MIN CHC 1999-09-08 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

have contested case hearings, which would require additional meetings over and above the two a month, we would ask for volunteers and try and rotate the Commissioners. It's been light this year. I don't think we had not a single contested case yet. So the workload right now is not a problem. The state of the economy has something to do with that, too. There's not a lot of activity out there. RAY: Kevin. BALOG: Just a hypothetical question. There's this thing about East vs. West so since you're currently sitting on the chair, if you had to draw a line across this island, where's the East and where's the West? Because all I've heard about is fair representation for the people on the West side in Kona but the West don't only mean Kailua and Keauhou, at least not in my mind. So, is there something that you and your staff, or fellow Commissioners, may know that we don't know, where the West is and where the East is? Because you could say some of Ka'u is in the West side and the rest of Pahala, and wherever, is in the East side. So have you guys ever talked about where this line may or may not be drawn? In my mind, it always comes back to this feasibility of where would you draw a line, how are you going to separate East vs. West. When you talk about the West, if you're specifically talking about fair representation for the people of Kona, what happens when somebody in Hamakua, which is one of the largest districts in the island, says where's our fair representation so we need our own Commission, or the guys in Puna, say, eh, Puna is Puna and there's • Upper and Lower Puna. So have you ever thought about it or discussed it since I left there? TANAKA: No, Mr. Balog, we haven't and one of the reasons I don't even want to bring it up is because just the thought of having two separate Commissions, basically, will split the community, I think. If you go under that attitude, then you might as well have two County Councils. You might as well have two Police Commissions. And if you have two Planning Commissions, what happens to the Board of Appeals? Do you have two Board of Appeals or do you still have one? And then again, under the same argument, the members of the Planning Board of Appeals, are they properly represented from Hilo, Kona, so forth and so on? So I think it's real difficult. 1 think that we have a hard time as it is and we are a single body here. We're the largest island in the Hawaiian chain but City and County of Honolulu is a whole island. I hate to even think about dividing the island because I think it would be detrimental. We have a hard time, as it is, as one body, so what makes us think that if we divide it in two, it's going to be easier to manage. But, I don't know if you'd split it geographically or by volume of income on planning issues. I don't know how you would do that. That's a good question. BALOG: One of the reasons I asked you, you brought up Oahu, is Oahu has about 90% or 80% of the state's population and they operate as one city and county. It