MIN RDC 2011-11-03.tif - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

MS. FORD: Can everyone see the map that is over my shoulder? Okay, thank you. Good morning, Commissioners, and thank you for allowing all of us to testify. I am not happy with Plan A or Plan 40, so I submitted a hybrid. Every plan needs to be tweaked, including this one. This is not about me; this is about getting a fair plan. So I'm not going to read most of my testimony. I would like to say that everybody on this island, in this room, can tell you what district they think they should be in. What some of them are not saying is what district they absolutely do not want to be associated with. And it is coming across loudly and clearly, and with all due respect to the Commissioners from Hilo, anybody who lives outside of Hilo wants nothing to do with the possibility of having a representative from Hilo. It has been unfortunately very clear, I don't need to go into all the details; you have heard it before. In my plan, which I am calling the hybrid, Hilo has two districts, and Kaumana stays with Hilo. Puna has two complete districts inside of the geographical boundaries of Puna. Almost all Puna residents that need to be assigned to another district are in the Volcano area, which I have assigned with Ka`u, South Kona, and southern North Kona. Basically, Volcano, upper and lower, will stay in the same district where it has been for at least ten years. Attempting to put Volcano in the Puna district means a third district for Hilo, populated by many Puna residents who will not be able to get a Puna representative elected. And that district will be controlled by Hilo, i.e. you have a third district in Hilo. Volcano could be with Hilo, Puna, or Ka`u; and we all know where Volcano wants to be, and that is obviously in Puna. However, I chose Ka`u as the least objectionable of these three alternatives; you must decide where Volcano would hate to be the most, eliminate that possibility, and then decide where the numbers are going to work. Kailua Village remains in one district, because of the Business Improvement District. It is very important that this urban core of Kona be recognized by a district so that its characteristics and the support and the CDP be adhered to. These particular residents in the Kailua Village area have never had single representation. They have always been split between two districts. District 8 is the northern area of Kona; it is also the access to Saddle Road. In Plan _A, you have got a thumb sticking up from District 6 up to the South edge of Saddle Road; you cannot get from District 6 to Saddle Road without driving through District 7 and District 8 to get up to Saddle Road. It is an illegality; it needs -- -Just get rid of that plan completely. It does have some good things; because my plan is a hybrid of both of them. District 9 contains Waik6loa Village and most of Waimea, excluding the Lakeland area. Kohala, like Kona, is too big to fit into just a single district. In fact, what has not been mentioned here is that historically, and currently, South Kona, the district I live in, has been split between Kona and Ka`u, and nobody raises that as an issue. You have got to consider that somebody is going to get someplace and South Kona has always been split. Lakeland goes with Hamakua in my plan because it just doesn't fit into the deviations, which are very high in this plan, but because this Commission has chosen to keep communities of interest together, I put in the high deviations. You cannot use Hamakua to encroach upon Hilo; you cannot do it. They have nothing in common. I will stop here, my 22