HomeMy WebLinkAboutExhibit 7 (2)EXHIBIT 7
Alternate Plan History
Log
PLAN
DATE
Keep Reject JUSTIFICATION
,.`
Plan _1
8.24.11
X
Splits up too many communities
Elections
Plan _2
8.24.11
X
Elections
Plan-3
8.24.11
X
Splits up too many communities
Elections
Plan-4
8.24.11
X
Splits up too many communities
Elections
Plan-5
8.24.11
X
Splits up too many communities
Elections
Plan-6
Splits up too many communities and odd
8.24.11
X
Yen Chin
shaped districts
Plan_?
8.24.11
X
Splits up too many communities
J. Melrose
Plan-8
8.24.11
X
Splits up too many communities
Yen Chin
Plan-9
Splits up too many communities and creates
8.24.11
X
M. Middlesworth
only one Hilo District
Plan_10
8.24.11
X
Scott Stoddard
Plan-11
8.24.11
X
Splits up too many communities
M. Middlesworth
Plan-12
8.24.11
X
Deviations too high: +8% and -8%
J. Weatherford
Plan-13
8.24.11
X
Deviations too high
J. Weatherford
Plan-14
8.24.11
X
Splits up too many communities
Rene Siracusa
Plan-15
8.24.11
X
Based on size of districts
Koka Software
PLAN
DATE
Keep
Reject
JUSTIFICATION
Plan
Similar to Plan_10 that is being kept for
_16
Joe Carvalho
8.24.11
X
discussion purposes.
Plan 17
C. saiki for
8.24.11
X
Commissioners
Plan-18
Connectivity issues in Dist. 6 and splits
9.9.11
X
David Shiigi
Waimea into 3 Districts
Plan-19
9.9.11
X
M. Middlesworth
Plan_20
9.23.11
X
High deviations
Margaret Wille
Plan_21
9.23.11
X
High deviations
Commission
Plan-22
9.23.11
X
High deviations
Commission
Plan_23
9.23.11
X
Commission
Plan-24
9.23.11
X
Doesn't meet the contiguous test
Margaret Wille
Plan_25
9.23.11
X
Doesn't meet the contiguous test
Margaret Wille
Plan-26
9.23.11
X
High deviations
Mary Walker
Plan_27
9.23.11
X
Non connectivity in several districts
Scott Stoddard
Plan-28
9.23.11
X
Dru Kanuha
Plan-29
9.23.11
X
Duplicate of Plan-28
Jeff Melrose
Plan_30
9.23.11
X
Jeff Melrose
Plan_31
Lack of road connectivity and only 1 Puna
Brenda Ford
9.23.11
X
district
PLAN
DATE
Keep
Reject
JUSTIFICATION
Plan _32
9.23.11
X
Lack of road connectivity and only 1 Puna
Brenda Ford
district
Plan_33
9.23.11
X
District 5 is not compact
Brenda Ford
Plan-34
9.23.11
X
District 9 not compact
Brenda Ford
Plan_35
9.23.11
X
Connectivity issues
Brenda Ford
Plan-36
9.23.11
X
High deviations in Districts 8 and 9
Margaret Wille
Plan_37
9.23.11
X
High deviations in District 9 and connectivity
Margaret Wille
issues
Plan-38
9.23.11
X
High deviations
Margaret Wille
Plan-39
9.23.11
X
High deviations
Margaret Wille
Plan_40 (Plan-39
corrected)
9.23.11
X
Commission
Plan 10
10.21.11
X
High deviation in District 4 and no support
-
for it at Public Hearings
Plan-17
10.21.11
X
High deviations and splits Paradise Park
Plan_23
10.21.11
X
High deviations in 3 districts
Plan-28
10.21.11
X
Splits Waikbloa Village
Plan_30
10.21.11
X
Splits Volcano and Waikbloa Village
Plan 40
10.21.11
X
High deviations and splits Hawaiian Paradise
-
Park
PLAN
DATE
Keep
Reject
JUSTIFICATION
Plan _40
revised 10.17.11
10.21.11
X
Splits Keaukaha
Plan-40
revised 10.19.11
10.21.11
X
(Keep for further discussion)
Plan-46
10.21.11
X
(Save as Commission's Draft Plan-A)
Plan-40
revised 11.1.11
11.3.11
X
(Save as Commission's Draft Plan-B)
Draft Plan_B
11.10.11
Revised
(Save as Commission's Plan-C)
Draft Plan_B
11.10.11
Revised
(Save as Commission's Plan-B1)
Draft Plan_B
11.10.11
Revised
(Save as Commission's Plan-C)
Draft Plan_B
11.10.11
Revised
(Save as Commission's Final Draft Plan)
Commission's
Draft Plan
11.30.11
Revised
ACC °PTA; "D AS C DMML , 5 D ' INA L PAN