Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutFY23-24 Real Property Appraisal (Real Estate Appraisal), ACM Consultants, Inc.t`.t tT '; Fl1,.—; ,CE .q fD,,^0'2 rEC D: „ ULI-L,L-0G3 /•ACM A& rM At cONsuLTANT& W meal Estate Valuation & Consul&n& June 9, 2022 Deanna Sako Director of Finance County of Hawaii 25 Aupuni Street Suite 2103 Hilo, Hawaii 96720 Re: Statement of Qualification and Letter of Interest - REAL PROPERTY APPRAISAL SERVI CES Dear Ms. Sako: Pursuant to your Notice to Providers of Professional Services, we would like to request your consideration for continuance on your list of firms as a provider of Real Property Appralsal (Real Estate Appralsal), Category FN. 12, for the fiscal year 2023 — 2024. Enclosed for your information and use are the following: • DPW Form 120 which includes required information listed on your notice including firm information, qualifications of key members of our firm, education, and training. • List of recent Hawaii County projects • Certificate of Good Standing and Certificate of Vendor Compliance • Appraiser License • Client References • Company Brochure We also invite you to visit our website, www.acmmaui.com. Please contact me at (808) 270-0604 for any additional Information you may require. Thank for you for your cons-deration and we look forward to providing further appraisal and consulting services to the County of Hawaii. Respectfully yours, ACM Consultants, Inc. Ted Yamamura, SRA, CGA, RIW-AC Executive Vice President Enclosures 2073 Wells Street, Suite 100 • Wailuku, Maui, HI 96793 8 Telephone: (808) 242-6481 0 Email. ofce@acmmaui.com a � N N a H N 1q tii w i� � h TsJ p z Q H cr) O 1 O N y x ul W C E e H N T cc E U H u+ E } H O N p> la a z W rn N y — a H F w 04 00 U N W r F4 n H 7 O xz I�:i d fd M N Uy w b Pa y� 7. co)cy) N W d CAN G I ti Lv 0)00 N CCO CD oo H y O 2 p IN tD Wz W Z Y_ o0 Y N a N 64 In X H U u1 b j64 q j LL E-4 Q U 7 O ly 7 Yp i� co H H fA U C y � H y N N LLLLL (I) CV C. G 13 H a N� C v op co W �Hi ~ ^ C y i Y.� z H A O W a P1 O W 1 H� u N A � U a 14 H N s m E G H la w Q N p B N W a W w k, O 5 0 a W[ � a � o H O � w VI o z w U H a $> 4F A U H M 4 d i' c: 141 L xx�y CIL n u ru�y pb Q a N to 4P O O W ,4 w 0 r r N � O a e xa O4 u a CO O p� a 7 n w 0 9 b of E� aa T E+ a w z �` w r o a C a o x o a z H N H H rL a a o o NW W �� H 3 0 a H a H V •A ��4) y eM H 'a H E 2Gpy� H y O C H N y H W m W a Z N w ._ H IA H W N .�j H q y U o N a K H [3 N N En m j c_ 2= p a � v � a 04 m o g H rn WUzz _u A. Q F V H H O y µ ux} N O O W 7. F ; FFH W y �p W CL l6 H7 F N Q O.' U F ypW�, wH a W W P4 H z H a � .� O Q. F p W z �' r f°a7� z w z O T H HD w N p N F w C �_4 E W cc a ~ W z z vi {tip �R7 O j TC vt O N cc H P W W O Z m G "m cG rx W W N En m H a H Lti O� y ril V O fR uWW� cc K N [] 9 yU O R A q Y C Z W N 0 C a)�. O �- CO)N . H M LLi W WH H ) : [�7 IpW{, cV •L CL H i L I W m 44 O Id of ►7� H [s� N z H Ai H r-r a fYi w a H U W EN Ga O iz I I 1 � a O H H O N r-1 s4 0 W a 0 a E W a `� E W s E ci � m w a E0 La -4 ra w (� v Ei w s [E� 7 N E O F O I U P O N I W O 1 O -21 O y y U V O U a W O W N "�.'� O z H y! W O z I.FA ?+ H rn E •� Y+ a ual �H N M W 7 W w E O 3 W C.77 Ow 3 OO7 N O H WO ?fir H O N ►i HH r] O F HH r7 O F pH 6� w HW U OH W w U IOi O Y z6U �I N O pHC H N a tn H �7 H F ,[N;y}� � E H F E. E4 E iF Z E CHI H ppO W �1�17 a x E AEI M W �LH�,7,77 a E H 4O7 GG e � � I 41 V tl U 1{ 'Uj., rmCl a H w CA � 14 a H W U] c ,I k � a W N t w c � m a O a U mw �j O F a_ E w tq ji O N y :F4 M W i� 3 Q LL L N C Cs a CL y C N to cc H ° H cc �a m v a Q O to N to F F 14 co i�L f4 rn 44 0 M a W O a O ta E+ H ul z 0 U y H H O W Q H H ° Q1 O N r-1 a O 3 a c) Q H O 9 w 0 W H a a H U H A Q H eH H O O H p W � W Q o 06 c D C !-i N � C O H U A N O U W U z H Cl) z 0 H �� rr U) cn H cn a 9 w w H E U C3 04 0 0 W U Gu U O E a d V. A N b n• W z H z H E U W LL O H N " 0 0 La En W O � z O DH 9) pW A N Fi A 3 N a4 .a 4 4 u N U ro N V) N a O u w >, 4-1 .r{ A rtl u V) 4 O u C m 4 n V) w O w O O u a A U) W. W 0 a rn A rw rl. >+ z W E1 Ei W yN a Q W E-4 W O U U) H W O y H a z O U N f!} WU N �] u a � a a �W Ezw a y O 0 Ey WU y E m h U ice! U a µ H a v E-1 8 O g O W a � a W W w a W x E1 x Ei 5 H H U Ul 14 N N M H W W � H S+ T. H O W O W o 0 x x M 0 z O E O w a a o EF z ul 0 wV h N U a oaa A N U 154 ca ru O w0 h V V U w c-i a E-0 z `� z 0 p1 O W m H a7 Z �'L N H w z F N H E+ U O Pi .+ a W pA y gH T•i � F w CA N Cd H to E F N Q F U x a w HI, N E-1 Ea 0 U A El a ON U U 00 a x E a 1-4 fn Q U J o°c a 0 L¢ r ?� H o Z . C C C O Id J j a.r R. ro U vl W � N ��4 O u 7 C al N U O. a1 �A µ O a� N U a) N O. r: .-4 X - O N U ul 3: v a� '-1 E n w �v x�rn N V H �T to .0 u ,3 -i m m al U w-4 r•z •.i a 0 o V) v H ^I lr >, O v C 1r $4 u o V) 4 rd U ro u ., (L) ai N r• N u a ru o, V as C .4 -i u s-r .--I N U N N x x c O •N --t fo O 9 4) w ar L v .a -� b V) ax4 o U 4J Ul '-1 r6 O i-Si C •-I N at w m P 14 O H H T - 3 N r0 y _4 —1 . -1 w U h N � 7 U V U L 44 O 1l7 tp Q1 fd Of rn ON a� a Q W F H N ZO U L dP N G O � E I50NI G V) u^ H E. wo u Z y 99 a m E. NW P9G O R O ►� N �Q J m z a a. O Z H 44 0 to N tp 10 a E p E U dp y w a H W �Nj H ` W d a 0 wzw Q H � ga �aa H N N O V `L. OL u 7 N a Ei yN U W iJ H H z a w y w ��V}} xi s O a H W� O qa 4 J O F Q y,� � J a Q O O Z a ah 44 0 b QI 3 o W° 41 LIQ 0 .� �, ° '�^ ro 3 � -P ° O r C +. O 0 Z O Nit=`0°i � W M p) � VOj cLd O CL O c CD O 0� -a m= c N O U 0. 0 CL co �• a> d 3 r_ m m 0 O r-L m M V� (DE O c a ro w. vN� •ca O r O• V 0 '� M> 0 3�°c 75� O E �. m O � c Cr :3 0 C +• C C m C a u o° c' 0 = '0 •— N 0) 0 CL (Q 0 4) -- 0 Q u U ro o° m c`O C n m > W e � Kam. 0 O` c � co O O E m b to H N O co m X ch c 4; Q E p w z �- T°' C 4- O a) O ca :ti m O a c u° .P o•a) (A r.+ m=°'� i � a EtooE_ r i m 46Q)-O> u �'vx co3E� `Ua` O C O ccca ... E ca cm 4J 0 C rt [3 °�' C cb 00 r C O N> m � m c c y N a U W 01 fA _Ile C_ r_ O Q N O {E�H�j1 rt 41 C � c cu +3 � r � C � '� C � 41 [ t :� 8 `� m C o c c C 0 LO 0 0 E CO � O co y o v E wM O O O nOO 3 xi iE - CL E o , � = m � c o '0 N H ) p O CL� O •� US L- +. COL _> O p �. w F� LL o cn .� cn c O c]. Q ca + >+ > CO o V CO �° cc E �n .� � 0 U L C O 0-0 0 O¢ C E ` 0 O w O Q a� O C d 0) �N>Q E64 EQo Ts,°'� V1 ri .-i > Y Q 1 b N V7 C -0 O � U a4 o Q -- to O 3 O 0 m 0 4J R u O O .N co N 0 'O 'a � 0) C O O C r �' Q a N U a '� -- C r ++ to m U O m 0• m 'o O N cC6 N `c {� uHi ' E. Mn cu ` 0 'S O U N ¢CL aEi >, C CD 0? z U a r�I 0-0 0 C 0 cn C p• C 0 E N nt �w a? O }• o m � �O to � m (D «• E '� •� Q m N to O c (Dt Q id O_ a U — r� +� co U � m U m�s� Q '0 C 3 E m b N CD c U 'O OHS V ``p c O N a > m E a m. ar a u�i o `� L- co p vi ) (D c m m a� v o m } p° ai m >, cn N O O — C is -O v gN F- N o o � '0 0 wr�u :3 Q E�Q'0 °'mom ° cy.(D m Co o � 3 3.,`-- o .rl u)-E U.�L�� rooms w a, m cEau`�ia�aUi >- 'c�a � �° a o U ra a-, �� ���W 0 3 a� m -o av CL o r Or o C' w G a? w 64 (V w U> >• cn E Q o r ca ,� a� Q� c F- m D •� 0 Q� -0 s4 O U � C7 N O U r- 0 m .w .,A �4 0 x-0 v -P (D -ri �4 sA •ri U m -P 0) G O 3 -P 14 0 (Vw m >1 43 r-I : U -rs •.-1 O � a w >1 ra o w -P �f.- M U) -i a. ►-, o U • U W rri E- z .Q rn a, LW m 0 -- m 0% 0 co ri Z W w a a a, L) U) 6 re O z H z O H H H A r., N z 0 cn a H U z H a of 0 H H H N O a H E4 C a o� H w L V H N L CL Q $ Q N (} rn H C mNHto c O W x W O w 2 3 W W a� a H •r C) z fj H E E~ a � H n c.a z cn H H E-� W U Z M x 7 U o a4 '-j O At O a a 00 H a E- w W O E a >. a ow 11 a E ca H ; � T a Ln T C O O N C CL o C Q H H O Y a Z U CD C iv v) Ca � N ++ 0) >t+ aa E N 5 •� N H OC cC oG Q. I o�0) H Q) EA EA a m rn T E H E y � C C Z Q m ~' C m m N U- E . A °G O c U a E A E+ N N W H 14 H H O {o7�f H 0Q6 h N F a [4 R R Fs h�i COUNTY OF HAWAII Completed Projects and Contact Information Project Project Year Location Department Contact Halelua Oceanfront Land Acquisition 2022 North Kohala, Hawaii Dept of Finance Mr. Hamana Ventura Kakala O Kamoa Oceanfront Property 2022 Kailua-Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finance Mr. Hamana Ventura Destiny Deep Sea Water Property 2022 Kailua-Kona, Hawaii State NELHA Mr. Gregory Barbour Kapanala Land Acquisition 2022 North Kohala, Hawaii Dept of Finance Mr. Hamana Ventura Mamalahoa Hwy Drainage Improvements 2022 Waimea, Hawaii Dept of Public Works Mr. Alan Thompson Kalnallu Parking Parcel 2021 Kealakekua, Hawaii Dept of Finance Mr. Hamana Ventura Kapalama Kohala Parcel Acquisition 2021 North Kohala, Hawaii Dept of Finance Mr. Hamana Ventura Kukuihaele Lot 1 Acquisition 2021 Hamakua, Hawaii Dept of Finance Mr. Daryl Inaba Bar -King Dog Kennel Acquisition 2021 Keaau, Hawaii Dept of Finance Mr. Hamana Ventura Kealakehe Rubbish Dump Extension 2020 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finance Mr. Hamana Ventura Holualoa Lots Acquisition 2020 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finance Mr. Hamana Ventura Kona Micro Units 2020 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finance Mr. Hamana Ventura Papaikou Beach Access Easement 2020 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Corp. Counsel Mr. Sinclair Salas-Ferguson Pohoiki Road Restoration 2020 Puna, Hawaii Dept of Public Works Mr. Ben Ishii Mamalahoa Hwy Drainage Improvements 2020 Waimea, Hawaii Dept of Finance Ms. Deanna Sako Kapanaia Land Acquisition 2019 North Kohala, Hawaii Dept of Finance Ms. Deanna Sako 73-410 Hulikoa Drive Property Acquisition 2019 Kailua-Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finance Ms. Deanna Sako Waiolpae Tide Pools Appraisal Review 2018 Pahoa, Hawaii Dept of Finance Ms. Maxine Cutler Lono Kona Sewer Project 2017 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finance Ms. Maxine Cutler Kona Industrial Properties 2017 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finance Ms. Maxine Cutler Kau Park Lands Acquisition 2017 Kau, Hawaii Dept of Finance Ms. Maxine Cutler Papaikou Beach Access Easement 2017 Papaikou, Hawaii Dept of Corp. Counsel Mr. Ron Kim Saddle Road, East Section 2017 South Hilo, Hawaii State DOT Lennie Okano-Kendrick, P.E. Pahoa Parking Property 2015 Pahoa, Hawaii Dept of Finance Ms. Alexandra Kelepolo Pahoa Oceanfront Parcels 2015 Pahoa, Hawaii Dept of Finance Ms. Alexandra Kelepolo Hokulia Bypass Road Litigation 2015 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Corp. Counsel Mr. Steven Strauss Dept of Interior Land Acquisition 2014 Kau, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Ken Van Bergen Kalholena Lot 14-1-F Update 2014 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finance Ms. Alexandra Kelepolo Pahoa Land Acquisitions 2014 Pahoa, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr, Ken Van Bergen Kapiolani Street Extension ROW Lot A-2 2014 Hilo, Hawaii Dept of Corp. Counsel Mr. Joe Kamelamela Kahuku Coastline Land Acquisition 2014 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Ken Van Bergen Hokulla Bypass Road Lot 2 Appraisal 2014 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Corp. Counsel Mr. Joe Kamelamela Kapulena Well Dev. Phase 2 2013 Hamakua, Hawaii Dept of Water Supply Mr. ]ason Killam Vacant Parcels for Acquisition 2013 North Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Ken Van Bergen Kapiolani Street Extension 2013 Hilo, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba Manono Street Improvements 2013 Hilo, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba Update of Laaloa ROW Lot B-2 2013 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finace Ms. Kathy Garson Road Lot B 2013 Hilo, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Ken Van Bergen Hokulia Bypass Road Extension 2012 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Corp. Counsel Mr. Joe Kamelamela Hokulia 80-Lots 2012 Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba Laaloa Avenue Extension Project 2011 North Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba TMK 9-2-12-5 Land Acquisition 2011 Kau, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba Easements A & E-1 2011 Hamakua, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba HECO Easement 2011 Hamakua, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba Lot 26-B Acquisition 2011 Pohoiki, Puna, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba Laaloa Avenue Extension Project 2011 North Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Ken Van Bergen TMK (3) 7-5-19-25, Parcel Acquisition 2010 North Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba AM Drive Acquisition Parcels 2010 North Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Ken Van Bergen Kau Land Acquisition Parcels 2010 Kau, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Ken Van Bergen Honokaa Sewer Easements 2010 Honokokaa, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba Puainako Street Extension 2010 South Hilo, Hawaii Hawaii County Mr. Al Inoue - 935-2995 Kaholalele Parcel Acquisitions 2009 Hamakua, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Ken Van Bergen North Kohala Parcel Acquisitions 2009 North Kohala, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Ken Van Bergen Market Value of 16 Pauuilo Lots 2009 Hamakua, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Daryl Inaba Remnant Valuation -Oshima 2009 North Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Harry Yada Ane Keohokalole Hwy Project 2009 North Kona, Hawaii Hawaii County & Mr. Al Inoue - 935-2995 Easement A, Puna Baseyard 2008 Puna, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Harry Yada Land & Improvements Acquisition 2007 South Kona, Hawaii Dept of Finace Mr. Harry Yada Ane Keohokalole Hwy Project 2009 North Kona, Hawaii Hawaii County, State DOT Mr. Al Inoue - 935-2995 Kawailani Streeet Improvements 2008 South Hilo Hawaii Hawaii County Mr. Al Inoue - 935-2995 ACM it Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs CERTIFICATE OF GOOD STANDING I, the undersigned Director of Commerce and Consumer Affairs of the State of Hawaii, do hereby certify that according to the records of this Department, ACM CONSULTANTS, INC. was incorporated under the laws of Hawaii on 04/29/1997 ; and that it is an existing corporation in good standing, and is duly authorized to transact business. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs, at Honolulu, Hawaii. Dated: May 01, 2023 Director of Commerce and Consumer Affairs To check the authenticity of this certificate, please visit: http: //hbe.ehawai.i.gov/documents/authenticate .html Authentication Code: 462554-COGS PDF-108383D1 STATE OF HAWAII STATE PROCUREMENT OFFICE CERTIFICATE OF VENDOR COMPLIANCE This document presents the compliance status of the vendor identified below on the issue date with respect to certificates required from the Hawaii Department of Taxation (DOTAX), the Internal Revenue Service, the Hawaii Department of Labor and Industrial Relations (DLIR), and the Hawaii Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs (DCCA). Vendor Name: ACM CONSULTANTS, INC. Issue Date: 05/01/2023 Status: Compliant Hawaii Tax#: 20103567 New Hawaii Tax#: GE-0105611244-01 FEINISSN#: XX-XXX8494 UI#: XXXXXX3923 DCCA FILE*: 108383 Status of Compliance for this Vendor on issue date: Form Department(s) Status A-6 Hawaii Department of Taxation Compliant 8821 _— Internal Revenue Service Compliant COGS Hawaii Department of Commerce & Consumer Affairs — Compliant LIR27 Hawaii Department of Labor & Industrial Relations Compliant Status Legend: Status Description Exempt The entity is exempt from this requirement Compliant The entity is compliant with this requirement or the entity is in agreement with agency and actively working towards compliance Pending A status determination has not yet been made Submitted The entity has applied for the certificate but it is awaiting approval Not Compliant The entity is not in compliance with the requirement and should contact the issuing agency for more information TED YAMAMURA State of Hawaii Appraiser License License Number E�iration date CGAr 460 12l3112023 IMM CO MAWM DMAMNCMT w COMM13 u�OOMIluE.R 1WNRb CERTIFIED GENERAL APPRAIgEjR f. TEE) K YAMAMURA } f 2073 WELLS ST STE IOOx WAILUKU,I'll 96793 9 1 i. SIGNATURE OF LICENSEE i0tom of oe�'s�+�*aroor�wtdtW�r�+�sr,r�n� .fw%w.bd�..t..us.r,r .. 8p a¢i61tu. _ A�'rBnlsH► -- s firfiie.�l.y6'iliwww+w�_.aw_ soot .�.�w....�E.df,i�.�i,s�6�G.�a.,.wi,�6.r,s�ly.r'�r X ¢.y�A.r�.s si► a..nN.w.Ak�.a�.mwk OW1nn.�T «ws Cr..ew �.thr. R TUN 4M� WMT W DW*AVIOAT ►LAM OT MNIMM009 N NOT T AP4@ft WLl 00 M Mr. Guy Hironaka, Real Property Manager Mr. Aaron Sakamoto, Chief County of Maui -Department of Finance City and County of Honolulu 200 South High Street, 2nd Floor Dept of Design and Construction, Land Division Wailuku, Hawaii 96793 650 South King Street Tel: (808) 270.7725 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Fax: (808)270-7878 Tel- (808)768-8717 Email- guv.hironaka@Co.maui.hi.us Fax: (808) 523-4567 Email' iamacoranonolulu.gov Mr. Hamana Ventura, Property Manager Mr. Russell Tsuji, Land Division Administrator County of Hawaii State of Hawaii -Dept of Land & Natural Resources 25 Aupuni Street Suite 1101 P 0 Box 621 Hilo, Hawaii 96720 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809 Tel: (808) 961-3528 Tel: (808) 587-0422 Email, hamana.ventura@hawaiicounty.gov Fax: (808) 587-0455 Email: russell.y.tsuii@hawaii.gov Mr. Cyrus Chen, Appraisal Section Chief Ms. Linda Mural, Property Manager State of Hawaii -Dept of Transportation, State of Hawaii -Dept of Agriculture Right of Way Branch 1428 South King Street 601 Kamokila Boulevard, Room 691 Honolulu, Hawaii 96814 Kapolei, Hawaii 96707 Tel: (808) 973.9471 Tel: (808) 692-7693 Fax: (808) 973-9467 Fax: (808) 692-7327 Email: a, �nawaii.gov Email: Dhawaii.gov Mr. Randall Endo, Vice President Mr. David Hlnazumi, Senior Vice President A & B Properties Hawaii, LLC Grove Farm 11 Puunene Avenue 3-1850 Kaumualii Highway Kahuluir Hawaii 96732 Lihue, Hawaii 96766 1eE (808)872-4307 Tel: (808) 245-3775 Fax: (808) 871-7497 Fax: (808) 246-9470 Email: rendo@abprop.corn Email: dhinazumi@groyefar n.com Mr. Shane Nishimoto, MAI, Chief Appraiser Ms. Krista Lunzer, Director of Transit Property American Savings Bank Acquisition and Relocation 300 North Beretania Street City and County of Honolulu Honolulu, Hawaii 96817 Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation (HART) Tel: (808) 539-7814 1099 Alakea Street Suite 1700 Email-- snishimoto&sbhawaii.com Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Tel: (808) 768-6159 Email: inzer@wdschockco.com ACM �} Corporate Resume ACM CONSUL f AN S, INC ACM Consultants, Inc. 2073 Wells Street, Suite 100 Wailuku, Maui, Hawaii 96793 (808) 242-6481 www,acmmaui.com .t Con in s Company Profile Services Clients References Qualifications It a A. CONSULT^TS. iNC. Company Profile ACM Consultants, Inc. is one of the most experienced independent real estate valuation and consulting companies in Hawaii. The firm is based on the island of Maui and provides diverse services throughout the State of Hawaii. As an integral part of the real estate decision process, ACM Consultants, Inc. provides real estate valuation opinions to a wide range of clients from individual buyers or sellers to developers, lenders, government entities and large private institutions. The firm Is involved in providing valuation and market study services for residential properties, condominium units, vacant land, estates, and complex, high value residential real properties throughout the State of Hawaii. ACM Consultants, Inc., also provides expert witness services in the court system of the State of Hawaii, U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court. We also provide specialized services to assist in alternative dispute resolution processes such as mediation and arbitration proceedings, and eminent domain. The principal and associates of ACM Consultants, Inc. are experienced and highly educated in their various fields of expertise. Within the firm are members who have attained the distinctive SRA appraisal designation from the Appraisal Institute, and R/W-AC Certification from the International Right of Way Association. LEN INOKUMA, SRA, CRA, owner and president of ACM Consultants Inc., has been an integral part of the company since 1999. After graduating from the University of Nevada, Las Vegas with a BSBA in Real Estate Finance, Len moved back to Maui to begin his career in residential appraising. By 2002, Len was licensed as a certified residential appraiser (CRA) in the State of Hawaii, and later earned the respected SRA designation from the Appraisal Institute. Being born and raised in Hawaii, along with his extensive knowledge of real estate, Len became an expert in all types of residential properties. As president, Len is actively involved in every aspect of the company. This includes working with clients, overseeing daily operations, leading ACM's growth strategy, and focusing on creating new and applicable valuation products, which will serve his clients more effectively. During his spare time, Len is an active member of his community. He is a board member of the Hawaii Chapter of the Appraisal Institute, the President of the St. Anthony Parish School Board, and a board member of St. Anthony Grade School's PTG. He also serves as a member of both Hale Makua's General Board and the Development and Community Relations Committee. Len resides in Kahului with his wife, Dayna, and two sons, Devin and Chase. TED K. YAMAMURA, SRA, CGA, R/W-AC, Executive Vice -President and senior appraiser was raised on the island of Maui, is a veteran of the U.S. Air Force and educated at the University of Hawaii, Manoa. He received banking experience as manager for the former Honolulu Federal Savings and Loan and began his appraisal career as Vice President, Maui Branch of the former Alexander & Alexander, Ltd. In 1982, he established ACM, Real Estate Appraisers, now known as ACM Consultants, Inc. He is an SRA designee of the Appraisal Institute and also a Right of Way -Appraisal Certified (R/W-AC) appraiser in the State of Hawaii. His primary expertise is the valuation and counseling for government entities throughout the State of Hawaii, arbitration services, litigation support and expert witness services in the court system of the State of Hawaii, U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court. He also provides valuation of complex, high value residential real properties. Mr. Yamamura is also Yellow Book and Right of Way educated and experienced. ACM Consultants, Inc. is proud to be a part of the complex and challenging process of real property valuation on Maui and the State of Hawaii. As the economics of real property changes from market to market, we take pride in knowing that our staff are able to quickly adapt and provide the quality and professional service our clients deserve. ■ INCORPORATION ■ ADDRESS AND CONTACT Founded August 1982. Incorporated State of Hawaii, April 1997. 2073 Wells Street, Suite 100 Wailuku, Maul, HI 96793 Telephone: (808)242-6481 Fax: (866)871-1226 Website: p://www.acmmaui.com ■ COMPANY HISTORY ACM Consultants, Inc, formerly known as ACM Real Estate Appraisers, Inc., is a Hawaii corporation. ACM Consultants, Inc., is a professional organization providing informed and objective real property valuation services to clients requiring responsible, comprehensive and creative guidance to enable informed decisions and viable solutions in real property valuation problems. ACM Consultants, Inc. is engaged solely in the real property valuation and consultation field. ■ PROFESSIONAL MEMBERSHIPS Appraisal Institute, SRA Designation (Len Inokuma) Appraisal Institute, SRA Designation (Ted Yamamura) National Association of Realtors, Appraisal Section, Founding Member International Right of Way Association, Past Chapter President International Right of Way Association, R/A-AC Certification (Ted Yamamura) APPRAISER LICENSING State of Hawaii, Certified General Appraiser State of Hawaii, Certified Residential Appraiser ■ KEY PERSONNEL Len Inokuma, President SRA, CRA Ted Yamamura, Exec VP SRA, CGA, R/W-AC Ashley Haleakala CRA Tamra Takeshita Tian! Quipotla ■ SERVICE AREA State of Hawaii, All Counties it Jr ACM SERVICES — Residential Appraisals Single Family Condominium Unit Vacant Land Multiple Dwelling Properties Estates High Value Properties SERVICES — Specialized Appraisals Eminent Domain Easement Valuations Partial Acquisition Valuations Right of Way Acquisition and Permitting Federal, State and County Highway Projects Enhancement Valuation Highway, Airport and Harbor Properties Lease Rent Re -Openings Remnant Valuations Revocable Permits Submerged Lands LEGAL Arbitration Mediation Estate Valuation Litigation Support Expert Witness erAceS ACM • CLIENTS Clients ACM Consultants, Inc. is approved by numerous financial, private and governmental institutions. A partial list of clients include: FINANCIAL American Savings Bank FSB Bank of America Bank of Hawaii Bank of Oklahoma, N.A. California Savings Bank Central Pacific Bank CitiBank, Hong Kong Citigroup Private Banking Deutsche Bank Federal Credit Unions Finance Factors, Ltd. First Hawaiian Bank Hawaii National Bank Home Street Bank Pacific Rim Bank Silicon Valley Bank Territorial Savings Bank The Bank of Tokyo US Bank PRIVATE ENTITIES AND CORPORATIONS Alexander & Baldwin, Inc. Lowe's AKF Development Malulani Investments, Ltd. Castle & Cooke Company Maui Electric Company CH2M Hill Clinical Laboratories of Hawaii Commercial Properties of Maui DR Horton -Schuler Homes Dowling Company, Ind, Fidelity National Title First Wind Energy LLC Haleakala Ranch Company Grove Farm Hawaiian Cement KRS Development Henkels & McCoy Kamehameha Schools KSD Hawaii Kapolei Property Development LLC Kaanapali Beach Hotel Kaanapah Development Corp Kaanapali Land Management Corp Kaonoulu Ranch Kapalua Land Company Kaupo Ranch Kukui'ula Development Company 4 Marriott Maui Memorial Medical Center Makani Nui Associates Mitsunaga & Associates Oceanic Time Warner Cable Pacific Rim Land, Inc. Parsons Brinckerhoff Pacific Rim Land Property Development Center Pulama Lanai The Mills Group Sempra Generation-Auwahi Wind SSFM International Spencer Homes Starwood Hotels & Resorts Stanford Carr Development Tesoro Refining & Marketing Co. Title Guaranty of Hawaii Towne Development Hawaii University of New Mexico VIP Foodservice West Maui Land Company .1k ACM towllm w- 0j LEGAL/ACCOUNTING/ PLANNERS Ashford & Wriston, LLP Alston Hunt Floyd & Ing Bays Lung Rose Holma Bronster Fujichaku Robbins Cades Schutte LLP Carlsmith Ball LLLP Dwight K. Muraoka, Attorney Deeley King Pang & Van Etten Glenn Kosaka, Attorney At Law Goodsill Anderson Quinn & Stifel Munekiyo & Hiraga Inc. Frampton & Ward LLC County of Maui Office of the Mayor Department of Public Works Department of Finance Housing & Human Concerns City A County of Honolulu Office of the Corporation Counsel Department of Design and Construction Department of Land Management Klevansky Piper LLP Kobayashi, Sugita & Goda Karen Temple, Attorney at Law Mancini, Welch & Geiger LLP McKeon Imlay Mehling Horovitz Tilley Pamela Shults, Attorney At Law Ranken & Associates Rush Moore, LLP Takitani Agaran & Jorgensen LLLP Niwao & Roberts, CPA's N & K CPA's, Inc. Russell Yamane, CPA Corporation Counsel Department of Water Supply Department of Planning Parks and Recreation Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation (HART) Department of Environmental Services Department of Transportation Services Kauai County Public Works Department Planning Department Hawaii County Department of Finance Department of Public Works 5 Office of the Corporation Counsel Environmental Management It 0 ACM CCW$%TAN7$. C. Mate of Hawaii Department of the Attorney General Agribusiness Development Corporation Department of Land & Natural Resources Department of Education Department of Transportation — Highways, Harbors, Airports Department of Agriculture Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism Department of Hawaiian Home Lands Hawall Health Systems Corporation Hawaii Housing Finance & Development Corporation Hawall Community Development Authority Hawaii Public Housing Authority Natural Energy Laboratory of Hawaii Federal Housing and Urban Development USDA Rural Development United States Coast Guard United States Department of Agriculture United States Department of Agriculture-NRCS Veteran's Administration NON-PROFIT AND EDUCATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS Carden Academy of Maui Emmanuel Lutheran Church and School Hale Mahaolu Kapiolani Medical Center for Women & Children Maui Coastal Land Trust Mental Health Kokua Pacific Cancer Institute 6 Kauai Economic Development Board Queen Emma Land Company The ARC in Hawaii The Trust for Public Land The Roman Catholic Church University of Hawaii University of New Mexico 9 ACM CO.C6tTA TL W_ * REFERENCE SOURCES Mr. Guy Hironaka, Real Property Manager County of Maui -Department of Finance 200 South High Street, 2nd Floor Wailuku, Hawaii 96793 Tel: (808) 270-7725 Fax: (808) 270-7878 Email; guy�hirQnaka�co,mdui,hi..us Mr. Hamana Ventura, Property Manager County of Hawaii 25 Aupuni Street Suite 1101 Hilo, Hawaii 96720 Tel: (808) 961-3528 Email: Mr. Cyrus Chen, Appraisal Section Chief State of Hawaii -Dept of Transportation, Right of Way Branch 601 Kamokila Boulevard, Room 691 Kapolei, Hawaii 96707 Tel: (808) 692-7693 Fax: (808) 692-7327 Email: Mr. Randall Endo, Vice President A & B Properties Hawaii, LLC it Puunene Avenue Kahului, Hawaii 96732 Tel: (808) 872-4307 Fax: (808) 871-7497 Email: r _ Mr. Shane Nishimoto, MAX, Chief Appraiser American Savings Bank 300 North Beretania Street Honolulu, Hawaii 96817 Tel: (808) 539-7814 Email: srFis►knouo-@ash,Na�t,ca Mr. Aaron Sakamoto, Chief City and County of Honolulu Dept of Design and Construction, Land Division 650 South King Street Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Tel: (808) 768-8717 Fax: (808)523-4567 Email: camoto_@hanolulu.gov Mr. Russell Tsuji, Land Division Administrator State of Hawaii -Dept of Land & Natural Resources P 0 Box 621 Honolulu, Hawaii 96809 Tel: (808) 587-0422 Fax: (808) 587-0455 Email: usseii.y.tsu i whawaii.go_v Ms. Linda Mural, Property Manager State of Hawaii -Dept of Agriculture 1428 South King Street Honolulu, Hawaii 96814 Tel: (808) 973-9471 Fax: (808)973-9467 Email: Iinda.h,murai@_hawaii.gov Mr. David Hinazumi, Senior Vice President Grove Farm 3-1850 Kaumualli Highway Lihue, Hawaii 96766 Tel: (808) 245-3775 Fax: (808) 246-9470 Email: '"mazumi@grove farm. ccm Ms. Krista Lunzer, Director of Transit Property Acquisition and Relocation City and County of Honolulu Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation (HART) 1099 Alakea Street Suite 1700 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Tel: (808) 768-6159 Email: klunzer mdschockco_com #> it ^C M C1DWAtF-7S. WC Ir Qualcatiorrs PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS Len Inokuma, SRA, CRA ASSOCIATION MEMBERSHIPS: Certified Residential Appraiser, State of Hawaii No. CRA-645, Licensed 10/9/2002 Expiration: December 31, 2023 L ASLR4 PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS: Member, Appraisal Institute, SRA Designation, Hawaii Chapter No. 67, Designation - 2014 EXPERIENCE: President ACM Consultants, Inc. 2073 Wells Street Suite 100 Wailuku, Hawaii 96793 May 1990 to Present EDUCATION: University of Nevada Las Vegas - BSBA Real Estate Finance - 1989-1995 Baldwin High School - 1985-1989 COMMUNITY AFFILIATIONS: Hawaii Chapter of the Appraisal Institute President 2022 Hawaii Chapter of the Appraisal Institute Vice President 2020 Hawaii Chapter of the Appraisal Institute Secretary/Treasurer 2019 Hawaii Chapter of the Appraisal Institute Director 2016 - 2018 St. Anthony School Board 2017 - 2019 St. Anthony Parish School Board President - 2016 St. Anthony PTG Board 2016 Hale Makua Services General Board 2014-2019 Hale Makua Services Development & Community Relations Committee Chair 2014-2019 Honolulu Japanese Chamber of Commerce 2005-2006 St. Anthony Parish School Board Board Member 2003-2004 St. Anthony PTG Board PTG President 2003-2004 PTG Vice President 2002-2003 PTG Member 1999-2004 SUCESSFULLY COMPLETED THE FOLLOWING COURSES AND EXAMINATIONS: Appraisal Institute, 7-Hour National USPAP Update Course, Online 2022 Appraisal Institute, "Business Practices and Ethics" - Online 2019 Appraisal Institute, "General Appraiser Market Analysis and Highest and Best Use" - Online 2018 Appraisal Institute, Supervisory Appraiser/Trainee Appraiser Course - Honolulu, HI 2015 Appraisal Institute, "Advanced Residential Report Writing, Pt. II" - Seattle, WA 2013 Appraisal Institute, "Advanced Residential Applications & Case Studies" - Seattle, WA 2013 Appraisal Institute, "Residential & Commercial Valuation of Solar" - Albuquerque, NM 2013 Appraisal Institute, "Introduction to Green Buildings: Principles & Concepts - Online 2013 Appraisal Institute, "Online Residential Report Writing and Case Studies" - Online 2013 Appraisal Institute, "Online Real Estate Finance Statistics and Valuation Modeling" Online 2012 Appraisal Institute, "Residential Market Analysis and Highest & Best Use" - Online 2011 Appraisal Institute, "Online Business Practices and Ethics" - Online, 2011 8 0 ■ ACM Appraisal Institute, "Online FHA and The Appraisal Process" - 2009 Appraisal Institute, "7 Hour USPAP Course" - Online, 2009 Appraisal Institute, "15 Hour USPAP course" - San Diego, California 2006 Appraisal Institute, Course I210, "Residential Case Study" - Seattle, Washington, 2006 Appraisal Institute, Course II420N, "Business Practices and Ethics" - Honolulu, Hawaii 2005 National Association of Master Appraisers, Course 772 "National USPAP Course" Honolulu, Hawaii 2004 Appraisal Institute, Course 310, "Basic Income Capitalization" - San Diego California 2004 National Association of Master Appraisers, Course 627 "Principles of Real Estate Appraisal" Honolulu, Hawaii 2001 National Association of Master Appraisers, Course 636 "Practice of Real Estate Appraisal" Honolulu, Hawaii 2001 National Association of Master Appraisers, Course 660 "Writing The Narrative Appraisal Report" - Honolulu, Hawaii 2001 National Association of Master Appraisers, Course 672 Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice" - Honolulu, Hawaii 2001 Appraisal Institute, Course 120, "Appraisal Procedures" - Tempe, Arizona 1999 Appraisal Institute, Course 110, Appraisal Principles" - Tempe, Arizona 1999 QUALIFIED CONTINUING EDUCATION SEMINARS ATTENDED: Appraisal Institute, 2021 A] Annual Conference, Day 1 and 2, 2021 Appraisal Institute, Chapter Leadership Program, Webinar, 2021 Appraisal Institute, "Appraising Condos, Co-ops, and PUDs" - Online 2021 Appraisal Institute, "Appraisal of Manufactured Homes Featuring Next -Generation Manufactured Homes" - Online 2021 Appraisal Institute, "Desktop Appraisals (Bifurcated, Hybrid) and Evaluations" - Online 2021 Appraisal Institute, "Business Practices and Ethics" - Online 2020 Appraisal Institute, Chapter Leadership Program, Webinar, 2020 Appraisal Institute, 7-Hour National USPAP Update Course, Honolulu, Hawaii 2020 Appraisal Institute, Desktop Appraisals (Bifurcated, Hybrid) and Evaluations, Virtual Classroom 2019 Appraisal Institute, Hawaii Banks' Appraisal Perspective and Expectations, Honolulu, Hawaii 2019 Appraisal Institute, State of the Profession: Statutes & Rules for Hawaii Real Estate Appraisers, Honolulu, Hawaii 2019 Appraisal Institute, Spotlight on Common Errors and Issues, Honolulu, Hawaii 2019 Appraisal Institute, Spotlight on USPAP: Agreement for Services- Instructions for Use, Honolulu, Hawaii 2019 Appraisal Institute, Spotlight on Confidentiality, Honolulu, Hawaii 2019 Appraisal Institute, Spotlight on Review, Honolulu, Hawaii 2019 Appraisal Institute, 7-Hour National USPAP Update Course, Honolulu, Hawaii 2019 Appraisal Institute, Valuation by Comparison: Residential Analysis and logic, Honolulu, Hawaii 2019 Appraisal Institute, 7-Hour National USPAP Update Course, Honolulu, Hawaii 2018 Appraisal Institute, A Lender's Perspective: The Role of the Appraisal, Honolulu, HI 2018 Appraisal Institute, Solving Land Valuation Puzzles, Honolulu, HI 2018 Appraisal Institute, Spotlight on USPAP: Common Errors and Issues, Honolulu, HI 2017 Appraisal Institute, Spotlight on USPAP: Appraisal Review, Honolulu, HI 2017 Appraisal Institute, Litigation Assignments for Residential Appraisers: Doing Expert Work on Atypical Cases, Honolulu, HI 2017 Appraisal Institute, Doing Expert Work on Atypical Cases, Honolulu, HI 2017 Appraisal Institute, Advanced Land Valuation: Sound Solutions to Perplexing Problems, Honolulu, HI 2017 Appraisal Institute, "Income Approach for Residential Appraisers - Honolulu, HI 2016 Appraisal Institute, "7 Hour National USPAP Update Course" - Honolulu, HI 2016 Appraisal Institute, "FHA Appraising for Valuation Professionals" - Honolulu, HI 2016 Appraisal Institute, "Thinking Outside the Form" - Online 2016 Appraisal Institute, "Cool Tools: New Technology for Real Estate - Online 2016 Appraisal Institute, Impact of Collateral Underwriter for Appraisers and Lenders Webinar, 2015 Appraisal Institute, Unraveling the Mystery of Fannie Mae Appraisal Guidelines Honolulu, Hawaii, 2014 ACM r,�„w,a.,_ LEGAL: Appraisal Institute, Litigation Assignments for Residential Appraisers: Doing Expert Work on Atypical Cases - Honolulu, Hawaii, 2014 Appraisal Institute, 7-Hour National USPAP Update Course - Honolulu, HI 2014 Appraisal Institute, 7-Hour National USPAP Update Course - Honolulu, HI 2012 Appraisal Institute, Uniform Appraisal Dataset Aftereffects: Efficiency vs. Obligation Honolulu, Hawaii 2012 Appraisal Institute, Marketability Studies: Six -Step Process & Basic Applications Honolulu, Hawaii 2012 Appraisal Institute, The Uniform Appraisal Dataset form Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac (Hawaii ID 11-016) Honolulu, HI 2011 Appraisal Institute, FHA and The New Residential Form, (Hawaii ID 10-172) Honolulu, Hawaii 2010 Appraisal Institute, Hawaii Lands, Historical Review (Hawaii ID 09-909) Maui, Hawaii 2009 Appraisal Institute, The New Residential Market Conditions Form (Hawaii ID 09-005), Honolulu, Hawaii 2009 Appraisal Institute, Proposed Interagency Appraisal & Evaluation Guidelines/HVCC (Hawaii ID 09-006) Honolulu, HI 2009 Appraisal Institute, REO Appraisal: Appraisal of Residential Property Foreclosure (Hawaii ID 08-140), Honolulu, Hawaii 2008 Appraisal Institute, Appraisal Challenges: Declining Markets and Sales (Hawaii 1D 08-139) Honolulu, Hawaii 2008 Appraisal Institute, Fannie Mae Seminar (Hawaii ID 06-123), Honolulu, Hawaii 2006 Appraisal Institute, The Professional's Guide to URAR (Hawaii ID 04-137) Honolulu, Hawaii 2005 Appraisal Institute, Case Studies in Limited Partnerships and Common Tenancy (Hawaii ID 04-097), Honolulu, 2005 Appraisal Institute, Scope of Work: Where Are We Now? (Hawaii ID 04-098) Honolulu, Hawaii 2005 Appraisal Institute, Reappraising, Readdressing, Reassigning: What to do and Why and What to Include in a Work File (Hawaii ID 04-097) Honolulu, Hawaii 2004 Appraisal Institute, Fannie Mae Residential Presentation (Hawaii ID 04-099) Honolulu, Hawaii 2004 Appraisal Institute, FHA Appraisal Inspection from the Ground Up: What Every Appraiser Should Know (Hawaii ID 03-011) - Honolulu, HI 2003 Appraisal Institute, "Business Practices and Ethics" Honolulu, HI 2003 Appraisal Institute, Client Forum: "Meet Your Bosses" Honolulu, HI 2002 Appraisal Institute, "Practical Ways to Leverage New Tech. Tools in Appraisal Business" - Honolulu, HI 2002 Appraisal Institute, "Financial Reporting Valuations, Part 1: Principles/Concepts" Honolulu, HI 2002 Appraisal Institute, "Technology Update, Part 1" Honolulu, HI 2002 Qualified as an expert witness in Second Circuit Court, State of Hawaii. 10 At ACM C0H*k1.NT5,W. ualioatons APPRAISER QUALIFICATIONS - TED K. YAMAMURA, SRA, R/W-AC. CGA • STATE LICENSING State Certified General Appraiser, State of Hawaii, License No. CGA 160, 9/18/1991 I R W A Expiration: December 31, 2023 ..,....,...•.».....«,.»» SRA • PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS Member ---Appraisal Institute - Honolulu Chapter #67, SRA Designation - 1985 Member ---International Right of Way Association (IRWA), R/W-AC Certification - 2007 • PROFESSIONAL AND COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT Past Member ---State of Hawaii, Commission on Water Resource Management - 2012-2014 Past President ---Hawaii Chapter of the Appraisal Institute - 2010 Past Member ---County of Maui, Board of Water Supply - 2008-2012 Past Member ---State of Hawaii, Board of Land & Natural Resources - 2001-2006 Past President ---International Right of Way Association (IRWA), Hawaii Chapter #30 - 2004 Past President ---Maul County Council, Boy Scouts of Amerlca - 1987 • EXPERIENCE AND EDUCATION Executive Vice President ACM Consultants, Inc. 2073 Wells Street Suite 100 Wailuku, Maui, Hawaii 97693 Previously associated with the following: Vice President - Alexander & Alexander, Ltd. - Maui Division - 1979-1982 Assistant Vice President - Honolulu Federal Savings & Loan Assn. - 1974-1979 Veteran - United States Air Force - 1967-1971 Educated: Maui High School and University of Hawaii • SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED THE FOLLOWING COURSES: International Right of Way Association - Course 431, Problems in the Valuation of Partial Acquisitions, Online 2021 - 2021 Appraisal Institute - National Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) 2022-2023 Update Course - Online 2022 Appraisal Institute "National Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions ("Yellow Book") Practical Applications" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2017 International Right of Way Association - Course 403, Easement Valuation, Tucson, Arizona - 2008 International Right of Way Association - Course 410, Reviewing Appraisals in Eminent Domain, Tucson, Arizona - 2008 International Right of Way Association - Course 401, The Appraisal of Partial Acquisitions Fresno, California - 2007 International Right of Way Association - Course 409, Integrating Appraisal Standards, Anaheim, California - 2005 Appraisal Institute - Course 400, Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), Honolulu, Hawaii - 2003 Appraisal Institute - Standards of Professional Practice Part C, Honolulu, Hawaii - 1997 Appraisal Institute - Standards of Professional Practice Part A and Part B, Honolulu, Hawaii - 1993 International Right of Way Association (IRWA) Course 214, Skills of Expert Testimony Honolulu, Hawaii - 1988 Society of Real Estate Appraisers (SREA) Course 102 Examination, "Applied Residential Property Valuation, Honolulu, Hawaii - 1982 Society of Real Estate Appraisers (SREA) "Narrative Demonstration Report" Examination, Wailuku, Maui, Hawaii - 1983 11 ACM Society of Real Estate Appraisers (SREA) Course 101 Examination, "Introduction to Appraising Real Property", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1979 • CONTINUING EDUCATION SEMINARS AND WORKSHOPS ATTENDED: Appraisal Institute "Excel Applications for Valuation" - 2021 Appraisal Institute "Eminent Domain and Condemnation" - 2019 Appraisal Institute "Fundamentals of the Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions" - 2019 Appraisal Institute "Solving Land Valuation Puzzles" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2018 Appraisal Institute "Income Approach for Residential Appraisers" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2016 Appraisal Institute "The Discounted Cash Flow Model" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2015 Appraisal Institute "Complex Litigation Appraisal Case Studies" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2014 The Seminar Group "Eminent Domain & Condemnation in Hawaii" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2013 University of Hawaii/State of Hawaii Department of Transportation Federal Highways (FHWA) Highway Noise Policy and Abatement Guidelines Workshop" - 2011 Appraisal Institute "Real Estate Finance, Statistics, and Valuation Modeling" - 2009 Lorman Education Services "Law of Easements: Legal Issues and Practical Considerations in Hawaii" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2006 Lorman Education Services "Eminent Domain in Hawaii" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2006 Appraisal Institute "Mini -Series on USPAP Issues" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2006 International Right of Way Association (IRWA) "Uniform Act Symposium", Anaheim, California - 2005 Lorman Education Services Zoning and Land Use in Hawaii", Honolulu, Hawaii - 2003 The American Society of Farm Managers & Rural Appraisers "Conservation Easements" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2001 The American Society of Faun Managers & Rural Appraisers Appraising Rural Residential Properties" - Honolulu, Hawaii - 2001 Appraisal Institute "Valuation of Detrimental Conditions in Real Estate" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2000 Appraisal Institute "Case Studies in Residential Highest and Best Use" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2000 Appraisal Institute "Advanced Sales Comparison Approach" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2000 Appraisal Institute "Appraisal of Nonconforming Uses" Honolulu, Hawaii - 2000 Appraisal Institute "Litigation Skills for the Appraiser: An Overview", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1998 Appraisal Institute "Special Purpose Properties", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1997 Appraisal Institute "Appraising for the Secondary Market", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1996 Appraisal Institute "The Condominium Form and the Small Residential Income Property Appraisal Report Form", Anaheim, California - 1995 Appraisal Institute "Residential Appraisal Review", Chicago, Illinois - 1994 Appraisal Institute "Understanding Limited Appraisals and Appraisal Reporting Options" Chicago, Illinois - 1994 Appraisal Institute "Accrued Depreciation", Las Vegas, Nevada - 1992 Appraisal Institute "Market Analysis", Las Vegas, Nevada - 1992 American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers (AIREA) "Easement Valuation", Los Angeles, California - 1990 Federal National Mortgage Association (FNMA) "Fannie Mae Appraisals", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1990 Society of Real Estate Appraisers (SREA) "Federal Home Loan Bank Board Appraisal Standards", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1989 Society of Real Estate Appraisers (SREA) "Uniform Small Residential Income Appraisal ReportNew York - 1989 Society of Real Estate Appraisers (SREA) "Professional Practice", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1988 Society of Real Estate Appraisers (SREA) "R-41c and the Appraiser", Las Vegas, Nevada - 1987 American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers (AIREA) "R-41b and Subdivision Analysis", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1985 Society of Real Estate Appraisers (SREA) "Creative Financing and Cash Equivalency", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1983 Society of Real Estate Appraisers (SREA) "Appraising Single Family Residences", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1983 International Right of Way Association (IRWA) "Condemnation", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1982 Society of Real Estate Appraisers (SREA) Application of Market Extraction's", Honolulu, Hawaii - 1981 12 r ACM LEGAL Qualified as an expert witness: First Circuit Court, Honolulu, Hawaii Second Circuit Court, Maui, Hawaii Third Circuit Court, Hawaii Island, Hawaii U.S. District Court, Honolulu, Hawaii U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Honolulu, Hawaii Experienced in real estate arbitration assignments in the State of Hawaii 13