Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutFY23-24 Real Property Appraisal (Real Estate Appraisal), Paradise Appraisals, LLC• • �� �_ NT ':. FUNANCE !L � ''sec Paradise Appraisals, LLC July 27, 2023 C/O Ms, Deanna Sako Director of Finance, County of Hawaii 25 Aupuni Street, Suite 2103 Hilo, HI 96720 T'o whom it may concern, l2( UTZ 79-7266M,unalalioa }fw). Unit 9 healakekua,111 96750 kons';rahawan.com 808 A22 0999 I am enclosing the Statement of Qualifications for Real Estate Appraisal Services and Expressions of Interest for professional real estate appraisal assignments contracted by The County of Hawaii Department of Finance. This letter shall serve as my Letter of Interest to provide appraisal and real estate consulting services to the department. Paradise Appraisals, LLC was started in 1997 in Kailua Kona. We have two appraisers and a total of four full time employees in our office in Kealakekua. Our firm provides answers to property valuation questions on a very w'de variety of property types and purposes. We provide valuation services for commercial, industrial, multi -family, residential, and agricultural properties. We have provided valuations for eminent domain, Federal Land Acquisition assignments, conservation acquisitions, and affordable housing project acquisitions. I have served as an arbitrator in numerous land rent disputes and have been recognized as an expert witness in both Federal and State courts. I have also been published in the Appraisal Journal of the Appraisal Institute, regarding the proper measurement of market land rent. I am attaching the copy of my resume for review. I appreciate your consideration of my application for approval for assignments. If additional information is needed, please let me know. I have enclosed the following for your consideration. 1. A list of major valuation assignments I have completed. 2. Proof of Errors and Omissions Insurance. 3. My resume. 4. Transcript detailing my appraisal education. Thank you for considering me., Sincerely, R. J. Kirchner, SRA, CGA 275 Paradise Appraisals, LLC 79-7266 Mamalahoa Hwy, #9 Kealakekua, HI 96750 808-322-0999 rj@pahawaii,com R.I. Kirchner, SRA, CCA 275 5p"iahzing to Commercial, Industrial, I uxury, Large Acreage, and Leasehold Property, including Arbilralion and 1 ifi,atior. .14 , V-X' List of Proiects Large Land Assignments: Client TMK Trust for Public Land 395-11-Parcels 1, 4, 5, 6& 395.12-pace) 1 357-3-10, 357-2-11, 3S7-2-27, 357-2-36, 357-2- 37, 357-3-1, 357-3.2, 357-3-3, 357-3-7, 357 3- Confidential 8357-3-18 Confidential 357-3-parcels 10, 11, 27, 36, 37,1, 2, 3, 7, 8, 18 U.S. Dept of the Interior AVSQ 392-1-parcel 72 U.S. Dept of the Interior AVSQ 396-13-Parcel 6 Confidential 382-12-15 Farm CreditSerices of HI 331-4-75 Confidential 398-1-Parcels 9 and 10 U. S. Dept of the InteriorAV50 386-1 Parcels 1, 26, 29, 30, 3, 77, 78, 79 First State Bank 347-7-11 -r�3�c� •ay v -.... r R. J. Kirchner, SRA, CGA 275 Paradise Appraisals, LLC 79-7266 Mamalahoa Hwy, #9 Kealakekua, HI 96750 808-322-0999 rj@pahawaii.com Date of Assignment Client 4/18/2021 Trust for Public Land 12/6/2020 Confidential 12/6/2020 Confidential 8/19/2019 U. S. Dept of the Interior AVSO 7/18/2019 U. S. Dept of the Interior AV50 11/15/2018 Confidential 7/20/2018 Farm Credit 5edces of HI 4/16/2016 Confidential 2/3/2016 U. S. Dept of the InteriorAVS0 6/13/2015 First State Bank Recent Maior Commercial Property Assignments: Grand Naniloa Hotel in Hilo Kukuiula Resort, Development Appraisal Aina Lea Affordable Housing Project Kapapala Ranch, Rental Determination McCandless Ranch, Partial Acquisition HPM Factory, Shipman Industrial HPM Retail Stores in Hilo and Waimea Shipman LTD Property holdings (McDonalds, Long Drugs, Keaau Shopping Center Land Lease...) De Luz Toyota and Chevrolet Dealerships Orchid Ilse Ford Nissan and Chrysler Dealerships on Hawaii Island All Napa Auto Stores on Hawaii Island Papa'a Ranch on Kauai Clients Who May Be Contacted: Aaron Young, MAI, SRA I VP & Chief Appraiser ( Appraisal Department 999 Bishop Street,1103, Honolulu, HI 96813 1 P (808)525-8715 1 F (808)525-7163 1 avoung@fhb.com Cnmmcrr.=.ii Indw-trial. Mulb4gin&. Ln.-ui} Homes. Snxflr; Fyimtiy, Qc-r% i[gmwmv-_-L,rnd._Eat,rdt.rt.nit, Daniel G. Schwartz Vice President/Senior Reviewer 350 South Grand Avenue,llth Floor Los Angeles, CA 90071 Tel: 213.673.9283 E: dan,schwartz@cnb.com James Dunne : Vice President SR. Review Appraiser 1 Valuation Services Group I Commercial Banking J.P. Morgan I T: 949 860 6607 1 james.dunne@jPmorgan.corn I www. mor anchase.com commercial Guy M Hironaka County of Maui Finance Department Real Property Management Specialist V (808)270-7725 Guy Hironaka <Guy.Hironaka@co.maui.hi.us Glen Cole, MAI, AI-GRS Compliance Specialist/Review Appraiser Technical Services Division Appraisal and Valuation Services Office U.S. Department of the Interior 1220 5W 3rd Ave, Suite 1010 Portland, OR 97204-2825 503-808-6079 (Office Phone) 503-808-6318 (Office Fax) 503-260-3613 (Cellphone) Email: glen_cole@ios.doi.gov qm trrrral lndu-tr wl MUK14-ntly LtiZ.v l Horny!- Single. Ronr.; CnadoWtmut_R , L,4nj. Cnrr ulY+t.rnn, Ariwteafi m,. korrn,daon LAB LIA Adnwlnisirators & Insurance Services APPRAISAL, VALUATION AND PROPERTY SERVICES ASPEN PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY INSURANCE POLICY DECLARATIONS Aspen American, Insurance Company (Referred to below as the "Company") 590 Madison Avenue, 7th Floor New York, NY 10022 977-245-3510 Date Isued Polley Number I'mrious Policy Namlxr 1 /30/2023 LAIUD7974-09 AA1007974-u7 MIS 1S A CLAIMS MADH AND RGPOIt'!'IiD POLICY. COVEi10CE IS JAMITED TO JJA13IL1TY I -'OR ONLY T1IOSH CLAIMS '1'1 PAT ARli 1.111 1' MADE AGAINST Tills INSURED DURING ' I M, POLICY PERIOD AND 'THEN RI3BO]rJ'liD TO THE COMPANY IN WRITING NO I...VrIiR-11-JAN SI\IT (60) DAYS AVI—Elt FXPIIt:1'fION OR TI-RMINATION OF THIS POLICY, OR DURING 171-JE EXTENDED REPORTING PERIOD, III APPIACABI.1:, FOR A WRONGFUL ACT COMMI'1711'sD ON OR A IER THE RETROACTM DATE AND 131-FORN TilF CND OF 1`lfE POLICY PERIOD, PLIs ISIi RHAD 1I11., Policy CARE1TUI.LY. I. Customer 11): 139905 Named Insured: PAILU 1SH' APPILMSAI 5,1.I.0 Pnridise Appraisals 79-7266 Mamalahoa 1•hghuny #9 Kcalakckua,111 96750 2. Policy Pcriod: From: 02/15/2023 To: 02/15/2024 12:01 A.M. Standard Time ar the address stated in 1 nhave. 3. Deductible: S1000 T'ach Claim 4. Retroactive Data: 02/15/1997 S. Inception Date: 02/15/201 G G. Limits Of U2bility: A. $1,000,000 Hach Claim B. S2.000,000 At%rm.7;ttc Subpoena Response: S5.000 Supplemental Payment Coverage Prt:-C1aim Assistance: S5,000 Supplemental lliymem Cox-cvage Disciplinary Proceeding. S12,500 Supplemental Payment Coverage Loss of Earnings: S500 per dap Supplcmcnrtl 11a)mcnt Coverage 7. Covered Professional Services (as defined in the Policy and/or by Endorsement): Real 1-state Apprsi:sal and Valuation: Yes Nn R"idential Propem: YesCommercial N Property- Yes No Bodily injury and Property Darnage Caused During ApprakA inspection (S100.000 Sub -Limit): Yee X No 'I f"res", added by endorsement) Right of Way AgenI and Relocation: Yes No X Machinery and Equipment Valuation: Y. Ne X Personal Propt:M- Appraisal: Yes No L 'If"yes", added by endorsement) Real Estate Sales/Ilrokcrage: yeq No X ,If "yes", added by codorsemcnt) Jlspen American Insumace Company Page 1 of 2 I.IAQ11 "/19) l purt Claims tn: M.\ Administramrs K Insurance kn'icur Ffrxl•}34 11Gi3, P.t). llnx IM9, 1GOP ,\nxc pa St, Santa liatbam, CArurnxr 931111 Annual Premittsn. $2,089.00 10. Forms attached at issue: LIA002 (04/19) 1.1.► 11) (05/19) HA01? (05119) I,1A018 (05/19) U.►119(05/19) MA122 (05/19) J.1.1164 (05/19) LIM65 (05/19) 'i'his Mchratinns Page, tugetlmr with t1w eumpimd and signed Rrkv Applir-Am including ill attachments anJ exhibits thcnlo. and the PnFcy shall eanscimre tlx comrser hewn the i\amui Insured and the Company. 01/30/2023 Uau: Audrorived Repnesemarirc Agwn Arnurkan Insuranec Company Page 2 of 2 Cust ID. 119905 LIA(101 04/19) Appraisal, 'Valuation and Property Services Professional Liability Insurance Policy Named insured: PARADISE APPRAISALS, LLC Policy lumber: AA1007974-08 Paradise Appraisals Effective Date: 02/15/2023 Customer ID: 139905 THIS ENDORSEMENT CHANGES THE POLICY. PLEASE READ IT CAREFULLY. ADDITIONAL COVERED PROFESSIONALS ENDORSEMENT In consideration of the premium charged, it is agreed that Section IV. DEFINITIONS (I) "Insured" is amended to include: "Insured" means: The persons identified below. but ordy wi le acting on behalf of the Named Insured: Name Rkymond J. Kirchner Nicole M. Al. Moue Coverage Effective Date 02/ 13/2023 02/15l2023 All other term, conditions, and exclusions of this Policy remain unchanged. Aspen American Insurance Compare Page I of I LIA012 (05/19) • —•• -?r,:, At.lm.d.11eu.! list, I slit Mal d.a.ua I 11 4n" ;is 1. t•il.! l,,lll.i t„!11 t0111 Paradise Appraisals, LLC Summary of Qualifications Raymond J. Kirchner, SRA Professional Experience: R. J. Kirchner is an independent fee appraiser since June 1982 with offices currently in Kallua- Kona, HI. R. J. Kirchner was formerly Vice President and partner in R.W. Kirchner & Associates Appraisal Farm with offices in Stillwater, Mn. He then became a contract appraiser, working primarily for SEVCO Appraisers on the islands of Kauai, Maui and Hawaii from September of 1991 to March of 1992. R. J. Kirchner became the Chief Residential Appraiser of SEVCO in early 1992 and continued in this capacity until he left that firm in May of 1994 to become a principle partner in Royal Pacific Appraisals. R. J. Kirchner started Paradise Appraisals in February of 1997 as its managing partner. R. J. Kirchner is currently the sole proprietor of Paradise Appraisals LLC, completing commercial, industrial, agricultural, and residential assignments throughout the state. Appraisal Experience: Over 18,000 appraisals and reviews participated in since 1982. Most of these appraisals were completed in Hawaii, the Minneapolis/St. Paul Metropolitan area and western Wisconsin area. Appraisals include existing and proposed construction, single-family, duplexes, elderly hous-ng projects, condominiums, townhouses, commercial buildings, apartments, industrial properties, farms, condemnation, land lease rental determinations, and partial acquisitions. His most recent appraisal experience has been on all the islands of Hawaii appraising single family, land, small residential income properties, condominiums, subdivisions, office buildings, industrial properties, multi -family complexes, commercial properties, and partial acquisitions. Professional Courses and Articles Written: Author of "Land Rent Reset Arbitration in Hawaii: Credibility and Transparency" for the Fall 2014 edition of The Appraisal Journal published by The Appraisal Institute. Author and instructor for the State of Hawaii approved appraisa course "A Return to the Basics." R.l Kinlincr. SRA.l i,.1 2?; She. i,lhiill, ill ( i!!iliuercol. intfu.,trial. Liimin. I arye :%cleagi. an-1 I eawhold llroperl%. incimling lrhihtillai! and 1 iltgalilui /// -N lnt. 1{ t11i.1L1Lf�.t }FN t i tut •, ,P• I'.t .111�.1•{.t:.l {{�•li4 ill Paradise Appraisals, LLC Qualifications as an Expert Witness: R. J. Kirchner has been qualified as a professional witness in U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Hawaii Bankruptcy Court, the 3rd District Court of Hawaii, and in the District Court of Washington County, Minnesota. He has also served as an arbitrator and as an expert witness for land rental disputes in both Hawaii County and Honolulu County. Important Cases R. J. Kirchner, SRA has provided professional witness services in. 1. MALUHIA EIGHT, LLC, MALUHIA ONE, LLC, a/k/a MALUHIA APARTMENT 1, LLC, and MALUHIA NINE, LLC, a/k/a MALUHIA APARTMENT 9, LLC, Debtors. United States Bankruptcy Court, N.D. Texas, Dallas Division. Honorable Harlin DeWayne Hale, Bankruptcy Judge. October 21, 2010. 2. Mapunapuna industrial land rent re -openings. Mr. Kirchner served as the expert witness as to the market rent for the land for 32 industrial lots in Mapunapuna in arbitration hearings. 2012. 3. Served as the third arbitrator for 11 consolidated cases involving land rental re -openings in the Hilo Industrial area where the lessor was the State of Hawaii DLNR. 2010-2012. 4. Served as the expert witness for 17 parcels located throughout the State in the Damien Wong divorce case in front of the Honorable Judge lbarra. May of 2014- 5. Served as the expert witness for four owners in Hokulia before an arbitration panel regarding damages due to non -disclosure. August 2017. 6. Served as an expert witness for Aina Le'a, Inc., a partially completed 432 unit townhouse development. First Amended Chapter 11 Plan of Reorganization of Aina Le'a Inc., dated February 20, 2019. Major Clients: Bank of America (residential & commercial), J. P. Morgan Bank, First Hawaiian Bank (residential & commercial), Morgan Stanley Private Banking, U.S. Bank, Bank of Hawaii (commercial), Goldman Sachs Bank, Lloyds Bank, Wells Fargo, First Republic Bank, Citi Bank (residential & commercial), Finance Factors (residential & commercial), HUD, Central Pacific Bank, Deutsche Sank, Maui County, Hawaii County, U.S. Department of the Interior, The National Park Service, and numerous local banks, appraisal management companies, government agencies, accountants, and attorneys. R.I. Kip OvIo, N1tA. ( (1 N 2' til+ruallnn 111 ('t,allnercial. Ittdu,l11.11, I umirt, l .erge ioui�c• rota l eawlitild Proper'!%. Insludtng 1rhil -Mun and 1 tligalu,n Paradise Appraisals. LLCM Professional Memberships: • R. J. Kirchner currently holds an SRA Designation - Appraisal Institute, Headquarters located at 225 North Mi.chigan, Chicago, Illinois. ■ Certified General Appraiser #275, State of Hawaii (current). ■ Former Certified Federal Residential Ucense Real Estate Appraiser - State of Minnesota; License #4001391; 1991. ■ Former court appointed Condemnation Commissioner - Washington County, Minnesota. ■ Appointed member of the Minnesota Commissioner of Commerce's Task Force to license appraisers; 1987. ■ Past lobbyist for all eight major appraisal organizations in Minnesota; 1987 to 1990. ■ Past appointed member of the Minnesota appraisers Licensing Board. ■ Former Vice President - Washington Development Corporation, a non-profit corporation for the development of low income and elderly housing. ■ Appointed member of State of Hawaii DCCA Advisory Committee, since 2007. Education Background and Training: ■ Attended the University of Wisconsin at River Falls, Wisconsin from 1982 through 1987. Society of Real Estate Appraiser Course 101 - Foundations of Residential Appraising, completed in 1985. ■ American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers Course - Residential Valuation, completed in 1987. ■ The Appraisal of Partial Acquisitions - International Right of Way Association, completed in 1987. ■ Residential Demonstration Appraisal completed for the Society of Real Estate Appraiser, passed in 1988. ■ Society of Real Estate Appraiser Course 101 - Foundations of Residential Appraising, completed in 1985. ■ American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers Course - Residential Valuation, completed in 1987. ■ The Appraisal of Partial Acquisitions - International Right of Way Association, completed in 1987. ■ Residential Demonstration Appraisa' completed for the Society of Real Estate Appraiser, passed in 1988. ■ Standards of Professional Practice - Society of Real Estate Appraisers, passed in 1989. ■ Standards of Professional Practice -University of Hawaii, passed in December 1991. R.I. Lii,litier. SRA. t'L, % 27.5 SpcaalEnn; li! i UnIRt6'liEJl. Indlilli'i.11. ! nslll"L• f .ir�C.�CiC.IyL' and l cac hoW Pruperk lnJudni, 1rl,ibalitin and I ili�aliuu -2M �Ii1.11. Yt1•i5 19;.4 „11 .! Paradise Appraisals, LLC ■ Standards of Professional Practice -Appraisal Institute, passed May 1999. ■ Basic Income Capitalization Course 510 -Appraisal Institute, passed in August 1993. ■ Seminar on new URAR form - Appraisal Institute, 1993. } Uniform Standards of Professional Practice Parts A&B - Appraisal Institute (Honolulu), passed in April 1994. ■ Highest & Best Use and Market Analysis, Appraisal Institute, passed in 1997. ■ Advance Sales Comparison & Cost Approaches Course 530 - Appraisal Institute, passed in December 1998. ■ Uniform Standards of Professional Practice Part C - Appraisal Institute (Honolulu), passed in 1999 and 2001. ■ Appraisal Institute's Course I1550 - Advanced Applications (State Code: 01-037), at the University of San Diego, July 2003. ■ Appraisal Institute's Course 04 097 - Reappraising, Readdressing, Reassigning: What to Do and Why and What to Include in a Work File. Honolulu, Hawaii October 2004 ■ Appraisal Institute's Course 04-098 - Scope of Work: Where are we now? Honolulu, Hawaii October 2004 ■ 7 Hour USPAP Course - Appraisal Institute -October 2004 ■ Appraisal Institute's Seminar Professional's Guide to the Residential Appl. Report 773 Maui, Hawaii June 2005 ■ Appraisal Institute's Course 11420 - Business Practices and Ethics. Honolulu Hawaii October 2005 ■ Lorman Education Services Eminent Domain Seminar Honolulu, HI May 2006 ■ Appraisal Institute USPAP Update Seminar. Honolulu, HI June 2006. ■ Appraisal Institute -Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions. Chicago, 11• July 2007 ■ Litigation Skills and the Appraiser March 2008. ■ Appraisal Institute Hotel Valuation 2010. ■ Appraisal Institute's Advanced Income Capitalization, 2016. ■ Appraisal Institute's Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal band Acquisition June 2017. ■ USPAP every two years since 1992. ■ Numerous additional courses and seminars. Email: � u I�alliln aii.ru111 Tax ID #48-1293715 It I. Kir,h ltk. tilt 1. [ (.'1 2 til'etrll us('unustkrilal.lndu,L1.11 1 utun.I 11'gd AOtt.l;r..slUi I C.nell-IIJ Prn(sr_rts M11t1din., letittrailtlnmit) I lla;atrua Appraisal Education Transcript April 1, 2022 ,'IIIIpp Not an Official College Transcript If j Institute® Must send actual signed certificate of completion Raymond J. Kirchner, SRA P. 0. Box 550 Kailus Kona, HI 96740 Account #E 85186 This document may not be accepted by all licensing boards as verification of course completion. Please note that the hours reflected below may differ by state. Refer to the specific state matrix for actual state approved hours. .. .Attendance Appraiser's Guide to November 17, Appraisal Institute Hours Completed: 7.0 Expert Witnessing 2021 - February November 17, 15, 2022 2021 Excel Applications for November 3, Appraisal Institute Hours Completed: 8 hours Valuation 2021 - February November 11, 1, 2022 2021 Business Practices and October 26, Hours Completed: 6.0 Ethics (Online) 2021 -January October 27, 24, 2022 2021 Eminent Domain and November 9, On -Demand Online Hours Completed: 7.0 Condemnation 2019 - February Education November 17, 7, 2020 2019 Uniform Appraisal June 15 - 16, Honolulu Country Hours Pass Attended, 14.0 1.0 Standards for Federal 2017 Club, Honolulu, HI Exam Date: Land Acquisitions: June 16, 2017 Practical Applications Business Practices and February 1 - Hours Completed: 5.0 Ethics March 3, 2017 February 13, 2017 General Appraiser November 15 - Hours Completed: 27.0 Income Approach/Part 1 December 30, November 23, 2015 2015 7-Hour National USPAP October 29, Waimea Community Hours Attended 7.0 Update Course 2015 Center, Kamuela, Hl Fall Real Estate October 1, 2015 WA State Hours Attended 7.0 Conference 2015 Convention Center, Seattle, WA Cool Tools: New December 1 - On -Demand Online Hours Completed: 7.0 Technology for Real 31, 2013 Education December 8, Estate Appraisers 2013 Rates and Ratios: December 1 - On -Demand Online Hours Completed: 7.0 Making Sense of GIMs, 31, 2013 Education December 7, OARS, and DCF 2013 Appraisal Curriculum November 15 - Hours Completed: 8.0 Overview - Residential December 15, December 4, 2013 2013 A raisal pp Education Transcript April 1, 2022 Not an Official College Transcript Insidtute` Must send actual signed certificate of completion Real Estate Finance, December 1 - On -Demand Online Hours Completed: 14.0 Statistics, and Valuation 31, 2011 Education December 11, Modeling 2011 Hotel Valuation February 22, Waikiki Hilton Hotel, Hours Attended 7.0 2010 Honolulu, HI The New Residential March 16, 2009 Hilton Waikiki Prince Hours Attended 3.0 Market Conditions Form Kuhio Hotel, (P-M.) Honolulu, HI Proposed Interagency March 16, 2009 Waikiki Hilton Hotel, Hours Attended 4.0 Appraisal & Eva[ Honolulu, HI GuidelineslHVCC Analyzing Distressed December 15, On -Demand Online Hours Completed: 4.0 Real Estate 2008 - January Education December 26, 14, 2009 2008 What Clients Would Like April 1, 2008 Hilton Waikiki Prince Hours Attended 7.0 Their Appraisers to Kuhio Hotel, Know Honolulu, HI Litigation Skills for the March 31, 2008 Hilton Waikiki Prince Hours Attended 7.0 Appraiser Kuhio Hotel, Honolulu, HI Business Practices and December 4, Hilton Waikiki Prince Hours Pass Attended, 7.0 1.0 Ethics 2007 Kuhio Hotel, Exam Date: Honolulu, HI December 4, 2007 7-Hour National USPAP December 3, Hilton Waikiki Prince Hours Attended 7.0 Update Course 2007 Kuhio Hotel, Honolulu, HI Uniform Appraisal July 12 - 13, Chicago Chapter, Hours Attended 16.0 Standards for Federal 2007 Chicago, IL Land Acquisitions: Practical Applications 7-Hour National USPAP July 20, 2006 Ilikai Hotel, Hours Attended 7.0 Update Course Honolulu, HI Business Practices and October 20, Renaissance Llikai Hours Pass Attended, 7.0 1.0 Ethics 2005 Hotel, Honolulu, HI Exam Date: October 20, 2005 Professional's Guide to June 9, 2005 Maui, Maui, HI Hours Attended 7.0 the Uniform Residential Appl. Report Scope of Work - Where October 15, -, Honolulu, HI Hours Attended 4.0 Are We Now? 2004 7-Hour National USPAP October 14, -, Honolulu, HI Hours Attended 7.0 Update Course 2004 I Appraisal Education Transcript April 1, 2022 II IIII�I Not an Official College Transcript I�l� Institute,Must send actual signed certificate of completion Advanced Applications July 20 - 26. University of San Hours Pass Attended, 36.0 4.0 2003 Diego-, San Diego, Exam Date: CA July 26, 2003 Real Estate Disclosure October 11, Waikiki Beach Hours Attended 7.0 2001 Marriott Resort, Honolulu, HI Real Estate Fraud: The October 10, Waikiki Beach Hours Attended 7.0 Appr. Responsibilities & 2001 Marriott Resort, Liabilities Honolulu, HI Standards of Prof. May 24 - 25, Waikiki Beach Hours Pass Attended, 15.0 1.0 Practice, Part C 2001 Marriott Resort, Exam Date: Honolulu, HI May 25, 2001 FHA and the Appraisal September 27, Hawaiian Regent Hours Attended 7.0 Process 1999 Hotel, Honolulu, HI Standards of Prof. May 17 -18, Hawaiian Regent Hours Pass Attended, 15.0 1.0 Practice, Part C 1999 Hotel, Honolulu, HI Exam Date: May 18, 1999 Advanced Sales November 9 - University of Hours Pass Attended, 36.0 4.0 Comparison & Cost 14, 1998 Phoenix, Murray, UT Exam Date: Approaches November 14, 1998 Highest & Best Use and September 14 - Arizona State Hours Pass Attended, 36.0 4.0 Market Analysis 20, 1997 University, Tempe, Exam Date: AZ September 20, 1997 Standards of April 8 - 9, 1994 Ilikai Hotel, Hours Pass Attended, 10.0 1.0 Professional Practice, Honolulu, HI Exam Date: Part B April 9, 1994 Standards of April 6 - 7, 1994 flikai Hotel, Hours Pass Attended, 15.0 1.0 Professional Practice, Honolulu, Hl Exam Date: Part A (USPAP) April 7, 1994 The New Uniform November 6, Ilikai Hotel, Hours Attended 7.0 Residential Appraisal 1993 Honolulu, HI Report Appraisal, General October 8, 1993 Continuing Hours Attended 4.0 Education, Hawaii, HI Advanced Income August 15 - 21, Nolte Center, Hours Pass Attended, 36.0 4.0 Capitalization 1993 University of Exam Date: Minnesota, August 21, Minneapolis, MN 1993 Basic Income August 8 -14, Nolte Center, Hours Pass Attended, 36.0 3.0 Capitalization 1993 University of Exam Date: Minnesota, August 14, Minneapolis, MN 1993 Professional Practice December 14, Continuing Hours Pass Attended, 7.0 0.0 1989 Education, Exam Date: Minnesota, MN December 14, 1989 II Appraisal Education Transcript Institute" Not an Official College Transcript ® Must send actual signed cerliflcate of completion Recert 126 January 1 - University of Florida, Hours December 31, Gainesville, FL 1988 Residential Valuation August 1 - 6, North Star Chapter, Hours 1987 St. Paul, MN Introduction to April 8 - June 8, St. Paul Hotel, St. Hours Appraising Real 1985 Paul, MN Property April 1, 2022 Pass Attended, 1.0 0.0 Exam Date: December 31, 1988 Pass Attended, 36.0 3.0 Exam Date: August 6, 1987 Pass Attended, 45.0 0.0 Exam Date: June 8, 1985