2026 06 10_Appellant Ohana's Objections to Record, Rosehill Dec, and COS_v1.pdf

Home

Beyond the categories of records described above, the `Ghana has identified specific documents, discussed below, that were in the Director's file and are directly related to the Decision yet absent from the Record on Appeal. The documents identified in this objection are those the `Ohana has been able to identify, and they are illustrative but not exhaustive. Other records that were in the Department's file and are directly related to the Decision, but that were omitted from the Record on Appeal, are likewise part of the Record and should be included, whether or not the `Ohana has been able to identify them. A. The Notices of Violation and Orders (PL-PCV-2022-00015) The Planning Department's Notices of Violation and Order issued to the Applicant for unpermitted activity on the subject property were public records in the Director's file related to the Decision and are a part of and should be included in the Record on Appeal. The Department issued three such Notices concerning the subject property, TMK No. (3) 1-2-018:001: the October 10, 2022 Notice of Violation and Order ("lst NOV"), issued by then -Director Zendo Kern for unauthorized grubbing and grading without an SMA permit; the October 29, 2025 Notice of Violation and Order ("2nd NOV"), issued for the Applicant's unpermitted work and additional ground disturbances on the subject property while the SMA Minor Permit application was pending; and the January 28, 2026 Notice of Violation and Order ("3rd NOV") for the Applicant's additional land clearing, grubbing, and/or construction work on the subject property without an approved Archaeological Monitoring Plan in violation of Condition No. 9 of the SMA Minor Permit PL- SMM-2025-000079. The Record on Appeal includes Stop Work Orders that reference this enforcement activity but omits the Notices of Violation and Order themselves and their associated compliance history. C!