2008-03-20 TKOHALA LLC - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

LIM: Okay. Thank you for your willingness to allow the applicant the time and the ability to formulate our case and present you our feelings on the proposed downzoning and our request for the time extensions for the zoning ordinance and the SMA permit in this case. For purposes of the record, I would like to reiterate our preservation of any objections that we’ve raised to the process and the substantive matters that have gone on in these proceedings. And as I understand it, we are still in the consolidated proceeding; so I’d like to make my comments that I’ve given throughout this proceeding applicable to both the Change of Zone application and the Director’s action on that, and our SMA time extension and the Director’s action on that permit also. Also, for purposes of the record, to the extent that the public witnesses have given any expert testimony, we’d like to object to that because they have not been qualified to testify as experts in this matter. Okay. I missed Mr. Darrow’s presentation a little bit. But am I to understand they’ve received the March 18, 2008, letter? DARROW: Yes. LIM: Okay. What I’ll do is I’ll go over our overall presentation on the issues relating to the Change of Zone and SMA application matters before you. And then I’ll go and follow up with our proposed conditions that would be submitted as amendments to our proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order in the SMA matter, and also as our proposed conditions for the Commission’s consideration on the time extension for the Change of Zone. As the Commission noted in its initial presentation, feelings have gotten strong. Apologies have been made, and there are strong feelings on all sides. And it’s because this is a very important issue for both the applicant and the County. The applicant’s position is that throughout the last 15 to 20 years all State and County authorities have recognized that the areas of makai of the Kohala Ranch project, which by the way is – Jeff, can you do me a favor and put up the graphic for the General Plan, GIS, for that area – that all the areas makai of the Kohala Ranch project should be limited to urban development in that area as shown on the Land Use Pattern Allocation Guide Map for this area. As you can see, both the State Land Use Commission and the County General Plan since 1989 and also in that 2005 revision that you just went through have shown the majority of the property as Low Density Urban and State Land Use Commission Urban for the entire property. It’s our position that this is the County of Hawaii’s official policy position as expressed by law in the General Plan. And this is something that the County of Hawaii has supported for numerous years. As you can see, in the Kohala Ranch project, which is located mauka of this project, that is an area of several hundred acres, which is presently entitled for development of between 1,000 to 1,500 residential units and, I believe, a golf course also. Located to the south of the subject property, one property away, is a multi-family residential development that has been developed into half-acre, essentially, farm lots or residential lots. In the past 26 years, based upon our research and a research done by the Planning Director, in the past 26 years there have been no involuntary downzonings of any properties that have occurred. th Even then, and this was in 1982 – and this is part of our submittal to you in our last March 18 EXHIBIT A 13