Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-10-25 The Kikala Keokea Homestead Hui Testimony From:Folsom W To:WPCtestimony Subject:Kikala Keokea Homestead Testimony Use Permit Application (PL-USE-2024-000028) Date:Friday, October 25, 2024 9:51:59 AM Attachments:Kikala Keokea Testimony.pdf Aloha Windward Planning Commission, Please find attached Kikala Keokea Homestead Hui testimony regarding Use Permit Application (PL-USE-2024- 000028). Thanks for your time and consideration. Uftujnpoz!Sfhbsejoh!Mboe!Vtf!Qfsnju!QM.VTF.3135.111139!)UNL!4.2.3.118.145* Qmfbtf!opuf;!Opujdf!pg!uijt!qspqptbm!xbt!tfou!po!Pdupcfs!8ui!boe!sfdfjwfe!po!Pdupcfs!22-!xijdi!hbwf!uif!mpdbm!dpnnvojuz!pomz! 23!xpsljoh!ebzt!up!voefstuboe!uif!qspkfdu-!up!sfrvftu-!sfdfjwf!boe!sfwjfx!bqqmjdbujpo!epdvnfout!gspn!uif!Qmboojoh!Efqbsunfou-! up!fevdbuf!uifntfmwft!po!uif!mbshfs!dpoufyu!pg!tvdi!b!qspqptbm!boe!up!qspwjef!xsjuufo!uftujnpoz/!!Xf!ivncmz!sfrvftu!uibu!zpv! hjwf!bmm!dpnnvojuz!uftujnpoz!uif!dpvsuftz!pg!zpvs!gvmm!buufoujpo!boe!gbjs!dpotjefsbujpo/ Wjfx!gspn!qspqfsuz!jnnfejbufmz!bekbdfou!up!qspqptfe!dfmm!upxfs Uif!qspqptfe!ufmfdpnnvojdbujpot!jotubmmbujpo!xjui!261!gppu!upxfs-!uxp!tfqbsbuf!ejftfm!hfofsbupst!)41Lx! '!59Lx*!boe!3-991!trvbsf!gppu!dpodsfuf!frvjqnfou!qbe!bmmpxjoh!gps!uxp!npsf!hfofsbupst-!foubjmt!bo! pwfsbmm!joevtusjbm!gppuqsjou!gbs!mbshfs!uibo!boz!puifs!jotubmmbujpo!jo!uif!sfhjpo/!!Xjuipvu!rvftujpo-!ju!jt! hpjoh!up!ibwf!b!esbnbujd!boe!ejtqspqpsujpobufmz!ofhbujwf!jnqbdu!po!uijt!jnnfejbuf!bsfb!cz!voefsnjojoh! uif!joifsfou!usborvjmjuz!boe!sbx!obuvsbm!cfbvuz!pg!xibu!uif!Qmboojoh!Efqbsunfou!ibt!sfdphoj{fe!jt!b! Æobuvsbm!cfbvuz!bsfb/Ç!!Bqqspwbm!pg!uif!gvmm!tdpqf!pg!uijt!qspkfdu-!bt!qspqptfe-!xpvme!cf!bo!vogfuufsfe! bcvtf!up!uif!dibsbdufs!pg!uijt!qsjtujof!bsfb-!up!uif!vojrvf!obuvsbm!ibcjubu!pg!gpvs!uisfbufofe!boe!foebohfsfe! tqfdjft-!up!uif!bekbdfou!qspqfsuz!pxofst!boe!up!uif!mpdbm!dpnnvojuz/ Xf!bqqsfdjbuf!uif!dpnqmfyjuz!pg!dpotjefsjoh!uif!esjwf!gps!foibodfe!jogsbtusvduvsf!jo!cbmbodf!xjui!uif! qvcmjd!hppe!boe!sftqpotjcmf!tufxbsetijq!pg!pvs!obuvsbm!sftpvsdft/!!Sftqfdugvmmz-!xf!bmtp!jnbhjof!zpv!bsf! vobxbsf!uibu!uijt!dfmm!upxfs!qspkfdu-!bt!qspqptfe-!sjtlt!tfwfsfmz!ebnbhjoh!pof!pg!uif!nptu!cfbvujgvm! mpdbujpot!po!IbxbjjÉt!tpvuifbtufso!dpbtumjof/!!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!fybhhfsbujpo/!!Uijt!mpdbujpo!tuboet!pvu!cz!gps! juÉt!votvmmjfe!sbx!cfbvuz!xjui!b!Obuvsbm!Gpsftu!Sftfswf!bcvuujoh!voefwfmpqfe!tubuf!mboe!Ñmmfe!xjui!ifbmuiz! Pijb!gpsftu!bmm!uif!xbz!up!bo!voefwfmpqfe!dpbtumjof-!xifsf!zpv!dbo!tff!boe!ifbs!uif!xbwft!dsbtijoh!po! uif!spdlt!ofbsmz!uxp!njmft!bxbz/!!Gsjfoet!gspn!bmm!pwfs!uif!tubuf!dpnf!ifsf!boe!bsf!cmpxo!bxbz!cz!uif! cfbvuz!boe!tfsfojuz!pg!uijt!mpdbujpo/!!Mpdbmt-!xipÉwf!mjwfe!ifsf!tjodf!cjsui!bsf!tp!tvsqsjtfe!up!Ñoe!uibu!uijt! tqpu!fwfo!fyjtut!boe-!voqspnqufe-!uifz!sfhvmbsmz!tbz!uijt!jt!uifjs!gbwpsjuf!mpdbujpo!po!uif!jtmboe/!!Kvtu!mbtu! xffl-!b!gsjfoe!wjtjufe!boe-!xjuipvu!lopxjoh!mpdbm!nbslfu!wbmvft-!tbje!if!bttvnfe!tpnf!pg!uif!qspqfsujft! ejsfdumz!bekbdfou!up!uif!qspqptfe!upxfs!nvtu!cf!xpsui!%6!njmmjpo-!cbtfe!po!uif!wjfxt!boe!uif!qfbdfgvmoftt! bmpof/!!Op!kplf/!!Xf!lopx!uifsf!jt!b!dpnnpo!obssbujwf!pg!efojhsbujoh!mpxfs!Qvob!uibu!nblft!ju! qtzdipmphjdbmmz!fbtz!up!efwbmvf!uijt!sfhjpo!cvu!opuijoh!upqt!uif!cfbvuz!boe!qfbdf!pg!uijt!qmbdf/!!Bmpoh! xjui!uif!txffqjoh!wjfxt!cpui!nblbj!boe!nbvlb-!uif!njdsp.dmjnbuf!ifsf!jt!wfsz!ejggfsfou!gspn!kvtu!2!njmf! vq!uif!spbe!boe!3!njmft!epxo!uif!spbe/!!!Xifsf!pof!jt!upp!xfu!boe!uif!puifs!jt!upp!ipu-!uijt!bsfb!jt!tp!pgufo! kvtu!sjhiu/!!Xifsf!pof!jt!cbljoh!xjui!op!xjoe!boe!uif!puifs!jt!tpdlfe!jo!efotf!dmpve!dpwfs-!uijt!tqfdjÑd! bsfb!tp!pgufo!ibt!b!qfsgfdu!cbmbodf!pg!tvo!boe!usbef!xjoet/!!Bu!ojhiu-!uifsf!jt!tp!mjuumf!mjhiu!qpmmvujpo!uibu! uif!Njmlz!Xbz!qsbdujdbmmz!kvnqt!pvu!pg!uif!tlz!boe!ju!jt!tp!rvjfu!uibu!xf!dbo!ifbs!uif!dbmmt!pg!uif!mpdbm! tifbsxbufs!boe!uif!Qvfp-!xjui!xbwft!dsbtijoh!jo!uif!cbdlhspvoe/!! Xiz!sjtl!ebnbhjoh!uijt!cfbvuz!boe!usborvjmjuz!gps!b!mfwfm!pg!dfmm!dpwfsbhf!uibu!jt!opu!offefe@ Dpwfsbhf!'!Dpmmpdbujpo/ Jo!uifjs!bqqmjdbujpo-!uif!bqqmjdbou!dmbjnt!uifsf!jt!dvssfoumz!op!dpwfsbhf!jo!cpui!uijt!bsfb!boe!jo!uif!ofbscz! Tfbwjfx!Ftubuft!bsfb/!!Uifz!dmbjn!uibu!Æsftjefout!nvtu!xbml!ps!qbsl!jo!gspou!pg!uif!DPXt!up!qmbdf!dbmmt!ps! vtf!ju!gps!cspbecboe!tfswjdft/Ç!!Uijt!jt!gbmtf!po!bmm!uisff!dpvout/!!Nboz!zfbst!bhp!uijt!bddpvou!nbz!ibwf! cffo!usvf-!cvu!opu!gps!b!wfsz!mpoh!ujnf/!!Tfswjdf!jo!Tfbwjfx!jt!tuspoh!boe!xf!dbo!qfstpobmmz!buuftu!uibu! tuvefout!bsf!opu!bu!bmm!efqsjwfe!jo!uif!xbz!uif!bqqmjdbou!eftdsjcft/!!BU'U!dvssfoumz!tfswft!cpui!uiftf! bsfbt!xjui!nvmujqmf!pwfsmbqqjoh!dfmmt!mpdbufe!bu!tjuft!xjui!joevtusjbm!gppuqsjout!bu!b!tnbmm!gsbdujpo!pg!uif! bqqmjdbouÉt!qspqptfe!tdbmf/!!Gjfme!uftujoh!uijt!tusfudi!pg!Ixz!241!tipxt!befrvbuf!efdjcfm!sfbejoht!boe! {fsp!espqqfe!dbmmt!jo!uif!5!njmft!cfuxffo!uif!uxp!fyjtujoh!upxfs!tjuft/!!Xf!dbo!sfbejmz!tusfbn!IE!wjefp! dpoufou!jo!uijt!bsfb!boe!tfswjdf!jt!fwfo!tuspohfs!bu!Tfbwjfx!Ftubuft/!!Uif!dmbjn!pg!ÆOPÇ!tfswjdf!tipvme!cf! opu!cf!bddfqufe!po!jut!gbdf/!!Xf!voefstuboe!uibu!Qmboojoh!sfmjft!po!Sfofhbef!UpxfstÉ!dpwfsbhf!nbq!cvu! uifz!nvtu!opu!cf!jodmvejoh!BU'UÉt!dpwfsbhf-!xijdi!xpvme!sfÒfdu!xibu!Wfsj{po!upp!dbo!bdijfwf!xjui!uif! fyjtujoh!upxfs!gppuqsjou/!!Dpmmpdbujoh!uifjs!frvjqnfou!xjui!fyjtujoh!upxfst!jt!b!wjbcmf!tpmvujpo!gps!cpui! Wfsj{po!boe!U.Npcjmf/!!Uijt!jt!tvqqpsufe!cz!uif!gbdu!uibu!Wfsj{po!boe!U.npcjmf!vtf!uif!tbnf!mpx! gsfrvfodz!tjhobm!bt!BU'U!)811!NI{*-!xijdi!dbo!usbwfm!bt!nvdi!bt!36!njmft/!!Jo!gbdu-!U.npcjmfÉt! gsfrvfodz!jt!mpxfs!)711!NI{*!xijdi!dbo!usbwfm!gvsuifs!boe!npsf!sfbejmz!qbtt!uispvhi!pctusvdujpot/!! Hjwfo!uif!bsfbÉt!mpx!qpqvmbujpo!efotjuz-!njojnbm!ofuxpsl!efnboe!boe!uif!bdujwf!sftusjdujpot!po!ofx!mpdbm! efwfmpqnfou-!uiftf!dbssjfst!tipvme!cf!sfrvjsfe!up!cvjme!pvu!uifjs!jogsbtusvduvsf!uispvhi!dpmmpdbujoh!uifjs! frvjqnfou!bu!fyjtujoh!dfmm!upxfst!uibu!qspwjef!wjbcmf!pqujpot!xfmm!xjuijo!uif!usbotnjttjpo!dbqbcjmjujft!pg! uifjs!tuboebse!frvjqnfou/ Uif!upxfs!uibu!cftu!tfswft!uijt!jnnfejbuf!bsfb!jt!mpdbufe!uxp!njmft!vq!uif!spbe!po!b!mbshf!joevtusjbm.vtf! usbdu!xjui!op!jnnfejbuf!sftjefoujbm!ofjhicpst!)UNL!4.24.112.118*/!!Uibu!upxfs!jt!nvdi!tnbmmfs!bu!pomz! 211É!ubmm-!xjui!bo!frvjqnfou!cbtf!pof!ufoui!uif!tj{f!pg!uif!qspqptfe!pof-!zfu!tujmm!nbobhft!up!qspwjef! tvgÑdjfou!dpwfsbhf!gps!uiptf!xip!mjwf-!xpsl!boe!wjtju!jo!uif!bsfb!bt!xfmm!bt!gps!Ñstu!sftqpoefst/!!Cfdbvtf!ju! xbt!xfmm.qmbdfe-!uif!dpnnvojuz!xfmdpnfe!uibu!qspkfdu/!Ubljoh!bewboubhf!pg!uibu!fyjtujoh!tjuf!xpvme!cf! hppe!qmboojoh!bt!ju!qspwjeft!uif!sfrvftufe!dpwfsbhf!pqqpsuvojuz!xijmf!hfofsbujoh!wjsuvbmmz!op!efmfufsjpvt! jnqbdut!po!uif!dpnnvojuz!ps!po!uijt!sfdphoj{fe!Æobuvsbm!cfbvuz!bsfbÇ!xijmf!bmtp!jnqptjoh!op! voofdfttbsz!jnqbdut!po!uif!gpvs!epdvnfoufe!foebohfsfe!tqfdjft!uibu!joibcju!uif!qspqptfe!qspkfdu!bsfb/ Bftuifujdt!'!Efdjtjpot!Cbtfe!po!Gbjs!boe!Usvf!Nfusjdt/! Qmboojoh!Efqbsunfou!tubgg!ibwf!tbje!uibu!uif!qspkfdu!bsfb!jt!b!Æobuvsbm!cfbvuz!bsfbÇ!xijdi!jt!xiz!uif! Qmboojoh!Ejsfdups!sfdpnnfoefe!bqqspwbm!pg!uijt!bqqmjdbujpo!pomz!bgufs!sfrvftujoh!uibu!uif!upxfs!cf!b! sfmpdbufe!bxbz!gspn!uif!ijhixbz!jo!psefs!up!qspufdu!uif!wjfx/!!Uijt!sfrvftu!ftubcmjtife!cpui!uif! jnqpsubodf!pg!uif!Æobuvsbm!cfbvuz!bsfbÇ!boe!uibu!bftuifujdt!nbuufs/!!Ju!bmtp!ftubcmjtife!uibu!uif!qspqptfe! upxfs!epft!opu!dpnqpsu!xjui!uiptf!bftuifujdt/!! Jg!b!qsfdfefou!ibt!cffo!tfu!pg!qspufdujoh!bftuifujdt!po!cfibmg!pg!qbttjoh!npupsjtut-!uifo!uiptf!tbnf! qspufdujpot!tipvme!fyufoe!up!uif!qspqfsuz!pxofst!xip!tqfoe!gbs!mpohfs!qfsjpet!pg!ujnf!bu!uibu!qsfdjtf! mpdbujpo!boe!xip!ibwf!jowftufe!dpotjefsbcmf!sftpvsdft!jo!psefs!up!gvmmz!fokpz!ju/!!!Uif!jefb!uibu!qspqfsuz! pxofst!tipvme!cf!sfrvjsfe!up!mppl!bxbz!jg!uifz!xbou!up!fokpz!uifjs!wjfx!tjnqmz!epftoÉu!tuboe!up!sfbtpo/!! Cfmpx!bsf!wjfxt!mppljoh!tpvuixftu!boe!nbvlb!xifsf!uif!upxfs!xpvme!mppn!gbs!bcpwf!uif!dbopqz-! spvhimz!61&!ubmmfs!uibo!uif!ubmmftu!Opsgpml!qjof!uibu!bmsfbez!sjtft!gbs!bcpwf!uif!fwfszuijoh!fmtf/ Uijt!wjfx!jt!gspn!bqqspyjnbufmz!36É!fmfwbujpo!tipxjoh!uif!esbnbujd!jnqbdu!b!261É!upxfs!xpvme!ibwf!po!uif!wjfx! tife!boe!uibu!uif!upqphsbqiz!epft!opu!sfrvjsf!tvdi!b!ijhi!upxfs!gps!mjof!pg!tjhiu!tusfudijoh!gps!njmft/ Qmboojoh!tubgg!bmtp!tbje!uibu!uif!Qmboojoh!EjsfdupsÉt!sfdpnnfoebujpo!up!bqqspwf!uif!bqqmjdbujpo!xbt! mbshfmz!cbtfe!po!qipup.tjnvmbujpot!qspwjefe!cz!uif!bqqmjdbou/!!Vqpo!sfwjfx!pg!uiptf!qipup.tjnvmbujpot-!ju! fwjefou!uibu!uifz!fnqmpzfe!b!xjef!bohmf!mfot!uibu!bsujÑdjbmmz!ejtupsut!boe!gpsftipsufot!uif!tj{f!pg!ejtubou! pckfdut-!ftqfdjbmmz!jo!sfmbujpo!up!gpsfhspvoe!pckfdut/!!Uif!oblfe!ivnbo!fzft!tfft!uispvhi!b!sfmbujwf!gpdbm! mfohui!pg!54nn/!!!SfofhbefÉt!mfot!dipjdf!xbt!spvhimz!ibmg!uibu-!bt!fwjefodfe!cz!uif!ufmmubmf!tjhot!jo! qbsbmmby!tijgu-!sfmbujwf!tqbdjoh!cfuxffo!ufmfqipof!qpmft!pwfs!ejtubodf!boe!fwfo!uif!sbqje!jodsfbtf!jo!spbe! qbjou!tj{f!po!bqqspbdi!up!uif!mpxfs!dbnfsb!qptjujpo!jo!Æwjfxqpjou!4Ç/!!Jo!wjfxqpjou!4-!xifsf!uif! gpsfhspvoe!usfft!xfsf!mpxfs-!uijt!tj{f!ejnjojtijoh!fggfdu!xbt!nbhojÑfe!cz!2*!mpxfsjoh!uif!mfot!up!nblf! uif!cbdlhspvoe!pckfdu!bqqfbs!tnbmmfs!jo!sfmbujpo!up!uif!gpsfhspvoe-!3*!!vtjoh!b!wfsujdbm!btqfdu!sbujp!up! nblf!wfsujdbm!fmfnfout!bqqfbs!mftt!dpotqjdvpvt!jo!sfmbujpo!up!uif!fnquz!tlz!bcpwf!boe!4*!gsbnjoh!uif! jnbhf!tp!uif!uif!qspqptfe!upxfs!xbt!qmbdfe!tp!gbs!pgg!up!uif!fehf!uibu!pof!dpvme!fbtjmz!bshvf!uibu!ju! xbtoÉu!fwfo!jodmvefe/! Ju!tipvme!bmtp!cf!opufe!uibu!nvdi!pg!uif!gpsfhspvoe!usfft!bmpoh!uif!ixz!bsf!dpoujovbmmz!tvddvncjoh!up! Sbqje!Pijb!Efbui!tp!uibu!qspufdujwf!tdsffo!nbz!opu!cf!uifsf!jo!uif!opu!upp!ejtubou!gvuvsf/!!Bt!ju!jt-!uif! qspqptfe!261!gppu!upxfs!xpvme!cf!ofbsmz!4!ujnft!ijhifs!uibu!uif!hfofsbm!dbopqz!jo!uif!bsfb-!3y!ijhifs! uibo!nptu!pg!uif!ubmmftu!usfft!boe!61&!ubmmfs!uibo!uif!wfsz!ubmmftu!Opsgpml!qjof/!!Up!voefstuboe!ipx!uijt! xpvme!mppl!gspn!uif!bekbdfou!tvcejwjtjpo-!xf!qmbdfe!b!espof!pwfs!uif!qspqptfe!upxfs!tjuf!bu!fybdumz!261! gffu!ijhi!)tff!cfmpx*/!!Bqpmphjft!gps!uif!qpps!sfoefsjoh!cvu!ujnf!xbt!mjnjufe/!!Uif!ifjhiu!jt!bddvsbuf!cvu! uif!upxfs!xpvme!mjlfmz!bqqfbs!mbshfs!tjodf!uif!qspqptfe!upxfs!cbtf!xpvme!cf!pomz!411!gffu!bxbz!gspn!uif! cpz!tuboejoh!uifsf/! Xifo!uif!bqqmjdbou!qspqptfe!uijt!mpdbujpo!up!Wfsj{po-!eje!uifz!tubsu!xjui!261É@!!Hjwfo!uibu!BU'U!jt!bcmf! up!qspwjef!tfswjdf!xjui!b!211É!upxfs-!jt!ju!qpttjcmf!uibu!Wfsj{po!xpvme!ibwf!bhsffe!up!uijt!qspkfdu!jg!b!211É! upxfs!xfsf!qspqptfe@! JuÉt!bmtp!jnqpsubou!up!opuf!uibu!uif!qspkfdu!bmmpxt!gps!uif!beejujpo!pg!uxp!npsf!dbssjfst!xijdi!xjmm!opu!cf! tvckfdu!up!sfwjfx-!tp!b!npsf!sftqpotjcmf!wjtvbm!jnqbdu!bttfttnfou!xpvme!cf!cbtfe!po!qipup.tjnvmbujpot! uibu!jodmvef!uif!beejujpobm!qbofmt!gspn!uiptf!gvuvsf!dbssjfst-!bo!fggfdujwf!epvcmjoh!pg!upxfs!frvjqnfou/!!! Jg!zpv!dboopu!Ñoe!zpvs!xbz!up!dpmmpdbujoh!uijt!frvjqnfou!fmtfxifsf!jo!pefs!up!qspufdu!uiftf!vojrvf! obuvsbm!sftpvsdft!boe!mpdbm!qspqfsuz!pxofst!sjhiut; Vtf!b!ÈnpopqjofÉ!qpmf!bt!bftuifujd!dbnpvÒbhf!jotufbe!pg!uif!qspqptfe!npopqpmf/ Sfevdf!ifjhiu/!!Jg!uif!211É!npopqjof!3!njmft!vq!uif!spbe!qspwjeft!tfswjdf!ifsf!uifo!b! 211É!npopqjof!bu!uijt!mpdbujpo!tipvme!cf!npsf!uibo!tvgÑdjfou/ Jnnfejbufmz!vqpo!bqqspwbm!cfhjo!qmboujoh!b!ubmm!mboetdbqf!tdsffo!up!njujhbuf!uif!wjtvbm! jnqbdu!po!uif!bekbdfou!tvcejwjtjpo )Ju!tipvme!cf!opufe!uibu!uif!bqqmjdbou!dvssfoumz!dmbjnt!uibu!261É!jt!upp!ubmm!gps!b!npopqjof! ifsf!zfu!uifz!sfrvftufe!qfsnju!gps!b!266É!npopqjof!kvtu!bdsptt!uif!spbe!)VTF!2:.1118:*/! Tbnf!mpdbujpo-!tbnf!fohjoffsjoh!jttvft/!Uif!Lbvnbob!qspkfdu!xbt!bqqspwfe!bt!b!2:1É! npopqjof/!!Opofuifmftt-!hjwfo!uif!upqphsbqiz!boe!mpx!mzjoh!usff!dpwfs-!211É!ifjhiu! tipvme!cf!npsf!uibo!befrvbuf!up!bdijfwf!uifjs!tubufe!dpwfsbhf!hpbmt/!Jg!uif!bqqmjdbou!gffmt! cfuufs!xjui!uif!fohjoffsjoh!bu!211É!uifo!bmm!uif!cfuufs/* Foebohfsfe!Tqfdjft/! Jo!uifjs!Obuvsbm!Sftpvsdf!Bttfttnfou-!uif!bqqmjdbou!bqqfbst!up!dmbjn!uibu!Æop!lopxo!qspqptfe!ps!mjtufe! uisfbufofe!ps!foebohfsfe!tqfdjft!bsf!dvssfoumz!lopxo!up!sftjef!xjuijo!uif!qspkfdu!bsfb/!!Uijt!xbt!cbtfe!po! uifjs!sfwjfx!pg!uif!V/T/!Gjti!boe!Xjmemjgf!ebubcbtf!boe!uifjs!pctfswbujpot!evsjoh!b!ebzujnf!Æxbml.uispvhi! tvswfzÇ/!!!Uif!qspcmfnt!xjui!uijt!bttfttnfou!bsf!bt!gpmmpxt; ¦Foebohfsfe!tqfdjft!bsf!hfofsbmmz!sbsf!boe!uifsfgpsf!opu!mjlfmz!up!kvtu!qpq!vq!po!b!rvjdl!tvswfz/ ¦Nvmujqmf!qffs.sfwjfxfe!tuvejft!epdvnfou!uif!qsftfodf!pg!uif!uif!OfxfmmÉt!tifbsxbufs!boe!uif! Ibxbjjbo!Ipbsz!Cbu!jo!uijt!bsfb/!)2-!3-!4* ¦Uif!bqqmjdbouÉt!tipsu!pctfswbujpobm!tvswfz!xbt!evsjoh!ebzmjhiu!ipvst!boe!cpui!uiftf!bojnbmtÉ! epdvnfoufe!bdujwjujft!bsf!opduvsobm!xijdi!EMO!opufe!nblft!dpotfswbujpo!ebub!ejgÑdvmu!up!buubjo/ ¦Ibxbjj!Ibxlt!bsf!tffo!ifsf!fwfszebz!zfbs!spvoe!boe!uifjs!qsftfodf!jo!uif!bsfb!cffo!mpoh! epdvnfoufe/!)2-!3-!4*/!!Uifz!nbuf!ifsf!boe!uifz!oftu!sjhiu!ifsf!jo!uif!ubmmftu!usfft!pg!uijt!qsfdjtf! bsfb/!!XfÉwf!xbudife!nvmujqmf!hfofsbujpot!hspx!vq!ifsf/! ¦Uif!Qvfp-!Ibxbjjbo!Pxm-!jt!dpnnpomz!tffo!ifsf!jo!uif!fwfojoht-!pgufo!kvtu!b!gfx!ivoesfe!gffu! gspn!uif!cbtf!pg!uif!qspqptfe!upxfs!)2-!3-!4*/ Up!cf!gbjs!uif!bqqmjdbou!epft!opuf!uibu!uif!Ibxbjjbo!Ibxl!jt!dpotjefsfe!bo!foebohfsfe!tqfdjft-!uifz! bdlopxmfehf!uibu!uifz!tbx!pof!boe!uifz!gvsuifs!bdlopxmfehf-!!ÆJu!jt!b!qpttjcjmjuz!uibu!ibxlt!nbz!vujmj{f! uif!ubmmfs!usfft!xjuijo!uif!qspkfdu!bsfb!gps!spptujoh!ps!oftujoh/Ç!!Uifz!sfdpnnfoe!b!cjpmphjdbm!tvswfz!21! ebzt!qsjps!up!dpotusvdujpo!cvu!xibu!fybdumz!xjmm!uijt!bdijfwf!tp!gfx!ebzt!cfgpsf!csfbljoh!hspvoe@!! Jo!sfgfsfodf!up!uif!tifbsxbufs-!uif!bqqmjdbou!bmtp!bdlopxmfehft!uibu-!ÆDpmmjtjpo!xjui!nbo.nbef!tusvduvsft! jt!dpotjefsfe!uif!tfdpoe!nptu!tjhojÑdbou!dbvtf!pg!npsubmjuz!pg!uiftf!tfbcjse!tqfdjft!jo!IbxbjÈj/Ç!!Xf! lopx!uif!tifbsxbufs!bsf!ifsf!cfdbvtf!xfÉwf!ifbse!uifjs!dbmm!bu!ojhiu/!!Uif!tifbsxbufs!jt!vojrvf!ifsf! cfdbvtf!uijt!Òjhiu!dpssjeps!sfqsftfout!jut!Ñstu!fwfs!Òfehmjoh!Òjhiu!gspn!uif!oftu!up!uif!pdfbo/!!Qmbdjoh!b! upxfs!jo!uif!Òjhiu!qbui!pg!uijt!Òfehmjoh!kvtu!mfbsojoh!up!Òz!dpvme!mjlfmz!mfbe!up!ljmmjoh!uiftf!cbcjft!cfgpsf! uifz!fwfo!ibwf!b!dibodf!up!hfu!ftubcmjtife/!!B!261É-!uijt!upxfs!xpvme!cf!fbtjmz!uxjdf!uif!ifjhiu!pg! bozuijoh!fmtf!bspvoe!ju-!dsfbujoh!b!vojrvf!pctubdmf!xifsf!jotujodu!nbz!opu!fyqfdu!pof/!!Uif!Foebohfsfe! Tqfdjft!Bdu!)FTB*-!27!V/T/D/!¥!2642!fu!tfr/-!tbzt!ju!jt!qspijcjufe!up!kfpqbsej{f!uif!dpoujovfe!fyjtufodf!pg! boz!foebohfsfe!ps!uisfbufofe!tqfdjft!boe!dfmm!upxfs!bqqmjdbout!nvtu!efufsnjof!xifuifs!boz!qspqptfe! gbdjmjuz!nbz!bggfdu!mjtufe-!uisfbufofe!ps!foebohfsfe!tqfdjft!ps!eftjhobufe!dsjujdbm!ibcjubut/!Xf!voefstuboe! uibu!uif!ufmfdpnnvojdbujpot!joevtusz!Ñoet!jut!xbz!bspvoe!uiftf!qftlz!qspufdujpot!boe!uibu!VTGXT!boe! EGBX!pggfs!Æcftu!nbobhfnfou!qsbdujdftÇ!jo!ufsnt!pg!njujhbujpo!cvu!dpotpmjebujoh!uiftf!gbdjmjujft!uispvhi! dpmmpdbujpo!bu!fyjtujoh!tjuft!xpvme!op!epvcu!cf!bo!fwfo!cfuufs!nbobhfnfou!qsbdujdf/!!XfÉwf!tqplfo!xjui! VTGXT!qfstpoofm!xip!bhsff/!!Bopuifs!wpuf!gps!dpmmpdbujpo/ Jg!dpmmpdbujpo!jt!effnfe!vobddfqubcmf-!xf!tuspohmz!sfrvftu!uif!gpmmpxjoh!nfbtvsft; Sfevdf!upxfs!ifjhiuup!op!npsf!uibo!41&!bcpwf!uif!hfofsbm!dbopqz/ Cbu!tbgf!xjsf!po!tfdvsjuz!gfodf Sftusjdu!bmm!mjhiu!Ñyuvsf!qptjujpojoh!up!cf!epxodbtu!gspn!31É!nbyjnvn!ifjhiu Tijfme!bmm!mjhiujoh!up!xibu!jt!fttfoujbm!gps!mjhiujoh!pg!hspvoe!frvjqnfou!pomz!jo!psefs!up! fmjnjobuf!bmm!voofdfttbsz!mjhiu!qpmmvujpo/ Ipmmpx!ujmf!xbmm!nfoujpofe!cfmpx!xjmm!bmtp!ifmq!dpoubjo!mjhiu!dpoubnjobujpo Joevtusjbm!Jnqbdu!'!Sjhiu!up!Rvjfu!Fokpznfou Jo!sfwjfxjoh!puifs!dfmm!upxfs!bqqmjdbujpot-!xf!uzqjdbmmz!tff!b!tjohmf!cbdlvq!hfofsbups!jo!uif!41Lx!sbohf/!! Xiz!epft!uijt!pof!ibwf!up!cf!tp!mbshf!xjui!41Lx!boe!!59Lx!hfofsbupst!uibu!xpvme!fbdi!qspevdf!efdjcfmt! fydffejoh!Efqu!pg!Ifbmui!opjtf!psejobodft@!!Jg!dpmpdbufe!pqfsbupst!bsf!vtjoh!uif!tbnf!hsje-!xiz!dboÉu! uifz!tibsf!b!tjohmf!hfofsbups!up!mjnju!cpui!tpvoe!boe!gppuqsjou@!!Xf!voefstuboe!uibu-!jo!uifpsz-!uiftf!bsf! joufsnjuufou!fnfshfodz!cbdlvq!hfofsbupst!cvu!mfuÉt!cf!sfbmjtujd!bcpvu!uif!opupsjpvtmz!votubcmf!mpdbm!hsje! qpxfs!jo!uijt!bsfb!xjui!sfhvmbs!qpxfs!pvubhft!boe!spmmjoh!cmbdlpvut!)2-!3-!4-!5-!6*/!!Uiftf!qspwfo!qbuufsot! xpvme!dbvtf!uiftf!hfofsbupst!up!dpoujovbmmz!uvso!po!boe!pgg!uispvhipvu!uif!ojhiu-!jo!dmptf!qspyjnjuz!up! xfmm!ftubcmjtife!sftjefodft!uibu!ibwf!qvu!bmm!uifjs!tbwjoht!joup!cvjmejoh!uifjs!esfbn!ipnf!jo!b!usvmz!vojrvf! bsfb!tqfdjÑdbmmz!cfdbvtf!ju!jt!pof!pg!uif!npsf!tfsfof!qmbdft!jo!uif!xpsme/!!Uiftf!bsf!dpnnvojuz!nfncfst! tp!dpnnjuufe!up!uijt!mpdbujpo!uibu!uifzÉwf!mbtu!uispvhi!uxp!sfdfou!mbwb!Òpxt-!xijmf!ifmqjoh!up!nbjoubjojoh! uif!mpdbm!fdpopnz!boe!uby!cbtf/!!MfuÉt!bmtp!cf!sfbmjtujd!uibu!gfefsbm!mbx!bvupnbujdbmmz!bmmpxt!gps! dpmmpdbujpo!pg!fwfo!npsf!frvjqnfou!bu!uijt!gbdjmjuz-!boe-!bt!qmboofe-!uxp!npsf!hfofsbupst!gps!uxp!npsf! dbssjfst-!xjui!op!ofx!qfsnju!bqqspwbm!sfrvjsfnfout/!!Uijt!jt!dmfbsmz!joufoefe!up!cf!uif!mbshftu!joevtusjbm! tdbmf!ufmfdpnnvojdbujpot!jotubmmbujpo!jo!uif!foujsf!sfhjpo/!!J!voefstuboe!uibu!Sfofhbef!Upxfst!pxot!uif! mboe!boe!uifz!ibwf!b!tuspoh!fdpopnjd!npujwf!up!tff!uijt!bqqspwfe!cvu!Qmboojoh!nvtu!dpotjefs!uif!foujsf! tqfdusvn!pg!gbdupst!xifo!dpotjefsjoh!cftu!vtf!boe!uif!qvcmjd!hppe/!Cfdbvtf!uifsf!jt!bmsfbez!bo!fggfdujwf! ofuxpsl!vujmj{joh!bo!fggfdujwf!mpdbujpo!po!bo!joevtusjbm!vtf!qspqfsuz-!uif!tdpqf!boe!mpdbujpo!pg!uijt!qspkfdu! bsf!foujsfmz!vokvtujÑfe!boe!dpotujuvuft!bo!fhsfhjpvt!bcvtf!pg!uif!mboe!boe!uif!mpdbm!dpnnvojuz/ Xf!bddfqu!uibu!mpdbm!bvuipsjujft!dboopu!dpotjefs!sbejpmphjdbm!ifbmui!jnqbdut!)eftqjuf!uif!gbdu!uibu-!jo!3132-! uif!V/T/!Dpvsu!pg!Bqqfbmt!gps!uif!Ejtusjdu!pg!Dpmvncjb!Djsdvju!svmfe!uibu!uif!GDD!jt!ofhmjhfou!jo!jhopsjoh! npvoujoh!qffs.sfwjfxfe!sftfbsdi!efnpotusbujoh!ofhbujwf!ifbmui!jnqbdut!gspn!opo.jpoj{joh!njdspxbwf! sbejbujpo!bu!mfwfmt!gbs!cfmpx!uif!GDD!mjnjut*/!!Cvu!uibu!jt!opu!mjdfotf!up!jhopsf!uif!puifs!ifbmui!jnqbdut/!!Up! cf!dmfbs-!uiftf!hfofsbupsÉt!qspevdf!opjtf!bu!mpx.gsfrvfodjft!tipxo!jo!b!hsfbu!nboz!qffs.sfwjfx!tuvejft!up! cf!gbs!npsf!ejtsvqujwf!up!xjmemjgf-!nfoubm!ifbmui-!tmffq!qbuufsot-!tusftt!mfwfmt-!dpsujtpm-!cmppe!qsfttvsf!boe! fwfo!qsfhobodz/!)Jtjoh!I/!fu!bm/!3115<!Jtjoh!I/!boe!Lsvqqb!C/!3115<!Ebojfmttpo!B/!boe!Mboetuspfn!V/! 2:96<!Tdivtu!N/!3115<!Hsbwfo!TO/!3111*/!!Jo!tpnf!nfub!tuvejft-!uif!fggfdut!tipxo!up!cf!fwfo!xpstf!xjui! joufsnjuufou!fyqptvsf/!!Uijt!opjtf-!dpncjofe!xjui!uif!ejftfm!fyibvtu!pg!tvdi!mbshf!hfofsbupst!jo!dmptf! qspyjnjuz!up!epxoxjoe!sftjefodft!xpvme!wjpmbuf!uifjs!sjhiut!up!rvjfu!fokpznfou!bt!xfmm!bt!uif!Tubuf! Efqbsunfou!pg!IfbmuiÉt!ÆPckfdujwf!2;!Bdijfwf!b!usborvjm!boe!ifbmuiz!fowjsponfouÇ/!!!Dpmmpdbujpo!xpvme! fmjnjobuf!uijt!dpoÒjdu/ Uif!tdbmf!pg!uijt!qspkfdu!jt!bo!pofspvt!boe!fydfttjwf!cvsefo!up!qmbdf!po!uijt!dpnnvojuz/!Jg-!ipxfwfs-! dpmmpdbujpo!jt!effnfe!vobddfqubcmf-!xf!vshfoumz!sfrvftu!uif!gpmmpxjoh!nfbtvsft; Sfevdf!tj{f!boe!ovncfs!pg!hfofsbupst Qspwjef!dbcjofut!xjui!ÈMfwfm!JJJÉ!joufsobm!opjtf!tvqqsfttjpo Jotubmm!Foibodfe!Fyibvtu!Tztufnt!vtjoh!sjhiu!bohmft-!bdpvtujd!mpvwfst!boe!tpvoe. bctpscjoh!mjojoht!jo!bjs!evdut!up!tjhojÑdboumz!sfevdf!opjtf!xjuipvu!jnqfejoh!bjsÒpx/ Wjcsbujpo!jtpmbujpo!cfuxffo!nbkps!dpnqpofout 9!gppu!ipmmpx!ujmf!po!uif!uisff!tjeft!pg!uif!frvjqnfou!bsfb-!xjui!uif!tjef!gbdjoh!uif! ijhixbz!sfnbjojoh!pqfo!gps!fbtf!pg!bddftt!boe!fnfshfodz!Ñsf!qsfwfoujpo! XjmeÑsf!Sjtl Uiftf!vonpojupsfe!hfofsbupst!xpvme!qsftfou!b!dpotjefsbcmf!xjme!Ñsf!sjtl!jo!bo!bsfb!uibu!ibt!ibe! vodpouspmmbcmf!xjmeÑsft!uibu!xfsf!pomz!tupqqfe!cz!ijhixbz!qbwfnfou!)uibu!xpvme!pwfs!op!qspufdujpo!jo! uijt!dbtf*/!!Ju!jt!xfmm!lopxo!uibu!bvupnbujdbmmz!usjhhfsfe!ejftfm!cbdlvq!hfofsbupst-!qbsujdvmbsmz!uiptf!vtfe! xjui!dfmm!qipof!upxfst!jo!svsbm!bsfbt-!dbo!qptf!xjmeÑsf!sjtlt-!ftqfdjbmmz!xjui!dpncvtujcmf!gvfm!boe! mvcsjdbout!jo!bo!bsfb!qspof!up!bddfmfsbufe!dpssptjpo/!!Jg!mfblt!pddvs-!uiftf!tvctubodft!dbo!jhojuf!po!ipu! tvsgbdft!mjlf!fyibvtut!boe!nbojgpmet-!xjui!ufnqfsbuvsft!sfbdijoh!649¢D/!!Uxp!vonpojupsfe!hfofsbupst! epvcmf!uibu!sjtl/!!Uif!gfefsbm!mbx!jogfssjoh!qpufoujbm!pg!dpmmpdbujoh!b!upubm!pg!gpvs!hfofsbups!xpvme! rvbesvqmf!uibu!sjtl/!!Bmtp!uifsf!jt!uif!rvftujpo!pg!nbjoufobodf!bspvoe!uijt!vobuufoefe!jotubmmbujpo/!!Xf!bsf! njoegvm!uibu!uif!efbemz!Nbvj!xjmeÑsft!xfsf!dbvtfe!cz!#voefufdufe!sf.fofshj{bujpo!pg!csplfo!vujmjuz!mjoft-! xijdi!dbvtfe!tqbslt!uibu!jhojufe!vonbjoubjofe!wfhfubujpo/Ç!Dpmmpdbujpo!xpvme!up!bo!fyjtujoh!joevtusjbm! tjuf!kvtu!vq!uif!spbe!xpvme!bwpje!uijt!voevf!ib{bse!up!uijt!Æobuvsbm!cfbvuz!bsfbÇ!boe!uif!jnnfejbufmz! bekbdfou!tvcejwjtjpo/ Jg!dpmmpdbujpo!jt!effnfe!vobddfqubcmf-!xf!tuspohmz!sfrvftu!uif!gpmmpxjoh!nfbtvsft; Dpvouz!xbufs!cspvhiu!ejsfdumz!up!uif!tjuf!ps!b!21L!hbmmpo!xbufs!dbudinfou!xjui!qvnq!boe! Ñsf!iptf!ipplvq/!! Xbufs!mjoft!nvtu!cf!pg!nfubm!ps!tjnjmbs!Ñsf!sftjtubou!nbufsjbm!)opu!M0IEQF!iptf!ps!D0 QWD!qjqft/* Nbjoubjo!b!Ñsf!csfbl!tbgfuz!{pof!bspvoe!frvjqnfou!qbe!boe!qpxfs!mjof!dpssjeps!xjui!b! nbjoufobodf!tdifevmf!hvbsbouff!gspn!sftqpotjcmf!qbsuz/!! Ipmmpx!ujmf!xbmm!)bt!bcpwf*!up!foibodf!Ñsfcsfbl Dpoubdu!jogpsnbujpo!pg!sftqpotjcmf!qbsujft!xjui!sbqje!sftqpotf!boe!tivu!epxo!dbqbcjmjujft! gps!fnfshfodjft Tfdvsjuz! Jotubmmjoh!bo!vonpojupsfe!vujmjuz!spbe!tp!dmptf!up!uif!bekbdfou!tvcejwjtjpoÉt!qsjwbuf!dpnnpo!spbe!dsfbuft! votfdvsfe!hsbefe!bddftt!up!uif!foujsf!tvcejwjtjpo!xijdi!jowjuft!b!sf.jouspevdujpo!pg!lopxo!qsfwjpvt! qbuufsot!pg!uifgu-!mppujoh!boe!usftqbttjoh!ivoufst/!!Ju!ibt!ublfo!zfbst!up!tupq!uiftf!qbuufsot/!!Dpmmpdbujpo! xpvme!ifmq!fotvsf!uibu!mpdbm!tfdvsjuz!nfbtvsft!bsf!opu!voefsnjofe/ Jg!dpmmpdbujpo!jt!effnfe!vobddfqubcmf-!xf!tuspohmz!sfrvftu!uif!gpmmpxjoh!nfbtvsft; Tfdvsjuz!gfodjoh!tfqbsbujoh!uif!bddftt!spbe!boe!frvjqnfou!bsfb!gspn!uif!bekbdfou! tvcejwjtjpo/!!Ps!qmbdf!ju!bmpoh!uif!foujsf!qspqfsuz!mjof!cvu!tfu!cbdl!fopvhi!up!bmmpx! qmboufe!mboetdbqf!tdsffojoh/ Qspqfsuz!Wbmvft/!! Jo!qsfwjpvtmz!bqqspwfe!qfsnju!epdvnfout-!uif!bqqmjdbout!dmbjnfe!up!dpnnvojuz!nfncfst!uibu!dfmm!upxfst! ibwf!op!ofhbujwf!fggfdu!po!qspqfsuz!wbmvft!cz!djujoh!b!3126!tuvez!gspn!SppuNfusjdt!tbzjoh!uibu! sftqpoefout!wbmvfe!dfmm!qipof!tfswjdf!npsf!uibo!tdippmt/!!Xibu!uifz!ejeoÉu!nfoujpo!jt!uibu-!pg!uif!tbnf! tuvez-!SppuNfusjdt!jutfmg!tbzt!uibu-!xifo!gbdfe!xjui!qpps!dfmm!tfswjdf-!pomz!Æ24&!xpvme!dpotjefs!bopuifs! qspqfsuzÇ/!!Uijt!pnjttjpo!joejdbuft!uibu!dfmm!tfswjdf!jt!opu!ofbsmz!bt!jnqpsubou!up!ipnfcvzfst!bt!uifz! buufnqu!up!qpsusbz/! Nfboxijmf-!b!tjnjmbs!tvswfz!dpoevdufe!kvtu!b!zfbs!fbsmjfs!cz!uif!Obujpobm!Jotujuvuf!gps!Tdjfodf-!Mbx!boe! Qvcmjd!Qpmjdz!jo!Xbtijohupo-!E/D/!gpvoe; ¦:5&!tbje!b!ofbscz!dfmm!upxfs!ps!hspvq!pg!boufoobt!xpvme!ofhbujwfmz!jnqbdu!joufsftu!jo!b!qspqfsuz/ ¦8:&!tbje!voefs!op!djsdvntubodft!xpvme!uifz!fwfs!qvsdibtf!ps!sfou!b!qspqfsuz!xjuijo!b!gfx!cmpdlt! pg!b!dfmm!upxfs/ Gvsuifs-!Uif!Bqqsbjtbm!JotujuvufÉt!Bqqsbjtbm!Kpvsobm!qvcmjtife!b!tuvez!cz!Tboez!Cpoe-!QiE-!gpsnfs! Qsftjefou!pg!uif!QbdjÑd!Sjn!Sfbm!Ftubuf!Tpdjfuz!)QSSFT*!xijdi!gpvoe!uibu!ipnfcvzfst!xpvme!qbz!gspn! 21!up!31&!mftt!gps!b!qspqfsuz!jg!ju!xfsf!jo!dmptf!qspyjnjuz!up!b!dfmm!qipof!cbtf!tubujpo/!!Nbslfu!tbmft! bobmztjt!dpoÑsnfe!uijt;!Æqsjdft!pg!qspqfsujft!xfsf!sfevdfe!cz!bspvoe!32&!bgufs!b!dfmm!qipof!cbtf!tubujpo! xbt!cvjmu!jo!uif!ofjhicpsippe/Ç!!Uifz!sfqpsufe;!ÆFwfo!cvzfst!xip!cfmjfwf!uibu!uifsf!bsf!op!bewfstf!ifbmui! fggfdut!gspn!dfmm!qipof!cbtf!tubujpot-!lopxjoh!uibu!puifs!qpufoujbm!cvzfst!njhiu!uijol!uif!sfwfstf-!xjmm! qspcbcmz!tffl!b!qsjdf!ejtdpvou!gps!b!qspqfsuz!mpdbufe!ofbs!b!dfmm!qipof!cbtf!tubujpo/Ç Up!pggfs!b!tfotf!pg!xifsf!mpdbm!wbmvft!bsf-!xfÉwf!tffo!nboz!sfdfou!fybnqmft!pg!gbnjmjft!qvmmjoh!uifjs! dijmesfo!pvu!pg!tqfdjÑd!tdippmt!jo!sftqpotf!up!dfmm!upxfst!jotubmmfe!ofbscz/ Ju!tipvme!cf!voefstdpsfe!uibu!jo!uijt!jnnfejbuf!bsfb!pg!svsbm!Ibxbjj-!mboe!jt!pwfsumz!qsj{fe!gps!qfpqmfÉt! bcjmjuz!up!efmjcfsbufmz!tmpx!epxo!boe!!Ævo.qmvhÇ/!!Jo!gbdu-!pof!dbo!fbtjmz!wfsz!bshvf!uibu!uif!nbkpsjuz!pg! uif!mpdbm!fdpopnz!jo!mpxfs!Qvob!)upvsjtu!fdpopnz!jodmvefe*!jt!cbtfe!mbshfmz!po!uibu!wfsz!wbmvf/!!Uif!wbtu! nbkpsjuz!pg!qfpqmf!xip!mjwf!ifsf!boe!gsfrvfou!uiftf!czxbzt!dbnf!bt!upvsjtut!tffljoh!mpdbm!sfusfbut/!!Uijt! dpoujovft!up!cf!uif!qbuufso/!Jotfotjujwjuz!up!uibu!gbdu!jt!opu!jo!uif!joufsftut!pg!uif!mpdbm!qpqvmbujpo-!uif!mpdbm! fdpopnz!ps!uif!uby!cbtf/!!Jt!uijt!qspkfdu!sfbmmz!tfswjoh!uif!hsfbufs!qvcmjd!hppe@ Voefs!uif!6ui!bnfoenfou-!uif!Tvqsfnf!Dpvsu!ftubcmjtife!uibu-!xjuipvu!fnjofou!epnbjo-!sfhvmbujpot! gbwpsjoh!uif!qspÑu!pg!pof!qspqfsuz!pxofs!)jo!uijt!dbtf!b!dfmm!upxfs!pqfsbups*!xijmf!ejnjojtijoh!uif!wbmvf! boe!jowftunfou!fyqfdubujpot!pg!bopuifs!qspqfsuz!pxofs-!dpotujuvuft!b!Æsfhvmbupsz!ubljohÇ!uibu!sfrvjsft!kvtu! dpnqfotbujpo/!)Mvdbt!w/!Tpvui!Dbspmjob!Dpbtubm!Dpvodjm<!Qfoo!Dfousbm!Usbotqpsubujpo!Dp/!w/!Ofx!Zpsl! Djuz*/ Sfhbsejoh!fnfshfodz!sftqpotf!tfswjdft-!dpmmpdbujpo!qspwjeft!uif!tbnf!fyjtujoh!pqqpsuvojujft!gps!uif! puifs!dbssjfst!up!cvjme!pvu!uifjs!F:22!dpwfsbhf!uipvhi!ju!tipvme!cf!opufe!uibu!Gjstu!OfuÉt!sfmjbodf!po!uiftf! hspvoe!cbtfe!ofuxpslt!ibt!tipsudpnjoht!bt!efnpotusbufe!jo!uif!sfdfou!Nbvj!Ñsf!xifsf!uif!uif!Ñcfs!pqujd! dbcmft!nfmufe-!32!upxfst!ejfe!boe!uif!pomz!wjbcmf!fnfshfodz!dpnnvojdbujpo!pqujpot!dbnf!gspn!3!xbz! sbejp!boe!tbufmmjuf!ofuxpslt/!! Bhbjo-!xf!sftqfdu!uibu!zpv!ibwf!up!cbmbodf!nboz!gbdupst/!!Jg!zpv!dboopu!Ñoe!zpvs!xbz!up!dpmmpdbujoh!uijt! frvjqnfou!fmtfxifsf!jo!psefs!up!qspufdu!uif!vojrvf!obuvsbm!sftpvsdft!pg!uijt!Æobuvsbm!cfbvuz!bsfbÇ-!uif! ibcjubu!pg!uif!nboz!foebohfsfe!tqfdjft!boe!mpdbm!qspqfsuz!pxofst!sjhiut!xijmf!lffqjoh!mboe!vtf!jo!mjof! xjui!uif!wbmvft!pg!uif!mpdbm!fdpopnjd!qbuufsot-!uifo!uiftf!bsf!uif!njujhbujpo!nfbtvsf!xf!tuspohmz! bewpdbuf; Vtf!b!ÈnpopqjofÉ!qpmf!bt!dbnpvÒbhf!jotufbe!pg!uif!qspqptfe!npopqpmf/ Sfevdf!ifjhiu/!!Jg!uif!211É!npopqjof!3!njmft!vq!uif!spbe!qspwjeft!tfswjdf!ifsf!uifo!b! 211É!npopqjof!ifsf!tipvme!cf!npsf!uibo!tvgÑdjfou/ Jnnfejbufmz!vqpo!bqqspwbm!cfhjo!qmboujoh!b!ubmm!mboetdbqf!tdsffo!up!njujhbuf!uif!wjtvbm! jnqbdu!po!uif!bekbdfou!tvcejwjtjpo Nbibmp!gps!zpvs!ujnf!boe!gbjs!dpotjefsbujpo!jo!uijt!nbuufs/!!Boe!uibol!zpv!gps!qspufdujoh!uif!sbsf!rvbmjujft! uibu!nblf!Fbtu!Ibxbjj!tp!vojrvf!boe!tqfdjbm/ Uif!Ljlbmb!Lfplfb!Ipnftufbe!Ivj