COM 0032.035 2006-2008 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

businesses will thrive and others fail. Laws exist outside of the zoning and land use system to control competition that society deems unfair: anti-trust laws, truth-in-labeling laws, and the like. The land use system is not supposed to limit competition to favor certain businesses against ' others. It is a legitimate use of the land use and zoning powers to establish preferred locations for businesses, and to prevent businesses from getting started in undesireable locations. For example, it is a perfectly legitimate use of zoning power for a community that is trying to preserve and enhance an existing downtown business core to use zoning to prevent big-box mercharrts from building at a highway crossroads away from the downtown, so that the downtown remains the primary commercial cemer. This is the type of zoning battle that has been fought in many communities against big retailers such as Wal-Mart, but it should be based on a policy about the use of land, and the proper location for businesses, not the belief that one group of business owners aze more deserving than another. Other laws set the requirements for wages, hours, and health care that corporations must meet. Zoning and other land use laws do not set these standazds. Given these general principles, the Planning Director cannot give a favorable recommendation to an ordinance that would ban superstores everywhere on the island. The combination of a lazge department store with a section that sells food, under the same roof and with the same ownership, cannot be said to be a bad thing in itself and under all circumstances. It is simply a different form of retail enterprise. It is not something like an illegal drug lab, a casino, or a brothel that a community may ban because it believes it is a harmful activity in itself. An island-wide ban could have the pazadoxical effect of creating a monopoly for Wal- Mart in the "superstore" category, given that Wal-Mart will apparently build a superstore on DHI-II, property. Unless DHHI. leases another site to a superstore competitor, that would be the only site where a superstore could be built on the island if this ban is enacted. There is reason to be concerned about the location of superstores. They aze typically very lazge in comparison with other retail businesses and can attract very lazge traffic volumes to a particular area. One particulaz concern is that a superstore can bring traffic from a large region to an azea that may not have been planned to be a regional commercial center. Some of our MCX zoned areas, for example, may have been planned with the idea that they would have mixed -6-