'YOIA ( V'Yol ds r1t1Y f tr°el'YYe l rir IIY( 1ne" grlt Q'Y1'Y tAle ("'obit r f In ommented[,U70R691:Moved to advertising.
)pVod..bVw houa. c bcrla9 .s.l�c II Vre.. II}t cc7.,nirt f ar.c. c atcic7r°,y Vr aII......raIn,)IV 7.qu a w..gp:. ;ws
mlw 1 Y extu'wtrnew y how uu)eor a t3 t ubVu lYw(� 1r'Ythl a to uu) tt a wtu Commented[WK71]:Are these two provisions the
same thing? Also,is there another section that
ma g g t u ansut uY w te�y w I�t ubVt:lY...a pu o a➢ for tlYw,u7 ge of boa P u'sw u uaw.(9 to outlines the details of the bus pass program for those
g)a w;1I.R w u: uI BID 0 ,yu k u)t of tprw (9w .o tat wed buds feu u'wY an(I IN 0y rnlrn l be oasw�(9 fc r I iY with extremely low income,or is the agency going to
(.hwatgou) gwc.ofled on 11 p :'.....lOYw P .6 w wffl.bw ussi.nd at varuwi lo(q uon:.to bwY create rules for the program?Seems like it is
Sw Vw�ete(9 and abvwwt oseb by t0r mass transit az wa urwy. ' i°l mass transit ;�mmey rifay missing that piece.
u)tw u'Quito contraeh.ial arran n.xr tt nts wotb any pa t of s, g 1j, h,ou pgkIo� Commented[AJ72R71]:Its duplicative. Yes,
�uu ttauu 'w,u ttw,uuts tull'wY c9wYw�nwYc9 to be ou)the bw�st, �uabloc ou)terl,gt for thw,sale and oSsuaauttee �administrative rules would be developed.
..... ....
of boas 1T a g" Commented[WK73]:I'm not understanding this
L)---...... wY aggtu'�utt�ut �u w:yeW �uW°gw_�� ut� atggw,,�xt��u�wY�,cru7tlwYt�gtaY ' u7 aYcru7ltaYwYu�,��utc��uLg paragraph(5).What is the intent here?And what
w st a bli,A w d 1) a co nt,raet cr u' )u.] ¢, aY aug o r(. w 1)AA, ¢mw n t lY.�Cw.iYtty a n d Ow sa s w.i fl wA,, kind of situation would this paragraph apply to?
4,, 11h caJlYV)Irn) sss orl a)aid ua0 to 8% g)w a y)as,,soV d _ _ _ _ _ Commented[AJ74R73]:Travel Training for first
a w 4i Va4 aA Lkt+y I time riders or persons with disabilities learning how
(h) Suspension of fares;non-applicability to some services;terminates December 31, 20244. �'to use public transit
........ [......... ] ...... ........ ........ p .........
(1) Commented WK75:I think this should be run past
1PI t�LDB)]r t bl lity 1¢( t 11rtt1 ... C II vlt c 1 C II nij rl,.811 C Dec lltttbc II y)..�. �ram`-"i!��Ql�� Finance. I am a little weary of a contractor making
(,�) --[,nvs esd tbll )1,t(l by 1,16 ecli rt [tl�l, btt U,7.Vctui(3t ), C[t k t,,,ci yh of M P money off of the County in this respect.Also,ifMTA
,w a dk ( &,(-r�-t-+4 ¢�N eta k 1] C¢rU, [t ), +t lltttbc]C 'f i02,5 df t(�.er b¢r t II 1, i n(l is going to have the option of selling passes online,
then wouldn't that eliminate the need to contract
iui ,uiv M.t_ i ui [it c vl crwuc( ll lu.i . (3 ¢11 �c I 1ILL();,b ]c with sales outlets?... ... .- ,, r�c
hall II I(3tt [Irtt c ¢rl r ball t
...
d lti Ub ect ion. Moll lu¢rt a D Dl !..o d w it ¢¢refit ll wit(l hwr d Il tde t 11 vtr es loin Commented[AJ76R75]:This is a common practice
O ... ... ....1L y 3.. � ..... for public transit in order to get business to sell bus
(7 curb 1¢r cU....b v 1PI 3c II vl¢C _4 IDC II 11(.5....by 1]Lc Gl..d Ir 1111 llttl�'.P11 ¢rl Ir uIl°c tP1.G:. passes as a convenience to its customers. We are
II C t':II.C 11 141UL.(A.¢4rt- ¢rM.t 3f1.t-um-¢-t1�tk�lhv~.3-1-E*47 1Frfa�t.-f-k 4(-D1-.„"t"t&"Ih'�k?-1.E`t 11 b)-��'�Fk;k-k'kl Nf� �Ya:#k-1--1Fh&*Ih`1Ftilb-','N t already doing this with Token Transit and it was
Commented[AJ77R75]:Furthermore,it is for those
(') d]tt a J�cr..t ieruiereLl.lc l;l tui¢ruutatiit tllW„tcllllttttuit;t,,carui�Yc;+cutttbcll ;,t„�, fib;) Q1 ;t,, who don't have online access or cannot get to Hilo
U
uuilE xi E„ui(3tt(3 by„1]tc r¢rUn Il
Commented[WK78R75]:Who came up with the 80/(
(ll) 1<[L yt 14 _1.12 l 11 C Il,,,,111 l lU,ly 'Ql 1(1 C II 1 h ,clo C of..f 1C ll r-b-.ytt t ll 1,',it ➢tttt_3,,,1 a tul ,Lf commission? I would advise to eliminate
1(71r7f11 P11 111 1 ¢rl , I t 1PI (rll lltti 1PI48 (r ih?1; pYa 1rl 4U A �;
Commented[WK79]•I actually don't think this is
w ill 1Pl fgll y LE t, IPI¢fU. ,IPI, �r t_,�7C PI .tt II 1;ll,l�Y r XR JCIC(7 by R,¢ U1 C r¢),III��r tll L_¢ 1,1¢r 1,11 needed since HCC§2-78.1 already gees the mass
¢rt]tcn.._F,cllvl¢ci......14uc.Il¢rlluttt uirc Galt Ilc�u,, ic(3 by, i]tc (22Urirll I.g2.
Commented[AJ80R79]:See above on this matter.
18-33 SUPP.1 (1-2017)
cv,pbIu Ae fI;c auraY.. i(zui(if..:[;,biic prir;E, r iiipacQ3:..-I) d6 supa ecf�,zrri,.:.
Section 18-91.
nll iHH ff 9 P raa..-"YmFw,4, Iyy.-.
O i y)4-y 4 -"ih+r a.e...*4 P W rrf 4)egg'ge, H�i�i41j +fi l-a-r, e 4'e.4"j
�i t ��at�a�a, ,...4r�f)44 d_;,. 4)r �.f�, �,�F H.... 4iige...4+rA...
iaap-44he ev"I wi�4,&arfa the
l i ..a,a�veya43�n�mr tltau4 rx ' he moss tr).M. rt a..;-�eaa, ma.y.c as ,o a:.. 00
4ala+erracY fc,e..„I(DP plc le,4>Y I1LG,:aI(J tIl4�t aPc ..I t �e,ff� .(i rrVat;rlata,d.......'. llrr s jYIl .1436:i!.
Ia 1P ItP ,➢"ll it l lr,::;rl,rhty coil `~9hoi, al I�'ra c [aio„i,airra [l(",,a,.i�l affbd all [1CD,c,ai al r.��;uic.d,,,,
Ian, tllrc pa tr.2,ffa it a, .:....-.
(1986,ord 86-15,sec 2;am 2011,ord 11-62,sec 2.)
Section 18-92. Fare schedules.
Q Iba allt:. .a Commented[WK81]:If we are repealing shared ride
FA Fw E-*6-elf ED U l -�:
fares,how are the fares going to work?
a.
Commented[AJ82R81]:See above under Shared
r'-.. `&µ ...If"y,.pg]. e Fa.re!ni. Ride with paying a subsidy up to$12.00.
0........ 0...s.a..I-e. 4 y �
i.;.::Ir 544.y...ratt1 a l-e i7 ir•
(1990,ord 90-37,sec 8;ord 90-91,sec 4;am 2001,ord 01-82,sec 1;ord 01-84,sec 1; am
2011,ord 11-62,sec 2.)
Division 2.Paratransit Service.
Section 18-93. Establishment of paratransit service.
(a) The mass transit agency shall provide a paratransit service to complement the
fixed route services operated by the County. This paratransit service shall be
referred to as Hele-On Kako`o.
(b) Hele-On Kako`o shall comply with all federal and state regulations that relate to
paratransit as a complement to fixed route services for public transportation.
(2016,ord 16-108,sec 1.)
18-33 SUPP.1 (1-2017)
§ 18-94 HAWAI`I COUNTY CODE
Section 18-94. Definitions.
As used in this division,unless the context otherwise requires:
"Paratransit service"means the County public transportation service which
complements the current fixed routes providing origin-to-destination service to eligible
4141v44ji+l ��a�,,(ui Ear, under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.
al e*I'„("Ill 111VI means a person deemed eligible to ride on the paratransit Commented[WK83]:FYI,we need to further modify
service in accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990; Code of because we use the term"passenger"throughout the
Federal Regulations 49,part 37,subpart F,section 37.123 or a person certified as ordinance to refer to passengers as people and riders
eligible forparatransit services by the mass transit agency. generally,and who are not paratransit passengers.
2016 ord 16-108 sec 1. Commented[AJ84R83]:Delete.
Section 18-95. Eligibility.
(a) The mass transit agency shall approve or deny applications for Hele-On Kako`o
services within twenty-one calendar days after receipt.Approval may include a
finding that an applicant is eligible for some but not all of Hele-On Kako`o services.
Specific reasons shall be cited for any decision other than complete approval.
(b) If a decision has not been made within twenty-one calendar days,the applicant
shall be deemed eligible for paratransit service on a temporary basis until a
decision has been made.
(c) d �r: r43� 1- I'a c u;;,;;E;; found eligible for Hele-On Kako`o service will be issued a
paratransitidentification card. Commented[WK85]:This term may need to be
(2016,ord 16-108,sec 1.) defined.
Commented[AJ86R85]:I am not sure it needs to,its
Section 18-96. (Suspension of service as t explains. 1
(a) The mass transit agency may suspend the provision of Hele-On Kako`o Commented[WK87R85]:If I am questioing the use
services ton ik 1(i�..( i ,(lrs who��V2i36 f �+a3--f �w)a �3- p� +a wk��3�1 f N& I¢rL A t� of a term,then likely other members of the public
ilie,,,,no how tui(3 l tt( r auir(ill at�¢rui;��e?l�r y ( i,��yl� [t��...-II} i]t�_lltm l n ui fit:-- will too. Just providing advice that it should be
,Uir y i rice wlf h f he ADA-,Code of„F ed(II 1.1--di( ,Ui t,t�]¢rui ��..,--u(1Il1 defined. Up to you whether you want to follow it.
'1„,,,,, U LpD..Il,r 1,.,4yP 'A ..�-D([t) t -_ llrrt(ui(3cr�.... Commented[WK88]:Please double check that this
(b) Trips missed by a p (ui (ll;n rt 4p��W+�.4-for reasons beyond the section is in compliance with 49 CFR§37.125(h),per
control including,but not limited to,trips missed settlement agreement with DOJ(paragraph no.
due to�w-*+4,4 (3 ii zv(iierror,shall not be included in any count of missed ommented[AJ89R88]:Has been checked.
......................................................................................................................................................................................................................
scheduled trips Commented[WK90]:Are these 3 or more unexcused
(c) Before suspending service,the mass transit agency shall notify the trips? Or does it matter?
�ir mwrrting:
Commented[AJ91 R90]:Deleted and revised to
(1)
That the County proposes to suspend service,citing the reflect compliance with ADA on suspension of
extent of the suspension,the basis for,and the length of the services.
proposed suspension orrestriction of service;and .....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
(2) _Of their opportunity to appeal the mass transit agency's
decision to the transportation commission.(2016,ord 16-108,sec 1.)
SUPP.1 (1-2017) 18-34
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION § 18-97
Section 18-97. Appeals.
(a) Any applicant or F�4e+j_a _e.ui air.who is aggrieved by a decision by the mass
transit agency-regarding eligibility or suspension,may appeal the decision to
the County transportation commission.
(b) Appeals must be filed with the commission within sixty days of the date on the
notification of thenmss ill auj,p,pi--. agency's determination. The appeal shall be
effected by filling out the notice of appeal in a form prescribed by the mass
transit agency and filing the same with the transportation commission.
(c) Within sixty days from the date of mailingorl)ersonal service of such notice of
peal upon the mass transit agency,t he commission shall afford the applicant
or;��3 pro a�,E ui err,an opportunity to be heard andto present information or
arguments or both.The notice and hearing requirements shall conform to the
applicable provisions of Chapter 91 Hawai`i Revised Statutes as amended.
The transportation commission may affirm,reverse,or modify the decision
under appeal based upon findings of facts which justify the decision.
((-4(r*)...The commission shall provide a final written decision within thirty days of the
eempl^+iorhme^pffl;vEW ;lose of the hearing.The County shall not be
required to provide paratransit service to the o r<3 ova 1pro a�s rort;;err,pending the
resolution of the appeal. However,if the commission does not provide a decision
within this time,service shall resume or beprovided to the,. �i43 �lpro a E ut�,,, r. Commented[WK92]:Should include a definition of
(2016,ord 16-108,sec 1.) "County bus system".
This is Maui's definition:
"County bus system"means the fixed route bus
Division, fr!,RkA:ed R,oute" e.rvR.ce. service,commuter bus service,and ADA paratransit
service that receives moneys from the County by
y.. contract or rant agreement. The term includes all
"°rooctaanrx 1.fi�9fia Q;anasr�k .q.lass"roy�k�amu:.�. g g
—Phe➢rr11 ill a jsdi a Cyw hall ,E IIC ptrur rpylt lrrlri]tt try t�1111katphn(l➢1 t rifftlfitn etrythe County bus stops,all transit facilities,and all transit
.... .....
C4 trua:roty[ro4a y t w facility amenities"
.... .... .... .... ...
i1ur....ar r aril r3l.uir t wri.)1 ilia #¢ ltpa.i t t ii A t]u r It alroi, ri.� auir3.�,± ,,. a.�Lplpl.rr apylEp...�tatutes and Commented[AJ93R92]:Will do.
rn�,rui auir..�. ] Commented WK94 I propose deleting this
...... .. I ]: P P g
........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ language as it lends ambiguity and vagueness. It is
„�;,4,el+an „ ,,,.+; ,,,w r,7
' difficult to define how to do things in an"efficient
O....... ==....' = .... ..... ........ .... = = . and effective manner"and in accordance with"sound
+; 1-4-The n1 "s t n" rrl art pa ;euir°v�altpall e at papyla�alt t lte irrrui era management ractices»
ltE r3 U.IE uir3 aE vE l rrf. t..vrr t.._gr� i]tE d ruuii W �.:pa W t euut .]"lte a°r Ut t gar°1tE r3UlE 7,. au.r3 �(Commented[AJ95R94]:okay
levels,_e.pf Eiivrc Ball bernron(,riin ay1ce.wri]ii).r.E.Lta',as,-t-1auroro9 unaaVto-u�arro9aV tu�aurosyrou1 utr li...., � ... .... .. ... .... .....
u ulan 1,2—n 7 my jjL,hfl e thereof Commented[WK96]:I think this is also
( ,,,,,, i, ell atrLjL d rrU,rrj . p}U .`v feni shall be C t abh he(l Underd14ivr root l of � unnecessary. All financial obligations that MTAwill
this article
—.................................................... take in the operation and maintenance of the County
bus system must already be done in accordance with
.tt llrri� al[trt a, t i<W �t ail1 avt ili ,,,,protrWt II t¢ t t a�) f�t trll 41c,�pr i at ,,,,;P all��c a u,,II rd ,,, the charter,which triggers the parameters within
l ar I111 L t¢r }C ,`;7,C II VC Q7 lly t]LC UP11'y �yU W t C.ll7{1 l',�, all i�G ,1CIQ7 II IQ7C f,aar I111 IC 3„-C t a�}113;tC(7 ir]C,,, which appropriations be made by Council.
3E r ui i E r3 pyW t)iE urrt a 7...f aui ri as E ui+W �,li all b ,
Commented[AJ97R96]:Okay
(p} lui<rrui(rriiurri uirt wrtlii]iE ill�ui ri aui.� urrtulir uuirrr3alirroui �rrorriit..tirrui urrlarotEii JLrola.ui auir3 ruty ..... ... .... ..... .....
...
U L a e thereof a n d Commented[WK98]:We should include a def n t on
trurriprolr Muir t wrill„ t uit�� al... aV auro m¢3 nruirui;;;tr��Q3rui aupr t 3;urrt apro ,t;)tt pyUJ(iui, r trQ3tp..auiQ3; ofthis term.
r rrr3t uir3 art]tt ir:. aproprolrr ,l)IE law 7,-aril aril r3r,uj.aui+t r;,on t ii uirup,,^ l auir3.tiap t, prol aut,uirui, aui, Commented[AJ99R98]:Okay
)yaalc3aur real tllUria(ru.... `
Commented[WK100]:Not sure what is meant by
�11 a V,k3 a n(I V 1i d l a(I Ilti€� f st 1)1 i"[I (1',,,_1)W/the mass t V.n V aL,w�YYQ y IYVY w.�Y1,f a¢ fifJ: 47 rl(.4 Y. development plan. Do you mean the counts
+-
'the rn ana�ernent of Lb rn t o�auasut �a�e_ cy IPa rk,... n(I r ide, f ar i I tie flr",ig�1 atf fl h,y I,'re rnass general plan?
.... ..... ....
Lransot a w ur y rmw aurt0wsw AJroe0r aRJt w.igii sw.o,- ad hw..th Q opar It.i:.._.w tw rn,....pan not..:oa:ror9w a tpr�..... Commented[A1101R100]:Yes
18-35 SUPP.1 (1-2017)
u a�aua gwau aw:rut c,f t Ore m a s t � of �ageraa; Commented[WK102]:Couple things:
l.Can you give me an example of when a facility
�`Section, f.8_:99. �Cont1r`acts folf C�n..�;➢c^If`,flt R.an,A7 `fl 17 C�.,;p�Y'u aR R.17,'�;a�:;.A7,a;fl 17,r;a�:;.C;rof t��l a�:;.Q.�C;ro�:�.17'�;'�b��.,�b"s�"st c^,;p�"u. would be established and when one would be
( � [tt orris uisti t t ncW urri tW r;¢�auii ll tr i
�u;F" +^��Fa uavfo ,eY'Vlce�t o designated,and the differences thereof
...
manage o�rot II Ytt „1[td„maintain t hL, d o,u.nj y j}U.3 v t t ni.,, 2.It is OK to leave this definition under this
section;however,I would propose that the
definitions for"County bus system" and"transit
and multi-modal transportation master plan"be
Division 4. Taxicab and Transportation Network Companies Subsidies set forth at the beginning of the chapter with all of
the other general definitions.
a°roccttor 118 99 �1 At,thorr iz attoi
°' Commented[AJ103R102]:1.Building a transit
The lltttpt; ll tui.,ii t tui¢;W llttt tv t t t�111 ]t 6t i tXtr t;) tui¢] d ;¢]W �llo ➢,tllttt t t, center mPahoaon lands acquired by the County.
tll�,ul �Dolll tt,loul t]i tIl"ul tl lVt. foil �Yt �':-ul ,t II t3 t U�Y��Y tlltlit ull 1¢u 1]Lt d oUu11`v Oyu. tulQ] l.0 XIl,till tuLgA1; 2.Entering into an agreement with Prince Kuhio
..... ...
y 31,t lltti t -�:t d .t t�roi,,, ll ] '�.a-�l.... Plaza to operate a park and ride lot using 25 of their
spaces.
Division, 5. scofIl)t ;inaked irai?sit Facilities
, � .. , �Commented[AJ104R102]:Okay
Section,,18-99.2 . Fee folr t�sc of C]esh,,a ated tlydaiasit facilities. Commented[WK105]:I propose deleting since this
individual, llouprcz;poll tY6Z; Aionfhi i u t ,,,to]w omatwa]fiaua otfat;u]otyrouiillo]]tc] �yW
would lock the County in to only contract with a
„ s private company.My proposed revision doesn't
1]Lt llrri l� 1ll tut,11 t ,t ul¢V �L t]]u� y 1 0 1]Le d oUu11;V t �t t of,,,1' a Q1Q1-.'t II �'Lou4,,,,,foll 1]Lt,_U t of 1]t,d¢ substantively change the fact that we may contract
]ttv„ [tt u7u, of t ¢]t,�7t° uitit, ,,illtui ii,_Itrt]tiy .....tIIEs„ uh tut._�ffleri¢]z,ujt oll ru31o¢]ttui„t¢;r with private entities.
olrot ui tql¢]close t t]tt (tr h W
b_d[at t¢3o t...11 rules, ig...tr r oil¢3. uir t wtii. dd avd a 51 ddk a II zn Commented[AJ106R105]:Sounds good.
ute Lin tLv II al] [¢fin t[tt turriP]t urrit uii,01 tool a.(httuuit t u_01 ioui,tui,(l t n(oll enit uii ¢if t]u3.-. Formatted:Left
resection.
Commented[WK107]:I don't belive we
As used in this section, a"designated transit facility'means t E t]ti W o volt¢] o-ly„i]tt d ou.,it v think it starts with"I".
.... .... .... ....
] uul ui t L i]tt jui ti t cuttuy doll ill, �roullproo7,t o� prou_ ]tr t II tutF,proollt tt,i¢iui ur[t--0 a ��Commented[AJ108R107]:Okay-
[ ..... ] y
t;]Cptui tt r ,uittll ,t7Lil.n tt �t<u]]titt ,,,;I ... tut, ,llt4]t ]ot, , �)u shelf tll io4] �U.3,,, Commented WK109:Dowe have an facilities or
` rooms within those facilities that the County would
open up for use by the community?Or is the intent
that MTA is anticipating opening up facilities?If we
Division, d",c ,activities RrohibitcdWhile.....Using fl c F. `a➢)sL o.rt"at A.o➢,, end up having facilities open to the public for use,
then we will need to execute license agreements with
.-��o➢,+� ,-,".e+L.,,"., County the users.
4„d ,.9.,;i.° ,�
�,roect]or.�.a i.8-99.3 .3 ,�.ct�vata�^s and conduct n°^ .����.�.�
bus sVsteni a➢x.] at transit 1 A4',i.ii:Ge s° _ _ Commented[AJ110R109]•The latter,as we are
(:a)......,.The following activities or conduct shall be prohibited on the Count,ybuss stem and at going to have transit hubs with community rooms. 1
all transit facilities: Commented AJ111R109 Similar to parks and
' recreation allowing use of their facilities. Honolulu
'' :... ... has similar provision.
......... :::..........................:..........:............:.............:...:.............:...:..................:..........:...:...:....r..,....:..........:..........-.....:...........:.............-:..-....:..................... - .- .......... .. ............... ......................
Commented[WK112]:This maybe confused with
` ...... " ' ....... ..... ..... -" .... ...... ........ ...... ..... ....... a 1 the term"designated park and ride facilities!'used in
e...............:..................:..........:...:...:....r..,....:..........:..................:...........:.....:....:-:............................:.....:::....:....:.......... ........ ................................... e facility"as
,,,,,, ,, ,,,,,;,,,,;,,,",;, section 18-98,and with the term"transit
(f� 5mokinz�in any bus,or within any designated non-smoking areas at any County bus used in section 19-3. I would suggest that we pick
st0 or transit facility t Q]t Eiult Q] In lj RS d iia�iDt t II '28 OF >7 11.1e 19 �. ^ ` � >Q^r � which term we want to use,define it,then stick to
p «..... ter.
1 using that for consistency purposes.Also,is there a
......:Ale ....,--< <.... - ....11,11".. ...... .....- r, ....... .. d difference between a designated facility an a transit
enelase4...........:...:.....:::....................:...........................x,.......................................s.�a::...-..............................:..............:.......:::........................................,.....................:................,......................................................................-........................... 9 9
c+ + facility.,as used Section 19.02.
an
Commented AJ113R112:Lets use transit facility.
( .�....,C onsuming any form of food or beverage,including alcohol,or carrying or possessing .......................................................................................................................................................Y..............�
any food or beverage in a container other than a container that is tightly closed, Commented[WK114]:The definition of"County bus
covered or packaged so as to minimize the possibility of accidental spillage when the system"would include transit buses,but I think it
container is shaken or dY opped;provided that nothinU in this para�aph shall be would be good to have a separate definition for
construed as prohibiting the Carr ink or possession of groceries in a suitable bag or transit facility'
other contalneY',,,aIl"Ad 1➢"9 4S4kll"IfIl ]1it➢"9¢S8 wit��i e�+t.ai7]h+��iF,�d®e�(�/�43OIl"Ak`1G]F,ill"ittiL'1➢"9 hT _ + or I�Commented[AJ115R114].:Ok
--- Commented[KV716]:Added
.... ..... ....... ..... .....
.....:.........a:.....:.............:...........................:.............:.:..........................:.............................................:.............................:............:..........:............a.....a::...................:...............................................................................................................................................................................
a [e
18-35 SUPP.1 (1-2017)
(3) Using or playing anv electronic device, musical instrument,or other sound-producing
or sound-emitting device unless the device is connected to a headphone or earphone
which limits the sound produced or emitted to the individualFwll� F.-E..-ui..° i:' n a-�z-
fl�I
4+-V4e twr 4 ir...:ic l I ray..-` & 8 air � wr= 4 a�aaF -0,Il r a za 8 9l1a r a V
1444d +�Ii� provided that nothing Commented[KV777]:Deleted
contained in this para�aph shall be construed as prohibiting the driver of the bus or
vehicle from using or phi n;such devices for official business. Further, nothing
contained in this paragraph shall be construed as prohibiting passengers from using
telephones and pagers for communication purposes:provided they are used in
accordance with this paragraph As used in this paragraph "electronic device"
include,_but is not limited to televisions radios,recording devices portable stereos
or Speakers, electronic games,telephones cell phones,walkie-talkies,pagers, and
the like.
(4) Carrying or possessing any live animals except a service animal(properly harnessed
(ra�>rrle-LLLbe ndiv_iadu al dr �krlaS,��r°e vcrr8 a arr�S Nr a device or S Nrc device hinders or
___
lrule➢'It➢t With S�➢E SErVICr_ r9lYYt 1�,_�,�8{tic{�eC1lVc_L,YLr7r Yn a]ric o ta��3,4� •And _ Commented[KT118]:We need to change the
accompanied by the individual with a disability owning the service animal or to language here. Not all service animals are required
whom the service animal has been furnished, and except for small animals perly to be harnessed as it may hinder services provided to
pro
knt in enclosed containers;provided that nothing contained in this Para i aph shall its owner.
be construed as prohibiting a police officer from carrying or possessing an animal
used for law enforcement purposes.
(�) IDiscarding, disposing of, placing,throwing,or dropping anv litter, as defined in HRS
Chapter 339-1,in, on,or from the County bus,vehicle,or transit facility, except into
proper receptables designated for that purpose.
(i Failing or refusing to vacate seats designated as priority seating for senior or persons
with disabilities passengers or the fold-down or other movable seat area designated
for wheelchaiY•securement,when requested to do so by the driver,or anv other agent
of the transit system,or a police officer;provided that nothing contained in this
paragraph shall be construed as requiring other elderly or disabled passengers to
vacate seats designated as priority seating for elderly or disabled passengers;and
further provided that nothing contained in this paragraph shall be construed as
refluiring the driver or other agent of the C"ounty bus system to enforce a request
that other passengers move from the priority seating area or wheelchair securement
area.
(7) C"irrying or possessing any flammable,combustible, explosive,corrosive, or highly
toxic liquid or other substance, article,or material that is likely to cause harm to
others or to emit anv foul or noxious dust, mist,flume, gas,vapor,or odor;provided
that nothing contained in this Para i a)h shall be construed as prohibiting a person
from carrying or possessing anv match or cigar,cigarette,or lighter,which is not
lighted or smoldering;and further provided that nothing contained in this Para i aph
shall be construed as prohibiting a person from boarding the County bus system with
an oxygen tank.
(R) �-Sarsitting defecating urinating or expectoa•ating-rya-tk�-9�w rrovided that nnth�ng_
contained in this shall be construed as ar>tslvin-to anv_t>erson who
cannot conApdy with this subsection 4 _ as a result of a disabilitv_, c e,or a medical
condition.
(9) Obstructing,impeding,hindering,interfering with,or otherwise disrupting the safe
and efficient operation of the bus or vehicle or anv driver or other agent of the
C"ounty bus system in the performance of that individual's official duties.
(10) Standing in front of the white or yellow"standee" line,in doorways or stepwells
while the bus or vehicle is in motion.
(11) Erecting,installing, or placing any structure,fixture,tarp,towel,blanket, sleeping
bag bedding chair,tent cardboard ply board shopping cart or any other object or
material at any County bus system stop or transit facility.
18-35 SUPP.1 (1-2017)
(121Placingunauthorized signs or advertisements within the interior or exterior of any
County till°ansit bus or vehicle or transit facility.
(13) Vandalizing defacing, destroyin damaging,or placing raffiti on any County
f r°, s21.,,bus or vehicle, or upon anv transit facility.
(14) (Extending any portion of one's body outside of the window of any County transit
bus or vehicle.) _ _ _ Commented[WK119]:Is this even possible with our
(15) Priding on any part of the exterior of any County i ll ,Ui [tbuS or vehicle. mass transit buses and vehicles? Do the w ndows
( Boarding Rya ^ -the bus throu;-h the rear exit door.unless directed to do so b� open?
the diivt,r an othF,r agent of the tr rn5it y�ytem or an olice ollrcer. _ Commented[,v12 OR119]:Yes
(17) Vio f dui ^ IM A. II➢8S 'r"07 C aril '711 1112,p uid'711 1106 pay,mnended rr
- Formatted:Font:12 pt
(18) Refusinv or failinv to immediately exit a bus after beinv specifically requested to do �Formatted:Font:12 pt,Not Expanded by/Condensed
so by the driver, any agent of the County bus system,or anv police officer. by
r........................:::........................................:::........................................::........................................:::........................................:::..............................::
—Refusing or failing to immediately cease and desist from doing any of the activities �L Formatted:Font:(Default)Century Schoolbook,11 pt
described in this section after being specifically requested to cease and desist by the
driver, any agent of t e d ou.0 u.� iIl;ity A s nift#a n 4 wf�yH efw+,or any po ice officer.
n-
a t ,e..,v,_. . II��,.!-F,e. n,.,� ,y�.� 1. .�.,,,, �+�➢-., +„tea Fe.,.,v, +L, A-.,,�...T+
�EK��-r.".lt-+o,-..-z,.., . �h�,�d�r-«x-rw-i-�--Zzrn,o_• ., ,�-h",° rrrr=}f•+�-�-,+ .rrc,-rn.",.. +`.ram+-�' ,r-r
+,.i., .,,+ ., r,.,,�+..+.•.r..+�, n-,�,., �„tie,.r e .,.f,,a A..,+-tie,, a .,,.e• n+;r=¢--�-•�+,,-'n`
.. •, rff is ea=t�-�-dc�-rc- • ,.
U
(20) When boarding a County bus or vehicle:
(i) Knowingly failing or refusing to pay the applicable fare for
transportation on the County bus system.
(ii) Presenting a pass or other fare medium for transportation on the
County bus system,when the person presenting such fare medium
knows it has not been provided, authorized,or sold by or for the
County bus system,or knows that the pass or other fare medium is
not valid for the place,time, and manner in which it is presented or
knows that presentation of the pass or other fare medium violates a
restriction on the use of such fare medium imposed by this chapter or,
anv mass transit agency administrative rules.
(iii) Not having a final destination when riding. All passengers must
have a destination when riding At the end of the designated route
the passenger shall deboard the County bus or vehicle and wait for
the next one and pay a new fare aril �l;ie,rw a pro, ,s
(iv) Failing to store articles pi )erly,,,,�ruaclIl.a ing bloe(king m�les oA°
urotuuro+r!r :A e .- All strollers, scooters,foldin carts, and large Commented[KW 21]:added..
packages must be stowed away under the passenger's seat. Baggage
that can be stored under a passenger's seat or on a passenger's lap, Commented[WK122]:I don't think we should
that will not protrude to another seat or otherwise interfere with i include a specific number. I think the better
o-the_r__Lassen ers,will be admitted at no charge. No baggage may be approach would be to keep it general,like HNL's
ordinance,which reads"Baggage that can be stored
Stored in the aisle or on the se its l � ,t C. lipa ll u..rt exceed C d 111T� under a passenger's seat or on a passenger's lap,
x 1 is n_° that will not protrude to another seat or otherwise
Fa1hn to use exact cash and/or cura envy for the fare. No c��h���a�n��g�e����d�u��e interfere with other passengers,will be admitted at
to overpayment of the fare may be provided by the driver. ' ' no charge. No baggage may be stored in the aisle or
on the seats."
(Commented[AJ12311122]:Okay. ....
" Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.69", No bullets or
numbering
18-35 SUPP.1 (1-2017)
(bI The driver of any County t a m tii_bus or vehicle or any other designated went of the
County bus system or any police officer may refuse to allow any person to board the County
a ris,tf;bus or vehicle:
(1) When the person appears to be intoxicated"i l (4+rs'vainirr--4la k>, ,ne ub,t ,nc,>�
k ....
(2 When a person is not wearing a shirt,pants shorts,or dress,or both, and proper
footwear. f;ollerblades and skates are not allowed to be worn on buses.
4-When a person attempts to board with any of the following: weed eaters,flat screen
televisions, surfboards,boogie boards, body boards,fishing poles,roads and spears or
canoe oars/paddles:provided that nothing in this Para i aph shall be construed to
prohibit the on-boarding of bicycles inside buses at the discretion of the driver and as
space permits.
..............................:...............:................
.......:.:...::..................:.......:.:..........................................................................................
.........................::......::...................................:............................: . :.
y-kYek1.-...8"Eb1--YS.Yr.Y(:,:..Ill}t--YdF•' 'a'vY"C X=v"� kY 4 'Yek N-�--t,4tYrYF•:�:-.N W y-4-A-'N' 141P-HY1.....rc-Yktrc
' wrtiakY��r-IkYa��4•>-a.��ll,+ --��Y�:;�ia, w,��li i-IkYa-raw= >�i w :��i t�kYa-a--1�;�i-ac-�x;��`~��f-r
I' rtii° IkY wi li+s i r,G�Fw'ti �kY 3 , kt IkY 4• � l a :: x ;a (Commented[KV124]:Deleted
X+k
............. .......................,..............................................................:....................:.......................................:....................................
............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
HP
+h„h, +',
Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.61 , No bullets or
(4) When i person attempts to board with any refuse,includin solid waste,recyclables, numbering
reusable materials household hazardous waste f ininiaA le ha a id "ova r ii d deyl+r= >r
Commented[KW 25]:Added
•eenwaste,whether or not such items are contained in any open or closed package, -- --- -- -- -- --.
trash bag,cardboard box,or container.
(5) When the person is engaged in activities or conduct that,if such activities or conduct
occurred in the County j.Larj.sit bus or vehicle,would violate the provisions of
.......................................
subsection(a).
(U) When the person is engaged in activities or conduct that,if such activities or conduct Commented[WK126]:This is a bit confusing(note I
occurred in the County t a alu.sii,,,bus or vehicle,would violate any other law or copied and pasted it from below to rearrange for
ordinance. proper formatting). Is the intent here to state that
I(c)'Phe driver of any County transit bus or anyother agent of the transit system may refuse to the driver may refuse to transport if a person has
transport any such person who has already boarded the Cou nf, t ransgt bus. The driver agent already boarded a bus,has committed any violation
or any police officer may cause such person to be ejected from the C u rzt„ t;l,n s, t bus.It shall under(a)of this section,and has refused to leave
Y
be a violation of this section fora person to board a County transit bus after being requested upon request by the driver(or any authorized
person)? I would propose the following language
not to do so by the driver.another agent of the transitsystem or police officer for the reasons instead:
specified in this subsection,or fora person to refuse or fail to immediatelyexit a County
transit bus when requested by the driver„ another agent of the rapt Q oaaiitw b.0 ,,,system„or Any person who violates the provisions of sections
police officer to do so for any of the reasons specified in this subsection 19-3(a)through(b)may be denied boarding or be
. ejected from the County bus or vehicle. It shall be a
..........................................:...:....a::.::........................:.......................:.......:..........eanveysa:...............................................:...:.............c........:..........:...:..................:........................a::................. ..... .................................-.. -
violation of this subsection for a person to board a
:............:....................:...........:.............:.............................................:....................:..............................:.............................................................................................................................
i r,; + f,, ,<. ++,• +_F ;1 +; � County bus or vehicle after being instructed not to
R�i�-
' `T'`°�" T' — by an authorized individual. Additionally,it shall be
All ele4i*)n"s
:. ...... ...... ......... .....-.
a violation of this subsection for a person to refuse,
h, seF,a,„++-p,as,'+f'-,,.;14t,,.s i us or v
:.. or fa l to,immediately exist a County b ehicle
NT
....... ,..... .... ...... .... - ..
when requested to do so by the driver,any agent of
the County bus system,or police officer.
-... ..
�Commeme [ J127R126] Okay
Okay.:
1
- ......................... Commented[WK128]:I propose to delete this clause
`,ra`•� +`.. because it may be crossing over into lat amendment
:.....::...::...:.............:.......:.........................::...............:.............:...:................:...::................................................................:.............:...................................................................................................................................................................................:......................:...
territory,
which would be protected conduct. If the
—884
....................:........r,....:......................................................:....:...........:....................:...........-:.....::...........:............................::.............................................................................:...........................................................................................................................
concern is about riders exhibiting disorderly conduct
and/or committing assault,the HRS takes care of
.....................:..
NT
' ....-
that kind of conduct in HRS 711-1101(disorderly
conduct);HRS 707 Part 3(assault);711-1112
......:................:.....::..................................-EIS ................-:.....::.......:.::..........:::................... .... .............:.::.,....:..:............:.::...-:...................:::. .....
--- -- - (interference with the operator of a public transit
!4k,- - ..:.................................................... :....... ..:..:.: :....... - ...:.:. ......... - vehicle);and 711-1106(harassment).
......... ,........ .......:. ..........' Commented[AJ129R128]:Okay. .....�
18-35 SUPP.1 (1-2017)
...............................................................................................
All i4414s4 40"14—
............................... ........................................................................................................... ..............
. .. ..............................
.................................
1. aj,44
............................. .......................................................... ..........................................................................................................................14S'R t4i4i4442m4+4
................ ......................................................................................
Shall 4E�a4E)WE4 t+)fj'44�t,48 44��.
NT
i I R F11 *144R(41#s i44a V014+sles�)V fas, V
....................... .................................................................................................................. ......................................................................................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
............................ .....-............... ........4....... .............. ........
4RRS-4 fas"'44"es.
...................................................................................
IT,T- li"'A ;Iall 1",�,Ie "I kpap'] 1"ase's ep a,1pal4s,I
.......... .................. ................................................ .......................
Commented[ K130]:This doesn't need to be stated
since the language of the ordinance will speak for
.................... ................................ ..................
itself that these activities are prohibited.
........ ...
.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. Commented jAmmmj: kay
c44W4SR144 Skj-+-"""----,44 4)P444 414S44S. ..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................. ...............................................................................
RV 4 4R14S-',,-4,414'44S RS 4ef4l4e4 44!F4awa;'�
............ ................................................................................................... ............................................................................................................... ...............................................................................................
Q044)14:�: 1.�W
........................................................
i6a. ......... -I
..........................................................................
4R14S4VS RV t+'Pk�#S W'1414 44�4
................uu......... ...........................................................................................................
..................................................................
....................
14ave e4iast stRR e-P-11� 4111, sal4i44 Faa4e e-44R--,
.................................................................. .............9 ............................................................................................ ......� RR�F11 Rile
.......................................................................................................
A-A V1111
RP 4RRP RP 14444 RR...........................................
........................................................... ............................... .......................... ..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
.R 12.y 14R4 4 a 414s.
.... .. ...........................................................................................................................................
-.s ap @C-,PeFA6)141e Hj -4R 4,ases 6)p g H P 644 i4 4,4 Commented[WK132]:l would recommend deleting.
................................................................................. .4..................................................................................................................................................................................................................
............................................................. ......... ............ ............................................................................................ It is not only vague and overbroad but also may be
k 4-4 getting into first amendment territory.
........ ..... ..............
T11 .................................................................................
ig Ri'eR RF ...................... ........................................................................................................... 33R132]:Okay
.............................................................................................................................................................
IA-
.......................................... .......... .............
...................... ...........................
Commented[WK1 34]:1 would recommend deleting
IA 'a RR a for vagueness and overbreadth. I think the
J4±1,PH1;34 W1494��'aR aHHa4R4 RP
............................................................................................................................................................................................. 419
.......... ....................................................... ....................
8+1 S 8 a elass P,448++�- provisions in the HRS/penal code for harassment
.....................7................................................m...
LJ-1 R... ....)I and disorderly conduct takes care of these types of
situations.
.............................................................................................. .............. .......... ............. U�
th8 ffl+)VaWE�SE�at a---W Commented[AJ13SR134]:Okay ith Elisa
....... .... .................................................................................................................................................................................. ................................. ..................................................
. a--
................................... ......... .............. Commented[WK1 36]:Again,this is already in the
................................................................ .... .......................
�4.4.2 44sei�. State HRS/penal code so it doesn't need to be stated......... .............. ........ ...............................................................
.................................................................................... x.
here in the ordinance since it is already a crime.
Commented.......... iR 6J.:..O.Yay
.......................... .............................. ....
...........................................
..................................
.........................
.........................................
...........................................
18-35 SUPP.1 (1-2017)
L- •]• Commented[WK138]:Is there a reason why this
a,ection,-1.8-99 a5 aroa�?;,r�s rta^ala:!Jrra^d. section is reserved/
Thellrriass fntutsrt t e utr,W [tell ICt Urll t t,tt r.rlf. �Yrr U..0 j.r SDI 1W Wrt]ulfi t lr[t d .rUltt- (Commented[A1139R138]:Removed. No reason.
an u 1e l' ..... t dt rr. l rt]e roilR)rf ions,y . I
c+'t..trot yg_gg,; {��„ - Commented[WK140]:Should this also include
�.............................. ...
transit facilities?
Section.1.8-99.4 6494 l�e" n ovTal antr...alai^fl�ac.n.,�of sA���a. �Commented[AJ141R140]:Yes
No ren.�. rut Ittll.11enlove.o deluce Ign.s..r0 urlled,.f be errecferj.lby.rrll Uutd.e thy....
u.lirrll°rt v rrf t lu�a ptt1 r.(.J.
..................................................................................................t r........................
"'roaotAanr 8-99.47 a Non,...krrarsf rraryaaan;fl9aaspu ss5ar :....identafl"ication,...1arral�a
An.y�Ilroa 91.E or od,r zt olo¢ atgon¢ to dj lssued Under II s;e+t iorri 1 f 90 tut0 1 8 al i zs Commented[WK142]:Should"bus pass"or
noun ll tut le.lr t�yle tui0 i ell not be U 7e 4l l tu�,y L II ort of her II th tut b t,�te �L II ort t o whmttirt W.Is identification card"have a definition?
... .. .. .... ... .. ..
uerl NrrpreII czar �tellydyt;p,rutrrll tt.t;;tutttprtt¢,p„rdyttrotap .y..a pre.; rrllrr3euttilrrtt .rutrelld{,�� ..at.yle. Commented[AJ143R142]:I don't think so.
Under s4ecfkal- JQ_90 tutdl8 95�m sed�at.._n Itl E -�.:12121ir Art rcll;tr(r+ titr,u� f rri��l; trot 2IIilll...
lt, 11 t �yU.u....ir t n...zQle utt..Ir+.fit..trot r n�°r3 r U :.uutr3cn°....s4e+t irrut.,�7 I t.._ utr3 S-$3 r, Uutle,,7.a.....
L.!!ize�,lyy t]e n t f ur r lo 1rltiruitot]e, ,� , 1t1li;_u.u�,�E11 Ub7,E+t..rrui
ire]rs ort Wl>er, r u;0d3 ur h�.„b.0 P t a,F o ide cif if r+ A iort� ell d l�,pt e d ta..12erut t I t1,7e,,,,
.JL�P rr tt irrtri,/r e Ili..Ir+.fit ion,Who Ilknow�rt ,ly pe..Jrllrrut Ire II t,�....0 e t]tc...abU it t-,...o rr3e uia..(r+ u:l:....
r t...Q. rrll Wltg,r tlt e II .Wrt Itrrut,,,,pt..at]tall rz tt..rrut llrgnurri t]te llni t t II ,ut rt t-�><]r W t]1 ,,,,p5z Ir ¢rra y--�}U pr t n..=-- Commented[WK144]:I think this is simpler,but
..
de uti..(lc,A sort r [( It tlllbe,;,,,,ireutptl[zer3 by having the person's bus pass or identification card � still covers it.
immediately revoked and shall be prohibited from obtaining a bus pass or identification card
for a period of one year from the date of conviction.-� -Commented[AJ145R144]:Okay
Commented[WK146]:Misdemeanors trigger the
right to a jury trial,which could potentially be a
..........................:............:......................................z............:..............................................:..................::..................................................%.........................`..............................`.....'............e:'...........:..:....:.......................................................................................................................................................
if thlong,drawn out process. I would recommend either
„„ + imposing a straight fine,or at the most,petty
-`"""""""....."''""""""" misdemeanor,which is imprisonment for up to 30
........................z :.................:'........`..... "
days or a$1,000 fine,or both
..................
r �' - ��Commented[AJ147R146]:Okay,
..........:...........:............................................:..................:...:..............:..........................................:.............................................................................:..........................:......................................................x.......................
. .......................................................................................................................�
(ap....... Formatted:Highlight
— Ire IrrllrrWrut Pr II trot- pi ell be ;,^ ^^ :'�n violation of this section, and if,
convicted,be fined not more than five hundred dollars($500.00): Formatted:Highlight
tLUlr Formatted:Highlight
.� .�-.
1QCIn,, a 7Q�
--- Commented[WK148]:These would need to be
tl)Any person who knowingly uses a bus pass or identification card issued to another defined. Also,the h ghlighted terms may also need
under section 15-90 and 15-90. to be defined.
(y} \nv„prep �r�tt;;¢rWltrruttt,,,,t �yU prap, 11 rQittu.t..Irr tt.,..¢curt tl..c3,_Itt �yeesut r ucQ:.....au.Qltll„6`ae+t..rrn. Commented[AJ149R148]•Okay.
fa3-- 0 tui0. l 3 r,wltrr Ilkutr trial ..lrz rniu i yutrrt]te ll fo U e fh..A bu pv o aderti..(lr tt.;iort r teed.; .... ... .... .....�
(1}Any,,,prell out,,Who rrpyt,�ut or t¢rrrpyt Ijrt t bUS1l: .t o z0.tuttillrr„tiort r atr0 r cable Commented[WK1 50]:This would be a
... .... ...... .......
undeII s`aecfirrut t`3-9-AO tu7,d p 9�-.- t e4l U;O.r J t It1F7e tprprh<rtt..trot.or-'eIItilrr�ir¢rui,t�]t � misdemeanor,whchtrggersrghttoajurytral.
(�}nn�,,;pre 11 trot Who df e,p, pyu-;pr t o lute utt ilrr at sort r ttrd r ue d Under Wig+t taut;�p u5 3-A
Would need to get prosecutor's input on this.
.. ..._
ui0. 1£3*9,5 wrt]tout rp lOY i,ut]tall r at r¢rut 111 rparri t]tt urriat uik rt t, t utcv ,�Commented[A1151R150] Okay.
.... .....
Section 1.8-99. S.� lia r.a➢ty far a anaar ta:rrfla atar anrr aasar.. oanaariteii feet to111a^r2sy...:Ru assa sy.. we nee o Commented[WK152]:I think d t evaluate
— whether this penalty is a fair consequence for all of
r ana;ppnanrrsn .rt `aUp roved r°ale.ds the prohibit activities/conduct under HCC 19-3,as
\nW I.H�rsort ovt ukr S rru aSS eS tuty uua�apt�utu<turo 4 11 <t uroteu Vt ut rrl U�Ilrua tack.. uz, g u ya.. ,¢aru7]truV, they are proposed to be written. For example is
..
aK1g1u'cryed¢ kuP� rru cutrrWrut. IW U e Ur[tlmltationoY'CounteYfeltat¢ ceut IYt,k e ,rtrU,.prrrut,rrll°,,,, either a$1,000 fine and/or 10 days jail fair if
0; 11 t rue r3 c,0 i d fall II U I e 11 e 7ht e ll,upon conviction they eof be,j rPt e Q7 not ➢rrio t.[L[Y a n u1,r 000.00 o' someone is caught eating on the bus,or improperly
IIM) ,so1z..:d for 1-1 -or,�th auz cruxl:year 0r both.
storing articles/luggage? The consequence may be
fair for someone who is caught smoking on the bus,
or who is trashing or vandalizing the bus,but not
Section. ::3-99.3 9. ,.......................................r. ➢ ;y;a„ necessarily fair for someone who rides the bus
L,),-Aluy pre]t,Frrut vr¢rl�t iut, �e+t rorjf,-J 8-994-3,42..rll t,�rut tbett rut, ,tau„ t r t without a final destination. We may need to
what oe very tutrrt]tear pre II out,_]ut vr¢rl nt lot auty,_rrl Ur li,,,,prll rrvr i¢u1 [t tj,, Uprrrut r e tvrr t..t ut„t[tt II t¢rf separate out certain activities/conduct that warrant
..
be flued rut gut ilouutt rN4 ex eerrut u higher penalties from the ones that don't
..... .... ..... ....... lua F" a uc uac S3
ILLS Or ire bare Dy so fguz..,c9 lauad 111-1souz..,c9. _ Commented[A1153R152]:Rev sed.
18-35 SUPP.1 (1-2017)
(h�v�a Vi"LA ion is ed..oi�l.�in iliffed fo corif inue sjh��I I consf if..Uf..e ir�A e
.. .................-.......................................................................................... ................................. ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ...............................
OfTense ujd s I I��I I Ire jl.�.gnrs I I able w;suc I I Under f I 6s,secf iort
...................................................................................................... ....................................................................................................................................................................................
..........Aruy .Lj� I(.Ld. �L,.L..2 n I;g 11. a vrrrlai irrn. Ll I I I
I flke fhe yjwne�ujd m1dres,
......................................................................................................................................................................................................
s r&I I( � l .I.......V......r...o.......h.....Ao............u........j...d.........sh
. ....j.......l.......r...s.....s...ue...
(111.,1.2 1.! W.L.i.j.J I".? 11 s I l e I Y1
.0 . ........................................................................................................................................................................L. J.�� ��!J) ( rj�.Ajiyj
................................. ................... ..........., urIr pre,.L.2.2 n IL
Y I..........W ..][..........f f I re r rrnrrra,l�rjf lo..b.........................................e onfe r........................................... 2..................J..I.......l.
. ... .........................................................................................
. e i��i I1 f s u � J.�.!we x1d A.. finle in
rn fhe suninions,or Cif Aj2yt (LxCejl.�!� j� fhe ofl'rcer lim wrresf rrt rrjsfxjces
........................................................................................................................................... ..................... .....................................................................................L M ILL ..........................................................................................................................
W 12.(.�.Y.J.:.
...... VrohAo nelusesl fo �de fhe.o.........l....l....c.....e..............with. ......u......c.....I.1.H.�....r....s.....o......n.........s.........n.......a......r...r...i....e.........a.n.....d.....
m1dress,oI,a
MY l2.1.1HAi n:nily LL 11 LL.2.2D L112.11 L]V L] L]l.)I l(.1 1 1 �d�
VrohAor fafls or ref'uses lo hillne(. V 1i I cew;e x1d desrsf fi,0111 SuCh
(liv Iv or fo inlnlwfi Ael J U.111................... .............U
............. .................. ............... .............................................................................................L 111R. ( � b
... ................................
d ef e I�111 Y I e(l!a I I e b U s 11 V I. I e o f he f r�in"llif
........................................................ V.-I I/ 1 11
................................................................................... .................................... ........
2 L iL.rhce of f rcer
......................................................U....,....l....h.......e......o......f...'....l...c.e..............r....s........o......n.....1
L ..... .........V.......r...o......h......A........o. l.......I...s.......
�ssed a s� 0YI S,Or cif Aio
.................u...................................g�11111
2......................................................................................
Commented[WK1 54]:This seems vague,and I don't
(d) provided
There shall be y-police officers a form of summons or citation for use in know if it will hold up if challenged.If the offense for
- _for use! _Lpolice
citi_n-violators of this article where the circumstances do not mandate the physica which police are contacting in the present day is
arrest of such violators. The form of the summons or citation shall be Commensurate because a person was acting disorderly on the bus,
with the form of other summonses or citations used in modern methods of arrest soand that person has a pending court case for
de_,dunedtoinclude all necessary information to make the same valid within the laws disorderly conduct that happened 6 months ago,but
at a grocery store for example,would this paragraph
and rules of the State of HawaN and the County. grant an officer to automatically arrest the person
)...........P!.L rsrorjs of,f 16s, wirf�cle wre rn m1dif ion fo x1d sh ill rYt Y12..W�tL Hill I I.I. for his/her previous and pending court matter
....... ... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ..............................
...........................................
fL
.......... r2.1[. IIUJ(.2 involving the same offense?
Sectio)a 1.8-99.10 S s nt.p,�, Commented[AJ15SR154]:What would you
io)a ofse.rvice.
................................................................................. recommend?
.........................................................................................................................................................
Its n1w"s frxjsr � .;, I
�:11�L L� I of Illw"s f rxisif
Y n ... .............................................................................................................. Commented[WK156R154]:Eliminating it.
Who VrohAe fhe of'Secf 8-99.03�. '
....................................... ................................................................................................ ....................................................................................................................
18-9LjL:r0....".-............18-99.74rG4 xid 18-99.4484-7 ...C......o......m........m... ented[AA 57R1 54]:Okay
.... ...... ... ...... ...... .....
Y u.-� se.]�Y.rce fhe limn' f rxis, f fhe
............... .............. ............................................................................... ............ ..............L]............. ........V........................
.................................................................................................
TI�A dle C
LL)................................................................... n V
........ .............. ..... ..... ........... ...
, (Y1 exIleyJA of,files, sjl.� s�.� L g� f f Ice,-.
....... ...n.................... ....................................................... .... ................
oirresf rrcf ion of,servrce.x1d
......................................................................................................................................................................
f?�).............tlIthiiti L.I.I.I.L.2Lj 2D ij.1.1.2 I fhe Illw"s frxisj (.n 's de(jsiion�
......................................................................................... ........................................................
�Ajop 18-99.110-.4-4 AI.)..p
Commented[WK1 58]:This section should
(i)............. D 1 n
.L�I.Llll iL III I.L. .......... V(.d l V..� �.� I l.V fhe lims's frxisif substantially mirror HCC 18-97 to include the
.............I ... ........ ............ .....I................................................................................................
n e f L L.!!� nl.�IL D j fhe decrsrort fo fhe proposed edits.
........................ ....................... ..... ..... ... ...................................................................................................................
Commented[AA 59R1 58]:Okay,
�)........... p,jLw ds Inusf be f'fled With fhe coninlission.wj.d I.J.n x.f. I of, fhe(hAe ort III
.........................................................................................
of,fheagena's defelrnl�n�A�ort P1 I.e��.ppe�d sh dl be efl,ecfed bVI,11 ,,
,z
.............................................................. ...................................................................................................................... H.1
o.......u.....f.....f....h.......e.........n.......o.....f...i M ,
�...Y....l....... f ....... ......... l.V....f.....h.......e.......l..i.m..........s..................r.....x...j...s.....r..
......n......d.....
jj.firt fhesmilewiffid.( f.I�.r lort coninlisslort
.................. ......................................................................................... !...... . ..................................................................................................
(.11)..........�L.Ill�rt sr ly J�Y.,.2 ,roill f he(LA e of,I �Jfi I o I Of'Sudl 001 iC(�Of'........................... ....................................................................................... ..........i.... ...... .......................................................................................................................................
il.ILWL L! g.vlrn j m Lf.ilasil a enL 111e......c.....o......n......l....n......l.....r...s...........r..oy.t...........h.......�...ffl..........a..iffoI�J� i ..............l....i.t........
L2L L.IL�11!211L.2 Lt 91!il.L li..........he hewrd xjdfo L
............................................................................. . rrjknrnl��f�ort or
........................................................................................ ......................
or
............b.o.....d.........l.........T........he....Prat......o......f.....r...c.....e.......x.1...d..........h......e......w......i... I......... .U...r...r.....e......n......l....e......r...j.f...............h.........j.......l......co.n.....f.....o......r.....n......i......f....o.........f.....h.......e...........L.L.J.r.j.r...c........A......)....l...e....
nrrnn 9j 7 klvvaiij Reviised SULU.tOS Is ayriendwL
. ............................................................. ... ......... .................................................................................................................................. .....................................................................
(rl.................I Hein f ii.2 Y.,I IILIL 11 In (j( f he decrsroyt Under
... ..................................................................................... ..... ....................... .........2 L M2 j v........................................................................................................
11 U.�I.sed u.von Undiyj .s ig [1acts w.h.u01ju.s4 iN fhe decrstort
......... ..... .....................................................................................
h e cnlnlis sroyt
LD.........................................o..............................................................2.11illl LLLva e a Irnipb,1 wriffen decrsroyt wif[6 I.Ij d�.� of'fhe
........................................................................................................................ ..IL..........................................
close of,f he[I L.lj n P I n V..sh�jl rjr.A b.e servrces fo fhe
....................................................................L ............... ........ .............................................................. ..... ................................ .................................................................................................
L IH�D.d ........r...e......s.....o.....lu......f......r..o.......r...t......o.....f...f....h.......e..... ]..ln
jj...� L� U......,....f.....h.......e....................................................................d.o......e......s
...
rde a de rs ort wif.[in.jjj fjIl.( serv�ce sh�jl res, In o�!�L
�2...............i g� Y.rded fo fhe
..........L......... ..........................................................
18-35 SUPP.1 (1-2017)
Commented[WK160]:These terms may need to be
om „vit defined,or else it may be too vague.
(Commented AJ16111160:Administrative Rules
Commented[WK162]:Same comment as above re:
Il1l,;va.sa.ana I,a �al.v�E 1t.. r defined.
Sectio)a 1.8-99.12 Adve.irflsha, hasaale `anal anu side �,otuaty,-it arasat buses. Commented[AJ163R162]:See above
.. .... ... ....
,The 111 t➢ auilgrt 1, C ui CW,llrrt%v ]!1L ¢roll let 1¢3vt 4r] rui L-:'C Inside, ujd ouf r¢1a �:�: >�`?. Commented[WK164]:What about advertising
.... ..
i ll uisit buses. The mass transit agency shall promulgate administrative rules for outside of thebus/vehicles?
advertising.;
........-'..........................:................:.......:.....:.....:...........:.............................................r..,.....:.............................-..............................:........ .................:...........................-:..-:....:......-:..-:........:..
CCommented AJ165R164•Oka
�. ...... z ..,
[ ]• Y
"' � � Commented[WK166]:Or vehicle?
...
.,+ a [AJ Rt ] vehicles d don't
-... 1 .....» -' .- ,...» " -` '- ,. .. .: .... any ad space , e is es inside
Commented 67 66•Nov
have 1
`.. .. -C ,' on?And y
Commented[WK168]:Is this comm wh
' �. only within aone-half-mile radius?
.... ....
z
I' CCommented[AJ169R168]:No,not common.
Removed.
........ ..... .........
Sale ti Commented[WK170]:I think this is unnecessary
...
( ,``7x f�ui¢� rd m�vtiiti ru!,,, prolra �lua�gode a croatsgdw LC.ptr,[td`¢ruuitW�tu,auz of [a1a, L;hl lllba uttimla and since the authortyisgventothemasstransit
v 1rI Alt Io au'i.ui¢rouuir eni uii of 1 I�roulilia'.. t��vrr:e�r rvrr ¢rofr r It 1�r rt AIa ui 11 u.fra d h ee¢roI t]tt agency already in HCC§2-78.1.
.... .... .... ... .... .... .... ....
212�1r c�,_1 li all be ni 1¢la av 1rI alila,fii a a ¢roI r;�1 ail a t¢ !roil luirz�i k.m exa niproi [Irmtti Ia¢3elnj,,,, �[ommented[A1171R170] Okay.
uir¢rurritl,t 1x11i¢ru! uui¢3a.i `��+t+ti¢roui 1i.11(rll .l„¢roI i]ta Il,¢3aii 1I Iulltiiuial avauiuc,d ¢ro¢3tCommented[AJ172R170]:Deleted
n i 1x e..xa nllai g!i 1uir�ai1¢rui li dl not 1ae..d uira¢3..,�ia u a epf 1¢3va ii i..�1 rui lro�g a rui 1..a..¢rounty.... ... .... .. ... .... .....
ill uisit bus solely 1aa¢r,plu.�aa¢i]ta¢pau7ui¢rUui¢eurrit¢uit ¢rou°pa4lvt¢II°t rst¢llrrit¢uit irel�ers io t]tt¢I¢rrpat7¢rui¢roI au'i Commented[WK173]:Thereis already an
vC it, 3„11D¢r i rrll t, LL t)it,,,t 12i t x1.2111Dt ¢rll l i rl at i¢rin,,,t vert U,f ht to A iort of,f tt t verit,r not � established section in HCC,Chapter 2,Article 14,
Sections 2-76 through 2-78.1 for Mass Transit
¢rowPiC Q7 4;roll ¢rot YC II „1 C d LL 12i C XC llrr1 Y1 ¢ro !11 j¢rori, Agency. This maybe more appropriate to be
]'¢Ylr Ljh.Le„J(50.411',J)S.L^L�¢71 tlhii ub R ro tii¢,n l and alyd ad R Irtii iJlh, 1a ati a..-.➢T34 1:h�„ ,J(5 ati a,,,,b,1 Iin lha", included under that established section.
wr¢3a 1u!¢3 v,ruiclia I¢roui
(a°), d lit 111 t ii 1uisj 1 .a ui¢:y li 1I1 st t t lit ii°,fit t I¢roii,t�ia ii t uii„zui, ¢roil Iett iui, ¢roI 2,¢3va ii t i,,lull:... (Commented[AJ174R173]:Okay. .. ...�
ces d1 Well at d Iaur{,ui pru t;zt c pri lva ii t i c attic uii chat c 1ujd such lr!i,,ero c ,,,,, Formatted:List Paragraph,Indent:Left: 0.13",Right:
It 1I1�e t t. �v aav ii i a ii a d Statutes - 91 0.25",Line spacing: Multiple 0.95 li,Tab stops: 0.44",ua r pi t¢ rui 8 ro ¢ Tu t wriT d
....... ........ ........ ......... ....... ......
Left
Qro...... l.S-9913 �alvartasarl; am ] a?aartyba.as@crass s
Commented[WK175]:Do you mean County bus
d]ia ni ill 1ua;F ii 1 ,a ncv urr11W ll1¢row adv,,,a iii i a urrl,l uii ¢roui a I!1_a,l, i ue� uui¢3cn;,,tli�... � system?
CouP11`v 1yu3 W 1C➢tl1 f'mr f7ucfulr
.... ..... .... ...
lv d ltt t W rot ¢roI ldva ii t i lui,,i]t 11 aut ui¢rot as ii urrui t t d¢roui t]tt iui r¢3a ¢rfr¢rout r¢le¢roI d ¢rouuTt �u. -- Commented[AJ176R175]:Deleted.
(11.) a ... Q '. .. ... ... ...Y
... ..... ... .... .. ...
1,ui rt buses, ..t fi¢t IIDt..llrritt,t t 4I¢ro fi Co, u it y U 1D 1 ,L,..a { Commented[WK177]:I don't think you need to state
1 this,since everything should be promulgated as an
administrative"rule",which should happen to cover
all aspects of the agency operations.There aren't
really any"policies or guidelines"besides internal
(County)ones. Any"policies or guidelines"that may
affect the public's rights are considered"rules"by
law and should therefore be promulgated through
the administrative rulemaking process(HRS
Chapter 91).
Commented[A1178R177]:Deleted.
.................................................................................................................................................................
Commented[WK179]:Would mass transit agency do
its own audit? I can see doing an audit of any
Commented[AJ18011179]:Yes of contracted servic
.... .....................................................................................................................................................................................
Commented[AJ181R179]°..De le—be d................................................................................�
........................
Commented[WK182]:I'm not sure whether this i
Commented[AJ183R182]:Deleted section.
18 35 SUPP.1 (1-2017) ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................�
This page intentionally left blank.