HomeMy WebLinkAbout2025-02-06 Dyanne Christensen through 2025-03-07 Nancy Wood (15)From:Dyanne Christensen
To:WPCtestimony; LPCtestimony; Council Testimony; Kimball, Heather; Kagiwada, Jennifer; Onishi, Dennis;Kierkiewicz, Ashley; Kanealii-Kleinfelder, Matt; Villegas, Rebecca; Galimba, Michelle M.; Inaba, Holeka; Hustace,James; cohmayor@hawaiicounty.gov
Subject:Unclear General Plan 2045 from today meeting for tomorrow questions
Date:Thursday, February 6, 2025 1:58:07 PM
Todays meeting:
The plan was said that it doesn't need to be specific. Why? This leaves too many loopholes
for any new changes to be governed under the plan. Wiggle room so to speak, to fall under acategory to have the right to add in additional actions after the plan has been passed.
TDR= Transfer Development Rights,(shift) this is said to be voluntary. In other areas that it's
said to be "voluntary" it usually means pushed out having to "voluntarily move" which in thereal sense it isn't then voluntarily. Such as insurance will not insure you at this location, the
rezone of the property (although I feel this is disguised in the language) you can not buildhere.
It was talked about that if you fall under the TDR, that the 1,000 sqft home you wanted tobuild now you can be directed to a piece of land to be able to build a 2,000 sqft home. We all
know nothing is this simple, like the plan in itself is easily misconstrued to be agreeable if notasked the right questions. How much is it going to cost the landowner to transfer over to the
designated land that the plan is suggestioning to be provided? Are they going to be limited atthat time to use only the people who benefit from the plan to build the construction of the
home? Will they own the land or will it be a leasehold as the HOA has been described? Toomany nuances that leave people to be imprisoned by the Shift /TDR areas.
Transportation was touched on about electric vehicles and how we do not have the
infrastructure for it. But, nothing mentioned about the blackouts we already are having on theBig Island.
The pull outs for the buses. The route looks as if it will be in front of peoples homes for the
buses to pull in to let passengers off and on the bus. Carving into the personal property of anowner, will they be paid to take their property and make their land a smaller parcel than when
they purchased it? Will the plan cover the change of the TMK that goes with the property asthe property line has changed? Which if the property line is not remapped and it's sold, who's
at fault for the non disclosure when this wasn't' by choice of the homeowner?
Homeowners compensation was mentioned. But, we know when the state/county wants yourland it isn't like selling your land at a profit, It is taking what they will give you. It was said
that the home/land that now has been "rezoned" already had a conservation easement of theland but was used as state URBAN land. How can an easement for conservation take over all
of your land? Having an easement from a neighbor does not give the neighbor the right to takeyour land. You can purchase the land but when we are ready to use your land we can take it?
Still leaving the homeowner to not be able to use their home as a line of equity, take the pricethat is offered to move off their property without making the profit of what they have put into
the home and the added value to the land. Having to pay taxes on the money given to you at alesser dollar amount than your home is worth, while being displaced.
All of this should not be lumped into one plan. There are too many components that they
want to "cluster in" a county plan. Making it too easy once a plan is passed to do the opposite
of what has been spoken in the meetings. Twisting the words of their meanings to fit thenarrative of the plan.
We as a whole will be the ones paying the price if it is passed the way it is now, it is harder to
undo than it is to revise before passing.
Please do not pass this plan on to all of us. Some sounds minor but history has proven planslike this can crumble a county. Especially with too many components in one plan.
Plan DivideTransportation that includes what it looks like, not a vague picture using climate change.
Zoning, did the people who purchased the state urban land know that this could be apossibility with the conservation of the easement changing their home to not be state urban but
to conservation? If this wasn't known this could lead up to county lawsuits. What constitutesthe right of the rezoning of a property although said it isn't rezoning.
People will fight back after the fact ones affected by the plan. No one thinks it's a
big deal beforehand until the aftermath starts.
Mahalo,Dyanne Christensen
808.557.6834
dyannechristensen@gmail.com
From:Joanna Weber
To:WPCtestimony; LPCtestimony; Council Testimony; Kimball, Heather; Kagiwada, Jennifer; Onishi, Dennis;Kierkiewicz, Ashley; Kanealii-Kleinfelder, Matt; Villegas, Rebecca; Galimba, Michelle M.; Inaba, Holeka; Hustace,James
Subject:DO NOT Recommend the Hawaii GP 2045!
Date:Saturday, March 1, 2025 10:30:16 AM
Attachments:image001.gif
Aloha Commissioners,
The Big Island Plan cannot go through the way it is designed. It is hard to
believe any locals helped design this plan.
Here are some concerns:
There is a huge part of the plan dedicated to "Climate Change".
However, why do most experts state there is NO climate
danger? Climate Experts Speak Out Against Climate Danger ClickHere!
The word "Stakeholder," defined in the plan, is written 86 times and
literally means anyone in the entire world can have input on this plan.
Please, recommend “Stakeholder” to be changed to the following:
"Local Communities”. Local Communities are local Big Island farmers,
homeowners, renters, organizations, businesses, and individuals wholive on Big Island or have property on Big Island that will be
personally affected by projects, decisions, or activities in the general
plan. Effective local community engagement and management are
crucial for the success and sustainability of any initiative, as it helpsensure that diverse perspectives and interests are considered.
The OSCER Department in the plan will null and void all public input
and leave decisions to unelected officials. This is NOT okay! Thisdepartment should not be created. This is on page 188, 40.8.
The Planning Department has sent out letters to many homeowners
telling them their land use will be changed from resident to recreationdue to the General Plan 2045. This will drastically lower their property
value and opens the door to re-zone the area. This is not pono. It
breaks the Aloha Spirit law § 5-7.5. To reduce someone's property
value is not okay. This must be made pono again.
There is a huge section on climate change and things that will be
affected. This needs to be further researched. There are over 1900
credentialed scientist who say there is no climate danger. Here is thepdf showing the scientists and which country they are
from. https://clintel.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/WCD-
241023.pdf John Coleman, the first weather man for Good Morning
America and the Founder of the Weather Channel has gone on CNN
and other media outlets stating, "There is no climate danger". Heexplain the reason for this narrative is the investors, in renewable
energy, want to make these changes.
Hilo does not have a Community Development Plan. How can a BigIsland General Plan move forward without that? Hilo is 22% of the
island.
1.13 under "Increase the biodiversity and resilience of nativehabitats" it reads, "Incentivize private land management practices
that protect and enhance natural resource values and, when
appropriate, pursue the acquisition of lands for the protection of
natural resources." "Incentives" means more taxes. "Protection"means more rules. Whose "values" is this plan referring to, because
it's not the locals’? "Pursue the acquisition of lands", does this say,
they are going to pursue taking people's private property? Again with
"protection of natural resources". This plan should be focused onpeople growing more food and it is doing the exact opposite!
This plan wants to turn land into "conservation". The exact opposite is
what is needed for Big Island! We need to turn land into Ag Villagesand grow more food! Steve Shropshire, a resident of Papaikou, has
created an Ag Villages plan.
Ag Village to add to the General Plan:
Papaikou Ag Village Objectives:
https://www.standtogetherhawaii.com/_files/ugd/86fc0c_2cb1cc6d604f4c
dd971ad40831c745bc.pdf
Papaikou Site
Plan: https://www.standtogetherhawaii.com/_files/ugd/86fc0c_5e4cdb02
efeb46a5ae949a3579aff00d.pdf
Papaikou Development:
https://www.standtogetherhawaii.com/_files/ugd/86fc0c_c2af52c8b3c645
b1a6868a724eee8304.pdf
A Hawaiian-born Kanaka revised the Collaborative Biocultural Stewardship
which is in the plan. You can see it in the pdf below:
PartOne: https://www.standtogetherhawaii.com/_files/ugd/86fc0c_0a1d5be8f
1d140069415f7b691725786.pdf
Part Two: https://86fc0cbd-8207-4076-85fa-5a62e4e933b4.usrfiles.com/ugd/86fc0c_ecc498ba192d4a7689ebf31c3681
c2ec.pdf
Here is a longer revised version of the plan from locals: https://www.standtogetherhawaii.com/_files/ugd/86fc0c_b34739e4c99c46
1685de4c0207bf286e.pdf
The way this plan is written is very far from what will support our island.
ALOHA, JOANNA WEBER
From:Christy Schuerch
To:WPCtestimony
Subject:Testimony for General Plan 2045
Date:Wednesday, March 5, 2025 1:38:34 PM
Aloha,
I am a resident of Volcano, Hawaii, 96785 zip code. I am extremely interested in addingadditional protections for our native Ohi'a forest, which is being decimated by unpermitted
grubbing and grading, feral ungulates, ROD and invasive species. We need much strongerordinances and building codes at the County level to protect this natural resource for the native
wildlife, watershed, and economic viability of our community. I support the CollaborativeBiocultural Stewardship in the General Plan 2045, and strengthening of the current ordinances
going forward. In addition, there needs to be a facilitation of property tax incentives to thelowest level for small size lot owners ( 9000 SQ FT) wishing to put their lots into Native Ohi'a
Forest conservation.Sincerely,
Christy SchuerchPO Box 1352
Volcano, HI 96785
From:Heidi WhiteTo:Planning Internet Mail; WPCtestimony; LPCtestimony; Council Testimony; Kimball, Heather; Kagiwada, Jennifer; Onishi, Dennis; Kierkiewicz, Ashley; Kanealii-Kleinfelder, Matt; Villegas, Rebecca; Galimba,Michelle M.; Inaba, Holeka; Hustace, James; cohmayor@hawaiicounty.gov
Subject:My community and I OPPOSE THE GP 2024Date:Wednesday, March 5, 2025 6:06:53 PM
To all of you in Government positions I along with my community and ohana write tooppose this General Plan 2024!
STOP This General Plan 2024 its BAD for our Island.
We stand and ask the County Council to vote against the County Planning Department's 2045 General Plan because it is NOT good for the
community.
We stand and ask Mayor Kimo Alameda to oppose the County Planning Department's 2045 General Plan for the reasons stated below.
We also call for a Hawai'i' Planning Director who will advocate for community rights and hear our voices that speak against high-end
developers. Accountability for past actions must be taken.
As a resident of the Big Island for over 45 years, a Realtor for 29 years, a mother and grandmother of seven. I have witnessed the
gradual erosion of the conservation of land to high-end developers and our rights being removed due to the actions of the Hawai'i
County Planning Department in favor of these developers over the voices of the community and wanting more control over our lives. The
department's proposed 2045 General Plan is beyond comprehension for the average citizen, with complexities that beg for transparency
and accountability.
We demand Hawai'i County Planning meetings for their 2045 General Plan to be held at times the community can attend, which
is after 5 p.m.
Tragically, this plan includes Land Title Changes, which are deeply concerning. When someone in the Hawai’i County Planning
meeting stood and opposed a land use title change, the director dismissed it as an “oversight.” This raises serious questions
about the number of oversights in their final draft. Changing land use titles strips us of our rights to private property and
introduces vague, yet potentially harmful, rezoning measures.
Furthermore, the plan includes ambitions to create a broadband and smart grid, a lofty goal for an island lacking the necessary
resources. This raises significant questions about the feasibility and environmental implications of such projects.
It's crucial to ensure that these changes DO NOT proceed. We must continue to push for transparency and accountability in these
decisions to protect our land, Island, and future
What's more distressing is that the Hawai’i County Planning Department seems to always focus on high-end development initiatives that
overtax our resources and infrastructure instead of considering the voices of our community. A clear example was when 18,569 voices
opposed development in a petition. Yet, Zendo Kern, the Hawai'i Planning Director at the time, ignored these voices and stated the resort
would not hurt the land even with articles like these two:
https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/feature-story/cautionary-tale-2019-coral-bleaching-event-
hawaii#:~:text=Coral%20Bleaching%20Is%20Occurring%20more,had%20catastrophic%20impacts%20state%2Dwide
https://coral.org/en/where-we-work/hawaiian-
islands/#:~:text=Hawai%CA%BBi's%20reefs%20face%20major%20global,into%20Hawai%CA%BBi's%20waterways%20every%20day
This is the petition he ignored: https://www.thepetitionsite.com/854/086/898/residents-who-oppose-the-resort-in-punaluu-
ka%C5%AB/
This is the article showing Kern’s opposition over local voices: https://www.civilbeat.org/2024/03/hundreds-of-hawaii-island-
residents-protest-proposed-housing-project-in-punaluu/
Additionally, we urge Mayor Kimo Alameda to reappoint a new Hawai'i County Planning Director. Jeff Darrow's 26 years with the Hawai'i
Planning Department, supporting Zendo Kern, have demonstrated a lack of commitment to the land and local voices. These voices have
consistently opposed high-end developments, advocating instead for the conservation of the land for endangered species and the
island's future. Jeff Darrow's support against local voices in the past years shows he is not the right fit for the job, and we demand that
accountability be served.
We need a Planning Director who prioritizes island resources and infrastructure over high-end developments, favors land conservation,
and listens to and supports local voices. We need someone who will work to ensure the Big Island retains its unique character and
doesn't turn into another Oahu. We also need someone who is respectful of our rights by NOT overreaching their station, as this 2045
General Plan is doing.
We stand, and OPPOSE Hawi'i County Planning General Plan for the reasons stated:
In the General Plan
Page 79
9.4 Support mechanisms, such as PUD and Cluster Plan Development (CPD), that group parcel density to preserve open space,
recreational areas, or scenic viewsheds.
The General Plan DOES NOT explain what a PUD means.
Taken from this site: https://www.forbes.com/advisor/mortgages/what-is-a-planned-unit-development/
"A planned unit development, or PUD, is a community of single-family homes, and sometimes condos or townhomes, where every
homeowner belongs to a homeowners association (HOA)."
Taken from this site: https://www.zillow.com/learn/what_is_pud/
"To most home shoppers, a planned unit development (PUD) may look like a single-family home. But the legal structure for a PUD is
more similar to that of a condo and can impact the mortgage process.
Again, you’ll need to read all these documents to determine whether that specific PUD is right for you. And remember, all PUDs are
different, so each one will have its own set of rules and restrictions."
Page 80
9.f Study the feasibility, issues, and opportunities related to the development of a TDR program to strategically preserve open space and
achieve density to remain consistent with the land use pattern in accordance with the General Plan Land Use Maps.
It's deeply frustrating that the Hawai'i County Planning Department isn't transparently explaining its Transfer of Development Rights
(TDR) program. It feels like they’re pushing for land use changes that suit their vision without respecting the community’s strong, unified
opposition over the last six months. In every meeting, 100% of the community has voiced their disapproval, yet it seems those concerns
aren't acknowledged.
General Plan Page 87
Everything below is to enforce their TDR program, which they are not explaining.
13.1 Encourage flexibility in the design of residential sites, buildings, and related facilities to achieve a diversity of socio-economic
housing mix and innovative means of meeting the market requirements.
13.2 Prioritize increase in density, rehabilitation, and redevelopment within existing zoned urban areas already served by basic
infrastructure, or close to such areas.
13.4 Encourage the rehabilitation and/or utilization of maximum density in multi-family residential areas.
13.8 Focus on medium- and high-density residential and commercial uses in communities that can sustain a higher intensity of uses and
where consistent with General Plan Land Use Map and existing town character
13.9 Support the rezoning of land to multiple residential near places of employment, retail, utilities, and educational, recreational,
cultural, and public facilities.
Their efforts to align with the General Plan Land Use Map are causing significant changes across the island, which is a significant
concern. For example, changing the Land Use Title from agricultural to urban for high-end developer Hokulia would allow developers to
bypass the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) requirements, which are crucial for protecting the land and the community. This move
could have profound implications for the environment and local residents, and this 2045 General Plan wants to change high-end
developer's Land Use Titles for many others as well.
Moreover, they're not considering the island's resources, which are already under considerable strain. Please see these News Articles in
this petition that show how the Big Island is dealing with resource and infrastructure issues because Hawai’i County Planning is not
making it a priority https://www.change.org/p/help-big-island-resources-and-infrastructure-stay-safe-for-all-who-live-here-and-
visit
Page 149
30.12 Plan for broadband infrastructure to support smart grid development
Hawai’i County Planning doesn’t talk about the power broadband and a smart grid will need, and Hawai’i Electric states, “That’s why we
will need everyone to work together over the next month, and possibly longer, to conserve electricity. We are extremely tight on what we
call our generation margin, the margin between the demand for electricity and our ability to supply it. This demand typically peaks on
weekdays between 5 and 9 p.m. and that’s when the margin is most critical.”
https://www.hawaiianelectric.com/safety-and-outages/an-update-on-hawaii-island-power-generation
The island doesn’t have the power for broadband or a smart grid, and the traffic it will create because it has to lay cable underground will
be massive.
https://smartgrid.ieee.org/resources?cafid=0&id=223:
“A smart grid alone does three things. First, it modernizes power systems through self-healing designs, automation, remote monitoring,
and control… Thus, a smart grid sits at the heart of the smart city, which cannot fully exist without it”.
Also, a Smart Grid will allow them more control through “remote monitoring,” which will invade our privacy.
https://minnovation.com.au/smart-cities-2/disadvantages-of-smart-cities-potential-challenges-and-concerns/:
“Privacy and Data Security:
Smart cities rely heavily on the collection and analysis of vast amounts of data from sensors, cameras, and connected devices. This data is
crucial for optimizing city operations and services. However, extensive data gathering raises concerns about privacy infringement and
data security. Citizens worry about their personal information being accessed or misused.”
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S240584402414011X:
Drawbacks or disadvantages of Smart Grid
Following are the drawbacks or disadvantages of Smart Grid:
Continuous communication network should be available.
During emergency situation, network congestion or performance are big challenges in smart grid system.
Cellular network providers do not provide guaranteed service in abnormal situations such as wind storm, heavy rain and lightening
conditions.
Some smart meters can be hacked which can be used to increase or decrease the demand for power.
It is expensive to install smart meter compare to traditional old electricity meter.
Hawai’i County Planning Department does NOT have any research about how a broadband and smart grid will affect the health of the
island, its community, animals, and plants. For example, at the bottom of this article, it
states https://electronics360.globalspec.com/article/11104/the-dangers-that-come-with-a-smart-grid:
“Re: The Dangers That Come with a Smart Grid
#1
John Endres
2018-Feb-23 2:31 PM
One very critical danger that comes with a "smart grid" was not mentioned: the adverse health effects from electromagnetic fields.
Current estimates of people experiencing adverse health effects from wireless technology hover at around 5%--I am one of them. After
the installation of a water utility smart meter at my place of work, I experienced an escalation of symptoms (over time) that started with
headaches and ultimately culminated in a seizure (I lost control of my legs). One month prior to the smart meter installation I had a
complete annual physical and was given a clean bill of health. I underwent a barrage of medical tests after a week of experiencing health
symptoms (thyroid, EEG, MRI, etc.) and everything was normal. I did begin to feel some of the painful head and eye sensations (that I
would feel near wireless sources) at the end of the MRI.”
Nor do they have any research on health risks with cell towers that they are allowing to be placed anywhere, and some of these cell
tower tops are just a few feet from residential homes, HWY, and retirement homes…because a lot of the island is a mountain. If you put
the base of a cell tower on one street, the top could be directly across from the community.
https://mdsafetech.org/cell-tower-health-effects/:
*** Percentage of studies that reported harmful effect of EMR in various groups in MOEF Report
Human Effects– 62% showed effects, 13% no effect and 25% inconclusive
Plant Effects– 87% showed effects and 13% were inconclusive
Wildlife Effects- 62% showed effects, 4% no effect and 36% inconclusive
Bee Effects—85% showed effects and 15% no effect
Bird Effects- 77% showed effects, 10% no effect and 13% inconclusive
“Overall results of this review show three types of effects by base station antennas on the health of people: radiofrequency sickness (RS),
cancer (C) and changes in biochemical parameters (CBP). Considering all the studies reviewed globally (n = 38), 73.6% (28/38) showed
effects: 73.9% (17/23) for radiofrequency sickness, 76.9% (10/13) for cancer and 75.0% (6/8) for changes in biochemical parameters...Of
special importance are the studies performed on animals or trees near base station antennas that cannot be aware of their proximity
and to which psychosomatic effects can never be attributed.”
It's concerning that the Hawai'i County Planning Department isn't providing detailed information about the potential disadvantages of
broadband and smart grid projects. They seem to be focusing on the benefits without addressing the possible negative impacts,
especially when the island lacks the extra power for it.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S240584402414011X:
"However smart grids, being computerized remote-control systems overseeing electricity distribution, are vulnerable to cyberattacks."
30.5 Siting of new communications facilities shall comply with performance standards and site colocation as stated in the Code.
Hawai’i Planning does NOT explain that they use the word “sitting” to mean the laying of cable underground. The term "siting of new
communications facilities" is extremely confusing. It generally refers to the process of selecting and preparing locations for new
infrastructure, such as towers and cables, needed to support broadband and smart grid projects. This often involves road construction
and can lead to increased traffic and disruptions because these cables need to be laid underground.
These cables could be laid shallow as this site states https://primex.com/fiber-optic-internet-going-underground/:
“The terrain and the local conditions need to be taken into account when considering underground broadband deployment. In rocky
terrain, cable must be laid in a shallow trench.”
https://pulsefibre.co.uk/2023/06/15/when-more-is-less-the-risks-and-downsides-of-overbuild/:
“Cost: Fibre optic broadband infrastructure can be an expensive endeavour, especially if it involves duplicating existing networks. This
cost can ultimately be passed on to consumers, making broadband services more expensive and potentially reducing the adoption rate
of fibre optic services.
Inefficiency: As mentioned above, overbuilding can lead to dormant infrastructure, creating wasted resources and increased
environmental impact. This is particularly relevant in the case of fibre optic broadband, where installing fibre can be resource intensive.
Fragmentation: When different service providers own and operate various parts of the infrastructure, it can make it difficult for
consumers to switch between providers and could result in reduced competition.
Legal and regulatory issues: Particularly in cases where existing service providers have exclusive rights to operate in certain areas. This
can result in lengthy legal battles that delay the deployment of new infrastructure.
Maintenance: Increased maintenance costs can occur, especially if there is redundant infrastructure that needs to be maintained. This
can ultimately lead to higher costs for consumers or reduced network quality – something we are wholeheartedly against at Pulse Fibre.
Technology obsolescence: Expensive upgrades or replacements may be required down the line if new infrastructure is not designed to
accommodate future upgrades.
Wasted resources: Overbuilding for fibre solutions can result in the waste of valuable resources, including time, money, and materials.
Environmental: Overbuilding multiplies CO2 emissions as duplicate workforces are deployed, travelling more miles, digging more holes
and creating a piecemeal labour profile. As well as laying more raw materials which may never get used. More information can be found
on the Journal of Lightwave Technology.”
It's concerning that the Hawai'i County Planning Department isn't addressing the increasing traffic issues while pushing for broadband
and smart grid projects. Infrastructure, especially roadways, is already under significant strain, and these new projects will exacerbate
the problem rather than alleviate it.
General Plan Page 87
13.13 Support master planning by public and private institutions and landowners which emphasize TOD, affordable housing, and mixed-
use development.
Page 117
20.e Adopt a Complete Streets ordinance.
Hawai’i County Planning Department mentions “Master Planning and Ordinances” but they DO NOT explain what these are in their 2045
General Plan. It seems they want to leave things open so they can change the meaning in the future if needed.
Page 89
13.44 The development or designation of new resort areas should complement the character of the area; protect the environment and
natural beauty; respect existing lifestyles, cultural practices, and cultural resources; and provide shoreline public access.
Page 142
28.11 The County shall ensure that golf course developments develop and implement grading and site preparation plans to...
It's frustrating to see so many development applications going up all over when the Big Island clearly does not need more resorts and
golf courses. The island is already facing resource issues with existing developments, and there are still many years of already-approved
projects that haven't even been started yet.
The island needs sustainable development that prioritizes the well-being of residents and the conservation of the island's resources.
Please read this petition: https://www.change.org/p/help-big-island-resources-and-infrastructure-stay-safe-for-all-who-live-here-
and-visit
"The West Hawai’i Sanitary Landfill, the only remaining landfill on the Big Island, is forecast to reach capacity within the next 20 to 25
years." https://bigislandnow.com/2023/09/17/big-island-now-poll-no-27-results-more-than-one-solution-needed-to-help-extend-
life-of-west-hawaii-landfill/
"Water issues are not just happening ‘somewhere else’. In Hawaii the finite boundaries of each island requires geographically defined
water self-sufficiency systems that are reliable, safe, and expandable. On each island there are dozens of micro-climates and varied
geologic features that impact the availability, methods, and costs to access safe water. http://www.oneisland.org/hawaii/green-
resources/water
"HECO issues rolling power outages around Big Island by: Emily Cervantes Posted: Feb 13, 2024 / 05:11 PM HST Updated: Feb 13, 2024 /
09:12 PM HST Hawaiian Electric initiated rolling outages for Big Island after several large generators became unavailable and reduced
output Tuesday night.”
https://www.khon2.com/local-news/heco-releases-conservation-alert-for-big-island/
14.1 Support the State Land Use reclassification to Rural in alignment with the General Plan Rural designation.
What is the General Plan Rural Designation? Is this more high-end land use titles changing from agriculture to rural?
Page 111
17.4 Land use applications shall identify as early as possible any existing or potential active living corridors that should be incorporated
into the County’s open space network.
Who decides what a living corridor is? Is this the county's way of taking private land areas away through a Land Use Application?
Read more reasons to OPPOSE the General Plan at this page https://bigislandsupport.com/2045-gp-testimonial/
We firmly oppose the Hawai’i County Planning Department’s 2045 General Plan. We demand the reappointment of the Hawai’i Planning
Director to someone who will prioritize addressing Big Island resources, conserving the land, and listening to local voices. We need a
leader who will stand with the community, not high-end developers, to preserve the unique character and future of the Big Island.
Heidi White, Realtor (S)-57643Direct: 808-895-4304
At Home On The Big Island, Hawaii
From:Kathleen Mishina
To:WPCtestimony
Subject:Testimony to WPC for Special General Plan Meeting on March 10, 2025
Date:Wednesday, March 5, 2025 10:54:37 AM
Attachments:Testimony to WPC re General Plan 2045 page 1 o3.pdf
Testimony to WPC re General Plan 2045 page 2 o3.pdf
Testimony to WPC re General Plan 2045 page 3 o3.pdf
Aloha to all members of the Windward Planning Commission,
I am emailing my written testimony for the upcoming WPC meeting for the General Plan2045.
My 3 page testimony is attached.
Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions.Thank you,
Kathleen Mishina
808-895-0313kmmishina@gmail.com
From:Ken Forbes
To:WPCtestimony
Subject:Windward Planning Commission testimony for March 10 meeting
Date:Wednesday, March 5, 2025 6:50:36 PM
Attachments:testimony for GP meeting.docx
Please see attached testimony regarding Windward Planning Commission GPmeeting on March 10.
Ken Forbes
PO Box 199
Hakalau, HI 96710
County of Hawai`i
Windward Planning Commission
Via email: WPCtestimony@hawaiicounty.gov
RE: Comments related to the Final Draft General Plan 2045 in consideration of
Hakalau Point
Chair Lin and Commission Members:
Thank you for this opportunity to testify.
I was born and raised on the Hamakua Coast and Hilo and returned from Oahu
after retiring. I live in what’s called the Hakalau Plantation Village. Along with
others, I was involved in providing testimony to the Hamakua CDP Committee,
focusing on Hakalau Point.
Regarding housing:
Does the draft proposal for Hakalau Point provide housing opportunities for the
existing Hamakua community?
The 18-year history of the Hakalau Plantation Village, near the Point but mauka
of Old Mamalahoa Hwy, provides a lesson about that. Nineteen of the 22 lots have
houses now, mostly 1/3 acre.
o Mostly folks who moved from the mainland to live here.
o Many are retired. There are 4 physicians, 2 former lawyers, 2 former
engineers, an architect, other retired professionals.
o The majority of the houses have been resold at least once. Almost all who
sold returned to the mainland.
o The 3 most recent sales: $920k, $980k, $1.4 m.
In short, regarding housing, the draft GP does not appear to me to address
community interests.
My hope has been that an Open zoning designation in the GP would reflect the
County’s preference that this land beside Hakalau Bay not be developed. As with
others, I view it as one of those places that the County should recognize as special.
Yes, there is Low Density Urban nearby but is that a good rationale for using this
particular piece of land in the same way? The community input to the CDP
thought not.
With respect,
Ken Forbes
From:Kevin Kunz
To:WPCtestimony
Subject:Testimony Hawaii Count Genral Plan 2045
Date:Wednesday, March 5, 2025 1:58:13 PM
Attachments:WPC General Plan Testimony. K. Kunz 3.5.25.docx
Dear Friends,
Please find attached my testimony related to the proposed Hawaii County General Plan, 2045.
Mahalo for the work you do to preserve our unique community, our cultures and our living environment.
Kevin Kunz19-4071 Wright RoadVolcano Hawaii 96785808-895-6619
Kevin Kunz
19-4071 Wright Road
Volcano, Hawaii 96785
March 5, 2025
Windward Planning Commission
WPCtestimony@hawaiicounty.gov
Dear Leadership at the Windward Planning Commission,
I am writing in support of the County of Hawaii General Plan 2045, specifically Section 2.0:
Collaborative Biocultural Stewardship.
As a resident of Volcano Village in the Puna District, a committed senior, a volunteer
member of this community, and a Back Country Volunteer at Hawaii Volcanos National
Park, please view me as a serious stakeholder for the ideals and objectives set forth in
Section 2.0. Further, my position reflects that of several dozen of my Puna and Volcano
Village friends. Although they are less likely to comment on the General Plan, I can assure
you that they will support it and work for it as it comes online.
After attention to our families and preservation of our unique Hawaii County community
cultures, the absolute necessity of preserving our distinctive, one and only physical
environment becomes paramount. Indeed, this environment influences who we are, or
may become, and all that we do. For generations to come.
As currently written, Section 2.0 is, in my view, perfect. It covers all bases, and enhances
the opportunities for collaboration by any stakeholders, allowing activation of our citizenry.
Truth be told, participation of the community is an essential and necessary element. I and I
know others as well, do others pledge to support not just this plan, yet also our
commitment to step up when our participation is needed. From pulling invasive plants, to
teaching others the responsibility we all have together to save our environment, to reaching
out to county, state and federal level pullers.
Finally, and emphatically, I wish to comment on Section 2.0, Actions 1.o: Study, develop,
and establish Biosphere Reserve Buffer Zones. With Puna and Volcano Village’s
geographically inclusive and/or adjacent location next to Hawaii Volcanos National Park
(HVNP). HVNP is a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve, and we are the buffering community. Let
us step up our game with this General Plan, and preserve all we can in this unique buffer
zone.
Sincerely,
Kevin Kunz
From:K C-A
To:LPCtestimony; WPCtestimony
Cc:Council Testimony; Kimball, Heather; Kagiwada, Jennifer; Onishi, Dennis; Kierkiewicz, Ashley; Kanealii-Kleinfelder, Matt;Villegas, Rebecca; Galimba, Michelle M.; Inaba, Holeka; Hustace, James; cohmayor@hawaiicounty.gov
Subject:DO NOT RECOMMEND Big Island General Plan 2045
Date:Wednesday, March 5, 2025 8:52:18 PM
Aloha Commissioners, The Big island Plan cannot go through the way it is designed. It is hard to believe any local helpeddesign this plan. Here are some concerns: There is a huge part of the plan dedicated to "Climate Change". However, why do most experts statethere is NO climate danger? Climate Experts Speak Out Against Climate Danger Click Here!The word "Stakeholder," defined in the plan, is written 86 times and literally means anyone in the entireworld can have input on this plan.Please recommend Stakeholder change to the following: "Local Communities”. Local Communities arelocal Big Island farmers, homeowners, renters, organizations, businesses, and individuals who live onBig Island or have property on Big Island that will be personally affected by projects, decisions, oractivities in the general plan. Effective local community engagement and management are crucial forthe success and sustainability of any initiative, as it helps ensure that diverse perspectives and interestsare considered. The OSCER Department in the plan will null and void all public input and leave decisions to unelectedofficials. This is NOT okay! This department should not be created. This is on page 188, 40.8. The Planning Department has sent out letters too many homeowners telling them their land use will bechanged from resident to recreation due to the General Plan 2045. This will drastically lower theirproperty value and opens the door to rezone the area. This is not pono. It breaks the Aloha Spirit law §5-7.5. To reduce someone's property value is not okay. This must be made pono again. There is a huge section on climate change and things that will be affected. This needs to be furtherresearched. There are over 1900 credentialed scientist that say there is no climate danger. Here is thepdf showing the scientist and what country they are from. https://clintel.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/WCD-241023.pdf John Coleman, the first weather man for Good MorningAmerica and the Founder of the Weather Channel has gone on CNN and other media outlets stating,"There is no climate danger". He explain the reason for this narrative is the investors, in renewableenergy, want to make these changes. Hilo does not have a Community Development Plan. How can a Big Island General Plan move forwardwithout that? Hilo is 22% of the island. 1.13 under "Increase the biodiversity and resilience of native habitats" reads, "Incentivize private landmanagement practices that protect and enhance natural resource values and, when appropriate, pursuethe acquisition of lands for the protection of natural resources." "Incentives" mean more taxes."Protection" means more rules. Who's "values" is this plan referring too because it's not the locals?"Pursue the acquisition of lands" does this say they are going to pursing taking people's privateproperty? Again with "protection of natural resources". This plan should be focused on people growingmore food and it is doing the exact opposite! This plan wants to turn land into "conservation". The exact opposite is what is needed for Big Island!We need to turn land into Ag Villages and grow more food! Steve Shropshire, a resident of Papaikou,has created an Ag Villages plan.
Ag Village to add to the General Plan: Papaikou Ag Village Objectives: https://www.standtogetherhawaii.com/_files/ugd/86fc0c_2cb1cc6d604f4cdd971ad40831c745bc.pdf Papaikou SitePlan: https://www.standtogetherhawaii.com/_files/ugd/86fc0c_5e4cdb02efeb46a5ae949a3579aff00d.pdf Papaikou Development: https://www.standtogetherhawaii.com/_files/ugd/86fc0c_c2af52c8b3c645b1a6868a724eee8304.pdf A Hawaiian born Kanaka revised the Collaborative Biocultural Stewardship that is in the plan. You cansee it in the pdf below: PartOne:https://www.standtogetherhawaii.com/_files/ugd/86fc0c_0a1d5be8f1d140069415f7b691725786.pdfPart Two: https://86fc0cbd-8207-4076-85fa-5a62e4e933b4.usrfiles.com/ugd/86fc0c_ecc498ba192d4a7689ebf31c3681c2ec.pdfHere is a longer revised version of the plan from locals: https://www.standtogetherhawaii.com/_files/ugd/86fc0c_b34739e4c99c461685de4c0207bf286e.pdfThe way this plan is written is very far from what will support our island. Mahalo, Kim Cobb-Adams Stroud
From:Rebecca Melendez
To:LPCtestimony; WPCtestimony; cdp@hawaii.gov; Planning General Plan; Villegas, Rebecca; Kimball, Heather; Kagiwada, Jennifer; Onishi, Dennis; Kierkiewicz,Ashley; Kanealii-Kleinfelder, Matt; Galimba, Michelle M.; Inaba, Holeka; Hustace, JamesSubject:Please stand with YOUR community and vote UNFAVORABLE on the 2045 General Plan
Date:Wednesday, March 5, 2025 3:14:39 PM
Attachments:image.pngUnclear General Plan.doc
Aloha Council Members, Why are you continuing to favor this plan when the community is clearly opposing it? This petition Opposing the General Plan has almost 200 signatures and is growing https://www.change.org/p/we-oppose-hawai-i-planning-department-s-2045-general-plan-we-stand-for-a-new-director. This is almost the full size ofyour chambers. Please start standing with the community and vote UNFAVORABLE for this General Plan because YOU are supposedto support our voices. Continuing to vote in favor of this General Plan when 100% of the community at the meeting andI'm sure emailing you are OPPOSING this plan, is showing signs that you are being paid off and this is a seriousoffense. The average citizen cannot understand most of the plan because the County Planning Department has disrespected ourcommunity by writing a General Plan that is so vague and extremely unclear. I feel they did this so they would be ableto change meanings later. The plan does not fully explain their "Ordinances, Impact Fees, Ordinance Fees, Regulations, Master Plans"... All theydo is mention these, but they offer no explanation of what they mean. The community has a right to fully understandwhat all of these mean. Where are their full explanations, since they want to implement more fees and moreregulations? The County Planning Department has extreme changes in it’s General Plan? Has there ever been a plan with this many changes? Has there ever been a plan that has so much overreach in control/power? Can the council keep past General Plan's instead of this one? Because this plan is so extreme in changing Land UseTitles, putting in a lot more Regulations, Ordinances, a Smart Grid, and Broadband that the island doesn’t need, andcompletely changing the way we live on island. Does an Island really need wifi under the roads? This is what their Smart Grid would do. Does an Island really needBroadband?
35.i Develop best management practices for the development and maintenance of golf courses in collaboration withgovernment, private and nonprofit agencies, and other stakeholders.
Why does the county want to develop more golf courses when we need to stand up and help save our corals.
Golf courses use a lot of poisons to keep their lands weed-free, and these poisons runoff into the ocean, causing algae bloomsand other pollutions.
"Coral Bleaching is occurring more frequently in Hawai'i. Across the Hawaiian Archipelago, coral bleaching has increased infrequency and severity since 1996. The last major bleaching event in 2014-2015 had catastrophic Impacts state-wide… Thiswas the third major bleaching episode in Hawaiʻi over the last 6 years. The frequency of these events is unprecedented in thearchipelago. NOAA scientists and partners have determined that the key drivers of the bleaching were environmental factors(such as heat stress, depth, and surface light) and human impacts (sewage effluent and urban run-off). "
https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/feature-story/cautionary-tale-2019-coral-bleaching-event-hawaii#:~:text=Coral%20Bleaching%20Is%20Occurring%20more,had%20catastrophic%20impacts%20state%2Dwide
"Damage to the Hawaiian corals is "widespread," especially in areas, such as bays, where there is limited water flow andtemperatures heat up quickly, DeMartini said."
https://abcnews.go.com/US/hawaiis-coral-reefs-peril-researchers-restore-coral-ecosystems/story?id=101486998
‘Strong Correlation’ Between Overtourism and Coral Reef Degradation
Co-authored by Greg Asner, director of the ASU Center for Global Discovery and Conservation Science in the Julie AnnWrigley Global Futures Laboratory, and leader of the largest coral reef monitoring program on the planet, the study in questionfound that there was a “strong correlation” between what has been dubbed “overtourism” and significant coral reefdegradation.
“I know these reefs extremely well, so I’m careful to not say correlation is causation,” explains Asner. “But there was a reallystrong correlation – even I was impressed.”
https://earth.org/coral-reef-degredation/
Department of Aquatic Resources DAR has a full report on West Hawai’i reefs, and they show that over 60% of the reefs arenow covered with Turf Algae. https://dlnr.hawaii.gov/dar/files/2024/12/ar_hrs188-2025.pdf
DAR Reports that turf algae is the dominate coverage in West Hawai'i reefs.
What is Turf Algae? Look at the above link on page 78.
"Algal turfs characteristically trap ambient sediments and smother corals and other competitors
for space by gradual encroachment."
image.png
https://www.livingoceansfoundation.org/algae-on-the-reef-faces-functions-of-seaweed/
“For many people, algae on the reef is synonymous with environmental decline. Often the presence of algae is associatedwith terms such as “harmful algal bloom” and “eutrophication,” which imply the negative effects of too much algae in anenvironment. It’s true that under some conditions algae can grow uncontrolled and become a problem for reef-building corals,as they compete for both space and sunlight on the reef. One thing that can lead to an overgrowth of algae is an excess ofnutrients in the water, either naturally from upwelling of nearby nutrient-rich waters, or from anthropogenic sources, such asagricultural runoff from land. These nutrients act as fertilizers for plants on the reef, allowing them to grow very quickly.”
37.3 Prioritize new housing including the missing middle in or near mixed-use developments, urban growth areas withinfrastructure, and near existing and proposed transit centers.
There are year’s worth of developments that have been approved that haven’t started construction yet. Please read this petitionand see all the News Articles that prove that Island resources need to start becoming the focus rather than continuing to keep
approving more and more developments. https://www.change.org/p/help-big-island-resources-and-infrastructure-stay-safe-for-all-who-live-here-and-visit
37.c Assess and amend the land use and building regulations and explore fiscal opportunities to support universal designprinciples and ADA accessibility for more physically accessible housing.
They need to wait for all the many homes they have already approved for future development to see how the island’sresources handles all of them because as of today the resources and infrastructure are seriously overtaxed.
News Articles Proving What is Happening to Big Island Resources:
“Hawai'i State News Update: Hawaiian Electric initiates rolling outages throughout Big Island February 13, 2024 · 5:23PM HST* Updated February 14, 2024 · 4:21 PM
The emergency outages are being initiated in various areas around the entire island to prevent loss of power to an evengreater number of customers. The timing and extent of the outages will depend on the amount of demand on the systemand the availability of generators.” https://bigislandnow.com/2024/02/13/hawaii-island-customers-asked-to-reduce-electricity-use/
“LOCAL NEWS
HECO issues rolling power outages around Big Island by: Emily Cervantes Posted: Feb 13, 2024 / 05:11 PM HSTUpdated: Feb 13, 2024 / 09:12 PM HST Hawaiian Electric initiated rolling outages for Big Island after several largegenerators became unavailable and reduced output Tuesday night.”https://www.khon2.com/local-news/heco-releases-conservation-alert-for-big-island/
"Here's how power outages can have repercussions for Hawaiʻi's water supply Hawaiʻi Public Radio | By SavannahHarriman-PotePublished February 13, 2024 at 10:59 AM HST
Water departments on Oʻahu and Hawaiʻi Island have advised customers to conserve water ahead of possible storm-related power outages this month.
But what does the power grid have to do with the water supply?
It is impossible to separate Hawaiʻi's power system from its water system, said Kawika Uyehara, deputy director ofHawaiʻi County's Department of Water Supply." https://www.hawaiipublicradio.org/local-news/2024-02-13/residents-on-hawaii-island-and-oahu-are-asked-to-conserve-water-amid-power-outages
U.S. Hawaii is "on the verge of a greater catastrophe," locals say, as water crisis continuesBy Li Cohen
Updated on: April 11, 2024 / 8:23 AM EDT / CBS News
In Hawaii, one of the most important sayings is ola i ka wai, "water is life" — a phrase that not only sums up what itmeans to exist on an island, but what it means to live, period. But now, one of the largest of the island chain's landmasses is facing a triple threat to its sole freshwater source, and if it isn't addressed soon, one community member says,"we're in deep trouble." https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hawaii-water-crisis-climate-change/
This is a map of Power Outages on the Big Island. This map wouldn't have been created if Power Outages were not aserious issue on island. https://www.hawaiianelectric.com/safety-and-outages/power-outages/hawaii-island-outage-map
“Hawaiian Electric is reporting that several large generators on the Big Island are experiencing a range of issues andmay lead to the need for rolling outages if supply does not meet demand."
https://www.reddit.com/r/BigIsland/comments/1bnuar3/hawaiian_electric_is_reporting_that_several_large/?rdt=52660
"NewsHawaiian Electric asking Big Island customers to conserve power due to down generators
March 25, 2024 · 11:49 AM HST
Other News Articles:
https://www.kitv.com/news/local/rolling-power-outages-possible-on-big-island/article_1811581e-cae6-11ee-bec6-bf9467cc02f6.html?fbclid=IwY2xjawIqwUNleHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHQKMTNPT8EedBYRidyQEoPWlese5n4dRl-6FeuHh1nYCoQ8kqtESAhgXjw_aem_9WNsZM4cllevOmbCMPZGNg
https://www.bigislandvideonews.com/2024/10/17/water-supply-issues-statement-on-red-flag-warning-power-shutoffs/
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hawaii-water-crisis-climate-change/
https://hawaiibest.us/2023/09/11/big-island-now-poll-no-27-whats-the-best-way-to-extend-the-life-of-the-big-islands-only-remaining-landfill/
https://www.civilbeat.org/2024/04/acute-problems-plaguing-big-islands-wastewater-treatment-systems-prompt-epa-crackdown/
38.1 Enable data-driven research to support and maintain a housing inventory program that monitors existing housing.
What are they going to monitor, and why? Are they taking our privacy away?
39.8 Encourage the development of workforce housing within or near urban growth areas and employment centers and requirelarge new developments that create a demand for housing to provide affordable workforce housing.
There are years worth of housing developments that haven't started construction yet, and Hawaii Planning want to "Prioritize"even more housing developments when they need to "Prioritize" the islands resources and infrastructure because they are beingovertaxed today. Please read this petition that has almost 600 signatures: https://www.change.org/p/help-big-island-resources-and-infrastructure-stay-safe-for-all-who-live-here-and-visit
Where is the map that shows all the already approved developments that haven't even started yet so we can see how they arecreating the Big Island? I've asked Senator Kanuha to send me the link to this map because why is Hawaii Planning wantingmore developments when the island's resources are overtaxed today.
35.r Develop and implement a cemeteries master plan for the siting of future cemeteries.
What is their “cemetery master plan”?
36.b Develop a medical center TOD master plan and rezone it as a Regional Center TOD.
What is the "TOD master plan” and how will they “rezone” it?
19.a Continue to adopt the County Street design manual as the County’s complete street design program/policy.
What is the “County Street design manual”? I don’t see this information in the General Plan.
20.e Adopt a Complete Streets ordinance.
What is a "Complete Streets ordinance"? Another regulation? 25.7 Maintain an Asset Management Program aimed at utilizing maintenance plans to prolong the life of our utilities as well asreduce whole-life costs.
What is their “Asset Management Program”?
25.a Develop and adopt an Impact Fees Ordinance to aide in the expansion of public utilities.
What is an "Impact Fees Ordinance"? More regulations? 26.5 Ensure the highest quality of water is reserved for the most valuable end-use.
What do they consider “the most valuable end-use” for water? The resorts or the community?
26.6 Encourage the design of large development projects (200+ units) in the North Kohala, South Kohala, North Kona, SouthKona, and Kaʻū Districts to be as water neutral as reasonably possible through water conservation, recharge, and reusemeasures to reduce the water footprint.
How can 200+ units be water-neutral?
Why is the county encouraging big developments when the island has resource issues with developments that arealready here? Are they NOT paying attention to island resources? Please read this petition:
https://www.change.org/p/help-big-island-resources-and-infrastructure-stay-safe-for-all-who-live-here-and-visit
26.7 Promote best practices in sustainable water collection and use for private water systems.
What does this mean, “for private water systems”?
27.i Streamline the sewer connection loan program.
What is this loan program? Is the island going into more debt because of it?
26.e Maintain the water master plan to consider water yield, present and future demand, alternative sources of water,guidelines, and policies for the issuing of water commitments.
What is their “water master plan”? What would be their water guidelines and policies for issuing water?
31.c Develop and adopt an Impact Fees Ordinance to aide in the expansion of County services and facilities.
What is an “Impact Fees Ordinance”? Another regulation?
13.e Amend Zoning Code to:i. Establish a TOD overlay zone project district with a minimum size of 15 acres.ii. Create a TND overlay zone for existing zoned lands within identified residential and commercial zoning districts.iii. Allow for residential uses in ML and MCX zoning districts.iv. Support innovative uses of alternative energy, agriculture, aquaculture, and others, in MCX zoning district
What exactly does “Establish a TOD overlay zone project district with a minimum size of 15 acres” mean?
What does a "TND overlay zone" look like?
What does ML and MCX stand for? These are not in their glossary, and I can't find them in the GP or online.
This General Plan is NOT CLEAR AND NEEDS TO BE OPPOSED, IF NOT ONLY FOR THE REASON THAT IT ISNOT CLEAR.
14.1 Support the State Land Use reclassification to Rural in alignment with the General Plan Rural designation.
14.b Amend the zoning districts currently listed as Family Agricultural District (FA) and the Residential and AgriculturalDistricts (RA) to be consistent with the Rural designation and to allow for home occupations that do not negatively impactrural character
Would this mean the county would have the right not to approve homes on "Rural Designated" lands if they feel it can“negatively impact rural character”? Are they over-reaching their control?
19.6 Use traffic demand management to aid in reducing traffic congestion by targeting an increase of active transportationmode share to 10 percent (bicycling, walking, micro-mobility)
What do they mean by "Use traffic demand management to aid in reducing traffic congestion"? Will they somehowlimit cars?
What is the General Plan Rural Designation?
14.2 Support reclassification/rezoning of appropriate General Plan Rural designated areas where an intermediate land use and awell-defined buffer between Urban and Productive Agricultural areas are consistent with the surrounding uses and ruralcharacter.
What is the "reclassification/rezoning of appropriate General Plan Rural designated..."?
30.3 Collaborate with utility companies to incentivize the underground siting of electrical and telecommunications facilitieswithin public rights-of-way What does underground sitting mean (they spelled sitting wrong)? They do not make this clear because they do not want us toknow they want to lay down wifi cable below our streets causing more traffic in our 2 lane roads. At least this is what I think itmeans from my research of a "Smart Grid" and "Broadband".
30.5 Siting of new communications facilities shall comply with performance standards and site colocation as stated in theCode.
The above sentences are confusing because it looks like the county doesn’t want us to understand that to create“telecommunications facilities fully,” they must put Cable underground; hence, they use the wording “ undergroundsiting.” So, we don’t fully understand the consequences of laying cable under our streets.
They seem to want to confuse us, because “sitting” sounds better than causing serious traffic to dig up all the roads to lay downthis kind of cable all over the Big Island, which will cost billions.
30.b Develop standards for the siting and construction of wireless telecommunication facilities.
This site explains what the General Plan doesn't explain about "siting and construction" https://primex.com/fiber-optic-internet-going-underground/
"The widespread adoption of Internet of Things (IoT) and smart home technology has internet service providers (ISPs) andintegrators on the hunt for the most effective methods of broadband delivery for many scenarios.
"The cable will be closer to the surface and more vulnerable to damage. In this case, a more expensive cable that can withstandcontact will be required. Cables buried in clay will also need to be of higher quality because the clay can hold stones and pushthem against the cable. In clay, the trench will also need to be much deeper.
In developed areas, the existing infrastructure can be problematic. Digging through concrete sidewalks and roads is costly anddisruptive."
The traffic on Big Island has been increasing every month, and they want to dig up our two lane roads to "sit" their "broadbandinfrastructure'? THEY ARE NOT ADDRESS INFRASTRACTURE ISSUES ON ISLAND.
30.9 Alleviate barriers and assist broadband projects with navigating through the regulatory permitting process.
They haven't show any research for the health risks of a smart grid and broadband because wifi will be on all the timeon our streets. We need to see the research for the health risks of this.
What is their "regulatory permitting process"? They don't explain this.
27.15 Prioritize the use of gray water in areas connected to County water and not connected to County wastewater.
Why doesn’t the county start looking for new inventions to help the island instead of traditional sources when the island’spopulation is steadily growing and needs new ideas to help? They could start considering using inventions like these:
https://ecofriend.com/innovative-products-designed-capture-reuse-gray-water.html
https://newsroom.ucla.edu/stories/gray-water-clean-up-yoram-cohen-271642
https://www.greenprophet.com/2015/04/10-inventions-to-save-earths-water/
35.f Update the County of Hawaiʻi Recreation Plan to reflect newly identified recreational priorities.
The county has sent out letters changing private Land Use Titles to recreational land. Does this mean they will belooking for more lands to change their Land Use Titles into recreational lands, thereby taking their property away bynot allowing them to pass it down to family or sell it?
Why is it legal for the county to take private lands away from people to give their lands to recreation? It's NOTRIGHT!
I heard these people would still have to pay the property tax on their land, which the county wants to turn intorecreational land, is this going to happen?
Please stand with all these reasons why this 2045 General Plan needs to be UNFAVORABLE. PLEASE STAND WITHYOUR COMMUNITY. Sincerely,Rebecca Melendez
From:Sherrie Galdeira
To:WPCtestimony
Subject:Testimony in Support of Collaborative BioCultural Stewardship in the General Plan 2045
Date:Wednesday, March 5, 2025 7:52:08 PM
Aloha,
I am a resident of Volcano, Hawaii, 96785 zip code. I am extremely interested in adding
additional protections for our native Ohi'a forest, which is being decimated by unpermittedgrubbing and grading, feral ungulates, ROD and invasive species. We need much stronger
ordinances and building codes at the County level to protect this natural resource for the nativewildlife, watershed, and economic viability of our community. I support the Collaborative
Biocultural Stewardship in the General Plan 2045, and strengthening of the current ordinancesgoing forward. In addition, there needs to be a facilitation of property tax incentives to the
lowest level for small size lot owners ( 9000 SQ FT) wishing to put their lots into Native Ohi'aForest conservation.
Mahalo,
Sherrie GaldeiraPO Box 1265
Volcano, HI 96785(c) 808-345-9641
(e) sherrie.galdeira@gmail.com--
Cooper Center CouncilSherrie Galdeira, President-Elect
(p) 808-967-7800(e) Email us
(w) Cooper Center Council(a) 19-4030 Wright Road
P. O. Box 1000 Volcano, HI 96785
--
HCAN 'Ohana Leadership Council Member
PO Box 23198Honolulu, HI 96823
Phone: 808-531-5502 | Email: info@hawaii-can.org
HAWAI'I LEGAL SUPPORT SERVICES
A Hilo Businesses, LLC EntityPARALEGAL | NOTARY PUBLIC | CIVIL PROCESS SERVER
PO Box 1265
Volcano, HI 96785
(c) 808.345.9641 | (e) hilobusinesses@gmail.com
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTE: This e-mail and any attachments are confidential and may be protected by
legal privilege. If you are not the intended recipient, any disclosure or use of this e-mail or anyattachments are prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify the senderimmediately and delete this copy from your system.
From:Ali Eden
To:WPCtestimony; LPCtestimony; Council Testimony; Kimball, Heather; Kagiwada, Jennifer; Onishi, Dennis;Kierkiewicz, Ashley; Kanealii-Kleinfelder, Matt; Villegas, Rebecca; Galimba, Michelle M.; Inaba, Holeka; Hustace,James; cohmayor@hawaiicounty.gov
Subject:General Plan 2045
Date:Thursday, March 6, 2025 12:25:40 PM
Aloha,
PLEASE do the right thing and vote NO to this horrific plan! It is obviously not by ourpeople or for our people. It is a land and power grab. Who in their right mind would want
to destroy our beautiful island with this tyranny? I would hope no one living here! It is sodisturbing to think people must be getting paid off to go along with this agenda. People
are tired of government overreach and being ignored. At least we were heard regardingHB 1118, one tiny victory against a barrage of bills aimed at taking our freedom.
Mahalo
From:Dan and Shannon Fisher
To:WPCtestimony
Subject:Vote "No" we do not recommend Hawaii GP 2045
Date:Thursday, March 6, 2025 5:13:02 PM
Aloha,
Please vote no on the Hawaii GP 2045. The following are a few concerns to consider;
1. Homeowner is not mentioned.Please recommend Stakeholder change to the following: "Local Communities”. Local
Communities are local Big Island farmers, homeowners, renters, organizations, businesses,and individuals who live on Big Island or have property on Big Island that will be personally
affected by projects, decisions, or activities in the general plan. Effective local communityengagement and management are crucial for the success and sustainability of any initiative, as
it helps ensure that diverse perspectives and interests are considered.
2. Improve our current infrastructure. Our current electric infrastructure can not support themodel in this plan. We rely on bio fuels and they should not be diminished. It would be too
costly, in fact unattainable, to promote a " green agenda".
There is a huge part of the plan dedicated to "Climate Change". However, why do
most experts state there is NO climate danger? Climate Experts Speak Out Against
Climate Danger Click Here!
3. The island needs sustainable development that prioritizes the well-being of
residents and the conservation of the island's resources.
Mahalo for your attention,
Dan and Shannon Fisher
From:Karen Alvarado
To:WPCtestimony; LPCtestimony; Council Testimony; Kimball, Heather; Kagiwada, Jennifer; Onishi, Dennis;Kierkiewicz, Ashley; Kanealii-Kleinfelder, Matt; Villegas, Rebecca; Galimba, Michelle M.; Inaba, Holeka; Hustace,James; cohmayor@hawaiicounty.gov
Subject:Vote Unfavorable Recommendation on the Hawaii GP 2045!
Date:Thursday, March 6, 2025 2:01:19 PM
The Big Island General Plan is very long and complicated. I know most of these
political documents are written so that the average person cannot understand them
and make it so it is overwhelming. One has to study it throughly and most will not and
cannot as it is so hard to comprehend.
However, owning property and land here on the Northern tip I can see this plan is not
in favor of the people who have lived and worked their land for years. I am so
disappointed that this plan would even be recommended. I am not sure who you
people are and why you would even favor it. I wonder if our government is putting
plants into these positions and they aren't even living here and don't care about the
people or the state of Hawaii. This is a beloved place and you are planning to
devastate this beautiful place and the people. Please wake up and let God guide you
for the benefit of all of us. It's becoming a very scary place to live.
Thanks for your consideration.
Concerns Include:
Land Use Titles changing Residential to Recreation DROPS property value
The plan could set up MANY opportunities for the State to take your land &
Rezone
The plan could regulate OFF-GRID living
The plan will further STRESS the electric grid by increasing prices. They want
to create a Smart Grid and Broadband infrastructure that will dig up roads to
lay WIFI cable underground that will be on all the time
Most of the Big Island will change to Conservation land (only a park can be on
it) or Natural land (no people, buildings, or farming). How will Hawaii
Homelands give land back to Hawaiians?
AND MORE!
From:Silvah N Gould
Subject:DO NOT Recommend the Hawaii GP 2045!
Date:Thursday, March 6, 2025 2:52:28 PM
Attachments:1741308456111blob.jpg1741308481368blob.jpg
Aloha Commissioners,
This Hawaii General Plan 2045 is not Pono for Hawaii. It is based on “United
Nations Agenda 21”. This is an Invasive Species and should be eradicated for
the islands to thrive and live.
While you are skippin-and-a-hoppin about in your Wonderland, somebody in
the dark had been scheming and plotting to take ALL the Wonder and the Land!
Agenda 21 is the agenda for the 21st century. It has been re-branded in many
names. Case in point: Hawaii General Plan 2045! 2045 is a milestone within the 100
year (21st century) plan.
Agenda 21 is on a global scale: There's a worldwide movement to control you,
believe it or not, by seizing your private property and resources and is taking root at a
local level. This is a United Nations agenda to establish global government through
radical environmentalism. It's a global plan and is being implemented locally through
“Hawaii County General Plan 2045”.
Agenda 21 Sustainable Development Plan (or Goals - SDGs) is the action plan to
INVENTORY and CONTROL ALL:
· Land
· Water
· Minerals
· Plants
· Animals
· Construction
· Means of Production
· Education
· Energy
· Law Enforcement
· Healthcare
· Information
· Means of Transportation
· HUMAN BEINGS IN THE WORLD
It’s a comprehensive plan of action for total world domination.
American Planning Association's - 12-week long communications boot camp: where
they re-indoctrinate, re-propagandize planners and they told them that they need to
inoculate elected officials against their constituents for speaking the truth about the
Agenda 21 SDGs. If people are aware, people will reject regionalizing their
government by an outside unelected entity.
We ALL live here and have families; we should not be selling our GOD given rights
and freedoms to the few that would only want to take control and monetize …and
leaving the rest of us outside of DEI (Diversity, Equity and Inclusion)!
If Agenda 21 is a “conspiracy theory”, then why are the UN’s sustainable
development goals on the Hawaii website? See website screenshots below - the
SDGs are the same!
United Nation Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) posted online:
https://sdgs.un.org/goals
Inline image
Hawaii (Website) - Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) - the same goals as the
United Nation's
https://planning.hawaii.gov/sustainability/sustainable-development-goals/
Make General Plan 2045 for, of and by the people of the island of Hawaii.
Mahalo!
From:nancy wood
To:WPCtestimony; LPCtestimony; Council Testimony; Kimball, Heather; Kagiwada, Jennifer; Onishi, Dennis;Kierkiewicz, Ashley; Kanealii-Kleinfelder, Matt; Villegas, Rebecca; Galimba, Michelle M.; Inaba, Holeka; Hustace,James; cohmayor@hawaiicounty.gov
Subject:Strongly oppose Hawaii GP 2045
Date:Friday, March 7, 2025 8:55:36 AM
According to the map I've seen, My land will be eligible to become a state owned park.
Obviously, I oppose this.. Yes I will be dead in 2045 (most likely) but my children and grandchildren love our land and would NEVER sell it..much less give it to the state! How dare you
try to slip this in without public awareness!!! and why??? This Plan smells foul. It is poorlywritten. No one I know has heard of this! Is the idea to sneak this by the people of the big
island while we stumble around in shock from the damage our current president and his boyare doing to our democracy? Who are you to secretly decide the future of the Island? You will
be dead by then too (or getting close). I Nancy Wood, strongly oppose this plan. Hawaii GP 2045!
Adamantly,Nancy A Wood