2024-03-31 PL-CCI-2024-000003 Bill 121 Doug Howell Testimony

Home

From: Doug Howell To: WPCtestimony Subject: Why Bill 121 is the wrong approach Date: Sunday,March 31,2024 6:45:47 AM To: Chairman Dennis Lin Windward Planning Commission County of Hawaii 25 Aupuni St. Unit 1502 Hilo, HI 96720 Aloha, Chairman Lin, I am writing to express my concerns about Hawaii Bill 121 and its potential impact on our local communities. I believe the proposed regulations are a knee-jerk reaction which will not solve the main problem, which I see as affordability. The far-reaching implications of these laws have not been fully considered, and if passed, would be a tragedy for our county and its diverse residents. As a resident of Kea'au, I have witnessed firsthand the benefits that short-term rentals bring to Puna, not only in terms of economic growth but also in fostering a sense of aloha and community among visitors and residents alike. Two of my primary concerns is (1) the lack of data supporting the need for such stringent regulations, and (2) the cost of the almost certainly resulting litigation should it become law. It seems that the bill is being pushed forward without a thorough understanding of its potential consequences on homeowners and the local economy. Therefore, I urge the Planning Commission to recommend conducting an economic impact study before even considering new regulations. This study would provide valuable insights into how Bill 121 could affect our community and allow for more informed decision-making. The bill's proposed requirements, such as the affidavit requirement and invasive registration processes, pose significant challenges for homeowners. These requirements not only infringe on private property rights (making future litigation likely) but also create unnecessary burdens for those trying to comply with the law. I believe that streamlining the registration process and removing the affidavit requirement would be beneficial steps towards a more equitable and manageable system.