HomeMy WebLinkAboutPuna CDP Action Committee recommendationsWilliam P.Kenoi
Mayor
Duane Kanuha
Director
Bobby Command
Deputy Director
County of Hawaii
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
PUNA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PLAN ACTION COMMITTEE
Aupuni Center • 101 Pauahi Street,Suite 3 • Hilo,Hawai`i 96720
Phone(808)961-8288 • Fax(808)961-8742
June 9, 2015
Duane Kanuha
Planning Director
Planning Department
101 Pauahi Street, Suite 3
Hilo, HI 96720
SUBJECT: Puna CDP Action Committee Recommendations for the General Plan
Comprehensive Review
Aloha Director Kanuha,
This is in response to your memo dated February 6, 2015 pertaining to the General Plan
Comprehensive Review. The Action Committee ofthe Puna Community Development Plan
respectfully submits its recommendations for the comprehensive review of the County of Hawai`i
General Plan. The AC appreciates the opportunity to provide comments and looks forward to working
with the Planning Department as the General Plan review progresses.
Sincerely,
Patti Pinto, Chair
Puna Community Development Plan Action Committee
Encl: PCDP AC recommendations for GP Review
Hawaii County is an Equal Opportunity Provider and Employer
0 9 9 3 6 2
Puna CDP Action Committee Recommendations for the General Plan Update
Background
The headings below correspond to sections of the General Plan. AC recommendations are bulleted
below the section heading. Recommendations are based off of initial excel spreadsheets that were
developed and used to compare GP policies to Puna CDP policies. Side by side comparison provided
context for development of recommendations. Additional recommendations were added based on
comments from AC members. Recommendation alignment with PCDP is noted in parenthesis (section
of PCDP or just a general comment that aligns with general CDP goals).
General Plan Sections
Introduction
None at this time
Economic
Strategies to improve infrastructure in substandard subdivisions(general recommendation, 3.1.2)
Tax incentives or TDR (transfer of development rights) strategies for reducing buildable lots(3.1.1g)
Use of village/town center concepts to target infrastructure investments (5.2)
Use of improvement districts for infrastructure financing(3.1.3d.2.)
Encourage village plans to guide growth and provide centralized services(3.1.2d)
Adjust LUPAG designations as appropriate to align with CDP(general recommendation, 3.2.3c)
Designate specific CIP projects to improve services to underserved communities experiencing higher
growth (3.1.1c)
Develop strategies that support and encourage ag tourism(3.2.2g)
Add CDP specificity on business incubator districts(3.2.3a)
Advocate for telecommuting opportunities(4.1.3b)
Local job growth is primarily in "green" industries such as agriculture, alternative energy,
communications technology,eco-tourism and natural resources management(3.2.1.g)
Create new"green" opportunities in the agricultural, alternative energy,and natural resources
management in Puna (3.2.2.k)
Energy
Keep GP policy to encourage energy research and development but focus on renewable energy(3.6.3)
Establish LEED standards for buildings(3.6.3)
Provide additional property tax incentives for energy efficient homes(3.6.1)
Pursue new renewable energy sources,through ocean energy or enterprise subzone (3.6.3i.)
ADD all 3 sections(3.6.2.a,b,c)
Review(3.6.3 actions) and ADD
Environmental Quality
Add increased specificity to GP to incorporate CDP strategies (general recommendation)
Encourage State legislation to prohibit the use of cesspools(2.3.3a)
Aquifers could be used for future community wells in high growth low elevation areas are protected
from pollution by untreated Wastewater disposal systems. GOAL: (2.3.1.a) & (2.2.3.e)
Flooding and Natural Hazards
Add CIP projects that address flooding(2.3)
Prepare water management plans(2.3.3)
Develop community relief centers(general recommendation)
Consider strategies that restrict grubbing and grading in flood prone areas that changes topography
that could contribute to flooding.
Encourage state legislation to prohibit cesspools as a means for wastewater disposal in areas below
1,000 feet Mean Sea Level,with the objective of protecting both water quality in coastal areas, as well
as in the aquifer, particularly the portion underlying State-owned lands in the Maku'u area,where
there is potential to develop the source for community potable water wells and agricultural irrigation
purposes. OBJECTIVE(2.3.2.a) DOES THIS APPLY TO(11.2.2.c)?
Historic Sites
Encourage use of Design Guidelines (2.1.2b)
Advocate for improved database of historic sites(general recommendation)
Structures and cultural sites that are significant to Puna's history and cultural traditions are preserved
2.1.1.a)
Awareness and appreciation of host culture is expanded (2.1.1.d)
ADD "Kanaka" Building Code (2.1.2.d)
Retrieve and record information on trails and historic resources in the Puna, including research of old
survey and plat maps and various records of Mahele, Land Commission and Royal Patents(2.4.3.b)
Amendments to the County building code for structures utilizing traditional Hawaiian building design
and construction methods(2.1.3.b)
Natural Beauty
Consider scenic turnouts and linear parks with the intent to protect the intrinsic qualities of the areas
Hwy 137)
Consider wildlife corridors and utilizing native plants for landscaping in park projects.
Natural Resources and Shoreline
Fully utilize PONC funds(general recommendation)
Add BRBZ to GP or additional tools for preservation of the BRBZ area (2.2.2a.)
Add development controls for areas subject to subsidence (2.4.3)
Support the development and preservation of wildlife corridors
Develop strategies for combating invasive species(2.2.2)
Consider PCDP section 2.2.2.b.d.e
Where does the GP address tax incentives for native forests, restoration and abatement of invasive
species(2.2.2.b.c.d.e)
Reduce the minimum lot size to qualify for the native forest preservation tax reduction and allow it in
any zoning district. Enrollment of a lot in this program is voluntary, but it is binding and permanent,
and attached to effective measures to prevent significant clearing or other adverse alterations of the
forest cover(2.2.3.e)
Inappropriate and disproportionate County zoning can be adjusted in order to maintain and increase
the quality of life and to preserve valued natural and cultural resources (3.1.1.e)
Housing
Plan for additional retirement communities in Town Center locations(3.3.3g.)
Consider allowing ohana dwellings on ag zoned parcels(3.3.1c.)
Advocate for graduated conveyance taxes to discourage property speculation (3.1.2j., 3.2.3d)
Advocate for additional "self-help" programs for affordable housing opportunities(3.3.2e.)
Advocate or support assistance programs for repair and maintenance of affordable housing(3.3.1c.)
Provide for transitional shelters and services for homeless(3.3.2c.)
ADD "Kanaka" Building Code (2.1.2.d)
Amendments to the County building code for structures utilizing traditional Hawaiian building design
and construction methods(2.1.3.b)
Public Facilities
Keep GP policy to develop new or improve existing health care facilities but apply to entire island
general comment from AC, 3.3.2)
Consider alternate LOS criteria for determining minimum LOS (general recommendation)
Increase emergency response capacity(3.3.1)
Implement CERS recommendations(general recommendation)
Use CDP specificity to locate public facilities(general recommendation)
Explore use of existing school facilities to implement after school education opportunities(general
recommendation, 3.3.2)
As part of"safe routes to school" initiative,open Lauko Road to provide better access to Mt.View
school (general recommendation,4.5.2)
Public Utilities
Add strategies to assist Puna communities to develop water systems, public and private(general
recommendation)
Plan for County infrastructure improvements that serve Village Town Center locations (3.4.3)
Develop strategies to improve wastewater treatment(2.3.2)
Develop policies for land pooling or TRDs to encourage clustering development(village/town center
models, reduced infrastructure costs) (3.1.3a)
Advocate for additional funds from PGV to be used in Puna for infrastructure improvements(general
recommendation, 3.6.1d, 3.6.3g)
Limit expansion of PGV(general recommendation, 3.6)
Advocate for increased cell phone coverage to improve communications but ensure that cell phone
towers blend in with the natural environment(3.4.3e)
Advocate for improved internet access(3.4.3c)
Advocate for phased undergrounding of utility lines
Recreation
Complete the P.O.N.C. purchase of the Vacation Land Legacy Property adjacent to the Wai`opae
Reserve and implement plans to provide alternative shoreline access to the Reserve and at the
southern end of the property, provide access for fishing (general recommendation, 3.5.3e.2)
Consider additional CIP projects for recreation facilities consistent with CDP (general recommendation)
Provide PCDP specificity for development of parks, including coastal parks(3.5.3)
Develop and maintain new and existing trails,forest and coastal (3.5.2, 3.5.3)
Consider adding "Friends of the Park" policy(general recommendation)
Develop policies for linear parks (3.5.3d)
Develop trail system that can provide for alternate modes of transportation, i.e. bike paths/walking
paths,and provide recreation alternatives(3.5.3,4.5.3e.)
Consider additional CIP projects for ocean swimming areas at Pohoiki/lsaac Hale Beach Park
Transportation
Include all of Puna CDP Section 4.2 on Mass Transit(MTS recommendation)
Use CERT information to improve connectivity between communities/subdivisions(4.3.2a.)
Provide more specificity pertaining to Puna roadways(general recommendation)
Consider improvement districts to fund infrastructure improvements (3.1.3d.2.)
Advocate for specialist that seeks funding for road projects(general recommendation)
Consider including alternate route for Highway 11 from Volcano to Highway 130
Consider paving Beach Road and keep open (general recommendation)
Keep GP policy on developing mid-level roadway Makai of Highway 130(PMAR) (4.3)
Consider paving Railroad and keep open to traffic(general recommendation)
Advocate for more emergency call boxes along highways(3.4.3d.)
Advocate for bike paths/lanes along highway and major roadways for alternate modes of
transportation (3.5.3d.1&5,4.5.3a.)
Develop trail system that can provide for alternate modes of transportation and provide recreation
alternatives(3.5.3,4.5.3e.)
Makai route from Hawaiian Beaches to Paradise Park with connection from Railroad to South Hilo(GP:
13.2.5.1.2.a). Develop PMAR along general route shown in Figure 4-1,with specific design and
alignment to be determined based on an environmental impact study that identifies a project having
the least socio-economic impact(4.3.2.b)
Transit service and improvements reinforce and complement village/town centers (4.2.1.b)
Prepare a County-wide Tansit Master Plan to provide an overall framework for transit improvements
while incorporating user input from each district(4.2.3.a)
Land Use
Support community based action groups in developing Regional Town and Village Center Plans that
will guide growth and development in their communities consistent with the PCDP (5.2)
Update LUPAG map to be consistent with Village/town center concepts(5.2.1)
Look at current areas with multiple "special permits"and adjust LUPAG appropriately(5.2.4)
Offer incentives (tax breaks) for people willing to designate lands for conservation (2.2.3d.)
Add specificity from CDP—locations of industrial zoning(5.2)
Recommend increasing consistency between LUPAG Maps and County Zoning Maps
ADD Adopt a Biosphere Reserve Buffer Zone(BRBZ) (2.2.2.1)
Enact BRBZ(2.2.3.a.9) "Amendment to the general plan to recognize the purpose and intent of the
BRBZ and designation of State-owned lands in the BRBZ to'open"
Develop and adopt special zoning and development regulations for the greater Kapoho area (Kipu
Point to Pu'ala'a) to take into account the problems associated with the ongoing and catastrophic
subsidence and property loss, pressure to develop lots for residential and commercial use, and
increasing demand for access to the shoreline area for recreational use. Request the State to make
some of their Kapoho area accreted lands available for integrated solutions, including relocation/land
exchange and recreational opportunities. (2.4.3.f)
Services and community facilities are more accessible in village/town centers that are distributed
throughout the region, including underserved subdivisions that have been experiencing higher levels
of development growth (3.1.1.c)
Facilitate land use entitlements and financing for the development of new town/village centers
3.1.3.d.1)
Propose amendments to the zoning code and/or apply district-wide rezoning to limit allowable
building footprint on residential and agricultural-zoned lands,except for sites designated as
village/town centers or for land pooling projects(3.1.3.e)
Recommend reviewing the rezoning of all Agricultural (A) zoned parcels in the State Agricultural
District in Puna to a zoning that would be consistent with the goals and policies of the PCDP(3.2.3.b)
Create a real property tax exemption (perhaps 4 to 6 years) for farmers entitled to Federal crop loss
insurance (3.2.3.o)
Plan Implementation
Requesting clarification on the roles of the CDPs and the Action Committees(general
recommendation)
Amendment Procedures
None at this time