MIN CHC 2010-03-12.tif - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Ms. Jarman moved to amend Section 154(p) and Section 15 -9 to delete the phrase, "...in the Sunday paper of two Hawaii Island daily papers with the largest circulation for the three Sundays preceding the election." The language would be changed to read, "The clerk shall publish the ballot title, ballot question, ballot summary and arguments for and against the measure in two newspapers of general circulation in the County of Hawaii at least 45 days prior to submission to the electors of the county." Seconded by Ms. Osborne. CHR. HAITSUKA: We have a motion, we have a second. Is there any discussion? Mr. Shumway. MR. SHUMWAY: It seems to me that one of the points of this is that is should be in the Sunday paper. If they publish it in a Monday paper or Tuesday paper not everyone will see it. I think part of the idea is that the Sunday paper is much more widely distributed and read. So I think taking that out weakens the idea of what they are after. CHR. HAITSUKA: I considered that myself, but I do a lot of legal publication and know a lot of statutes and I don't know of any that just require a Sunday publication. I think Sunday, maybe for some people; but for me, it's not the paper that I read. I understand the intent, but I think you will find that most legal publication requirements in the statutes are going to say you have to publish in newspapers in just general circulation or in a particular county. I don't know if you necessarily have to have that Sunday. I think it makes it a little bit more difficult and a little bit less flexible for the publication, given the timing. Ms. Hecht, Ms. Wilkins; do you have any comments? MS. WILKINS: I look at this not just as a legal requirement, but as an informational education of the public of what they are voting on, so that's why we are trying to get it to the highest circulation on both papers, and enough time so somebody will hopefully see it. If it's running into a time restraint, then I would suggest that it be changed to maybe a Friday paper, a Sunday paper, and maybe a Friday paper; but let's not try to cut back or put it in a place where nobody is going to see it, like in a Monday paper. We want people to know what they are voting on. MS. HECHT: I think you understand the intent was to get it in the paper with the most circulation; that was the intent, you were right. CHR. HAITSUKA: Mr. Nahale -a. MR. NAHALE -A: I would rather have the more general 45 day language. This again is the kind of micro - managing in the Charter that is challenging for me to be okay with. I would rather it be more general. I support the 45 day language. C