HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-12-05 Skye Czember Writen Testimony TIELI WANG (PL-SMA-2024-000058)for TMKs: (3) 2-1-014:044,045 and 046 was DENIED on September
24, 2024 and then REFILED and APPROVED under PL-SAA-2024-000249 for TMK: (3) 2-1-014:046. Based
on the Hawaii County Planning Commission Rule 9-11,(f), (4) PL-SAA-2024-000249 SHOULD NOT BE
APPROVED NOR ACCEPTED for 2 years from September 24, 2024 the DENIAL date of PL-SMA-2024-
000058.
POINT#1
Windward Planning Commission Actions on September 24,2024-DENIED-PL-SMA-2024-000058
"APPLICANT:TIELI WANG (PL-SMA-2024-000058) (PLEASE SEE THE ATTACHED)
Application for a Special Management Area Use Permit to construct three (3), three-story, single-family
dwellings and related improvements; one single-family dwelling will be constructed on each parcel.The
three (3) parcels total 24,250 square feet and are located within the Special Management Area.The
subject properties are located at the end of Machida Lane, approximately 300 feet east of Onekahakaha
Road, Keaukaha, South Hilo, Hawai'i,TMKs: (3) 2-1-014:044,045 and 046.
DENIED".
POINT#2
According to the Hawaii County Planning Commission Rule 9-11,(f), (4), pg 9-19 REFILING:
Whenever an application for a Special Management Area Use Permit has been denied, no new
application for the same or similar development, covering all or any portion of the property involved in
the application, shall be accepted by the Commission through the Director for a period of two years from
the effective date of the denial of the application; provided, however,that upon showing of a substantial
change of circumstances the Commission may permit the filing of anew application prior to the
expiration of such a two-year period.
POINT#3
On November 13, 2024 Special Management Area Assessment Application (PL-SAA-2024-000249)was
APPROVED (PLEASE SEE THE ATTACHED)
Applicant:Tieli and Tianlong Wang
Landowners:Tieli and Tianlong Wang
Request: Construct a Single-Family Dwelling and Related Improvements
Tax Map Key: (3)2-1-014:046
Location:Onekahakaha,South Hilo District, Island of Hawai'i
Based on Hawaii County Planning Commission Rule 9-11, (f), (4)this application should not be approved
or accepted. As"no new application for the same or similar development, covering all or any portion of
the property involved in the application,shall be accepted by the Commission through the Director for a
period of two years from the effective date of the denial of the application", which was on September
24, 2024
'Red at8 by
Ccif_y - 'd---AL—
,� » p
•
POINT#4
As defined for 3 reasons for DENIAL of SMA PL-SMA-2024-000058 at the Windward Planning
Commission hearing on September 24, 2024:
1).Septic System Impact(recommended hooking up to sewer system)
2) Road Access Issues(the bad condition of the private road with no maintenance agreements leads to
problems and concerns with tsunami evacuation and fire truck access)
3) Other Environmental Concerns
None of these issues have been mitigated in the application of PL-SAA-2024-000249 and therefore
should be DENIED and written into the amendments of any future development of TMKs: (3) 2-1-
014:044,045 and 046
The Hawaii County Planning Department advised Ms.Colter to submit the application for all 3 lots
together as a larger development and therefore the SMA permit application should not be permitted to
be submitted individually after the initial SMA permit application was denied. Ms Colter admits to this
fact that she was advised by the Planning Department to submit all 3 properties together as the owners
intention is to develop all 3 properties.
Mahalo,
Neighboring Adjacent Property Owners:
Gwendolyn Hill &Christopher Owens [23 Machida Lane]
Please attached your signature and your address as a neighboring property owner