HomeMy WebLinkAbout2014-06-18, Committee on People with Disabilities Minutes
MAYOR’S COMMITTEE ON PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES
c/o Hawai‘i County Office of Aging,
1055 Kino‘ole Street,Suite 101, Hilo, Hawai‘i 96720
MINUTES
Wednesday, June 18, 2014
The County of Hawai‘i Mayor’s Committee on People with Disabilities met at
10:15 a.m. at the Aging and Disability Resource Center at 1055 Kino‘ole Street,
Hilo, Hawai‘i.
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Wesley Tanigawa, Vice Chair; Pauline Aughe, Chris
Cholas, Janice Mancini, James Souza, Laura Tobosa.
ABSENT:
Paige De Lima, Jessica Arruda, Dr. Ron Wagner-Wright, Raelene
Souza.
OTHERS PRESENT AND GUESTS:
Renee Schoen, Corporation Counsel;
Sandra Arriola, Aging; Alisa Mitchener, Teri Spinola-Campbell,P&R; Jesse Floyd,
DD Council; Clayton Honma, P&R; Tara Trujillo, Interpreter; Sam Nagasawa,
Karen Riedel, Paul Pascua, Ron Amundson, Kauila Haumea, Gail Yoshishige,
Pam Cabreira, Sada Anaud Kaur.
CALL TO ORDER
Chris had a question about what the by-law states regarding the amount of
meetings a member misses before they can be removed from the committee.
Renee stated that there is an HRS provision about that and she has discussed it
with Paige. Letters were sent out to people who have not attended meetings.
Dr. Ron has expressed his need to be removed from the committee.
W. Tanigawa,
Vice Chair, called the meeting to order at 10:15 a.m.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF THE APRIL 16, 2014 MEETING
W. Tanigawa
called for a motion to accept the minutes of the April 16 meeting.
L. TobosaJ. ManciniJ. Souza
moved to accept the minutes. seconded.
recused himself because he didn’t attend that meeting. Everyone else was in
favor. Motion passed.
STATEMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC (Agenda Items)
J. Floyd
stated that there is a statewide push to emphasize employment options
for people with disabilities. They are trying to get the different agencies to work
collaboratively to increase employment opportunities. He feels it is important for
the county to recognize its role as being a collaborator/facilitator to bring diverse
groups with business to the county to increase the perception that we can come
to recognize what barriers exist and what things work in order to provide valuable
services. Jesse would like this committee to take more of an active role in that
area.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Report from Recreation Ad Hoc
W. Tanigawa
stated that the next item on the agenda is Report from Recreation
Ad Hoc Committee.
Although a meeting was not held, J. Mancini, C. Cholas and P. Aughe offer the
following suggestions from discussions and phone calls with A. Mitchener.
J. Mancini
read the attached report.
(See Attached Report - Recreation Ad Hoc Committee)
Review of nomination.
W. Tanigawa
inquired if there was any feedback from the committee regarding
R. Schoen
nominations. stated that the committee would be receptive to
receiving nominations from the public and then the members would review it, edit
it or whatever, and then present it to the entire committee.
P. Aughe
explained to the public in attendance what the nominations were for
which is the committee would be creating a process in which we can recognize or
the mayor could recognize people who are doing really good work in the
community in various areas. So, we thank the public for always showing up.
NEW BUSINESS
W. TanigawaClayton Honma
welcomed who is the Director from the
Department of Parks and Recreation.
C. Honma
stated that Parks and Recreation has a four year completion plan and
is being monitored by the courts. The courts identified a few projects that they
wanted completed. A plan of what the cost would be was given to the courts
along with a timeline and timeframe of completion for each project. Currently
about 30% of it is completed. The plan came out to about $15.5 million over four
years to be spent on ADA improvements. That was incorporated with other
renovations for other facilities as well too. The following are the completed
renovations: the Kulaimano Community Center, Waiakea Rec. Center,
Laupahoehoe Senior Center, the Kohala Senior Center, Waiakea Uka
Gymnasium and Ballfield. The most recent completion has been the Honokaa
Rodeo Arena. We’ve done the Panaewa Equestrian Center. There is still quite a
bit on the list to complete, however, Richardson’s Ocean Park is next on our list.
2
Several projects that the courts want done are the Municipal Golf Course, the
drag strip, and the zoo. Those are really unique items for the county and they
want to see the county get it done. We spent way more money than what we
were required to spend originally. However, we have to address our ADA
concerns out there and we’ll continue ADA upgrades to our facility. It gives the
courts confidence that we are progressing at a rate that they are comfortable with
and we’re going to get the job done. All the projects that we do is ADA
accessible and any concerns or challenges that come up, we have guidance
from Alisa Mitchener in our department, along with Teri Spinola-Campbell from
HR to help us figure the funding and guidance in taking care of some of the
day-to-day operational issues. That’s kind of where we’re at right now.
S. Nagasawa
inquired if Parks was going to work on the beach access first at
Richardson’s.
C. Honma
stated they would be doing the building, bathroom and parking first.
Beach access would be more on the operational side. The building needs to be
renovated because of the hazardous materials that are coming off of the building
and the age of the facility. Some plants and trees will be removed and the patio
area is going to be expanded out as well. For Richardson’s itself, Clayton
doesn’t know how far up to the beach they’re going to go.
S. Nagasawa
spoke about the path being really uneven. She stated that working
with the disabled and bringing people to county programs that are happening at
Richardson’s is like an obstacle course, and it’s suicidal trying to get these folks
from the parking lot which is right over to where mobi mat starts. Without help,
some people can’t even go. That should be a priority.
R. Amundson
wanted clarification whether the patio area was going to be
accessible from the outside of the building or if you have to go into the building.
The difficulty with making it accessible through the building is that the building is
sometimes locked up so people can’t get to the patio.
C. Honma
said he didn’t know exactly but would look into and get back to him.
A. Mitchener
spoke with Parks planners and was informed that there will be a
pathway from the parking lot along side the staff parking, continue with the
pathway that exists now on the right hand side, and it would expand into a broad
walk situation to the point that goes down past the house. It will end at the
plumeria tree where the sand becomes hard packed. That’s actually where our
mobi mats begin. The parking lot is going to be expanded. There will be four
accessible parking stalls. So that connects the parking lot alongside the right
hand side entrance. You go down around the right side of the house. They are
going to level the slope from the patio down to the sand, and have a small picnic
table. There will be no showers there because of environmental issues.
C. Honma
stated that the upgrades were for the Hokulia and their educational
teachings. The hazardous materials and some of the paint were removed, and
3
the building was painted. The patio is going to be expanded too. Clayton will
review the plans with the Parks planner then he’ll share the details with anyone
who is interested in wanting to know what it will look like.
A. Mitchener
inquired if a tour of the Hokulia exhibit could be organized for
people who use wheelchairs. Clayton stated it could be done after the Summer
Fun program and it will continue to be open until September, whenever
construction starts there. So there will be opportunities for everybody else to get
in. We could tie it in and educate everybody here and see what they are doing
with the Hokulia and have the direct hook up to them on the boat itself. It sails
for a little bit and it will rest for about four months as the storms go by and they’ll
go back on the ocean after four months. There is a lot to be educated about the
Hokulia. We can all share and learn.
Going back to one of the ideas that the Recreation Ad Hoc committee suggested,
P. Aughe
stated that she understands that there are standards in the terms of
ADA and what you as a county are required to meet. She is recommending that
maybe asking or inviting people with disabilities to look at the designs in a more
practical aspect, because standards don’t always translate to realistic. It’s an
extra step and it goes above and beyond what is required, but Pauline feels like
Hawai‘i County is a county of wanting to be inclusive, having that aloha spirit.
C. Honma
agreed. He stated that they follow the law as best as they can all of
the time, but like you said, some of the times the law just doesn’t cover it all. It’s
good to be considerate and cognizant of those concerns and issues and we’ve
been working on being conscious and doing those things.
Sada Anaud
, member of the public, reiterated that when the county does these
ADA improvements to make it safer for the disabled, they are making it that much
safer for abled body people as well. That lowers the liability for the county. So,
it’s not just for the disabled people, it’s for everyone.
According to Clayton an example of that would be the Ainaola Park. Everyone
uses the paths that are made for accessibility rather than just walking the regular
paths. At Yano Hall, the stairs are a lot more dangerous than the actual
accessibility ramp because there are railings. Our elderly people prefer to use
the accessible ramp even though it’s a little bit longer. It’s a much safer route
and a more well used route than the regular access that they do have. Clayton
stated that Sada Anaud was absolutely correct on that, and he agrees that it is
for everyone. We just did Honokaa arena and we’ve had cowboys that have
finally come out because it’s now accessible for them to get into the bleachers
system. It’s not just making it accessible but it also upgrades the facility as far as
the look goes and accessibility to our bleacher system.
BREAK: 10:45 – 10:50
W. Tanigawa
resumed the meeting after the break and inquired if there were any
C. Cholas
more questions for Clayton? had some questions regarding Kalakaua
Park. He stated that all the blocks from ancient times are obstacles waiting to
4
cause accidents for people that are using white canes or people with chairs. The
gaps are more than an inch wide. He wanted to know if there was there anything
that could be done to make it accessible, and also the sidewalk around it.
C. Honma
informed Chris that the sidewalk around it belongs to Public Works.
The actual walking path that crosses the park, and the stone stairs, or seating
that they have there, that’s been an issue and a challenge for Parks as well too.
It is not currently on the priority list as far as accessibility goes. Parks is
concentrating on prioritizing resources for the ones the court has recommended.
It’s not even good access for regular people that use the park. Clayton stated
that the job needs to go out bid to make it all compliant as far as for safety
issues. He doesn’t know when Kalakaua Park will be addressed, but it is on our
radar to get looked at.
C. Cholas
also wanted to air some concerns he had about Coconut Island.
There are issues on the disabled parking stalls and access aisle next to the
bridge. People still use the access aisle illegally to unload things and transport it
across the bridge making it unavailable for the disabled person to use. Being
close to the bridge is nice if people would not violate the access aisle and if water
pooling (flooding) wasn’t a problem when it rains. Chris suggested that maybe
Parks might just see if the design could be looked at, then maybe put the
accessible parking on the far left slot in that Coconut Island parking lot. It won’t
be as close to the bridge but it might be more available to the disabled.
Clayton stated that is was something to consider.
C. Cholas
is also suggesting that it would be wonderful if P&R could have a web
page that shows accessibility in all the parks on the island. It would really help,
for residents, tourists, anybody. He would know which parks he could go to
without having to get there and find out he can’t get into the facility. Chris likes
that idea of a website that shows accessibility in our parks and community
centers.
W. Tanigawa
thanked Clayton for speaking to the committee.
Housing Ad Hoc Committee regarding Invitation to Stephen Arnett, Hawai‘i
County Housing Administrator
C. Cholas
stated that the Housing ad hoc committee has not been able to meet
so there is nothing to discuss.
REPORT OF THE COUNTY OF HAWAI‘IEQUAL OPPORTUNITY OFFICER
AND ADA COORDINATOR, TERI SPINOLA-CAMPBELL
See Attached Report
5
REVIEW FROM COUNTY OF HAWAI‘I ADA RECREATION SPECIALIST,
ALISA MITCHENER
See Attached Report
A. Mitchener
gave a short synopsis of the hippocampe wheelchairs and the
mobi chairs. The difference between hippocampe and the mobi chair is that the
mobi chair can go over the rocks and sand, it can go into the water and it can
float out deeper. It makes a difference in the number of transfers and how you
access the actual water itself. The mobi chair runs about $2400.
ANNOUNCEMENTS
W. Tanigawa
announced that Dr. Ron has given the committee notice that he is
resigning from the committee for personal reasons, so at our next meeting we will
probably need to select a secretary and treasurer. So, if any of you think you
might want to, please consider this between now and the next meeting.
Another announcement is that this is the end of our County fiscal year and Sandy
will be updating our committee address and contact information so please give
the information to Sandy. Wes just wanted to advise the committee that the
contact information is to be used for the ad hoc committee purposes only and
keep Sandy informed and updated.
NEXT MEETING
The next meeting will be on Wednesday, July16, 2014 in Hilo at the ADRC
Training Room.
ADJOURNMENT
Meeting was adjourned at 11:15 a.m.
Transcribed by:
Sandra Arriola
6
ADA Coordinator’s Report
April - June 2014
April:
I attended a one day conference the Disability and
Communication Access Board sponsored in Honolulu. Melissa
Anderson, Transportation Engineer with the U.S. Access Board
presented on Accessible Pedestrian Facilities. Warren Lee, the
Director of Public Works, and Casey Yanagihara from the
Engineering Division also attended.
I conducted Service Animal training for the staff of Hui Malama Ola
Na Oiwi in Hilo. Hui Malama is federally funded to provide health
education, health promotion, and outreach to native Hawaiians
and others who qualify for their services.
May:
An amended Request for Modification Procedure (RFMP) was
distributed to our departments and is now posted on the Equal
Opportunity Officer’s web page. The amended procedure was
submitted to the Federal Court in February prior to our annual
conference call in Russell v. the County of Hawai‘i. The new RFMP
clarifies its purpose and intent so those making requests have a
better understanding of the criteria we use to consider requests.
The Job Accommodation Network in conjunction with the Business
Leadership Network conducted “Building an Inclusive Workforce”
on May 15. The focus was on reasonable accommodation and the
interactive process. The session was well attended by County
employees.
I coordinated a DCAB training in Hilo on May 20. Mona Higa from
the Facility Access Unit of the Disability and Communication Access
Board delivered two presentations on ADA 2010 Standards –
“Application and Scoping Requirements” in the morning and
“Providing Access to Public Facilities” in the afternoon. The training
was targeted to design professionals and attended by County
employees and external consultants.
ADA Coordinator’s Report
April - June 2014
Also in May, I conducted two Reasonable Modification training sessions
for County employees with William Brilhante, Deputy Corporation Council.
June
Anthony Akamine, Election Information Specialist with the State’s
Office of Elections conducted a session for our Nutrition Site
7
Supervisors (Coordinated Services, Department of Parks and
Recreation) on access to voting and the various auxiliary aids that
are available at polling stations for voters with disabilities. Anthony
left a number of “Hawai‘i Votes” packets, which anyone who wants
one can have. There is also a Braille Information Packet.
8
Recreation AD-Hoc Committee June 18, 2014
Although a meeting was not held, committee members Janice Mancini, Chris Cholas, and Pauline
Aughe offer the following suggestions from discussions and phone calls with Alisa Mitchener.
Create a P&R page on accessibility on the County Website
Coconut island accessible parking “pools” after rains. Move that parking space closer to
picnic use, create curb cut and signs; leave old space as a loading zone.
Recruit new committee members; identify people with potential
Create internships or projects for students to serve P&R in the disability field. Connect to
University courses, high school projects, or community service for scouts, clubs, or
businesses.
Review ADA design and transition plans and schedule
Create opportunities for people with disabilities to offer input on access design features
at Richardsons
Create volunteer system for beach access support. Volunteers could:
Install mobi mats
Check beach wheelchairs in and out
Demonstrate proper use of beach wheelchairs
Conduct public surveys of Mobi Mat programs
9
Recreation Report for the Mayor’s Committee on People with
Disabilities
June 18, 2014
Alisa Mitchener, Recreation Specialist, 961-8681
All nine pool chair lifts are ready for summer season. Pools have
flotation equipment by request, if needed, due to a disability.
I conducted staff discussion and review on allowing caregivers to
serve participants of the opposite gender in the pool’s locker rooms.
I’m conducting Aquatics Orientations at Pahoa and Laupahoehoe
Pools to train agency caregivers and personal assistants.
Lifeguards have been briefed on including kids with disabilities in
learn to swim programs and teaching strategies have been shared for
individual students.
I attended a workshop offered by the Job Accommodation Network
and the East Hawaii Business Leadership Network on the value of
employing people with disabilities. They are accepting nominations of
businesses that are committed to the employment of people with
disabilities. Contact Raymond “Kauwa” Elia, Business Relations
Inclusion Coordinator, Big Island Workplace Connection, Ph: 981-
2860 ex 228
Summer Fun
P&R is serving approximately 1800 children in our annual Summer
Fun Programs Island wide.
I conducted staff training on inclusion for 125 summer hires.
I published an article in the Hawaii Recreation and Parks Society
magazine on a team building activity for summer staff training. The
goal for each team was to create a super-device using LEGO to
make a difference in the life of a child with disabilities. Their device
must help someone do something, change attitudes, or “bust”
barriers. An extra environmental point was given for “Green” devices.
The activity promoted bonding among staff before the program and
gave them a way to connect with the keiki they serve. Creativity does
not come with instructions. What will you build this summer to make
our world a better place?
10
I am working with parents, case managers, and agencies to create
individual modification plans and emergency plans for children with
extreme medical needs in the Summer Fun program. I provide staff
and program support, assessments, and recommendations for
Summer Fun from May through July.
Mobi Mat Season Starts Friday July 25, 2014 (except Friday August
th
15 Statehood Day) and will be offered at Richardsons in Hilo every
th
Friday until September 26. Mobi Mats, Hippocampe wheelchairs,
flotation equipment, and an outdoor rinse hose are made available on
Mobi Mat Days for beach access. No personal assistance is provided.
Access around the building is still rugged. Purchasing a Mobi Chair
would enhance beach access.
I’d like to request support from the Committee for a forum for
recreation professionals that includes people with disabilities, family
members, physical therapists, swim instructors, water safety officers,
and agencies to discuss collaboration of aquatics programs and
ocean events. The purpose of the forum would be to bring people
together to share their experience, describe goals, maximize
resources, and create a network to enhance access and inclusive
beach and ocean experiences for people with disabilities.
Announcements:
Deep and Beyond is seeking volunteers for Snorkel Day for people
with disabilities on Friday June 27, 2014 at Richardsons. Snorkel
Day is also held on the third Friday of the month at Kahalu’u
Beach in Kona. The event is from 10am to 2pm. Please call 326-
4400 ex 4017 to volunteer or to register for the program.
11