HomeMy WebLinkAboutComm No 0016.01 - Updated TOSA - Nov 2 2018Douglass Shipman Adams
Chairperson
Jennifer Leilani Zelko-Schlueter
Vice Chairperson
Date: November 5, 2018
2018-2020
HAWAII COUNTY
CHARTER COMMISSION
To: Members of the Hawai`i County Charter Commission
From: Douglass Shipman Adams, Chair
Hawai`i County Charter Commission
William Carthage Bergin
Michelle Galimba
Paul K. Hamano
Kevin D. Hopkins
Bobby Jean Akane Leithead Todd
Sarah H. Rice
Christopher John Imiloa Roehrig
Marcia A.K. Saquing
Donna Mae Springer
RE: Updated Table of Charter Sections Affected by Requested Language Changes
Please find attached the updated Table of Charter Sections Affected by Requested
Language Changes, which incorporates proposals and communications submitted since
the issuance of Communication No. 16.
This table is intended to provide an overview of the communications and related
proposals received thus far, that transmit potential amendments to the County Charter.
The table is not intended to endorse or promote any particular potential amendment to the
County Charter.
Staff will periodically update this table as needed.
Should you have any questions, please contact our Commission Analyst, Jon Henricks.
DSA/jdh
Comm. No. 16.1
Hawai`i County is an Equal Opportunity Provider and Employer
Updated: 11/1/18 (LRB)
Disclaimer:
01
C
Qi
CS
u v aj L
L v .
a
U
0
QJ
CS v
0 'a .c
v) c a
a c
0 0
tri tr) 0
�
0
44 a
4°
c
Ili
a v
o v
0
O4 a
CU v 0
-
tn
(=
Notes
Proposed correction to wording of section.
Revised draft.
Legislative Auditor Nims proposed change to name of
office.
Would change name of "Legislative Auditor" to
"County Auditor."
Proposed correction to wording of section.
Revised draft.
Council Member O'Hara's proposal relating to
confirmation of directors. *Also relates to 6-2.2, 6-3.2,
6-4.2, 6-5.2, 6-6.2, 6-7.2, 6-8.2, 6-10.3, and 13-8.
Re. Dept of Information Technology. Director Jules
Ung's proposed language changes.
Re. Dept of Information Technology. Director Jules
Ung's proposed language changes.
Re. Dept of Information Technology. Prosecuting
Attorney Roth's proposed language changes.
Corporation Counsel Kamelamela proposal relating to
minimum qualifications of Corporation Counsel.
Proposal No.
CA -1 Adams
CA -1, Draft 2
Adams
CA -5 Saquing
CA -1 Adams
CA -1, Draft 2
Adams
E
E °
° z
(,
CO
r-1
r-1
Cr;
r-1
Ln
4
CT)
r-1
CO
r-1
r-1
Cr;
r-1
CO
1.1-)
%-i
1.1-)
%-i
CO
4
°)
%-i
Section Name
County Redistricting Commission
Office of the Legislative Auditor
Cost of Government Commission
Managing Director*
Qualifications
Powers, Duties and Functions
Appointment and Removal
Section
N
%-1%-I
m
CO
m
N
N
1n
*
N
�-I
(o
m
(o
(o
N
if;
(o
N
Notes
Re. Corporation Counsel. Opinion relating to
representation of Administration and Council and any
potential conflict arising from this.
Windward Planning Commission Chairperson Clarkson
proposal to delete last sentence of (c) relating to ex -
officio members.
Windward Planning Commission Chairperson Clarkson
proposal to delete last sentence of (b) relating to rules
of practice and procedure.
Windward Planning Commission Chairperson Clarkson
proposal to delete transitional provisions section.
Amends powers, duties and functions of director of
Research and Development to include research and
coordination of County response to complex issues
that require planning and coordination across
departments.
Commission Analyst Henricks - Legislative history
relating to sec. 6-9.3 relating to Game Management
Advisory Commission.
Proposed correction to wording of section.
Revised draft.
Proposal No.
CA -4 Galimba
CA -1 Adams
CA -1, Draft 2
Adams
E °
o z
V
00
r i
1.n
N
Ln
N
00
r-1
Lri
on
r-1
c1
m
,--1
Section Name
Powers, Duties and Functions
Windward Planning Commission
Duties and Functions of the
Windward and Leeward
Planning Commissions
Transitional Provisions
Powers, Duties and Functions
Game Management Advisory
Commission
Section
m
11i.
(.0
U
m
(.0us
if
rir-:o0
(o
us
CO
(.0
m
of
(.0
M
Notes
Dept of Environmental Management. Director
Kucharski's proposal to add "and regulating" to policy
statement.
Dept of Environmental Management. Director
Kucharski's proposal to add "and enforce" to powers,
duties and functions.
Proposed correction to wording of section.
Revised draft.
Council Member O'Hara's proposals - would add new
Statement of Policy and number this section 7-2.2.
Re. Police Department. Council Member O'Hara's
proposals - would amend and renumber this section to
7-2.3.
Proposed correction to wording of section.
Revised draft.
Council Member O'Hara's proposals - would renumber
this section to 7-2.4.
Would authorize Police Commission to discipline the
Chief of Police.
Proposal No.
CA -1 Adams
CA -1, Draft 2
Adams
CA -1 Adams
CA -1, Draft 2
Adams
CA -6 Saquing
E
Eo
o z
v
o
.-I
i°
.-I
m
,-I
r,
cri
,-I
00
00
m
,-I
cri
,-I
00
o
Ni
Section Name
Statement of Policy
Powers, Duties and Functions
Environmental Management
Commission
Statement of policy
Police Commission
Chief of Police and Deputy
Section
Ni
0
c -I
l0
0
c -I
l0
if
0
c -I
l0
N
Z
N
N
N
CO
N
N
di-
Ill
Fire Commission Chairperson Becker proposal to add
language to this section.
Proposed amendment to authorize Fire Commission to
discipline Fire Chief.
Proposed correction to wording of section.
Revised draft.
Fire Commission Chairperson Becker proposal to amend
this section.
Notes
Council Member O'Hara's proposals - would amend
sec. 7-2.4 relating to Powers, Duties, and Functions of
the Chief of Police and renumber it to 7-2.5; renumber
7-2.6 and 7-2.7, and insert new article relating to office
of the independent police auditor.
Proposed correction to wording of section.
Revised draft.
Fire Commission Chairperson Becker proposal to
remove "a fire commission" from this section.
Corporation Counsel opinion relating to Fire
Commission and Mayor's authority to discipline Fire
Chief and Fire Dept personnel. Proposed language to
amend sec. 7-4.3(a).
Proposal No.
CA -1 Adams
CA -1, Draft 2
Adams
CA -6 Saquing
CA -1 Adams
CA -1, Draft 2
Adams
E
E o
oz
v
CO
CO
%-1
Cr;
%-1
%-'
N
c -I
,-i
c -I
%-1
N
o
N
CO
%-1
Cr;
%-I
N
Section Name
Powers, duties, and Functions of
the Chief of Police;
Dismissal, Suspension, Demotion
or Grievance;
Administrative Supervision; and
Independent Police Auditor
Liquor Commission
Organization
Fire Chief
Fire Commission
Powers, Duties and Functions
Section
O
Cr
N
N
0 O
N>v
N O i
Z .:r -
N
m
N
%-1
N
CO
N
1!)
N
l0
N
Ill
Notes
Env'I Mgmt Commission, Chairperson Bennett proposals
to create new Dept of Water Sustainability and move all
DWS provisions and DEM water related provisions into
this Dept.
Dept of Water Supply's response to Comm 7.4.
Council Member O'Hara's proposal - would require
Water Board to conduct annual reviews of future water
needs and plan to meet needs.
Proposed correction to wording of section.
Revised draft.
Charter Commission's Ad Hoc Committee's Report
Public Access, Open Space and Natural Resources
Preservation Commission Chairperson Tomich's
proposals.
Proposes replacement language.
Proposal No.
CA -1 Adams
CA -1, Draft 2
Adams
0
c
r0
E
r0
N
Q
U
Eo
o z
0
I:
r1
1
N
CO
Cil
%-1
Cr;
%-1
ri
Cr;
t0
N
r-1
N
Section Name
Article VIII. Dept of Water
Supply
Water Board
Public Access, Open Space, and
Natural Resources Preservation
Fund
Section
0
4-,
!)
00 00
00
1.r)
%-i
0
.-1
Notes
Charter Commission's Ad Hoc Committee's Report
Public Access, Open Space and Natural Resources
Preservation Commission Chairperson Tomich's
proposals.
Proposes replacement language.
Salary Commission Chairperson Ono concerns relating
to ord. 18-30 - salary commission's approval process.
Proposed correction to wording of section.
Revised draft.
Creates climate change and resiliency commission.
Requires directors or heads of county departments,
agencies, or offices to provide annual report to newly
formed climate change and resiliency commission.
Proposal No.
0
c
r0
E
r0
N
Q
U
CA -1 Adams
CA -1, Draft 2
Adams
CA -3 Galimba
CA -3 Galimba
E o
o z
0
.-1
Ti
Cr;
l0
IN
.-1
N
N
N
CO
.-1
.1
Cr;
.-1
N
.-1
N
.-1
Section Name
Public Access, Open Space, and
Natural Resources Preservation
Maintenance Fund
Compensation; Salary
Commission
Climate Change and Resiliency
Commission.
Greenhouse Gas Emissions;
Reporting and Reduction.
Section
l0
.-1N
o
CO
m
New
Section
New
Section