HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-09-25 1250 Oceanside LLC 2nd Exhibit List, Exhibit 20 (PL-BOA-2024-000104) CARLSMITH BALL LLP
PATRICK K. WONG 5878
75-5722 Kuakini Highway, Suite 208
Kailua Kona, Hawai`i 96740
Tel. No. (808) 329-6464
Facsimile No. (808) 329-9450
pwong@carlsmith.com
DEREK B. SIMON 10612
1001 Bishop Street, Suite 2100
Honolulu, Hawai`i 96813
Tel. No. (808) 523-2500
Facsimile No. (808) 523-0842
dsimon@carlsmith.com
IAN R. WESLEY-SMITH 10626
121 Waianuenue Avenue
P.O. Box 686
Hilo, Hawai`i 96721-0686
Tel. No. (808) 969-8416
Facsimile No. (808) 935-7975
iwesley-smith@carlsmith.com
Attorneys for
1250 OCEANSIDE, LLC
BEFORE THE BOARD OF APPEALS
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
COUNTY OF HAWAII
In the Matter of Appeal Case No. PL-BOA-2024-000104
of 1250 OCEANSIDE, LLC'S SECOND
EXHIBIT LIST; EXHIBIT 20;
1250 OCEANSIDE, LLC CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
From the decision of the Planning Director, Hearing:
dated April 29, 2024 (Docket No. 24-0001) Date: October 11, 2024
Time: 9:30 a.m. in Kona
4892-8689-8153.2.051730-00058
1250 OCEANSIDE, LLC'S SECOND EXHIBIT LIST
Appellant 1250 Oceanside, LLC ("Oceanside"),by and through its attorneys, Carlsmith
Ball LLP, hereby identifies the following exhibits that may be presented at the hearing currently
scheduled for October 11, 2024, and/or during any further proceedings in this matter.
Exhibits 1-11 where filed with Oceanside's General Petition for Appeal of Decision of
the Planning Director, dated May 28, 2024, and Exhibits 12-19 were filed with Oceanside's
Exhibit List on September 18, 2024. Exhibit 20 is filed with this Second Exhibit List.
1250
Oceanside's Description of Exhibit
Exhibit No.
1 Declaratory Order; Exhibits "A"— "C"
2 Petition for Declaratory Ruling; Exhibits "1"— "12"
3 Supplement to Petition for Declaratory Ruling, submitted on February 7, 2024;
Exhibits "A"— "C"
4 Hawai`i County Ordinance No. 96-7
5 Hawai`i County Ordinance No. 96-8
6 Development Agreement, dated April 20, 1998
7 Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief; Appendixes "A" — "B";
Summons
8a Order Re: Defendant 1250 Oceanside LLC's Motion to Dismiss Complaint,
Filed March 31, 2023 [Dkt. 1], Filed May 11, 2023 [Dkt. 15]
8b Order Granting in Part County Defendants' Motion to Dismiss the Complaint for
Declaratory and Injunctive Relief, File March 31, 2023 [Dkt. 1], Filed May 25,
2023 [Dkt. 21], and Staying Proceedings Pending Referral to County of Hawai`i
Planning Department
9 Letter from County of Hawai`i Planning Department dated January 31, 2011,
approving Variance No. VAR 10-027
4892-8689-8153.2.051730-00058 2
1250
Oceanside's Description of Exhibit
Exhibit No.
10 Hawai`i County Council Resolution No. 317-12
11 Construction Plans (Coversheets) for Hokuli`a Phase 1, Package 1 & 2 (Sub 98-
124)
12 Mayor Rule 1 (Development Agreements)
13 Shoreline Park Management and Public Access Plan,November 1998
14 Grant of Easement and Covenants, dated September 16, 1999 (Shoreline Park)
15 Hawai`i County Council Resolution No. 316-12
16 Hawai`i County Council Resolution No. 20-12
17 Dedication Deed(Kona Scenic Park), dated December 12, 2016
18 County. of Hawaii v. C&J Coupe Fam. Ltd. P'ship, 124 Haw. 281, 299, 242
P.3d 1136, 1154 (2010)
19 Photographs, taken June 26, 2023
20 Annotated maps from County of Hawai`i Real Property Tax Office website
Oceanside reserves the right to supplement this Second Exhibit List and identify
additional exhibits not expressly noted herein in response to any pleadings, memorandum,
arguments, exhibits, or witnesses identified or filed by any party.
4892-8689-8153.2.051730-00058 3
DATED: Honolulu, Hawai`i, September 25, 2024.
/s/Derek B. Simon
PATRICK K. WONG
DEREK B. SIMON
IAN R. WESLEY-SMITH
Attorneys for
1250 OCEANSIDE, LLC
4892-8689-8153.2.051730-00058 4
EXHIBIT 20
4
ti
' 41r a ..\,,..... ,■
s,
41161 " `..
t-w ti r 4
8. •
1 Ackerman Ranch Inc. ,'
(TMK: (3)7-9-012:004) --- Ii,Mauka Halekii Extension •
•',�
4. ._,�_._ (TMK(3) 8-1-036:999) .___-• ---'w. Ir. -_ 0bF 'I
r I.`., 4,a 1° aar
ms .
i 141
6 ( Q C . liI I, .• ' {
l i r'
(
J . .. . i r., I Connector Road
.1 (TMK (3) 8-1-004:070) s J \-
' F Mamalahoa Bypass
: a
iit
„ s
xI "
fit ,. a
a1111.
% f , Makai Halekii Extension " r , •
(TM,K(3) 8-1-004:070)
r3Connector Road
(TMK (3) 8-1-030:055) o ' \ 4 `b l
a`a 1
it,_.,_. )_ . _--
C &J C• oupe Family
Limited Partnership
(TMK: (3)8-1-007:045)
r.
r >
i r'
EXHIBIT 20
iiimmix, If: ,r
IF n. y
A. . b
iiAn
Fi"#k.°
' — Ackerman Ranch Inc
(TMK:
11
(3) 7-9-012:004) '` .t
. - ^ 1
.^ w a
Or
$ yr*"
if 1
t
1.
J "
Connector Road
(TMK (3) 8-1-004:070)
m y .
r iii?
4 M ,miµ �..'` 5ww ifs"
,.,'
yHy*1� uyRlf+�d� A. % t ' fdF w, T"
'w..
fisa i*, • %.* '00, A f.s Y J� p4 OM1 wtw ,
,.
"' M4
Liow
a
Connector Roadr , -,
(TMK (3) 84-030:055) ill . , a. 1I " ''
e..
:fin ��. ' Y� �r _nay' " ic, an,..,,,,, N IWw771 y ,'.
q n
MI C &J Coupe Family Limited `
„o\
Partnership
(TMK: (3) 8-1-007:045) k .
'+
r`
r
.
r
ei
i
r4
. .
41'4:
i M abs °
,
•
� � fit. o + w � s' ,r s iZ`f a,' t . 6 7 '1.
�" �
it
... 0 * , it:st �� � m u� n t,, Yu „41w44 1 ;:
0
u " votwax*is n._ �- � 4 .-. 1,
f1 v" . t I. d ' ;e :1' Wr gym" ' S�
`�' „� Makai Halekii Extension , �� '�
�.; _f (TMK (3) 8-1-004:070 ,iti ���
Nes
wy..,,,..... •may,, k ^.. . ” t e S
, Alf 0 0 .,„
it
? 1 41"11;-7, '111411'46*1 IP.' i . . , **11,,„--:*.tif -''',1., .p.,.0 ,
110110,
a .
o
,,rrNo "R
ito
mow..,, „nri Wy
Wit, '' s' k 4 t' 01 IP
1.
1.
r y
� � #+ .. d ��w4
t ^ ft
tl yy n a
'w�^M
�
"
y,p
M wp` owwue '' — 9AIW
Y. �' t M' ,�1�. 'mow'' 1 .t
4 V uYl�l Y
.,. Pw
_
,
. . .,.. .„
. ,..
. ..
A .1 "Lk ' ' ' I. h - . ,
. ' $ I * ..4,.. i f ' ' •
. .t. .
se . . •
.0. -11.•s, —
11
, . A. .•.• ,.
, ,
. ..... k.. a , .
i •P ,
A
TOO'
1
vo wiet wipe 6 ' 4104 . . • . ,..
.I. . •Elp
7 114 • veer .4' 4 '''' •,..
7;«.,.
• P '''' ill ' - "' ih i- .
. 7. .
. a . .
•
,'. • °
? .
. 0., .
10 ,
' .
- • . .i . .
., 6
h-4,11 ,
. ..
- .
A
4 ,
ii . I ,
—
,-
,.. .
...
- -
4 Mauka Halekii Extension till •
. „
, •
%...7' .., .
IP.. ,...'
'I. (TMK (3) 8-1-036:999) i:„..
„,• ,
._ •.
.. , .
.. ..
, .. .
•,, .
• .
•
•
• -
.,... . ., ,,••• .. • ,
, .
•
. ..,.„„„ . .
1•,..
„ .
• ,n'',;,•,.., - .•• 44-.„
.. , • „c•::. , „.....,...• .H „ '''
'''.. . ..... . .4. Ie..
411C4':4
,.
tttic
0,
,'''fo' ..''...;&
ii
tli ,,,,,....„,,.. ..,,,,,,...„-, '.....i.-,
4:' 0...:
•'.- , . .
c
) 1.---7,----\
it , 0'. . 0.
,, ) \ „
ow -. - .
q
9.
•
-71 l' '''' -'"';'.e5":'"A''' \ \ ..),''''', ',1 '''','V'''''-.' ''..,,\ , _;.ii\
' ' \ ,„, '\ „,,,4( ').!,—.4'' ,...—''''-—1 ' '''2'.II..,——'--—'-- --. ' \ t
,.. _...... 7------1 - "''',.. ..,---,r \,„ . .r ,' ,----- i.,) / \-„
., ,,,..„.......
. , .
..
,....' „,
,., ..... \ \
1el / '''''''''''1, /.
, „,,,',.:,...7' '::,, ", ,,,,, ''";-'7:,:'17<,,,-.,, _.....,,.....----L,....-1 ,../
/
1 ' ,
,./>'—'"'-'''
....L.,-„„,
. .,.. ,
...,. ", ......
..
...,,,,,,,,,.......,_
". 11
. ,
. ',,...
„..,„
BEFORE THE BOARD OF APPEALS
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
COUNTY OF HAWAI`I
In the Matter of Appeal Case No. PL-BOA-2024-000104
of CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
1250 OCEANSIDE, LLC
From the decision of the Planning Director,
dated April 29, 2024 (Docket No. 24-0001)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was duly served upon
the following parties by electronic mail (E-Mail) on September 25, 2024:
ELIZABETH A. STRANCE, ESQ.
JEAN K. CAMPBELL, ESQ.
ELIZABETH B. BAILEY, ESQ.
Corporation Counsel, County of Hawaii
Hilo Lagoon Center
101 Aupuni Street, Suite 325
Hilo Hawaii 96720
Attorneys for Defendant
COUNTY OF HAWAII
KENNETH R. KUPCHAK
MARK M. MURAKAMI
TOREN K. YAMAMOTO
1003 Bishop Street, Suite 1600
Honolulu, Hawaii 96813
Attorneys for Intervenor
C & J COUPE FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
4892-8689-8153.2.051730-00058
DATED: Honolulu, Hawai`i, September 25, 2024.
/s/Derek B. Simon
PATRICK K. WONG
DEREK B. SIMON
IAN R. WESLEY-SMITH
Attorneys for
1250 OCEANSIDE, LLC
4892-8689-8153.2.051730-00058 6